संवाद # 203: India is NOT ready - problem with Modi, Indian Army, IAS, Agniveer | Bharat Karnad

[@prithudak1]

I can feel the pain of Mr Karnad, IAS and IPS is the worst thing that happen in India

[@karansalwan7308]

and inept politicians

[@somitmukerjiforu]

MUH BANDH APNA KAM KAR

[@prithudak1]

@@somitmukerjiforu air bhi comi chamche. Apni baap se bhi aise baat kartein hajn

[@parthsarathik6242]

Kyu ​@@somitmukerjiforu

[@perpetualprosperity2963]

Tashan hai aur koi kaam ke nahi yeh British ke zamane mei atke IPS & IAS 😂

[@Vishal-]

People not being able to take ‘truth bombs’ from someone who literally was one of the people to draft ‘India’s nuclear doctrine’. Shouldn’t live in ‘an echo chamber’

[@JaiHind_]

The truth is we are doomed in every aspect,but 99% of our population don't have functioning brain😅😅

[@nitin5745]

@@JaiHind_ one of the best comment

[@futureiitianjee]

​@@JaiHind_ Your comment made my day Exactly same as my feelings We are indeed doomed

[@JaiHind_]

@@futureiitianjee yes brother if you curse congress,congress called you godi/andhbhakt,if you curse moody they called you pappu,as if world revolves around these parties,we need completely new political ideology,who has the ability to rule India with iron fist and develope our country,🤞

[@anttalsuraj9804]

@@JaiHind_that’s exactly what i thought mediocre thinking people like orwell said most important thing for these people is loyalty to party

[@punitmodhgil624]

3 points. 1. Nehru's first defence minister was caught in Jeep purchase corruption scandal. 2. Nehru said No to Security Council invite long time before 3. HAL was making planes much before.. Nehru ji nationalized it and killed it.

[@SRINATHKADIAM-o6f]

You are right, and these points needed to be spelt out.

[@TheKumarmanoj]

U forgot the BIGGEST blunder of dat ahole...NEHRU WAS AGAINST INDIA HAVING DEFENCE FORCES OR ARMY....whereas pak knew dat in future they will backstab India and take a big part frm India ...if possible even Delhi....NEHRU THOUGHT INDIA IS A PEACE LIVING NATION AND WAS A DEVELOPING NATION SO ALL DAT MONEY DAT WILL BE WASTED ON AMMUNITION AND WEAPONS SHOULD BE DEPOSITED IN KHANGRESS BANK ACCOUNT...1962 WAS HIS BIGGEST BLUNDER

[@MandeepSingh-bv2zw]

​@zero_in_official absolutely spot on !

[@pradhyumnyadav126]

😂

Nationalisation kills productivity and the organisation/s

[@satbirsingh6791]

ये वाकेई बहुत ही ज्यादा अच्छा इंटरव्यू है।forces की काफ़ी सारी चीज़ों के बारे में अच्छी जानकारी मिली है। और जिससे ये भी पता चलता है कि इतने आधुनिक समय में इंडिया कितना पीछे खड़ा है। जबकि हमारे पास लगभग सभी तरह के साधन मौजूद हैं

[@shopperorder6115]

Hands down the Best podcast from India. The variety of topics, quality of guests and the mix of historical topics that made Bharat great as well new ones that can make Bharat great once again. Strategic thinking, planning and execution is so central to long term success. Jai ho.

[@subu150390]

I've been following Mr.Karnad for a long time (more than a decade now). Even in his old age, the man is as sharp as he was then. Please keep bringing him back.

[@shantanudutta1539]

He is a store house of knowledge and these are learned men whom the PM should listen to to make India great. Enjoy listening to the podcast.

[@ypatil647]

can you please how are you following him.. I really loved him in this podcast @subu150390

[@varenyamarya]

But I think....he is giving contradictory statements throughout the podcast....for example on one side he is praising L&T & on the other side he is criticizing for missing real manufacturing.... during 2000s chinese products were like shit & we used to make memes on them....but in 2020s they are making world-class quality products....so how can we expect that quality in one go.... assembling products is one of the many ways to engage companies....

[@aviral5124]

"US me meritocracy h" yaha pe chandraskekhar "ravan" hai 👹

[@ajaykumar-ss9he]

चंद्रशेखर रावण तो आज 40साल से है। लेकिन भारत तो गुलाम जब हुआ था तब तुम्ही लोग थे न? फिर कैसे हुआ

[@harryyash9422]

​@ajaykumar-kyunki tumhare baap Dada tab bhi to chor the na kyon tumhare baap Dada nahin the kya is Dharti per 😂😂😂 jakar Apne hi Babasaheb ka laddu Saheb ka book padh lo usne khud apni kitab mein likha hai ki India became slave of Mughals and Britishers because of the low caste people😅 as they refused to fight with high class people for the independencess9he

[@sauravchowdhury4790]

​@@ajaykumar-ss9he kyunki kuch log British ka hoke bhi lad rahey thay aur unka iss baat pe guroor bhi hain jaise Bhima Koregaon mein huwa.

