I Fixed the Blue Sky Ranking

Schaff ranks a LOT of Ice Age movies, plus some other random nonsense Blue Sky made idk
Chris' channel: / spacechris7
Editor's Channels:
Citizen HAL: kzbin.info/door/Aht...
Shooting Films: / thesonic. .
Mordo: kzbin.info/door/YAs...
VillagerWolf: kzbin.info/door/4Yy...
SpaceTree Studios: / spacetree88
Clem: kzbin.info/door/iCv...
Patrick: / @pappyg3187
Goop: / goopvideos
CGF-Movies: / cgfmovies
Mr. Bamason: / mrbamason
Patreon: / schaffrillas​​​​
Twitter: / schaffrillas​​​​
Redbubble: www.redbubble.com/people/scha....
Reddit: / schaffrillas. .
Esteemed $5+ Patrons:
aheaney15
Alexandra
Andre Gutierrez
Andrew Young
Ashley Forrest
BATMAN
CG Lemonade
Charlotte M
Childish Memphino
ClownDuck
Cole Jackson
Crimson Court
Danmccould
Dman990099
Dr Noe Context
Emily Allen
Flan
Gabi Christie
Ian Seebach
Jacob Baum
Jacob LaBossiere
Jake G
Jonathan Kermanian
Joseph
Justin Gonzales
Leif Bradshaw
Logan McQuaid
Matt Fernandes
Michael David Rose
Milky
MirrorWqve
Nessie
NoneLovesMe
Olivia Mendel
Peter Hollens
Pierre Desbrieres
Prismabunny
Put 9-Volt in Smash Bros. Please
Quetzal the Snek
rEactor
Reagan DeFriece
RoscoesDad
Ryland Tews
Sassy
Scott St Jean
Seth Howell
Soloco
Suarez
SuperJimmy978
Tailored Muffin
That Guy Named Rai
Uncultured Swine
Vellum Tony
Vintage
Volianer
Wafflegamr

[@funnyhappystudios]

Fun fact: Diego was meant to die in the first movie, but since test audiences liked him, they kept him alive. Probably explains why he doesn’t do shit after the second movie

[@JMB_Knight]

I honestly would have preferred that, I know people would get upset by that but it would honestly make his redemption arc all the more better

[@floraosc]

WAIT DIEGO WAS GONNA DIE-

[@thegoldendragon8207]

Breaking Bad

[@hellyeavesx]

Bravo Vince

[@moistwrmonastring1017]

Oh wow, that would’ve been incredible in such an old kids movie, but nope! Of course they had to let him live

[@redpandaman6826]

I originally went "oh, I wonder what he thought was wrong" and then remembered the date

[@Zeagods-CyberShadow]

Yup

[@samking7955]

What was wrong with the date

[@joanjarrin4113]

@@samking7955 April fools

[@carricksimone5122]

@@samking7955it’s 2012 again how did you not notice

[@Ian-es3ec]

Bruh why u have more likes smh

[@lenlaegrim]

"Dreamworks didn't even make 5 of any of their franchises, not even Shrek" oh, this aged wonderfully

[@ImaginaryAlchemist]

Aged like a fine milk

[@MariOmor1]

It already aged before Shrek 5 was even announced, Puss in Boots already counted as a 5th Shrek film with the sequel being the 6th

[@dravendarkplays9607]

The Shrek storyline has four movies if in correct. The side movies don't count since they don't follow shrek

[@Afatgrandma]

​@@dravendarkplays9607 Shrek 5 was just announced it isn't out until May

[@dravendarkplays9607]

@@Afatgrandma god you better be kidding

[@aidenknight6948]

Rio 2 was so good it sold 2 Rioillion tickets. Truly one of the animated movies of all time

[@clairefortune6228]

Nah

[@cyberia1998]

@@clairefortune6228Fo’real-a?

[@MrPineapple045]

2 Brazillion tickets

[@wyatteb1663]

how much is a brazillion? @@MrPineapple045

[@themug406]

Shit joke stolen from every video about Morbius ever

[@bluewater6878]

For those of you confused, the original ranking was taken down because of copyrighted music in the end. Edit: It's not an April Fools Day joke. Lol.

[@jjrays9913]

Ohh

[@n19ntendods]

Oh……

[@ratkingwastaken]

I’m pretty sure they can just cut out copyrighted sections of videos with the KZbin editor. I believe in his Megamind video, there was a small section that got cut out

[@caltendo7658]

What was the music called?

[@lukesoup27]

Oh I thought it was because people were mad about Rio 2 lol

[@taicanium]

Schaffrillas: "I don't vitriolically hate the movie at the bottom of this list." Ice Age 5: Schaffrillas: "And I took that personally."

[@jcf_plus]

Ice Age could've stayed as four films. Why God, Why?

[@boydixonentertainment]

@@jcf_plusIt should’ve stayed as three. Dawn of the Dinosaurs is a good enough stopping point.

[@jcf_plus]

@@boydixonentertainment Correction, It should've stayed as four!

[@zrexy79s11]

He said he was more bored of it than angry. He was angry at the franchise itself for going on so long, not the film itself.

[@ForkyandAnyaFan2009RESOR-ep8cr]

Well collision course wasn't even a bad movie but it could have been way better. I just think that it's better that I say that Ice Age should have had just ended in five movies but nooooo. Disney had decided to make a cringe Buck Wild movie.

[@haleyb4023]

As an archaeologist who loved the first Ice Age when I was little, I was CRUSHED by the wasted potential. How would early humans, presumably the first to come to the Americas, interact with excellent sources of food that are sentient? Does the baby remember them? Does the baby's family remember them? How does that effect their interactions? But no, we simply must have colorful female sloths and aliens.

