MLB Trade Proposals for Garrett Crochet; Should the White Sox Trade Him?

[@chrisgotski9837]

The Sox needs bats. They have some pitching in the minors. The Padres deal needs to start with Salas or merril. No thank you on the brewers prospects or the Cardinals prospects. You should remake this video and focus on bats with power because there's non in the white sox system.

[@rhyde]

The White Sox are absolutely not getting either of those guys lmao

[@yazyo3842]

@@rhydeAnd that’s why the padres aren’t getting crochet

[@jamesnevsimal2359]

Work on another video focused on batters. Because the trades you talk about are awful.

[@pancakejonzze]

@@jamesnevsimal2359 who cares? Don’t be jelly make your own content

[@nolansnyder2262]

the sox consistently undervalue guys like this. cease was traded for way less than any of these proposed deals, and garrett crochet only has half a year more of team control than cease did at the time while having significantly less of a workload to base his value off of. the crochet deal should be similar to a cease deal, but slightly more because he will be paid basically nothing for the rest of the year. if the sox are asking for a guy like salas then they aren't getting a deal done at all

[@gianbasye8173]

I am Biggest Fan of San Diego PADRES since 1998 PADRES with Former PADRES Manager 15 Bruce bochy

[@gianbasye8173]

I want Chicago white Sox trade Garrett Crochet to PADRES For Adrian Morejon Luis Campusano trade to Chicago White Sox Now

[@victorfuentes2631]

The white Sox need to spend money and build around these young guys!!

[@joesaiditstrue]

Even if the Sox spent money in free agency, there aren't enough difference makers available to turn the Sox into a contender

[@jimjames6990]

The sox should build around Crotchet, Roberts few top propests and sign 2 or 3 free agents. They would have a good team. But the Sox are Rettardded and CHEAP. The dumbbest team in MLB

[@idicula1979]

This would have been a great season for the Whitesox to get a competent manager, not Pedro Grofol, because they have some great pieces to trade, I mean Louis Robert basically makes this team look competent. I mean they could have hit the ground running for next year. I mean their is no reason there three very desirable peices should not have them in a championship window this year, and of course the last championship window had monumentally bad luck. But I have no trust in Jerry Reinsdorf, this team, this franchise will never reach its full potential with Jerry Reinsdorf not valuing competence and winning over his families relationships. And that is why I’m turning in my fan card, BECAUSE THE WHITESOX WILL EVER BE A COMPETENT ORGANIZATION WITH JERRY REINSDORF RUNNING IT AS HIS LITTLE FIEFDOM, HE WILL ALWAYS PROVE CHICAGO WHITESOXS FAN TO BE SUCKERS.

[@jasonyi65]

Orioles get Crochet and Kopech Sox get Basallo, Beavers, Bencosme, Pinto and Deivi Cruz. Who says no?

[@Erik-vn5xk]

W video, as a sox fan I appreciate the genuine packages you've given for Crochet unlike the cheap ones opposing fanbases seem to think will land him Padres one needs to add Lesko or DeVries imo, Phillies is lacking imo I would need Aidan Miller to headline the way Mayo does the Orioles one, Others are solid just comes down to personal preference Excited for your Robert video although I'm a little worried after noticing BTV values him quite lower then Crochet which is interesting

[@ElephantInTheMfRoom]

Phillies don't make much sense for a SP especially at such a HIGH price. Wouldn't trade Aiden Miller for Luis Robert..

[@Chris-xt8io]

@@ElephantInTheMfRoom Aidan Miller will take over 3rd, when Bohm moves to 1st and Harper to DH. The Phillies aren’t resigning Schwarber or Casty. Surprisingly Dombroski is keeping the farm intact and Miller would’ve been gone at last years deadline if he was going to trade him. We shouldn’t give a top 100 prospect for a guy who plays 50 games a year. Finally, he’s signing some high priced FAs, and bolstering that with a strong farm and young players. The Phillies daycare (Bohm, Stott, Marsh, Rojas, Suarez) are finally coming together. For the first time since 2006, this team is built for sustainable success for now and in the future.

