Sayed Hossein Al-Qazwini - Was the House of Fatima Attacked? - Y.H.P Fatimiya Majlis 2013

Ya Hussein Project Fatimiya Majlis 2013
Lecture by Sayed Hossein Al-Qazwini
Night 1

[@shassan1740]

Mashalla, beautiful speech. May Allah punish those that hurt the family of Mohammad (a.s). Thankk you AliAlbasriFilms for the share. Jazallah kheer brother, may Allah grant you heaven.

[@joemaloney3321]

All Sunnis (atleast people with conscience) condemn people who disrespected the Prophet and Ahle-bait. We love Ahle-bait with all our hearts and send laanat on anybody who hurt these loved people by their words actions or intent.

[@IslamOriginal14]

Ahlul Kisa was a threat to those seeking fortunes

[@red.anon.313]

You can't be sunni while claming you love AhlulBayt (as). Being sunni means you praise abu bakr and umar, yet abu bakr sent umar to burn down and attack Fatima (as)'s house. Enough with your hypocrisy you sunnis.

[@abuhaidaralakhbari]

How is that? U cant love ahlul bayt and love abu bakr, umar, uthman, muawyia and so forth at the same time. They stole the rights of the ahlul bayt

[@yourmomshouse8993]

@@red.anon.313 exactly they are going to have to answer the prophet one day

[@yourmomshouse8993]

@@abuhaidaralakhbari exactly my brother

[@memeandrew3152]

Ohhh my lord, people always have something to comment about, I always wished instead of arguing and try to prove each other right or wrong, just spend some time with our own self and try to research or find more information about whether this speech is right or wrong. Trust me no one will lose anything instead whether we will be happy or sad with the founding's at the end of the day we all gained some knowledge, and who doesn't want to seek more knowledge. May Allah give all the believers more knowledge and bless our sadah better heath and iman ya rab

[@dr.mobarakali255]

The truth must be heard and only the truth will prevail.

[@whyiamashia9497]

This what I found kzbin.info/aero/PLhz8wosokP1JI5kZQxDVX0ii_CeEvJjCp

[@t-rexkalita1379]

@@whyiamashia9497 whats the use??? The sunnis rule the world whereas shias are not given any respect.

[@whyiamashia9497]

@@t-rexkalita1379 sunnis are being killed in Palestine and only Iran a Shia country is helping them with weapons

[@siyang105]

@@t-rexkalita1379 R u muslim?

[@zainplays1092]

May ALLAH Swt reward u all momineens for the sake of the Ahle bait a.s. Ameen

[@orlandobanto5781]

Allahumma sali ala muhamd wali muhamd

[@mohamedjagani4832]

Excellent lecture. Shaikh has certainly presented the facts here for the world to be aware of what happened to the lady of light.

[@majedalkafaji8592]

اللهم صل على محمد وال محمد احسنتم وطيب الله انفاسكم وحفظكم

[@orlandobanto5781]

Allahumma Salli ala muhamd wa Ali muhamd wajjil farzahom

[@afgmo10]

MashAllah

[@fabcorp1]

I knew that I was missing something in my life. The House of Fatima if attacked or not..Geeeeeeeeeeeezzzzzz.

[@khizarabbas5522]

ماشاءاللہ

[@mohammadkhaledhussain3684]

Ma'Sha'Allah Great Speech ❤️🌹

[@dr.mobarakali255]

Jazakum Allahu Khairan. The Truth will prevail and falsehood will perish. A grave injustice was done to the Beloved Messenger of Allah SAS and his appointed Successor, Ali ibn Abu Talib SAS. How sad for the Ummah... What if Khutbah tul Fadak occurred before the attack on the house and in fact as a direct consequence therefore triggered the attack? You did not consider this possibility... The details attack are fraught with sensitivity, complexities, and question both logic and reason on both sides, and Allahu alam.