[@ghanvedsingh8946]

​aap motilaal Nehru ko kaise bhool sakte hain jo angrejon ki pervi karte the?@@sauravchowdhury4790

[@Aastha.12345]

​@@ajaykumar-ss9hekyoki BHIMTO ke purvaj napunshak Ghar me baithe rahe and upper caste ke log ladte rahe.

[@aviral5124]

Modi as PM ye haal h, imagine RaGa as PM. 💀💀

[@hukmaram5810]

Leftist.. naxalites hi chalayenge sarkar..natiza😢😢

[@bally1asdf]

Moti Moti karo

[@sukhbirsingh2450]

मोडी जी से तो अच्छा ही करता आज मोडी जी ने सेना मे भी 3 लाख सैनिको की कटौती कर दी है

[@aviral5124]

@@sukhbirsingh2450 राहुल चीन का भला सोचने वाला है वो तो इससे भी कम कर देता....योगी जी की जरूरत है अब तो।

[@gagan3440]

@@aviral5124 Yogi Khud UP haar gya, Ayodhya bhi. Abhi Kanwariyon ke atank ko nai rok paya 10 din tk. Baba math mein vapis jayenge.

[@manukk2311]

My mind blew up listening and heart sank understanding.

[@abhayghildiyal9706]

We have Rahul Gandhi going to HAL Bangalore.. briefing their employee unions that Modi is privatising..... You will loose your job etc... These king of politicians getting funds from outside..

[@Scooby-Doo24]

Divide & Rule

[@Dangermonkey1000]

Ruhal thik bolta hai

[@Cosmicrage-hy1en]

@abhayghildiyal9706 just listen with open ear you fool

[@ankitkataria-rh5hd]

@@Dangermonkey1000 noo without privatisation yu hi reh jayenge. Top defence companies of world are all private.Because they can manufacture fastly

[@sevenstars4817]

​@@ankitkataria-rh5hdactually in foreign countries like germany france america they speak all one language. But in india there is argument cuz no one knows which language to speak and so end up speaking english which hampers communication between employers and so the delays

[@angryindian7568]

What a joke hindustan aeronautics limited was result of foresight of walchand hira chand and maharaja of mysore what has nehru done?

[@hukmaram5810]

Nehru + bakri chhap to sena ko hi hatane ke favour me the😮

[@uditraj8290]

Nehru ne HAL ko destroy kr diya Nationalise krke😢

[@hrushikeshgouda4965]

he nationalized it.

[@saurabhrai5461]

@@hrushikeshgouda4965 ma chod di bharat ki

[@angryindian7568]

@hrushikeshgouda4965 it was british government which nationalized it during second world War get your facts right

[@0706suchi]

Pension is indeed killing us. I am shocked to see villagers who are just literate enough to read a very simple text on paper getting 70-80K/month (Govt. guest houses, PWD, etc. in Himachal Pradesh). They barely have work. Mostly it is gup-shup. For guest houses all the more they have work may be max 2 months in whole year because these are such remote villages with 0 fancy restaurants or attractions. The attractions are few waterfalls (most tourist don't wanna trek so...), lovely scenery all around. Hence, tourist are eith very less or just transiting such places.

[@TheRobinandme]

Let it be , if the money is coming that way, still let it come. Himachal interior have a very poor resource of trade and export. : Land locked . Its essential revinue sources as number of hydle electric plants have been taken by others states since ages. I will never feel agitated if a class 4 person in govt job here is getting whatsoever salary or pension. : Our resources are already plundered by other states. And we haven't been given our due since independent India.

[@rafeeq4313]

Bhaiya reservation ka kamaal hai

[@bealive64]

Money have nothing to do with Literacy

[@RajeshwarSingh-z4v]

Not understood

[@veejay1972]

Could not understood.

[@malaynavneetgovil1524]

He is having a genuine frustration . He should also come out with his contribution to the problems .

[@MandeepSingh-bv2zw]

@@malaynavneetgovil1524 huh ? What do u mean ?

[@aditierpconsultancy7124]

@@MandeepSingh-bv2zw Solutions to the problems

[@daddyyogi5761]

I like this guy, I hope the country's top executives take note on this and we demand action on anyone who has lured by obesity. Doing nothing and just living in comfort on common man's hard earn tax.

