Sanjeev Sanyal Destroys Devdutt Patnaik: Live Reaction | Bharat That Is India | J Sai Deepak | Anand

The information provided on this [website/platform/document/etc.] is intended for [educational/entertainment/informational] purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, professional, or any other type of advice. The content presented here may include excerpts, quotes, or references to copyrighted material, which are used under the principles of "fair use" as defined by the copyright laws of [your country or jurisdiction].
"Fair use" allows for the limited use of copyrighted material without permission from the copyright owner, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. The use of copyrighted material in this [website/platform/document/etc.] is transformative in nature, adding new insights, commentary, and value to the original works.
While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information presented, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the content provided. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.
We encourage users to independently verify any information provided and to consider seeking professional advice where appropriate. If you believe that your copyrighted work has been used in a way that constitutes copyright infringement or violates your intellectual property rights, please contact us at [contact email/phone number] and we will promptly address your concerns.
By accessing and using this [website/platform/document/etc.], you agree to the terms of this fair use disclaimer.

[@RR-wp8jt]

Devadatta isn't a mythologist, rather he is a mithya logist.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

lol

[@Changinglives2000]

devdutt is true to his name, he is MYTHOLOGIST , creating myth left and right

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🤣

[@psroutine7132]

Devdutt wasn't on air. His responses were recorded. Ofcourse his argument made no sense but would have loved a fave to face debate

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@srs4655]

No that will not change anything ..people like devdutt are not interested in actual good scholarship..they make arguments in bad faith...they will change context of evidences found to prove their preconceived notions..true scholer is one who make or change his opinion with every good information found and will not stuck to one conclusion...devdutt is not such person ...I think he is carrying forward agenda as student of sheldon pollock...no intellectual honesty

[@adityaakumar611]

yes his recording shown in interview but devdutt answered the same questions. Devdutt books has many wrong translations and many people challage him for debate .even in twitter he block the commment section ,only open for mitra mandli..he is gone too far in left that his sanity is on question..

[@chiru8486]

he had all his time when replying on twitter. still, he went on to call sanyal hindutva brahminical fascists instead of countering his points. and as for facts, pattnaik is not just false but a liar too. he mixes and juxtaposes verses from different hymns to form new narrative and peddle lies about supposed formation of caste system blah blah blah. he calls dasas as slaves while dasas are emmigrating tribe called dahae in northern iran who are aryan themselves. never believe anything he says.

[@suryakantthakur2862]

Devdutt patnaik has avoided all the challenges given to him to debate on his works and statements, so don't expect

[@thatcoolteacher]

Guys we want more voice from Bengal the home of Shiva and now Durga pooja... One has to know the plight of bengal due to Momota begum... Pls save sanatan or else get taliban rule 🙌

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🙏🏾

[@Mayank-Pawar]

He could have become perfect person for British in the 19th century! 😂

[@anantharamanmr]

Hehe Gandhi still wins that post😂

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@Roar1921]

I am not a. Devutt fan but i am glad he recognizes our civilization celebrates diversity

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@anantharamanmr]

And yet he spews venom on Brahmins..

[@Roar1921]

@@anantharamanmr he is a wolf in the garb of a cow😂 there was a time when people had lesser sources of information and felt he was authentic. Now his myths won't fly

[@prajwalm.s7976]

Finally got the video I wanted

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🙏🏾

[@Moonrisephoenixx]

Devdutt has not appeared on media channels for quite sometime now. And not appearing here was a smart move on his part I must say. Because he knows he wont stand a chance in front of Sanjeev Sanyal. Sanjeev would have destroyed and burned him to the ground had he been live. The inpact would have been 10 times worse on Devdutt.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Shit

[@rushtyin318]

Yes imagine Devdutt infront of JSD, anand ranga, Sanjay Dixit, shushant sharin, live with Sanjeev lol, they will eat him alive

[@psroutine7132]

It were the Buddhists monks who for the very first time kept the chandals outside the city and made them untouchables

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Well probably not. Arthashastra also talks about having Chandals and dog breeders to live on the outskirts. Altho untouchability is not specified.

[@bld-cd6xb]

I am an alien from another planet and i can't pronounce 'e' sound, we call it 'u' therefore rahul gandhi will become Rahul Gandu, right?

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🥹

[@anantharamanmr]

Slam n dunk! 😂

[@psroutine7132]

When i first saw this i thought devdutt is actually mocking the leftists 😅

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@edres7563]

From Sanskrit sindh to arab/persianised hind, to greek ind and finally english india...wow what an 'authentic' journey to accommodate the ability of others who cant even pronounce a nation's own name! The mental gymnastics are off the scale!

