Secret Letters? Vigano says Pope Benedict did NOT resign

[@DrTaylorMarshall]

store.taylormarshall.com for the Traditional Catholic Calendar nsti.com - Get all 10 Catholic courses when you enroll this month! Use promo code TAYLOR20 for 20% off www.twc.health/marshall - Be prepared for a crisis. Get up to $40 off your life-saving emergency kit now plus free shipping with code TAYLOR while supplies last.

[@facilegoose9347]

14:00 _Thesis..._ Not Hegelian, Marx-ish. The latter regresses to Spinozistic materialism (the Absolute Finite of Man in the image of his Creator in isolation is now 'like unto gods' and himself as the sole sentience in the materium the only 'god' as such, his own salvation-- we see this recapitulated with talk of Israel itself floated as the 'moshiac' as such ...) The _thesis-antithesis-synthesis_ shibboleth came to the English speaking world from a secondary work on Schelling and became conflated with German Idealism in general. PachaPapà in this schema views the Catholic Church as a vehicle for universalist perennialist-nominalism, aiming at progressive syncretization (i.e. _convergence strategy_ as applied to so-called 'spiritual science') in a farce ecumenical Bed of Procrustes. Per actual Hegel, the foundation of _Objective Freedom_ proceeds from Subjective Spirit's worldly actualization & apogee in Christian Religion/The Church, as in the moral community (of souls), which in turn gives content to The State which discovers ever higher resolution of Natural Law to mediate between persons-- all of this is the true object of _demoralization,_ because they are the _'superstructure of false consciousness'._ Perforce, The Enemy here is the late Sov. strategy of *convergence,* 'The Scissors', which ratchets the frame of reference out of moral/spiritual/intellectually honest alignment, and not anything remotely resembling _dialectic_ Greek, German or otherwise. Read Marx's _The German Ideology,_ Gramsci's _Prison Notebooks,_ and the Defector Literature; then compare against Hegel's Philosophy of Religion Lectures (Hodges' translations, or his commentary if time is an issue). You'll find a friend in the latter and exactly what the former misappropriated and bowdlerized and reverse engineered for lawlessness. Calling this out is a point of intellectual pride and a narcissistic injury for these types' intellectual stolen valor routine-- they are cunning, but all it takes is a familiarity with the primary source material. The following will serve as good QRDs Peter Hodgson, _Hegel and Christian Theology; and _Theologian of Spirit._ (natural secondary literature introduction for Christians.) Wallace Stace's _The Philosophy of Hegel._ (very efficient short overview) O'Regan, _The Heterodox Hegel;_ and _The Hermetic Hegel,_ by Magee. (Christian Kabbalah, Jacob Boehme, and Neoplatonic influences & Swabian intellectual culture context & influence) Harris', _Hegel's Ladder._ (extensive commentary) 15:40 _Supercession._ They abrogated the covenant and killed His Son. The 'dual' alternative looks like the very young heresy of British planted Dispensationalism (A. Crowley's family was of the original *Plymouth Brethren* sect; food for thought). Legions of Saints would run afoul of EU incitement speech 'crimes'. They constantly agitate for the New Testament _to be censored_ (like in rouge-China). The (___)daizers insisting on being a special intra-group caste of Super Christians was and remains a source of tension since antiquity.

[@GeraldHunt-i5q]

@DrTaylorMarshall there courses are not catholic because you ard not catholic. Go back to the anglicans. Once again you cast doubts on catholicism driving your listeners in to schism while riding the fence like a coward

[@Mike-qc8xd]

intention is everything. I am sorry I wish this could be true

[@andrew-c1y9b]

I believe, the LORD got in front of this present day mess by using Vat2 ...... The development of .the Emeritus teaching within the Vatican 2 documents projects the Activation of the Katechon Mechanism. Stepping 2 the side manoeuvre that B16 accomplished with his declaration and retaining all the trimmings of a double pope.followed his understanding of the Emeritus doctrine. Knowingly or not B16 has irreversibly broken the papacy. De coupling the Chair of Peter from the Keys of Christ. With the funeral of B16 5/jan 2023 the Keys have returned 2 Christ in Heaven. Expect an Ex cathedra, statement De Ranking the papacy before the next pope. My modelling does forecast pope PIZZA is next in line but, like Francis will be Keyless 2 restrain the approaching lawless1. Taylor, do you have any information on the Cave of Jeremiah and its discovery?

[@almy6071]

I agree 100% with Archbishop Vigano. He is a true soldier of Christ. May the Holy Lord continue to bless and protect him!

[@pchoi2002]

He needs to become Pope and revive the infiltrated Vatican and Catholic Church. This imposter they have in office is not of God. He is a representative of Satan. I hope Catholics can see this.