[@DiegoRedeemedLover]

I am not a professional archaeologist, but I feel you on this point so much! The plot point of the humans deeply intrigued me as a young preteen, and one thing I know I truly wanted from an Ice Age sequel was for the baby - Roshan - to come back, that he remembers all three of his beast fathers and the love they gave him, and how he was changed forever because of his encounter with the herd. Roshan/the humans were even potentially gonna come back in IA2 but this was shot down as being "too predictable", which has forever saddened me becos IA1 was this beautiful drama-comedy and then the sequels were tonally off comedies that barely paid any sort of homage to IA1, and Manny and Diego, as characters, suffered when those dramatic ties to the humans were cut becos their character development/arcs have direct lines leading back to _Roshan_ / the humans. But no, like you say, let's ignore that entirely to shill Sid and other sloths, aliens, and Scrat! Manny and Diego and Roshan deserved better. :(

[@FurKid_the_Gg_roo_99]

Not to mention that instead of, Idk, expanding on Manny's trauma of LOSING A WIFE & KID w/ the effects it had on him or maybe what they were like before -except for the 2nd one Ig, the sequels never really did anything with it! The 3rd 4th ones in particular could've actually been interesting if they used that!! Imagine Manny having to deal with Peaches not being able to fill in the void that his og kid did -whether it be her growing up or other differences, or him being scared of his future dad life because he doesn't want to lose Ellie & his to-be baby like he did before?? That would've been at least fascinating!

[@ccaagg]

'Sentient' is the wrong word to use. Normal, non-talking, real-world animals are sentient.

[@NebulaRanger]

​@@ccaaggYeah, the correct word is "sapient"

[@ccaagg]

​@@NebulaRanger And the reson we use the word 'sentient' in the context of AI gaining humanity is that if it's sentient, it, like animals, has its own unique _experience_ of existing. EDIT: And should therefore, if sentient, be treated like a non-human animal.

[@sandyr5407]

The most upsetting thing about Ice Age having four sequels is that not a single one was about them finding the kid again from the first film. I kept hoping that he would show up all grown up one day and see all his animal friends again, but no.

[@mimicmey]

Yeah, this is why I pretend the movies after the first one take place in a parallel universe where humans don't exist and they met through different circumstances, because there's absolutely no continuation* from the first one to the rest other than the 3 guys travel together now. Edit: continuity*

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

He dead 💯

[@TheWildSuperStar]

@TheGlassesPro Is that an april fools joke or you being fr

[@TheWildSuperStar]

@TheGlassesPro Wow, it would be kinda cool to see an ice age like that

[@TheWildSuperStar]

@TheGlassesPro Cool! Thanks!

[@JAProductions494]

Ok, this was the most elaborate April Fools joke ever and I will now gladly explain it to those confused So, the original video was taken down due to copyrighted music at the end. The music could easily be edited out but James was getting REALLY annoyed by all the comments complaining that he put Rio 2 (a movie he didn’t even like) above Rio 1. As a result, he wasn’t in a rush to edit the video and see all the annoying comments again Instead, he uploaded this video where the normal spot for Rio 2 was taken out and was instead placed at the end to be the ‘real best Blue Sky movie’ to spite all of the annoying commenters. That way anyone genuinely offended by James not hating Rio 2 can just assume it’s an April Fools joke

[@idontknowwhatmypfpis1918]

This shit got more layers than that Onion

[@chileanyways196]

Thank you

[@synergy76]

Cool

[@CooperHudgins]

@@idontknowwhatmypfpis1918 LAYERS

[@starmanofspacetime9825]

Really good April Fools joke

[@atomicproto3204]

The fact that Schaffrillas is capable to ironically love a character of a mid-bad movie in every company still is amusing as hell.

[@MutedAndReported3032]

Are you implying he doesn’t love Bigweld unironically? Blasphemy!

[@Crafty_boy70]

@@MutedAndReported3032 I think he's talking about the monkey guy but not sure

[@atomicproto3204]

@@MutedAndReported3032 Of course not! Bigweld in all his might did the movie into a good one.

[@cyberia1998]

@@Crafty_boy70Yummo Wickersham

[@atsukana1704]

@@cyberia1998ahh, monkee

[@plague8163]

The original Ferdinand story was a beautiful short story about how even though Ferdinand appeared to be rough and wild, he didn't hurt anyone when given the chance. He just wanted to smell the flowers. He looked mean, but was actually super sweet.

[@FirstnameLastname-sb3hj]

that actually sounds nice

[@plague8163]

@@FirstnameLastname-sb3hj It is! Even though it's a children's book, I'd recommend giving it the quick 1-3 minute read it is to anyone who needs something to get them by.

[@lunecker]

​@@plague8163the disney short film was exacly that, short and sweet

[@cursedtails1249]

I was expecting 42 minutes of a joke ranking but I got something even better

[@JuanPablo-su6vw]

The exact same video?

[@JuanPablo-su6vw]

Never mind

[@Rats0World]

​@@JuanPablo-su6vw ☠️

[@sorosspy]

​@@JuanPablo-su6vw it's not same?

[@wintersins]

​​​@@sorosspyIt is just some copyrighted music got cut and he changed his original ranking of Rio 2 to its correct position.

