🚫😲Serious Errors in Tablighi Books⚠️| Fazail-Ul-Amaal | Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq

[@MoreDawaah]

It’s surprising how some people comment without even watching the video. Shaykh Uthman’s message is very clear and easy to understand. This is NOT a refutation of Imam Zakariyya Kandhelvi (may Allah reward him for his noble intentions). The Shaykh’s main concern is with the Tablighi Jamaat’s insistence on promoting this particular book. He highlights that the book does not merely contain weak ahadith but also includes FABRICATED ahadith-lies attributed to the Prophet ﷺ. Such a book should not be given to regular people as a casual read, as they lack the knowledge of hadith literature and its gradings. There are numerous authentic books that can be promoted instead. The continued attachment to this book suggests that their primary focus is not adherence to the Sunnah but allegiance to their Jamaat. May Allah guide us all to prioritize the Sunnah and truth.

[@mohammadfaizan5076]

@@MoreDawaah Please ask Shaykh Uthman to make a video about tableeghi jamaat and their impacts on Muslim Ummah and individuals, Please ask shaykh Uthman to point out their sacrifices, What is the motive behind their work? We want to know, Can he do it? No he wont. JazakALLAH brother.

[@MoreDawaah]

He's done that already. Years ago he made a video on his journey with them.

[@freethinking1-1]

Changing version! Since small we always hear wahabi imams putting great emphasis on reading kitab ut tawheed of ibn abdul wahab , it is your great imam by the way, but go and count how many weak and fabricated ahaadith are there in his book? Albani said. Please tell uthman to do a video to tell that his book is as well dangerous, he will not as he is dishonest. And so on kitaab us sunnah etc..... And it is more dangerous because in aquidah we are not allowed to use weak ahadith! Aquidah =sahih or mutawaatir! So do a video preventing people from reading such books. Go to youtube , you will see wahabi scholars encouraging people to read these books . Very dangerous for our tawheed!😂

[@freethinking1-1]

And the concerned book is only for fadaail and not aqueedah! And his comments on mawdoo ahadith in the book are false. I wrote in the comments. Some hadith many ulama considered them to be weak but only few said that it is possibly fabricated, why? Because they did not come accross some proves to accreditate it, then they say لم أجده , i did not find it, so on my conditions it is fabricated. But it is too difficult for u , since this requires so much knowledge, stay in your dawah field and dont create new fitnahs to get popularity ! God bless u

[@naushadali1122]

See the benefits brother due to this dawah work and sacrifice done by people which is the duty of every Muslim. There are so many mosque all over the world bcoz Allah helped these people in the great work they were doing, which the Prophet pbuh himself did by meeting individuals in person.

[@arep1030]

Pointing out the weakness of fazail amal without crediting the tablighi jamaat for their impact on Muslims around the world and Islam itself is a bit unfair. Even as a Muslim who prays 5 times a day myself, going out in the path of Allah with the tablighi brothers has changed me completely as a Muslim. And im not the only one. People and even Muslims may undermine the efforts done by the tablighi jamaat but Allah knows best. Even for me ive seen so many people who changed for the better because of this effort. May Allah reward all my brothers who sacrificed themselves, their time and money to revive the deen with the highest jannah

[@nazeerpasha2075]

The mission of Tablighi Jamat ..... Spreading heresy and disbelief. THE REALITY OF TABLIGHI JAMAT... Calling Muslims towards the pristine teachings of Islam or reviving Heresy? Some quotes from the book 'tasee'h-ul-kha'yal' written by Mufti Naval ur Rahman Deobandi,Ameer of Sharia Board of America, Chicago, USA 1. Page 147, Dead body fights back with the person , who is giving him a wash. 2. Page 147.Dead body admonishes his heirs for not burying him in his desired place. 3. Page 147.Dead body makes a shrill cry, when place in the grave and all the creatures run away. 4. Page 147, Dead persons found sitting on their graves and listening to the birds. 5. Page 110, Graves , where the invocations of the distressed are accepted. 6. Page 105, Praying for rain through the 'waseela' of dead person. 7. Page 105, Praying for rain through the 'waseela' of a 'janaza' 8. Page 105,Praying at the grave of Musa bin Jafar , when facing difficulties. 9. Page 101, Allah writes a letter to Ali bin Mu'af'faq. 10.Page 101. Receiving fruits from the shirt sleeves of Maruf Karkhee. 11.Page 113. Khizar advises Umar bin Abdul Aziz. 12.Page 113. Khizar is alive 13.Page 113. No calamity to overtook Baghdad, because of 4 'awliya-allah' 14.Page 152. Reciting one Quran in between 'maghrib and eeisha salat' Reciting one Quran every night Reciting 3 Qurans in a day. 15. Page 152. Buying a 'hoor' after reciting 4000 Qurans. 16. Page 157. A cow in labor pleads to Hazrat Eesa for easy delivery. 17. Page 157. Dua and taweez for easy delivery. 18. Page 108. Rubbing the cheek on the grave of Rasool e Akram, when in distress. 19. Page 108. Getting a message from the grave of Rasool e Akram. 20. Page 108. Hungry man's plea at the grave of Rasool e Akram 21. Page 146. Witnessing 'an'waar' before death. 22. Page 146. A 'janaza' goes up in air and people were unable to catch it. 23. Page 146. A dead body bites its own hands. 24. Page 146. A dead body laughs , while being placed in the grave. There are many more..............

[@ShahrukhKhan-gi9fg]

Good deeds + prayers + best character = Building materials. The Correct Islamic creed= Land. The tablighis are working hard to sold the building materials but what's the use of it if you don't have the land to make the infrastructure. Their creed is corrupted compared to mainstream islamic faith and good deeds alone without right faith are meaningless. You should read more about the beliefs of tabligi jamaat founders along with Deobandis. Even the hypocrates during the time of Prophet(SAW) pray 5 times , kept beard etc.,then will they be granted Jannah based on that?

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Fazael e Aamal...just flipping through a few pages is enough to reveal the creed and heretic deviant teachings of Sufi Zakaria.

[@arep1030]

@ShahrukhKhan-gi9fg My brother the only reason it is called 'deobandis' is because they are differentiating themselves from the barelvi, who do all these innovations in the subcontinent, then there's the qadianis and whatnot. In subcontinent of india, they are the true Muslims in every sense of the word. I used to study the deen under teacher who studied in pakistan and i have no doubt about his aqidah. You know one of the signs of munafiqeen during the times of prophet? Of course there's the famous hadith, when they speak they lie etc, but also the signs is they don't come to fajr and isyak prayers because it was dark so nobody will knew any way, and the don't go out in the path of Allah when it's hot and sunny, ie the condition is hard for them. Have you ever go out in the path Allah? Do you even have the intention? Please don't believe everything you've seen online. I have met people who dreamed of the prophet the first time he went out with the jamaat. When people make money based on Islamic lectures and videos, these people spend their own money in the path of Allah to call people back to Allah

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@arep1030 Deobandi Brelvi sects originated in Indian subcontinent. Deen e Islam started from Makkah.

[@altafnazir]

no book except quran is 100% perfect in the world

[@imadkashif6024]

None! None! None! of the scholars/Authors have ever challenged nor they said that their books are 100% Correct!!!! They say that “I tried my best to bring in those stories or words that people can take it heart and come closer to Allah”.

[@BilalAhmed-sw5jb]

True ✔️​@@imadkashif6024

[@simple-eastner]

But Fazael has non-sense at another level, SEEing ALLAH in a dream level. Do you believe as a muslim believe someone can SEE ALLAH, even in a dream? In Fazael Amaal, Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal saw ALLAH in his dream, had asked certain questions as mentioned in the Virtues/Fazael of Quran. This is a very BIG claim, so needs a proof. Does Mr Khandelvi give any proof of where he got this unique information un-known to other Muslims? Did any of Sahaba (RA) have such an experience? No. Sufis do talk this kind of non-sense stuff. Hint is in the question: What does An Arab Imam Hanbal ask Allah in dream? About Ajr of reading Quran without understanding. Why would an Arab, an Imam-Alim talk abt reading Quran without understanding?

[@moosahatim8324]

Mashallah perfectly we have to understand properly

[@simple-eastner]

@@imadkashif6024 "come closer to Allah”? how does lies and horrible non-sense be used is the name of Islam? Fazael Hajj has lies like Prophet(SAW)'s hand came out of his grave, when Ahmed Rafai read a naath at his grave. Proof? No proofs for lies. Why don't these people at declare these to be mistake or at-least revise this book? And pray for forgive of the mistaken author. I can give you more such non-sense from their book, but no use.

[@parvaizshah9274]

I know tablighi jammat people working in remote villages where masjids were abandoned and no azaan in masjid theses brothers made effort and all praise for Allah these masjid azzan was started and villagers started praying Salah.

[@makeknowledgerational7655]

Bro good things of anyone can't make their wrong deed right .... Salute for good work of Tablighi jamat but they must amend their weakness ❤

[@khanabrar5304]

Its good work .. no doubt .. but look at the material they are teaching from....and look at the impact on generations after generations ... these ppl have closed their ears and hearts to Authentic Source... They are programmed and they close their hearts to hear correct information... Just follow Quran and Authentic Hadith..

