Sarokar - विदेशी MBBS और वैधता l Foreign MBBS Degrees & Right to Practice in India

In this episode of Sarokar, we will discuss the Delhi High Court's order that makes passing the NEET Exam compulsory in order to study Medicine Abroad.
Anchor- Shyam Sunder
Guests: Dr. B. Srinivas, ADG(ME), Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Dr. Savita Malhotra, Former Dean and Professor Head, Department of Psychiatry
Sanjay Shrivastava, Secretary General, Board of Governors, MCI

[@khanabdul7149]

Aasse hi topics pr debate honi chahiye...Thaty what we want

[@ramsajivan8303]

इस इक्जाम को पास करने कि अनिवार्यता भारत के भी छात्रो को होनी चाहिए ताकि पता चले कि बाहर से पढकर आने वाले लोगो के साथ अन्याय तो नही हो रहा है।।

[@Grad7te___gupta_]

yes bhai

[@vishalpandey1734]

common exam must be for the certification for mbbs to indian and abroad students like it to spread it.

[@utpalchoudhury330]

Making NEET qualification Mandatory is a welcoming step , the present FMGE should also be continued..

[@somnathojha2107]

Q

[@anuradhakumari4349]

21:37 perfectly valid question 👍

[@tanmaytejasnarayan5696]

अगर वास्तव में मेडिकल के क्षेत्र में बेहतर व्यवस्था चाहती है सरकार तो देश में भी mbbs करने वाले का भी रजिस्ट्रेशन से पहले एग्जाम होना चाहिये।

[@ankitgarade4897]

Apne India me sabhi ko same number pr government medical clg milna Chahiye. Apne yha to ST SC ko 250 _300 number lane pr MBBS. Doctor bna dete hai Hard work to sabhi same KR rhe phir itne low marks me obc or general wale ko bhms bhi ni milta Kaha se acche doctor BN Jayege Government me ko medical course complete hone ke bad or ek exam Lena chahiye pta to chale Kitna knowledge hai ya phir bs aa gye aise hi Pas ho KR sabhi Ka exam Lena bhot jaruri hai

[@nazirimam3616]

st sc wale jab kam number pa ke mbbs ki seat le lete hai tab minimum standard kahan jata.

[@valour4784]

👍

[@muzaffarkareem6333]

Its good for better health system but need some implement...

[@sameermathur8991]

SARE STANDARDS INKE PICHWADE ME GHUSE HUE H

[@user-qz8yc4wq5q]

मोदी की सरकार फिर एक बार

[@shahbazali-ve6zh]

sir india ma bhi ek bar karbo na sir usa ki traa neet karbo mci ko katam karbo

[@kazimohi2911]

from 626 applicant ,passed 31% Bangladesh is comparatively perfect than China,Nepal,Russ, Khazakistan

[@apurbaroy5992]

Truth Hurts yep bro...bengalis are international...from Nobel prize to oscar bengalis are everywhere...bengalis are members of royal society London....joy bangali

[@kazimohi2911]

I think so brothers

[@juniedtazrian593]

Ho vai amader i khali ulta indiai jaia treatment koron lage kicu bujina asole kahinita ki.

[@suchmooch603]

Ask Putin?

[@Parveen-id8in]

In Australia,Canada,UK and USA government is very strict specially in Health and Medical field. No one can get any Medicine without valid prescription. but in India, there is not any rule and regulations people running practising without any knowledge and education.

[@pankajvatsa2900]

India se MBBS karne wale ka exit test kyon nhi, kya guarantee hai ki entry test ke baad unhone apni quality maintain ki hai.

[@sandeepsangharsh4242]

Sarokar is fantastic program

[@utpalchoudhury330]

Quality of medical education can't be compromised at any cost

[@prajwalkc4437]

Their attitude towards Foriegn medical graduates sucks. Indian graduates who get 35 percentile can do PG ... FMGE with 49 percentage can't practice medicine.

[@patelronak619]

Same problem for me also bro.

[@xyz6297]

@@patelronak619.... Bhai ye fmge Vale jholachhap se bhi badtar hi saalo ki himmat nhi competition crack krne ki

[@pratyushmishra7299]

@@xyz6297 gadhe kabhi bahar ki padhai dekar dekh aur fmge nikalne mein to tera khandan bhi nahi nikal payega.

[@pratyushmishra7299]

@@xyz6297 aur ek baat bata 500 no wala bhi bahar kyu ja raha hai kyunki india mein itni seat hi nahi hai to kya 500 wala 550 wale se bewkoof hai jise india mein seat mil gayi.

[@rajarshikundu2886]

Becz u guys r shit

[@divya_george3140]

I just have to say .. there should be an exams for Indian graduate students too ... At least they should experience the pain of giving exams for 19 subject .. 😬

[@mahshooq.mohamed]

Haha in which year are you now?

