Ryan Tedder Reacts to Student Songs from his Studio class

[@graceintheplace13]

I can’t believe how much this human knows about music. That was incredibly impressive.

[@grandpanda2791]

He gave feedback in such a positive and friendly way, I love it

[@afpwfarmer]

All of these videos are incredible. Amazed they don't have millions of views. Everyone with an interest in music needs to watch this

[@cynthiacairns9209]

He was the best part of that tv show Songland. Just to watch him work with a songwriter was such a gift! I wish he'd do another show like that!

[@fatuzi]

really wish that show would come back

[@riffism]

Tedder is a fucking hit machine for a reason.

[@sViviftie]

Ryan's feedback made so much sense but I really want to point out that first song was already so GREAT wtf these people have potential

[@tskolits]

Excellent feedback on those songs. Encouraging and also specific areas that the songs could improve. I learned a ton just from Ryan’s feedback. Thanks again.

[@joericeacoustic]

"Feel Something" was interesting - for like part of a film score, somethin along those lines

[@pdxfun4888]

He does not do this with all the tracks from all participants. He is very knowledgeable and quickly can assess what you can do to improve your song. He does have assistance and they do the same . He is amazing regardless and a beast with his skill set . Gifted

[@michaelgormleymusic]

That “rogue” note in the Jessica Lindsey song was a greeeaat shout. 👌🏼

[@DeSanKwuh]

This is why he's THE Ryan Tedder - I thought that first track was flawless but after his critique I found myself nodding to all his critiques 👏

[@tinagomez4418]

This is such a good video. Need this to be continuous series, I would love to hear more of Ryan's take on songs, he's very knowledgeable.

[@darioparisi6863]

7:18 is it just me or that note off scale sounds amazing. Sounds like she used the major 7 in a minor key which usually sounds pretty good

[@SaraSmilesandCreates]

I think if it was a bridge or verse 2 it wouldn’t be so jarring

[@beewirks]

never heard feedback spun in such a positive light so consistently before. solidifies my stanning of Ryan Tedder lol

[@KosteckiRealEstate]

Ryan is a living legend. Genius level analytics.

[@Strive4OnlineSuccess]

The feedback was really awesome. I have been to ASCAP and Taxi events, but enjoyed your critiques. I could watch more video like this, because I think the feedback is just awesome. You give people great ideas to make their song more solid especially with editing the melodies in the chorus.

[@ejstonemusic]

I’m not really a pop person, but theses songs sound great, and with Tedder’s input they would be amazing! He’s a genius 🤟

[@khayzwholewildtv5938]

the feedback is very amazing. i feel like i learned whole lot of information there

[@KasperK-su9oz]

He was spot on on all his little improvements. That's talent! I want that talent too.

[@ThinkerThunker]

I'm not ready for this class AT ALL. Not singing-wise or writing-wise. But ... I still might go ahead and sign up. Because it's obvious Ryan knows what he's talking about, he's a nice and genuine guy, I get and agree with pretty much everything he says on these critiques. Plus, I feel like this might get me started on the right foot.

[@phatsmitty]

@ 4:20 the chorus fix is perfect ...

[@martyjones8016]

Please please bring back Songland!!!

[@ashsaltzmanmusic4187]

Yes!

[@therealdiemond]

Some really nice tracks… crazy to think how many good artists are out there that just need some artistic direction and can easily be on top with the big ones. Jack Price reminded me a bit of The Midnight vibe. Nice. Really like Heidi’s one. With a solid production that can easily be my favorite.

[@CarolAnnRuaro]

Ryan's comments are very insightful, interesting, it's obvious he knows how to build a song!

[@mikoap24]

thankyou youtube for this recomendation

[@varunmodak6100]

First song’s guitar instantly reminded me of “I Think I’m Paranoid”

[@nebyusamuel7858]

this is why Ryan is a genius

[@danknittel1250]

All of these are fire!

[@ANGELSVEN]

I LUV this!, analyzing the arrangements for what works, what doesn't work optimally and what could be better (melody, instrument arrangement, etc.). And I totally relate to your arrangement instincts. Your analysis of the "Super 8" chorus is SPOT ON (the "window" repeat and ascension half way through the chorus ~ perfect). I agree, there are two strong artists in that group. I wish your classes were live instead of just on line.

