Saving Citarum: Indonesia's Fight To Clean 'Dirtiest River In The World' | Once Upon A River

The Citarum River is dubbed as the dirtiest river in the world. Majalaya's factories have dumped roughly 280 tons of chemical waste into this critical waterbody every day. Despite its dilapidated condition, its waters irrigate farmlands which feed 30 million people across West Java. This is why the Indonesian government is trying to save the Citarum.
We embed with the Indonesian military on Operation Citarum Harum, a multi-million dollar cleanup operation that aims to transform this 270 kilometer long river back to its former glory. On this journey, we film with environmental activists on the frontlines fighting against illegal chemical discharge in their bid to reverse damage to the region's ecology.
In this battle to balance economic development and impending climate change, we discover factory owners investing in the future of sustainable waste disposal and individuals using artificial intelligence to save the Citarum.
Continue watching Once Upon A River: • Once Upon A River | Fu...
=======
About Once Upon A River: In this three-part series, we discover historical ties between communities and with some of the most critical waterways in Asia.
==============
#CNAInsider #OnceUponARiverCNA #Asia #Indonesia #Citarum
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider

[@destianfamas2456]

"It's just 1 plastic" said by 25 million people

[@Mysterious_Person.87]

its not just 25 milions people said. But it said by 1 bilion people said that

[@vorzagaming3230]

Yo this is gonna never ending if u guys keep talking wkwkwkk

[@destianfamas2456]

@@vorzagaming3230 i'm not talking anymore u dumbprick wkwk

[@siegfried2k4]

@@destianfamas2456 Why are you so pressed lmao

[@yejerncha2136]

Yes indeed 😭😯

[@samsummer3847]

Congratulations Indonesia. Good luck. Nothing is impossible. Time to proof what other people said was wrong. From the dirtiest river into the clean river. InshaAllah. From Malaysia.

[@quddussalam8593]

Thanks :)

[@altamisamzar3304]

Thx

[@littleoctopus2520]

Ty Malaysiaa uwu

[@dariuswhat6622]

Thx

[@hanantyofiradiputro107]

Thx

[@farhysthunterz6654]

The effort of restoration the ecosystem need to be recognized...i watching this matter since 3 years ago and glad for the update.. congratulations indonesia for making this happened...still not too late...salam dari malaysia

[@khairulammar6056]

same i watched it also....glad their effort gets picked up by others. salam dari Malaysia jugak.

[@LaoSoftware]

Malaysia and Indonesia need to save the planet. Need to work together and clean up the pollution. Closed the factories. We need clean water, clean air, and clean soil.

[@yoeltogarmikael3278]

@@LaoSoftware close factories? Which one should we closed?

[@HoshikawaHikari]

Yay fellow Malaysian~

[@yejerncha2136]

@tommy aronson yes can confirm am Malaysian

[@yoeltogarmikael3278]

Indonesian government probably need to be more strict about building houses and factories near the river

[@yoeltogarmikael3278]

@borray s yeah that can work too

[@rizkykurniawansolihin5807]

The govt. Doesn't care at all, they just care about investment

[@yoeltogarmikael3278]

@@rizkykurniawansolihin5807 no they not the citarum harum program is on progress everything by the way why do you hate investments so much? you dont like peoples to work more?

[@rizkykurniawansolihin5807]

@@yoeltogarmikael3278 of course no, but the investment that the govt did, doesnt care about nature.

[@yoeltogarmikael3278]

@@rizkykurniawansolihin5807 which investment?

[@landove1486]

Kudos to Indonesia. The only country in this series of "Dirtiest River" that actually does something. I can see significant improvement from last documentary few years back.

[@gaestroorly4668]

What about other countries?

[@shadowblitzo123]

India said that about the ganges river. Look at it now. Indonesia will still be unproductive.about it and will be even dirtier than the ganges river

[@10klikeanonimbalikwxc14]

@@shadowblitzo123 ganges is way dirtier, it's literally black color documentary in 2014 (7 years ago) that titled "world dirtiest river" is usual clickbait title without actual research

[@thegreatneess]

@@10klikeanonimbalikwxc14 there is one did by vice news 2 years ago "India Wants To Use Flesh Eating Turtles To Rid The Ganges Of Decomposing Bodies"

[@ruizsyajudha5994]

@@shadowblitzo123 did you even watch the whole video?

