BAND-MAID - PUZZLE X3!! - Album, Live, and Live Acoustic versions!!

[@t-kanazawa855]

hi! Ryan Mear I always enjoy your reactions. I'm Japanese and my English is not good. so I translated the lyrics of "PUZZLE" on Deepl and hope it helps! "Nice to meet you." I could hear the puzzle pieces falling into place. But I'm sure you don't remember. But that's fine with me In the gloomy darkness You gave me a place where light shines through With an innocent smile, you said it's okay to stay the same Even if it's a love that won't come true I don't care what number you are Hey, that's a lie. I can't see you. I don't know you. It's only painful But I want to know. I'm thirsty. I can't resist Just for now. Let it consume you. I know that if I say it out loud, I won't be able to stop And you hugged me. Out there, it's just the two of us My own wish Like a candy ball melting into sweetness I wonder if you'll disappear someday too Leaving behind only a sly glance and a scent but that's fine with me A night alone with me Where and what are you doing? Every time I think about it, I can't sleep I can't be selfish I can't just be a good boy and wait I already know the answer. I can't do it. I can't say it. I know the truth I'm not allowed to grab you I touched her gently. My fingertips were sure I felt your love. Please don't say you're sorry. Let me see your eyes avert I'm falling into a deepening wound that won't heal I'm falling into you again The lighter I don't use Glasses in a row And new clothes Don't cry I'm a shell of you I can't see the end I just want to dream Are you gonna wake up? Don't cry Let me believe I can't see, I can't know I'm in so much pain But I want to know, I crave to know I can't resist Just for now Let it consume you. I know that if I say it out loud, I won't be able to stop And you hugged me. Out there, it's just the two of us My own wish A puzzle that's falling apart Memories that can't be filled I close my eyes again I'm falling into you again

[@t-kanazawa855]

By the way, the lyrics were written by MIKU!

[@jamesredman1263]

Thank you

[@334zolo]

Great! thanks

[@t-kanazawa855]

Miku's lyrics are really great. As a native speaker of Japanese, I can understand why her lyrics are so great. I feel that she is underrated in the band. But I'm pretty sure she's the fifth poet genius!

[@neilwoodley530]

Yes, Yes, Yes..Her lyrics are extraordinary. And beautiful. A truly wonderful song writer.

[@70soperator16]

These young ladies choke me up all the time.....I'm 66....so I have a grandpas view of them.....I see the dedication and sacrifice.....I see the childhood preempted by hours of practice......I see the ridicule of their peers as children often do.....although I dont know them at all.....my tears are those of a proud grandpa at their accomplishments.....sorry.....kinda mushy......but honest and true

[@joki5346]

Same age, same feelings.

[@neilwoodley530]

Just watching this again and mystic Ryan predicts the future....Incubus... Spooky. 😊😊😊

[@billmcleangunsmith]

When a language that you do not understand moves you to tears, the music is as good as it can be.

[@darkchiron]

Saiki is very good at conveying emotions in her singing and facial expressions. She's a performer extraordinaire and the band's musical compositions help out a ton.

[@jan-ovepedersen5764]

Page does that to me as well, it's something in Saiki's voice that hits me hard all the time. These songs bring me huge emotions and I can't explain why.

[@bartyslattfast]

@@jan-ovepedersen5764 Saiki seems to sing from her heart. She always gets me.

[@bartyslattfast]

@@jan-ovepedersen5764 have you seen Page live? it is amazing.

[@gaborberkes468]

Well...and never forget the genius who imagine and composed all this songs/Kanami Tono/I think her soul in a different level...But of course all members genius in they part and what makes they really a unique...the contact between all members...This song my all time favorite from the first akord when I heard first time...I just had same reaction...tears rolling on my face.I was sad happy every emotions in one time...Should everybody hear this song...

[@sacluvsBM]

Fun fact: in Japan saying "just bring it" is considered quite rude in polite society. It is tantamount to saying go to hell here in the west. There is a lot of punk in this "impossibly hard rocking band". Sacramento loves Band-Maid.

[@sacluvsBM]

@@otobokegaijin6218 and l did not mean that. I was expressing an equivalent in impact comparison with an English phrase. I certainly did not mean to imply it translated as go to hell. Only that in certain context it would be considered a very rude statement. Thanks for letting me clear that up.

[@ericifune5543]

Saiki's is the voice of a pained soul. Kanami is the voice of the angel soothing that soul.