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🙏🏿

[@kavankomer3048]

Sindhu means water body, river or sea etc... Sindhu doesn't necessarily mean river now in Pakistan. Why I said this??? Well if you read Bajrang baan, that strotra explains power of Shri Hanuman. And it mentions that he crossed sindhu when going to Lanka. Patnaik fellow is a Chuutya

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@wolfenstein1369]

Vhai darun kaj korcho ..reaaly likd u r work bhai...I go to college street regularly and liked the channel name....borgi r bangla r byapar ta nie ekta kichu korbe bhai??amar one liner reply ekjon ke diechilam je amra nijerai dai borgi ra amader lutheche mogol der sathe fight korar janya...lyad jadi amra khai , tahole borgi de r oi dosh...they were right from their standpoint...if we are not strong enough, then nobody cna save you...dosharop kore labh nei..but me also fan of Sanjeev Sanyal....❤

[@bharataubaca1998]

Why does he sound like sakuni mama? @devdutt

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@ytskt]

You are doing injustice to shakuni by comparing this moron with him.

[@211119801847]

Spreading venom is a snakes job why some humans are taking this job from it😅

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@Dunning_krugerr]

Are the British calling their country as burthania.. or angrez desh or vilayat... ? They lived here for 300 years and killed 60 million of us .. still we don't talk of it ..

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@4thgen.warfareexpert780]

That mohak mandal guy actually refered to DDP as intellectual or scholer or something 8n his videos,😂

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@BeE_AriyaN]

Birds of same feather flock together 😶

[@geethahs2021]

So he means to say we should continue comitting the mistakes of Greek in pronouncing the name sindhu😃

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes!

[@supriyoghosh6533]

Devdutt is good fiction writer and story teller. Please don't treat him an expert...all his knowledge is borrowed from translated texts.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@amitpratap7551]

Please always address Crypto with the Crypto - for example say- "Crypto Devdutt Pattnaik" which shows Shatrubodh.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@anantharamanmr]

What does he mean by political conclusion? When you talk about people, its naturally political, that is, "of concerning to people". Here we are talking about India's or Bharat's political name and therefore it makes sense to side with the political conclusions. Not sure why this is even an issue, as Sanjeev ji says, both are interchangably used and we know the plurality of our culture, and calling ourselves Bharat is in no manner an undermining of the plurality. These idiotic media folks need to find more meaningful topics to discuss.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@saitandale8482]

Devdutta ka baja baj gaya hai 😂

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Hey rajaji

[@nikjs]

So the news channel lied to their audience and doctored in clips instead of having an actual live debate where both speakers are online and on video at the same time and can hear/see each other.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes. And I think that's why they decided to delete it and re upload it

[@astro_aviral]

Shit shit shit Kya haga hai 😂😂😂

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@gnsindhur9890]

If were so interested in being India, then maybe we could call ourselves Sindhudesha, or something like that. It refers to the Sindhu and is a correct pronunciation. Or we could xall it Jambudwipa because we have Jambu trees here. Both have to do with nature and geography. Even if we want to retain India, we can always correct the pronunciation. Why should we adhere to a name which is in a wrong pronunciation?

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@zbsishrth3734]

Hindu word is mentioned in many Hindu scriptures. How could they not pronounce s in Sindhu but pronounce s in Islam, Hussain, Ayesha etc?

[@zbsishrth3734]

@@linguistme6870 s silent in Zoroastrian?

[@aarounge]

Y is Devdutt here ? Wat credibility he has to speak on this ?

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Mythologist

[@anantharamanmr]

Well he's here because the channel's equally "in"credible 😂

[@ytskt]

He peddles the western POV with an Indian wrapper.

[@harshravi13]

Me:- Devdutt is garbage. Avg DP Fan:- How can you say this? 😡 Me:- After wasting my 2021 in reading half dozen of his books :)

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@amitpratap7551]

धर्मो रक्षति रक्षित: । Malecch ideologies ke eradication aur Attacking Malecchon ke Vadh ko Dharma poor swikriti deta hey. In Missionery-Dravidian-Jehadi ideology Ki Total eradication Karo Bharat se.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@piyushpatnayak4951]

lets accept plurality and call dd a synonym for a-hole

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@won2kafour]

This Patnaik is a Crypto-Christian?

[@ytskt]

Might just be a cheap sell out. He is just a frustrated loser because he knows that he is exposed most Indians don't trust his gobbledygook anymore...

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

No idea

[@kyotoyep6666]

If you want some Pure unadulterated BS 24/7...than Devdutt is your Guy😅

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🥹

[@edres7563]

Yes we are a pluralistic civilisation, with many names for many things, but for some reason India which is an exonym, has been officially chosen to represent the nation to others. If that is ok and didnt cause us to become a middle eastern type singularity as Devdutt disingenously claims, then what's wrong with using one of the many names that are indigenous to the land, such as Bharat, in order to officially represent the nation to others?? Its like saying UK should be called Angleterre, because thats what the French call it, or that no one should dare to have the audacity to decide what to call themselves, but wait for others to name them instead! Damn! This kind of sh*t only seems to fly in Bharat. Elsewhere, they dont tolerate it one little bit.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Haha

[@TM-dj7ec]

In one hand he will say we r not not "mideastern monotheism we r plural hindu" in other hand hr says "hIndus should include mideast monotheism culture that is muslim". Ajib aadmi hai

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🥷🏿

[@StudyingReligions]

He is propaganda Artist!

