What Makes This Song Great? "Waste" Phish

In this episode of What Makes This Song Great?© we explore the song "Waste" by Phish.
💫 The Beato Ultimate Bundle - $99 FOR ALL OF My Courses: ⇢ rickbeato.com/
📘- The Beato Book Interactive - $99.00 value
🎸 - Beato Beginner Guitar - $159.00 value
👂- The Beato Ear Training Program - $99.00 value
🎸- The Quick Lessons Pro Guitar Course - $79.00 value
… all for just $99.00
Get it here: rickbeato.com/
My Beato Club supporters:
Justin Scott
Terence Mark
Farren Mahjoor
Jason Murray
Lucienne Kilpatrick
Alexander Young
Jason Wagner
Todd Ladner
Rob Kline
Nicholas Long
Tim Benson
Leonardo Martins da Costa Rodrigues
Eddie Perez
David Solomon
MICHAEL JOYCE
Stephen Stubbs
colin stead
Jonathan Wentworth-Linton
Patrick Payne
MATTHEW KARIS
Matthew Barouch
Shaun Samuels
Danny Kurywchak
Gregory Reedy
Sean Coleman
Alexander Verbitskiy
CL Turner
Jason Pappafotis
John Fulford
Margaret Carno
Robert C
David M Combs
Eric Flatt
Reto Spoerli
Herr Moritz Adam
Monte St. Johns
Jon Beezley
Peter DeVault
Eric Nabstedt
Eric Beggs
Rich Germano
Brian Bloom
Peter Pillitteri

[@savwally]

The best thing about this video is that people will either hear Phish for the first time here or overcome some preconceptions and give them an honest listen. I am happy for those people. Some will discover a new passion that will be a blessing to them for the rest of their lives. Thanks Rick. I love the channel, especially the interviews with the behind the scenes folks.

[@PYITE314]

Well said!

[@livinginaradio]

Waste has always been a great song for that. It's just a great song and transcends the stigma of being just a "jamband."

[@Steaminlidz]

@@Esb906 Yep. I’ve always liked Indian food, but for years - I didn’t like lime pickle. People who I knew who were really into Indian food always liked lime pickle - but to me it tasted like petrol. For years I tried to eat it. Eventually, I got used to it and now I love it. I’ve tried Phish many times. I cannot get into it.

[@PlateOshrimp499]

You're not wrong. I'm a 25 year musician/Phish-Hater, and this performance is free from what usually repels me. Excesses are reigned in, and the tones are lovely. I must be gettin' old ;)

[@JohnSmith-oe5kx]

I am certainly one of those giving Phish an honest listen after having ignored them to this point. Thanks (again), Rick.

[@williamsanders2348]

Phish is one of those bands that are so talented and complex, I'm scared to give them my attention, I may never get it back.

[@2112CO]

Just do it 11 17 97!?!

[@willschantz795]

@@2112CO what better day than on the 23 year anniversary

[@DerBlutenPat1348]

just surrender to the flow

[@whatwouldhousedo5136]

"Once guys get into Phish, they never come back". And you'll never be happier.

[@CosmicFishbowl]

Yes, do it. It's a deep pool, but when you get in you'll love it. No other band like them.

[@Guitargate]

Dude. I'm so pumped to see the Phish camp support your efforts Rick. Excellent work. Perhaps the tides are finally turning!!

[@SnowTheJamMan]

Hey Michel, i love your dead videos, i hope one day you'll gove Phish another chance, if not on your channel then at least privately, cause they're really an incredible band

[@PYITE314]

Michael, your phish videos were great while they lasted. Hopefully you can get their blessing to do more. Thanks!

[@Guitargate]

@@PYITE314 thanks! You never know!

[@Guitargate]

@@SnowTheJamMan thanks! Life’s all about second chances.

[@rjdunnigan3353]

I highly recommend “Warren and Trey Jam”. Really cool video of the two of them trading blues licks. Maybe it’ll get around the blocking issues too? Btw love your channel Michael! Keep up the awesome content!