[@Erik-vn5xk]

@@ElephantInTheMfRoom yeah I don’t see Phillies in on Crochet but do see them on Robert. Not being willing to trade Miller for Robert is kinda stupid imo tho, Robert already a young superstar with team control, if you’re lucky that’s what you hope miller can become close to. The already is will always be more valuable then he could be. Plus Phillies are already contending, this would be a move to put them over the top and get a potential mvp candidate for years (he would be so much better once leaving Sox lol). IMO you absolutely trade Miller for that, plus White Sox would definitely need him or Painter plus a lot more to consider a deal

[@jesusofapes1]

The chances of the Brewers traded Jacob Misiorowski for Crochet are 0 .0001% . A couple things Tyler Black a 1st baseman not a 2nd baseman and that value chart is wrong ! He is just to good to trade off right before the payoff without significant compensation . I could see them trading off Jake Bauers before they would trade Tyler Black. I think the Brewers will try and make this trade for Crotchet but not with that level of risk involved at that price. They will never give up the best pitching prospect in baseball he is not only the Brewers #1 pitching prospect He is THE #1 pitching prospect in ALL of Baseball. Misiorowski is far to good to ever dream of trading and his value at 29.3 on that chart is ridiculous. To get a player of Misiorowski level prospect you would have to pay up far more than you would for a Crochet and that simply is not going to happen . Owen Miller, Joey Weimer, Dylan O'Rae, Luis Castillo and MAYBE Cooper Pratt would be more on target if they wanted a pitcher it would be Justin King perhaps.

[@miguel.ledesmaledesma1790]

I wouldn’t mind if my Mets took a gander at him. That said,Crochet will cost a pretty penny prospect wise. And rightfully so.

[@scottbryan455]

No way Elias would give up that package for Crochet. McDermott could be included, maybe Jud Fabian. Mayo is likely essentially off the table. I could see some combination of Fabian, McDermott, Stowers, Norby

[@LiamlaChapelleYonson]

Man, I get you think Mayo is going to be good but Grochet is 24 years old and has a fip under 3, he’d absolutely head line your rotation. He’s absolutely worth mayo and more.

[@scottbryan455]

@@LiamlaChapelleYonson he may indeed be worth more, but I said that's not a move Elias will make. It's not in line with any trade he's ever done and the Orioles love Mayo. Also, there is no way Crochet would front the Orioles rotation. Corbin Burnes does, and Bradish was 4th in Cy Young last year. You value Crochet (not Grochet), and rightfully so. But based on how Elias operates, the Orioles aren't going to overpay ever, especially for a guy with a lot of potential but has an injury history, is on an innings limit and is in his first year starting. He would be a great add, but doesn't fit as a starter for a playoff run based on his inning limit this year. Now, if they put him in the BP for the rest of the year, then yeah, he helps in the stretch run and could start next year. But again, giving up a guy (Mayo) with among the strongest arm and among the best power in MiLB isn't nothing.

[@JohnStarliper]

Mayo has great power and can’t play D. Hurt right now. Nowhere to play because Basallo is the 1st baseman / DH of the future and he’s a better hitter than Mayo. Burnes is gone in a few months and Crochet is an ace. Do it.

[@scottbryan455]

@@JohnStarliper if Mayo is so bad defensively, then why do you want him? Also, Crochet has a total of 1/3 of a season as a starter (albeit a dominant one). Why does that make him an ace? Under that logic Ubaldo Jimenez was an ace because of his dominant half season in Colorado one year.

[@oscarherrera779]

@@scottbryan455Where is Mayo playing in their future? Orioles have Basallo 1B, Holliday 2B, Westberg 3B. All of them are young and really good. Orioles have a chance to win it all for the next 3 years and Crochet (or Robert) would be the perfect trade piece to include in the title run. Mullins can’t hit. Burnes is due for a big contract that they can’t afford. A Mayo swap for one of them would be almost perfect.