[@thejungwookim]

I love how Schaff cares so little about this list that he turned it into an April Fool's Joke Truly a Yummo Wickersham moment

[@Emmaniak]

Based

[@NicoEdgy]

not to disrespect the dead, but literally no one cares about Blue Sky

[@AdiBoi-fo6ix]

​@@NicoEdgyClearly you are in denial about the greatness to come from the studio that gave us Robots and Yummo Wickershum

[@Data-Expungeded]

@@NicoEdgyi mean i kind of cared. Ever so slightly

[@jk_d7837]

​@NicoEdgy I kinda cared only because I watched their movies as a kid lol but the animators losing their jobs is the saddest part.

[@chainlink2459]

I'm holding back tears... the performance was so powerful. Jesse Heisenberg would be proud.

[@happyapathy22]

Jesse we need to cook. -Mark Zuckerberg

[@roxtechs]

Not gonna lie I thought it was Michael cera

[@DuplexWeevil337]

​@@happyapathy22-mark zuckerbeak

[@Totas_funnynumber]

Bravo Vince

[@Hello_World_not_taken]

You’re gosh-darn right -Walt Disney

[@destiny6478]

As an animator who has worked at many of these studio's movies you review. All your animator jokes make me laugh so hard

[@xaviercarrillo1703]

If you are allowed to say it which was the best to work at?

[@destiny6478]

@@xaviercarrillo1703 I enjoyed Dreamworks a lot but Disney feels like my home studio

[@Paulnurburg78]

Give me a c give me an a give me a p CAP

[@Blanch590]

@@Paulnurburg78these companies employ thousands of people. It’s not far fetched.

[@Paulnurburg78]

@@Blanch590 I don't know man these comments smell very fishy but it might be a possibility that it is true

[@funnyhappystudios]

It’s sad that a toxic fanbase forced Schaffrilias to destroy a perfectly crafted and well spoken review just so they could be internally satisfied that “everyone” loves Rio and they weren’t wrong

[@carlososoriohernandez3979]

More like "internally satisfied that everyone hates Rio 2 and they weren't wrong"

[@Miniduck9013]

I absolutely adore Rio but I’ll never understand why people get so pressed over movies

[@t1mburt0nsdandruff]

I hate the second Rio, but it’s terrible that the Rio fans (I actually didn’t think Rio had a fan base, I just thought it was popular for the songs) couldn’t take Schaffrillas’s opinions about it. As someone who loves Rio, getting pressed over someone’s opinions about it is extremely petty and ridiculous. Schaff has every right to not like it, he has different tastes in movies and that’s perfectly fine.

[@Mr_bukowski4435]

@@Miniduck9013ya I love Rio a lot as well but like I wasn’t shitting on him for not liking it cause I actually understand other peoples opinions and that I have my own.

[@axlrosest]

bruh, i always loved Rio in my childhood but the sequel was kinda forgettable. Then i saw the movies again last year and dude, i almost cried. That movie is just so fucking good, it might not have the best story but personally it's just one of the best movies because of my childhood. It had it's flaws but overall it's just a gem for me. Then i saw Rio 2 and i puked.

[@christalee9975]

Fun fact about The Peanuts Movie: Everyone's actors were switched out due to them getting too old for the roles with the exceptions of Snoopy and Woodstock. Their actor, Bill Melendez, who also directed almost all of the Peanuts specials, passed away a few years prior to the films release. So they used archives of his voice as the characters to voice them. Also every actor in the movie is a child except for 3 of them, one being Melendez.

[@Ninja_4561]

Not-so-fun fact: on Disney+, all of the child actors' names are intentionally edited out for no reason (the three adult actors are still credited)

[@hunterolaughlin]

It’s like if Bill Melendez did his voice recording sessions up in Heaven and sent to Blue Sky Studios for use.

[@Finn-ok5hn]

@@Ninja_4561 this is actually done for the privacy and safety of the children, bluey also does this

[@Ninja_4561]

@@Finn-ok5hn I assume the voices for the kids from Bluey might be from children of the crew members (though I could be wrong), but almost every other child actor in the entire movie & TV industry is credited for their work. Removing their names wouldn't do anything because their names are already known (you can just check Wikipedia)

[@FragglevisionReturns]

@@Ninja_4561 which is interesting because one of them went on to play freaking Will Byers.

[@Rembreiker_lychec9257]

One thing I like in Rio is how they didn't make Blu incompetent. Because it would be easy to make him completely loser who Jewel has to constantly save and teach about living and parting, and who suddenly gets badass in the emotional climax of the third act. But no, he isn't useless, he isn't burden (beside the no flying thing of course) and he has quite a few moments. Like the time where he climbed on top of the arbor with Jewel or how he mimicked dog's barking to scare off a cat at the smugglers. But possibly most important the dance off scene. Where in more generic movie you would expect Jewel to be the one to initiate the dance with Blu, instead it's the other way around. I like it. It makes it more believable as to why she fell for him.

[@smithybagel_balls6730]

rio taught me what romance is

[@laraprisma6381]

as a Brazilian who doesn't live in Rio, the movie is great and fun! the songs are the best parts!

[@archivist_13]

Y'know, I never thought of that, good point

[@archivist_13]

​@@smithybagel_balls6730 damn really?

[@egbertmilton4003]

@Sentiental Rio 2 was much better than Rio 1, and that’s a fact

[@CooperHudgins]

Watching Jonah Who rank Rio 2 as the second worst Blue Sky movie and then watching Schaff ironically rank it as the best movie ever made me realize how truly all over the place some KZbinrs can be when it comes to ranking animated kids movies.

[@AUM_-po9sc]

Originally it was in the middle of the ranking, above Rio 1

[@CooperHudgins]

@@AUM_-po9sc I remember that like it was yesterday😆

[@AtlasBlizzard]

I mean, you can not like Rio, but Rio 2 is just objectively worse.