[@FajrulMutaqin]

it's better late than never, we have a long way to go, Indonesia. Water waste management, garbage handling and recycling, law enforcement and our society awareness. Keep on the track!

[@wahyuningsih6828]

Nanti ganti presiden jg gitu lg

[@yovi234]

efek generasi milenial skrng yg mulai sadar lingkungan jg sih..buang sampah / limbah di sungai jd big NO isu..apalagi skrng plastik mulai dilarang.. Membangun bs tanpa merusak..

[@rosemangofairy]

My boss was involved in this project, and she invited me to a meeting with the military groups. They were absolutely incredible. Super organised, efficient and took their jobs extremely serious. The military's involvement was absolutely needed here, as it was also a business/corporate mafia problem. It wasn't just a technical, "let's clean up the river" problem. This is what happens in a lot of development/sustainability projects. Large corporations (foreign or domestic) come into under-developed areas, pollute and bully the locals into secrecy.

[@ordyhorizonrivieredunord712]

Same here, we had to write in the papers and awake the people before anythig was done and myself and others have unceasingly worked to clean up our rivers and many industrial plants had to be dismantled. There is still a lot to be done yet we have seen some improvement as the fish has started to come back. 🌹

[@ordyhorizonrivieredunord712]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/baWbfI1tmLmZo80 🦝

[@happyface96]

The big business have the mafia, but the governments got the army😂

[@taen6917]

Wow in Indonesia the military makes a project to clean the river😳😳😳 . While in the west and Africa , our military is program to shoot us an protect politician . I’m proud of you Indonesia

[@itstirta5005]

Yes and they not only join clean the river They are join to when indonesia get the disaster (earthquake, flooding, etc.) The military have so many respect from our people

[@gaestroorly4668]

They also build roads in my village. And sometimes they also shoot the civilian in Papua

[@mataratriaglanie3660]

@@gaestroorly4668 they are not civilian if they carry a loot of gun

[@taen6917]

Two things will happen to our military in Africa . 1) it’s Very interesting here in Cameroon we only see the military when the president has lose an election 😂😂😂😂😂 . when we protest for basic needs and looting a bar or beer company to get all the alcohol during peaceful protest. 2) We won’t see the military During disasters like earthquakes, bush fire , Insect and paste attacks on farmers . Or fighting rebels , ooh everyone in the military either has stomach problems , their homes also got hit so helping their families . 🙄🙄🙄🙄 The military trucks will be out of gas till the disaster is over 😂😂😂.

[@gaestroorly4668]

@@taen6917 I'm surprised 🙀🙀🙀

[@MB-wc7dr]

Hello from Canada. I have watched various documentaries regarding the Citarum River. Kudos to the Indonesian government for taking action.

[@MB-wc7dr]

@Ordinary Citizen You should write to the Canadian government, not me.

[@MB-wc7dr]

@Ordinary Citizen I knew that you were not a Canadian. I did not vote for Justin Trudeau. But if you want to make the Canadian government listen, then you should be writing en masse to them. His email is [e-mail]. This email goes to his office staff.

[@R.U.1.2.]

@@MB-wc7drSo you're the usual disgruntled Canadian, but who are you talking to?

[@aveplant8363]

@@R.U.1.2. Someone who deleted their comment due to embarassment

[@R.U.1.2.]

@@aveplant8363Because it's a BS. argument with you speaking with a lack of knowledge and, an authority you don't possess. Not worth my time, no further discussion, troll someone else if you want to have sophomoric fun.

[@HERYId]

today the Citarum River is better with a light level of pollution, the "Citarum Harum" program since 2018 has changed the river for the better, the Citarum water quality index value in 2020 is 55 and the standard for water quality is 70

[@javadwipa5184]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4apooWZd8uroMU

[@javadwipa5184]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/paDQn4mqlsmnZ7s

[@javadwipa5184]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4Ovi2Z7f712m8k

[@smolgok384]

Great

[@sideecm]

very impressed with the naga people. Good job Indonesia

[@sferris33]

All countries need to follow Indonesia example to clean up our environments. All countries, govts, military, police, etc need to work on improving our environments.