[@nafeezabolia9724]

Subhaan Allah

[@faisalchowdhury1945]

Guidance comes from Allah. People should teach from the Quran and the Sunnah , not made up Hadiths.

[@yongzeal]

Doesn’t matter if foundation is weak. Read and check before it’s too late.

[@mohammadfaizan5076]

May ALLAH forgive shaykh zakariya for his mistakes, may ALLAH reward shaykh zakariya for his efforts for this deen, But i can say all by my heart no one is doing more sacrifice than tableeghi jamaat for this deen in this era. And ALLAH knows best.

[@rms74044]

My Allah forgive your parents and you

[@mohammadfaizan5076]

@@rms74044 ameen 😂

[@casilasgoaler]

that's an emotional statement, there's no proof whatsoever saying that Tableegi people sacrificed their life for Islam. They don't even follow the proper Sunnah guidelines of Dawah, so what Islam are they promoting, nonetheless, their Iman is also filled with corrupted beliefs, so what nonsense you are talking man?

[@jameelbombaywalaansari4985]

Which aqeedah is currepted just tell me one of their please let me also know ​@@casilasgoaler

[@abu-umarahmed7308]

Exactly their ideology stems from sufism.

[@reflex.pubgmobile]

Whatever he is doing now, all his deeds goes to the thableeghi man who saved him from gang members in the first place. Now he thinks those books are false, it changed millions world wide, Allah accepted it. Thableegh teaches you hikmah and humbleness.

[@a.m.9357]

He is not saying tablighi are wrong. He is saying 'some' hadeeths are false, made up. Tablighi do a great work of spreading Islam and helping people with prayers, etc. But they keep insisting on that particular book which contains false hadeeths. That's all.

[@reflex.pubgmobile]

@a.m.9357 These are books written by top level ulama of the world. There are thousands of alims coming out every year from this institution. We dont need advice of gangster shaikh. Btw this book is to encourage people to do more amaal and good deeds. That you can see from thableeghi people.

[@a.m.9357]

@@reflex.pubgmobile He is not a gangster, he also brought many people in the right paths in Islam. Stop your prejudices. Fazail e Amal has been criticised for decades by many many scholars for containing false hadeeths and information, not only Sheikh Uthman. Search on KZbin and you will find. As I said, Tabligh does a great job, but when something has been pointed out as false by so many scholars, you have to admit your mistake and correct them. Nothing wrong with that.

[@yongzeal]

What the heck! Tableeghi Jamat would have been correct he still would have been with him and me as well. It doesn’t matter how Shirk or Bidah looks good but they are poisons .

[@hanifdalal-zr3gj]

​​@@a.m.9357 There are no false hadith in that book bro.. These are very high profile ulama.. and they well know wat they doing.. Yes weak hadith may be there.. BUT according to wat we know about weak hadith.. if they are pertaining to fathail/virtios of deeds..( and NOT mathail).. they are acceptable by vast majority of Ulama of all schools.. And Allaah knows best

[@ShakeelAhmed-lc6xy]

Brother if you found fabrication then write to Darul uloom Deoban about it and let them check this and revert back to you. instead of publishing a video to divide the ummah and creating a doubt about the work which has been carried by tabligh e jamat . our elders are very clear about seerat of prophet muhammad ( pbuh) and seerat of sahabah.hayat tuz sahabah for all the guidelines...brother shaykh uthman itself a effort of tabligh jamat (4month/40days/3days etche has given time) and may allah guided him towards seeking more knowledge. Ameen...if we bring 10 new reverts to islam and we are loosing 1000 + muslims loosing eman and not following shariah. Our young generation are misguided and becoming addicted to drugs and mobile phones.10% to 15% attendance in masjids no one worries about it. surely we have to invite our non Muslims brothers to Islam but same time don't you see a big hole in your bucket. May Allah bless us guide us unite us Ameen, Jazhakhallah khair

[@ImranAli-tm3rq]

These 'ulema' from tablighi jamaat strictly follow a book for their taleem every day that has lies in it (fabricated hadith)..why do they allow this book that contains fabrication?

[@simple-eastner]

"effort of tabligh jamat (4month/40days/3days etc....)"- All this is based on Dreams of Moulana Ilyas. Sorry Jamaat was started based on these extraordinary(impossible) dreams kzbin.infoUgkxMaTv12XuYL25ga4OIpqCfhSGQjWHfyCk. Why Impossible because grave of Nabi(SAW) has been and is one of the most guarded, specially since the time of Crusades. And is now run based on this kind of dreams: kzbin.info/www/bejne/g57dZH6wjtN2e9k. Alas as per these people Nabi(SAW) is coming in dreams for Moulana Saad. Why did not He(SAW) come in dreams of Suhaba(ra) for Usman(ra) or Ali(ra) or Hussain(ra) to stop the Fitna before they were being killed? Please fear Allah and save your Akhira.

[@Lithiumwater]

The the whole movement is has British origins from British India. Phony sects that litter India/pakistan

[@nafeezabolia9724]

Aameen

[@moosaadia2217]

I agree with this comment. I will stop following this sheik.

[@hafizhamza-i4k]

Moulana’s zakariya ra was a great great Islamic Scholar. May Allah Rest him peace in Jannah. This is a great book read all over the world. Why are you against Tablighi Jamaat?

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Zakaria Kandhalvi's life mission was to spread heresy and disbelief. Tablighies and Deobandi believe that the Prophet is alive in the grave , listens and helps • The propaganda of the 'aqeedah that the Messenger of Allaah (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) is alive in his grave, listens to us and has the knowledge of the Unseen • The author of Fadhaa.il A'maal, Muhammad Zakaria Kandalvi believed and wanted to propagate that the Messenger of Allaah is: • a) alive in his grave and listens to us; b) has the knowledge of the unseen.

[@RohaanAsif-s3x]

​@@nazeerpasha2075 I have read many of your comments, and in every single one of them, all I see is hatred and ignorance. If you enjoy talking nonsense this much, why don't you come for a debate?

[@MDKAIFALAM-l9v]

​@@nazeerpasha2075yes prophet Muhammad SAw is Alive in his grave according to Barzkhi jindagi ❤❤ Lol do research

[@TablighiJamaat-sh6wc]

@@nazeerpasha2075 Maulana Zakariyya was one of the greatest Hadith Scholars of our time He was a Sheikhul Hadith for more than 50 years Maulana Zakariyya taught Hadith for more than 50 years. He was the Sheikhul Hadith of Mazahirul Uloom Saharanpur, a position which is impossible to obtain unless someone has dedicated his life to the science of Hadith He authored so many books of Hadith Commentary Amongst Sheikh Zakariyya's major works include: Badhl al-Majhud (Abu Dawud commentary) Al-Hall al-Mufhim (Muslim commentary) Al-La'ali al-Dirari (Bukhari commentary) Awjaz al-Masalik (20+ volume Muwatta commentary) Khasa'il al-Nabawi (Commentary on Shama'il of Tirmidhi) These book are still used until today He was invited to Madinah by Saudi scholars and passed away there. Due to his extensive works in Hadith, he was invited to migrate to Madinah by the scholars there (allegedly Sheikh Bin Baz also invited him). In 1973, at the age 75, he eventually migrated to Madinah and passed away 9 years later in 1982. He was buried in Jannatul Baqi.

[@alfarooqraut2133]

What have you done for the sake of Islam?? What is your contribution towards Islam???? Spreading hate???

[@beerquadriceps]

Have been following Shaykh Uthman's Dawah since long & like his street dawah programs w/ Christians, Atheists and others. But he keeps coming up w videos criticising & ridiculing Tablighi Jamaat. While healthy criticism is beneficial for the Ummah at large but I've noticed how ppl in the comments keep defending the Jamaat w references & credible logic. This shows how many lives the Tablighis have enriched. May Allah unite us & guide us all, ameen. 🤲🏻

[@abdullamomak3470]

References and credible logic? I don't know in what world you're living in. I haven't seen a single comment giving references to any books, the blind followers of this group just know how to slander & insult people giving references without a valid counter argument against those references because of their laziness & insincerity

[@king_panda1387]

​@@abdullamomak3470 yes there is go and look.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Did the Prophet permitted seeking intercession from the Dead? • Coming back to our topic of grave worship, Kandalvi stated 80 years ago in very explicit words the virtues and benefit of grave worship of grave worship• Fadha'il Hajj, Page 138: • "When you see the green dome then it should be with awe and reverance and you should take care of the honour of the Huzoor and reflect that in that pure dome is he who is the best of creation, leader of the Prophets and virtuous the angels. The place of the holy grave is superior than any other place and that place which touches the holy body of the Huzoor is superior to the Ka'bah, superior to the Arsh, superior to the Kursi in fact superior than everything in the heavens and earth."