[@johncona7645]

68 years on the planet and never paid attention to Phish despite hearing lots about Trey....Thank you Professor Beato...im heading into my practice room and getting this piece down...Beautiful music and as you said..So satisfying

[@MikeP2055]

If I may . . .? Check out Trey's "Divided Sky" from the Beacon series he's been playing the past several weeks.

[@RussellSpurlock]

Yes yes yes And check out the next Beacon Jam on Trey's Twitch channel Friday night... You'll love it

[@phunkyjunkee]

Go to a phish show. You are cheating yourself by not. Seriously.

[@synftw_]

It's such a beautiful song to play for someone once you've got it, too. Such an intimate and pure message to give to the listener that always hits.

[@SnowTheJamMan]

I NEVER expected you to cover Phish, as a hige fan i'm very happy, love your channel.

[@boomerdell]

Oh, and I am right there with you: when Page and Trey are vamping like that, I seriously could sit through an entire day just listening and watching. Incredible.

[@wartimemodels]

Trey is the man. Never gonna happen, but I would pay good money to hear Rick break down what happens during the Bathtub Gin from the Great Went. The way it builds and releases is pure euphoria.

[@justinlalugski2083]

that little solo Trey played in this waste version kinda had that Gin Jam in it for a few bars.

[@LieutJimDangle]

wartimemodels Went Gin rules. Check out Anatomy of a Jam on that one.

[@jgfunk]

@@LieutJimDangle the anatomy of a jam on that is so great

[@Stevesk0011]

@@jgfunk exactly. What else is needed?

[@DaFreezeey]

There is already a breakdown of that exact jam called "anatomy of a jam" ... look it up

[@christopherdavies1759]

Phish! Yes Rick much respect! Billy breathes is an insanely underrated piece of work!

[@andrewthompson5242]

My favorite Phish album.

[@phowell333]

It's kind of like their "white album" for me.

[@be-bop4043]

Such a good album!

[@KarmicWealth]

This was my fav “what makes this song...”. I love Phish, but that’s not why. It’s because there was a calm, heartfelt meditative groove to your explanation. I dig it man. Thanks for existing. And I mean that sincerely.

[@GeekSpeakDesign]

Once a month I try to introduce my kids to music they haven’t heard... this morning I played “Weigh” for my high-schooler. Phish was a huge part of my youth

[@BAGOFROCKS]

Really? On a sunny day? Why Weigh?

[@ChristopherScanlan88]

Sparkle was my daughter's favorite Phish song when she was little.

[@dbrowdy]

My older brother introduced me to Phish in high school with "Contact".

[@wmleonard8562]

That's child abuse.

[@steved2112]

OK it's no longer a hypothetical: I will click on anything Rick Beato puts out.

[@steved2112]

I've always admired Phish's amazing musicianship, but I don't dig the jam band genre. That said, this is a really pretty song.

[@mitchweiner]

I’ve been doing that for years! He’s always interesting!

[@MCFalzarano]

Hey, I love this and never thought I liked or understood Phish. Thanks. What a great locale to have afternoon tea and play beautiful music. Learning more interesting things about music/bands I didn't know enough about 👍🎼☺️

[@micheleparker8123]

You did it again, Rick- introduced me to a world of music I've never heard and loving it. Time to update my repertoire. Thank you, my friend!💖

[@MatthewWebb62024]

You won't be disappointed.

[@Phishcactus]

welcome to the family

[@jimlanpheer5281]

Enjoy the journey! THIRTY FIVE years (and counting....) of incredible music to check out there.

[@MrPhilm00r]

My first favorite Phish song. It was the first song that I wanted to listen to after basic training. I'll never forget the moment that I heard music again finally and that beautiful guitar riff went straight to my heart.