[@pauloemmi6216]

Doesn't last long before the corrupt officials fill their personal pockets and don't bother cleaning rivers or looking after environment.

[@brianroche8860]

go indonesia never gave up.. love from your brothers philippines

[@bukancalonpns]

The current governor is an avid architect who study in the States, not like the previous governor that try to make his oligarchy but failed.

[@sidvicious7452]

Ridwan Kamil is the best

[@sommervillem1069]

yep,he graduated from Berkeley, California,one of US Top University

[@andrewj3177]

Glad he got elected He isn't perfect, but was the best from all candidates

[@truthseeker1934]

I just wished he didn't ride the religious wave.

[@sommervillem1069]

@@malakatan3235 proof?

[@dianardiansyah7708]

The journey to cleaning up the river hasn't completed yet, but progress indeed has been made.

[@rehanfauzan4623]

the main source of pollution on this river is not actually trash since mostly now already cleaned up but the waste from its surrounding textile industries. the government now enforces strict regulation to tackle this issue, the problem is, not every factory can afford expensive water treatment plant, so i think by giving them subsidy will accelerate the healing of this river.

[@Lifeisgoodbelieve1in3]

I think the owners of the clothing industry need to pay for the capacity to clean the water

[@AshrakAhmed]

Why not have one govt own plant to handle all the smaller factory who can't afford their own waste water treatment plant. the smaller factory gets charge a low set fee based on volume of waste for the clean up. and by everyone making some contribution, the whole cost don't just settle on tax payers and at the same time small factories can compete on cost of production

[@patdaly6644]

Amazingly scary to see the amount of pollution these poor people have to deal with every day. Thank you to everyone who are making their lives safer. Thank you for sharing Geraldine England

[@andrewj3177]

So that why the river is cleaner when i bypass it, the effort works, at least for visible pollutant Bravo TNI

[@LaowaiDaveJCP]

"citarum: the dirties river on planet" Ganges: Hold my naked babaji

[@zakb7418]

i see the title so dramatic

[@kafiamadeus7351]

As an indonesian i think we need more of this kind of work. Not only on rivers but every aspects like roads, villages, cities, etc.

[@nickkassam319]

Great to involve military soldiers to fix the issues with the locals...it is more than time to act boldly with less talks and more actions

[@mitamitamaharanibahria8573]

I'm a local villagers near majalaya, and yes, those textile industries majority just dump their waste water without any treatment to the river, as for the rubbish People used to throw it to the river or just dump it on the roadsides because they don't have any choice, our government doesn't give any facility for us where we can throw our rubbish Especially the Kabupaten Bandung region. And last year there's another international media already shown to the world how worst the citarum condition at that time, and also how the kids DNA already polluted. Please world, see our river, and help us, help our kids.

[@faturr]

there's no landfills nearby? i live in rural areas in Semarang, there's some young guy that collect trash from home to home every 3 days then they sent to, my family would separate the trash from wet trash, and plastics that burnable. It's just cost 5K, we're very helpfull by that. while papers and glasses we sell to collectors who come once a month.

[@ahyarhartanto1802]

@@faturr in west java, it's totally different, no one is hired to collect the rubbish, that's why don't be shocked to know that even in rural area in west java the river is full of rubbish. coming from me who own a house in bandung rural area, the river across my house is full of rubbish as my neighbour throw their rubbish right into the river 🤦

[@faturr]

@@ahyarhartanto1802 no, those young guys not working for government, they're self employed. but they got a way to making money by that.

[@ahyarhartanto1802]

@@faturr did I say something about "they work for the government" ? if you pay them it means you hire them as simple as that lol 🤦

[@faturr]

@@ahyarhartanto1802 oh, pardon. 😂😂

[@bellascythe9594]

Proud for Indonesian all of the elements working.

[@premman6052]

tentara yang sudah bekerja keras untuk membersihkan sungai kotor, kemudian di persenjatai untuk menembak orang2 yang mengotori sungai tsb, sehingga sampah masyarakat bisa berkurang. salut TNI, anda adalah pahlawan sejati, sudah di latih perang malah di suruh kecebur ke sungai yang kotor, semoga pemerintah bayar pemebersihan sungai ini di luar gaji dinas tentara.

