Truly inappropriate to attempt to meme-ify a righteous scholar. Please think twice and ask whether this was a necessary video to post.
@LetterBeginning7 ай бұрын
Replying to @ryuusuk33: You cannot claim something is Haram in Islam if that something is not agreed upon by consensus. There's a huge difference of legal positions regarding music. Educate yourself before claiming this is Haram or Halal or else you'll end up in the Hellfire/Jahannam.
@ryuusuk337 ай бұрын
there's clear sahih hadiths about the forbidding of music/instruments The prophet pbuh sayings are the ultimate authority over any scholarly consensus that you have Atleast you must acknowledge that it is haram even if you can't stop listening Be careful, don't do "istihlal" it's a serious sin brother Do not soften the religion to suit your desires
@faresasfary7 ай бұрын
Ask yourself Would SHY like this frivolity? SHY isn't somber and he usually tells some anecdotes in his lectures to refresh the minds and to keep them attentive and interested. You stopped the video just to take a miscontexulaed image of him. Before being haram or whatever that you've done, it was really really silly and lame.
@chadmuslims6 ай бұрын
Yes he would like this
@ryuusuk337 ай бұрын
cut the music brother, it's haram
@----f7 ай бұрын
isn't singing ok? reaching extremism with this comment ngl
@ryuusuk337 ай бұрын
@@----f yes it's okay just voice but here there's musical instruments like piano playing in the background
@LetterBeginning7 ай бұрын
You cannot claim something is Haram in Islam if that something is not agreed upon by consensus. There's a huge difference of legal positions regarding music. Educate yourself before claiming this is Haram or Halal or else you'll end up in the Hellfire/Jahannam.
@ryuusuk337 ай бұрын
@@LetterBeginning there's clear sahih hadiths about the forbidding of music/instruments The prophet pbuh sayings are the ultimate authority over any scholarly consensus that you have Atleast you must acknowledge that it is haram even if you can't stop listening Be careful, don't do "istihlal" it's a serious sin brother Do not soften the religion to suit your desires
@m.s.m.39167 ай бұрын
Maybe not haram, but it's certainly stupid to use it for this video