[@valuedhumanoid6574]

I used to live a few miles from Deer Creek (don't know what it's called now, I call it the original name) which is an outdoor venue in central Indiana. It was always fun when the Grateful Dead or Phish would come and do three or four shows in a row for a whole week. Because I was so close to the campgrounds, we would always open up my house and let people shower, I would grill brats and burgers and not charge a penny for them, things like that. I only had one problem with one of the Phisheads and that was just because he had done too much Molly and was out of his mind. For the most part the fans are courteous, respectful and always appreciative. I had a giant oak tree in my front yard and I would have ten or fifteen Deadheads/Phisheads sitting under it with someone playing guitar, someone with bongos and my wife would bring out a pitcher of lemonade and ice water and we would just jam. I miss those days.

[@mikesmith8860]

I may have hung out at your place summer of 96 Phish Tour

[@valuedhumanoid6574]

@@mikesmith8860 That would have been the time frame.

[@mikesmith8860]

The tree sounds really familiar, i had just turned 21 a few weeks prior, was on tour with my new gf, so on the adventure of a new relationship while on the adventure of a tour. Its people like you who make magic real, thank you even if it wasnt your place we hung at, kindness like yours keeps hope flowing....i texted her, this morning, she thinks she still has some pics from that tour, she is looking to see if she has any from there, if she finds any ill pass them on to see if that was your pad

[@mutoneon]

They've been playing Deer Creek every year lately!

[@anthoniegonzalez]

Long live Deer Creek !

[@williambock1821]

Fishman is one of my favorite drummers of all time. Unbelievable limb independence.

[@themayorvt2]

Masterful he makes it look so easy

[@tstahlfsu]

Saw these guys in 99, 00, and 01 and haven't looked back. Love Phish.

[@lisas7741]

They’ve gotten even better in the 3.0-4.0 years!

[@quintongibbons1069]

It’s about time Rick talked about phish

[@philiphalpenny3783]

Phish are devotees of the stupendously great Little Feat. Has Rick ever examined the slide guitar genius Lowell George?

[@MCFalzarano]

@@philiphalpenny3783 yes!! Little Feat.. can't wait for that analysis.

[@travisbicklesmohawk7069]

Billy Breathes has always reminded me of Pet Sounds. The way the tracks are arranged gives it a similar 'feel.' Like it's trying to tell you a story that takes place over a long period of time.

[@garysheer]

As a beginner guitarist who has glued himself to Rick's "How to play a pentatonic scale" video, I am ecstatic to find out he's not only a Phish fan, but has relations to Trey! Small world.

[@jeffd4497]

I’m a huge Phish fan. My family not so much. Was listening to this acoustic version and my mom remarked “wow what beautiful singing” - never thought I’d see the day when someone complimented phish on their vocals. True testament to how good this version is.

[@soyounoat]

Page McConnell is just amazing with his vocal harmonies and keyboard work. Thing I love about PHiSH is that each of the 4 members is indispensable and irreplaceable. It really is a serendipitous union of the right people, and I have been a devoted fan since 1991.

[@dlunsford1980]

I went down the Phish rabbit hole around 1996 and never came back up.

[@MrPhilm00r]

same

[@PYITE314]

Same here - saw my first show in 97 when I was 17 and haven't stopped since. Even flew to Florida (from WA) for Big Cypress NYE 2000 - that was crazy.

[@dlunsford1980]

@@PYITE314 looks we are the same age.

[@ggvilleman1]

Same... then got to see em first in fall 97 at the Nutter Center in Dayton! Been chasing it ever since!

[@johnballs0540]

That sound like my dad

[@adamedk]

Billy Breathes was my intro to Phish back in 1996 - I’ve been hooked every since. Thanks for covering Waste!

[@domcagney2352]

Not enough people respect the one of a kind genius of Phish, they're my favorite band of all time. I had no idea you that connection to Trey Rick, that's awesome...I'm an even bigger fan now. Phish has an endless expanse of songs, they've been touring since the late 80's with only 2 breaks, they're still putting out albums...I can never put into proper words what this band means to me. I'm glad to see, slowly but surely, people are getting past their preconceived notions about what Phish is all about and checking them out. You really won't find a better 4 piece set of musicians in music. Inventive, uplifting, extremely skilled, funky, energetic, eclectic, original...I could go on for days lol

[@brianrodman1033]

Man I love how diverse the songs you cover in these videos are

[@WitStream1]

Trey is the best, on numerous levels. So glad to see you give him a nod and glad to hear you worked together!

