S1: As Muslims, we Have NEVER Faced Intolerance in India - Dr. Sofiya Rangwala ji

The Festival of Bharat - Series 1: As Muslims, we have never faced intolerance in India - Dr. Sofiya Rangwala ji @ The Festival of Bharat. Browse The Festival of Bharat's KZbin channel for more talks by Dr. Sofiya Rangwala ji and other inspiring subject matter experts, scholars, change makers and public figures.
HOW TO SUPPORT US
FoB KZbin Support Link: / @thefestivalofbharat
FoB Patreon Support Link: / festivalofbharat
MORE CONTENT
Browse The Festival of Bharat's KZbin channel for more exciting content, music & talks by other inspiring subject matter experts, artistes, scholars, change makers and public figures.
All of our content is available at no cost, and with no premium subscriptions required. You can help us spread the word as far and wide as possible by sharing our videos, and subscribing to our channel at / thefestivalofbharat
SOCIAL MEDIA
Like us on Facebook @ / festivalbharat
Follow us on Twitter @ / festivalbharat
Join us on Instagram @ / festivalofbharat
SUPPORT US IN SECONDS
www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...

[@anti-ignorance1870]

Dr Sofiya, The Hesitation in your Voice is a subconscious alert that some muslims will send abusive tweets later, Takes a lot of courage to speak the Facts , Welldone Sister.

[@winnethepooh7986]

I thought it was just a stage fear or anxiety. It is normal when you are not used to such a crowd.

[@earthtourist]

Hesitation in voice comes when a person not sure about what she is saying and not because she is thinking about bad tweets...1 fine day you will know the facts

[@khersi.6261]

Well ! HINDUS have been facing severe violent brutal INTOLERANCE FROM MUSLIMS, in THEIR OWN HOMELAND FOR 830 YEARS !!!!!!!!!! DON'T BE SUCH A LYING HYPOCRITE ! MUSLIMS WERE GIVEN PART OF INDIAN LANDS... THAT IN ITSELF WAS EXTREMELY GENEROUS.... GIVEN THE FACT THAT FIRST TIME IN ITS HISTORY INDIA WAS INVADED BY SHAH MOHAMMED GHORI..AT NIGHT !! RAJPUTS NEVER FOUGHT AT NIGHT ? THAT ALONE TELLS A LOT...

[@ameya486]

@QURANa VIRUS To save yourself from Quran a virus, you need to maintain social distance at any cost for lifetime to save yourself

[@sandeepsingh-by4db]

i am sikh and i want to say all the so called minorities of india that if india is intolarant than which country is tolarant and in which country you wants to go?? aamir khan has said lots of thing against india at that time which i think political motivated but still he is in india most of his fans are hindu even after his release of pk movie. can he make a same on other religion?? its ok u dont like particular party which is fine but dont hate the country which has given you recognition in whole world.

[@rangilabetichodhapsipigemb6745]

sandeep singh guru govind SINGh amar rahe🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😍😍😍😍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@SunilThummala]

Well said brother.

[@shankarpal8507]

paji end hi karti✌

[@rohitdwivedi4074]

Paji dhamal kr diya

[@jphande77]

They never go just try to get focus and create chaos through our their life...

[@pavanjoshi9054]

Very well said Dr. Sofiya. Truely appreciate.

[@joegeorge7868]

Thanks Ma'am. Jai Hindh. Jai Barath Matha!. I am a Christian from Kerala. I reject that any Indian Religious group is oppressed by any Political Party. Sure, there are Isolated incidents. But our Indian Democracy is a Light to the world.

[@bharatpathik9036]

Well said sister, 'Tolerance is inherent to India'. Thanks.

[@bharatpathik9036]

@MoooHAMmad Atankvadee , Only bigots and beastly minds are daydreaming 😀😀

[@bharatpathik9036]

@MoooHAMmad Atankvadee , That's unfortunate. As long as Islam is there, evolution of mankind to humanity remains incomplete because they aren't taught to see others as equal.

[@khersi.6261]

@@bharatpathik9036 IDIOT !

[@powerprivilege6790]

Muslims and Catholics of India need to apologize to the rest for the abuses of the past. Instead they are brazenly demanding of special status and treatment! That is what angers the Indians.

[@TauroChuck]

Bolna kya chahteeeee hooooo

[@chitrasharma9932]

right

[@mnjags]

"Tolerance in inherent to India" Well said. It is in our DNA.