[@trex-pubgmobile5390]

Abb aa gya exam congratulations

[@fazlurrahman9791]

NEXT

[@asifkalam674]

HMM A TO GAYA HAI.. SUB LOG DENGE INDIAN MBBS AUR FOREIGN MBBS TOO... BOTH WILL BE TREATED EQUALLY AT PAR...

[@medico137]

@@asifkalam674 means indian mbbs student konsi exam denge aur kb deni hogi

[@priyatripathi4807]

Very well said 50%and 50percentile...huge difference..

[@thelearningadda9377]

I am very happy to see like this type of debate

[@aparajitarath9240]

Is mahila ne sahi zWab diya. Thank you. Yeh har country me hai...

[@ajoychowdhury3188]

MCI control by Indian private colleges mainly from south India. FMGExam is not a screening test,its almost same like PG exam. If this kind of exam will apply in Indian graduates, percentage will be 40%. Fall in respect of India doctors due to greed. MCI visit in India is most funny things, they inform colleges govt n pvt first,colleges collect doctors, patients, systems everything then inspectors coming an enjoying the moment.

[@openmind7853]

Even you can't pass 50% then how can you be a doctor to treat human life

[@ajoychowdhury3188]

We never say stop exam,we told transparency in exam n in syllabus

[@ajoychowdhury3188]

Without any information don't jump on any discussion

[@sohailshaikh1334]

That's why those who clears FMGE will also clears NEET PG easily

[@rekhachaudhari6456]

Kaun kahata hai bharatke medical college standard hai

[@dimabelane1118]

दुर्भाग्य यह है इस भारत देश का कि अपने ही देश में हॉस्पिटल्स का स्टैंडर्ड नहीं रखा जा रहा और जो बच्चे अपने पैसे पर बिना कोटे के पढ़ाई कर बाहर से आ रहे हैं उन पर बहुत ही अनुशासन लगाया जा रहा है

[@moralstories8932]

Good writing

[@ikramhussain1539]

Ye exam apne india ke pvt medical college se paas kiye dr ka bhi lo apko pata chal jayega ki unka kiya hall hai, keval pvt college ke dabaav me test taughest rakha gaya hai

[@aparajitarath9240]

I Iike this lady's argument... anchor ko chup kardiya... salute madam.

[@drramusinghrajput6026]

Indian college se graduate Kiya hua student bhi FMG exam pass nhi kr payega

[@rajarshikundu2886]

Tu pehle karr ke dikha

[@nobodybohra299]

Sahi mai....

[@pratyushmishra7299]

@@rajarshikundu2886 Saale tum to bilkul nahi kar paoge meri cousin pmt mein 380 layi thi 2011 mein aur Abhi usne mci first attempt mein clear kiya hai with 198 marks uska neet pg bhi qualify ho gaya hai aur plab bhi aur wo ab UK mein hi practise karegi kyunki India mein tumhari jaisi mentality wale gadhe jo hain.India mein agar sach mein fmge exam lag gaya to indian medical graduates ki poll Patti khul jayegi waise bhi sirf 35 percent hi students hain jo bina fail huye mbbs pass kar pate hain baki to do teen saal fail ho kar hi pass hote hain.Aur jo mci passing percentage tum dekh rahe ho wo 2013-14 ka hai ab mci passing ratio 60 percent above hai tabhi jitne indian students graduate hote hain utne hi foreign medical graduates mci pass karke yaha practise karte hain samjhe lallu.

[@rajarshikundu2886]

@@pratyushmishra7299 mein final year mein hu mbbs ka...aur mein India mein padhta hu AIPMT clear kiya tha....tum aur tumhare cousin jeshe bhag nehi gaya tha kisi bahar ka chutiya college mein padhne

[@rajarshikundu2886]

@@pratyushmishra7299 jao jakey russia mein mbbs parho....tumhara ehi aukaat he

[@nivatrivedi2902]

Fmge exam is not screening examination it is equivallent to PG exam

[@sauravsingh661]

Rather than complaining about the standard of fmge exam, one should ask for a common exit exam for everyone, government medical college, private medical college and fmg. This will ensure a decent level for the paper and will automatically raise the pass percent.

[@SukhjinderSingh-yl8sl]

Permit me to recall that their is a provision of rmp(registered medical practitioner)&pmp(private medical practitioner)who can and are authorised to practice in the country today then why not foreign trained medical college graduates?

[@SukhjinderSingh-yl8sl]

Please recall the switch over from a 2 year graduation to a 3 year graduation with the introduction of 10+2+3pattern of education it was done in a pretty scientific manner by introducing a year long bridge course as mandatory after a 2 year graduation to be eligible for ma/msc/mcom

[@drbanwariprasadsingh9954]

द

[@prahladraiagrawal7147]

@@SukhjinderSingh-yl8slnmelotion. .