[@drdrofub4544]

Yes. Longtime fan, first time caller. I’m fan of your channel and grew up on Led Zep, VH, Yes, etc... but I’ve been deeply into Phish for 20 years and...Waste was my and my wife’s wedding song. Lotta hate towards them (?) so good to see some love. Keep on keepin’ on.

[@HT-io1eg]

I’d never heard of Phish. Just bought the album. You should point this out to blockers

[@rauldutari7532]

Enjoy!

[@tezk9044]

Blockers are Fokkers

[@natural1952]

Blockers don't care.

[@jamesparr6840]

Just bought it too...!

[@literallyshaking8019]

Buy their first album “Junta” I’ll check back in in 10 years after you’ve spent thousands of dollars following them around the country all summer/fall.

[@deBebbler]

Nice choice of Waste. NEED MOAR PHISH!!!

[@murraylynn7631]

Never really listened to Phish before, even though they were releasing music in "my era". Great song. As I listened to you describing how the melody works with the chord progression it got me thinking about one of my favourite courses from my undergraduate degree. In my 4th year at university, I had some extra credit space to take up so I decided to take a course offered by my school's music faculty for non-music students. It was call "Popular Music in Society". The course calendar described it as a survey of popular music. It sounded like an easy, fun course to lighten the load in my final semester of my final year. It was taught by the wife of the bass player from the band "Spirit of the West". On the first day of class about 50 people showed up. The professor walked in and the first words out of her mouth were "everybody is here for songwriting, correct?" She then described that the course work would be writing songs and performing them in front of the class. A little more than half the class got up and walked out. I decided to stay. Over the next 4 months, we went through a series of excercises and projects that had us creating our own lyrics and developing melodies. It was scary at first for an economics major but really fun. The reason this video got me thinking about that was when you were describing the relationship between notes in the melody and the chord progression. It got me to thinking about a few questions with regards to song writing and developing melodies. What is a more effective way to write music, develop a melody idea fist and build a chord progression around it or develop a chord progression idea first and find the melody in the chord progression? Or is it a mix of a bit of both? And what makes a better song? Love your videos. I always learn something when you break down these songs.

[@bigneiltoo]

Junta (1988) is their best. Billy Breathes (1996) probably second best IMO.

[@KingPhoey]

I am going to have to revisit this band. When that album came out I was listening to heavier stuff and now that I am older and writing my own songs I really relate to this band a lot more.

[@Lightningph]

Yes!!! Check out the new album Sigma Oasis!!!

[@thick_air]

Phish does get heavy as well

[@anthonynicholson5523]

Thanks Rick!! A band that has been a part of my life in so many ways for the last 25 years and your channel a daily part of my life the last two and a life saver during 2020...and you are both are connected. Crazy. It’s like there is a string of goodness that travels through people I gravitate towards and they all end up being connected somehow. Thank you for this.

[@aesteinberg]

As much as I love music, I love how you, Rick, help me understand how and why I appreciate it. I love Phish, and "waste" is one of my favorites. Your "WMTSG" is just fantastic. Love you, love your channel! Keep on rockin'!

[@epochalyptic_]

Yes, saw this live in Mexico two years ago and came back home and learned to cover it. Noticed the key change later for sure lol, I like it in standard myself. Another phenomenal story and breakdown Rick, thank you!

[@RC32Smiths01]

Phish is one of the more unique and interesting sounding bands for sure! I didn't expect a WMTSG on them, but I am excited.

[@AllenA-d1q]

There are a few aspects that always brings joy to my heart and I play, and sing this song is amazing the way it progresses. Reason it sounds so great is the amount of practice and times they've played it. A dream is true....