[@zainplays1092]

Mash ALLAH very nice speech

[@abusalah4914]

Yes I agree with the supplication that call on ALLAH to punish those individuals or groups who harmed the family of the Prophet, but certainly such punishment will not affect the Souls of Umar, Abu Bakr, and Uthman. These noble men were the most concerned companions of the Prophet about the Wellbeing of the family of the Prophet. In fact Umar when he Sought marriage of Um Kulthoom (the Daughter of Ali and Fatimah), he did it out of his extreme attachment to the Prophet and his Kins. That is a VERY COMPELLING PROOF that there were no Animosity between Umar and Ali (RA). Who is that fool that give his own Daughter to marry a so called "Criminal" who "Viscously" smashed the door of his own house and Causing the miscarriage of his own baby? Besides, what was Ali the LION of the Battle field doing? Why was he "Cowed down"?

[@alphadog7011]

No 'compelling proofs' exist apart from 120 years of Ummayyad and Abbasid fabrications of hadiths. These three were the biggest Fitnah afflicting Islam.

[@Turaab2608]

🤦‍♂️ I dont think u watched the full thing

[@paktechniques2012]

We ask you the same question that what happened to Hazrat Uthman, when his house and his wife were attacked , Why he kept quiet despite having the Army men, and Khilafah (rule). Was he coward down???

[@paktechniques2012]

The narration you quotes about Hazrat Omar marrying Hazrat Bibi umme kulthoom (as) , that is false. This is the most worst false ever written in books with having false references. My question to you is where this Marriage happened, who were the people that attended this Marriage, And How this Marriage took place, You have no answer, that's for sure. And when you will ask us about the marriage of anyone From Ahlebait, we would give you the book reference, so that you can surely read yourself because we have true narrations explaining every single thing. Even the attack at house of Prophet's daughter is also explained widely in your Sunni books. The narrators are Hazrat Abuzar, Hazrat Zubair, Hazrat Imma Hassan (as), Even Hazrat Abu Bakr himself said that I wish I could not had done three things, one of them was the attack at house of Prophet's daughter. Even Rasoolallah (saw) used to tell his daughter about the incident that would took place after Rasoolallah saw would not be among his daughter. He (saw) used to cry, this evidence is also in your Sunni books, Read Sibtain the book of Allama Al Jubbaini (Sunni scholar and defender of Omar ). Read Allama SHIBLI NAUMANI's book , Al Farooq , who says that it could have happened because Omar was very angry companion, and even sometimes he used to give objections on the decisions made by Allah and Prophet (saw). SHIBLI was also a Sunni scholar and defender of Omar but still they accepted the truth. If you want to criticize someone on exposing your favourite one's, then please criticize your own Sunni Scholars , many of them tried their best to hide such things but some of them told the truth, and narrated the true references and Ahadiths. We are the followers of Allah (swt), Holy Prophet (pbuh) and Ahlebait (as) and they told us everything, even the way we have to pray Salah, or fast, they guided us. And also told us that who is wrong and who is right. Surely , that time was very difficult for Ahlebait, they were not allowed to speak , At the time of MUAWIYAH , People and government used to curse Imam Ali (as), you can realize that there were too many enemies of Ahlebait and only five or six were the real Companions of Ahlebait. So Ahlebait told us that who was wrong , but in a way that Islam can survive, and they sacrificed for Islam. This is Islam. Islam doesn't allows us to follow people who themselves were involved in wrong doings. This also proved that some of the munafiqeens (hypocrites) used to try to kill and harm Holy Prophet (pbuh) and many fabricated False Hadiths against Holy Prophet (pbuh). We love the companions, but we also hate the hypocrites. Quran says that , "The people among you , some of them are hypocrites in Makkah, and there is wrong inside Ahle Madina" The believe of Shia is , that there were some Great Companions like Hazrat Malik bin Nauwairah, Abuzar , Miqdad, Malik e Ashtar, Hujjur bin Udai , Muhammad bin Abu Bakr (RA) And there were also many hypocrites who even tried to kill holy prophet (pbuh) .