[@jka3062]

​@@abdullamomak3470yes they have. You are an extremist arrogant type who doesn't want to hear otherwise. Remember tabligh has done more than any modern "salafi" sect. Tabligh is one that encourages the best rational thinking. And 4 hadith perhaps out of 4000 - and the author did not hide out the full Arabic.

[@Hussycrafts]

Bro this is not an original Shaukh uthman this is a fake AI.

[@ReclusiveWealth]

Narrated Al-Mughira: I heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "Ascribing false things to me is not like ascribing false things to anyone else. Whosoever tells a lie against me intentionally then surely let him occupy his seat in Hell-Fire." I heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "The deceased who is wailed over is tortured for that wailing." : Sahih al-Bukhari 1291 : Book 23, Hadith 49

[@ReclusiveWealth]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn that answers the whole thing

[@ReclusiveWealth]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn avg tabligi guy be like

[@ReclusiveWealth]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn hah biddati

[@ReclusiveWealth]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn ur blind fr 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn Did Prophet permitted Grave Worship? In Fadhaa.il Durood, p.97, Incident no (Hikayat) 35: The Messenger of Allaah (allegedly) said: ((Whoever wants something from anyone should go to his grave and supplicate to Allaah for it)) Again on page 109, Incident number (Hikayat) - 48, Fadhaa.il Durood (The last chapter in Fadhaa.il A'maal, Vol.I): "Sh. Abu Khair Qattah said that: I went to Madeenah and stayed there for five days but did not achieve the pleasure and satisfaction. I went to the graves of the Prophet, Hadhrat Abu Bakar and Hadhrat 'Umar and said, "O Messenger of Allaah I am your guest tonight." Then I left the place and slept behind the minbar. I saw in my dream that the Prophet of Allaah with Abu Bakar on his right, 'Umar on his left and 'Alee was in front of them all. Hadhrat 'Alee then shook me and said that the Messenger of Allaah has come to visit me. I got up and kissed the Prophet between his eyes. The Messenger of Allaah then gave me a piece of bread which I ate half and when I woke up the other half was in my hand."

[@VocalArtist2025]

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim ! (Fatwa: 973/749/D=1431) The one who said that the hadith of Fazail Amal are mauzoo he told a lie made accusation. Of course, some hadith are weak, but they can be relied and practiced in the chapter of virtues as per the view of the majority of Hadith scholars. Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best Darul Ifta, Darul Uloom Deoband, India

[@HasanDalal-g4s]

❤

[@samsudeenm5264]

Brother if you found fabrication then write to Nizamuddin markaz about it and let them check this and revert back to you.instead of publishing a video to divide the ummah and creating a doubt about the work which has been carried by tabligh jamat . Nizamuddin markaz is very clear about seerat of prophet muhammad ( pbuh) and seerat of sahabah.hayat tuz sahabah for all the guidelines...brother shaykh uthman itself a effort of tabligh jamat and allah guided him towards seeking more knowledge....if we bring 10 new reverts to islam and we are loosing 100 + muslims loosing eman and not following shariah..our young generation is misguided and become addicted to drugs and mobile phones.10% to 15% attendance in muslim mohalla.no one worries about it.surely we have invite our non muslims brothers to islam but same time dont you see a big hole in your bucket.May allah unite the ummah . Jazhakhallah khair.

[@fareen968]

You can question from your markaz

[@mohammadwasimofficial9479]

We all have come to know all this only today, otherwise who knew these things, isn't it brother? And the Sheikh is the first one to make these videos, otherwise the poor Tablighis don't know anything, right? What are you saying, just think, how many scholars and people are there who were Deobandi earlier and then became Salafis after reading these books, think a little and then say brother, it is not right to defend everything like this.

[@Haleembostan]

A REAL SHYKH N MUFTHI WOULD DEAL THIS MATTER BEHIND CLOSE DOORS LIKE THE 4 IMAMS DID MAY ALLAH BLESS THERE SOUL WHY YOU SHYKH UTHMAN MADE THIS PUBLIC. THOSE TALBLIGH BROTHERS HOW MANY MUSLIMS THEY TOOK BACK TO MOSQUE AND PUT THEM IN STREIGHT PATH SO ACCORDING TO THIS SHYKH INVITING MUSLIMS BACK TO MOSQUE TEACH THEM HOW TO READ THE QURAN AND SALAAT ARE THESE TABLIGHI BROTHERS WRONG .IN MY EYES MAY ALLAH BLESS THEM FOR THERE DEEDS AMEEN

[@ebunurah6162]

@@Haleembostan the book is publicly out there all over the world. So he is just warning the borthers and sisters who read the book. Of course he is going to do it publicly. It's not an issue to do behind close doors. Back then there was no spread of info like there is today. He knows that even if he went to the publishers/spreaders of this book, they're not gonna change a thing. So whatever is out there is on a global scale like this can be dealt with as such.

[@mohammadwasimofficial9479]

@@Haleembostan Is it right? So that people remain in the dark? This thing suits only Sufis (Deobandi, Barelvi), not Salafi scholars. To what extent is it right to hide such things, you should ask this from your heart, and yes, the things to be hidden are those that have no relation to religion and Sufis are against Allah and His Prophet in their faith (aqa'aid) itself.

[@justacalmandreasonablepers6085]

I didnt see the video, may be the book have lies but in my personal opinion Whenever i have met Tablighis they were the most humble and generous guys, i got to know they go on tabligh without any monetary gains instead they use their own money for the cause. I had worst experience from the other extremes salfis and barelvis always argumentative call each other names kuffars, grave worshippers etc... I dont consider my self from any sect but these were the things i had come across.

[@ReclusiveWealth]

see the video ull get the point

[@TablighiJamaat-sh6wc]

@@ReclusiveWealth Sheikh Uthman faked all the evidences. He did not read Sheikh Zakariyya’s fulll arabic commentary. There is no fabricated hadith in Fadhail Amal!

[@ahmadusaid8215]

Definitely It's not a substitute for Quran! But Reading FA, made me closer to the Qur'an! Reading FA, made my Namaz better Reading FA، made me accountable to my actions! Reading FA,made me realize,that's islam,is not only about me and my family, but I have the responsibility of the whole Ummah. Reading FA, I came to know about the sacrifice of Prophet and the Sahaba!

[@Hussycrafts]

This is totally created with AI

[@ShahrukhKhan-gi9fg]

Salesman never bangs the door or caught you by surprise, they are trained to be kind, polite and well-mannered in order to make sale that's it. Christian Missionaries are step ahead they gave you monetary perks for heeding to their call. Never judge the book by it's cover. Dajjal will bring the dead man live in reality and many followers of deviant sects of Islam will blindly accept that as they never understand the core islamic creed. Time for you to study, research and seek guidance.

[@saadsajid2223]

The person who does not recite Quran and make lot of mistakes is critisizing Sheikh ul Hadith Molana Zakariya R.A who was Hafiz e Quran a big scholar and mohaddith and was buried in Madinah

[@cherryontop2911]

We are humans and we make mistakes the only and all perfect is Allah(swt). Shkh is not just saying something from himself but rather showing us the evidence from great scholar.

[@owaisahmadzargar9658]

Like to share few points. 1. Its not just zakaria kaandhelvi, its Sheikhul hadees moulana zakariya kaandhelvi. In this nation titles were given by ummah based on prowess in particular field, imam ul fuqaha nouman ibn thaabit was called imam al azam, hazrat abdullah ibn mubarak was titled ameer ul momin fil hadees and moulana zakariya was titled sheikh ul hadees bcoz of his broad knowledge on hadith and also knowledge of other madhahib, moulana in fazail e hajj in ziyarat un qabr un nabi alihi salam quotes many hanbali fiqh books. 2. Fuqaha tell us that if a person teaches mouzu and makzoob hadith its sin. Sheikh ul hadees as also pointed by u clearly mentions the nuqs in those narrations and that is being ameen and to highlight those points and tell us dont use it as a whole is not wise. For aama tul muslimeen they r not supposed to grade hadith and take as per their likes. 3. To say those examples of mouzu hadees effect ur aqeeda and fiqh is laughable. Those narrations arent there for aqaid/ahkaam but they only touch fazaail as u know the name of the book. 4. When a person opens fazail e amaal it clearly enlists the books from which quotes and material have been taken which includes bukhari shareef, muslims shareef to roohul meaani to riyadus sualiheen. Its a conprehensive book and the kind of discussion which he metions under ف is deep. Like a doctoral thesis he gives detailed view what different scholars have said and what they mean. 5. Considering all these points fazail e amaal is one of the best books to enrich ur faith and a taste for doing amaal, besides it also gives so many other things like pasti ka waahid ilaaj which is an eye opener to current doomed situation of muslims and how to get over it and other jewels of wisdom. Fazail e amal is not a book written by devil that we distance from it but a book that was written with a purpose and it has certainly stood for that purpose. Rest salafists want to turn us away from scholars and fiqh which will never happen. The work that brother uthman does in calling christianity to islam is ❤️, leaving what people in medvial ages did. The very first person in colonial period who stood against missionaries and made them flee was moulana kaeraanvi who fought the british missionary and beat him in munazira and was later called to turkiye to debate with him there. The same scholar wrote izhaar ul haq of which ahmad deedat makes mention and even today is a must read for those who wish to do the dawah work.