[@farisasmith7109]

Wow, those soldiers are exposing themselves to lord knows what in that water with no protection. I applaud their commitment though.

[@zaarkhananal7165]

I was horrified when I first learned about this, especially because people were still utilizing that water, but it's great that there are some people who are fighting back. I was really pleased to learn about the wax worms, I'd never heard of them before. I'm going to have to do more research on those little critters.

[@elgrz2214]

Thanks CNA INSIDER 👍 Fair enough documentation to describe the solution that occurred in the Citarum river. The best documentation of the Citarum river I have ever watched

[@agengwib]

Gak bisa basa ingress:v

[@topz8196]

@@agengwib study bro, don't forget to practice 😁

[@xoxo.000]

Bravo bapak-bapak TNI dan semua pihak yang terlibat dalam Citarum harum. Saya sangat respek ❤️❤️🔥🔥

[@jabrique]

The problem is that we still throw garbage to the river system.. even when i drive down passing a bridge over a river there will be a car or motorcycle stopping by and throw a bag of rubbish to the river... it is sad that we still have this mindset of, " i only throw one bag, and the others still doing it so, so it doesn't matter." We should ponder more about our river system for our future children...

[@quddussalam8593]

Kebiasaan orang indo sebenarnya, Mikirnya itu kayak kalo udah dibuang sampahnya bukan masalah dia lagi, Menghilang aja masalahnya bukan dia yang bertanggung jawab, Nanti jadi masalah orang. Miris sebenarnya itu bukti Indonesia masih di beberapa tempat underdeveloped sekali

[@quddussalam8593]

Tapi juga itu karena infrastruktur untuk pembuangan sampah itu di wilayah sungai itu gk ada. Yang ada sampah dibakar atau dibuang (Sendiri), Nah masyarakat mengira bahwa sungai itu tempat sampah. Miris

[@quddussalam8593]

@borray sXD Wonderful Indonesia

[@kidwolf0015]

It's not just you guys. For whatever reason, people love throwing sharp broken cans, entire water bottles, broken balloons, cigarettes butts and boxes, broken toys, and other trash in my yard! I'm pretty sure that they litterally *don't even realize* that they're doing it. I'm constantly secretly cleaning it up. Yeah, some people in the US care so little about littering that they litterally pollute the yards of people that they visit with sharp potentially rusty medal can scrapes! And I have no protection against tetanus, due to a somewhat compromised immune system with a bad history of contracting disease from vaccines so it's even more messed up. (While it's fairly rare, such conditions do exist.) I've been secretly composting the coffee grinds, egg shells, non-dyed paper that had no exposure to cleaning chemicals, and paper towel rolls. To be fair, the entire family already uses old fruit and vegetable scrapes for our plants. I feel like most of the trash comes from guests...

[@itzme.7389]

File a case on that fool

[@reynanteapas5416]

Hoping that this documentaries awake to the indonesian, so That one day their livelihood that mostly depend on well restore..

[@liongkienfai104]

2:08 Citarum isn't even in the top 10 longest rivers in Indonesia. 3rd longest river in Indonesia is Mahakam in East Kalimantan province. 38:38 Sundanese people, not Javanese.

[@Pfyzer]

Javanese as in Island, rather than the ethnics

[@GabrielDipo]

@@Pfyzer noo no no we don't do that here

[@diazalbn]

@@Pfyzer i'm sundanese myself, even tho we're living in java island we're not called javanese, 'some' people could be offended if it's happen btw

[@hectoristoomuch]

@@Pfyzer the island is called java,javanese is the people that live in it,and not even everyone is javanese there is a lot of tribes and cultures still here ini java

[@deluca333]

@@Pfyzer yeah, u're right.

[@yenawirahma1597]

2:10, correction not the Third Longest River in the Country, but Third Longest River in Java. Source: Wikipedia, and I'm an Indonesian.

[@itzme.7389]

Yeah

[@redwanrizvi]

Military taking part in clean up of river. We want this to become reality in Bangladesh also, specially for Buriganga rive.