[@matthewoboyle6010]

I'm not a huge Phish fan by any stretch, but I respect them immensely. This song and this version of Waste are absolutely incredible. Completely blown away by both and I love Rick teaching us about the musical aspects of it. Trey has also done a wonderful cover of It Makes No Difference from The Band, which is one of my favorite songs and covers ever.

[@slandersir7255]

You might like Billy Breathes too, if you enjoy this song.

[@Gschmidt247]

I always thought rick hated phish LMFAO this makes me happy

[@kierstbtown2992]

If ever there was a “satisfying” album, this is surely it. Loved to hear the analysis and the story of working with Trey.

[@jackginnever4401]

I don't know how I haven't seen this for 2 years. I've followed Phish since about 1994. I had no idea that Rick worked with them. This connects with me in so many ways. First, I'm a keyboard player who used to have a Wurly. And Page McConnell is one of my favorite keyboard players. And Trey's songs are so great. To dissect this song like this is exactly what drives me. Wonderful work Rick!!!

[@toddr.lockwood843]

Excellent commentary, Rick. Waste is one of Phish's most fundamental compositions, and a good example of deceptive simplicity. I owned White Crow Audio in Burlington, the studio where Phish recorded A Picture of Nectar, and Rift in the early nineties. Even back then, these four guys had already developed into formidable musicians. They maintained a strict rehearsal schedule and focused 100% on developing their music. It showed.

[@timharrington4470]

What makes this channel great? Ridiculously awesome content provided by one Rick Beato. Now I'm going to be listening to some Phish for the next few days. What a beautiful chord progression.

[@SG-js2qn]

It's funny to me that when they're playing it doesn't sound like the Beatles, but when Rick's playing, it really does. Subtle stuff.

[@mattwright6075]

My exact thoughts.

[@tbahamaful]

NJ guy here Old friend in Aspen let me know how much he was enjoying your videos. I’m very happy to be on board. My guitar is dusted off and I’m happily playing along. You’ve got great taste

[@SlothVsPlatypus]

This song was the last dance at my wedding. Gets me every time. Love phish, one of the best bands.

[@davidhoxit4274]

Haven't listened to alot of Phish but I enjoyed this

[@drumsybatabamboom8022]

Billy Breathes is such an inspired album! That opening track "Free" had me hooked with those chord changes!

[@pitpride1220]

Never been a Phish fan. If Rick is into it, I'll at least give it a shot.

[@marysmith7765]

I wasn’t either until I heard Billy Breathes. I think it would be time well spent.

[@christopherpenny6216]

They never get enough credit. People write them off as a jam band. The structure of their stuff is great. They do silly stuff but I like to think it's because they can.

[@liquidsolids9415]

The Story of the Ghost is a great album too. Enjoy!

[@happiness1772]

All I know about Phish is that old AxCx song about them called "Beating Up Hippies for Their Drugs at a Phish Concert."

[@ralelunar]

Yeah, me neither, this song was wonderful to discover

[@Norweeg]

I didn’t expect to see Phish on this channel as I was scrolling through my feed. Those boys from Vermont are by far my favorite band.

[@dbrowdy]

Says the guy with a "Yes" album cover avatar! :-D

[@chrisgreer2692]

This absolutely made my night. So happy to see these guys on here.

[@paulthorn6437]

The was my wedding song. Some of the family were giving my wife and I side-eye when they announced it, but I could give a f***.

[@TheDirge69]

Great choice, the lyrics are so pertinent.

[@matabercrombie3816]

We had a bluegrass band play at our wedding and I made them learn this for our first dance.

[@lisas7741]

This is a perfect wedding song, your family has no taste in music if you got the side eye aka stink eye, over this!

[@pebblesanddirt]

It was our first dance at our wedding

[@DabsDad]

It was mine too. I miss my wife who passed. It was her favorite along with Strange Design.

[@Brooksnation1]

This was a real treat Rick. Thank you so much. So many great Phish songs but this has always been one of my favorites too. BB is such a killer record. Man, this duet version is really wonderful.