[@urmilagarg7350]

@@SukhjinderSingh-yl8sl u j 😭. Íi 😭í. Ij 😭😭j 😭ji 😭j 🙏🙏ji. Ji 😭😭íjj 😭😭I 😭🙏j 😭ji. Ji 🙏j 😭j 😭😭😭😭😭🙏😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🙏😭😭😭😭😭🙏😭🙏😭😭🙏😭😭🙏😭😭😭😭🙏😭😭😭🙏😭😭🙏😭😭😭😭😭🙏😭🙏🙏😭🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏l 🙏ll 🙏lol 🙏ll 🙏llll 💐ll 💐lll 🙏🙏💐💐😭💐;!I

[@mukesh37yadav]

Indian private medical college ke students se kahi achhe to foreign se study karne wale students hai. M.B.B.S ke bad, Foreign se study kar ke ane ke bad to FMGE exam clear karte hai. Or indian private medical college walo ko पैसे ले कर license de di jati hai. Kya unka examination nahi hona chahiye????? jo पैसे ke dam pe licence de di jati hai. uske bare me kiu koe nahi bolta, Indian medical college me M.B.B.S ke education yadi achhe hai to license exam se kiu pichhe bhagte ho, Do na license exam.. License ke liye to har country me exam hota hai Fir India me kiu nahi???? License exam sabke liye hona chahiye

[@beingindian4967]

MCI is governed by puppets of Private medical colleges who are owned by politicians In India if you pay 50 lakh you can do MBBS, If you pay 1 Cr you can do postgraduation otherwise keep trying and keep giving exams because seats are limited. After 10 yrs of hardship , after 10 yrs of investment what doctor gets? GP - around 50000 a month Specialist around 1lakh a month🤔

[@abhisheksinghasia]

Jada doctors hone ka matalab Heen hai jada logon ka tabiyat kharab ho raha hai ya hoga tab heen doctors earn kar payenge...India need naturopathy experts for good diets and good food along with pure drinking water. 🇮🇳🚩

[@kailashdhobale2204]

⁰⁰⁰0000pp0pp

[@kailashdhobale2204]

⁹

[@arshadkamal1409]

What about the students coming from pvt Indian Medi-Cal colleges? In no case they are better than Foreign Medi-Cal Graduates!

[@nivatrivedi2902]

Sir those student who are not coming are doing excellent work outside

[@indianfact6862]

You made my day...kaha kaam kr rhe h waise?

[@singh_gaurav_kd3029]

Yess ! You are Right. Mostly Doctors Job in UAE . I"ll also Go there.

[@armaanmalik860]

Wow

[@reshurolly]

Foreign ke padhai ko km to aank lia ... Pr jin students ko NEET k 300 marks me reservation k through entry mil jati hai medical collage mil jate hai ...unko q koi judge ni krta ... GENERAL candidate 500 la kr bhi kch ni kr pa rha hai ... Fir bhi parwah ni .... Jo kabil hai usko aap value nahi doge to foreign ja kr hi khud ko sabit krenge na ... Agr kch rules lana ya hatana chate ho to RESERVATION hatao ... Atleast education me to RESERVATION hona hi ni chaie

[@reshurolly]

@amrita anand jaruri to bhot kch hai ... But kch ho thode raha hai ...

[@reshurolly]

@amrita anand reservation should b totally removed from education system ... Wo reserved seat wale bachho ka knowledge kon sa bhot achha hota hai .... Unke lie b FMC k jaisa koi exam karwao fir to

[@RahulSir2023]

@@reshurolly bhut jaruri hai reservation sale hatana Kam se Kam economy wala do Jat pat wala hatakar

[@valour4784]

500 nhi 580 m bhi nhi ho RHA general ka

[@bhoomisbuzz]

Sahi kaha.. Hum general ko sukun se sikhane nahi dete ye government wale.. I hate indian government.. hume yaha 500 lakar v sikhne nhi dete... fir hum out of india jake sikhenge.. To v inko problem.. Ye faltu ka screen test rkha.. Itna v kya judge karenge aap... Judge karna hi hai to unko karo jinko aapne 300 mark me government mbbs me admissions diya hai.. Unko to injection dena v nahi aata hoga.. Unka koi screening test nahi leta...

[@informal2928]

Good step by Modi govt. MCI is scraped now it will work under BODs until NMC being formed and test is essential if u want to serve in India learn Indian syllabus also If u can't go back to foreign country ..

[@rajedrapatidar2885]

Abbs vadas Bhet good vakalp hi

[@adarshranjan2873]

Where r ur standards when u take SC/ST students even after scoring half of the passing mark... Mera is system pr v bhrosa ni h..