[@patrickmagrady3563]

Beautifully said.

[@nates8548]

Mincho has the voice of an Angel

[@RyanMear]

Yes!

[@nates8548]

@@RyanMear If you get a chance, listen to the acoustic Puzzle again and let it play through to acoustic Anemone. You won't be sorry. I promise. 🙂

[@geraldgetskow3420]

Having seen a couple of her videos before she joined Band-Maid and before they were pulled down, I can wholeheartedly agree.

[@madsstavang]

Puzzle is a masterpiece and Kanami is a creative genius. Yeah, wow is the only appropriate word for it.

[@wolfscoat6207]

Whenever I hear it I'm just short before crying. I have not heard much songs where the singer did lay her/his heart completely into the song. Puzzle is Saikis song, the acoustic version definitely. She looks beautiful in her sadness. Also a masterpice of arrangement from ( I guess ) Kanami. This girls did have already at that time the quality of a Superband. Sad that Rock is still no more that important to the most music fans. To much lalala music on the market, with only one reason...to make money for the Labels.

[@mkoose]

Word

[@jamesredman1263]

I believe the potential fans are out there. They just need to learn about the real rock that is also out there. Also I'm seeing quite a few rap people expanding their listening and beginning to appreciate it. Band-Maid's rapid increase in views and music sales shows discovery by more people. I find that very encouraging.

[@wolfscoat6207]

@@jamesredman1263 Let's hope you are right, it's true there are some signs.

[@bryanhallman8183]

The acoustic version of Smile is even more emotional.

[@jon87583]

Agree - Saiki really puts the right emotion into each performance. And the acoustic "Puzzle" here (along with Anemone in that concert) are prime examples.

[@Mentolado17]

Kanami's backing vocals in the acoustic version give me goosebumps, just beautiful

[@darkchiron]

Kanami was a singer/songwriter before joining Band-Maid, so the acoustic version of Puzzle is really back to her roots. Her backing vocals on it are just so gentle and beautiful. She is a glorious woman.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

You couldn't have said that better.👍

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Soz Ryan i forgot to mention you're also the best thing to happen to YT for a long time. Thx for the triple reaction.👍

[@RyanMear]

Wow, man, thanks👍

[@curtisrrobles7885]

I completely agree with this

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@curtisrrobles7885 Wow Truthometer reads 100%.

[@curtisrrobles7885]

@@GaryHolloway-810 😲

[@tomaztruck6]

Same

[@tomaztruck6]

Second verse, Saiki is acting it out on her face. She is sooo underrated, at least by me when I first started listening to them. Her hands are fascinating to watch as well, maybe from her modeling days? Then she collapses on herself at the end, just brutally beautiful.

[@Gabor...hachi.juu_ichi]

Totally agree, I actually thought this brilliant album was Saiki's coming of age and Miku's lyrics helped her express herself....she really is phenomenal, wish she got as much recognition as the instrumental talents but hey, they won't care, they all just stay true to themselves and between themselves they truly care about each other.

[@busser649]

When you think you're ready for the unexpected, but the unexpected isn't what you expected, that's BAND-MAID!

[@mattdhorstman]

My reaction to your reaction :) 1:50 - Incubus is awesome... and you're right... I do get vibes. 3:30 - Why are your headphones backwards? Kanami = Right, Miku = Left... or am I the wrong one? 4:35 - It may be impossible to over-sell this song... 6:45 - Wait until he hears the live vocals. 11:45 - There it is... ahhhhhhhh 14:10 - Witness pure ROCK GODDESS mode... 18:10 - That first time you hear Kanami 23:08 - As if she wasn't good enough at everything else already, she's got a beautiful voice 23:35 - This bridge, where they replace the guitar solo with the vocal harmony, brings me to tears sometimes 24:45 - Totally agree, the full song expresses the anger, the acoustic version expresses the pain One of the best songs from one of the best bands in the world, reacted to by one of the best reactors on YT right now. What else is there to say.

[@BMfansince2020]

I noticed it too that for videos, Miku is on the wrong side. I just pretend I am Akane listening to the song. I think same with Take me higher reaction.

[@mahfoeth]

Nice minute report :)) 🤘🤘

[@RyanMear]

I didn't switch my headphones around!

[@RyanMear]

Hey, Matt, I really appreciate this, thanks!

