What if Poland LOST the Polish-Soviet War? | Project Red World - Episode 2

[@Ile-17]

9:00 Very small detail once again but Finland would most likely not occupy and later annex the second "Arm"/Petsamo area. Finnish white forces occupied it as part of the Kinship wars and it was officially ceded to Finland in 1920 as part of the Tarton rauha/Tarto peace deal which ended the kinship wars (Karelian uprising was part of thease wars). Like i said this is small and insignificant detail :D. You also pronounced those Finnish city names very well! Great video again , can't wait for more!

[@cuddly3705]

man, I guess we just can't have a rewriting history series where Czechia doesn't get annexed in to Austria. just keep us independent man.

[@blu3_l08st3r]

Haha Austria-Bohemia and Hungary-Romania goes BRRRRRRRRRRRR

[@rewriting-history]

I am a Czech ultra hater, didn't you know that? PS: I know people will take this seriously, I cannot believe I have to say it but yeah this is a joke.. :D

[@Tami42069]

W Video idea

[@rewriting-history]

I will do it again, but outside of the series

[@Lexperplex-o3x]

Nice, I like your creativity and storytelling with this scenario, keep it up!

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that! I am getting better so expect me in a year to be a beast!

[@FillUserChill]

When I'm at my lowest but this guy posts:

[@rewriting-history]

Sorry to hear! I will try to make your day better and do a livestream soon, as I cannot post a video so soon! I will make sure that you are my motivation for the next episode! Stay strong! 💪

[@FillUserChill]

@rewriting-history bro ur the best, please don't quit KZbin 🙏😭😭😭

[@SwordGhost]

​@@rewriting-history This project is really great, so much that i made a full part about china and the France and Italy helping him in my head With the warlord era ongoing and the two communist nations of germany and russia, Italy and France wanted to make sure they don't expand the socialism revolution toi the colonny, if the communist party that was already in china un that time united the country, all the Asian collony could try to break away , so i think to prevent that, the entente Send equipement , guns and everything they can to make sure that nationalist china win the Warlord era before the communist make there move in there, even Japan could help them if they gain something If i give you that idea of that project i'm gonna be more than happy, and if this was already planned , it's good too 😀

[@chargyisonline7790]

Great Video! You could touch upon how Stalin (Historically) was an internationalist in the earl 1920s and only became an isolationist after the hummiliation in Poland, and the Failure of the KPD in 1923, and how Trotsky wouldn't be looked down upon, since this too would be a major PR stunt for him, since he just helped the USSR win a war on all sides. The Soviet Union, Germany and Finland would also probably join a military alliance of the Comintern, and the Comintern may be more agressive and Internationalist, mantaining Lenin's position, this probably means no popular front goverments and more Communist Agitation especially in the Balkans. The only way Hungary would accept such a proposal of being basically an integrated region of Romania would be if they had more or less absolute autonomy in the region.

[@chargyisonline7790]

The issue here is there probably wouldn't be a central leader of the USSR in the first place, since the Supreme Soviet would most likely be empowered by these victories and the General Secretary would take a backseat. More likely someone like Rykov or Zinoviev would "lead" because they were in the Supreme Soviet Presidium.

[@unaihmg9352]

Even if Trotskys vision of permanent revolution was accepted, his vision of the national liberation movements and the peasants was still rejected by the soviet people

[@P0PG03S]

@@chargyisonline7790 THIS.

[@minestar2247]

@@chargyisonline7790 oh, so it would basically be a parlimentary republic? trully the dream of the dictatorship of the proletariate was achieved

[@justagreekhistorian]

The series is amazing so far, can't wait to see more

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that! I suggest you try the series format, it works great for me!

[@dhhsjshdjsj]

This series just started and yet i'm already loving it lol, imo, one of your best series so far

[@minestar2247]

yeah, it's just like kaisertum, it's of such great quality

[@rewriting-history]

Glad you enjoy it! I have some surprises down the line and I cannot wait to deliver. Also I see that people LOVE the series format, so I will consider doing more and more!

[@ayyybob]

14:20 The Unified Confederate Kingdom of Transylovakia, Romania-Hungary and Bessara-moldovia

[@OrangeSheepPlayz]

Yooo episode 2!! :D

[@rewriting-history]

I have a bit more of this series cooking!

[@OrangeSheepPlayz]

Yooooo

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Keep up the good work! This new series is fantastic 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate this very much!