[@LUIS-ox1bv]

Archbishop Vigano is the firebrand, and voice n the wilderness the Catholic Church is in dire need of. People today, as they did with the late, Archbishop Marcel Levebre, do not recognize the very heroes within their very midst. Archbishop Vigano is but one of the clarions that many refuse to heed, listen or seriously consider.

[@bonniesammons2348]

I heard an SSPX priest say in reference to the Novus ordo “it may be valid, but it’s not pleasing to God”. That made total sense to me.

[@charlessupton]

How can something be valid and not be pleasing to God? God is the Lawgiver, the Arbiter and the Judge. What law can we invoke to establish the supposed validity of the Novus Ordo that supersedes the Law of God? That's what doesn't make sense; it is impossible on the face of it.

[@clivejames5058]

I live in a remote area. A priest only visits us twice a month so I have to accept Novus Ordo.

[@hospitallerknight7106]

You could make that statment about the SSPX itself lol

[@mopo539]

@@charlessupton Mam has done many things through error that are not pleasing to God. Our Priests will

[@mopo539]

Will have to answer for leading their flick astray. The Novus Ordo though may be valid does not give the same level of glory and honor to God as The Traditional Latin Mass. in the NO the Priests is in the “ Spotlight” in the Latin Mass GOD is our focus. There have always been errors but the smoke of Satan is becoming more prevalent with time. Look at the changes: Guitar masses, tabernacles in separate rooms/ areas, etc Do you think those things are pleasing to God? So many more errors. Then we can stray from the worship to our pedophile scandal. Are these things pleasing to God? A pedophile priest saying Mass? So many. Their errors not God’s.

[@remmymills3453]

Let Vigano unlock all of the truth. God is good.

[@luke9747]

Why do we care what a sedevecantist says. Follow the church, The Bride of Christ. It is nonsense to put yourself outside of the Bride of Christ

[@99plusone4Jesus]

I've never believed that Pope Benedict resigned. Always felt he was strong-armed into stepping down.

[@verainnoserve214]

I have always felt he was murdered

[@JanePurcell-v5d]

Love Archbishop Vigano 👏👏👏

[@uncomfortabletruth-nr3gv]

If thieves and robbers break into my home in the middle of the night and say this is our house now, what would I do? If I couldn't get to my gun fast enough , then I would at least try and get my family out to safety, call the authorities and have them thrown in jail. But I couldn't just sit in the house and pretend like nothing was wrong. It will be a glorious day when Our LORD and Our Lady fix this mess

[@patriciusborealis1708]

It all makes sense. As time passes, the situation should become even clearer.

[@finallythere100]

We’ll just not passing smell test . Benedict was such a Canon Law expert, he would not have made such a mistake. But all of that is speculation. It is not by the letter is all we need.

[@cynthialagraff4144]

I agree. I believe they forced Benedict out under threat to his brothers health.

[@DanielaMattos1980]

We haven’t had a Pope since Pius XII but more and more people will start seeing. AB Vigano is slowly saying the quiet part outloud. May God continue help Vigano, he is a beacon of light in this madness.

[@Gdblesstheusa]

I totally agree with Vigano! Add on to this paper, the problem of the Two Sister Lucy’s coming to the surface! It’s all coming out now.

[@paperclip612]

Absolutely agree.

[@BarbaraBelsky]

Like Obama wasn’t president. Corrupt hierarchy everywhere but God sees and will shake it out.

[@templehansen6072]

What is Two Sister Lucy's? Is there an article on it or a video?

[@paullukasik8698]

There is plenty of of info on the Internet about it​@@templehansen6072

[@mariamartin94]

@@templehansen6072See Sister Lucy Truth

[@c.jacobellis3289]

I often wonder if these people really believe in our Church, and faith, don't they ever realize that with all their BS, antics, corruption and games they will someday stand before Jesus?

[@Rain-xe5vr]

That's why it's quite obvious we're dealing with apostates here. You cannot believe in God and neither fear nor love him. If you love him, you would keep his commandments, if you feared him you would keep his commandments. These people obviously do not believe in God which makes them apostates.

[@markjoslin9912]

You’re right but I’m no longer sure they believe in or fear God. The church for them is just a money machine, to finance their heresies.