[@hawkmoon4107]

This is the beauty you can only find in the best lyrics. "Puzzle" can be sing with anger in the original version and with sadness in the acoustic one and have a totaly different meaning for the listener. The same line will be sarcasm, or will be despair according to the way the band deliver it.

[@arsnlin]

Let this be here (the lyrics):- When you said “Nice to meet you.”, It’s like hearing a puzzle piece fell into place. Although I certainly don’t remember but that’s fine with me. You’ve given my light a place, Amidst the melancholic darkness. Don’t ever lose that innocent smile, Even if my love will render futile. I don’t mind how you prioritize me. Hey…those are just lies. I can’t see nor know, All I feel is pain. But I long for the truth, So I can’t just resist it. Just for the meantime, Go and get encroached. There’s no stopping once I voice out Knowing that, you embraced her. It won’t hurt for you two to go outside. That’s only my wish. Like sweetly melting candy, Someday you’ll disappear, too. Your sneaky stare and scent will only remain. but that’s fine with me. On this lonesome night, I wonder where are you and what’re you doing? The harder I think about it, the more I can’t sleep. I can’t say that’s selfish, Since such a good girl is waiting for you. The answer should obvious by now. I can’t do it or even say it, Actually I know That holding isn’t permitted. But you softly touched me With your finger, no doubt about it. I felt love along with it, So don’t do things like apologize. Do enchant me and I will avert my eyes. I’m addicted to this incurable wound as it deepens more. I’m still falling for you. Useless lighters, The lined up glasses, The new clothes, Don’t cry, those are your remnants. I can’t see the end to it, All I want is to dream of you. Will I ever wake up? Don’t cry, let me believe in them. I can’t see nor know, All I feel is pain. But I long for the truth, So I can’t just resist it. Just for the meantime, Go and get encroached. There’s no stopping once I voice out Knowing that, you embraced her. It won’t hurt for you two to go outside. That’s only my wish. The puzzle is crumbling, It’s like the memories won’t go away. My eyes are still closed. I’m still falling for you.

[@geraldgetskow3420]

Miku is an absolute treasure and genius when it comes to her writing

[@remmy2000]

Wow!! My mind is puzzled😲

[@jamesredman1263]

Thank you

[@palominokid3002]

I've not heard such a brilliant composer + lyricist pairing since the days of Lennon & McCartney, or Elton John and Bernie Taupin. Tono & Kobato can rightfully take their place along side the legends of modern songwriting, we are in the presence of genius with these two !

[@MSIContent]

WTF! I just cried again when I hit the last line!!! Miku really has an old soul.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

BAND-MAID are the best thing to happen since a alien race of concert venues visited Earth & decided to settle here :)

[@RyanMear]

Man....I had it backwards this WHOLE TIME!

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@RyanMear LOL. Don't worry Ryan it's "Reverse day" on Aug 17th :)

[@TomClark-Futoura]

I'm sure glad the aliens left behind nine little seeds that grew up to be four lads from Liverpool and eventually... a band of incredible Maids. 👽

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@TomClark-Futoura Very true Tom. I'm sure glad the Maids improved on the fab 4's haircuts tho :)

[@curtisrrobles7885]

@@GaryHolloway-810 👽👽👽👽👽🛸

[@threemonkeysk]

13:49 Crazy amount of lyrics, yeah true, but Live, Saiki has so nailed it, Puzzle done 3 ways Album - awesome. Live - died and gone to heaven. Acoustic - I can hear Angels!

[@jan-ovepedersen5764]

Saiki is one of the best singers in hard rock ever.

[@geraldgetskow3420]

The album/ live versions of this song are the angry side of the story. The acoustic version is the sad side of the story. An interesting dichotomy given that the lyrics don't change for either.

[@tmirinazg5387]

Japanese Band-Maid fan here! I love to watch the reaction of overseas people cuz their reaction always give me new perspective and just fun to watch. (you know we Japanese tend not to express our emotion openly compering to people in other countries...) I'm not so good at English really but very impressed by your reaction, your smile and eyes. Happy to see how you love their performance and works. Even in Japan, Band-Maid haven't got enough appreciation, IMAO, so glad that Band-Maid is getting praise on KZbin from all over the world, especially musical-experienced people like you. Thank you, Ryan-san and plz take care of yourself! ✌️

[@RyanMear]

Arigato👍

[@mmm152]

100パーセント　同意　伝えてくれてありがとう　フロムジャパン I agree 100 percent Thank you for telling me From Japan.