[@mohdarshkhan6486]

Exit exam sb k liye rakho...surf bahar wale bcho k liye nahii

[@nobodybohra299]

Haa

[@romanticboy283]

Hme apne desh ke neet students ko quality education ke sath practical knowledge bhi behtar ho aur desh me hi mbbs karna chiey jisse paise bharat me hi rhe 🇮🇳🙏

[@AnkitSingh-pc1lg]

There should be a common exam for all either foreigners or Indian for degree after exam

[@pratibhashukla5212]

Videsi doctor se sab ilaj karana chahte hai jab apne bharat ke bacche bidesh se padkar aate hai to unke saath bahut dogla vavhar bharat me kiya jata hai parichay ke name per gorakhdanda chal raha hai kaha jata hai private colleges ke dawab me ise pariksha ka result itna kam aata hai tak ki bacche unki manmani fees de bahar padne najaye

[@satyabansarkar2663]

Agar Medical Education India me world Class ka hai to India se paise Baale Log Triment ke liye Bidesh kiu jate hai? Sharam Aani chahiye Hamare desh ko. Bharat se kamjor Desh 20 - 25 Lac me Medical Education complit karte hai. Aur Hamare Desh me 70 - 1 crore. Kaha se leke Aayenge itne paise! Aur Ak Baat, Agar Entarns Exam Dena hi hai To iska matlab A huya Ki hamare sare Degree Bekaar hai. Chahe vo koi v Desh ka kiu na ho. Aasli Baat A hai ki Koi v Noble profession me Srif Aamir Ghar k log hi jayenge. Garib Agar Doctor, IPS Banega to Chota kaam kon karega! Islliye Agar Debate karna hi hai to Garib Ghar ka Accha Student ko Kaise Doctor Banayenge vo tay kijiye. Aur Governments ko pressure dijiye Hum jaise Garib ka Beta jo without Any Cochin, Any privet Tutor Neet Exam me 454 marks mil ne k Baad kuch kar nehi pate. Dusra koi vi Education me jao to 10 lac ka niche koi baat nehi karte. Ab mera beta governments college me to jayenge, Magar Life me uska Doctor Ban ne ka sapna Aadhurai rahega.

[@mohammadabrar7813]

भारत में पढ़े और विदेश में पढ़े सभी स्टूडेंट्स का एक साथ स्क्रीनिंग टेस्ट हो, इससे पता चल जायेगा कहां कैसी पढ़ाई होती है।

[@uttarakhandwala8745]

Bahar see mbbs kiye students ko hamara samaj bhi farji samghta h ,

[@akshatv3539]

congratulations your vision has come to reality...🤣🤣🤣

[@moralstories8932]

Good

[@gauravshrivastava1185]

Mainly some points are absent to discuss 1. What about student from USA,AUS,CAN 2. Panalist dont have information that students need to do internship 3. Where the quality or standards goes when AYUSH are allowed to practice alopathy in rural area. 4. Students gets admission through donation in private colleges are match etical standards. If host watch my comment please think.

[@Infoappetite]

Gaurav Shrivastava FMGE is for every student pursuing medical outside India.AYUSH is for prescription only and not for surgeons( MBBS and MD must).And those who are pursuing MBBS from pvt college in India,there is also recommendations to take examination for pvt college students of India pending under National Medical commission)to prohibit these jhola chaap doctors. They are not credible anyway.

[@gauravshrivastava1185]

@@Infoappetite 1. How much i know MCI giving exeption for some country through an amendent bill. Please go through mci website. 2.The bill for IMG exit exam is pending for so many years. I also hope it will pending for more years or may not be passed due to strong apposition by strong loby. 3. ayush allowed to do allopathy in rural area by various way like 3 month training of pharma. I agree jhola chap should not be allowed but rules should be same for every one. We Fmge are indian citizen having similar right like any other. We need job of any type. We accept Fmge but Nbe should follow guideline of screening test given by court.

[@indianfact6862]

Bhai gaadhe or ghodo me fark hota h russia me jaakr russian padte rhte ho masti marte ho jara india me dekho kaise hoti h padai...anatomy tm log bina dissection k khtm kr dete h beakufo

[@neeraj1752]

Why the private medical college fees is more than fees of mbbs from china, russia etc., If the fees of private college will be less than ukraine college than why student go for foriegn mbbs degree.

[@sohailshaikh1334]

Chinese & Russian Health care infrastructure is way ahead than Indian..FMGE is not applicable to graduates coming from UK & USA.. So it seems clear that Our Government is helpless in front of Capitalist countries

[@indianfact6862]

Chutiye konsa nasha kiya h tune be....india ki mbbs ki padai russia china jaisi countries se kafi upr he be...yaha pr kaisi padai hoti h tu b aache se janta h vakil mt bn

[@sauravsingh661]

Fmge exam is exempted for graduates coming from US, UK , Canada, Australia and New Zealand. For UG and PG courses. It goes without saying that the level of training in these countries is quiet competent, so they are exempted. It's not about captilist country list, else why Germany, France etc are excluded. And BTW if it was about power, why is China kept out.