[@iKhanWaqas]

Very well written. جزاك الله خير

[@hoquemamon]

Isn't it a wise decision to replace those fabricated hadith with authentic Ahadith. Is there any shortage of authentic ahadith on fazail?

[@owaisahmadzargar9658]

@@hoquemamon 😊😊my frnd my earnest suggestion would be to undertake door e hadees at an Islamic centre. A hadith is a narration which is seen by faqeeh employing all the sciences of jarah, asmaa e rajaal etc and then grading it. The reason of quoting these hadiths is we consider each and every narration attributed to prophet as blessings and grading doesn't mean they are falsehood but ahkaam which are more important are based on nasaais and weaker ones are left out. Better get an acquaintance. It's not like in science this is correct and other is incorrect hence cannot be taken.

[@anisdesai4692]

@owais. Jazakallah. You have made many of the points I would have made. Exactly wat I wanted to say. May Allah reward you. You have saved me and those like me alot of time typing the explanation. Also would like to add. The fazaail amal book has slightly weak hadiths but absolutely no fabrication. Every muhadditheen knows one cannot state a fabricated hadith except for the purposes to let people know it is a fabrication, to do so otherwise is a sin.

[@owaisahmadzargar9658]

@anisdesai4692 ❤️

[@Mohamed-d3r7s]

There are a lot of people who just criticize, but the question is, what do you do for this religion? Dont be a keyboard worrier.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Which religion? The religion which came from Madina, or the one which originated in India?

[@ahmadusaid8215]

It came from Allah​@@nazeerpasha2075

[@luiminix_1059]

@@nazeerpasha2075 islam its complete without any place's influence being over it , so it can't be like that medina people following the Islam always correctly and others are not. If saudi leader choses to drive the minds of medina people with strong influence and they perform the islam slightly wrong then will be Islam be considered as that way? No place is a Determinant of islamic learing, Islam can be taught by anyone to anyone regardless of the place, if the teachings are right.

[@dbmdawah7567]

Jazakallah o Khair 🌹 may Allah SWT guide us all.....

[@nakeebissadeen1606]

You are wasting your time and do not èxpose your ignorance. Sheik Zakariyah wrote these Hadeeth for laymen to understand Dheen without causing any disrepute to our beloved Prophet (pbuh). You are applying your scholarly interpretation to bring ill feelings towards the noble works of Tableeque. Fear Allah for using your knowledge to mislead the Muslim ummah..

[@MoreDawaah]

You cannot give such books to laymen who do not know about gradings of Ahadith knowing that it contains FABRICATIONS; not weaknesses. Plenty other books that are authentic that you can understand the Deen from. No need to hold on to it just because he wrote it.

[@nakeebissadeen1606]

@MoreDawaah What Sheik Uthman failed to understand is the Spirit in which the weak hadeeth was explained by Sheik Zakariyah Mowlana, through which Allah has guided hundreds of thousands non practising Muslims into the fold of Dheen. Moreover, he tried to slander and discredit the noble work of Tableeque Jama'ath in his other videos. While thousands of nonMuslims are converting to Islam, millions of Muslims are going away from the Dheen by not following the commandments of Allah. Only 5 to 10% of the two billion Muslims go to the masjid to pray five times salah. We have a task in our hands to meet everyone of them to remind their commitment towards Allah. Tableeque Jama'ath is just doing this work. Sheik Uthman should be more respectful towards this noble work and should not spread mischief and disinformation about this work.

[@mohammadalam9936]

​@@MoreDawaah We are using muntakhab a Hadith right now.

[@saleem.ullah054]

@@MoreDawaahbruh you need to learn the difference bw fabricated and weak... if there is fabricated hadees (not weak) in this book mention it here, otherwise remember you will be held accountable for your hate and lies toward a jamaat that is actually the most pious and dedicated muslim jamat on the planet earth

[@nakeebissadeen1606]

@saleem.ullah054 I have no hatred towards fellow Muslims nor spread any lies. In my humble opinion, you all are the product of Saudi government propagation of an aqeedah which was used by Bin Saud to create a kingdom, and even now, it is causing division among the Muslim ummah You pick on Tableeqi Jama'ath with petty issues and mislead your followers away from the Da'wah that I mentioned in my previous post. You will be held responsible for that.

[@araftamim-mx3dw]

Alhamdulillah for Salafiyyah Ahle Hadith ❤

[@AliTanoli-cq3js]

Quoting The Nabi s.a.w falsely is not a light issue at all. And we need to be aware of these type of things so Hadith literature is preserved

[@FactsWithActs]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn All of the ones he quoted were fabrications, keep coping

[@TablighiJamaat-sh6wc]

@@AliTanoli-cq3js there is no fabricated hadith in fadhail amaal. Read Sheikh Zakariyya’s arabic commentary properly!

[@MuhammadKhan-sq1eo]

Do you think that Hadrat Shaykhul Hadeeth, Shaykh Zakariyah Qudus sirruhu, was not of aware of all the ahdeeth he placed in his book, the mere fact that he put in the book these ahadeeth, should crystallise in the mind of any 2 bit scholar, that they are allowed to be put in. We can all see quite plainly what the the Saudis narrow vision on their religion has led them too. Demolishing such incredible land marks and buildings as well as other historical artefacts, from the time of Rasul Allah SAW, all under the guise of grave worship, duh,

[@FactsWithActs]

@MuhammadKhan-sq1eo 1. That is shirk, allowing lies against Rusūlullāh ﷺ which is explicitly Ḥarām because your scholar said so. That is what the Jews do. 2. What tf does the kingdom of Sa'ūdiyah have to do with anything, rent free in your head clearly. You diubandys didn't mind it when you used to recieve their funding...

[@Arkai123]

First of all, the word mawdu’ being written in the Arabic commentary does not necessitate that the actual hadith that was quoted is fabricated. In fact, the author Shaykh Muhammad Zakariyya cited that ruling (mawdu’) in regards to another narration, not in regard to hadith number 28. Anyone with even a slight knowledge of the Arabic language would have understood this from the passage. Secondly, based on this misunderstanding, for one to proceed further and comment on that particular hadith (no. 28) being “a clear lie on the Prophet (may Allah bless him and give him peace)” is baseless and senseless as well. In fact, that hadith is hasan (fair), neither weak nor fabricated. (See Raf‘ al-Manarah 248 and al-Radd al-Muhkam al-Matin 138) May Allah Ta‘ala save us all from such irrational decision-making regarding the noble sayings of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and give him peace). And Allah Ta‘ala knows best.

[@imranuzzaman2566]

Jazakallahu Khairan Kaseera Wa Ahsanul Jazah ❤

[@ashrafwilliams1398]

There is more Noor in doing Dawah and Tabligh in the prescribed manner than having undignified arguments at speakers corner. The organization for Dawah and Tabligh is considered the biggest Muslim Organization in the world. I would also claim that the organization had been responsible for more people embracing Islam than any other. Obviously, you have not done 4 months or 40 days.......... Islam is a Dynamic religion, so we must be on the move, and Alhumdilla, 1 000s of our brothers have sacrificed the comfort of their homes and are found all over the world.

[@Prograaaaming]

Wow brother here is assigning Noor 😮

[@faizmiah2363]

Shaykh Uthman has reverted 100s of people through himself and platform to Islam

[@simple-eastner]

What Noor? Tablighi Jamaat was started based on these extraordinary dreams of Moulana Ilyas( kzbin.infoUgkxMaTv12XuYL25ga4OIpqCfhSGQjWHfyCk perhaps his hallucinations, i don't want to accuse a Muslim of lying). And is now unfortunately run based on this kind of dreams: kzbin.info/www/bejne/g57dZH6wjtN2e9k. Alas as per these people Nabi(SAW) is coming in dreams for Moulana Saad. Why did not He(SAW) come in dreams of Suhaba(ra) for Usman(ra) or Ali(ra) or Hussain(ra) to stop the Fitna before they were being killed? Please fear Allah and save your Akhira

[@Omar-mx3dd]

I don't understand why tabligh ul jamah push this book when we have Quran and authentic books of hadith like Bukhari and Muslim.

[@alhamdulilla_AllahuQairunHafiz]

Donot fight among yourselves.... Donot get seperated inbetween and Hold ALLAH'S BOOK FIRMLY

[@speedster4647]

and speak the truth even if it's against yourself

[@simple-eastner]

HOLD ALLAH's ROPE i.e. Quran. And It read with meaning and understand. Dont end up read another book full of mistakes and horrible lies i.e. Fazael Amaal

[@MBA.x]

Shame on any one who has more love or loyalty other then to Allah and his messenger and the deen.

[@jka3062]

No one in tabligh is staunch on using this book. It is fazail- meaning virtue. Now they use muntkab hadith. The book is created for a layman to read. Tabligh has been the mujajid of the century

[@ymi6945]

Laymen must stay away from this stuff. It’s fabricated- lies. About the prophet ﷺ. No one needs made up Hadith about our beloved prophet ﷺ. Laymen or not.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@ymi6945 ... every one should stay clear of this dirty garbage.