[@jon87583]

Welcome! As a non-Japanese fan of Band-Maid (and a lot of other J-Rock artists) it is always great to get a Japanese fan's perspective. So, please feel welcome among the overseas fans! I met some fans who traveled to USA from Japan just to support Band-Maid - it showed me how music unifies people. Hope to see you at a Band-Maid show in Japan some day! 🤘🤘

[@TreadheadA1]

Just when you think you couldn't love Kanami more, she drops her angelic vocals upon your head! The acoustic version is a wall of emotion and is a beacon to the onion cutting ninjas. Puzzle is an awesome song in all versions but, acoustic tops it for me. Love your reactions! There is no doubt about how genuine they are and your comments help those of us who have no musical experience. Looking forward to more!

[@ForestOfSleep]

Kanami taking no breaks on this song. It's like she put every single riff she could into this song. If you want to check out some songs where Miku does lead vocals try to find live versions of Rock in Me and, Time.

[@Medley3000]

Puzzle is the only song where Akane never smiles and we all know she likes to smile and laugh. 😁 She is obviously genuinely touched by the song every time. 🥺

[@bach-kw8vx]

ARIGATO for the good good choice!! In my opinion, this song of the acoustic version is the MASTERPIECE! SAIKI's voice and KANAMI's guitar are so beautiful. And the japanese lyrics by MIKU is so beautiful, and so unique.

[@Slippy6582]

I knew this is gonna blow you away... Especially with the acoustic version right after the live version, it´s just mindblowing how Kanami creates music. I like to think that the acoustic version is the music she wrote the "naked" song and afterwards she added all the other instruments, lyrics (from MIKU) etc. It´s a rainbow of music, so many different colors, moods, riffs, feelings and paces, i LOVE this song so much, it´s beautiful. I adore Kanami, because for me she is an songwriter that stands out big time. She is so open-minded and doesn´t give her writing any restrictions, a lot of ppl trying to stay "true" to themselves or their genre and that sets limits... Kanami is just feeling it and goes to wherever she wants! Thanks for your reaction, not so much about technical stuff this time, just a pure reaction and i really appreciate it, this song needs your attention and emotion :) Greetings from Germany

[@xagorvangard]

I stayed up to watch this tripleheader. Puzzle is a masterpiece. All three versions are great. The acoustic version is my favorite ballad from them to date. Saiki's vocals and Kanami's harmonies just projects so much emotion. Absolutely beautiful. Thanks for the reaction Ryan. 👍

[@GaryHolloway-810]

I got my internet back 10 mins before this dropped. How lucky is that :)

[@curtisrrobles7885]

💯% true 🤙🏽

[@curtisrrobles7885]

@@GaryHolloway-810 💯% lucky 🍀

[@xagorvangard]

@@GaryHolloway-810 Very lucky indeed. You really need to do something about your internet

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@xagorvangard I know. Hey on Andrew Rooney drums "Secret My Lips", i noticed your name in the comments when he scrolled thru them. Silent shout out :)

[@erniezetroc]

Kanami's left hand is pretty strong. I love how she frets the low E on the acoustic with her thumb kinda like Hendrix. On Unseen World, I read she used 11's and 13's on some songs on Eb. I max out 10's on Eb, anything higher my fingers will fall off lol.

[@SPERanger]

Your last comments are spot on with the lyrics. Same lyrics, but completely different moods with regular vs acoustic. Sarcastic spiteful vs just depressing despair :(

[@falagar4567]

This song gets me every time. Doesn't matter how many times I listen to it or which version. And it's just one of many.

[@snowdog5895]

Band Maid is 5 puzzle pieces that fit perfectly together to create beautiful musical landscapes! Puzzle has been my #1 Band Maid song since I first heard it. 🎶🎸🥁🎸🎶🔥🙂

[@Davey-Boyd]

Lol! I'm re-watching this 17- April 2024 and hear you talking about Incubus and 'Mikey-Chan'. The day that "Bestie" was released!

[@etoineschrdlu9382]

The "Just Bring It" album art is perfect Band-Maid. Sweet young ladies sharing an intimate moment, but then the full moon and the tablecloth form a death's head skull. The inconguent "Gap" of metal and maids. It's no wonder they toured that year using it as their logo. I love all their music, but the electric version of "Puzzle" is the song that makes want to turn the volume to eleven. The acoustic version is the version that makes me reach the box of tissues. Band-Maid is unique.