[@RileyAicher1]

Damn that Brewers prospect package is insane lmao

[@RileyAicher1]

If we trade that I will off myself

[@jesusofapes1]

This guy does not know who Jacob Misiorowski is and he has Tyler listed as a 2nd baseman. So the realism in this video on that trade is about video game level. 1st Jacob is worth more in trade value than Crochet is even if this program he is using says otherwise. I could see the Brewers trying to pick Crochet but really the amount that they are predicting is just ludicrous I think Owen Miller, Joey Weimer , Luis Castillo would probably be more like what they would do there . Maybe if the Sox dug in and demanded a true gem Cooper Pratt could be a worthy trade prospect with high end future value. The Crew should do this trade but not if it cost the farm to do it.

[@mariatorres1981mt]

U should mlb trade proposals for Luis Robert

[@bensweetra4871]

He will. Jim and him do their videos in tandem… they must brainstorm together

[@rhyde]

Premieres tomorrow ❤️

[@rhyde]

@@bensweetra4871nah we don’t

[@LaMonteWade31]

@@rhydeI will be there

[@theDanimal234]

Literally less than 2 minutes into the video he says he will

[@pa1n3r]

that first padres offer was awful, but the white sox better hold on to Crochet he is young and SPECIAL. if they were to trade him tho (god forbid), they need bats

[@rhyde]

What’s a trade you would do?

[@larryfine6865]

Padres need to unload Xander.

[@coltonstelloh2831]

Misiorowski is a deal breaker for me im not giving him up for crochet

[@enjoylife7030]

Wow, this was a very good trade talk video but although its only 13 days old, now the Orioles have lost Bradish to TJ surgery as well, our third this year with Means and Wells. I still think if the O's can make a deal for a starter it will be a veteran because of the playoff race and issue of innings limits on Crochet. I also don't see Elias trading any of Holliday, Mayo, or Basallo. The others could definitely be dealt most likely Norby, Kjerstad, Beavers, McDermott or Stowers.

[@alfredo101109]

Norby and Mayo

[@johngolomb1136]

White Sox fan: I personally want to keep him, but if we trade him we need hitting prospects, specifically outfield. Our minor league pitching rn is stacked

[@CamKrazy2000]

I can see them trading Fedde but Crochet? But then again they're in a similar situation with Crochet that O's were in a few years ago with John Means who was their best pitcher when they were losing 100+ games/year. Means has done next to nothing since O's have been good because of injury issues and probably is done as a big league pitcher after his second TJ at the age of 31. Pitchers can get hurt any moment and maybe they should trade Crochet when his stock is high.

[@ericsmolinski1347]

I can see the Brewers moving an outfielder before the deadline, but no chance they are trading Misiorowski. His upside is way too high

[@LuBobEnthusiast]

White Sox have great minor league pitching…..need at least a top 75 prospect bat in any of these trades

[@davidshowmaker4408]

The Cardinals front office and ownership will never do anything to make this team better!

[@Nabersprod7]

Could the Astros land Pete Alonso?

[@brandondillman5841]

Can you imagine Pete in Houston with that crazy short left field? He might hit 70 bombs. lol

[@maxberglind3275]

I like the cardinals idea. Only thing for certain is that whoever the Sox get, they will mess it up.

[@chrisgotski9837]

My trade idea would trade Crochet to the Yankees. I'd ask for Rodderick arias Brando mayea Francisco vilorio and Jack neely. If the the Sox need to give up a bullpen piece like brebia or kopech I'd be ok with that.

[@LaMonteWade31]

Cole, Cortes, Stroman, Rodon, and Gil is all you need. The Yankees do not need Crochet

[@maxkeiper680]

What do you think my twins would have to give up? Btw loving the videos

[@darkwulf2k]

Not mad at that Orioles package. crochet would be nice for the bullpen. Burnes/Rodriguez/Braddish/Irvin/Kremer(when returns) is a fine rotation

[@darrentorain6278]

Nah make him a starter

[@nickfreiburg]

Cardinals would sooner call Hence up than trade him for SP. He’ll be MLB ready by late 2025 at the latest

[@rhyde]

Prospects never guaranteed

[@dark_ness2576]

As a Cards fan I really dont think it makes a whole lot of sense to give up all that much for a guy whos only proven it once as a starter espically when this team oesnt have much pitching depth so why trade more of it for a guy whos not elite

[@rhyde]

Fair!

[@Karnij85]

I think a good fit would be the Rangers. I hardly see them brought up with the good farm team they have.