[@casilasgoaler]

@@jka3062 yeah they been the mujaddid of Bidah for centuries, you are right

[@sanatanwar4243]

Sir, we see ur work online n we really appreciate it.. do u even know how tabligi jamat kept it simple helped million around the world.. where it started... Those who r not Indian... Know that large number of Indians do bidah n dargah things.. tablighi jamat helped so many people.. alhamdulillah Alhamdulillah... Know we r humans at the end of day the person who wrote the book... The people in tabligi jamat... We all make mistakes.. there r some better way to send the message about fabricated ahadis.. such thumbnail spread hatred amongst the community

[@QuranforPeace-z8u]

I can say truly i am very nearer to Allah, i always tell all the things to Allah even it is a small difficulty, tabligh changed my life, i can say that who dont want to leave their homes because of nafs desires, allah knows what is wrong what is right. Dont blame others who is doing something good for ummah, for the sake of monetization of youtube channel, dont spread hate, people wants some hate news always, so people might like this, but what tabligh did the impact on muslims, young stars became momins, some people learned quran, hafiz, aalims, masjids in remote areas in the world. Normal people rectified their surah, waju, salah. There is a lot of impact on Muslims, people name sake Muslims dont understand all this. Faith is main thing, Allah will guide you on the right path. If you have faith. Otherwise shiatn will lead you to destroy the good by spreading hate. Allah will decide on the day of judgment, just wait, if you want to take good take. Dont spoil or blame others.

[@ahmedismail6704]

It's ALLAH that changes the hearts.❤

[@Tmirvoice1]

Allah tablig jamaat ki hifazat farmaye (aameen)

[@syedhamza5228]

The fazail ul amaal is a book of hadith compiled from different authentic books of hadith like bukhari tirmizi etc. it is never the case where sheikh zakaria has created hadith himself or add it without mentioning it as weak or batil. If hadith mentioned in bukhari and tirmizi being weak does not cause a rasie of concern than why fazail ul amaal get targeted. Being known that both bukhari and tirmizi and other authentic books are available to ummah. And all other waqiyat that looks fake are same from other books that are approved and surrounded in ummah throught years. Those books never get pointed.

[@Mc-zr1dx]

Respected shaykh farook, ml zakariyya r.a is a very respected and pious scholar. He would perform many rakats of nafl salah and beg Allah to accept their efforts so the deen of islam can remain alive. The work of dawah and tabligh has changed lives of millions of people globally. Yes there are many weak ahadith in this book and regarding the fabrications i think be better if it could be brought to the attention of the ulema that are involved in this effort of dawah and tabligh and let us create unity and brotherhood amongst ourselves instead of disagreement and disunity. Its the only way we will prosper as an ummah

[@simple-eastner]

ml zakariyya r.a was SUFI and his books are full of Sufi Nonsense. Fazael has non-sense is at another level, SEEing ALLAH in a dream level. Do you believe as a muslim believe someone can SEE ALLAH, even in a dream? In Fazael Amaal, Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal saw ALLAH in his dream, had asked certain questions as mentioned in the Virtues/Fazael of Quran. This is a very BIG claim, so needs a proof. Does Mr Khandelvi give any proof of where he got this unique information un-known to other Muslims? Did any of Sahaba (RA) have such an experience? No. Sufis do talk this kind of non-sense stuff. Hint is in the question: What does An Arab Imam Hanbal ask Allah in dream? About Ajr of reading Quran without understanding. Why would an Arab, an Imam-Alim talk abt reading Quran without understanding?

[@mdriyaz5753]

It is very easy to find mistakes in others..... We have to see the people's good things and show them the purpose of life and make them good practicing Muslims... And unite all ummah to one platform that is Eman and Aamal..

[@zohaibkhan5859]

maulana zakrriya r.h made a dua to allah ﷻ that if you accept this book faizul ul amaal then make me die in madinah..and our sheikh grave is in madinah♥️

[@evolvedmango1601]

So, that makes these fabrications SAHIH. Use your brain to pop this bubble of blind following.

[@waseemtarique3507]

And how do you know that he makes this dua ?

[@zohaibkhan5859]

@@waseemtarique3507 through scholars who were his companion

[@hanzalasays]

Whenever shaikh zakariya رحمه الله mentions any hadees he mentions it's hukum just after it like this is saheeh or hasan aur zaeef or fabricated and he does proper تخريج of that hadees if anyone has done كلام on the sanad, so he's not responsible for just putting those ahadees in the book, you could've blame him only if he didn't have mentioned the hukum of hadees, by the way, when you're goin to expose sunan ibn e maja bcz Imam ibn e maja رحمه الله also wrote 35 or 36 موضوع ahadees in his book, and don't forget exposing sunan tirmizi for having bunch of zaeef ahadees (it's just an ilzami answer although I'm a sunni and have heart full of love and respect for these muhaddiseen رحمهم الله تعالي)

[@muf209]

Show me one living person including you shaikh who haven't made mistakes, show me one! If there is none then acknowledge the efforts of Tableegh jamaat and move on accepting it as it should be , just a mistake! Nothing more, nothing less. Jazakallah

[@perioguatexgaming1333]

At 2:44 sheikh says that it is mauzuu (fabricated) and cannot be used. These ahadiths are mauuzuu but not mauuzuu bil ijmaa ( ie a consensus have not been established on it) and hence used for fazail and not masail.

[@simple-eastner]

Does Islam need Lies? No. Even if those lies make one feel good, pious and spiritual. Give this "fazail and not masail" logic to someone else, the tablighis end up reading only Fazael Amal, and they are against people reading Quran with understanding and meaning. I would love them to start doing 20-25 mins(few Ayath)Weekly Quranic Durs by an Alim in their Sunday 2-4hours Gathering. They have not done it in 100yrs and will not do it. Often their lecture are repeat cast, full of same anecdotes(accomplishments-miracles-dreams of jamaat followers, tons of stories abt odd figures like Junaid, Rabia Basri, Sadi, Ibrahim Adan.. not even suhabas, not a tabayee to even Rashid Amhed Gangoi), at times totally devoid of Quran verses or even ahadith.

[@branzar123]

@@simple-eastner odd figures like Junaid, Rabia Basri, Sadi, Ibrahim Adan.. not even suhabas, not a tabayee to even Rashid Amhed Gangoi make tawba from this brother, it is not worth it. if Allah loved these people as much as most people think, this sentence will be against you. if your opinion is not high of them, best to stay quiet, that is safer. Your concerned brother.

[@simple-eastner]

@@branzar123 "Odd figures" - I am not using harsh words against them even after some of things/stories told by their sufi followes about them are purely unislamic-non-sense(like unmarried rabia saying- will burn heaven & cool hell fire) to even kufr(ya-junaid)

[@simple-eastner]

@@branzar123 "odd figures" why? Rabia Busri herself said nonsense like will put down hell fire & burn Jannah, is this odd and something no sahabi & even no Nabi(peace be upon them) ever said? Who are you declare "Allah loved these people"? "most people think" and say they were muslims. Some people dumbly think its good that they said kufri things like "ya junaid" to non-sense like "kabah going around Rabia Busri". Some other people say that these are false stories spread abt them and are wrong, but they were good. We are some other people who say we need not bother abt them or all stories abt them. Islam has Prophets, Suhaba and Quran & Hadith. In our Opinion "best to stay quiet, that is safer. Your concerned brother." Don't declare people these Jannati or even Wali because that is Allah's decision.

[@perioguatexgaming1333]

​@@simple-eastner hey, who are you referring to as "they"? have you ever met real jamatis or have your just heard about these lies spread by haters and believed them like a sheep? have you ever gone to a jamaat? i haven't heard a single name you mentioned while in jamaat, these are just lies. we do the work of giving dawah... and we are not against people reading and understanding the quran, we are against those who read and try to understand by themselves, often misinterpreting the meaning of it... can you read and understand shakespear yourself? or do you think the quran is easier to understand and is less deep than shakespear... and yeah about "tons of stories abt odd figures like junaid, rabia basri, sadi, ibrahim adan" duh we haven't even heard those names... why you making up all that stuff yourself? are you some kind idiot spreading hate in islam without proper knowledge?

[@AbdulRaheem-z1g4h]

The interesting part about this is that Sheikh Zakariya actually pointed out these fabrications himself in the original copy of "Fazail ul Amal" . However they were taken out in later versions of the book. Sheikh Zakariya pointed this out saying that he had made it clear that which of these mentioninings were unauthentic, and said that the purpose of this book was to compile the apparent sayings of Fazail regarding various Amaal.

[@stunnasaad]

the work of tablighi jamaat can't be dismissed however. Through their work, dar ul ulooms all throughout america and the globe have been popping up for example Masjid DarusSalam in Chicago (lombard,il). From what ive notcied, you are right that the book may mention some weak ahadith, however there is an easy solution to that. When going out in the path of Allah and doing jamaat/khurooj, you can bring scholars with you during ta'leem. Also during ta'leem if someone knows arabic, they can easily read from another more authentic hadith book.But the mufti of DarusSalam , his teacher was the author of Fazail Amal, and Darul Uloom Zakirriya is a well reknowned institution. However we can argue that some ulama can revise fazail amal and create a better version of it.