[@yourmomshouse8993]

@@paktechniques2012 I noticed none of them replied to you. They run like Umar in uhod

[@9335901007]

completely baseless and fabricated .mr qazwini more 50 percent of shia dosent believe in these theories its all fabricated by scholars like u I am a sunni muslim and i am the lover of ahlebait .u should make ur people understand that rather than wasting ur energy on cursing the sahaba u should understand and learn the teachings of ahlebait

[@shiatalias5219]

prove that 50 percent of shia does not belive in it it is easy to allege but you cannot prove it

[@red.anon.313]

You don't love AhlulBayt (as). Its fake love. You praise the veny enemies of Ahlulbayt (as). Did you not hear your own sunni sources mentioning Umar threatening to burn Fatima (as) ? Hypocrite

[@abuhaidaralakhbari]

U cant have 2 hearts, either you love the ahlul bayt or your khalifs that usurped the rights of the ahlul bayt. Its not baseless at all, i mean even your own books hint at the incident and theres no way 50% of shia dont believe in it, now this is baseless talk what you just said

[@josewednesday1236]

You are not a lover of ahlu bayt, you love the companions more than the family, sunni mosques don’t talk about ashura or any of the prophets family.

[@mohammadkarim5764]

What about Ali (radi Allah) himself? Was he a shia? What about Salman farsi (radi Allah), What about the prophet Muhammad(sl) was he a shia? If they were, im ready to become a shia today. One tiny little example, recorded by the historian, when Utman ibn affan (radi Allah) was seized by the khuarij, Ali (radi Allah) had posted his beloved son to protect him. One famous statement of Ali (radi Allah) about Abu bakar (radi Allah), "you should have seen him in the battle of badar, he was like a ferocious lion in front, behind, left and Wright of the prophet Muhammad ( sl) when anyone from the enemy came close to the prophet(sl)," . let me warn you before you criticize any companion of the prophet (sl) . May Allah guide us all.

[@MohamedSaad-pn1wn]

Look up the companians who are known as shia of ali and read instead of guessing

[@josewednesday1236]

Shia means follower, we are all followers Islam, sunni is not a word. The word Shia is also found in the Quran you can search it up my brother. May Allah guide you.

[@naseeraishah9145]

jioo jiooo

[@hassanabokor7861]

Stop disrespecting the sahaba you or Allah will punish you badly.

[@tazboy1934]

Muhammad Al yaqubi is from ahlul bayt he is not Shia...neither he curse sahaba

[@goofieextra4638]

Books to batayan kardi Kindly ravi ka name bhi bayan kardain Abban ibn e Ayash (kazzab) jisko Sunni or Shia dono kazzab mantay hain ap eh waqia sabit to karo pehlay. Waqia to kafi books me hay different turkon Ki soorat me lekin uski root Abban Ibne Ayan hay Jo Sulaim bin Qais halali Ki book say bayan kar raha apko challange hay k pehlay eh waqiya sabit to karo pehlay

[@paktechniques2012]

Sulaim bin qais halali ki book ki authentication , Ahlebait ne batain hayn ke yeh book 100% Authentic hay aur is book men buhat sarray Raaz bhi hayn. Aur is men koi changings nai huin. Jab Ahlebait ne batadya toh hum aur aap kon hotay is book ko Kisi na Kisi tarhan un authentic kehne wale. Men bhi Sunni hun liken Meri ankhen khulgai kiunke is book aur reference ke illawa bhi aur bhi books men aur bhi references hay . Hazrat Abuzar (ra), Hazrat Zubair , se aur Hazrat Imam Hassan (as) ki hadiths , aur Rasoolallah saw ki hadiths bhi hayn jo yeh saabit krti hayn ke kuch toh hua tha Sayyeda (as) ke khilaf. Aur yeh saari references khud Sunni books men hayn. Kash men apko yeh hawale yahan comment section men de skta liken buhat mushkil hojaiyga isiliye plz khud research kren. Aur Khuda ka wasta apne hee ravion ki kitabon parhlen. At least Hazrat Zubair ko toh ap log mante hayn woh ek Sahabi thay unhi ki hadiths parhlen is waqiay ke mutaliq

[@mrmo9289]

What does this lecture have to do with Sunni s outnumbering Shias in Iran, this sectarian mentality is disgraceful and for a sayed to speak like this is completely out of order!!