[@FrankBuchaski]

They are communists they work for satan

[@Patr4082]

NO MAN IS HOLY ONLY JESUS AND ABBA FATHER HOW CAN MERE MAN OVER WRITE JESUS' WORDS IN THE SCRIPTURES IT CLEARLY SHOWS ABSOLUTE APOSTASY. FRANCIS ADVISED US CATHOLICS TO TAKE THE VACCINE, ITS A GIFT FROM GOD REALLY???? LORD JESUS PLEASE HELP US BE OBEDIENT TO YOUR WORD NOT MAN MADE TRADITIONS YOUR WORD OMLY 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@pmg2120]

@@Rain-xe5vr Bingo. Best post I’ve seen in a long time.

[@patricialehle3750]

As you describe Vigano's view on the dissipation of the papacy, it left a cold feeling of realisation of the truth and reality of the "dual" papacy. Thank you for your analysis.

[@ReginaMcCarty-xk3rn]

100 % agree with VIGANO

[@KenDelloSandro7565]

If we're being honest with ourselves, we pretty much haven't had a Catholic orthodox believing Pope since Pio XII...and something happened with him towards the end of his reign with the whole Holy Week reformed Liturgy disaster.

[@lorichet]

And if we're being honest with ourselves, since Popes must be Catholic to be legitimate Popes, then we haven't had a Pope since Pius XII. The more I look into this, the more right I think the sedevacantists are right.

[@westtex3675]

How was the Holy Week reform a “disaster”?

[@charlessupton]

Pius XII might have served degeneration, but he didn't cross the thin line of apostasy: two very different things.

[@westtex3675]

What do you mean “served degeneration”?

[@sheilasamuels1066]

I grew up under Pius XII. I was terrified and could not believe God could love me because I was not perfect. It was such a relief to hear that I was a Child of God and could be saved.

[@espumatt]

What Viganò proposes sounds radical and revolutionary, but when you think about it, it feels just right.

[@DanielaMattos1980]

Absolutely

[@aidoan7795]

Holy Father Benedict XVI did not resign for sure , Cardinals in Vatican forced Pope Benedict out . Bishop Vigano very right and Bishop always telling the Truth . We love Vigano

[@mopo539]

Cardinal not Bishop

[@artifexdei3671]

So the conclave was invalid then? This means the church has been without a pope since Benedict's passing as he would've been a ruling pope

[@sheilasamuels1066]

There was talk that there was a lot of campaigning during the election. Some Cardinals spoke about it at the time. This is strictly forbidden to protect the true outcome.

[@missbell6080]

Benedict XVI. is/was not holy, and he would hardly earn this title If you consider what he said and did.

[@aidoan7795]

@@artifexdei3671 Don't you see and hear what False prophet BERGOGLIO =666 doing to our Church for almost 14 years ? he came to destroy Catholic Faith , he is Satanic , Communist and Democrat . BERGOGLIO is his real name 666 Revelations chapter 13

[@CRUSNET]

I agree with Abp. Vigano!

[@AmusedBabyPenguin-yt3vs]

Descent into Madness, Schizophrenia. No way out of this mess without the Light of the Holy Spirit.

[@marypalicke2387]

There’s always a solution and there’s always a way out. That is why we have faith in God.

[@MartaAcosta-d1n]

Ok, great, Bergoglio isn’t pope! The question is, since we have already determined this and if we believe it, what happens now? What are we going to do about it? Some consequences must be carried out; we can’t just let this guy keep living and acting as though he were the pope. What are we going to do about it?!? Let’s go, people!

[@williamwan5533]

Consider the historical example of Pope Innocent II, where the anti-pope was in charge of the bureaucracy in Rome for over 8 years.

[@Catticombs]

Matthew 16:18, that’s what we’re going to do. We’re not schisming.

[@mopo539]

We can’t do anything to him.

[@mopo539]

We can’t do anything to him. He also is not followed very closely. No lay people can remove him from office AND he has already appointed all of his partners in crime as Cardinals to surround him with more of the same

[@sheilasamuels1066]

One thing I have noticed is Francis has not made any infallible proclamations.

[@Mark3ABE]