[@joshi_new_wave]

I can tell you from experience, Puzzle is a great driving song too. One where you’ll for sure be playing drums on the wheel. Great reaction, man!

[@realdocloco]

One of the band member mentioned in an interview that two B-M members have perfect pitch - Kanami is one (Misa could be the other one). This could somewhat explain why her vocal harmonies are so perfect here.

[@COTTERO]

Yeap, I've always felt that Miku usually uses some sort of harmonizer for the backing vocals, and I think even Kanami does it sometimes... not a problem for me.😉

[@stups9975]

Puzzle is one song where I can’t decide which version I like better. I love all of them. And when that song comes up on my playlist .. better believe I crank it up 🤟🏻

[@KMASCII]

Yeah, the first time I heard Puzzle live I was thinking this kid (Saiki) was born with a marathon runner's lung capacity. But Puzzle has an epic feel from them all though.

[@TomClark-Futoura]

And as with me, Ryan, we have similar musical sensibilities with Kanami. I also played guitar for a few decades in rock bands and, while not overall as good as Kanami, I felt and played a certain style like her. That's one reason why I locked onto Band-Maid hard after only a few seconds of first hearing Thrill in 2014.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

I did like the way you handled that guy a while back when you told him you came from generations of musicians & playing in bands so you knew what you were talking about. Tom 1 v 0 guy :)

[@curtisrrobles7885]

❤❤❤

[@TomClark-Futoura]

@@GaryHolloway-810 Thx, Gary! But I hope my comments to Ryan don't seem like I was trying to one-up him in any way. I was sharing my story in a sea of stories why Ryan, me, you, fans and Maidiacs have found a special kind of attraction to Kanami and the Maid's type of music and playing style. I was really reacting to what Ryan tries to explain at 12:15. But I'm still ahead by one point. 🤣

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@TomClark-Futoura Lol. Tom you never try to get one up on anyone unless they deserve it. But always remember, if you're a point ahead never give it it back.😈

[@TomClark-Futoura]

@@GaryHolloway-810 The only thing I've given back at times is my dignity. 😔

[@AntonioMellor]

The song has lyrics that really match the acoustic version.

[@markbaker8255]

Saiki's passion in the acoustic version is gut wrenching, you can feel her pain and loneliness 💔 brings tears to this old rocker....absolutely love this band, they are going to conquer the world.

[@atldawg8642]

This right here is why I love this band. Take a song that conveys one set of emotions then flip it and take you somewhere else. Saiki showing her abilities to make you feel the song.

[@baddhorsie8318]

Miku's lyrics, Saiki's emotional vocals as if she is in the moment and Kanami's beautiful voice and guitar tying it all together .... Puzzle/ Anemone is perfection

[@roberttoomey6157]

The Maids are legitimately the best band in the world 🌎.

[@nem447]

They are both good in their own unique way, they kicked butt with the full band live, but the slowed down acoustic makes it a different song.

[@bandsublime9462]

You are absolutely right. They are a great guitar duo. Miku is awsome and her play fits their music perfectly to let Misa and Akane contribute and Saiki to shine. Mincho's modesty, very unusual for a lead guitarist/composer, is what makes this band so special. Thanks for the awesome reactions which bring me new insights. Greeting from Japan!

[@stickerred]

Band-Maid potential is unlimited. They're gems with different colors. Of course I love Kanami, her solos, performance and music let me believe in her mind very lonely. Talent and artists are always introverts.

[@GeographRick]

I just saw the most recent live video from Tokyo that is on their youtube site. Did you notice that at the beginning of the solo, in this latest live video, Miku took over Kanami's beginning riff into the solo? I noticed when I saw them live that Miku is taking over a lot over parts, which enables Kanami to be even better. I really admire how far Miku has progressed. There some others I I noticed in concert that Miku is doing MUCH MORE than what she used to do. Because of how much of herself she has poured into the 'Band Maid project'. Miku determined to succeed. I love her for that.

[@Bekka_Noyb]

Live version is one of my top 10 Band Maid songs! ♥

[@kaazan1]

The attack of Puzzle in concert is like a zunami that comes at you, Misa and Akane kill you, you feel them inside your body. Few band-Maid songs start out as powerful.