[@december1720]

westren people blame indonesia, meanwhile all big brand are participate in the factory are from the western. irony

[@jinoz8560]

Dont just make a claim, where is your evidence?

[@december1720]

@@jinoz8560 kzbin.info/www/bejne/fXargJ-jmK90e80 haha watch this entire documentary

[@jinoz8560]

@@december1720 Thank you for the video link. So mainly these polluting textile companies are subcontractors to the big brands like H&M (sweden), Uniqlo (Japan),etc2. If the big brands just pulled out of Indonesia, they will find other subcontractors from other counties which will decrease of employment in textile Indonesia industries. However, the blames are not entirely to these companies. From the government, the companies, the workers, factories owners, all need a reform and law to be re-enforced. It is not an easy case.

[@december1720]

@@jinoz8560 glad you brought this up. I don't blame western companies completely, I understand how the regulations are. But when it comes to environmental damage, especially in developing countries, western people tend to judge the country badly without seeing that the clothes they wear everyday contribute to environmental damage. This is also the same as the news about deforestation in Borneo because the people are planting oil palm. whereas all the ingredients they consume at Wallmart or other supermarkets all contain palm oil. this part why i say irony

[@flowdog6585]

@@jinoz8560 hahahaha both of you are respecting each other opinion

[@crikey1mate]

That’s so strange they used the military to improve the quality of life, these Indonesians have some wacky ideas! - Americans

[@JarHabar]

thank you for the kindness

[@elang1702]

Ikr, what an alien way of utilizing the military

[@karenmatthews5764]

Bless the people who are saving the environment!

[@AustinsAwesomeAdventures]

What's amazing about today's internet is that problems other countries and states have are being televised and shown on social media such as this so other can help the needy. This is sad to watch because it affects the people living there. Im glad the problem here is being addressed 👍

[@kanazef]

During this pandemic, the central government and west java government keep continue to work on the normalization of the Citarum River. Thank you for government effort, Nothing is impossible if there is political will. 💕💕💕 ✔

[@doomolit]

Cleaning the river is only part of the solution, the bigger task is to establish a sustainable integrated waste management system by the local and municipality government. The problem in Indonesia is that there are no coordinated effort in establishing waste management system, as people do not have or little environmental awareness... good first step, still long way to go..

[@punjabiplus3194]

Excellent documentary!

[@lividfont8714]

It's nice to see people are taking this serious. Good for you Indo.

[@btssoul6714]

Good that they finally open their eyes to the importance of clean water & not just on the profits that those factories make

[@akmalfaiz7094]

That Naga tribe place looks breathtaking 🤩

[@yearsago-wk2iu]

Naga tribe in India too

[@HoshikawaHikari]

Instead of just words in class, schools should play documentaries like these in class~ Words alone won’t do anything especially when the education system is not focused on passing on knowledge but scoring in tests, things need to change~

[@gemamoch1]

Happiness Project: whoever feels happy, they donates a tree to be planted. Birthday person donates 1 tree, married person donates 10 trees.. Good idea.

[@itzme.7389]

Great idea but in india there so less place These idiots keep building homes by cutting forests even when not needed this needs to be stopped people should start living together

[@simsgazytech2013]

As indonesian who can't do anything with our country bad waste management.. all I can do such as minimalize using plastic and segregate waste. Only this

[@evanraymond8728]

One of the reasons to be proud of my country ❤️💪

[@joehannes1822]

Ayo semangat warga jakarta,bisa mulai dari sekarang rubah kebiasaan,jangan buang sampah sembarangan,sungai citarum itu cantik kalau bersih dan bisa jadi objek wisata,bgi yg sering jalan” ke luar negri pasti iri liat sungai di tengah kota yg bersih: contoh kota Melbourne

[@rinohermansyah7937]

Citarum jauh dari Jakarta..