The circumstances surrounding Pope Benedict’s abdication have always been quite clear. He was presented with a dossier, which he had commissioned, setting out the matters which would have to be dealt with urgently if the Church was to survive. Most of these related to the decision made by the Church in the 1980s onwards to attract seminarians by setting up homosexual clubs there and to attract into the Priesthood not men willing to give up sexual fulfilment in marriage to pursue a higher calling, but to attract in men wanting to gratify their homosexual desires in an environment protected (and financed) by the Church. Pope Benedict appreciated that this decision had resulted in the explosion of sex abuse cases which was threatening to destroy the Church. He also accepted that, as Prefect of the Holy Office and later as Pope he was personally responsible for much of this. He did what every other Prelate in the Church did - buried his head in the sand and locked the dossier away in a drawer. His Butler decided that the good of the Church required the contents of the dossier to be given to the press. So, we had the “Vatileaks” scandal. Once again, Pope Benedict followed the route of denial - attack the messenger and deny the problem. So, he had his Butler arrested, tried and imprisoned for acting in the best interests of the Church. Eventually, the strain became too much for Pope Benedict, and he ordered his Butler to be released and he then abdicated. He then lived a life of prayer and penitence. In his final book, “What is a Christian” (which the Church has done everything it can to suppress) he formally confirmed that setting up these homosexual clubs in seminaries was deliberate policy, as was the associated culture of deceit and secrecy. Pope Benedict resigned because he knew he was a failure and that his failures had destroyed the lives of so many young men - both the abusers, who were encouraged by the deliberate policies of the Church and the abused. He spoke often, with horror, of “these dreadful crimes” and the Holy Spirit convicted him of his complicity in these crimes. To his credit he remained true to the Faith and never taught error. He never sought to argue, as the German Bishops do, that good is evil or evil is good. He always assumed that the Faithful were reasonably intelligent - that they would understand why he abdicated - that he was making a point, in favour of the Truth - that it was no longer possible for the Pope to be a good, Catholic, Christian in the modern, corrupt, decadent, Church and that the Church now needed a “man for all seasons” who would bend to the spirit of the age, gain the whole world, but lose his own soul. A Pope who would be applauded by Communists and Muslims for destroying their ancient enemy, the true Church of Jesus Christ. The Church found someone willing to fill the role.

[@Verityhurtz]

Food for thought brother thank you. I’m a fairly new convert and trying to discern the truth when it comes to the Catholic Church is problematic on so many levels

[@murzua5]

I agree with everything you said. So how do we get our Church back now???

[@J93392]

Prayer and penance

[@murzua5]

​@J93392 there's not enough hours in the day for all the prayers and penance we need to do!

[@catherineford6201]

You are so right. Put God first ❤️🙏

[@elijeremiah1058]

Taylor Marshall is the man 💪💪

[@juicyjules7409]

Big words tho. Confusing 🤔

[@Rain-xe5vr]

And that's the problem. He needs to work on his humility and his poverty. Always after money, money money and so far up his own arse it's not funny.

[@elijeremiah1058]

@ I hope he never changes.

[@t090e]

Why? He has kept quiet about the truths of the matter for way too long...kching!

[@paullukasik8698]

Forward to the 13 minute mark if you don't want to hear the intro, self promotion, and advertisement

[@BeyondDeath868]

*Proverbs 30:5 “Every word of God is flawless; he is a shield to those who take refuge in him.*

[@John.Macdonald]

Explain this to me hot shot. Psalm 137 " ............Happy the one who takes and dashes Your little ones against the rock!"

[@rrodriguez9001]

From day 1 I felt Benedict had not resigned to his annointing to an office which is for life, one that was established by Our Lord and Savior, the only one of its kind. By his "resination" he delegated his administrative duties but not his pastoral duties. If you recall, after Bergoglio was selected, he himself asked that he not be called Pontiff, but instead to be referred to as "Bishop of Rome". I am no expert on this matter and do not know what rituals and sacramental processes are followed. However, I suspect Bergoglio may have skipped over some of those pertaining to the functions Benefict had retained, which then begs the question of whether he is pope or not...and whether Peter's chair is vacant or not.

[@JBQ86]

Very down to earth explanation of the statements of the beloved Archbishop Vigano.

[@margieciaccio6070]

I think Archbishop Vigano is spot on in his assessment of the papacy.

I agree a 100% with Viganò, and my Grandpa was the Commander of Swiss Guards under Pius XII, John XXIII and Paul VI, during the hole process of which you are speaking and same time Ambassador from Switzerland to The Holy See! I was born in 1965 and raised partially in the Vatican by that time as Member of the Papal Family, to which the family of the Commander of Swiss Guards belonged. Grandpa was even shot in 1958, because he objected to sympathise with the “nemici della Chiesa”... happily, he survived!

[@MMC-jp1gl]

We don't need letters or private convos. The speeches given by +Benedict himself along with his long time assistant +Ganswein say it all i.e. that there was a "new way" (modernist speak) that papacy was going to be done now. You can't do that. It's an all or nothing proposition unlike the "synthesis" mixed bag that +Benedict lived out until he died. This is a mess that needs to addressed. +Vigano is right. Bergogolio not only isn't Pope he isn't even Catholic anymore. And yes, this bat crazy all started at V2 when the Modernists scrapped the original schema and took over the Council and thus the Church. God bless~

[@Rain-xe5vr]

Started long before Vatican two, but Vatican two was the coming out party for sure....