[@kevinworth]

Love coming back to this one! I would love to see a long form interview with you and Trey! Fingers crossed!

[@ThatOtherRaccoon]

Many of the bands that have appeared on here I'm not a fan of at all, BUT the amount of time, effort, and resources that go into the music created HAS to be respected. So although many of these bands are not my cup of tea, I have a huge amount of respect for what they have done.

[@kenduffy5397]

You are SO right! I’m not the biggest Phish fan. When I tell people “I’m not the biggest fan” all I mean is, I’m not a fan of that band, player, singer, or genre but I ALWAYS respect & enjoy the breakdown Rick does of their immense talents, & he is an awesome player! Now if I say: “I hate this Band guy or gal” that means in my opinion they’re overrated & or have as much talent as I do! I’m not a bad player actually but to be GREAT? An artist needs to be so above my level regardless if I’d practice 10 hours a day! I’d never be* as good.

[@nlgliarmis503]

Thank god. Don’t know what these bands what have done without your respect

[@ThatOtherRaccoon]

@@nlgliarmis503 I know huh? They should have an altar with my comment on it and just..thank it every morning.

[@ThatOtherRaccoon]

@@mikeaustin4138 I would agree, I have always been proud of being able to pick things out of songs and hear every instrument individually while also hearing the band as a whole. Rick's WMTSG series sheds a TON of light on things that I didn't even realize were there. Songs like "Black" that I swore I could hear every part of. I missed the piano even though it's obvious that it's there. What I'm getting at is that there will be bands that although I'm not a fan of them, the amount of effort that goes into their art is something that I respect and admire about them, even though, like I said, I wouldn't be a fan of their music.

[@rebelbarnes6382]

I know this one will probably fly under the radar, but how about a What Makes This Song Great on Slint? They were incredibly important in the foundations of post-rock, and did some very unique things in the music world.

[@convergefan1568]

Agreed. Just a classic.

[@liquidsolids9415]

This was another great episode. I love when you analyze the melody notes and how they fit in with the harmony to create an effective melody. The harmony vocal analysis was really helpful as well. Thanks for another great video!

[@petersavage5539]

Oh man. In the last year I've picked up my guitar again for the first time in decades. I've watched a number of your videos and to see you appreciating Phish and Trey just made my day. Thanks!!

[@jonn443]

PHISH???! Let me be one of the ones to say that I am absolutely thrilled beyond belief that you are incorporating Phish in your music series. I am a drummer and an avid musician and let me tell you that there is less than 1% of musicians that have the skill level and raw talent of Trey, Mike, John, and Page. They are all masters of their instruments.

[@filldrummin42]

Trey has excellent time because he actually started as a drummer. In the live show he plays drums any time they bring Henrietta out from behind the tubs to front the band. It's also why a lot of his compositions are rhythmically interesting as well as sonically. And if you're going to break down a song, please make it something like that (rhythmically and sonically interesting). Something like 'It's Ice' or 'Guyute' would be incredible. Keep up the excellent work!

[@brianrodman1033]

One of my favorite Phish songs. I just caught the duet video the other day, it was certainly a treat. You manage to cover a lot of songs that I really like and it’s always a treat to hear your insight when you break down the song structures.

[@Phished2001]

I’ve watched dozens of your videos and have always been very happy with the content. This was very interesting to see you approach phish and do so on a video of two members in an acoustic setting. Thanks for the great videos

[@VBshredder]

Was hoping for "You Enjoy Myself" but this is still a cool song. I really enjoy the more progressive work they do.

[@mazen2928]

One of their best songs...it's actually different styles in one song.

[@michaelsingJiuJitsu]

Only problem is Ricks video would end up being like 3 days long...

[@icculus19]

@@michaelsingJiuJitsu amd the problem is.......

[@perly2]

Check out the YEM from the 6/11/94 Red Rocks show. Absolutely insane.