[@gypsyking4234]

Thanks, Dr. Bharat Karnad, for giving us this very valuable insight.

[@mahadevsevak-n8b]

भारत आज भी गुलाम है । और कलयुग के अंत तक रहेगा, सभी देशों की अपनी अपनी आइडियोलॉजी है भारत की ideology सबको खुश करना ।

[@sudhirsingh869]

Very informative and excellent presentation...

[@bhagwansingh4093]

Thanks!

[@mohammadtambra4340]

After long time i heard honest person speaking ..... I agree India Best Engineers and why Gov't not using them to reduce time and cost

[@harishrawatjalam]

He is right our media is not talking about reality

[@GopalchandraMaity-v1x]

But, why are they silenr on real issue????

[@SurprisedBabyPenguin-kb9ib]

Most of the media houses are paid either by left wing politicians and right wing​@@GopalchandraMaity-v1x

[@mohican6158]

​@@GopalchandraMaity-v1xto keep public morale up

[@jks7856]

He has said it right about nuclear weapon yield, in 1998 bjp under vajpayee, pokhran test was not of any substantial yield, but for political purpose highlighted it and we got US sanctions that almost crippled industrial growth of India. A bail mujhe maar strategy, which even today bjp is following under modi.

[@amritanshu4460]

Thank you sir 🙏

[@mohitmehta261]

Very nice podcast, willing to watch more...

[@AmandeepKour-vy5kj]

To start business in india is not reliable. Like I am civil engineer preparing for je exam in j&k from 4 years but jobs are grabbed by fake EWS candidates. Now I m trying to make a contractor card but it takes 4 months for only character verification. I m kashmiri migrant imy parents and i don't possess any property in current residence. There is a formality of 1.5 lacs of property certificate to apply for PWD contractor card. If I get contract of 20 lac how department use my 1.5 lacs rupees of property. Bureaucracy is worst in india. Entire system is worst.

[@Health-Blitz]

Don't Lose Hope, You Must fight For What You Believe In

[@jaichanddtomar1153]

Such a delight and treat to listen to each of these mind boggling podcasts . Brilliant

[@GulabRajAh-z2c]

Nice podcast.

[@MEHARYT1]

Only chanel with valuable podcasts, Thanks

[@tanyalifestyle_._4002]

Sir India is democracy and see what happens whenever anyone say the word privatisation. Even reservation is killing India and many problems typically to India 😊

[@hukmaram5810]

Sabse bada dukh rajneeti he..isi ke liye reservation he..

[@tattvamasee]

Reservation is not that big problem but in actual giving support and hand holding of small players is missing big time .. Sabka saath sabka bakwas and bhashanbaazi .. I have been to china and have seen even the marketing of small players is done by govt ..even technology support .. I live in Delhi and Modi has made Delhi Hell except VIP area ..Land and DDA are under Modi .. MODI - Megalomaniac obsessed Doomed imposter (Of all time) .. no one is talking about job losses, small business shutting down like never before now

[@bally1asdf]

Olympics has reservation how may medals u won. There was no reservation before 1947 how many years high caste hindus were slaves of british

[@parthsarathik6242]

मजे मारने के लिए जनतंत्र एक मस्त चीज है पर राष्ट्र वो तो बलिदान और कर्तव्य से ही बनता है

[@uditraj8290]

​@tattvamasee bhai hum china se bilkul compare nhi kr skte but ye jo aap jib loss ki baat kr rhe ho ye v sahi hai, but india me majority of youth unemployable hai.... kyu hire kregi companies unko! Recently pune ke eek college me hiring keliye 67 companies aayi thi but select hue bas 9 students. Ab isme company ki galti hai ya uun students and college ki??? Kaha se grow karegs business yaha, infrastructure hi Kitna bnaya hai? Kyu koi bahar ka investor aayega yaha jaha ka logistics cost and time itna jyada ho. Recent 10 infrastructure growth ka dekhlo aur phle se compare karo agar aisa hi kaam phle ki government kr rakhi hoti to Kitna fayada hota desh ko. Har kaam eek sarh nhi ho skta bhai. Modi ko Kitna v criticism krlo aur krna sahi v hai but usne jo initiative liya yo aaj tak koi PM nhi ke paya. Yaha tak to log Make in India ka v mazaak bnate hai , swach bharat abhiyan ka v yaha mocking hoti hai😂. Startup culture ka v eek acccha boom aaya hai idhar but result me time lgega, government ne kai steps liye hai local business development keliye but hmare yaha ke mahan Beaurocrats 😢

[@raghavrathi884]

This was enlightening and the candor was refreshing! ❤

[@RohitSingh-vm3hr]

Thanks bhaiya, desh main reality main kya chal rha ha vo inn experts se hi pata chalta ha, kyonki news aur social media par toh sab apna apna propeganda chamkane main lage rahte hain.