[@pascendi88]

@@Rain-xe5vrprecisely. At V2 the modernists took over the institutional Church & since then they have held the keys.

[@MMC-jp1gl]

@@Rain-xe5vr Agreed. God bless~

[@irenemoreirataitson1677]

Thank you, Dr Marshall. Greetings from Brazil.

[@mariafalcon5397]

I agree with Archbishop Vigano, he did not resign.

[@DanielaMattos1980]

It does not matter, the problem is beyond Benedict XVI - he was not a Pope either.

[@boxpok364]

If there's any degree of truth to this hypothesis, I suppose it's good that the SSPX is so steadfast in its approach to traditional Catholism.

[@jerichothirteen1134]

The media seemed to hate Bendict. Without being obvious. Photos made him look like Dracula. Dark rumours were swirling at the time. May God bring the truth to light.

[@jamesMartinelli-x2t]

I knew it ! 1958 - Cardinal Siri was elected ( remember the white smoke up the chimney? ) and took the name Gregory. He was forced to resign and 2 days later Roncalli was "elected" - "John the 23". Pope Gregory died in 1989. Total confusion since 1958 !

[@joanhooper95]

Truth must be out ❤

[@Runsfrombears]

34:38 honostly we needed bergollio for people to wake up. Our Lord allowed it to happen. May his will be done!!

[@markjoslin9912]

All this can be solved by the Cardinals standing up for the faith and telling Francis enough. This needs to be done very publicly. Francis will unravel, the world will see the twisted petty man he is.

[@rf9612]

Thanks a lot Dr Marshall !!

[@markthomas6436]

As time goes on, I find myself more and more aligning my thoughts with Abp. Vigano. His clear grasp of the myriad issues in our time is unmatched. I consider him a modern-day prophet.

[@billbearback2591]

i find your volume too low , my laptop volume is at full as is my you tube , i wonder if any one else has this issue , thanks , love your work bra , cheers from down under

[@paullukasik8698]

Same here, I had to turn my volume up loud

[@lorih9182]

I had to turn my volume up about 3/4 of the way...and I have hearing like a bat 😅

[@jayalexander3356]

Same

[@elainehightower]

Something strange going on with the comments-where is the conversation?. Taylor, love ya man but the commercials for your book are too frequent.

[@Rain-xe5vr]

Taylor may be on our side but he loves money and he loves himself more than anything. It seems.

[@mariachico4456]

​@@Rain-xe5vr He has a family to feed.

[@angelacahill9460]

The Virgin Mary warned us all a long time ago about the apostasy in the Church.

[@bevceccanti5301]

It's beyond me. I just gravitate toward the Spanish Mass in my neighborhood...even though I'm not Hispanic. I don't speak Spanish. I don't need to. There's no question there is great belief and appropriate respect for the Eucharist. I never have to second guess.

[@johndoyle4416]

Challenging the direction of the papacy and, by extension, the church is a task that only a cardinal and not a Bishop can do, because only a cardinal is privy to the conclave.

[@paperclip612]

No more Secret Conclaves! - of utterly corrupt, dishonest red hats.

[@Basbw-z2o]

Cardinals and Bishops don't have discourse with each other? Maybe not all, but you have good camps and bad camps within. You will know them by their fruit. Frances has not shed any fruit, just the opposite.

[@Rain-xe5vr]

What about a two bit KZbin influencer?

[@johnfisher247]

Its is very clear from Pope Benedict's words and action, backed up by Mons Ganswein, who asked him to reconsider his decision that Pope Benedict intended and did resign the Papacy. How much clearer is it? Few think Pope Francis is a good or suitable man to be pope. However only the Cardinals and bishops can depose him AFTER his death. Francis will be judged by his actions, words and writings. I can assure you damning assessments of his false teaching once he is dead because Francis will not be able to punish them. A new Pope will not be able to forbid it. Yes there has been a process to dismantle Christianity in its application in society and life. This is from Catholics infecting the Church with ideas from secularity.

[@LUIS-ox1bv]

It remains a ridiculous and absurd idea, that Catholics have to allow Bergoglio to jackhammer the Church into oblivion and finally croak before anything can be done. This is preposterous, nonsense on its face. People today lack the conviction that comes with courage, and refuse to call a spade a spade. Hence heretics have their way. Degenerate and vile priests go about espousing falsehoods and living illiral liveds and are not defrocked or laicized. No one faces censure, consequences, nor penalties for grave transgressions against the Faith. Too many Catholics conflate acedia with true adherence. They simply don't care worth a lick,and don't care that they don't care. Doing nothing has never been the Catholic way. Never.

[@stephen8623]

Imo, it's hard to argue with Abp Vigano 's position. I absolutely agree with him!!!

