Roots of Balochistan's Crisis | Dr. Ammar Ali Jan and Dr. Hafeez Jamali | The Red Room

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

I am a Baloch American from Balochistan thank you for good program

[@jamilkhan715]

Very educative and timely .involvement of the local population is more important than deployment of toops to ensure the safety of the foreign investors.

[@lmclibya402]

Thank you for going though all this trouble for bringing us such an informative video...

[@samspiritual]

A must watch for every Pakistani.

[@Mehrabkhan11909]

Very beautifully presented & Analysed by Sir Hafeez Jamali Thanks

[@muznamalik4798]

I recorded him as well this August for Balochi tribal stories. Wonderful and learned person.

[@muhammadanwar9826]

Informative and based on logic and facts. Thanks

[@BilalMustikhan]

Glad to see Professor Jamali after so long

[@asaddani6735]

Absolutely amazing 👏

[@A.SMotivation-ii1wk]

❤ love 💕 sir thank you great work for educational content

[@learnwithsaeed1]

Awesome analysis

[@khudaedadkhan5529]

Great reasonable and well analysis about Balochistan in crises

[@jamal76US]

You know , you know “No sir I don’t know”

[@jamilkhan715]

That was just his conversation style. As we say in urdu: سمجھے آپ! He did justice to the topic anyway.

[@mindbodyexpert]

Congratulations “Mr Hafeez jamali U No - Urf - You Know”

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

Very nice BALOCH AND BALOCHISTAN INTELLECTUAL OBJECTIVELY

[@MinaMahboob]

One of my favourite channels ❤❤❤❤❤

[@ghulamali7247]

Dr.Jamali sb has well elaborated the root- cause of baloch and balochistan crisis.

[@berkantjan9664]

Untill and unless the issue if Balochistan is addressed it is impossible to bring peace and stability in the province. And it is directly related to Baloch national identity, Their legal recognition on their resources, land, and all major decision must be taken by them..the issue of Baloch and Balochistan is not some proxy war based on geopolitics and power struggle in the region. These are secondary. Its a historic and genuine issue deepky rooted in Baloch national identity politics and grievences .. All they want is their due right. These so called proxy war theories are just escapes or pretexts from understanding and accepting the issue as it is. We accept it or not. The truth is without the consent of Baloch nation it is impossiple to bring peace in the province... And other truth is now they are in full control of their land and resources. Even military operations are usless these .

[@tahirhashmi9832]

Very informative

[@hamzaiqbal1444]

New drinking game: You take a shot every time Jamali Sahab says "You know". Jokes aside, very insightful video. Learnt a lot from it.

[@rumsha_khalid]

Takiya kalaam hai Jamali sahab ka.

[@farooqbaloch979]

Bahot se loog baar ok ok boltay rehtay hain ,bahot se loog beech me baar baar understand understand boltay hai ,ye aadat bolain takiya e kalam boolain ,hi Ue koi issue nahe,baal ki kaal na nikala karain,sirf topic pe focus karain.

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

I AM A BALOCH AMERICAN FROM BALOCHISTAN LIVING IN AUSTIN TEXAS USA.

[@manojthaker3678]

Two nations theory Pakistan and Bangladesh. Now Pakistan and Balochistan 😇

[@Bendigaan]

Why Baloch should recognize by bakistan even they have their own identity Rich resources land and History.

[@mbs0710]

You Know You Know You Know You Know You Know You Know You Know

[@magagago2013]

The British policy or rule for that matter is overemphasised by Pakistani scholars. The pakistani state policies triggered far effective changes, as it faced more serious challenges after partition. Pakistan's sense of insecurity, especially after secession of Bangladesh, changed the situation for worse for smaller communities in particular for Baloch. The Pakistan's sense of insecurity had repercussion for all smaller provinces as KPK and Sindh too other than Balochistan although at different times. Since Pakistan's power corridors were dominated by Security apparatus, the security issue got magnified culminating at emaciated state of Pakistan.

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

Please do about Baloch and Balochistan intellectuals and political and human rights activists

[@mediaboxx8143]

Ammar long live❤

[@slicktip]

You know.

[@mindbodyexpert]

No we don’t know

[@dinbuzdar5567]

In 1947 November last week & 1948 January 1st week in Dhader Lower &Upper Houses of Balochistan assemblies unanimously voted for Independence. Sir you missed it.