[@nobodybohra299]

@@indianfact6862 bro moo band kar or Jake na world ranking dek doodh ka doodh pani ka pani hojayaga... And I am not foreign graduate I have searched!

[@skg3877]

@@nobodybohra299 Haan bro China aur Russia ke University bohot upar ranking mein hain

[@abhisheksinghasia]

Aisa nahi hai Sohail Jee. India need more naturopath experts than made in Ukraine doctors because good balanced food, pure drinking water are prerequisite for all Indians. Once all most all of us starts eating a balanced diet and pure drinking water then need of doctors and Medicines will be minimal. We should have a naturopath in every family along with a professional education to make our country India developed. 🇮🇳🚩

[@drshahrukhqureshi]

Very good suggestion of clinical internship...it's must to fulfill no. of drs.

[@Alec_Smart]

In Europe the training is for 6 years. In India they are training for only 5 years. How can they boast of better clinical practice ? As usual the Indian public is just duped

[@nihal20066]

To India me NRI ko 250 num pr MBBS KYU MIL JATA HAIN

[@stethowalaofficial]

Bhai NRI ka seats nahi hai indian medical colleges me bro

[@dontbeconfused11]

@@stethowalaofficial tujhe kaun bola re pagal...15% NRI seats hai

[@adityamanu508]

kyuki nri 1 seat ke 2cr dete ha

[@navrojmbbs4012]

In future according to my thinking abroad students will be more preferred then local medical doctors

[@stethowalaofficial]

Kv ni hoga😂😂😂 Indian graduates are not only neet qualified... Indian MBBS student cuttoff v par krte hai 600+

[@ashudhamija7176]

StethoWala private clg and reservation students laughs 🤭

[@stethowalaofficial]

@@ashudhamija7176 I'm not telling about them 😁😅

[@AmarSingh-cf1wm]

Very excellent briefing of madam hearty thanks for this type of debate.

[@hohohoney6874]

The ability of students of bihar is more than of ones but most of students are interest of mathematics behide of reasons lack of good infrastructure, medical sits,hospital,teacher, the course of MBBS more costly not possible for comman student.

[@MMB-124]

Thank God I passed , no more FMGE struggle )

[@dr.shamsraza009]

Indian graduate doctor ka exam kyu nhi hota?bar bar fmge exam de ke thak chuka tha,aur aaj country chhod di hai maine,bna lo apne rule and regulation.

[@ashishbhensdadiya3078]

shams raza abhi kaha ho janab ?

[@9032479763]

Bhaijaan sahi kha paresan kar Diya aapne bhai aur sister ko

[@rajusoni9175]

🇮🇳 walo ne neet clear ki hoti h 😎

[@icefreezer9934]

Indian graduate doctor neet clear krte h

[@ravis.ajagalle188]

India wale mehnati h bhai

[@ompbeniwal8123]

राज्य सभा द्वारा प्रसारित हिंदी के सभी कार्यकर्मो को देखता हूं और बहुत ही ऐसी तरह से जानकारी देते है इसलिए धन्यवाद

[@maneeshshukla3805]

Kya foreign mbbs Vale ka lable jholachhap se bhi kam hai

[@adityamanu508]

teri skl dheak kr tho nhi lgta ki tu mbbs ka m bhi kr paayega

[@harishchandra7306]

One'- Those students have already passed NEET, should not require to pass further exam. Second - there is scarcity of the doctors in India, allow the foreign MBBS passed doctors to practice to discourage THELA CHHAP doctors in India. Third - set a eligibility exam papers with proper and relaxed syllabus. Fourth- Increase the seats in India. Fifth- Put these doctors in internship for at least 6-12 months in Govt's hospitals and make them eligible thereafter. Sixth- Intention of govt behind this is not feasible.

[@Nitisyu]

29:04 best question

[@varghesev.a.7628]

As the students are Indians, they will be practicing in India, so the students must have their Internship in India. India Govt. And NMC must try their best to help these students to complete their MBBS studies peacefully and for the benefit of all Indians. We can give the medical practice in India.

[@Parveen-id8in]

In India 90% people running Medical store just hiring Someone’s pharmacy License and they are practising without any experience. Why don’t take government action against them?

[@shivajiraoholkar5521]

John they are doing service to humanity which doctors don't do,this is the view of politicians and lay man and beurocrates.

[@abhisheksinghasia]

Praveen jee what if Indian do have a naturopath in every family so that a balanced diet and pure drinking water should not be compromised. Once most of Indians start drinking fresh potable water and atleast balanced diet the need for doctor and medicine will reduce drastically. Citizens will become happy and healthy after having balanced food (climate based) & potable water. 🇮🇳🚩

[@hermanustoppo352]

Good morning sir.shyam sir apka vichar achchha laga.