[@John_Hudson_922]

we can hope

[@chris49ford]

Phish Food is the best Ben & Jerry's flavor, right after Cherry Garcia

[@bigneiltoo]

I was at The Great Went (1997) and met either Ben or Jerry who was running their ice cream stand.

[@marcoesquandoles5934]

Thanks so much Rick! That made my day and I will always see you you in a new light. My love for Phish and guitar are my Rock. Waste is truly a great song and some new faces will hear that! Well done!

[@erikhoffman2866]

I truly loved Shine...and the tour that supported it. Martin made a pro model for him at that time too! Glad he cleaned himself up. All the love

[@Nick-ih3xg]

Phish is awesome,this is a great little rendition. Could you also show these people trey's jamming and shredding skills? Show your subs just how good they can be plugged in and jamming?

[@gmiller598]

Interesting that I never knew you had worked with Trey. I know that was during his period where I think he lost his way a bit creatively from the drug use. I'd be curious to know your thoughts on how he has changed since he got clean. As a long time Phish fan I can tell he just looks so happy and positive now in his creations.

[@santotiago80]

I love this series so much! Rick teaches you a lot of useful music theory stuff but at the same time shows you how to listen and appreciate music

[@1968thedon]

Thank you so much for doing this song.... It always brings me to tears... it's nice to get a deeper look at it

[@PYITE314]

Thank you for talking about Phish! Please do more, perhaps You Enjoy Myself, Run Like an Antelope, or Stash - any of their funky rocking stuff. There is PLENTY to choose from.

[@ryanbyrd3835]

Cool. Haven't listened to Billy Breathes in forever. This takes me back.

[@atamagashock]

Dope to see you talk about phish! Waste will always remind me of my friend mike who sadly passed away in March 2010. I’ve always loved waste and it’s a treat everytime I see it.

[@edphaze6550]

Thanks so much for this! I'd really love to see more Phish on your channel. Love what you do for the musical community.

[@sonnysmith3713]

YES! Trey is a guitar GOD and he doesn't get enough credit.

[@lordmanshaft1112]

What? Trey gets tons of praise critically, and is borderline worshipped by corporate hippies

[@gfchiropractic]

Sad how right you are

[@joshuamorganmusic]

Trey isn’t a god...he’s a fucking JEDI🤘🎶🤓been following this band since Big Cypress!

[@Katatopianos]

Especially his stuff from the 90s. He was at his peak. Even today though he rips.

[@RussellSpurlock]

@@lordmanshaft1112 but he is never on the lists of "the greats", which I find insane Personally, I think Trey is easily in the top 10

[@t.sewell1513]

Free is an excellent cut off this album as well. And whatever is being played on Bliss (I believe banjo and bass) is wonderful!

[@Sooby007]

And Taste - that tune is amazing!

[@WhiteWolf--]

I believe its a 12 string Martin on Bliss, a couple of them doubletracked, panned left and right

[@tstahlfsu]

Free is one of my favs

[@peetrwilson]

Bliss is one of my favorite Phish songs! So sublime.

[@karltannous]

Billy Breathes and Story of the Ghost take me back to a very special time and place.. who knew that I needed to hear this song today. Thank you!

[@stripedelicstudios]

Yes! I love that song and was super jazzed to see them doing this outdoor video. So cool you hung out with them in Vermont

[@curt6525]

I was recommended vids of the trey guy this morning, I'd never heard of them before and now you're doing this? The great A.I GOD

[@marcoesquandoles5934]

This Trey guy is where it's at.

[@mattflickinger8151]

He has been streaming free (live) on Fridays at 8pm. I know its on Twitch, but might be elsewhere aslo

[@tmwsiy7158]

@@mattflickinger8151 Nope....just on Twitch unless someone is boomeranging it...but since it's free i don't think anyone is doing that.

[@merseyviking]

I pressed play, saying, "waste... waste... waste..." and lo! This makes me so happy!

[@stevehajewski6264]

I'm hooked on this channel, great to see you talking about Phish. "Waste" and "If i Could" have such amazing harmony.