[@LBinTX-c4x]

Wow! Vigano makes a compelling case. I had not previously connected Benedict with Hegel.

[@bevceccanti5301]

God bless Vigano.

[@kimsmith8972]

God bless. 🙏

[@AprilShowers1955]

Still praying daily for Pope Benedict XVI since he became Pope. Never believed Frances was pope. Frances believes he is pope.

[@chommie5350]

True a lot of people know that... His life was threatened....

[@charlessupton]

On p. 214 of INTRODUCTION TO CHRISTIANITY, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, who was to become Pope Benedict XVI, describes the notion of an immortal soul as “obsolete"---so how could he ever be considered in any sense a "Traditional Catholic"?

[@MichaelHowardMonroe]

In his encyclical Spe Salvi (2007), Benedict XVI discusses the Christian hope of eternal life, emphasizing the personal, eternal communion with God that believers anticipate after death. He articulated that the soul survives physical death and will ultimately be reunited with a resurrected, glorified body at the final judgment.

[@charlessupton]

If he changed his mind, why didn't he withdraw INTRODUCTION TO CHRISTIANITY from publication, or else revise it? (Maybe he did and I'm not aware of it.) But I tend to see this as one more example of the Novus Ordo tendency to speak out of both sides of the mouth, to sow ambiguity and contradiction as well as heresy---not to create a false theology but to invalidate the very idea of theology: "Doctrine divides, action unites." Likewise Francis in an interview with Vatican Radio that was on the Vatican website for years said "God does not exist" (though the 3 Persons of the Trinity do). But I'm sure than in plenty of other places he speaks of God as a reality. The effect of this ambiguity is not to enforce a false doctrine but to deconstruct the concept of doctrine itself, to spread not heresy but nihilism. A heretic asserts a false truth; Francis (and possibly Benedict) essentially say "there is no such thing as truth---no such thing as Christ, that is, who said 'I am the Truth'." This is pure postmodernism; if the Vatican is pursuing "aggiornamento," it will need to be as postmodern as possible.

[@MichaelHowardMonroe]

@@charlessupton could you post direct links to these quotes or paste them in context here?

[@missbell6080]

​@@charlessuptonexactly, Benedict was not better than the modernists, but started to destroy catholic beliefs from the beginning with his work at VatII - at first theologically and later fully open also practically as Pope. The Trick is to wordily click together contradictions and state, the destruction of faith coming out was a natural development within the church ("hermeneutics of continuity") - and most people falling for it thinking he was conservative for he protected the traditional mass. As a Pope it became clear He followed the same modernist line Like JPII, and later Francis.

[@laederefacile]

Karl Rahner disciple...

[@annap7678]

IF those letters were really written by Pope Benedict.

[@albertito77]

I hope that there is a genuine letter from Pope Benedict due to be released when Francis resigns or dies which declares him an antipope and all his Cardinals invalid. In order for there to be peace in the church, all of Francis' Cardinals would have to forfeit the conclave. Oh wouldn't it be lovely and that's what I would like for Christmas

[@Rain-xe5vr]

All that would do is begin a Civil War. there's no way those cardinals would step down. The church would fracture into 1 million schisms. Same as if they tried to excommunicate all those apostate bishops in Germany. this has been happening now for decades, simmering away behind-the-scenes. There are no quick fixes this will take Christ to fix it -- nothing less.

[@Chosen2021]

We already knew all this. All you have to do is listen to Andrea Cionci and Fr Minutella.

[@theresagoldschmidt8740]

Yes, also Ecole Hildegarde Bingen(French) podcasts.

[@benson0509]

Wouldn't the antithesis of the TLM be a black mass, not novus ordo?

[@Jesusiseverything2me316]

Im not trying to upset anyone but the current Pope gives me the chills

[@marypalicke2387]

Oh wow, I didn’t know which one to buy it for my aunt and so I bought the traditional one and then I was thinking I should’ve bought her the Marion one and now maybe I’ll go get the bundle and keep one for myself

[@dianaabbott6593]

Maybe Vigano can explain the doubts about why John Paul I was such a short pontificate.

[@josephnoneofyourbeeswax8517]

The status of Paul VI is also a source of controversy.

[@richardskaggs2711]

Your church is tearing itself apart under Frances. MARANATHA

[@fenianbastard6226]

The Irish word you’re looking for Malachi martin is “ seanachie “

[@mikev4089]

I will step up and be Pope if needed. All you need to do is like this comment and I will step up.

[@beeleeson6679]

Es, yes, yes! It goes back to Roncalli AND Catican 2.