[@devrajgupta7199]

Why this FMC not for passouts from India. Students with less achievement also get entry while those with higher achievement are denied. Your policies are compelling them to look abroad and ultimately face humiliation. It's really pathetic. With the minimum qualifying marks everybody should get entry.

[@aparajitarath9240]

Salute madam.. app jaise logon keliye india me quality and standard barkarar hai

[@nivatrivedi2902]

Why private collage student are not giving fmge exam

[@Dr.GOWTHAM_EM]

Niva Trivedi for this question Indian government can go and hang them self 😂😂😂🙌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻good question

[@vaibhavkumar588]

Coz pvt collegs are Run by many Ministers money.if their Collge students cant able to pass this Exam..then next year no one wil join there Collge by paying Donation.Simple Logic *Niva

[@indianfact6862]

Because india me mbbs me padai hoti h faltu subjct nhi padae jate

[@nobodybohra299]

@@indianfact6862 faltu subjects? Jaisa aap pad k aaya h....🤣private college sucks...

[@nobodybohra299]

@@vaibhavkumar588 true

[@sunilkumartripathi8100]

We should have an exit exam for all government, private and foreign returns graduates. Then we can compare the quality of everyone. Since we have reservations we might get surprising results.

[@pratikj21]

Fmge exam is a Pg level exam with very difficult questions. All fmge graduates are discriminated in India and treated ruthlessly and mercilessly by these MCI people. If they want equality then keep an exit exam for all doctors in India government private and foreign graduate who want to practice in India 90% private doctors won't pass I am guaranteeing this

[@nobodybohra299]

True

[@geetikasingh7289]

Standard hi maintain karte rehna...log practice Karna chood denge... Medicine is not about Money,not about competition, yeh pooja h..bahut patience chahiye complete padhai Karne ke liye

[@dr_shine_the_medico2348]

Mci test htana chahi yr Jo middle family k bchche hote h wo foreign m ja k stdy krte h aur apna paisa lgate h phir jb waha se aate h to yaha practice nhi kr pate h Aur jo ameer h yhi private m pdh k bina mci k practice krte hv Ye to yhi hua Middle family wale ko preshan kro Aur ameer asaani se gareebo ko lut k aur ameer bno

[@snigdhachoudhury4860]

Very well explained.

[@srijangupta8367]

saare general category students ko foreign m rehna chaie kyuki india unka h hi nahi

[@MrThakur047]

Yes

[@pratibhashukla5212]

Bahut sahi

[@iniyon_77Vlog]

Bilkul shi bol rhe ho👍

[@ShibabrataChakraborty]

Where people are not getting any Medical facilities in our Village, dying without Medecine - some are pleading for quality, Just a Hippocratic example. Against Quota system many are getting degree , is that not compromiseing the Quality.

[@choudharysahildhanda6797]

Jo sc st dr bante h,, wha quality kha jati h madam,

[@nobodybohra299]

Sahi bhai

[@Meri-duniy]

Lge raho SC st me ......jisme aage bdne ka junun rhta hai ...wo SC st nhi krta..sirf apne km pe focus krta hai.....aur jha tk reservation ki bt hai iska Matlab ye nhi ki koi bhi SC st medical ki padhai ke liye gush Jaye..waha bhi aise bacche hi jate hai ...jinme kabiliyat hoti hai.jinko lgta hai ki wo ish feild me padhai kr skte hai..

[@videomemes9363]

@@Meri-duniy haha kya chomu aadmi ho bey? Mere st/sc dost ka 380 marks me admission ho gaya aur mera 587 me nhi hua...ab bol kaha gya talent? Ha?

[@SMN-kr7qj]

Brothers and sisters How can we increase our doctors????? 1) by introducing bridge course for foreign students both theory and practical and compulsory Internship 2) same for our BDS graduate in India 4) when BAMS BHUMS BHUMS DOCTORS are practicing and assisting in most of our hospitals then the Said DOCTORS are more deserving for fulfilling the shortage of DOCTORS Kindly take it in the larger interest of Nation .no negative comments please give better ideas

[@sonikaseth7897]

Entrance kabhi all india qualify nahi kiya isiye itni kamiya nikal rahe ki muskil hai ager app thik se pade hai to phir kyu ye ye ek min eligibility hai wo bhi ager app pass nahi ker pa rahe itna time lagaya it means u waste ur time cheat ur parents to please

[@Rajnishkumar12366]

Iska ek hi solution h ,, govn.. Jyada colleges banaye.. To ye possible h

[@zakirpm6988]

As per my experience our children going to study after attending NEET and the students is going to MCI approved Medical colleges if the college is not good then why MCI is approving this is not fair the studies it's far better than Indian Medical colleges

