Who "Frowned and Turned Away" - Sayed Hossein Al Qazwini - Night 5 - Muharram 1437 / 2015

[@alisural8370]

This is enough to lead me towards ahlulybait’s ahadith. I don’t understand why they always defend the three at the expense of Prophet’s reputation....

[@xgusty7938]

To be most sure, stick with the Quran only 3azeezi.. Allah promised he will preserve His words

[@orlandobanto5781]

Allahumma Salli ala muhamd wa Ali muhamd wajjil farzahom yarhamom

[@lnm4188]

mashaallah.....continue the good work.

[@Mazzie2022]

ماشاء ﷲ May Allah The Most High Grant Sheikh Qazwini endless blessings. Eloquent speaker, excellently delivered. ALL Muslims should watch this. The followers of Ahlulbayt as always use logic and evidence. Brilliant الحمد لله

[@albertenstien8873]

Excellent.. wfaqakum allah

[@kadirushirazu1276]

thanks for revealing the truth

[@baraslim]

I agree... Only hz nabi saww is makshum Nor his ahlul bayt as Nor his sahabaa ra

[@bonusbertambah112]

read surah 33:33 then you know

[@kadirushirazu1276]

allahu akbar

[@lekanmuhammed2666]

May Allah bless you Sheikh. I admire your love for the Prophet (May the peace and blessing of Allah be upon HIM) Sallah Allahu alaehi wasallam. Sheikh, only ALLAH is perfect. The verse you are quoting says the prophet is the BEST in behavior, NOT the perfect or infallible. Among all human beings, He is the best, NOT perfect. That is why Allah does not send us angels. Sheikh, what about surat Kahf, where Allah corrected the prophet to say insha-Allah? Do you have another story behind that too? What about other prophets that came earlier, do they also commit mistakes and seek for forgiveness? or only our Prophet is the "Perfect" . Remember the famous prayer of Prophet Adam after eating the fruit? Sheikh may Allah bless you and continue to increase you in knowledge, and May the peace and blessings of Allah be on our holy prophet - Sallah Allahu alaehi wassalam.

[@zohebakhtar265]

Do not look into the tradition of both Sunni and Shia but make your own judgment based on the Quran. Both Sunni and Shia have the same Quran. There are 10 verses in the Quran of this incident and it tells you very accurately of what the situation must have been. 1. He frowned and turned away, It is possible that it was Uthman ibn Affan or the Prophet 2. Because there came to him the blind man. This tells very clearly that the blind man came to one person, not a gathering but was looking for one specific person. Why would he seek Uthman ibn Affan in a gathering where the Prophet was present? Most probably, he was looking for the Prophet. Remember that he was a blind man and was not seeking to sit next to Uthman. He doesn't know who was sitting there so he couldn't have been looking for Uthman specifically. 3. And what would make you know that he might (spiritually) purify himself, This tells that this person can become righteous by his eagerness to learn. So a neutral statement 4. Or become reminded so that the reminder might profit him? Here we can clearly see that the verse mentions two people, the reminded and the reminder. That means the reminded is the blind man and the reminder is someone who was supposed to remind the blind man of righteousness. Why would the blind man go to Uthman to be reminded while the Prophet was still in the gathering? Doesn't make sense 5. As to one who regards himself as self-sufficient, Neutral statement 6. To him do you address yourself Why is Uthman addressing rich people on righteousness while the Prophet was in their company? It is most likely that the Prophet himself was addressing some rich people 7. Though it is no blame on you if he would not (spiritually) purify himself. Neutral statement 8. But as to him who comes to you striving hard. This states clearly that the blind man came looking for someone. The Shia tradition doesn't specify that he was looking for Uthman. It states that he came and sat next to Uthman. But the Sunni tradition says clearly that he came looking for the Prophet to be reminded of righteousness. 9. And he fears (Allah in his heart), Neutral 10. Of him wast thou unmindful Interrupting someone when in the middle of a conversation is a bad habit and bad manner, there is no contradiction in the erudite mannerism of the Prophet if he frowns over a bad habit. It is but very acceptable. The reason Allah revealed the verses in the manner he did, is to guide the Prophet to focus on people who are more zealous rather than the one who call themselves self-sufficient and strong in society. Because iman is better than wealth and power Just in my humble opinion

[@8heavyhchamp8]

Even if your wrong or right I'll love to read your view always only because you want biased with sunni shia coz to be honest with you every sect always interpret Quran to fit thier agenda... ...the enemies have tampered with the truth right from when the prophet died... may Allah help us... me know your view on both sunni or shia who do you think is more logical?

[@EpicRevelations]

You don't need to look into any ones tradition. When you read the verse it is degrading to think that it is revealed for Holy Prophet and some of those are NOT neutral but rather negative statements towards an individual. It is humiliating to believe these were revealed for my Prophet. The Prophet would prefer a rich person over a blind man? Really? You're telling me you logically believe Allah is trying to "reform" his Prophet here about a characteristic that even a common man supposedly can surpass him in. In the Shia school of thought, the Holy Prophet is free of these lowly flaws. He is on another level and void of these disgusting characteristics that are ascribed to him. But hey, anything to defend the 3 khulafah am I right? I'm Really not trying to be mean but it's embarrassing and sad to see a so called follower of the Holy Prophet go out of his way to make the Prophet look bad in order to make Uthman look good

[@8heavyhchamp8]

@@EpicRevelations ok now I'll definitely try check the verse and I'll see what I can really say coz both of you makes perfect sense but someone must be wrong.. but the prophet can do that doesn't mean it's a SIN... I'll be back

[@ItachiAli1993]

What I dont understand why would Allah address Uthman Ibn Affan in his Holy Book to teach him. I mean here are verses that are actually lecturing Uthman. Shouldnt that be a PRAISE for Uthman because he has the honour to be corrected by Allah in His Book?

[@alisural8370]

Itachi Uchiha haha 😂 🤣. PRAISE?! You’re joking, right? 😂🤣 mashallah.

[@8heavyhchamp8]

Allah does what he wants ...what is right to us might be wrong to Allah and what is right to Allah might seem wrong to us...Allah is not unjust

[@ghalibahmed6676]

That has absolutely nothing to do with being praised. When someone praises you, they don't say "you did this immoral act, you should not have done this", rather if someone praises you, they say "You did such a good a meritorious act and I am proud of you". If Allah were to tell Hitler "You should not have killed all those Jews", would that be a praise? If this should be considered a praise, then when Allah says about the Munaqfiqeen "And when it is said to them "come and the messenger will ask forgiveness for you", they turn their backs", Would this be a praise for the munafiqeen because Allah pointed out their ignorance? Being corrected means Allah condemns what you did and wants everyone to know that what you did was an immoral act. Allah was using Uthman as an example of what not to do. This is not a merit or praise by any means

[@saidkhan5086]

Those protecting uthman, knows better that's why they're ready to sacrifice prophet integrity