[@beeleeson6679]

Vatican 2 (correction)

[@kathleenbush1676]

The Wellness Company sells Yoga equipment. I wish the company understood what they are pushing.

[@jodeemolitor3982]

This is such important news. We could vote in a new Pope soon. Blessed that Pope Benedict was the real Pope for much longer than thought!

[@rogerhayes2117]

The Church is not a democracy, "We" don't get to vote!

[@FourKidsNoMoney]

Who is going to vote at the next conclave? Something like 3/4 of voting cardinals will have been elected by Francis, so if he's not the actual pope how do you guys get out of this predicament?

[@johnf6267]

Need more volume. 👍

[@09mattmurray]

I agree these letters are important and this issue has some validity but it will never change the stream of infection within the church today. The only thing that will change it is God's Will and Christ's intervention...

[@robertepperson5422]

🎉John23rd was the first of the Anti Pope's and we have not had a Catholic Pope since 1958. Few who are that will find her Pray the Holy Rosary every day and have Faith in Jesus Christ our Savior

[@mrs.smilson5463]

And they knew it, that's why they didn't wear the Papal Tiara

[@fgallos]

JP2 seemed on the surface a trully catholic Pope, specially by his Marian devotion, but the horrible apostasy of the ecumenic act in Assisi and his kissing of the Coran revealed the rotten reality of the Catholic Church

[@billwelch9431]

@Drtaylormarshall Please explain this to us, particularly the part with the allegations against the Vatican and about worshipping Lucifer, etc. For the live of God tell us it isn't true. God bless you

[@jeanaustin4639]

The SSPX will lead the church out of this mess!!

[@PaulTuttle-wb9cu]

Half the screen is advertisements?????

[@tinadavy3990]

Any way you can shorten your podcasts... Want to know... but we're short on time ❤

[@robertcarr272]

The archbishop is exactly correct in his thorough critique of the Hegalian dialectic of the revolutionary process of dismantling of The church. We could also look deeply into the conclave of 1958... and the first election of Benedict XVI (the first - Guiseppe Cardinal SIRI)😉

[@davegaetano7118]

Canon law lists specific requirements to obtain an annulment for a marriage. Canon law also lists specific requirements for the resignation of a pope. When it comes to a marriage annulment, Canon law must be followed strictly. Why would anyone think that Canon law does not have to be followed strictly when it comes to the resignation of a pope?

[@Lancer-y5g]

An annulment is just an opinion and can be in error. It is not infallible. A Catholic tribunal burned Joan of Arc at the stake. You are living in a fantasy world if you deny the annulment scandal in America since the 1970’s. Several US diocese have a 100% finding of nullity with their tribunals. The church can be in error.

[@westtex3675]

I do not believe this is accurate. A pope resigning is not a sacrament. There is no special procedure in the code, as far as I know.

[@davegaetano7118]

​@@westtex3675 There are Canon Law procedures for this.

[@westtex3675]

@davegaetano7118 What procedures?

[@davegaetano7118]

@@westtex3675 Canon 332 §2 of the Code of Canon Law provides that: “[i]f it happens that the Roman Pontiff resigns his office, it is required for validity that the resignation is made freely and properly manifested but not that it is accepted by anyone.”

[@Newz_Bro]

As Steve Pieczenik states, unfortunately, Pope Benedict was weak in courage, he blended himself in the German youth Corps to survive.....

[@SarahFoale]

Wow! Blessings to you-thank you for your comment. However, I believe Pope Benedict XVI displayed the virtues of Fortitude, Wisdom, Humility, Fear of the Lord, Compassion, Knowledge & fulfilled the Holy Will of Our Lord Jesus Christ! I was extremely Blessed to have been a pilgrim at World Youth Day 2005 with Pope Benedict XVI, the same year of St John Paul II’s Death. Throughout my lifetime, both Benedict & John Paul II have significantly touched my heart & blessed my Faith. In saying this though, I hold extreme fondness & respect for many Popes pre Vatican 2, but both Benedict XVI & JP2, will always remain Special in my eyes. Hallelujah

[@canden-t7w]

The Biblical Jesus Christ is real love, hope, goodness, the universal King and very much real.

[@moiraeastman1997]

The current situation in the church goes back to John 23. The church has been and is being overturned. Since Vatican 11.

[@theresarichard797]

Agree 100 percent with archbishop

[@WT-Sherman]

The intent of Benedict XVI would outweigh the wording of a letter.

[@lydiapicano8806]

I always believed that Pope Benedict was forced out. If you remember he looked so sick when he left the papacy and then a few years later looked quite healthy. Also, our faith has been chipped away since Vatican II. Vigano's point does make alot of sense .

[@49patmac]

Wow you’ve chaged Taylor. What happened to prayer at beginning and ending of your videos?