[@swapnilghosh]

He is a typical example of naam badey darshan chhotey, for example for Agniveers, he's conflating SSC which is for officers, to Agniveers, which is for regular ranks.

[@abhinavvatsa2464]

भाई आपसे एक बात कहनी है .... आप एक podcast करो भारत में बढ़ते रेप की घटनाओं पर आखिर हम कहां चूक रहे है चन्द्रगुप्त विक्रमादित्य का समय जहां कामसूत्र जैसे महान ग्रंथ लिखे गए चंदेल राजाओं का समय जब खजुराहो का महान मंदिर बनाया गया । ये साफ साफ दिखाता है कि हमारा समाज ऐसा नहीं था हम कुछ छोड़ रहे है कही चूक रहे है मुझे नही पता आप तक मेरी comment पहुंचेगी भी या नही लेकिन अगर पहुंचे तो एक बार इस पर विचार करिएगा । उन लोगो से भी प्रार्थना है जो comments पढ़ रहे की हम क्या होते जा रहे है और आखिर चूक कहां हुई है । 🙏😔

[@shekharjoshi7292]

चूक कहीं नहीं है भारतीय संस्कृति की वजह से ही हम सेफ हैं। इसी कारण जवाहरलाल नेहरू से लेकर नरेंद्र मोदी तक आराम से भारत पर सफलतापूर्वक शासन करने में कमोबेश कामयाब हुए हैं। आज भारतीय लोकतंत्र की राजनीतिक प्रतिद्वंद्विता इतनी विकृत हो चुकी है है कि जिनके पिछवाड़े पर जनता लात मार चुकी है फिर अलगाववादियों और अराजकतावादियों के बल बूते जनता को गुमराह कर फिर से सत्ता पर काबिज होने की कोशिश कर रहे हैं।। पर जो विचारशील वर्ग है जो व्यापारिक वर्ग है और पूरे भारत में फैला किसान वर्ग है उसको ये विशाल गठबन्धन बनाये हुए विपक्षी अराजकता वादी राजनेता गुमराह नहीं कर पा रहे हैं। शासक दल बीजेपी इन पर सख्ती नहीं कर पा रही है क्योंकि ये लोग पहले से ही चिल्लाना शुरू कर दिए हैं कि मोदी तानाशाह है, आरक्षण खत्म कर रहा है, संविधान खत्म कर रहा है। पर कालचक्र सही घूम रहा है अगर ये सत्ता पर काबिज हो भी जाते हैं स्थितियां सुधरने के बजाय बिगड़ जायेंगी और ये ग्यारह महीने भी अपनी जान नहीं बचा पायेंगे। क्योंकि स्थिरता सनातन धर्म के कारण है न कि भारत विरोधी देशी विदेशी ताकतों से।

[@RohanYadavHinduKafirमुशरिक]

रिलिजन ओफ क्राइम सर्च करो youtube पे,पूरे दुनिया का सर्वे दिखा रहा कि मुस्लिम,non-मुस्लिम girls का रेप कर रहे।

[@ypoiuytuusbhe]

Until I did not see the video, I was assuming that Farhan Akhtar speaking

[@raveetr8730]

Don't worry so much sir.hope Your views will reach Modi ji. He will understand and take remedies.

[@smileplease5567]

Arre Bhai ye America ka agent hai, agenda ke tahat aaya hai. Modi ji ke aane ke baad bahut kaam ho raha hai, private sector me. Ye bata raha hai ki India ka nuclear weapon 15 kt ka hai, ye jaan bujhkar Aisa bol raha hai. India nuclear submarine banaa raha, thermo nuclear or hydrogen bomb bana raha. Ye America se bakwaas karne aaya hai.

[@navarang6177]

एक दम असत्य है। मेरे मित्र की कंपनी शुरुआत में डीजीटल प्रिन्ट मशीन चाइना,कोरीया से आयात कर बेचतीं थी फिर पार्ट्स लाके असेम्बली चालू किया आज़ पुरी मशीन सुरत में बनाकर बेचते हैं।

[@sachinkhiste8747]

@9:20 he is correct. In our country people consider talent as threat.