[@joemaloney3321]

There was no written history. All hadiths (sunni or shia) were put on paper/leather after hundred of years of passing away of the prophet. All these traditions /hadiths were related by people who heard it from their seniors and carried in the heart so- to-- speak by generations. So how can these guys tell all these stories with so much conviction?. Suppose all these incidents did happen, so what?. Islam is about Allah and His messenger Muhammad. Period. Every body else is secondary and have no role to play. their may be venerated , respectable people but following them is not binding on us atleast the Sunnis.

[@Final_Turn]

We lost the sense of political responsibility and ignored the sense to differentiate between right and wrong. That's major loss !

[@Final_Turn]

If Allah wanted us to ignore the history and move then why Quran always refers to history? History helps us to understand our mistakes and rectify our future. If someone ignores history then historical events shall not be source of our guidance but only "Asateer-ul-Awaleen" !

[@hythamsaleh9620]

قال ررسول الله (ص): إن فاطمة بضعة مني ، فمن أغضبها أغضبني , ومن آذاها فقد آذاني the prophet(saw)said:Fatima is part of me. Whatever upsets her upsets me, and whatever harms her harms me. Sahih Muslim, v. 5, p. 54; Khasa’is Al-Imam Ali of Nisa’i, p. 121-122; Masabih Al-Sunnah, v. 4, p. 185; Al-Isabah, v. 4, p. 378; Seir Alam Al-Nubala’, v. 2, p. 119; Kenz Al-Omal, v. 13, p. 97; similar wording is related in Al-Tirmidhi, v. 3, Chapter on the Virtues of Fatima, p. 241; Haliyat Al-Awliya’, v.2, p. 40; Muntakhab Kenz Al-Omal, in the margins of Al-Musnad, v. 5, p. 96; Maarifat Ma Yajib Li Aal Al-Bait Al-Nabawi Min Al-Haqq Alaa Men Adahum, p. 58; Dhakha’ir Al-Uqubi, p. 38; Tadhkirat Al-Khawass, p. 279; Yanabi^ Al-Mawadda, v.2, ch. 59, p. 478.

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Isn’t muhabala mentioned in the Quran? Why did the prophet bring Ali Fatima Hassan and Hussein with him to prove he was a prophet to the Christians. This is not Hadith it’s in the Quran.

[@TheTruthfulPromise]

Stop with your cursing. We are all shia, and lovers of Fatima (as) but that cursing of the sahaba is not necessary and just creates conflict.

[@hamed8077]

Then u r not a shia!

[@peacemaker2988]

+Truthfull Promise if imam Ali (as) did not give bayah to muawiya and imam huseyin (as) did not give bayah to his dog son yezit then ahlulbayt tells us conflict is necessary for the truth when are you people going to wake up ehlulbayt died defending real islam islam of Allah (swt) and his prophet muhammad (saas).