[@t1mburt0nsdandruff]

@@AtlasBlizzard yeah, like they made Jewel unlikable, had an unnecessary audition, and boring kids that serve nothing to the plot. I understand Schaffrillas’ opinions, but how is the sequel better? I get that Jewel and Blu should’ve had more chemistry, but it’s still a perfectly fine movie. I agree with Schaff that the romance stuff is kinda annoying, but Rio is sorta a romance that works.

[@absolutezerochill2700]

@@AtlasBlizzard he said it was. He just liked it more, like Spiderman 3 over SPderman 2 even though it's objectively worse. He SAID THIS in the video

[@KuramaKyubi9]

Fun Fact: The studio was originally planning to send the animation team to Brazil to help with the creative process for Rio, but the threat of mass suicide from the crew convinced them not to. This is widely considered the proper response to being threatened with going to Brazil.

[@lunecker]

I was actually in the studio that exact day and can confirm its all true

[@kindaepicngl1671]

​@@luneckerCan confirm, I was the studio

[@Grimexx955]

Robots was one of the movies that people gave too much hate towards for the past decade. The worldbuilding was very fleshed out, the message was ahead of its time for animation, and despite the armpit & fart jokes it’s actually kind of funny. The pop culture references were also not super outdated compared to other references, since they chose ones that actually lasted.

[@kcchristian]

As a kid those jokes were iconic, so they did their job well. I quote them to this day. "AUNT FAAAAAAANNY"

[@TECH097]

Not to mention it's message about upgrading obsolete machines is all too familiar with planned obsolescence and the exploitation of consumers over items like smartphones and computers.

[@owenslamansa4378]

What noone hates on this movie, every kid loves it when it came out

[@DoxicDoad]

Don't forget the thicc robot lady

[@scandathepole723]

I actually enjoyed this movie a lot as a kid, still consider it the peak of Blue Sky imo

[@DanGamingFan2846]

While I'll miss the original ending, I absolutely love this new one. It feels just like one of your old KZbin Poops. And your singing was immaculate. A 1000/10 masterpiece. Thank you very much.

[@watershipup7101]

Very much agreed.

[@ImTheGuy]

I'm pretty sure it's just his first nostalgia critic ytp, but with the names of thing being changed.

[@mauriceletterman7025]

Timestamps: 1:45 Ice Age 5 5:11 epic 7:08 Ice Age 4 9:34 Horton hears a Who 12:33 Ferdinand 14:26 Ice Age 3 16:31 Rio 19:19 Ice Age 2 22:04 Robots 26:51 Ice Age 29:06 The Peanuts Movie 31:53 Spies in Disguise 35:10 The greatest film since the invention of moving pictures

[@Alfrehe]

I read it wrong like ”the greenest film since the invention of moving pictures”

[@cyberia1998]

@@AlfreheI mean, the Amazon is pretty green.

[@handsomeclaw6802]

Rank 6 Rio 2 is this video didn't added due of the copyright because of the jingles

[@julianharris530]

​@@Alfrehe14:26 What Killed The Dinosaurs The Ice Age

[@DuckShooter98]

Finally we got an uncensored schaffrillas F-bomb 39:20 Edit: Never mind there was one in the Shark Tale review

[@joshuasgameplays9850]

Schaff's singing skills are truly incredible.

[@silashurd3597]

He deserves all the Oscars for this!

[@isaaccarter9007]

​@@silashurd3597 Oscar from sharktale no way

[@silashurd3597]

@@isaaccarter9007 😂😂

[@LazyOldFusspot_3428]

Surprised he didn't use dolphin clicks this time to censor out the f-bombs

[@bluefrosttouch9161]

I'm so glad Schaff changed his mind on Rio 2 and it's posted on the most normal and most bland day in April. Yessir this is the most normal video of all time

[@hillefoozy]

When I watched Nimona on Netflix, I actually forgot that Blue Sky was working on it and was pleasantly surprised to see them in the credits

[@RudeAndObscene]

There's an alternate universe out there where Blue Sky actually released Nimona, and somehow singlehandedly save themselves from oblivion.

[@Venom-Boiii]

The Peanuts Movie is the most wholesome movie I’ve ever seen. They captured the essence of the comics extremely well, and all the characters are berry likable. And that’s why it’s my favorite Blue Sky movie.

[@Gadget-Walkmen]

It’s also VERY well animated in a big budgeted way! Love that movie so much as it’s genuinely a great film!

[@dragonfly._.doodles]

I love that the trolls are a slow burn, you know the date but everything seems normal, but then you get that long pause and then you just brace yourself for the madness

[@ODISeth]

Ya know most KZbinrs would double down on their mistakes or just brush it under the table in the hopes that nobody remembers it, but you not only admitted your mistake, but decided to do an entire rerelease with the correction publicly showing off what you did wrong and how that phenomenal song changed your mind. True King behavior. Thank you.

[@syra1541]

right

[@Medothingshere-nb1yf]

I don't know if you're talking about Rio 2, or if you're just pulling a prank on me.

[@mimikyutubesaltaccount4875]

You say that like Schaff ranking Rio 2 above the original was a mistake

[@finalmountain]

Schaffrillas 2022: maybe Nimona will just be another Epic Schaffrillas 2023: More like AN epic movie

[@i_drewproductions]

"I wonder if theres any other american animation studios?' Animan:

[@MediaDroid960]

As a choir kid, that ending was so painful, yet so blissful at the same time. Bravo Vince

[@dimentdash]

Love that the Rio 2 April Fools was a mish mash of dialogue taken by Nostalgia Critic's Disneycember reviews.