[@Jankus_horalkus]

this video format is awesome and i love it 🙏🫡🇨🇿

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that! I will do a lot more episodes on the series

[@Zapadoslavwithcrown]

Ohhhh yeah another great series

[@khaledmoslehi1314]

Best series on yt 👌 keep up the great work

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that very much!

[@planetarystargazer]

What If Spain 🇪🇸 wasn't Fascist in WW2 and was instead Democratic

[@AMIR-xo1cq]

After their win in spanish civil war, franco gets imprisoned or escapes, and nothing much aside from reforms and rebuildings will happen untill 1941. I think German reich will use opportunity to invade spain and allies will ask for military Access, starting new front against germans in pyrenees mountains

[@IHaveNonames123]

I bet nothing changes

[@bulkax303]

Nothing would change

[@jamf4924]

​@@IHaveNonames123even in our timeline, Germany had plans to invade Iberia, if it wasn't for a "friendly government" in Madrid, Germany could have gone through with these plans and the west might have been able to land in Spain and free France earlier, creating a larger western block thanks to an earlier invasion the mainland

[@Unionofsovietrepublic]

What if Spain wasn't fascist in ww2 and was Dominoc(Domino's)😂

[@minecrafter123-d8t]

Stalin would not purge Trotsky and the opposition in this timeline and would be forced to a establish somewhat "democratic" state due pressure form council democratic communist states like Germany, and due to this the Industry and Military would be a lot stronger, making the soviets almost invincible and extremely stable

[@minestar2247]

actually, the industry would be weaker because stalin wouldn't be pushing for impossibly fast industrialisation as easily, and troysky was already hated by the comminists for being lenin but worst, so if he wasn't purged he would still get disgraced like in our timeline

[@rewriting-history]

I do agree that Germany's version of communism would be better, so it would influence the Russian one too. I don't know about Trotsky, maybe he remains in the USSR but has a lower-level position and is kept in check.

[@AnItalianShishposter]

Episode 2! Yeah!

[@Nationless36]

Another thing, the Rhineland wasn’t demilitarised between December 1918 to 1930, it was under an allied military occupation led by France. There is no way France would willingly leave if Germany is communist, especially during the polish soviet war. Just because the Spartacus is pacifist doesn’t mean France won’t occupy the Rhine, considering OTL Germany wasn’t communist and respected the treaty of Versailles, which I don’t think this Germany is doing considering they are literally invading Poland.

[@rewriting-history]

I know, but France cannot really annex it either. They will stay there with Belgian troops as peacekeapers for a while

[@Nationless36]

@ I think they won’t annex it, just stay there indefinitely

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

LOVE YOUR CONTENT! Thanks For this ❤❤❤❤

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate the support!

[@KCAerospace]

Another episode lets goooo!

[@rewriting-history]

Took me a while to make it, but I hope you will enjoy it!

[@indianajones4321]

Solid scenario and series so far RWH!

[@Captain_Griff]

Interesting 🤔 one , keep up the good work 👍

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that and I promise that I will!

[@robloxplayer_guestbaconnoo7364]

I am happy that there is a part 2 tbh

[@Shrekinbokludonu]

Nice video, Keep it Up!

[@rewriting-history]

Thank you very much! I will!

[@Kovácskristof-t5t]

Why Im i addicted to these videos ?????

[@rewriting-history]

I will take this as a compliment! I am addicted to making them, so I will deliver great results on the series and beyond that!

[@giandsouza6581]

What if trotsky fled to germany?

[@minestar2247]

well, that would empower the fascists of france and italy as he was an expansionist

[@LoanShark_totallyreal]

Yayy ep2

[@itsParkas]

I honestly LOVE these series! First Kaisertum, now Red World! To be honest, if I had to pick which country would fall next. I'd say France.

[@rewriting-history]

You are onto something, but not quite! Next video a European country would go communist

[@SunilDachmann-mg7mm]

Ok I feel like this should get an Oscar of alternate history.I love red world

[@rewriting-history]

I am far away from an Oscar, but I can get there one day!

[@Ryanlovedits]

Can't wait for project blue world

[@rewriting-history]

Oh that would be dope, although we already have something similar. We just need a blue China

[@Ryanlovedits]

@@rewriting-history what's the project that's already similar

[@Ryanlovedits]

​My idea is the Soviets losing the civil war and the whites established a democratic regime in Russia

[@Nemetas-734]

I love this Projekt its the best in my Opinioun

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that! This is just the beginning!