[@davidkuperman6525]

+Truthfull Promise QURAN; 33:57] Those who annoy Allah and His Messenger - Allah has cursed them in this World and in the Hereafter, and has prepared for them a humiliating Punishment. QURAN; 33-57] إِنَّ الَّذِينَ يُؤْذُونَ اللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ لَعَنَهُمُ اللَّهُ فِي الدُّنْيَا وَالْآخِرَةِ وَأَعَدَّ لَهُمْ عَذَابًا مُهِينًا

[@sajad810]

So should I stop cursing Yazeed, Abu Bakr al Baghdadi, Usama Bin Ladn, , etc? I'm sorry, but I'm not fine with someone killing Fatima AS

[@safuwanfauzi5014]

@Putro Nogo kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZCkZal_nq5jgK8

[@user-ov8yp8sn1i]

I swaer by Allah I try and be non biased and on a nuetral platform.. But its soo obvious to see and feel the lies and deceit oozing from this man's mouth.. Its almost comical.. May Allah swt guide us to the truth.

[@ehsanian3620]

You talk about respect for a women But how about you talking bad about aisha r.a ?? Tsk tsk tsk

[@alphadog7011]

It's Ayesha (L.A.) not R.A - Please do your research with honest intentions, don't just blindly believe what your moulvis teach you.

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Read Sura 66 in the Quran. When the holy Quran the miracle of the prophet the backbone of the religion of Islam mentions you as being hurtful towards the prophet I should revere you? Is it a coincidence that the two that are mentioned are Aisha and Hafsa? Who are those two father’s? Another coincidence? Use your brain. Look up Muhabala or did we make that up too. If you love Allah then you must love the man that taught you, if you don’t then let’s end the discussion there. But if you love the prophet then why do you want to hurt his family?

[@GHD9999]

Wahhab-Salafis al-Misyar How many of your friends and family were born out of the haram relationship known as misyar authorised by Saudi 'scholars'?

[@ItachiAli1993]

You lost it.....

[@thulfiqarallebnani9420]

You became jew?

[@WorshipNoneButOne]

Non muslim explaining Islam🙃🙃🙃

[@josewednesday1236]

Don’t hate my brother, this man is much more righteous than you will ever be.

[@WorshipNoneButOne]

@@josewednesday1236 He is a kafir Those who curse mother of believers and companions of Raoul peace and blessing be upon him are clearly Kafirs,Mushrikens.Rawafid are kafir.If someone has doubt that they are muslims then that person is also a kafir No doubt about it and we should not unite,peace,friendship and anything good thing with Rawafids who curse umul momineen may Allah bless her

[@baraslim]

​​@@WorshipNoneButOneOff course No doubt You also call us the real ahli sunnah was kuffar too You call us grave worshippers etc You also call us ahlul bidah I hope God will agree with your opinion That beside your sect All is kuffar and ahlul bidah Great job brother

[@WorshipNoneButOne]

@@baraslim Brother I am not saying all shias are kafirs.I have some shia friends too.I sit with them eat with them like our brothers.But those who go extreme and curse companions of prophet especially mother Aisha and other mother of believers Radiallahuanhu wa anha then there will be no relationship between me and then except hate and fight.We have problem with Ithna Ashariya (Rawafidh shias) other shias are our brothers and sisters.

[@WorshipNoneButOne]

@@baraslim If you don't curse any companion of Prophet or Mother of believers then you are from me and I am from you

[@paktechniques2012]