[@oscarzxn4067]

It's based on a Shark Tale YTP he did

[@silygoose5334]

Watching Scaff absolutely lose his mind and finally reach his breaking point while singing about rio made me piss myself 😂😂😂

[@QuartzRoolz]

so even though the original ending of this video is gone and is replaced with an (admittedly brilliant) shitpost, I do want to say that it really sucks that Bluesky never got to finish Nimona _as bluesky_ now the film is out. it would have been their spiderverse, its such an amazing film which now serves as a swansong to a studio which was finally getting somewhere rather than a jumping off point for potentially more amazing projects. Nimona is that 10 out of 10, that massive high point that bluesky needed. and they never really got it. and I think thats a shame.

[@lilianmesmo]

as a brazilian, i genuinely think Rio is a really really good movie and i love it the brazilian VA for this movie is so fire, you have no idea

[@finalmountain]

I’m not Brazilian but I do feel passionate about the first Rio. Also, although I can respect Schaff’s opinions I have an opposing opinion that “Rio an underrated gem” and Blue Sky’s one great movie (8-9/10). [Edit, now that Nimona exists Blue Sky has their one truly great movie]. I find Blu such a loveable protagonist. I think Jessie Eisenberg does fit the nervous but great spirited brainiac character while giving off good comedic performance and I legitimately don’t get why Schaff said overwise to that. I enjoy his journey learning to fly which I believe is metaphorical to finding his passion and expressing himself to not just Jewel but his bird species that he is insecure from. As for Jewel, while she is less focused on and seems arrogant on paper, I find her to be a more interesting and even more likeable than Blu. She has tragic conflict with the humans who took her family and has grown to fight for herself but remains lonely. She has the motivation to not like Blu due to him being connected with the humans. However Blu ultimately shows her that some humans can be trusted and she doesn’t have to fly alone Even though Schaffrillas thinks Blu and Jewel don’t have chemistry, I believe their chemistry consists of Blu metaphorically learning to fly based on Jewel’s skills as a wild and fierce bird. Furthermore Blu’s intellect helps him and Jewel get through conflict they face such as smugglers. Ultimately what really brings them together is them facing the conflict of smugglers and finding their grace from the cultural influence of the city and the local spiritual Birds and the animal friendly humans. Truth be told I can go on about this movie because it’s really something special in my eyes. I still have problems with it. I understand If some of you Brazilian’s consider certain themes of the movie a little stereotypical and some of the jokes are kinda cheesy. However for everything else I appreciate about this movie. It gives me the will to congratulate Blue Sky for making something this special. P.s I don’t like Rio 2 at all and I genuinely don’t get how Schaffrillas enjoys it ironically

[@gawys28]

Wow

[@misstauhata]

A MÚSICA DO CARLINHOS BROWN NÃO TER GANHO DE MUPPETS 2 É ROUBO

[@planety2021]

If I was an animated character I would 100% be blu

[@pinkfloydfan0075]

​@Final Mountain one of the best comments on the movie I've ever seen, always thought it was underrated 👏

[@ragnarok935]

I just watched the most elaborate and well choreographed April Fools prank of all time

[@thecapitalg]

But it's literally just a non copyrighted reupload of his OG Blue Sky vid

[@ragnarok935]

@@thecapitalg thats what makes it so good

[@bece00]

​@@thecapitalg hes an chaotic genius

[@brainlessappendix4369]

​@@thecapitalg have you watched until the end?

[@thecapitalg]

@@brainlessappendix4369 oh wait i hadn't watched till the end

[@eddykidplayzyt]

Nimona is good af, it has great animation, story, humor, and the funniest character name of all time, Ambrocious Goldenloin

[@liamdude5722]

I also love that name, but it can't beat the magnificent names in Lake Michigan Monster

[@snowhunter7536]

Ahh…Nimona Just watched it last night and I can confirm that it could have been Blue Sky’s first magnum opus. Better than Rio 2.

[@EuRoWeIrD]

Timestamps #13 Ice Age Collision Course 1:44 #12 Epic 5:12 #11 Ice Age Continental Drift 7:08 #10 Horton Hears a Who (asked) 9:33 #9 Ferdinand 12:33 #8 Ice Age Dawn of the Dinosaurs 14:26 #7 Rio 16:31 #5 Ice Age the Meltdown 19:19 #4 Robots 22:04` #3 Ice Age 26:51 #2 The Peanuts Movie 29:05 #1 Spies in Disguise 31:53 #⭐Rio 2 35:10 Extras: Recap 38:33

[@astheniceel13]

Rio 2 was Number 6 in the original list but this was an April Fools special so he said it was the best since it was April 1st

[@gregheffley9984]

​@@astheniceel13 dude didnt even watch the video

[@astheniceel13]

@@gregheffley9984 I did. I just guessed what it was before I watched it. Only to find it was best movie (April Fools thing)

[@DogsWithPurpose]

You are great

[@stwormmarkus]

He took number 6 down because everyone was like " OHHHhHHhHHHhH HE liKEs RiO 2 bEttEr thEN tHE fiRST ONE.

[@KaiserOfPrussia0910]

I am so happy that you acknowledge Rio 2 as the masterpiece that it really is! The part when Solid Snake teamed up with Vito Corleone and took down Voldemort in Isengard was epic!

[@toxi101yt5]

how tf you die to a chair

[@thejoabear]

Schaff should win an Emmy for those high notes in that incredible song.