[@rhyde]

I thought about them here, but didn’t do it since they have Scherzer/deGrom back soon

[@AWG_07]

If the cardinals do try and get Crochet they’d also be smart to try and get Robert as well to sure up that CF spot as well.

[@KevinWM2]

Exactly what I've been thinking as a Cardinal fan.

[@Phillysportssuperfan23]

As a Phillies fan I don’t like this trade but I would do it for Luis Robert or Randy arozarana

[@rhyde]

Robert would be awesome too. However, he’ll be cheaper.

[@mikethechristiangamer85]

What do you think the reds should do?

[@ElephantInTheMfRoom]

Phillies reversing on their plan to improve the minor league system for an upgrade for Taijuan Walker is highly unlikely. I would be more interested in Robert but not at the expense of 3 top 5 prospects especially with his injury history and his history of not giving 100%. 0% We grab another top starter when we have 6.

[@rhyde]

Starter and then a reliever most likely. Could be huge for the postseason. However, I definitely see the upside with Robert as well.

[@ElephantInTheMfRoom]

@@rhyde The postseason rotation is Wheeler, Nola, Suarez, and Sanchez. No room. maybe if there is an injury they trade for a starter but you already have a limited minor league system doesnt make much sense to not fill the teams holes with the limited assets you have.

[@SirPhilly]

As a Phillies fan, I am definitely not trading Abel and Crawford for garret crochet. Maybe Kyle Tucker but not crochet. Those two show a lot of promise.

[@rhyde]

Fair! I could see Luis Robert possibly

[@SirPhilly]

@@rhyde Would like that!

[@daquandavis5498]

I think the Phillies will look more at Luis Robert than Crochet

[@rhyde]

That’ll be tomorrows video 🥳

[@paulriker]

Sox need a 55+ bat as a headliner. They have 6 good pitchers in AA but are lacking hitters. I'd want A+ level too. Not to keen on 18/19 year olds. Salas would be my exception. My asks: Baltimore: Mayo + Beavers, or Kerstad + Beavers + McDermott SD: Salas + Mazur Cards: Walker + Hence Philly: Painter + Miller Brewers: Meh

[@jesusofapes1]

The best deal on the video was the Brewers and there is 0 chance they would ever give up that for Crochet. Misiorowski is the best pitcher in the entire minors Ranked the #1 overall pitching prospect in BASEBALL . Misiorowski would cost MORE than Crochet alone. If you had the luck of getting Tyler Black you would have an instant All Star candidate but that again will never happen because Crochet is not worth that kind of value. As Tyler Black is about of sure of a thing as there is in the minor leagues and is also the same speed an De La Cruz is on the record. So he instantly would be your teams best player . Everyone of these trades is completely never going to happen for a guy with less than 75 innings pitched EVER. You do not have a Daniel Wheeler there on the block. The best you are going to get out of the Brewers of any of these teams are high future guys with expected long and solid futures in baseball like Joey Weimer, Owen Miller, that would be more on that level and for your chance at a real superstar Cooper Pratt would give you that shot at a top their hitter someday.

[@paulriker]

@@jesusofapes1 i agree with everything you said. You typically don’t see high level prospects traded in these types of deals anyway, unless they are blocked. Knowing I don’t have to trade Cochet, I would just aim high

[@jesusofapes1]

@@paulriker with the Dodgers now involved you should shoot for the moon . The Dodgers bring a big ability to draw good players into your farm system and even your current roster. Now given the Dodgers call to the trade table the entire thing just got extremely interesting. There is every reason to shoot for the highest trade because the Dodgers can afford it . They might even just try to buy Crochet with cash from the White Socks which will help no one but the Dodgers. The Brewers will have to give up a piece they do not want to if they want to hang with the Dodgers in this trade war now. The one thing i disagree with is that you do not have to trade Crochet. I think you are forced to trade Crochet. I also think Fedde will have to go too . There is simply no ability to hold onto someone that needed and valuable when you need so much to become relevant . . The White Sox are... and I do not mean this to be insulting at all to your team or you but they are a terrible program with a weak farm system to build anything for the coming years. They will not be needing Ace pitching for some time which I know is a hard pill to swallow but the best thing for the White Sox right now is they suddenly have the power to invest to get much better now because they have star pitching available . There is no future with Crochet or Fedde on this roster past July. I would expect you see them start moving any day now.