[@RaffaeleRussorr]

Hi Ryan, Kanami Show, in the live version i thought "hey someone go on stage and stop kanami" how genius is this girl.... riffs on different riffs, i love the part when with the mini solo she accompanies and introduces the second verse introducing the timing change with Akane, same thing with the perfect solo work with Akane, what a band this is!!! and the acoustic version...... another Kanami show and what a voice. i love all this

[@Big_Al_63]

Dude, I am 59, musically my favorite band of all time.......The Beatles. I was a teen in the 70s so I grew up with Van Halen, Aerosmith, Boston, ELO, Rush and AC/DC. I just discovered Band-Maid last month. I am burning through all of their videos here like a hot knife through butter. They are now my favorite contemporary band. Hands down!

[@RyanMear]

I have heard this so many times, it's amazing every time!

[@RyanMear]

You are in for a great ride

[@melocitysolo9574]

The live video of "Puzzle" at Studio Coast is in the zone. All the band members are completely immersed in the world of this song. It's a perfect representation of the world of Miku's lyrics, namely the emptiness and anger that she feels. It gives me goosebumps no matter how many times I watch it. My favorite scenes : 10:42 Back view of Miku earnestly trying to set the tempo for the backing. 14:32 Akane's emotional drumming and her facial expression express the world of this song.

[@K.H.D710]

Triple Puzzle😍 What a treat! Ty, Mr. Mear👍👏👏👏👍😊

[@thunderchild7137]

Puzzle (both versions or at least one) should be required at every live performance. The anger and betrayal felt in the electric version. The self blame and desperation of the acoustic version. Not many can go to these extremes with the same song like that. Let alone make each one a masterpiece. This was the first time I truly saw their musical depth. Not just a great rock band, a band for the ages.

[@garylai363]

Hi Ryan, I’m fairly new to the Band-Maid pigeon hole but I’ve seen a lot of reactions now and I enjoy yours. You don’t need to feel bad about saying your musical tastes align with Kanami’s, and how you see things the way she does. You’re both musicians, and she has said that she wants to make the music she likes, and you can tell it aligns with your tastes. She’s a music geek and so are you, which is really cool to see from the perspective of a non musician like myself. Band-Maid is wonderful because they can write music that a surface level appreciator like myself can enjoy with their riffs, hooks, catchy choruses, energy, fun performances, etc, but also for trained musicians like yourself who can appreciate the finer details as well, like the songwriting, layering of instruments, transitions, creativity, etc.

[@RyanMear]

Thank you

[@craigfenson]

13:56-14:16 -- 20 seconds of underappreciated but sonically fitting rhythm guitar work by the little pigeon. [edit: her skill got recognized at 15:39]

[@dexterplant778]

What can you say? Band Maid once again produced a master's class in layering instruments with vocals from another dimension.

[@Hethern]

Without a doubt my favorite Band Maid song, the solo gives me chills every time I hear it!!

[@BM4-Life]

Was about to go to sleep then I seen this posted 25 minutes I gotta watch this. 😊 _(Sleeping is overrated)_ 18:08 _(and yea _*_Kanami_*_ sings what a beautiful voice)_

[@peterl9119]

Among all the Band-Maid reaction videos I've watched. (Trust me, I've watched them all) This reaction is by far my favourite. I was hit with so much emotion by the end of this video, not only because of Saiki and Kanami but also because of you. I appreciate so much your professional expertise in music and to see that Band-Maid had also made an impact on you too. That really means a lot to me. Thank you for sharing your knowledge in music and I'll look forward to your next video. Just subscribed and I will be checking out your music next.

[@RyanMear]

Thank you very much

[@334zolo]

i totaly agree with everything you just said =)

[@lonniekramlich6241]

Aaaaaaah, puzzle........one version rocks out, the other......brings you tears😎

[@JuanSan66]

Fantastic job sir, at the height of the masterpiece that this band of brave tiny smart and talented women has built. Puzzle is an overwhelming composition where, at all times, the listener is literally struck by a musical wave. Layers and more layers, like tides, of amazing music. Well, that was not enough for their creators, deciding to bring the monster to life in the live performance. In my life I have seen nothing like that. Puzzle acoustic is like taming that dragon only based on beauty and subtlety. This is the best rock band of this century and these girls can achieve anything they set their minds to, World Domination included. Thank you very much for this time, it has been excellent.

[@ichichu]

This will always be my favorite Band-Maid song!