The narration you quotes about Hazrat Omar marrying Hazrat Bibi umme kulthoom (as) , that is false. This is the most worst false ever written in books with having false references. My question to you is where this Marriage happened, who were the people that attended this Marriage, And How this Marriage took place, You have no answer, that's for sure. And when you will ask us about the marriage of anyone From Ahlebait, we would give you the book reference, so that you can surely read yourself because we have true narrations explaining every single thing. Even the attack at house of Prophet's daughter is also explained widely in your Sunni books. The narrators are Hazrat Abuzar, Hazrat Zubair, Hazrat Imma Hassan (as), Even Hazrat Abu Bakr himself said that I wish I could not had done three things, one of them was the attack at house of Prophet's daughter. Even Rasoolallah (saw) used to tell his daughter about the incident that would took place after Rasoolallah saw would not be among his daughter. He (saw) used to cry, this evidence is also in your Sunni books, Read Sibtain the book of Allama Al Jubbaini (Sunni scholar and defender of Omar ). Read Allama SHIBLI NAUMANI's book , Al Farooq , who says that it could have happened because Omar was very angry companion, and even sometimes he used to give objections on the decisions made by Allah and Prophet (saw). SHIBLI was also a Sunni scholar and defender of Omar but still they accepted the truth. If you want to criticize someone on exposing your favourite one's, then please criticize your own Sunni Scholars , many of them tried their best to hide such things but some of them told the truth, and narrated the true references and Ahadiths. We are the followers of Allah (swt), Holy Prophet (pbuh) and Ahlebait (as) and they told us everything, even the way we have to pray Salah, or fast, they guided us. And also told us that who is wrong and who is right. Surely , that time was very difficult for Ahlebait, they were not allowed to speak , At the time of MUAWIYAH , People and government used to curse Imam Ali (as), you can realize that there were too many enemies of Ahlebait and only five or six were the real Companions of Ahlebait. So Ahlebait told us that who was wrong , but in a way that Islam can survive, and they sacrificed for Islam. This is Islam. Islam doesn't allows us to follow people who themselves were involved in wrong doings. This also proved that some of the munafiqeens (hypocrites) used to try to kill and harm Holy Prophet (pbuh) and many fabricated False Hadiths against Holy Prophet (pbuh). We love the companions, but we also hate the hypocrites. Quran says that , "The people among you , some of them are hypocrites in Makkah, and there is wrong inside Ahle Madina" The believe of Shia is , that there were some Great Companions like Hazrat Malik bin Nauwairah, Abuzar , Miqdad, Malik e Ashtar, Hujjur bin Udai , Muhammad bin Abu Bakr (RA) And there were also many hypocrites who even tried to kill holy prophet (pbuh) .

[@SajidAli-ip7ov]

All lies.

[@Sam18736]

Well at 43:00 when he talks about Companions of the Prophet(PBUH) to be silent thats actually more than enough proof that this guy really doesn't know anything, I am going to watch further but seriously this is just funny....... He talks about some random incident of Rasool Allah(SAWS) being humiliated and people being quite without giving any reference, first off bring the reference then we will talk about things, because if we look at history there are many many places where if someone said anything to Rasool Allah(SAWS) then Sahaba(RA) stood up and Rasool Allah(SAWS) silent them off........ Now coming to Karbala that everyone remained silent, this just tells this person don't know literally anything about Karbala let alone be anything else.... After Karbala ENTIRE MAKKAH AND MEDINA, stood up for Syedna Imam Hussayn(RA) and the revolt was so bad that Yazeed sent an army and the army of Yazeed killed and raped Sahaba(RA) and their daughters grand daughters and that also happening FIFTY YEARS after Rasool Allah(SAWS) death, so now you are coming up with a story that couple of months after death of Rasool Allah(SAWS) the daughter(a woman) of Rasool Allah(SAWS) got killed and that also in Medina and everyone was silent yet they stand up after Karbala which happened miles away and nobody saw it but just merely reports makes them revolt.... Fool someone else but I don't buy stories like these.....

[@neshkur3459]

+Aaron Rodgers you don't have to believe what he says, but this "story that he is coming up with" is written in your saheeh books, so why don't you go ahead and read them hmm?

[@MuhammadYousuf-pl9on]

Tell me why didn't they stood WITH THE IMAM A.S WHEN HE WAS ALIVE ! HUH !

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Who was Yazids father? Who appointed his father? If you answer these two questions we can start the dialogue.

[@Procrastinators]

Whos this Zindeeq? Tell your artist to think about their fonts. Looks like a pair of nuts under the ي what a joke

[@amarabidali5316]

Yes, Umar (la) tried to burn Fatima (asws) alive just five days after the martyrdom of her father the Holy Prophet (saww).

[@tazboy1934]

Amar Abidali may Allah guide us