[@simple-eastner]

"When going out .... doing jamaat/khurooj, you can bring scholars with you during ta'leem." Yes Taleem(study) of Fazael Amaal, and not Quran. I would love them to start doing 20-25 mins(few Ayath)Quranic Durs by an Alim in their Sunday 2-4hours Weekly gathering. They haven't done it in 100yrs and will not do it. Often their lecture are repeat cast, full of same anecdotes(miracles to dreams-accomplishments of jamaat followers, tons of stories abt odd figures like Junaid, Rabia Basri, Sadi, Ibrahim Adan.. not even suhabas, not a tabayee). Oddly in same America you talk abt most non-muslim convert after reading Quran-translations reading it meaning-understanding, but alas these people never read Quran with meaning in their 40days or 4months travels(which is rituals based on dreams of Moulana Ilyas). While Allah's Nabi(SAW) said to hold Allah's rope i.e. Quran tight.

[@mohammedirfantn2518]

First hadith that you've mentioned is spread widely among Tablighis I'm among one of them.but sad nobody seems to get this..may guide Allah guide all of us.

[@sekousackor8254]

This is what happened when you want people to called you educated, May Allah grant Us Understanding 😢😢😢

[@Temporaryworld7]

This is the second warning ⚠️ for you Change your attitude of writing the subtitle If u don't know about tableegh jamaath Atleast go 1 day in jamaath uu will understand What is wrong and what is Right Instead of listening 🎧 and following sheikh and all May Allah guide you ...

[@AdnanKhan-bq4qf]

In society, everyone has a role to play to keep things functioning smoothly-doctors, engineers, lawyers, IT professionals, social workers, administrators, taxi drivers, farmers, street vendors, and many others. Each person contributes by doing their job. Similarly, in propagating Islam, various groups fulfill different responsibilities. Maddaris focus on producing huffaz, scholars, researchers, and imams who teach and guide people in understanding the basics of Islam. Organizations, dawah groups, interfaith programs, and community outreach initiatives work to educate non-Muslims and share accurate information about Islam. Meanwhile, the Tablighi Jamaat plays its part by focusing on self-improvement and reminding others to strive toward bringing the complete deen into their lives and becoming practicing Muslims. One may disagree with the methodology or certain practices of the Tablighi Jamaat, but scholars have not classified it as un-Islamic. Since there are no specific, fixed guidelines in the Quran and Sunnah on how to conduct dawah, contemporary dawah groups use a variety of tools such as print media, social media, television, and documentaries to spread the message of Islam. Yet, some self-proclaimed scholars are quick to criticize others who do not follow the same methodology. It is worth noting that the Tablighi Jamaat did not invent their material-they rely on Quranic ayats, hadiths, and stories from books authored by recognized Islamic scholars. Instead of merely criticizing the Tablighi Jamaat, scholars like Shaykh Uthman ibn Farooq should take proactive steps to produce material, series of lectures, recommendations, and structured processes for conducting tabligh in the best possible way. If he does not agree with the books currently used in taleem, he should recommend alternative books for study. If he does not support the 3-day, 40-day, or 4-month approaches, he should provide practical recommendations for self-improvement and methods to effectively remind others. Constructive solutions and guidance can help refine the efforts of those engaged in tabligh, benefiting the entire ummah.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Tablighi jamaat is a Sufi Revivalist Movement to propagate and strengthen the belief that the The Prophet and other pious persons ( awliya) are alive in their graves, listen to us, aware of the outside world and in some instances can come out of the grave to help the needy.

[@nimiefester8987]

The issue i have with people like this is that they assume people scholars like moulana Zakaria (ra) was not aware of these issues, likewise the thousands of scholars who came after. These salafies assume that they are the only ones who are guided, this in itself is misguidance, and Allah knows best.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@nimiefester8987 The Shias , Qadianies , Brelveis also assume that they are the only ones who are guided.

[@shaheendanger]

Tabligh like I was taught is when a husband or leader learns something in Madrassa or Khutbah and teach and convey to his family. However "Tabligh" jamaat especially in Cape Town RSA believes they know better than the Alims and Huffath. And that's where I have a dislike for their ways. Bit extreme. However I don't judge. Never came across an Alim attending a jamaat gathering.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@shaheendanger ... and any one who has gone in jamat two three times , becomes ameer. illiterate ameers.

[@rahmat9094]

No body / books/ school is free from defect.I respect every muslims and their effort to revive iman, islam and ehsan. Let us all celebrate the differences by building bridges and harmonious discussion. My respect to those eldest who had spent their time, energy and money in making qurban in fii sabilillah. May Allah guide us all. May Allah will unite us all as a single ummah in our lifetime.

[@halalhub7]

Sheikh Tablighi guys dont even know about fabricated or even weak ahadiths. Their intentions are pure but they dont have enough knowledge. You should come to Pakistan and India and talk these issues with leaders of Jamaat. They have changed Millions of peoples lives Inshallah but they need a leader who can change things.

[@fizzosayopahlawan1480]

U sure what u talking? Or u juz dumb hear n dumb say Ahahah

[@sheraztahir216]

"In the time of Prophet Noah, people were committing the sin of worshipping their elders. When I read the comments, I am amazed at how some people defend these actions, even though they clearly know that certain Hadiths are fabricated. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said, 'Whoever fabricates lies about me will have their place in the Hellfire.' You must decide whether you are followers of Prophet Muhammad or of your elders."

[@anisdesai4692]

There are no fabricated hadiths in fazail amal. 🙄

[@studytime6092]

Was there a need of using the term Tabligi Jamaat? In today's situation we are already divided and others are taking an advantage of this situation. Hope you will reply on this. Your efforts are highly appreciated but you know what is the situation specially in Indian subcontinent.

[@fahim-fahim]

What do you mean, these books are almost always exclusively used by the layman in these jamaties

[@studytime6092]

@fahim-fahim oh! understood your meaning" these jamaties". Aren't we muslims first? So there was no need of using the divisive words like tabligi jamat.

[@ShahzadAli-c2o]

The missionary activities of tabligh jamaat are odds with the sunnah. So it's the amal that warrants the label and the amal that causes the divisions. Only the Haq gives us reason to criticise this book.

[@studytime6092]

@@ShahzadAli-c2o Brother criticising the book is different and the title of the video is another thing. My comment was on using the term Jamati.

[@ShahzadAli-c2o]

​@@studytime6092using term jamati is no different to a person on a mission being called a missionary. It is not derogatory persè

[@HasanDalal-g4s]

Sheikh please don’t just try and paint this picture of the writer rahmatullahi alayhi that he didn’t know himself in regards to the sihhah and saqm of the ahdeeth or in fact no prior knowledge He’s a world wide accept muhaddith absolutely unmatched in his time He has much more knowledge insight of shariah and and the science of hadeeth than me and you put together thank you very much His commentary on mutta lil imaam maalik is unmatched and one of a kind and much appreciated by Maaliki Ulama themselves despite the authors being Hanafi (subhanallah) There is definitely reasons and wisdoms for using such ahaadeeth if only you had the courtesy to just refer back to the ulamaa of Deoband rather any Aalim with sound knowledge.They would’ve given you a sufficient answer Please do address Hazrat molana Zakariyya r.a with the titles he deserves. If any one would like a justification of Sheikh Uthmaans allegations then message me

[@muhammadmustafa5450]

What shaykh uthman is qouting has already been said by Tableeghi ulemas in their sermons. They themselves are asking people to adopt Riyadh us saliheen now. But this book fadail e amaal has all sorts of ahadith though wallahu aalam. I am a mere jahil, I spent 10 days with the jamaat and all I can say is good, a good majority of Muslims can’t even perform their Salah correctly. This work of tableegh is bring us back into the fold of Islam.

[@faridshaikh5]

Start reading the aunthatic Hadith of how to perform salah as per Rasool SAW, then no need to go for jamaat . Problem solved bro

[@muhammadmustafa5450]

@ Yeah brother if it was that easy many people wouldn’t be needing it. But the thing is most people even if they get the hidayat from the gaib it’s vital for us Muslims to reach out to them. And getting ilm without a ustad or ulema leads you astray.

[@MDKAIFALAM-l9v]

Hey Kazzab why r u lying.... Jhuto pe Allah ki lanat...... Koi ek fabricated Hadith btaw usme se Daef Hadith hai lekin fabricated nhi Kuch khud v padh liya kr kb tak apne Jahil Babon ko sun ke udta rahega.... Ilzam lagane se dar khoti ke putr Allah ke pas pakad hogi Ki unhe namaz padhne nhi aata

[@muhammadmustafa5450]

@@MDKAIFALAM-l9v who are you replying to?

[@muhammadmustafa5450]

@@MDKAIFALAM-l9v kis ko reply kar rahe ho?