[@samuelmurrill7438]

I love how you had to edit the footage of “Just Can’t Wait to be King” and overlap it with cut-ins to avoid copyright but I barely noticed it until the end of the song cause of how well it fit with ur beautiful song and those life changing lyrics

[@KeebeThePlush]

Glad to see Rio 2 can finally be up there with the perfect sequel hall of fam like shrek 2 and last wish

[@Ninja_4561]

Rio 2 makes Shrek 2 look like that one bootleg movie from 2007

[@bluestar4408]

@@Ninja_4561 Rio 2 makes all movies look awful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!’nm

[@fuutaipaste6403]

Out of all these movies, I'm still rooting for Robots to get recognized like Megamind. It's like a fever dream for a non English speaker kid like me. Of course I didn't appreciate it enough until I found it again years later. I think Robots has charming characters, simple yet astoundingly unique storyline whose meanings still hold true till this day, and for a animation film at that time from a less well known studio, I think Robots is very underrated. Maybe not everyone will agree with me on the story but the art style is so god damn beautiful and timeless with a retro futuristic vibe to it. No other robot animation film is as unique as it I swear (even Well-E, yes)

[@shoulderBirb]

idk how else to put it other than the difference is that walle isn't a movie "about robots" and i have no idea if that makes sense but im going with it 😭

[@user-he1tt7gt4d]

Robots has problems but it’s UNFORGETTABLE I mean it birthed “upgrades people upgrades” meme

[@citriosis]

​​@@shoulderBirbno you're so right.

[@SEGbruhproductions]

Then we gotta hope it doesn't get a sequel...ever 😃

[@thejuiceking2219]

@@SEGbruhproductions Robots 2: Rodney Rules

[@TheRealNTM]

I remember watching Ice Age The Meltdown once, and my parents came home, and my mother saw a bit of it and asked "Is this Lion King?" I don't know what to think of that. I just think it's funny.

[@DKdrop]

The Manny backstory scene of the first Ice Age is genuinely a core memory of mine. I can still remember being a kid and feeling moved in a way that I couldn’t describe. Thankfully, I only ever watched like half of one of the sequels, so I at least get to remember the movie in isolation.

[@chorizochomper7520]

Before I clicked on this ranking I already knew there had to be something to do with April fool's.

[@alexconner6866]

“ I don’t hate the worst movie on this list” Proceeds to go off on ice age 5😂

[@finalmountain]

I do consider Nimona Blue Sky’s creation, since It was 75% made by them before shut down then finished with some company support but keeping the original directors and other Blue Sky employees Given it’s positive reviews from critics and audiences it’s safe to say Blue Sky finally has an objectively great movie. Schaffrillas even gave it an 8/10 It may not be their Spiderverse but (like Mitchell’s Vs The Machines) Nimona is a better movie with a female protagonist than Dreamwork’s has ever done. Blue Sky and Sony outdid Dreamwork’s In this regard. Sorry, I love Dreamwork’s but I wish they would make a movie with a female protagonists that’s actually really good. Ruby Gilman is not one of those movies.

[@absolutezerochill2700]

wait when did schaff rate it?

[@silashurd3597]

What about Monsters Vs. Aliens? They had a female protagonist. Was that not good? Wait, why are you even concerned about what the protagonist has either a peepee or Va jay jay? This is why movies are starting to become dumb. Because you people are totally concerned with stupid social justice than entertainment that movies should be made for🤦‍♂️

[@greaterduck8374]

I love how after months the april fools comments have fased out and no ones stays till the end and just talks about the actual video

[@afeathereddinosaur]

I wholeheartedly agree with the ranking of Ice Age: Dawn of The Dinosaurs (2009) for the PS2. It is the best Blue Sky movie and fighting dinosaurs as a mammoth was the best idea ever conceived. Edit: the Buck gameplay was cool too, riding dinosaurs was awesome.

[@Yakal001]

Dude I loved that game as a kid

[@antusFireNova64]

Jokes aside, the actual video game was fun as far as I remember

[@an0rmalp3rson70]

I remember seeing my aunt playing that game once, it seemed pretty cool

[@onepresence9460]

I’m still mad that Disney closed Blue Sky Studios. I thought they were a really good animation studio. The first Ice Age movies, Robots, The Peanuts Movie, Spies in Disguise and Rio are really good. They had so much potential.

[@mantasma9024]

I say we all got to Burbank California where Disney studios is located And we’re all holding signs that say “Bring back Blue Sky”

[@Komelikus]

Río is waaay better in the latin spanish version (the one with the local phrases, not the neutral spanish one), voice acting is really cool, it really sells the characters.

[@briizyleaves]

Just in case no one knows, the Rio 2 segment is Schaff quoting one of his old YTPs that was a mashup of Nostalgic Critic Disneycember (and Dreamworks) reviews.

[@limepie3801]

Really my only criticism of the Peanuts movie is the Red Baron sequences. They were just bland and didn't really add anything to the movie. Otherwise, easily my favorite Blue Sky movie, and one of my favorite animated movies overall! Beautiful, faithfully adapted style and animation, genuine moments, and a heartfelt story and characters culminate in a very well done film!

[@jcoolguy1548]

Yeah, it's my favorite Blue Sky movie as well. I rewatched it recently and man it's as good as I remembered. It's a real wholesome and heartfelt movie. It's one of those movies that I can rewatch over and over and not get tired of it.

[@SparklingWithNiGHTS-yv5fe]

*The Rio 2 Schraffmadness scene of this video was Comedy Gold*

[@zemufinman1639]

19:19 In middle school our PE class made us learn dancing and one of the dances they forced the whole school to do was "the sid"

[@roadkillrabbit6774]

The exact moment I realized Robots was a BlueSky film, and that you claimed you didn't feel passionately about any of these films, I knew you'd go back on it lmao

[@kellyrocheleau4660]

This man has managed to become more chaotic than he already was. And this isn't even his final form.