[@pinkpalmsmusic]

oh man, great teacher. i wish i could work with someone like that every day. so much fun.

[@jeffrey.a.hanson]

On _I Could Use a Beach_ , I heard the payoff rhyming off *you* - “Ain’t no thing to *do* . Take in the *view* . Don’t know bout *you* , but if you ask _me_ …I could use a _beach_ for *two* .” Luke Bryan does this often and lets that soft rhyme be the teaser. Other option is a hard stop on the ‘me’ and really make it known. (This song would be a blast to co-write on…)

[@SubyPradhanOfficial]

You are the MAN ! thousand claps for this brilliant tip. I just tried and it worked 🙂

[@Revoic]

this is the best feedback video on youtube

[@shantanusharmamusic]

All the songs seem quite good to me. I guess that they were appropriately pre-chosen for the video :)

[@tourneytike13]

Just came to hear him say "urban undertones".

[@natemoyer6664]

Love love Super 8.

[@dohnjoe735]

They should have gone full on into the edm post chorus

[@steveboris6286]

If these are Ryan's student songs then I have to take this class.

[@AswantKumar]

Humble and a genius guy❤

[@contefedri]

Unbelievable how good this man is 🎉

[@peys032vid]

I totally agree with reacts Ryan, his genius.

[@AlfieTheProducer]

Perfect feedback.

[@hbmluiks]

The first song is a banger!🔥🔥🔥

[@Peakfreud]

Interesting I thought it sounded like a run on sentence. I don't mean this in a negative way just different taste in music.

[@deanandrewww]

I want that Heidi Webster song “Gold” to be a collaboration with Flume 😭

[@madeleine.stevens]

Feels like an Illenium song

[@KordTaylor]

Yup that Portis and London Grammer ref was good. That weird harm (male?) vocal stack in the Chorus was kinda weird.

[@HarlequinDolls]

“Feel Something” felt like it belonged on Arcane specifically imo

[@dohnjoe735]

Super 8 took his advice, i just listened to the song !

[@lisawaterhouse5985]

This is awesome!!!

[@Geregamo]

Loco immediately resonated 🔥

[@braxtonolita]

love this guy fr

[@itscameronbloom]

This was so useful!!

[@andrewroyster7980]

Song 2 could explain/desribe what feeling something is such as.. the lights surrounding us like magic the thought running through my mind like a bad habit...

[@patrickgarrity5529]

This was sick . More!!

[@DBicakci]

6:34 it is in a side scale. if she continued to hit one more note on that scale I am sure you would be like oh right. and I think its awesome as she chose to use only one note, others are all two notes. but yes it is a bit for ears who are into those things. i think it sounds very good.

[@ayseetv4875]

I thought that note was amazing. Gave it a fleeting jazz/cabaret feel and was a pleasant surprise.

[@franklinschieman7601]

It's a major 7

[@ayseetv4875]

If you don't mind, can you explain? I play piano but never took lessons and don't really know scales. The song is in A-minor, and the note in question is an A-flat. I thought the 7th of an A scale was G. An A-flat note would be the 7th in a B-flat major scale, right?

[@ZevMeth_originaljewishmusic]

I feel like it could've been fuller sounding, it sounded a bit dry to me.

[@dylanburrowsmusic3376]

@@ayseetv4875 If the song is in A-minor, G would be the minor 7th above A. However, minor scales often include a raised 7th and/or a raised 6th. The raised 7th in this case would be G#, also known as A-flat. Raising the 7th creates a stronger pull back to A. Hope this helps.

[@xznilloalexander6166]

This guy is kinda ridiculously good.

[@musicmoneymaker6457]

Feel Something has that so called off notes in the major melody is fine. Remember Katy Perry did it in Dark Horse

[@lucassimon9779]

Absolutely but it can be a red flag to reconsider if it’s not quite right to the point where it takes you out of the song and makes you scrunch up a little ya know but you’re not wrong

[@jijst5]

Reminded me of that!

[@latinmusicavideos]

Awesome on point feedback.

[@TpyoQueen]

He didn't like that note because it made him feel something

[@Dilbot447]

3:48 Ryan Tedder should remix these songs!