[@yadavinderyadav6918]

Aap chahe kahi se bhee ho. Lakin aap logo ki bhasa dekh kar bada bura laga ki aap future doctors ho

[@pramvirrathee1751]

Sirf june 2018 me ye 21% pahucha hai. qki usse pahle MCI chamcha tha private colleges ka. Usse pahle ye percentage 4% thi. Or jo 4% ise pass karte the wo 4 k 4% india me PG ki general seat b lelete the aram se. Lekin abhi abhi Mci ko dissolve kia gya to ye percentage 20% hui h. Good Step by Modi Government, Lets make bridge course also an option such that Indian public do not suffer. MCI ko dissolve karte hi, result 4% se 21% kaise ho gya. Aisa kya farq aagya siksha k satar me 6 mahino me.

[@rajadaimary4408]

Very informative

[@sagarkushwaha2370]

Dekh rahe hai log ki jo india main mbbs kar rahe hai wo kitna tez hai sarkary doctor ko injection dene nahi aata hai or bat kar kare hai india ke

[@basantmiri5773]

Kya aadmi hai tu India ko gali de Raha hai

[@AM-nx2iw]

@@basantmiri5773 usne india ki nhi bekar or jo nalayak fake doctors hai usko bola hai.

[@truthguidance6873]

😂😂😂vo apne bare m q bolega tbhi toh indian gov. K students ka mci nhi lete q ki unki awkaat pta chl jaygi

[@nocharan169]

Dr ko bahut sa alag kaam sarkar de deti hai....E v ek karan hai...

[@manaskumarhaldar2725]

One solution is to have qualifying examination for registration of all medical graduates. It is possible that many graduates from Indian medical colleges will fail.

[@subhojitsinha6810]

I think mam is talking that in foreign colleges.. The standard of education is not good.. But I want to say that in foreign countries.. Both foreign students and Indian students r studying together.. And after passing the xam they would be allowed to practice in that foreign country.. And I think no country will take unskilled doctors to practice with its country people.. So how is it that the countries like Ukraine, Russia etc has an low standard education.. If they r allowing to practice in their own country.. And why Indian govt. Is asking to give another xam.. Even when u r registered as a doctor in a well known country like Russia..

[@shreyajadhav4975]

yesss true,Indian govn didn't want students to study abroad

[@shreyajadhav4975]

@Kum Main True 💯

[@emmiraj]

Why this test is not required to the Indian medical graduates? Do you believe that they would qualify if they take this test? Experience comes by practice overtime whether a foreign or Indian student, then why the bias?

[@SukhjinderSingh-yl8sl]

It would be helpful to all concerned to introduce a level playing field for medical graduates willing to practice in the country today wether they have qualified from india/abroad this shall remove unnecessary bias ill will and heart burning amongst the young medical professionals

[@SukhjinderSingh-yl8sl]

There can be separate qualifying exams for graduates wishing to do private practice and post graduates(md/ms/mch)keen to do private practice and medical ethics cum epidemiology at research/teaching faculties

[@reshurolly]

Qualitaty ko badana hai to RESERVATION hatao ...

[@brijeshsinha9090]

Ha

[@Medicodoc-dn8dq]

Right

[@vijayworld7647]

Manuwadi sab ko bachho se yahi sikhaya jata hai ki har mudde par Representation (reservation) ko badanam karo yaha tak jab kisi ko pet dard bhi kare to bhi representation ko koso.

[@harishjakhar7906]

Right

[@sudamarajbanshi263]

lets MCI screening test for all indian and foreign students should be compulsory....NEET for eligibility ok

[@Its_alam791]

Indian students ko bhi dena chahiye..xm

[@wahib786]

Thanks for this debate

[@csingh681]

Quality"" what happens when student get seat through diff Quotas ? Help for Rich student 1cr donation --BETA AAP SABKO MCI KI JEB BHARNI HOGI

[@nobodybohra299]

GREAT GREAT comment!

[@Grad7te___gupta_]

सर जो एमबीबीएस भारत में किए हैं उनके लिए भी एग्जिट एग्जाम, विदेशी बच्चों के साथ होना चाहिए पेपर सेम होना चाहिए

[@anitachaudhary1979-l8m]

Sir plz have ye puchhna h ki jinke pass money unke bachhe 130 marks par mbbs mil jaata h lekin Jo 500 marks laate h n money ki kami se baar baar preparation karte rahte h .gov private ki fees Kam kyon nhi karti

[@mr.r.p6821]

Indian aur Foren Mbbs students dono logo se MCI test liya jaay Tabhi Gudwatta dikhegi !