[@prashantchaturvedi8146]

so true..I had a friend who is very well 'educated', and is a teacher in one of Delhi's top schools..she was posting stuff about intolerance, Kerala floods, anti-BJP on a regular basis. I commented on few of her posts, questioning the validity of her posts. None of my comments were abusive, or derogatory. She blocked me from everywhere, without ever trying to take time to logically discuss issues. This is the real intolerance, as pointed out by Dr. Sofiya. As per my ex-friend, I am a member of BJP IT cell, since I don't agree with her point of view. Am worried what teachers like her are feeding to the students on a daily basis.

[@tanyamehra1668]

Similar thing happened to me sir my teacher is a communist supporter from what I have understand about her political ideology and she keep on repeating luteyan media speeches and once she even said that she is ashamed to be an indian since bjp came to power as they are spreading intolerance in front of all the students and when I tried to show her the other face she without even fully listening to me told me that I have poisoned my mind with the bjp propaganda and indirectly compared me with hitler.

[@anitha2696]

😂 similar thing happened to me...but one thing ...they ppl don't have senses and patience to do research and listen to other ppl this is the reason they r that way foolish ppl...

[@JohnSmith-vr2rw]

GOD BLESS MODI.

[@junaidnasirkhan]

The basic structure of India is based on tolerance... But those illiterate politicians are root cause of intolerance.

[@indiamerejan4434]

Such a majestic messages. Extremely inspiring truth told in such language. Knocks out BJP and monster in seconds. 👍👍

[@mohnishm26]

u r having courage to tell truth .great woman .

[@purnachandrapatnaik.3477]

All are living here better except Amir Khan.

[@khersi.6261]

ABSOLUTELY CORRECT !

[@khersi.6261]

Well ! HINDUS have been facing severe violent brutal INTOLERANCE FROM MUSLIMS, in THEIR OWN HOMELAND FOR 828 YEARS !!!!!!!!!! DON'T BE SUCH A LYING HYPOCRITE ! MUSLIMS WERE GIVEN PART OF INDIAN LANDS... THAT IN ITSELF WAS EXTREMELY GENEROUS.... GIVEN THE FACT THAT FIRST TIME IN ITS HISTORY INDIA WAS INVADED BY SHAH MOHAMMED GHORI..AT NIGHT !! RAJPUTS NEVER FOUGHT AT NIGHT ? THAT ALONE TELLS A LOT...

[@cssharma2074]

Dear madam, It takes lot of courage to speak the truth. Hats off.

[@prasadpalaparthi3463]

👣 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 👏👏👏👏👏👏 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 अखण्ड भारतम् नमाम्यहम् || वन्देऽहम् भारतम् मातरम् ||

[@chaitu939]

Absolutely well stated, Dr. Sofiya ji. It's an undisputed fact that Indian society is absolutely Tolerant. If at all, the troubling reality is that the tolerance levels of we; Indians have been so extremely exploited on a daily basis that all the malicious anti-national lobby of psuedo-secularists, left-liberals, urban naxals and immoral politicians are just getting away, speaking against the nation.

[@lakhan4771]

Well said I appreciate your thoughts. You are speaking truth. You are a great woman.

[@1800options]

Tolerance is inherent to india, so true.

[@subhashpandey3460]

Dr Sofia, you are bang on. Routine life there is no discrimination whether Hindu or Muslim. I too have Muslim friends and we feel pity for those who talk about their divide.

[@AyushBisht20]

Wish there were more SENSIBLE people like you here.Hats off 🙏🇮🇳

[@Hukum1998]

Every outsider looted BHARAT, destroyed our 80% of our TEMPLES, BHARAT changed its name according to them and even divided it into "n" no. of parts but still, we kept ourself secular this is tolerance.

[@nirmalakhemlani1154]

Thx dr. Sophia for ur oppinion

[@sangeetasuman5828]

Thanks mam you are clear like crystal pure like fire

[@ashreyapathak5526]

Dr. Sophia....she is so regal in her voice.... India needs millions like you. Yes there are some minor incidents but it happens every where.

[@JatinEurope]

Please put full interview.

[@RaviSharma-mf8nx]

Sofiya ji you Indian proud

[@jphande77]

Intolerance is in only social media by few pshycos....