[@Nemetas-734]

@@rewriting-historyI hope so

[@pitido4099]

19:00 Tannu Tuva mentioned!!!!!!!!🔥🔥🔥

[@rewriting-history]

This rarely happens

[@tvoja_babka978]

good work

[@rewriting-history]

Thanks for the visit!

[@GuestMate]

New vid like the series already

[@rewriting-history]

I will do more and more!

[@ĽudovítTurčina]

My dream video of "what if both hungaryan and bavaran siviet republic survive" is finaly here!

[@rewriting-history]

This series is basically what if all went perfect for the commies

[@Ktosexe-uz8oq]

The series isn't realistic, but tbh it is entertaining

[@rewriting-history]

I never claimed to be realistic and said multiple times that my goal is to entertain and I am glad that you can see that and enjoy it!

[@Martynukzzz]

W vid tbh

[@rewriting-history]

I appreciate that!

[@Fred_theEll]

Communist germany can't hurt you, it's not real Communist germany:

[@rewriting-history]

They will very much hurt you

[@Fred_theEll]

​@@rewriting-history NEIN 😭

[@DiezelP]

East Germany: 🗿

[@matejsantak9153]

btw will there hoi4 mod like you did with project kaisertum?

[@rewriting-history]

Most likely not, as the mod devs are still working on Kaisertum and cannot catch up with me

[@playerh1298]

Nice.

[@rewriting-history]

Thank you! Cheers!

[@daniellovestortoises3044]

Keep it up with this awesome series In this scenario does china go communist and does america go communist during the depression or in the 60s and 70s as this scenarios is an awesome one

[@rewriting-history]

We are still in 1920, so there is a long time to go to mention America and China

[@Tomi-gm9qe]

i knew Hungary was communist!

[@rewriting-history]

Ayyy you spotted that, good job!

[@Tom-jg9de]

UK : Ho would win you or the red's Poland : well if they went full on it might be a problem UK: but would you lose? Poland : nie ja wygram

[@rewriting-history]

Poland be like: Nah, I got it

[@handsomedoor1705]

2 Video suggestions: 1 What if Dacia won the first Daco-Roman war 2 What if the treaty between Dacia and Rome was not disregarded by Traian I hope that one day you will do this

[@ugbhffgg]

8:39 it’s fun to see a Bulgarian pronounce Finnish cities

[@rewriting-history]

Ay, I thought I did good! :D

[@ugbhffgg]

@@rewriting-history sure did :D

[@legittrololo2163]

Let's goooooo

[@rewriting-history]

Hope you liked it!

[@thatgermandaniel]

I find it very interesting that in the west, you actually made Belgium not take the German speaking regions of Eupen-Malmedy, and kind of split it in half. Idk if that's just an illusion, though.

[@rewriting-history]

They actually took these lands, but I made them a bit smaller than on my usual maps. Taking German communists won't be desired by Belgium

[@thatgermandaniel]

@@rewriting-history Smooth German western border enjoyer :Trollface: I approve

[@Arandomperson-zi5br]

About france and Italy i think that they would give italy Savoy Nice and Corsica for italian help

[@rewriting-history]

I really cannot say if this is possible, as the French and Italians would become ultranationalist so they would have a bit of problems among their shared border

[@pizza8725]

Romano-Hungary union is based

[@rewriting-history]

I knew people would like it!

[@genralvilola7489]

7:58 G.C Mannerheim was angry at the Germans for coming to help the whites, because the war was decided a long time ago for the whites. Red Finland had no chance of actually winning. (Edit, you better give karelia to finland)

[@rewriting-history]

But I did say that this is unrealistic and that I prioritize entertainment over realism. I get that point, but I want to create an exciting scenario

[@DragonianScythoBoyNm4856]

🇭🇺♥️🇷🇴 cool idea for hungary romania personnel union

[@rewriting-history]

I didn't come up with it, but I am glad the people like it!

[@DragonianScythoBoyNm4856]

@@rewriting-history iknow, i mad maps of it, im just glad you didnt destroy my nation 🇭🇺♥️🇧🇬🇨🇭

[@Meanthes]

Can you do a video of what if the reds succeed in the Finnish cilvil war?

[@rewriting-history]

I can but I honestly don't see how this would change anything. Perhaps Finland is larger and keeps their 1919 borders up until the modern day, but thats about it

[@Meanthes]

@ Maybe their borders will be to what the soviets demanded from finland before the winter war, where the soviets get up to terijoki (Zelenogorsk) & koivisto (Primorsk), in exchange for repola and porjärvi

[@Silly_Cat69.]