[@oniilumabito]

Anybody else hear THE STUDENT'S SONGS and come away discouraged like me? lol

[@zaltzband]

RYAN YOU ARE A LEGEND - I freaking connected with everything you said and we think the same thoughts! Creepy!!!! Dream of meeting you one day and jamming, it'll happen!

[@ZevMeth_originaljewishmusic]

Why don't you sign up for the course Shloimy? I know you really don't need any pointers, as you're already top notch, but it'd probably be the easiest way to connect with Ryan!

[@biggareid]

im impressed

[@xdrian]

@FreeOrgans need to work with Ryan

[@jamesbott2086]

Maybe it's out of reach...but I could use a beach.

[@kevinjonofficial]

Great songs great video

[@kahyui2486]

5:03 is that quaqmire

[@qosmick.]

Twenty something sounds 89% Ryan Tedder-ish

[@KordTaylor]

Great comments I think. Not enough thought about the chorus these days I think. ❤

[@mattgraunke30]

Does anyone know if something like this exists for Filmmakers? I’m talking short form like music videos, commercials and short films. Would be cool to have this sort of feedback, Any recs would be great!

[@aerial5554]

there any many on masterclasses you can look up masterclass "film making"

[@malovina]

Oh wow Heidi!!

[@deanandrewww]

Ryan, be my teacher bruh

[@jakobmorningstar]

I Could Use A Beach sounds awfully close to Dierks Bentley’s Somewhere On A Beach, little close

[@MrDlnggorton]

All of these songs are far better than mainstream music

[@chrisvo203]

thats just...wrong LOL i mean music is subjective so you're entitled to your own opinion, but production wise, writing wise, and mix wise, these are at or below the average mainstream track

[@milim3135]

Shit I need this class

[@L.I.N.N.]

Whats the drink in the can?

[@andrewroyster7980]

Song #1 why not add a chorus like "life's so much more simple when you're twenty something, no worries about nothing"

[@vladimirciboci1485]

Great site. !!!About that "dissonant" note. I think it really sounds great and ti was deliberate by someone who knows music theory etc. or just has a great ear. That note creates a new chord. One could play a new chord behind it but it would not sound so great, at least not for my ears. Thanks for the great channel.

[@kelvynification]

I love the dissonant note in the melody:)

[@reaganlopezmusic]

yeah.. I agree..

[@saadiansar]

7:40 That note is very much in the scale and sounds fricking great addition to the melody, adding a melodic progression. Taking nothing away from this video which I really enjoyed watching.

[@filipmortensen2544]

it just came in the wrong place, should come later

[@pombalazio]

It would sit better if supported/reinforced by the arrangement/harmony

[@CityStarrzz]

He didn’t say it wasn’t… he said it’s a note in the scale he would avoid. Not the same thing

[@harmonicdaze]

As producers, we're all gonna have differing views based on our personal tastes etc. I would keep it the same, it sounds fine to me.

[@jijst5]

no because the songs doesnt contain any chords from harmonic minor

[@brooklynboy1000]

First song? Does it evmmeb have a chorus? Didn’t hear one.

[@ROGERKUE]

❤

[@MTKnockOut]

You have to do layers why wouldn’t you do rock layers Singers don’t make music shoot I forgot

[@mazfarnadeem1846]

Great guy! But it just doesn’t make sense sometimes. A nobody could make a song which would make no sense at all and could be the biggest song of the year 😅

[@thunderbird2426]

🙌🎶💫🙌🌻✌️🙂

[@pappyprimetime7510]

Where is the fire in the youth today? The world sucks and the youth are listening to and making all of this happy pop. Get angry kids. You should be

[@ransbarger]

We called it bubblegum back in the day.

[@SoundConstraints]

almost all of the youth are making sad music thanks to juice wrld and lil peep lol. This just happens to be a pop class

[@itsrlyshad]

🤔

[@KlemenKotar]

The note Jessica sang was a sixth in dorian scale. Best note in the verse imho :) (think Eleanor Rigby but with more drugs)

[@calvin645]

Sorry to ask who is Ryan Tedder?

[@malovina]

One republic band

[@comedycrackhead]

Hope jack price took that advice

[@nahswille5463]

How I can send you my record for reviewing Ryan?🫶🇸🇪😃

[@Blueberrystop]

❤