[@shravansatyanarayan1665]

BOSS So true!! Sometimes when I read comments of Hindus abusing Muslims and asking them to leave India or Muslims abusing Hindus, I feel shitty man. How can people hate some person based just on religion. Religion is just a part of an individual’s personality. Religion solely doesn’t define someone. I just hope the cowardly people, no matter what religious background, spewing venom sitting in front of laptops gain some perspective and think of people beyond just their religion. Stop painting entire communities with a single brush and live in peace.

[@sanchigulati2599]

Beautifully said

[@roykurian72]

India is a very tolerant nation and I hope it remains so for generations to come. It is very easy to create a Islamic state like Saudi but the vibrancy of a truly secular state is very different and what makes us special in the world today. I think that is what makes our special and let's ALL strive to keep it that way.

[@subbanarasuarunachalam3451]

You are educated and braodminded

[@amanvirsingh6607]

It should be clear to our young generation that all this divide , intolerance etc is the dirty game of politics and media houses - they are benefited by this false sense of unrest and insecurity in society.

[@rahulray9983]

Ye dissent tho sab bahaana hai asal mein Congress ko Satta mein laana hai

[@snegi5699]

Very true

[@tridentmusic4833]

She is speaking the truth...Jai bharat Jai hind

[@pinakinpatel5796]

Tolerance is inherent in India because of Hindus, add muslims or Christians also known as chrislamist intolerance starts creeping in the society.

[@sudhak5057]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/i4HZhH2GrN6YkMk

[@khersi.6261]

MAY ALL WHO WANT TO RAVAGE INDIA LIKE FOR 830 YEARS ! COME ! FOOLS LIKE HIM WELCOME YOU !!!

[@anandhindu2804]

thank you very much madam for such honest remarks about Hindus & Indians!!!

[@gauthamkumar1512]

Great

[@abhikhatri786]

Well said and true. Great job

[@shanme3659]

wow..hats of to man and ur partner......great of you

[@beyondinfinite275]

This is the truth about our India.

[@shanme3659]

wow hats of to you mam...

[@sujitbaruah4536]

Dr. Sofiya you are right indeed

[@canaufal]

Dr Sofiya..there is no religious intolerance India..I agree with you. We are much better than other countries around us. So proud to be an Indian. However, there is gender based intolerance, caste based (upper and lower) intolerance, intolerance towards poor etc are there.. Take an example of Rohith Vemula, Nirbhaya etc. So just because you are so well educated and well settled just don't ignore the fact how the people are suffering due to corrupted political agenda of almost all the parties

[@viswateja8712]

Super Maam

[@pruthweeshasalian3688]

Great video, great background music at the outro. Would be great if you mentioned the link of the sample!

[@pareshmehta4670]

True,agree 👍

[@akshayverma6687]

Now, this is truth

[@sudhak5057]

Who dislikes it when this lady says that tolerance is inherent to India?

[@elora179]

No, but us Hindus have. We elected a party that was intolerant to their own people.

[@avoirlafoi2580]

Best point.. there is intolerance if you switch off TV and stop reading newspaper....

[@kennethcarter4516]

Very well said Dr. Sofiya! Common people at grassroot level has not come across intolerance and very surprising that celebraty like Amir Khan .. etc has experienced intolerance in India.... I pity such idiots..

[@rajnandinivishwas8789]

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@prabhu4950]

👏👏👍👍👌👌🙏🙏

[@thakurdeepakaddy6318]

Yes mam you said write

[@nvmanjunathvagarur3968]

Real sister

[@vaibhav2k13]

Even liberal European nations have been putting bans on islamic religous practices like hijab while India has no such bans.

[@SD-bt4jj]

Desh first

[@avengers3273]

If there is news about religion clashes in india... national media will become poor

[@shivamgarg5655]

Indian muslims need to speak out all this. Pakistan has made itself your guardian, please speak at national and international level that 20 crores is not a minority.

[@krishnamsdhoni]

Tolerance is the very thing that caused human beings to suffer in india, peiple were too loose. Spreading hatred around ain't going to help anyone improve neither is spreading love

[@rakshityadav7527]

Why to live in such a intolerant religion in which, u give a suggestion with lots of fumbleness and hesitation due to fear of fatwa bcz of any misconceptualised word ! Great But yeah I respects your personal thoughts Sofiya mam !

[@ayyappanmba9545]

Intolerance is only in the minds of some traitors living in India and NOT in the minds of anyone else.