May i ask for the flag? I do not mean to steal it I just really like it and some flags i made or saw from others didnt sadisfy me

[@rewriting-history]

Google East Germany flag and in wikipedia you will find it. It's one of their naval flags

[@mell506]

Great

[@rewriting-history]

I hope you liked it!

[@rewriting-history]

I am glad you liked it!

[@mell506]

:)

[@adarshlokhande7653]

What if germany was technocratic in ww2

[@rewriting-history]

Difficult with the Nazis, this time it's possible

[@KiprasGavenas]

4:50 Most likely Lithuanians would demand greater autonomy, and to not be fully controlled by moscow, if they decided to become communist, but Lithuanians just got their independence in 1917 and we probably wouldn't accept these claims to be controlled by russia again, theyre was a few communist but most of them emerged in the later years. They would probably realize that fighting on the weaker side would mean more casualties and would switch fearing the loss of an lithuanian state. Is it possible? yes but with slim chances.

[@rewriting-history]

I presented that Lithuania would be a separate SSR with larger territory. In additon the USSR was supposed to be a republic of equals, but it only later turned into a dictatorship. Correct me if I am wrong but Lenin didn't envision the Soviet Union to have a dictator, rather something like collective leadership. Lithuania would be promised the moon, but then Stalin would come and slowly chip at their autonomy

[@KiprasGavenas]

@ oh ok, also a small request: can you make the ssrs a slightly different shade of red to stand out a bit in the map?

[@Tragecom]

As czech i Gotta say that right Wings republic.We would maybe go monarchist but under italian or Romanian prince Is more possible.

[@matejsantak9153]

i heard somewhere that you said communist rats but i forgot at what time you said lol

[@rewriting-history]

I don't remember saying that ever

[@matejsantak9153]

@@rewriting-history ok but i really think i heard it

[@wither67]

Hello. About the khalifat movement, ("khalifat", not "khilafat") Gandhi actually condemned the movement after a while because it had turned very bloody and violent. The idea of india revolting is impossible, not 𝘶𝘯𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘤, but impossible. Especially that of a communist one, which you are implying. The INC (indian national congress) wished for an autonomous dominion WITHIN the british empire, so as to stablilise the new country. a full on revolution would not only be unlikely, but it would be quickly put down, especially considering most of the leaders (Gandhi included) OPPOSED violent rebellions.

[@rewriting-history]

I never implied India would become communist, just that they would revolt. The UK would need to be more cautios as to not lose India, that's all

[@rarespanescu8346]

Lets goo big romania! Gigachad scenario

[@rewriting-history]

The Romanians will love this series!

[@codja_]

16:30 is wrong northern slesvig is ethnicly danish and was always intended to be accepted back into denmark however the french were pushing for annexation of either all of slesvig or both it and holsten wich were majority german

[@rewriting-history]

I think that Denmark mostly didn't want to have a German minority, which was present there. German influence over Denmark was really strong before WW1, as the Danish nobles used German, rather than their own Danish language.

[@codja_]

@@rewriting-history mostly correct however i dont see it happening that Denmark annexes nothing both due to internal and french pressure

[@Nalabear_2020]

Wasn’t Oman a British protectorate and not independent country unless I am wrong because they got independence in the 70 and Japan and south of the island in Siberia forgot its name

[@goldensword777]

I made a sanario where Germany went communist and Russia went Fascist for some reason

[@rewriting-history]

Oh like that, it's too unlikely but damn is it interesting

[@bleanG]

Age of history 3 gameplay when?

[@Alexandromeda1]

Rewriting history

[@indiradevi8136]

What if spain had good monarchs and successfully integrated Portugal?

[@Clips-ys5wt]

What if Prussia kept its polish territory after the napoleonic wars? What if Sweden wasn’t invaded by russia during the napoleonic wars?

[@Prussiankingdom1871]

I think the frikcrops will exist or not

[@50pka]

Bro came up with a union between Hungary and Romania, not Soviet Hungary 💀 Unexpected.

[@rewriting-history]

I already did Soviet Hungary and didn't want to repeat myself, hence why I decided to do something I have never done before

[@paulinalevina9690]

Hi there

[@rewriting-history]

Hello there

[@UlsterCountryball]

What if France turned fascist before ww2 under action fancais

[@rewriting-history]

They will in the next episode!