[@Simple_Indian]

Agree with Mr. Bharat Karnad on many assertions he makes here. Most people don't know of the unbelievable rot in our civilian bureaucracy as well as in our armed forces setup. Apart from increasing levels of incompetence there's also high level of corruption in the armed forces which doesn't get reported in the media, as the AF is a closed system with limited access to civilians. I share the dispair of Mr. Karnad as there's far too much which is wrong with our entire country's ecosystem despite British rule (supposedly) ending in 1947. Many don't know that over 70% of our original Constitution (often wrongly credited to Dr. Ambedkar) is actually derived from the Govt of India Act 1935 - a British era Act. Even today, our entire administrative (civil services) and legal systems are legacies of the British era, as our political leaders didn't bother overhauling it to SERVE Indians. Only another colonization will change our lousy systems.

[@birkaransingh6392]

That is so true.

[@dr.asimkr.mishra8306]

Excellent Analysis 👍

[@pankajbhandari1623]

These are important conversations, please keep that up and introduce more such people from parts of strategic areas, we don’t have choices, forced to political parties to change

[@dhananjaysingh1912]

Good discussion

[@humblenesss]

Sir, new reform in DRDO, if succesful, then India is truely going to take a step forward.

[@paragmahala3659]

PM koi bhi bane.... Hard decisions koi naa lega... warna political carer khatm

[@ThakurVikrant-b6z]

Very knowledgeable podcast sir

[@TJ-wo1xt]

Wow, I agree with dr karnad, I know the incompetence that exists in our millitary and the civil millitary beaurocracy

[@avisaha8917]

Bharat sir 💯💯

[@futureiitianjee]

Chinese standard weapon is 3.3megaton 💀🌚 agreed And ours is only 20kiloton☹️ Damn the situation is really worrying 🙄 We should as soon as possible start thermonuclear testing

[@razzaqahmad7397]

wonderful podcast Learn lots of things ......

[@gopichand6640]

I think the suggestion given by Bharat karnad in agniveer scheme is practical

[@BalramYadav-n6f]

Bharat karnad has said about the defence crisis in the defensive offense and everything came true He is the best strategist and he is saying true we could not become aatmnirbhar in past 70 years and we will not be this in future 70 years coz most of the commission comes from defence deal.

[@nevil1657]

Respect for you sir🙏

[@kulwant747]

India will become super power in 2030

[@TheROI-republicOFindia]

What a man !! courageous, intelligent, straight forward I want more podcast with him 😅😅😅

[@manishsinha5670]

Initially I thought if he knows this much why the government is acting fool. Then after 42:00 minutes I could conclude that he is highly impractical and bookish. 1 crore one time payment is not solution. Soldiers who are not financially educated would squander the money and hence would become a huge burden.

[@mohitt_jangirr]

He mentioned that....giving one crore will force them to learn a skill during services...

[@JohnWick-uj4gh]

Glad someone said that.

[@rakeshkumar-mo4ev]

Some people think they are master others are time pass , total conversations is superficial.

[@AnkitRana2101]

Just tell where were u hurt 😂

[@vik3469]

Nehru didn't start the nuclear program. It was started by Homi Jehangir Bhabha with funding from the Tatas. After the government took it over, Bhabha had to wrestle with Nehru to extract the required funds against heavy odds. The Marut program suffered because India didn't had the capability to produce the suitable jet engines and the West refused to make available suitable engines due to which the aircraft remained underpowered.

[@achyutdesai3398]

Yes you are right

[@neelkamal7454]

Someone spitting facts straight...bure haal hai humare

[@TheFriendsOfMrCairo]

A good and gripping interview

[@futureiitianjee]

It's a treat to watch mr karnad Was eagerly waiting for his video Thank you 🙏

[@vimaljoshi6736]

Indian are struggling he is enjoying their life because of their heritage if really love to contry come in field

[@odorlessflavorless]

Ofcourse we are not ready YET we are facing the Chinese for over 3 years now ! This is just "practice" 😅😅

[@pkmkb007]

Facing them in border skirmishes and actual war are two different things. When actual war starts I have full faith in bravery of Indian soldiers but what about our military equipment? Indian navy size is less than half of chinese navy and Indian airforce is also less than half of chinese airforce. Chinese millitary is one generation ahead of India in terms of technology. We are atleast 20 years behind China at this point in time.

[@mingmuyiyang8615]

The Indian army is the worst army among all China's opponents. China's war of resistance against Japan lasted 14 years, the Chinese civil war lasted 4 years, the Korean War lasted 3 years, China's self-defense counterattack against Vietnam lasted 2 months, and China's border war with Vietnam lasted 10 years. India's understanding of "war" is too narrow. We Chinese believe that India has never experienced a real war. In 1962, in the eyes of the Chinese, it was not a war, it was just an armed conflict between China and India. In 1962, the short armed conflict of only 32 days continued India's nightmare for decades. What makes the Chinese feel funny is that a border conflict has turned India into a "Battle for the Defense of the Capital of New Delhi".