[@tdubveedub]

There is always something new to learn with your channel. Thank you, Rick. I think I need to listen to more Phish.

[@ronfigg1]

Phinally Phish!!! Trey is a Jedi!

[@HansyPants184]

Trey= pretty dang good. Trey+Brocolli Rob=God tier. They really need to do an encore album together.

[@jakek201]

Wow thanks Rick! Gonna have to check out more phish, I loooove these chords and the melody over top of it, seriously thank you.

[@danielmccar]

Love that you did a live version of a Phish song. And this performance is stunning.

[@wmfranz]

thanks for getting Phish on here.

[@davedionisio9679]

So glad you picked a "slow" Phish song. They have such a (well deserved) rep as the king of the jam bands but their songwriting, nuance and complexity can get overlooked as a result. Thanks Rick!

[@Douglas_I]

Trey is one of those people that seem to have an endless amount of musical creativity, a musical savant! He's someone that understands music in ways most of us never will but he knows how to translate it for us when need be! I could also listen to him talk all day! I absolutely love the BBC interview he did where he discusses what it was like at the end. He talks about the group of fans that he would see at every show and how he hopes they knew it was time to be done as well. Anyway, great episode as always Mr Beato!

[@soapalot]

I’d like to think that with the advancement of Artificial Intelligence that some day in the future everyone will have a Rick Beato app on their phone that can analyse their favourite tunes. I always find a new appreciation for the songs you do, Rick, and I’m often driven to go and pick up my guitar again. So thank you!

[@WhiteWolf--]

I originally grew up in Vermont and Phish was a huge influence on me musically back in the 90s (prompting me to procure a Ross compressor and a couple TS9's thinking I could sound remotely like Trey lol), and I still see them when I can, my aunt used to live across the field from the Barn there in the Underhill area and I would hear noodling long into the wee hours many nights. Thanks for this Rick, in my opinion Billy Breathes is really an amazing showcase of brilliant songwriting, jam-band or not, I think its sort of their Sgt Peppers, as they were absolutely firing on all cylinders at that point( folks who saw them live during this time almost unanimously agree). Knowing your history with Trey its super cool to hear you break this down brother, thanks!

[@joshevans3452]

Sorry to one of "those" guys but Rift is really more of their Sgt. Peppers given that it is a thematic composition.

[@WhiteWolf--]

@@joshevans3452 Lol no worries, to each their own bro, I love Rift, its an amazing concept album. BB was to me their more rock-orientated songwriting masterpiece but Rift is easily my second favorite album from that era, followed by PON, and most likely overall

[@3ggshe11s]

Nice! Phish has never gotten the critical acclaim they deserve. Anyone who wants to hear a good cross-section of their music can't go wrong with "A Live One."

[@Snewman513]

Rick, time and time again, your knowledge, enthusiasm and keen ear for detail find a way to give me goosebumps. At least one goosebump moment per "What Makes This Song Great?", guaranteed!

[@jgfunk]

So glad to Phish here. Been watching Beato videos for years, been seeing Phish live since 1993!

[@Kernel4Ben]

What a nice surprise today, PHISH!!!

[@mattrudybass]

That vamp had a very "Cassidy" feel to it. Love it.

[@Mixolydio]

I’ve been patiently licking my chops waiting to see Phish land in this series. Beautifully done Rick. Thank you for it

[@knastvogel]

Thank you Mr. Beato. You make me appreciate great music even more. Can't wait for your next video.

[@zigguratdemetrius5984]

Hell yeah man. My dad went to UVM in the 80s and saw them all the time at Nectar’s in Burlington. Love Phish

[@PYITE314]

Waste is such a beautiful and calming song that I used to play it to put my baby son to bed.

[@nozziebear8478]

Awesome stuff Rick! Thanks for this and all your other awesome content!

[@thecthonian4976]

I must admit I never got into Phish before but this video intrigued me quite a bit. This is a great song and it makes me want more when I hear you analyze it. Thanks Rick! I love your videos. Really its some of my favorite content. Keep up the good work.