[@khersi.6261]

SHE KNOWS THE TRUTHS BUT NOT BRAVE TO SAY IT !!

[@israrahmed3836]

It's all about poor people weather they are hindu or Muslim she is a doctor that's why she didn't face discrimination society treats people with respect to their status and if a person is poor and get into trouble with someone powerfull The they try to harm them with their influence if they failed or not that much powerful then they use religion with a fake allegation. It's not in India but all over the developing world. I think intolerance problem can be solved by education and a strong justice system with a strong neutral investigation system.

[@parth2220]

Absolutely right, but there's is one thing which I would also love to add here, Hindus mostly love muslims and some of those who doesn't are confused, and the lurking reason is Pakistan, they always infiltrate in our country and tries to tarnish the unity through bomb blast and other unethical practices. When all these things happens some Hindus starts to think all muslims are like this even our own Indian muslims, as a consequence to this they start to hate them. I hope you understood😉 Lots of love from a Hindu brother/son.

[@lookoi9363]

When people travel out of their countries,they realise

[@hansmaheshwari5141]

But as hindus or bahujans we always did face discrimination, how ironic for India's hindus.

[@baisjs151]

Stop referring to yourself as bahujan and bring a change

[@jarnailsinghkhalsa]

Intolerance is in daily actions which Indians unconsciously perform.for e.g.the comments below : observe the bias in them.

[@paiaullasantosh6038]

So are sharukh and amir not Muslims???

[@alohamaloha2470]

Paiaulla Santosh Amir is a pseudo Jihadi. There are pics of him with some crazy Maulana and he also contributes to the Lefty Propaganda website, Wire.

[@Tragic.Kingdom]

Tolerance is inherent to India because of dharmic religious groups

[@priethwinramakrishnan5157]

Once Tamilan is rulled the planet.... still Tamil Rulled.. the world...

[@girish5856]

Hope vib-ra-tor girl of bollywood and her other friends listen to this madam and get some ENLIGHTENMENT.

[@rana0604]

If someone wants to feel intolerance, go to Islamic countries where Sharia laws are there in place partially & fully. Read Islamic scripture, life & deeds of Mohammad with visualization of it to have a smell & real face of intolerance how it really looks like.

[@krishnamsdhoni]

A social person can never bring actual balance because the very idea of society is material oriented. It is prone to conditioning from reality. So no matter whatever decisions you take out of it, its bound to be error. Intolerance and tolerance are both just interchangeable codes and all virtues are far from reality when the idea of virtue itself is dependant on existantial knowledge. So yet again, I disagree with everything india is doing. Don't assume intolerance is correct. Its only relatively appearing to be so. All forms of moral codes are just a path way to human suffering. It has no existantial relevence because that one requires jnana. Which is perceptional knowledge. So whatever you follow, its just going to bring suffering internally or externally, non growth and imbalance. You will suffer to reach this morality and will suffer even more keep this morality while the reality situation as well as existence is in constant change and is dis aligned with human beings. Only a detached jnani knows the correct path

[@artisharma359]

As a prime minister has won prizes for doing revolutionary steps for India🇮🇳 but no charcha on any TV📺 channel. Contrary pappu goes to other country &abuses PM. This is shown again & again on all the channels. So sad😭😢😵😷

[@SunilThummala]

People who think pak or middle east is tolerant to muslims are living in delusional world. As a indian born who is now in US for the last 20 yrs i can say India is the most tolerant country in the world. Peace in chaos is very unique to India. Indian muslims are peaceful compared to muslims outside India. There is something magical in India that make them universal. Don't fall into politics but focus on country's growth, at least from now. After all india got true independence just 4 yrs ago. If India was like now 20 yrs ago i would have not left India. Corruption and hopelessness created by corrupt mafia called congress party destroyed india after independence till now. Hindusthan amar rahe.

[@udaysheorey1490]

muslim samudai ko aik hi samasya par pura dhyan daalna chahiyea: itihaas padhiyay toh samaj may aata hai ki islam aik khatarnak sangathan hai jispar dharam ka mukhota chadhaiya gaya. Uskay koran aur hadeeths may bahutsey "nafrat kay kaatey" aur "jehrili jadh" bharey hain. Yeh kaun aur kaisay nikaley jai? Yeh subh nikalney sey Bharat may shanti, bhaichara aur insaniyat badhaygi, duniyabhar may subhko aram ki neendh mileygi aur karodon mussalman jo abhi islam may kaidi hain unko chutkara milega. Allah mussalman ko sahi salah daye aur iss chakravyu may say nikalnay ka rasta dikhayea.