[@joeking6763]

I always get a kick out of this album cover! Right up BAND MAIDS alley with the different way of looking at the cover and the look and sound of the band. MIKU says about KANAMI " If she holds the guitar she becomes aggressive." KANAMI says "I am told by many people that they thought I change on stage" Pete Townsend talks about being in the zone while playing on stage and not paying attention to anything else going on. This is why he kicked the police officer off the stage while he was playing. Police officer wanted him to know that there was a fire. The lead in music box sound is to let the audience know that they should be quiet. It is actually much longer on the video - thanks for cutting it down. I think - based on previous interviews and comments by KANAMI - that this is what the songs start as. Piano or acoustic guitar and then MISA and AKANE add their parts in and build on it from something like this. KANAMI states "When I compose, I don’t think much about the effects. I use it to enhance the songs I've already written live." I agree - The tone of the music dictates the intent of the lyrics. Example: Puzzle as an acoustic song is sad and depressed view - Puzzle as hard rock electric is mad and somewhat vengeful in attitude. Same song same lyrics two different viewpoints from the same person!

[@teuchterloon9130]

"Wow" is right. The acoustic is by far my favourite version of this song. It's hauntingly beautiful. You need to get watching a full concert though, man. I'm scared you'll have everything spoiled for you

[@shamalamadingdong5718]

I had a lot to say while you were watching the other two versions but I completely forgot what it was when you watched the acoustic version. The first time I watched it I stopped breathing when Kanami started singing. The whole performance is just breathtaking and beautiful. I just want to say that when I watch a lot of reactors I just kind of watch and it has little effect on me and they kind of sterilize it with overanalysis. I kind of had the same reaction I had the first time while watching you. My eyes started leaking because you just kind of sat back and absorbed it. That was a real reaction. Sometimes there isn't a whole lot that can be said. Respect ✊

[@RyanMear]

Sometimes I know when to shut the fuck up😉 Thanks

[@davidtollefson8411]

The accoustic version of Puzzle is completely breathtaking.

[@dennisueland8146]

...unless Mincho is singing backup as well. Not on this version, but.... I love her harmonies even more on the acoustic version of Anemone that follows this in that concert.

[@jamesredman1263]

Brilliant to do all three of these versions. Eyes are moist for the acoustic every time. Saiki is a true soulful artist, as is Kanami. An acoustic version of Anemone followed this. Also awesome of course. And: Kanami's exquisite sounding acoustic on Puzzle here is a K. Yairi SJY13H Steve Hicks Custom Electro-Acoustic. K. Yairi is Kazuo Yairi, who I believe was associated with Alvarez at one time. Gorgeous sounding guitar, phenomenal artist playing it, heartrending vocals... this gets to me every time.

[@RyanMear]

On a previous video, I noticed she was playing an Alvarez Yairi and went all stupid about it. I worked in a music store for a bit and they had them. Best sounding acoustic guitar I've ever played. So Yairi continued on without Alvarez?? Interesting

[@DeanF_MIDI]

Ryan! Great reaction. You didn't get into the lyrics much on this... but they are very intriguing. It's a song about a woman who is in love with a married man who has come to realize she will never be more than his mistress and that he will never leave his wife.

[@randymcmillen647]

Now I don't have to rewind "Puzzle" three times to hear it three times. Now I can rewind it once, and hear it six times! Thank you and God bless you, po!

[@RA57727]

This was a fantastic idea for a reaction video. Examining the CD recording followed by the two videos. But truthfully after the acoustic version you just need a little time - wow. I wish Band-Maid would release some their acoustic recordings on a CD. Thanks again

[@fernando-vd2cn]

Puzzle is my favourite so far... the heavy version, but the accustic is nice too.

[@markmathewssgbcpenaltyboxs6389]

Love this song! Love the acoustic because it really shows how beautiful Saiki's voice is and get to hear Kanamincho's soft, beautiful voice as well. Thank you for reacting to these videos.

[@mr.bluebird6544]

This may be my #1 Band Maid song, especially the live version. It's the little things, Miku bobbing to the rhythm, Kanami dancing with her guitar and that look on Akane's face as the tempo of the song builds. Perfect performance of a beautiful and complex song.

[@jannashesgbcnemophilafan4317]

Love this song. Kanamis constant riffs, and awesome solo. This song live, really shows the whole Maid feel. Not just the outfits. The chandeliers, light stands, video boards all add to the theme. Very emotional, beautiful song. Kanami and Raikei awesome together. Kanamis tones are awesome.

[@AngelLWJ]

My favorite bandmaid songs👍👌

[@denissmith9772]

These women move me to tears every time!