[@d7c388]

Correct. Look on his Twitter and see what he said about his next one…

[@abigailohara4560]

I know the whole daughter cliche thing was annoying in ice age, but as someone who lived through and is still living through them, It’s actually comforting… the whole 5 movies played a role in my life and I love them for it

[@estaextrana8486]

For me, Buck saved everything. I like Ice Age 5 only because Buck"s in it. Even in Buck Wild adventures, he is the only good thing in it, despite the bad animation. As always, Buck saves the day!

[@Yarr0000]

My heart and soul hurt for any of the ice age criticisms 🥲 It was my childhood and I couldnt bear to see him trash talk my comfort movie so I had to skip it My mom said ice age 1 was my first movie and I kid you not- I watched that over and over and over like a psychopath child the whole day and laughed a lot I don't really like other movies from the series other than ice age 1,2 and 4 but I gotta defend my childhood memories

[@estaextrana8486]

@@Yarr0000 Yeah he was a litle harsh on them. I didn't like how he tore them apart either. And I'm sorry you didn't realy like Ice Age 3. Of course, I am very fond of Ice 1, I love it, I always did, it's beautiful and incredible emotional. I think it's the only Ice Age I cried while watching it (besides the scene in Ice 3 where Sid says his goodbyes to his dino "children")but nothing can defeat Buck. He is the BEST, and will be the BEST thing about Ice Age. When I think of Ice Age, the first thing to come to mind, it's Buck.

[@estaextrana8486]

@PumpkinHead1021 The only thing that's realy BAD about Buck Wild it's the animation. Sure, it realy sucks that the original actors besides Pegg didn't return, but maybe somehow it could've worked if the animation was good. But yeah. It's not. The animation from 2022 it's worse than it was in 2002 when Ice Age first came out. Dishonor on Disney, and dishonor on whoever was in charge of animating Buck Wild. They destroyed Buck's own show and that's a CRIME

[@nrb3413]

@@Yarr0000 yeah, same here. As a kid, I loved ice age. it was just fun to watch. i watched the first four like three or four times on dvd and i never got tired of it. Maybe the criticism was valid but the child in me did not take it well 🥲

[@themothinyourroom9403]

That rio 2 segment was the best acid trip I've ever had

[@xeriiza]

"Dreamworks didn't even make 5 of their franchises, not even Shrek!" (1:56) Well that aged well.

[@carlopanis9020]

The Shrinch

[@viveleshistoires4874]

It took me a solid minute to get what this was about… Well played Schaff!

[@ZoruaMaster]

I don't quite get it yet

[@TheShuckmeister]

I've said it once and I'll say it again: Robots has influenced me more than any other movie growing up

[@kennymixter6475]

A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.

[@mantasma9024]

“You can shine no matter what your made of”

[@cardboardbox3787]

I am 9.9% sure in my head that James was drunk for that last sequence.

[@HaughtyToast]

Ice Age is remarkable in that it has a gradual downward slope of becoming less and less grounded until it becomes completely ridiculous, in the least fun way possible, while trying to play it off like the series was always like that.

[@far_and_near_26]

The Rio 2 section do be funny, but I miss the section about him bringing up Nimona. It felt good to see it get some recognition, and I did wanna see see how he reacted to it being picked up by Netflix

[@JaceAVinson]

The original version of this ranking was reuploaded. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fqPLaoZvpK9koLMsi=IbUlTwAmhsJaCN4f

[@krypticunlimited6925]

Blue Sky is everything you say it is, but I gotta say, Ice Age 1 is one of the most underappreciated movies of all time artistically speaking. The story and characters are genuinely really wonderful, and the humor is WAY better than people remember. Like I dont think people even realize how genuinely funny the movie is

[@TheQuashingoftheTub]

I'm kinda sad no one ever highlights the humans in Ice Age 1, and how the franchise itself kinda forgets they exist, because they are one of my favorite parts of early 2000's animation.

[@noodles_poodles392]

What I like so much about Ice Age 1 is that the movie wasn't afraid to show a dark and sad premise for the audience. The scene where they enter the cave with the cave paintings and where Manny cries because he lost his family (at least that's what he thought) is a really heartfelt moment. Not only that, that's why Manny gets the realization why he had to protect the baby and bring him back to his family. Love how this movie has good comedy and heartfelt moments into it. Love this movie to the bottom of my heart.

[@littlemeow124]

I love how, rather than simply reuploading the original video with the copyrighted music at the end removed, james completely removed the rio 2 section of the vid and redid the entire ending to him meme praising it as an april fools day joke. I bet the people who originally criticized him for ranking rio 2 over the original despite not liking it as much as the original must REALLY like this "fixed" vid

[@megapro1470]

What's so funny is that blue sky in all there 13 movies had more impact on me as a child than all of Disney.

[@shourya65.2]

❤

[@shourya65.2]

Same I also love both rio

[@ChirpyChips-vj4uo]

Whilst I’m disappointed at the lack of grevious and Sid episode 2. This has still made April fools day 💀

[@d7c388]

He said that will be next year

[@nicolemartinez4107]

I like your Dhmis profile picture. Have a good day :)

[@noaha6185]

I watched spies in disguise because of your original ranking vid. Its actually really good. I'd love a whole series set in that spy universe exploring different outlandish conceptual technology.

[@finalmountain]

Spies In Disguise is the one Blue Sky movie that would have made a great franchise if it had sequels

[@GooberInternet]

Well now you have to watch Rio 2 now because now it's the best movie. Do it. Peasant. You won't.