[@punyashloka4946]

​@@mingmuyiyang8615that's not true India has experience war for past 700 years , invasion after invasion. The reason India is so sensitive about border because India has suffered invasion for past 700 years. Those memories are still alive in Indian minds. That's why. Chinese has not suffered this kind of long slavery and struggle to freedom. Indians are sensitive about border because they have gained freedom after centuries of blood bath.

[@mingmuyiyang8615]

@@punyashloka4946 The great man Marx's evaluation of India's history made me see it clearly. -----India is not one of the ancient civilizations, nor does it have its own complete history. On July 22, 1853, the great revolutionary mentor Marx published "The Future Results of British Rule in India" in Britain, in which he wrote: "If the entire history of India is really history, India is actually a history of being conquered by foreign nations and foreign countries again and again. India itself has no history, or India has no history known to the world. And we are just looking at the history of one invader after another. India is a country built on this endless negative foundation, and such a country is doomed to have no future."

[@mingmuyiyang8615]

@@punyashloka4946 I hope Indians will read it carefully and experience it with their hearts. The huge difference in the founding of China and India is destined to be the biggest difference between India and China. Just look at the modern history of the two countries and you will understand. India was colonized by Britain for more than 200 years. In 1947, Britain experienced World War II, its strength declined greatly, and its status was replaced by the United States. India took the opportunity to gain independence through "non-violent non-cooperation". In other words, India's independence has not experienced the test of blood and fire. Such an independent country has no cohesion and willpower, and no national identity. Now let's talk about China. Since 1840, the Chinese people have been living in dire straits. Various disasters and wars have followed one after another. At that time, China was very poor and backward, and suffered all kinds of humiliation. Including the cession of Hong Kong and Macau, Taiwan became a Japanese colony, the burning of the Old Summer Palace by the Eight-Power Allied Forces, and the subsequent comprehensive and brutal invasion of China by Japan. In 1931, Japan launched a full-scale invasion war against China. From 1931 to 1945, the war lasted for 14 years. The Chinese army and civilians rose up to resist, fought bloody battles for 14 years, and suffered 30 million casualties, but finally won. Do you know why China suffered so many casualties? There are hundreds of reasons. I will only give one example: when the Chinese troops encountered the Japanese army, it was often the case that if there were 100 Chinese soldiers in the battle, the Chinese soldiers only had 20 to 30 guns. The remaining soldiers would not give up resistance or surrender. They used machetes, steel forks, and wooden sticks to bravely fight against the machine guns and cannons in the hands of the Japanese army until they died. This spirit of facing death and never retreating is the Chinese spirit. 30 million casualties! Do you think this can happen in India? For India, there are zero casualties, because India's knees are soft. India will give up resistance soon. Do you know why there is "Nanjing"? Because of the desperate resistance of the Chinese army and civilians, never surrendering and never giving up. After Japan broke through Nanjing, it was first to vent its anger, and secondly to scare off other Chinese soldiers and civilians who were resisting. But all this not only did not scare off any Chinese, but further aroused the Chinese people's resistance. The founding of New China was a test of blood and fire. Do you know why the Chinese national flag is red? That's because the founding of New China was paid for by countless Chinese ancestors with their blood, and we Chinese will always remember it. From 1945 to 1949, there was a civil war in China, and the Kuomintang fled to Taiwan. Originally, the Chinese people thought they could live a long-awaited peaceful life, but in 1950, the Korean War broke out and lasted for three years. The Chinese Volunteer Army successfully resisted the US route to the north without air superiority, sea superiority, backward army equipment, and extremely poor logistics, and our price was the loss of hundreds of thousands of brave PLA soldiers. In 1962, in the eyes of us Chinese, it was not a war at all. First of all, the time was only 32 days, and secondly, from 1959 to 1961, China experienced the most difficult three years since its founding, and many people starved to death in China during these three years. In 1962, India's economy far surpassed China. The United States, the Soviet Union, and Britain all supported India. At that time, India implemented the "Forward Policy" and attacked China with elite troops. We Chinese really don't want to fight. The Chinese troops that fought with India in 1962 were ordinary border defense troops, not regular PLA. In China, soldiers are called "the most lovely people". There is a Chinese proverb: Without a country, there is no home. Soldiers are the backbone of the country. Thanks to our brave People's Liberation Army soldiers, who are always ready to defend the borders of the motherland. No matter how India's military develops, it can't surpass China. Whether in the past, present or future, China can always defeat India. This is determined by the history and culture of the two countries. The Chinese people pay attention to the spirit of dedication and sacrifice. Don't surrender, don't yield, fight to the death, and see death as home on the battlefield. It is a huge shame for Chinese soldiers to surrender on the battlefield, and the spirit of dying rather than surrendering is deeply engraved in the bones of every Chinese. These are not possessed by Indians. Therefore, even now or in the future, India will never be able to defeat China. Now, do you think India can stand in the world like China? Absolutely not.