[@diramoti7490]

semua cuma ngomong doang.. mending diam kasih contoh

[@aziz_budiarto7997]

Bandung waee

[@joharitalib4247]

Wonderful Indonesia.....attract million of tourists

[@mythvagrant]

Good Job Shehzad Hameed

[@mfaisalfachrur3701]

Keep it up the good work

[@dustinbail5797]

If my country successful in cleaning our river indonesia can do it too love from the Philippines 🤗💖🇵🇭 Edit: Dec 12,2021 - eyyy guys why arguing lol haha 🤭

[@xyopiRIFx]

Yes, our country needs to learn more from your country in cleaning rivers. You have done a great job

[@ssrlly]

India needs to learn from Indonesia and clean the Ganges

[@shiraaichan4276]

That's so sweet of you

[@ghtrl8]

Even Pasing River is still polluted.. I mean it is best for us to learn fron Japan hahaha

[@thelord5223]

We learn to Japan not Philippines ... Sorry to say

[@TeamPhilippines]

The Government should build Water Treatment Facilities.

[@noddrey]

Went to Indonesia year 2017 on a cruise. Oh my😱 floating garbage greeted us when we arrived at the port of Java. Indonesian government should do something about it. Educate locals to be more responsible and participate actively on cleaning the environment. But udos to these man in uniforms who fight and cleanup this river. Hope everyone will follow

[@nabeel9782]

The government already educated, but the people here doesn't really care (maybe because there is no consequences)

[@brendatenorio5721]

Hats off to Alex, the manufacturer with a conscience n good business sense, the environmental groups, the monitors, military groups patrolling the rivers, country's leader for recognizing the urgency, scientists studying pollution impact n international organizations for funding. Environmental resurrection means humans must develop a respect for its environment, it's botanical n marine life as well as its terrestrial wildlife populations which no one mentioned except once in this entire series.

[@alexsantoso885]

Thanks Brenda 😊

[@khairulammar6056]

i love the narrator voice...really suit for the kind of an investigation documentary

[@mind9528]

Everyone should be educated about waste

[@azkahaitami4666]

yesss

[@Querenciatv]

Thanks for Sharing ❤️&✌️

[@moopmeep5094]

Aku orang malaysia percaya dengan orang Indonesia 💪 ayuh .

[@fahamifamami51]

Kamu pecaya, kamu mampus

[@llhiejen]

Clearly 1 of the BEST Documentary I saw in years. - Just a suggestion for Indonesian Government those Factories that cannot afford to install Water Treatment Facility, maybe the Indonesian Government can build a Common Water Treatment Plant to where All this Factories can tapp-in, they can charge them if they want for the Operational cost. with this the government can now make sure that All waters that will be drained on the river will be by government standard. - Another thing maybe the Government can purchase those Long Reach Amphibious Excavators that they can used to dredge the river. the 1 I saw on the video is too small base on the interview they say it can only reach up to 3 meters. they can used this machinery not only on this river but all rivers in Indonesia. "Go go Indonesian show the world that you can do this clean-up those rivers." - from your brother Filipino.

[@brianaucuba230]

Many reasons to hope for the future of the Citarum and other ecosystems like it. Best wishes for all the efforts in the video.

[@psilu4473]

It's nice the government is finally backing the grass roots organizations! Very exemplary ❤

[@cattogirl]

i'm from Karawang, west java. btw idk about Naga village, it looks very beautiful and clean in there

[@quddussalam8593]

Nanti yeh tahun 2025 Kalau beneran Citarum dah layak minum, Boleh lah Kita Ngebacot ke dunia "Ini loh sungai Terkotor didunia Udah Layak minum!" Gitu, Sekarang nih ye Masih kotor Bersihkan dulu

[@senjahari8941]

Jgn nuntut kalo lu ga bisa berbuat apa2

[@quddussalam8593]

@@senjahari8941 Siapa yg nuntut bunjang?, Oh mungkin lu ngira Comment gw kayak pesimis ya?, Gak kok malah gw dukung parah, Why not gitu ya kan Sungai terkotor bakalan bersih

[@funkystuf23]

Stuff like this should be shown on prime time television globally, it’s beyond shocking

[@jrsolomon5960]

Indonesia...good job- from malaysia, your neighbour.

[@JohnSmith-bz9be]

Well done. Good documentary

[@nathannataatmadja3349]

It is good finally they clean it, but it is useless if the people (or industries) who live near by actually the ones that caused the problem.