[@hailmaryrecordings8255]

I think the Sox need to hold-on to any talent they have.

[@brandondillman5841]

No point. Crochet only has 2 more years of team control and they'll be bad for a while.

[@aidenawe9359]

@@brandondillman5841could extend him

[@itsyaboihomeslice9353]

You should do MLB trade proposals for Pete Alonso

[@rhyde]

Coming soon ❤️

[@jordanwest7873]

As a white sox fan i’d prefer to keep Crochet but if we got a offer like the Phillys or O’s package you put together I could live with that.

[@Chris-xt8io]

Phillies aren’t trading for him; Painter, Abel, and McGarry are in the farm. We don’t need starting pitching. Nola, Wheeler, Suarez, and Sanchez are a really good top 4. If someone gets hurt McGarry will come up, and Turnbull will go back in the rotation. Also Justin Crawford is viewed as untouchable in the Phillies organization, as many rumors have come out

[@jordanwest7873]

@@Chris-xt8io great point white sox fans can only dream at this point

[@Chris-xt8io]

@@jordanwest7873 I think his logic is flawed because Carl Crawford played left and idk why Jordan couldn’t play right. Also he has at least 3 more years till he makes the show. He’s still in high A

[@purrellbarnett8592]

Orioles trade, Norby , Kjerstad, Dean kremer.

[@bemore_wins1355]

Orioles supporter here. Crochet is very good. But does not really fill a top need for the O’s right now. What the Orioles need is 1 or 2 very good back end bullpen pieces. There is no way I would be good with giving up a prospect like Mayo for a player (while very good) doesn’t really upgrade the 24’ team very much. The Orioles have an excellent staff already. But we are pretty mediocre at the back of the bullpen IMO.

[@rhyde]

Could have him pitch out of the bullpen in postseason once he’s coming up on his innings limit

[@bemore_wins1355]

@@rhyde the Orioles need a sure fire very good, reliable back end reliever with a track record, not an experiment. The team is too good to take that kind of unnecessary risk.

[@jasonyi65]

@@bemore_wins1355hes not inexperienced in the pen. His 2021 totals before the TJ cost him 22 and most of 23 2.82 ERA, 54.1 IP, 2HR allowed, 65K 27BB, ERA+156, 1.27whip, 12.0 K/9 Hes not remotely an experiment in the pen, hes shown he can handle it and put up some nice numbers. He also could fill the likely void in 25s rotation that Burnes will leave.

[@bemore_wins1355]

@@jasonyi65 he's not as good as Burnes. And the Orioles are playing to win a pennant this season. Again, I'm not okay with giving up big time prospects in order to take on risk. Nice pitcher, but big pass for me. Not a need.

[@thomasgaines4636]

I agree no experiment go get Tanner Scott and Ryan Helsey for the backend. I think O’s starters are enough. One of them can go to bullpen so they have their long man.

[@ragingpirate5727]

How are any of these trades good for a lefty with 3 years of control?

[@rhyde]

How are there so many times when I get a comment criticizing without putting their own ideas? It’s so tiresome at this point.

[@ragingpirate5727]

@@rhyde can’t handle criticism? Then get off the internet 😂

[@Methoes123]

O's could trade: Beavers, Fabian, and Santander for Crochet. Mayo is off the board.

[@rhyde]

I like Beavers and Fabian in there, I just don’t think the White Sox will want Santander

[@moneyline_0109]

Ya agreed Santander is not getting traded mid season nor would the WS want him. O’s wouldn’t trade Mayo for Cease so no way he’s traded in this deal. I’d swap him for Kjerstad and Mcdermott for Seth Johnson.

[@Methoes123]

@moneyline_0109 : Since Santander won't e resigned: its more than probable he will be used as a trade piece over an extremely low draft pic. Mayo will be replacing him in RF and take Santanders slot at 1st .

[@darrentorain6278]

Santander definitely not getting traded now he’s heating up

[@BLACK-SOX]

Awesome video robbie .. I'll pretend yall didn't get 24 hits