[@lucasdellamaggiore]

​@@finalmountain But you know, who actually needs that, right? Bring out Ice Age 6!

[@finalmountain]

@@lucasdellamaggiore I saying it could be a good franchise with good sequels if you don’t care then that’s your problem

[@lucasdellamaggiore]

@@finalmountain I was being sarcastic, of course it had potential to be a good franchise

[@mercedesswan7205]

The explanation of what happens in Rio 2, is so incredibly accurate, that it’s shocking! I remember it vividly now!!! Amazing! Thank you for reminding me of this fantastic piece of art

[@MC22816]

Glad to see u changed ur mind about Rio 2, I was rly mad when u rated it at the bottom in the first rating, but now I’m glad u saw because it’s a freakin mastermpiece, like it makes puss in boots 2 look puny. Everything about it was perfect, glad to see u saw it too 😊

[@aforkingfork]

*i pray to God that this is just sarcasm*

[@lessthan3...]

Schaffrilas always has the BEST April fools videos out of every KZbinr I’m not exaggerating no other KZbinr can do an April fools video like him

[@lukeskywalker9507]

This is just a reupload of the original video because that one was copyright claimed.

[@TheQuashingoftheTub]

@@lukeskywalker9507 Did you watch the end of the video? It's a direct response to the assholes on Twitter that bullied him over his Rio 2 placement.

[@TheQuashingoftheTub]

Seriously go find a timestamp comment to watch the Rio 2 segment

[@LuccaDoesStuff]

I wrote this comment on the original video so I’ll say it again to preserve it: I love that Schaff (or the editor for the _Rio_ section) used the _Angry Birds_ version of Nigel’s villain song. That’s still really cool.

[@freakfoxvevo7915]

I love the lore that both "snyder cuts" of the Schaffiverse (Shark Tale and Rio 2) have the exact same plot with small differences

[@dumbpro555]

Ok, so I come back from getting some tea, and I forgot to pause the video. When I come back, and put my headphones on, I hear schaff singing whatever the hell he sings near 39:00.

[@gametips1756]

That was the greatest cover I’ve heard all minute. Thank you, Schaff, for blessing us with this masterpiece. I am no longer sad dog

[@rediculashue1120]

In order to accept the peanuts' move as one of the best animated films is the fact that it stuck with the original characters' design and behaviors that were seen in the specials and the comics years ago. The fact that the only thing they changed was snoopy's love interest and that random pop song at the end of the movie really showed how far the animators were willing to go to keep the story original with out boring the people watching. And also the red barron was a conflict with snoopy in the comics and specials but they made it more interesting

[@StellaLuxNebula]

A kid at class saud "cars is such a great movie" i looked hin dead in the eyes and said "tf did you just say?" THE AUDACITY

[@mortytheorgre1500]

The rio 2 bit is a refrence to a nostalgia critic ytp called "doug walker's glowing review of shark tale" schaff did a while back, brings back memories actually

[@migsluna]

Rio 2 was so good of a masterpiece that Disney didn’t want Nimona to take that elusive best Blue Sky film spot, so they scrapped the movie and even the studio because how can any other film compete with Rio 2 (besides Nimona)?. At least Nimona was uncancelled by Netflix of all places. (So I unironcally hope the Nimona is a good film.)

[@FinnManusia]

Sure Netflix will take care of their animations...

[@maxhunke5166]

… the entire point of this video was to make Rio 2 memes… truly beautiful

[@takemeseriouslynt]

I think Robos suffered the most from their vision they got out during a weird time where most people were definitely pro cspiyalism with few concerns, robos was maybe far too different than your usual, and the craze was really about animals so i think that maybe a story similar could be revisited in more recent year and see how people would react

[@ignorant1126]

14:26 Wait, this scene was a dick joke? I thought the shadow was used to make Sid look like he was a mum caring for their child. The warm lighting and music plays into that too

[@ThatPancakeCat]

I always loved Epic. It's a generic story, yes, but the distance between Mary Jane and her father just feels so real and genuine. And the whole hidden world aspect, while it is very generic of course, is just a bunch of fun.

[@assassin8636]

It's not generic

[@odiedog]

The cover brought me to tears. It's a true masterpiece.

[@ZippyMcBeans]

list of Schaff's celebrity crushes: Tamatoa, Bigweld, -Yummo-

[@daseal1479]

Its great to hear the Robots love, one of my favorite movies as a kid, and I still remember it fondly to this day, it and Ice Age 1 are the top for me.

[@OtterPenguins]

My first reaction was “oh no” because this whole controversy was the stupidest thing someone could ever think of

[@tommymaxey2665]

28:45 that Dodo bird part was really funny "There goes our last female" is such an underrated joke

[@no_mnom]

I find it weird that they made Ferdinand a while movie when it's literally a children's book that's super short

[@MorganKing95]

Have you seen how short the original "Shrek" book is? While it's not common for movies based on very short books to be hugely successful, it's not impossible either

[@AtlasBlizzard]

Adapting short stories to feature films is nothing new.

[@steveelpro]

12:18 This is carved into my soul after watching the complete Bojack review

[@thewrench0157]

I was expecting a joke ranking for 40+ minutes, but this man fooled us all into watching a long ass video for the ad revenue. Honestly genius.

[@hhfggvogtthehy6451]

Ice age 5 is what happens when a studio can’t move on from a franchise and kick it back up again and again.

[@ZGURemixer]

11:45 I couldn't help but think of Bonzi Buddy when I first watched the film.

[@nprnilk]

I think it’s safe to assume Nimona would be ranked as the best BlueSky film.