[@davidtsang4949]

My absolutely favorite song of theirs! It's a wonderfully busy song. Kanami is just nonstop in this song and the live version sounds even better!

[@cembor]

I just want to tell you how much JOY I got from watching you hearing Puzzle for the first time. I legit was grinning so hard and wiping tears. Why? Because I knew just how much you would love this song based on your other reactions. And yeah, the feel of the lyrics changes along with the feel of the music in this song. Saikis delivery helps with that feel as well. Great reaction, loved it. So happy that you finally got to this point. :)

[@philcalvino884]

Excellent idea to go through all three - think you are the first to do it, and it was great to get your take on all of them.

[@SilentChaos15]

This is one of their best songs still for me. Heavy, catchy, progressive, dynamic. All the versions are awesome. Also right there with this song is Matchless Gum which was a non album track that came on the YOLO single.

[@roberttoomey6157]

SiKi is my favorite vocalist in the 🌎. Over the the last couple years of listening to her beautiful vocals she has won me over to her .

[@domker]

It's amazing how the same song "in three different flavors" can evoke so many emotions. Thank you for reacting.

[@paullow3377]

I think in one of their interviews, Kanami mentioned that she actually compose songs in a slower tempo and then speeds them up to achieve the hard rock sound. It's no surprise that many of her tunes can be played slow. However, it's not like we get to hear her original compositions often so it's still a big treat for us fans whenever they play the acoustic versions.

[@rambe_bk2018]

Wow incubus n 311..bringing back memories of junior n high school..especially brandon boyd love his vocals... Drive is my fave song from incubus...there's not much different the studio n live version but acc version its like totally different song... Mincho is the best n Saiki's vocal just WOW

[@bradmenpes809]

Ryan, your T-shirt!! For the win!! Really great reactions to a truly great song. It always amazes me that different versions of Band-Maid songs - studio, live, acoustic - produce three different songs. So complex, yet also so accessible, with an emotional impact so wide and deep it's like going down to the ocean and looking out to the horizon. There is real beauty in Band-Maid's songs and, for me, this is nowhere more evident than in their acoustic performances. This must be the music angels listen to in heaven.

[@ernestrimbeck7630]

I never would have put Incubus and Band Maid together totally different styles They both have a song called Warning so I say good call

[@fedogma8407]

If a tear doesn't come to your eyes during the acoustic "Puzzle" then you are a person with no emotions. All three versions are masterpieces.

[@philproffitt8363]

You gotta be glassy-eyed to pass the Turing Test :-)

[@jamesredman1263]

Every. Time.

[@334zolo]

What a treat to get this a sundaymorning! Im just gonna say that i loved the reaction, before ive even seen it Haha! Again, love ur reactions!

[@airlinesecret6725]

This is why Maidiacs are legally obliged not to recommend 'Puzzle' as a reactors first listen to BAND-MAID, as it can be to much and to dangerous emotionally !

[@curtisrrobles7885]

Very true 🤙🏼

[@savitrisdisciple]

Thank you Ryan for this reaction, love how you pointed out the difference in the vocal nuance between the electric and the acoustic. Saiki's delivery is emotionally brilliant in both. What poignant lyrics by Miku. What great composition by Kanami. What beautiful harmonies by Miku, and Kanami. The engine room drive of MISA and Akane. Puzzle is just one more Band-Maid song that I love. And to watch someone else enjoy the music I love is a great gift, so thank you once more

[@_DriveTime]

Great video. I can't really express how much I love this song, so I'll just point out some minutiae. The little music box like tune that is playing before the acoustic version is the melody of their song Anemone which they play an acoustic version of right after Puzzle. So for the people who know the Band-Maid catalog, it was both foreshadowing and a little bit of a fake out because they played Puzzle first.

[@RyanMear]

Oh, thanks, I haven't listened to Anemone yet, so I didn't get that.

[@lurkmerchant]

Wow. I can't ask for better reaction from anyone else on this song. I got a bit emotional from the way you really immersed yourself into this song and looks like you really felt the song. Thank you Ryan.

[@fastskipper777]

As I always say, this song is a masterpiece.

[@adilsonfernando1754]

Ryan, Saiki's voice was touched by the angels, Kudos from Brazil.

[@DaElfer]

i remember one reactor wondering why kanami was playing the rift from the chorus during the verse and wondering what she would do during the next chorus. lol