[@vansglitches1192]

What if everything went perfect for the maratha Empire?

[@АндрейКукурузка]

Video idea: What if Joe Biden became king of Albania in WW2?

[@rewriting-history]

Based lol

[@TejasSoma]

what will happen next will more countries trun communist

[@rewriting-history]

You shall wait and see, I think you will like the next one

[@cosmo6825]

Those German-Soviets borders are so ugly 😭

[@rewriting-history]

They are, but I didn't want to do the Imperial borders

[@domain9894]

Romano-Hungarian union ❤❤❤

[@rewriting-history]

I've commited the biggest sin

[@Andrei-eq8oq]

What if Spain or Yugoslavia and Etiopia was comunist?

[@rewriting-history]

We shall see how the series develops :)

[@Sir_Yangchuanosaurus]

Ten minutes early

[@veresdominikzsolt]

A union between romania and hungary NEVERRR

[@rewriting-history]

I committed the largest sin of mankind

[@veresdominikzsolt]

Yes but if this ever happend that it should be Hungarian colour 🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺

[@VeliHajdari]

Dint we get this alredy in the video what if germany was communist?

[@rewriting-history]

This is part 2

[@Neutral_man]

I dont approve of Hungary keeping Slovakia RAAAAAH

[@rewriting-history]

Understandable tbh

[@Un.om.patriot.1284]

Please Don’t make Romania small 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@rewriting-history]

We shall see how the series develops

[@Un.om.patriot.1284]

@ by the way. Here’s a video idea. What if Mihai Viteazul (Michael The Brave) took Constantinopole

[@GriffinKuyf]

This is unrealistic because I would probably just take over Germany and ask nicely for all my land back it’s really not that hard

[@CharlesIsMyName]

Maybe it is just me but your mic is very loud.

[@rewriting-history]

Better loud than the opposite tbh, as you can always lower it, but if it's too mute, you cannot hear even at max volume

[@vin49redemption]

What if someone made a mod about this ?

[@Arabmapperguy]

18:59 I have unsubscribed. How dare you mention the great commune of holy tannu Tuva insignificant. im joking ofc

[@rewriting-history]

Jokes aside once I wrote this I was looking at Tannu Tuvan coins and banknotes for like an hour. I will buy some soon

[@QUEfrang]

danger

[@Mafi43211]

iven do this series about comunism i m fr on the roman protocol side

[@psrgaming5509]

Last (not first actually this time)

[@rewriting-history]

Based ngl

[@pillowfromtpotreal]

​@@rewriting-historyhe is wrong, I am last

[@lubuskimapper4414]

NO

[@BartoszLimanowski]

Woul'dnt the baltic germans support the Baltic countries?. The german army there was absolutely opossed to soviet russia. The same in finland. You should have made this soldiers join the Polish and finish and baltic armies. Yes i know some of this soldiers would have turn communist if the "Fatherland" would have turn Red but still i see the German whites helping Poland and the rest of the countries.

[@rewriting-history]

Then we get the same ending as in our timeline. You need to consider that this will be boring

[@P1kaSans]

what if lithuania won ww2 when?

[@LetnanBanjo]

Early but not first.

[@Hthewise]

Border gore

[@rewriting-history]

Honestly it's not too bad

[@Pacific_LIII]

Communist Jumpscare

[@rewriting-history]

That's the name of the series, literally

[@Kosmochelik]

Dear RH. We found our agent that owned this account... well you understand As we understand, Mercurus-p1k did it. We'll have to leave the usual comments to confuse him -Team A

[@rewriting-history]

Oh yeah good idea! I keep replying to comments only to cause confusion si you can capture him! Thank you, agent, but I still fear for my life!

[@Chefo_311]

1 view in 1 Minute Bro fell of

[@rewriting-history]

I did, sadly

[@MarkoKostelac]

Under 10 minutes.

[@rewriting-history]

Samee!

[@MarkoKostelac]

@@rewriting-history You're so funny. Love the vids. Can you make a scenario if Japan and the USSR were on the opposite sides in WW2. This means the Americans join early. The Poles make a frankly ridiculous Intermarium and get kicking some Nazi-Soviet balls. The Axis are now called NazFaCom(Nazism, fascism and communism). The name I gave this is Traitors of Europe: Fall of dictators.

[@shrekler8538]

1st

[@rewriting-history]

Let's go!