[@balochbalochistan3935]

بلوچستان کا کوئی الحاق آج تک پاکستان کے ساتھ نہیں جمالی جھوٹ بول رہے ہیں 27 مارچ 1948 کو پاکستان نے جبری طور پر قبضہ کیا ہے بلوچستان کے دونوں ایوانوں یعنی ایوانوں بالا اور ایوانوں زیرین جن کا اجلاس 1947کو ڈھاڈر کے مقام پر ہوا تھا نے الحاق کو مسترد کیا تھا اس وقت پاکستان کی وجہ سے بلوچستان شدید بدحالی کا شکار ہے 1947 ستمبر کو خان آف قلات نے 13 سو کلو سونا دیکر پاکستان کے زرمبادلہ کو بین لاقوامی دنیا میں تسلیم کرایا جو کہ غلطی تھا

[@SabźBaloch-w4w]

Totally disagree 👎🏻 For your information Pakistan has occupied my land in 1947 through British military support from that day we are resisting for our freedom.

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

There is no democratic federal or confederate in Pakistan Iran and afghanistan.the Balochistan must and the other provinces must Vito power in senate and assembly.the all provinces must get 75% from resources of provinces.and all nationalities languages must be national languages..we are not being oppressing by Israel America or Russia or China. We are being oppressing by Muslim countries pakistan Iran and Afghanistan like our brother nation kurds

[@magagago2013]

Democracy, if allowed, would have solved most of issues of Pakistan or at least true nature of issues would have appeared to resolve. Unfortunately the clique at he helm of affairs have interest to serve directly in contrast of state's interest. The rulers have to understand that Pakistan is diverse in many ways and further futile attempts to erase diversity must be avoided.

[@mindbodyexpert]

Congratulations “Mr Hafeez jamali U No - Urf - You Know”

[@musicofbalochistan12]

Baloch Libreation Army Zindabad💚🩵❤️🇩🇯

[@RA-yv8nh]

I have to stop this very informational podcast midway through because the guest speaker is adding ‘you know’ in every sentence and i can’t focus on the information.

[@eonworldwide4724]

In the creation of nations many coercive tactics are used always This is justified only when those nations become prosperous lest the past history is dug out In the case of India too similar coercion was applied against Hyderabad but this never came out because India prospered Concessions once given to one province will lead to others asking for the same Hence not practical

[@lhauae]

U know u know....so irritating 😢

[@hajibaqi9788]

پاکستان کو عملاً پنجابی ریاست بنا کر رکھ دیا اور اس کے لیے تو پاکستان کو دولخت کیا تاکہ بنگلہ دیش کو الگ کر کے پنجاب کی ڈومیننسی قائم ہو جائے کیونکہ بنگال کو الگ کئیے بغیر پنجاب کی ڈومیننسی قائم نہیں ہو سکتا تھا،

[@NaeemBaloch-y6w]

Roots of balochistan injustes ...

[@Saidumer-pb5uf]

Not speaking the whole truth may be scares.

[@danishkhan-xd7xi]

Not convincing analysis...u know

[@thewonders2673]

Sir, aap ky channel per sab say ziada Adds aaty hai, please aap ye corporatism band kare.

[@rumsha_khalid]

Get a KZbin premium subscription to avoid adds instead of expecting the creators to not run them. Dr. Ammar Ali Jan has been fired from one university after another; the state has left no stone unturned in trying to financially cripple him. Activists like him have a right to earn through alternative channels in order to sustain their livelihood and their activism.

[@ejazbaloch8349]

He explained history probably but he is Unfamiliarity current situation of Balochistan

[@aminbaloch8195]

I didn't enjoy this interview of him because he is more Pakistani than Baloch. Pakistanis don't express Baloch problems correctly. Find another real guy who knows exactly the problem. Simply, Baloch are NOT Pakistanis , so sugar and salt are different chemical ingredients.

[@mindbodyexpert]

You Know - No I don’t know

[@BABARIJAZ-e2f]

Too much you know

[@Farooqbegoobegoo]

Baloch never accept Pakistan i can understand you can't say ture because your Punjabi 😂😂😂😂 show me the history where Baloch accept Pakistan?? As you know any proffers

[@mudassirhussain3802]

Please stop saying you know

[@faheemshah6217]

You know 😂

[@deedagbaloch3411]

Yes we know it is biased

[@thebestmoments2105]

Pakistan Zindabad SB pop KO shuffle kr do SB set ho jaaay ga