[@vinodkumar-vo2zo]

He is not wrong .he is critically analysing.see where is Arjun MBT,Tejas??? Both are 30/40 Yr old projects still far from completion .AMCA is not coming into the hands of IAF before 2035.

[@sagarmatha2186]

Fir v dil hain Hindustani 😅😅

[@bountifulish]

Speaking abt only one sector in isolation is easy and mischievous. Govt. runs on a wholestic approach. It has to look after socialism, the economy, the employment, the elections. A balance has to be maintained. Atleast the mindset is changing now. Defence forces are looking somewhat for indigenous things. Also don't forget Dr. Nambi Narayan whome Indian's themselves braught down.

[@ramkishorjoshi9711]

I am totally agree what he tellls modi ,but he cant change all these within 10years ,but see how people and oppostion parties behind him for small decesions he had taken in past Kissan bill CAA Article 370 Over foreign policies etc So its not easy how its in.USA He has to play at lot of fronts internal as well as outside He is doing great job need support to get such things

[@thespecialone8631]

Private sector mein pay nhi milti Govt should monitor that because we are selling cheap labour to west and our own people are being exploited. Shift from cheap labour to skilled labour is needed

[@HarminderParmar]

Great..Talk.

[@copyninja8976]

This candid conversation about how the Indian state's pysche works w.r.t Nuclear doctrine or absorption of technology, Make In India screwdriver intiatiative etc etc. We can laugh on the silly jokes he made but he opens us up on a dark reality of how screwed we are. Indians arent ready to swallow these red pills.

[@gamestechs]

Very talented person & we should suppress our govt to makeinrealindia🇮🇳

[@abhijitghosh296]

Excellent absolutely nonbiased views seeing for the first time

[@truthconscience81]

This is time pass talk, no specifics,

[@BhanuPrasad-hp4vm]

Mr. Bharat, no one wants die for few years of job leaving family without income..

[@Burner__]

The 1cr compensation idea at the end of color service was so cuckoo it made me question his whole expertise. It has been proven time and time again that a lump sump payment is the worst way to give compensation because of both splurging nature of the recipient and liquidity crunch for the government. Maybe he's not a economist but this much basic understanding of economics can be expected from someone making policy.

[@tanyalifestyle_._4002]

Really good jokes no first rain strikes 😂😂😂

[@Shubham-by3sh]

Only a joke defence minister can say in public that someday India will have maybe 6-7 Aircraft carriers.

[@fatbob3256]

Time line 43.55 it's not about saving pension money. It's about compromising India's security

[@ajitpradhan3825]

Sir, INS Bramhaputra capsized inside Naval Dockyard, not Mazgaon Docks

[@bally1asdf]

My father was in air force. No jawwan want to retire inn15 years until medically fit

[@lokesh9563]

As an Indian , Mr . Bharat karnad should understand that Indians are not meant for fighting . We are for continuing civilization . We have pagan and matriarchal society that will be unable to sustain wars on scales that Anglos and Muslim have fought . We will exists till end of times , although under jewish or Islamic rule just like last 1000 years .

[@fatbob3256]

In the Pension cutting discussion, are the armed forces such a huge burden that only their pension cutting is being done? What about other non- deployed forces? What about the various ministries that are working totally defunct but getting both salary as well as pension. 😅

[@keshavchandraagrawal9947]

Just a correction about pension, it is 50% of last drawn basic pay in comparison of 70% of last pay drawn of US Army.

[@arjuncheema5206]

He contradicts his own statements. On the one side, he says, India is not capable of achieving the technology and speed required for ship building etc, on the other hand he says, PM should forcibly say the forces to buy from Indian manufacturers. He seems to be another Tughlak.

[@AnkitRana2101]

He is critical of the navy and wants private participation, where is the contradiction

[@vinodjadhav6254]

Atleast some one Talking truth and Realities and not become government funded puppet.. thank u for best defence related podcast.

[@kgmuralidharan07]

India should not think of war whether it is ready or not. India has miles and miles of development work to be completed for the people and their well-being. Remember the fully developed India target 2047. India is busy with her growth, and so there is no time for war.