[@kamilsiddiqui4252]

Jazakallahukhairan sheikh for telling us this we will be careful and read riyad us saliheen😊

[@leemenzu2117]

I love this brother in dawah, but please brother stay in your field.

[@TheQuranandHadith-1]

Say what is right and truth, and refrain from saying wrong, fabricated, unpleasant things. May Allah bless you for highlighting the importance of sticking to Sahih Hadith and requesting brothers and sisters to humbly respect tabligh Brothers and efforts, however focus must be on and via Sahih Hadith for implementation.❤ Because fabricated things lead to biddah.

[@as-mb9yt]

Any word which brings a muslim to right path and towards namaz and masjid should be grabbed and respected.

[@praiseworthy]

Thank you for your input and this is not fair on all Tabligh people and are book that have used false Hadith either by mistake or ignorance already division is eating the Ouma let’s not finger point anyone and create more division. We appreciate your advice to open their eyes of people, and there is always soft way.

[@riazdangor5849]

Arab and Somali Tabligh Jamaats only use Riyadh us saaliheen for Hadith reading. Tabligh effort is a legitimate and correct aspect of Dawah and Islaah. Sheikh Uthman is not attacking the work of Tabligh, he is pointing out that we should not use this kitaab Fadhaail - e - Amaal as it contain fabrications and we know it is prohibited to ascribe something false to RasulAllah Sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam.

[@MDKAIFALAM-l9v]

There's no fabricated Hadith bro.... Do research before putting alligaiin But some Hadith are Zaif.

[@user-qs9nb5jq6b]

AlIslamproduction just defeated your whole video 💀

[@Abdullah-c1j2t]

Don't force this book to others . This is the main problem of tabeeghi jamaat. They are a bit stubborn.

[@DanishAnwar]

A bit is an under-statement. They brag that this is the most-read book after the Quran in the world

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@DanishAnwar .. Fazael e Aamal is their sacred book ,revealed on their elders, that is why it is read more regularly than Quran. In fact, it has replaced Quran.

[@opm7863]

It hasn’t replaced the Quran it’s read so it bring love for the sunnah in our lives may be if the speaker studies the life of its author he might get shocked at it his level of taqwa

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@opm7863 .. creed ( aqeeda) should be the priority.. Our Prophet was just working on 'aqeeda' for 13 years in while in Makkah.

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@opm7863 Without proper creed (aqeeda)... 'taqwa' does not mean anything. For 13 years , during his stay in Makkah, our Prophet was challenging the beliefs of 'mushrekeen'. Most of the Quran is on ' aqeeda'. On the other hand ,Tablighi Jamat's mission is to spread heresy and destruction of creed.

[@nahyanyousuf7815]

There’s tabligi brothers at my local mosque always reading this in the mosque. They’ve been banned from the mosque due to promoting this

[@mostafahassan6909]

May Allah reward your masjid administration for banning them

[@NoorMohammed-me9lg]

Where is it?

[@nakibhafiz]

Alhumdulillah...TJs should be banned everywhere

[@ArkhamDeluxe]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn "First of all, there is no fabricated books inside this book, usman quoted those who called some hadees fabricated but not those who called it either weak or hasan or anything" you're not even making any sense, are you saying he's reading from a different book?... He showed the page scans on screen and the mentions of fabrication in the text itself is clear to see...

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn ... Pray Allah to curse the liars. Aameen Zakaria Kandalvi writes on page 13/12, Fadha'il Namaaz, Fadha'il 'A'maal, Vol I: "It has been reported from a number of companions and from amongst them Hadhrat Uthman, Hadhrat Abu Hurayrah, Hadhrat Anas, etc. in different wordings that there are some people who possess the ability of Kashf. They can feel the sins being committed by people. Therefore the story of the Imam of the world Hadhrat Abu Haneefah is famous that he used to stand outside the Masjid of Koofah and see the sins of the people fall out as they performed wudu." (Kandalvi continues): It has also been reported from Hadhrat Uthman that the Prophet said:

[@mokaps1610]

Just for your information the respected Shaikh Zakaria (r.a.) is resting in Madina munawwarah next to prophet (s.a.w). His kidmat of deen is a sign of acceptance. So, think about our own destination and then try to point fingers at such a friend of allah. May Allah guide you to right path.

[@shaheermansoor-dotcom]

Mistakes are mistakes even if Sheikh Zakaria has done them. Best is to accept these are mistakes in the books and should not be the part of the book, so the layman can be exposed to true light of teachings of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ.

[@MohammedVanker]

The work of tabligh brought millions closer to the deen Rather focus on bringing people closer to the deen than constantly condemning all

[@safatrahman9477]

So what!!!! Tabligh brought lot of people closer, does it mean you can't even do constructive criticism? Do you know the consequence of innovation or bad creed? The mindset you are showing that the thing I love that much that I can't even feel their mistakes. Islam is knowledge not your emotion.

[@welcome9470]

He is not doing that constantly, you are watching it constantly, I don't think every day he focuses of Tablighi jamaah only, he actually respects them for good aspects of them and now also he is being respectful in giving advice and telling truth..

[@moojza]

Doing good doesnt make anyone beyond criticism

[@mohamedtariq3084]

Bro first understand this thing many people included whatever is they think good but if not from sunnah of prophet then it is not accepted deen is not whatever you and me like rather its what Allah's order and prophet's doing .Today I have perfected your faith for you, completed My favour upon you, and chosen Islam as your way. But whoever is compelled by extreme hunger-not intending to sin-then surely Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful ( surah Al maidha - verse no : 3 ) tabligh jamat most of them are going directly against this verse and they blind follow if its not prophet's way they how can u say they getting people closer to Allah ?

[@mohamedtariq3084]

1000 of weak and daef is not equal to 1 sahih so it doesnt mattsr of quantity rather quality this are all vain work

[@uzairsparacha]

Important to point out that many fabrications contradict the actual Quran and Sunnah

[@junaidmakada2987]

Leave hazrat sheikh alone What he did in his lifetime for the Deen in his life time will take you 5 life times to do

[@moojza]

Your right that many innovations will take forever to come up with

[@fazanahmad940]

​@@moojza Such a great reply 😅

[@FactsWithActs]

@@junaidmakada2987 How many people did he revert in comparison to Shaykh 'Uthmān? We didn't belittle your shaykh, but you asked for it...

[@nazeerpasha2075]

The book fazael e aamal is a source of ' ma'siyat-e-jariyah' for Zakaria Kandhalvi. He will be held accountable and punished for writing such a book.

[@junaidmakada2987]

@FactsWithActs Brother Million of muslims change their life in hazrat life time, and after his demise, they are still changing their life after reading this kitaab, which has already been excepted in the eyes of our creator

[@AbdulMajeed-ln2eb]

Do what ever you want.. Insha allah Haq will prevail and its prevailing all over the world in the name of Tabligi Jamat. Summa Alhumdulliah tabligi work has changed the lives of many people and will continue to do. His speech it self utter the hate about tabligi jamat. He cannot digest the success of this jamat. May Allah guide him to right path before his death..

[@abuji9429]

The thing is Zakaria RA were to lie he wouldn't have mentioned about the reference neither he states that he couldn't find a reference to a particular Hadith. Which is sign of his truth worthy to ummah. Instead of point fingers on Zakaria RA why don't sheik Osman highlighted those wrote Zaeef Hadith in the referencial of book of hadees.

[@LJ-jd5yy]

No one is saying he lied. Is your allegiance to the sunnah of the prophet or Zakaria? scholars of Hadith said it is fabricated and you still want to stick to it? May Allah guide us away from deviance

[@nazeerpasha2075]

Did the Prophet permitted seeking intercession from the Dead? • Coming back to our topic of grave worship, Kandalvi stated 80 years ago in very explicit words the virtues and benefit of grave worship of grave worship• Fadha'il Hajj, Page 138: • "When you see the green dome then it should be with awe and reverance and you should take care of the honour of the Huzoor and reflect that in that pure dome is he who is the best of creation, leader of the Prophets and virtuous the angels. The place of the holy grave is superior than any other place and that place which touches the holy body of the Huzoor is superior to the Ka'bah, superior to the Arsh, superior to the Kursi in fact superior than everything in the heavens and earth."

[@rasheedmuhammad7331]

Brother please be very careful in interpreting words of tassawuf for verily you will end up giving it the wrong meaning. There is no one as greater after After except our Master SAW now what Sheilkul Hadith have said is saying that if He the Prophet SAW doesn't need a special month for him to be born in for Him SAW, He made the month Special not the Month making Him special, this is a little link to Sheikh statement so ponder deeply don't just read and translate openly mindedly for some words are ambiguous amd some are straightforward. May Allah assist us all AMIN

[@Ifs_and_buts]

This is much needed video … I have been to tablighi jamaat multiple times and everytime I was there when teaching or recitation of this book was being done it left me puzzled …. Nowadays it is a challenge in itself to find islam despite being born in muslim family

[@atifusman6296]

Highly disappointed with the video title. Although Shaikh Uthman is 100% correct, the fact to be noted here is that if this book contains Lies, Allah swt would not let this Jamat spread all around the globe. Hundreds of people are accepting islam not bcoz of this book but the ideology, sacifices, duas, simplicity and the will to spend one's own money and time in order to please Allah swt in order to follow the footsteps of our beloved prophet Muhammad (Peace be Upon him).