[@diramoti7490]

They need to relocating those industries..

[@mortysmith666]

This is great video

[@DeihanDzilky]

_ORANG INDONÉSIA KALAU UDAH BISA BAHASA INGGRIS, BAGUS BANGET AKSENNYA JELAS!!!_ 👌🏻😎👍🏻

[@altamisamzar3304]

Itu yang ngomong bahasa inggris bukan orang indo itu naratornya dari uk kalo gaksalah 🙄

[@DeihanDzilky]

@@altamisamzar3304 bukan dubber nya, tapi orang Indo yg di wawancarai yg ngomong paké bahasa Inggris, bagus banget bahasa Inggris nya...

[@fancyacuppa8377]

@@altamisamzar3304 hmm...bau bau anak dari gen z nih :v

[@uwon1211]

FYI lidah orang Indonesia paling fleksibel didunia dalam pengucapan bahasa asing

[@DeihanDzilky]

@@uwon1211 *_Yup betul!!!_* 👍🏻

[@tinaalbertina8371]

Keep on track to do more and keep clean. Do not throw rubbish everywhere.. Love you ecosystem

[@gajahmada4847]

Citarum still long journey to paradise river

[@paulclement4860]

The awareness of the Indonesian people is still low in littering in rivers so that it pollutes the environment and can cause flooding in the rainy season

[@igehdyt603]

media singapur ini bagus banget. Komprehensif bgt pembahasaanya

[@endtimeslips4660]

this people will be blessed for spend their time for many people guarding river from evil factory

[@indomie.seedap]

Ayo citarum contoh surabaya... ana dari malang dulu tiap kesurabaya selalu ngerasain perbedaan dimana malang bener2 ijo sungainya bersih ngga ada bau, terus kesurabaya bau sungainya ngga ketulungan.. tapi selepas kepemimpinan bu risma surabaya sekarang ga hanya ja kota ijo tapi juga kota termaju dan terbersih diindonesia, kalau surabaya saja bisa mengubah dari keadaan terendah ketertinggi dengan dukungan pemerintah dan kesadaran masyarakat itu sendiri pasti citarum akan bisa juga merubah wajah jawa barat semakin meningkat.... les go my fellow !!!

[@karlaldrichacelar1300]

Thanks for beating pasig river!

[@yudhiarma]

Oknum penegak hukum tampaknya membiarkan pelanggar hukum demi pundi pundi uang

[@YeahAkka]

We’re still having some problems: • Access to landfill, Some people don’t have the access to the landfills. Here we have to pay for it. Some people don’t even have money to fulfil their needed, let alone to pay for their garbages. So they tend to throw away their garbage to the river or burning it. Garbage bank is a good idea, but it’s hard to find them. • Education, people start to throw away their garbage to its places BUT they forget to teach their kids about it. I’m so upset about it because it’s happening in my neighborhood. I clean up the ditches around my house regularly and i find kids snack packs, ice cream packs etc everytime. • Household wastewater, it’s also my biggest problem. Unlike the developed countries which have sewerage systems, our wastewater goes straight to the river. Building sewerage systems for the whole country will be so expensive for the government and we won’t see it in anytime soon. I have a plan to build my own wastewater management system.

[@malsixa.]

thank you

[@artificialanimeuniverse5063]

Congratulations 🎉 We gotta do this in the entire world

[@edwinsuryakurniawan4313]

i live in majalaya, and thats the fact. Honestly i shame and mad about that. Because many foreign industries around here, and that pollute the river.

[@folkeholmberg3519]

For a more reliable survey about the Citarum River I strongly recommend Deutche Welle's "The Cost Of Fast Fashion", despite it's a few years older.

[@akbaer60]

I love the way the narrator says citarum: cheetərəm

[@anyun123]

So proud 👍👍

[@Tammissa]

The western countries need to learn from nature. Back to basics.