[@coolchapraghu]

People , please follow OpIndia youtube Channel... I am a subscriber of their channel.. it produces good content supporting India and Indian dharma. This promotion is purely out of own volition.. OpIndia is not really in a rich position to pay for any promotion I think.

[@tonynaidoo7572]

Well said but as a Muslim you and your family accepted India as your country so there is no problem. The problem is with muslims who want to live in India but not accept India as a majority hindu nation

[@dharampalsingh6054]

Pls send amirkhan pakistan

[@Tragic.Kingdom]

Aamir Khan is afghani

[@shivakumarm6576]

People like you are the true face of India. You and people like you arecwhatvmakes this country. What I feel angry about in that dishonest people with an agenda are pedding lies about the country and its culture. As a hindu and a brahmin, I have never once even thought that an Iqbal or a Brenda or James is lesser Indian than anyone else including me. In fact I feel it disgusting that I even have to state this because it is not something that even needs to be stated. It's as irrelevant as saying rhat the sun rises in the east. But when a few Indians give voice to a concern that west and communist centric forces are using money power to deride India and its magnificent culture of inclusiveness, instead of proving their concerns to be incorrect, there is a tirade that the RSS and the BJP and its bhakts are intolerant. In this way the communists and left wing liberals and writers prove beyond doubt that they do have an agenda of destroying the ethos of this great country. We do not fear that they will succeed because our history of 1000 years has proved that Indian culture cannot be destroyed. But just as the malarial mosquito needs to be externinated so do we wish to deal with these Anti India forces of pestilence without losing our sanguine character. Shame on these forces that eat foreign money to tarnish their own country.

[@AjeetAdhikari]

Vote dena bhi jau nahi to kyae ho ga dehlo iattra bhoke ki nai hoga

[@sriramiyer893]

Agree திமுக வேண்டாம் போட

[@devanshthaker4]

Again its a Muslim woman who is talking sense but no Muslim man dare talk like this they are stopped or not allowed to talk good about India or its culture

[@vijayanandkapte634]

The intolerance is manufactured propaganda of communal congress party, intolerance is only in their mind. Hope less congress for their political gain they say and do anything against country, that party never emotional about country only emotional about Nehru-Gandhi family

[@vikasg989]

This patriotic lady doesn't know what intolerance is ask Aamir Khan ask congress ask human rights ask kashmiris and so called Muslims ?

[@venkateshtulabandula5251]

Quran says :- It's mentioned other than muslims or not belivers if they haven't belive in Quaran or existence of God allah Will be punsihed in hell The messenger of Allah said:- I have been commanded to fight against the people till they testify that there is no other god but Allah Quran also mentioned that You can trust your maid but never a trust a women who whorship idols That's why Mughal empire sold thousands of hindu women to islmalic countries And destryoed the thousand of hindu temples Bec we worship gods in idol form The fault is entirely in Quaran .it's follow blood ,swords and killing whoever not belive quran and it converts and it's allow discriminates Christianity The fault is quran and the Mughals followed it seriously. So this this the book you follow which encourage. Violence And dicriminate other religion and convert through blood and swords

[@kartikeyshukla100]

Babuton ki g jal gyi hogi.

[@maryamibrahim1853]

If ur Gujarat victim ur voice different baby

[@msdolly6101981]

Burning train victim?

[@baisjs151]

@@msdolly6101981 no he means the retaliation when the terrorists burnt down 50 plus human beings alive.

[@shahuss1]

Pretending lynchings did not happen and Delhi riots did not happen and the attacks at JNU and Jamia did not happen and the hateful speeches were not made against protesters at Shaheen Bagh cannot be wished away as tolerant behaivour, we need to acknowledge wrongs so there can be redemption madam, don’t stick your head in the sand and pretend all is ok.

[@ballyragoonanan]

Never intolerance. Only respect.

[@talha7610]

Achawwwwwww

[@khersi.6261]

HER VOICE IS LIKE THAT BECAUSE OF SUPPRESSED GUILT !!!

[@ramesh6177]

Islam will prevail

[@ramshalla664]

bjp agent

[@khersi.6261]

HER VOICE IS LIKE THAT BECAUSE OF SUPPRESSED GUILT !!!