[@uditraj8290]

War puch kr nhi aati bhai😂 aur India ne to war start v nhi ki hai khud se, hmesha thopa gya hai humpe... we should always be ready for war at any front😊

[@B..._598]

India is still busy with growth even after 77 years, so when will India be fully grown😊

[@vdrk8236]

1000 years will take to develop 😂😂

2047 is too late I want it accelerated

[@sandeepkumar6240]

Jis desh ki history galat pillars pe khadi ho wo kaise vikas karega. Jis desh me caste peaceful religion exist karta ho intelligent ideology philosophy ko khatam kar diya. Ambedker ji ne 70 saal pahle jo bola tha uspe amal hua hi nhi society me.

[@thexfactor3097]

Please invite Praveen Sawhney someday

[@mushtaqahmed6844]

Sir bilkul theeq Keh rahen hen . Indian technology behtar he . 2013 me me Iran gaya tha Waha pe Jo material ata tha Indian wo Best tha . Turkey se bhi kyun jis company me Kam karta tha . Us ka material India or turkey se ata tha . Ek Tarah proud bhi hua ke Bhai hamara padosi behtareen chezen banata he .or dukh bhi hua ke . hamarae desh .Door to door he.or hamara fasla . Kitna zyada ho gaya he . Love ❤❤ from Pakistan Sindh

[@rahuljaiswal-yo2pu]

jabardast mind

[@soothingmeditationmusic6581]

Good talk

[@deception6666]

Jaishankar and Ajeet Doval are highly highly overrated just media hype. They failed so many times 😂

[@robin4singh]

I can give that statement and half hearted support; Doval n Jaishankar duo need to make gains at big affairs beyond being great at small affairs.

[@hukmaram5810]

Sahi he..ham sare padousi kho chuke hen..

[@somitmukerjiforu]

ABE MUH BANNDH

[@gagan3440]

This doval guy only mishandled Kandhar Hijack. Jaishankar gutted our realtions with most of our neighours, even Hindu Nepal country fell to china lap, with Nepal printing our area on their Rs100 currency notes. "Duniya mein danka baj rha hai, pados mein nai".

[@jks7856]

They are true public servants of 3rd world country. Till death they want Government to pay for their expenses. To justify themselves they buy parrots.

[@aswininayak5877]

Nirmala yeh video dekh legi toh agle mahine se war tax lena chalu kar degi 😂😂

[@Is_the_way]

Jaipur dialogue wale uncle me dekha toh nipat he lenge

[@rohans1174]

52:15 With due respect, this suggestion can seem viable from POV of managing Finances but in practical, numerous problems are there.... 1. Why'd State Govts sacrifice their one of the major sources for employment generation? Police is anyway state subject. Along with that The ratio of enrollment in the army is tiltrd to some specific states...for that some retired personnel will be too much for some states or some will be too less. 2. Full absorption of 4Y Agniveers may help the CAPFs but after the proposed absorption of soldiers 7Y or 9Y colour service will create shortage of young blood in forces whereas parallel conduct of both absorption & direct recruitment will create cadre clashes inbetween the ranks.... Absorption only after 4Y service in CAPFs maybe the only viable solution

[@williamhunter7131]

RAHUL ko PM ban jane do sab theek ho JAYGA😂😂🎉🎉

[@dr.strangehead3439]

Kya Nasha Kiya hai bhai 😂😂

[@williamhunter7131]

@@dr.strangehead3439 wait and watch… i will reply you back when that happens

[@shivarajbiradar3171]

Bharat Karnad may be a great intellectual in his own way, but he has to look into the histrionic demographic meritocracy by elites to suppress the other. So, William Churchill said about the Indians mentality. Therefore, you have to reverse the trends of mechanisms of meritocracy created by Brahmins since more than the couple of the millenniums. So, Meritocracy is not feasible in Indian subcontinent. Because of its historic blonders.

[@mohitt_jangirr]

Correct....that is the foremost challenge we have....shifting population to demand competition or meritocracy rather than reservations...keeping things like historical oppressions and current discrimination prevailing in society in mind...

[@knowmore8509]

Bhai kabse intjaar tha bharat karnad ka lekin koi bula hi nahi raha tha tumne bula liya, he has the real view of the world rather than idealistic

[@vineetraina119]

Who is bigger danger to us needs to be dealt first.

[@rajeshkumarpancholi9819]

Politicians think for 5 years.i think 50 lakhs also enough.

[@yashthakur2624]

10:48 Bhai Aadhe cheeze Jo private companies Acche se contribute kar sakte hai ..woh BEL ko diya jaata hai

[@sigma_wolfpack]

Private company has a problem Bhai, ek to revenue source nast hota hai aur defence leak karta hai

[@sahilsinghfrand]

Always love to watch when Bharat Karnad sir speaks in hindi ❤