[@robertkertoikromo8643]

first step is taken.. and now go to work and protect

[@naximbliss8045]

Untung masih ada yg percaya ama leluhur, setidaknya ada yg berpikir bahwa kita juga harus serasi dengan alam. Alias nggak mikirin akhirat aja 🙂

[@youcanpunchmeintheface]

betul, walaupun orang2 mikir kita cuma "numpang" di dunia ini, tapi ga ada salahnya membuat bumi jadi tempat yang lebih nyaman buat penerus kita

[@naximbliss8045]

@@youcanpunchmeintheface iya, Tapi dari sitkon yg aku lihat saat ini, rata2 orang malah lebih banyak memikirkan akhiratnya dan seperti berpaling bagaimana biar bumi itu juga nyaman dan aman buat ditinggali. Bukan malah saling tengkar mulu cuma gara2 agama, sampek2 ada pertumpahan darah. Yaampun

[@Faktaalamsemesta90]

@@naximbliss8045 mayoritas biasa ...

[@periawan8586]

Sok tau goblok

[@naximbliss8045]

@@periawan8586 yg goblok biasanya yg gk punya atitude seperti anda

[@user-wp9ye7wn9w]

Yesterday, I saw the news update. Now, the fish robot! That'll be clean or eat of micro plastic and help us to the ocean in the future 🙂

[@edgarquines6018]

Just like our Pasig River you can revive Citarum Just involve all stakehoder Eventually the river will be back to its good condition Its a concerted efforts for all brothers Indonesian Allah bless all of you From your Filipino brother You can do it INDONESIA,

[@agusti_zainal0445]

Limbah sampah industri.limbah sampah rumah tangga...dijabodetabek... thanks you #TNImilitary selalu membantu rakyat n pemerintah dlm mengatasi Masalah2 di negri ini

[@livdirrengesuasmatsuoka9843]

THESE PEOPLE ARE HEROES. ❤👍👍

[@JuraganEmas]

4:40 any Indonesian know what instrument that guy used? And how the instrument operate?

[@chimergo6501]

Jaw harp aka Karinding

[@ytube.agusss]

It's called Karinding

[@senjahari8941]

Andy sunarto kirain bule

[@Papabogs1020]

Citarum river can be restored . I believe in it cause Pasig river here in the Philippines was once already a dead river.... through government efforts, it is already coming back to life..

[@GangetFans]

Great Documentary as usual CNA, rise a lot of thinking of what Western demand drive countries to

[@robertohosea]

Sukses buat pemda jabar dan TNI

[@prasssetyadi980]

but now it's so much improvement

[@funnywolffarm]

Curious is aeration techniques simply move the issue from the water mass to the air through basic chemical reaction. Is there any study on this?

[@lalakuma9]

Uh... I think those army guys should clean the river wearing biohazard suits or protective gear. Can't be good for them to be swimming in a river full of chemical waste.

[@kidwolf0015]

Unfortunately, it's the same water that they're forced to drink, cook, and bathe with.

[@kamerad_marzuki3631]

@@kidwolf0015 We cook and bathe using groundwater tho.

[@kidwolf0015]

@@kamerad_marzuki3631 So, there is a somewhat separate water source around? This makes does sense, but why are some of people still so determined to bathe and drink around the river? Is it strictly for religious reasons? (I'm assuming that there's plenty of people around here AREN'T purposely exposing themselves to the river by your comment. Also, it's annoying that the video never seeems to mention the wells....) Admittedly, using local groundwater may still not be safe from contamination. If it's source is close enough to the rivers it probably still has plenty of chemical contamination. Certain types of industrial waste can easily pass through rock and ground layers. It would be significantly less toxic than the river itself, but it's probably still not at safe levels. Do you happen to use any form of filtration with the groundwater?

[@kamerad_marzuki3631]

​@@kidwolf0015 Private wells and public tap water both are not drinkable. We have to buy purified water from the water depot for drinking. Some people from the lower classes, especially those living near rivers, uses water directly from the river for bathing and laundry purposes, while the middle class like myself usually uses private wells or public tap water.

[@kidwolf0015]

@@kamerad_marzuki3631 That makes a lot sense. Thanks for telling us about this, especially since the video skims over most of the topic. (I'm definitely still worried for the lower class individuals that are bathing directly in the river but at least it makes a bit more sense as to WHY they're doing it. I figured that there had to be SOME reason, but I wasn't quite sure what it was.)

[@SerchhipChelsea]

Goodluck Indonesia. 👍