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Haha

[@edres7563]

DevButt is proof that you can spew endless BS from every orifice and get away with it, so long as you say it softly, and with a creepy nauseous smile.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

👀

[@sunilthakore5715]

Bharat is a civilisational name of the people who habitated the land of what is now India. He does not know the word Baratnatyam is the the dance of what is now India. We are a culutre, a civilisisation that is Bharat, to say is is Brahimical is a slur in it's own right. He is getting lost in what he is trying to explain. The name Great Britain was not what was the original name of Britain , it was the pride of the Britsh that called it Great Britain, So as a rule can we not have Bharat , as this is historical not like the ficticious Great Britain. So they had created pride in their nation by invading countries around the world, but our desh cannot have pride, we have to still live under the names we were called by foreigners. These left leaning western thinking historians, just keep on wanting to thrash the vedic traditions of India, and remain pawns of the West. England historically has always had invasions and was never civilisatiional. It's name was deriverd from Anglo Saxon invaders [Angle Terra). It never actually actually had a cultural history, as India had. We had cities while Europe were in the forest. It had no science knowledge, math, and medicine. We were from Bharat a civilisation far more advanced. Yet our scholers fail to understand this, and still look cookoo eyed for the West for inspiration.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes

[@edres7563]

He doesnt think Bharat comes from India...so where the hell does it come from?? America? Africa? China? Australia? But India which is clearly foreign DOES??

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🗽

[@kbmnair2182]

Devadut is I'll informed. India is named by the British. The Europeans named Red Indians, West Indies, Indonesia etc etc which means "aboriginal" or which needs to be civilized. India is thus a name given by the Europeans for the uncivilized people of the world. Devadut is ignorant on this.

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🙏🏾

[@kbmnair2182]

@@collegestreetkolkata9669 Actually the Europeans have named us with a meaningless name India to insult and denigrate us.

[@eliotanderson6554]

You first point after his first comment was stupid he is correct regarding plurality vs singularity Seems like u r just a youtuber without enough credentials or experience or have enough expertise or education on those topics There is difference between sai deepak and andhbhakts

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Suck my credentials.

[@zbsishrth3734]

Hein? His first comment didn't make any sense.. If Greeks couldn't pronounce 's' then who were Socrates and Aristotle? If persians couldn't pronounce 's' then what was Persia pronounced as? Or what was Islam why not ihlam?

[@Moonrisephoenixx]

The problem with jerks like @eliotanderson6554 is that they refuse to see any other view point other than their own. There is only one world view that exists and thats their own if you dare to deviate from that you will be immidiately named , blamed & cancelled. It didnt take him one sec to call @college street kolkata an andhbhakt. But its strange this andhbhakt also critisizes bjp when ever required.

[@Moonrisephoenixx]

@rohansantra2750 exactly 💯

[@debapratimbhattacharjee1569]

Asurdutt Khalnayak

[@cinefile0075]

Sapt Sindhu ka hapt Hindu ho gya aur ush se Hindu word aaya. Fir to tumhari puri identity "Hindu" hi Persian Hain. Your whole identity is someone else's (wrong) pronunciation. Don't you think you all should have been called Sindhu officially then ?? 😅 And sanyal gave no explanation of word "India" he only gave about "Hindu" (Persian pronunciation). From where the word "india" came then ?? Aur yeh sab 10 saal me ab un logo (opposition alliance) ne naam India rakha tab kar rahe hain ...how much desperate and frustrated bjp is to be in power then ?? 😅

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Cuban history expert

[@cinefile0075]

@@collegestreetkolkata9669 didn't expect this from you ...name calling and all . 😁 U didn't give me answer... my question was don't you think yall should be called "Sindhu" (from sapt Sindhu) instead of Persian wrong pronunciation Hindu ?? 😀

[@amitpratap7551]

Crypto convert Devdutt Pattnayak malecch foreign Coloniser white-evangelist-races ka chattu hey. What will you do to such Fodu foreigner crypto convert Brown Sepoy?

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

🫨

[@Parasuram5]

Devdutt Patnaik is a hoax Why waste air time on him. Rahul You are lowering your standard

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Haha

[@Robinthakur-ji2tx]

It can be seen that you do not have any sense of Lingual Science as WhatsApp university donot teach you about that

[@collegestreetkolkata9669]

Yes Sanjeev Sanyal passed out of Whatsapp university. Go back to Cuba.

[@Robinthakur-ji2tx]

@@collegestreetkolkata9669 do you guys know anything without saying go here go there. You please study history of India, Languages, geography ,evolution from authorized source and gather knowledge .

[@anantharamanmr]

Kya taqleef hai be?

[@rushtyin318]

@@Robinthakur-ji2tx you give your test reports of these subjects you mentioned lol or go back to cuba.

[@bld-cd6xb]

@@Robinthakur-ji2tx please explain me how 'India' a distorted version of Sindhu Is more bhartiya term than 'bharat' itself.