[@SandeepSingh-jm9dm]

to tum neet crack krke foreign jao

[@sameermathur8991]

WHY FMG'S COME TO INDIA AFTER TOILING SO HARD THEY SHOULD GO FOR OTHER COUNTRIES , INDIA IS A COUNTRY FOR RESERVED PEOPLE AND YOU WILL STRUGGLE HERE TO PASS THESE SO CALLED COMPETITIVE EXAMS , HEALTHCARE SYSTEM IS IN ABYSMAL CONDITION HERE BUT THEY WONT ALLOW YOU TO PRACTICE AND IF YOU ARE FROM GENERAL CATEGORY THEN GOD WILL SAVE YOU.

[@shivaniphalle5676]

plz even have a conversations on topic..of tranfer..student.!! why student who study in foreign country cannot give mci exam if they take transfer..??

[@duniyaathome]

The quality of reserved catagory doctors in India who pass with very less percentage are also dangerous for human lives. So please reconsider the reservation. 🙏🏼 Also while registering please mention the reserved categories in registration. 🙏🏼

[@kgunasekaran1527]

Time to abolish NEET n make education as a state subject. Also open more med colleges in India.

[@manishgalchar7256]

Just ask them to apply for mbbs final examination with Indian students, those who have already completed the mbbs abroad, why this pg level questions of fmge, and secondly if the MCI has already recognised the universities in abroad, then why are now their questioning their abilities and teaching, Indian education system is corrupt and useless. Just complete mbbs wherever you want and try to settle and practice over there itself, nothing is here in India, even after 100 years, India is not going to change, bcoz this system creates corruption and it has no end.

[@gyaneshwarjagadale8716]

SIR.JI.RAM.RAM YOUR SUB VERY GOOD. THREE..MEMBERS TOLD. 1OO%.RIGHT. THANKS JAY.HIND 👍👌🌹🙏🏻🇮🇳

[@praveenupadhyay.]

I think once one debate should be on engineering .

[@ShyamSunder-vx9hb]

For admission in medical colleges there should not be any quota system in regard to SC ,ST and OBc

[@Roorkeepigeonfarm]

Bharat sarkar bilkul sahi karrahi hai videsi doctor ke sath ye supreme court ka bilkul sahi kadam hai videsh me padhai kar ke doctor banne se achha hai jholachap Dr banna hindustan zindabad supreme court zindabad...

[@shazisuccessstatus1115]

Sir mbbs ke lye phle to itni zyda fees krdi aur ek par ek rules doctr ki hi kami hgi aur age 25 se zyda hgi to admsn nh hgi yahisb hoga sir

[@BhannatEnglishKatta]

Really nice topic

[@avinashminhass5459]

mam my brother is doing PG in pediatrics in your esteemed institution. He has graduated from St Petersburg in Russia.

[@patelnila1310]

Araksan me kabil Dr melege?

[@BJPdarkhistoryINDIA]

USA ma bhi AIIMS ke graduates ko USMLE dena hota ha, jab ki yeh graduates india ke best hain

[@saurabhtripathi7442]

AIIMS stands no where in the world....

[@nishudoctor3910]

dear u r foreign students to them nd u r going on another country ..nd we r coming to our own country ..

[@gautamclasses7753]

Best knowledge about FMGE debate.

[@drshahrukhqureshi]

BAMS ✓ BEMS ✓ D PHARMA ✓ JHOLACHHAAP ✓ BRIDGE COURSE ✓ FOREIGN DOCTORS X

[@pratyushmishra7299]

Pata chal gaya tum gadhe ho kyunki actual figures nahi pata hain.Pehli baat ab wahan 300 or 250 plus wale bache zyada ja rahe hain aur dusra jitne students yahan se mbbs pass karte hain utne hi students bahr se mci clear kar ke aate hain aur bams bhms aur private medical colleges ke students ka comparison to foreign medical graduates se karna bhi mat.India mein 60 percent students ek ya do backlog ke saath hi mbbs pass kar pate hain aur bahar 90 percent mbbs bina fail huye pass karte hain jisme 70 percent mci exam clear karte hain in first attempt jo data website par hain wo aj se 5-6 saal pehle ke hain bahar ki countries specially Ukraine ya koi bhi European country India se jyada advanced technology aur facilities provide karati hain bina kisi donation ke.Hope you have got my point.

[@vijendersingh2023]

I heard this discussion carefully that the FMGE is theoretical test ,it does does give the skill guarantee of the doctors that they are fit and suitable for practice as there is no provision to judge their practical & clinical skill. So it is as same as passing the neet minimum percentage , need to reconsider .

[@lovanshusingh3448]

There should be Strict action against Jholachap Doctor's

[@shekharkumar9365]

FMGE it is difficult to score above 50 but easy to score around 40 ..... as the candidate/viewer has stated that some candidates are failing to score 50% but get as close to 49% or so .... the issue of grace marks subject to performance in previous attempts must be considered to clear such candidates