[@lorih9182]

He still does prayers when he does videos about theology or faith.

[@tomchambers1977]

My fave is Pius v

[@joshua1.9DouayRheims]

What dose this matter ? Is this going to remove Francis ?

[@paperclip612]

Perhaps, with a bit of Divine Intervention.

[@dukeofpurl]

Right on! Lot of talk - NO action.

[@kathleenchristinedivalerio1041]

Sad I made comments before and they are not here! Says there's only one comment… Even though I made three of them before it started

[@FlatBlackLak]

the lack of comments is very strange for this channel.... 😒

[@jumpmasterpadre9335]

Simply re-state your comments, or go away. These things happen.

[@tanya9463]

​@@jumpmasterpadre9335 It's your first comment don't be nasty to the top commenter.

[@PoisonShot20]

AI are every where. Even videos desapearing.

[@jumpmasterpadre9335]

@ Don’t be triggered by the truth. Re-state or go away. These things happen.

[@10Fritz-2]

With this new information it still sounds like there are pieces missing. Somethings do not connect. Still remember when Francis went and met with Pope Benedict 16th after he moved into his cottage. That expression on Benedict, he looked a bit ashamed. At least that what I seen. I still think there are pieces missing. I think this whole started 11 years ago.

[@lorih9182]

No. This started 65+ years ago. At least on paper. It actually started earlier with the "enlightenment" as they like to call it.

[@genemyersmyers6710]

Are you just now finding this.

[@sanctifyme4543]

Yes Taylor..the Church was literally divided..seeming like two Popes....but it does bring into question the legitimacy of Francis.

[@OrlandoArquiza]

He started it all, source of chaos, for those secularized due to boredom, more feedup, who do not want sacramentalized but evangelized there the synthesis of FAITH

[@myrnaleon8464]

I'm afraid it all started since Pope Paul V1 . 😮😮😮

[@DanielaMattos1980]

We have not have a real Pope since Vatican II. AB Vigano is finally saying out loud… what others called ‘sedevacantista’ but in truth is just simply Catholic

[@AmberlyssaMarie]

Pius XI is my fave!

[@Mark3ABE]

No Pope has ever been perfect. Consider Pope Pius IX. Expelled from his dominions by the Roman Revolution of 1848, he was advised by holy advisers to remain in exile until the Roman people invited him to return. Then, he was presented with temptation. The French Emperor, Louis Napoleon, a ruthless and treacherous self serving adventurer, who had sent French troops to Italy, with the original intention of preventing the return of the Pope to power, changed his mind and decided that, instead of handing over the Pope’s territories to King Victor Emanuel II in the hope of an alliance with him against Austria, he would simply take the States of the Church for himself. He restored the Pope to power as a mere puppet, subject to the authority of a French Governor-General. He stripped the Pope’s territories of their resources - he even ordered the Roman Mint to debase the silver currency, which resulted in the States of the Church being unceremoniously expelled from the Latin Monetary Union. Then, when he went to war with Prussia, he withdrew the French garrison and the Pope was finally forced from his abject position as a powerless French puppet ruler. He was fortunate not to be lynched by the Roman mob - fortunately King Victor Emanuel II arrived in time to restore order.

[@user-re2ss3jn8w]

Multi generational problem. I believe Benedict resigned. The moment Bergoglio stepped out on the loggia, I knew he was a fraud. Benedict being alive and looking and acting more like a pope than Frances gave us hope.

[@studiautoribressan542]

True

[@williammartinjr.3627]

JPXIii mocked our Holy Mother & Fatima children to whom it fell to reveal. PPVI authored the destruction of the Church & Faith. JPIi & PBXVI brought in Ecumenisim & opened door to idol worship (Assissi).

[@leoniea138]

Now he was under duress ...amazing how much intel connected to this that people don't know

[@danielbraun6621]

When Richard Nixon resigned he resigned from the office of the presidency not from the exercising of the office of the presidency. One sentence, short and concise.

[@Canetracker92]

If his intention was to resign, then he resigned.

[@davidparker2173]

Christ said that the gates of hell of would never prevail against the assertion of his church, but he never laid mention about the gates of his church, or whether they would ever be breached. Buddha did not want women to enter into his order because he wanted his religion to last at least 500 years. He finally gave into their desire to get onboard, but perhaps his strong warning helped form greater ladies, guided by ego free enlightenment.

[@chilpericmerovee9819]

Pope BXVI has been coerced and did never abdicate. Case of Sede Impedita as explained by Andrea Cionci (see video "Dies irae"), Padre Cornet (book "habemus antipapam") and Padre Georgio Faré.