[@ebunurah6162]

brother its so ignorant to say " if this book contains lies, Allah swt would not let.......". Cmon bro! The Christian bible is full of false/ridiculous stuff, yet Allah is allowing millions of people to accept Christianity as their religion. Even in some Muslim countries, majority of the religious people blindly follow their sufistic tarikaat which tells them that the only way to jannah is to give allegiance to their sheihk

[@nayazmohammad3678]

I am following a habligi jamath since 15 years, they never said fazil ul amal is the only book to read and has everything is correct, it's better for those who knows nothing about Islam...so they can start to know the Basics ( mote alfaz to understand better ) but we always recommend to read riyazud salehin and others as well. May Allah put whole muslim ummah on a right path. Only ALLAH knows which is correct and he is the only one who is accepting.

[@MoreDawaah]

Giving it to beginners is WORSE! why would you give a book with lies on the prophet ﷺ to people who know nothing about Islam? There are so many beginner books that are authentic.

[@nsikelelomacuphe9665]

​@@MoreDawaahbrother please these are only matters of faith, muslims through imaan can only guarantee the authenticity of Quran, as far as hadeeth is concerned we believe in the words of our Nabi (SAW) but all the other books were written by humans from what they heard but no one can says that 100% as what the prophet said but we believe it as part of our deen. Now if we have to start criticizing each other on hadeeth that we were not there when they were written on narrated. Please brothers this is definitely useless division

[@nayazmohammad3678]

@MoreDawaah Astagfirullah we love Prophet SAW morethan anything in this world and akhirah. May ALLAH guide us on right path if we are wrong. But we never got misguided in tabligi jamath and we always put Thalluk with ALLAH alone.

[@altafnazir]

pehli aisi dawat dekhi jisme daawat ke naam par sirf doosro ko expose kiya jata hai😂😂😂

[@salmanchandna]

Yahan exposing ka masla nahi hai mere bhai, asal maqsad to ye hai ke jo hadith huzoor e pak (alaihissalaatu wassalaam) ki taraf se chained nahi hain, yaani authentic nahi hain, unko aam public mein use kiya jaraha hai... Aur bhai yahan to fabrications bataye hain sheikh ne, Fabrication means the action or process of manufacturing or inventing something. Isliye saheeh ilm haasil karna hai mere bhai.. Main khud tableegh se judha hu aur mujhe bhi fikr hai ke kis tarah apne saathiyo ko enlighten kiya jaye saheeh ilm ke baare me.

[@AdnanKhan-bq4qf]

We are focusing on methodology, core practices, and books used by Tabligh-e-Jamat. Islam is perfect, but Muslims are not. We often use this example when giving DAWAH to non-Muslims. The effort of Tabligh is commendable, but those involved are not perfect. In fact, no one is Masoom (innocent) and free from error except the prophets. As long as Tabligh-e-Jamat remains connected with scholars and operates under their guidance, it will continue to benefit the Ummah. It is important to remember that the essence of Tabligh lies in its adherence to the teachings of Islam and the wisdom of scholars. By maintaining this connection, Tabligh-e-Jamat can ensure that its efforts are aligned with the true spirit of Islam. This approach not only strengthens the faith of its members but also fosters a sense of unity and purpose within the Muslim community. Moreover, the role of scholars in guiding Tabligh-e-Jamat cannot be overstated. Their knowledge and understanding of Islamic principles provide a solid foundation for the movement, helping it navigate challenges and stay true to its mission. By following the scholars' guidance, Tabligh-e-Jamat can continue to make a positive impact on the Ummah, promoting the values of Islam and encouraging spiritual growth. In conclusion, while the individuals involved in Tabligh may not be perfect, their collective efforts, guided by scholars, can bring about significant benefits for the Muslim community. By staying true to the core principles of Islam and seeking the wisdom of scholars, Tabligh-e-Jamat can continue to serve as a beacon of faith and unity for the Ummah.

[@k9Vlogs]

Sheikh we from India apreciate ur dawah efforts ..keep doing dawah instaed of pointing out Fazail e Amaal..Millions are on the right path coz of Tablighi Jamat.. Except ALLAH no one is Perfect..

[@faizmiah2363]

Your comment says it all, Tablighi Jammat are a deviated group

[@Alisha-z5h]

Alhamdulillah now sheikh is also pointing it out....Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (scholar) did this many years back and he is doing it❤

[@MohammedAtaullah-lo8ls]

When a alhe sunnat wal jamat - Ala hazrat tell about the kufr of this people, this man and his group start telling that we are wrong. But now he is doing same. Thats is the reason u should always follow alhe sunnat wal jamat.

[@strivingmuslimah3701]

This person isnt saying tht tablighi jamaat ppl r kafir.. He is just telling abt some Ahadith in the book they r reading, shouldn't be read and should not b thr... Learn the difference of calling someone kafir and of mentioning some mistakes in a polite and proper way... Whoever you are and whichever sect you belong to, just be very careful of calling any muslim kafir... Wat if tht person isn't and who are held accountable for it... May Allah guide us all and unite us as one muslim Ummah Ameen summa Ameen

[@MohammedAtaullah-lo8ls]

@strivingmuslimah3701 so according to your logic and the guy in video , u cannot tell if he is doing Kufr... 😂... Is that way of speaking go and speak with Qadyani jamat, Gohar Shahi jamat, shia.. Islam clearly states what is wrong is wrong. Whoever it does. The ULAMA have authority to declare kufr ....stop playing with your words like tableqi jamat

[@ProjectsnProducts]

It leaves me amazed how these men in comment section are going wild for being rectified. They need to reconsider who they're followings whether it's the prophet or their maslak elders. May Allah guide them and open their eyes and hearts to haq. Ameen

[@Saa42808]

Even the Arabic in the fine print says it is a fabricated Hadith. Go figure!!!!

[@silrein3036]

To those who said don't divide the ummah etc, I say this: right is right, wrong is wrong. If a hadith is clearly fabricated, then it is wrong and we shouldn't justify that 'hadith' based upon a certain group's good deeds to the ummah. It's irrelevant to the issue at hand. Some tried to justify that the book itself speaks a lot about good things. For this, I answer this: we should not take the book as our guidance for the same reason we don't take the bible as our guidance. If there's a lot of falsehoods, even if some of it 'can' be true, then it has lost all the credibilities to be followed. Same as any other books except the Quran and actual hadiths Stick to Rasulullah SAW's reminder to follow Quran and his Sunnah. I am sick of seeing a lot of people giving excuses for fabrications, thinking that despite those are the fabrications, what is important is the amal. That's an incredibly dumb reasoning (sorry not sorry for being harsh but honest) to justify the amal despite lying in Rasulullah SAW's name. You can say whatever you want to say about the author's deeds and intentions or you could judge and investigate the content of the book itself. Oh, I'm sure he was a wonderful guy when he was alive (according to some of you) but I don't and cannot care about his deeds (for it was for Allah SWT's judgement alone) but I can investigate the content of the book itself AND Sheikh Uthman's claims myself. It's because of these people (who still justify the fabricated hadiths etc), others slowly deviates from the actual teachings of Rasulullah SAW. Wake up, people. Look around you. See what state we are in right now. The division of ummah isn't because of people trying to come back to Islam's actual teachings.

[@Yousafxia]

Sheikh Usman sahib you are doing great Dawah work. PLZ! Don't waist your energy in such subjects having no ending.

[@Wassalaam92]

Incompetent and disingenuous. Just watched the first 3 mins. The speaker in the video conveniently ignores the bottom of the page which discusses why Sheikh Zakariyya used the Hadith and the researcher quotes from sheikh zakariyya himself.

[@sohailagwan]

In the whole world Darululoom Deoband and Tablighi Jamat work hard for muslim....and still many people who finds 1 mistake and forget 99 best things....

[@altafahmed7838]

Becoz of this book laks of people became Deen dar" Suraj ko dek ky thookny sy kya hota h 😂

[@nazeerpasha2075]

. Fits in to the definition of being a 'dajjal' ((There will come at the end of time, Dajjaals, Liars, who will come to you with ahaadeeth that neither yourselves nor your forefathers will have heard of. So beware and beware of them, lest they cause you to go astray and be put to trial)), [Saheeh Muslim and Musnad Ahmad, it is Saheeh] • And Ibn Hibbaan included the ahaadeeth on prohibiting lying against the Messenger (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) under the following chapter heading, "A mention that the one who ascribed something to al-Mustafaa while not knowing that it is authentic, then it is binding that he will enter the Fire", and then he quotes the hadeeth of Abu Hurayrah: • ((Whoever says upon me that which I did not say, let him find his seat in the Hellfire)), [Saheeh Ibn Hibbaan, p.27]

[@saleem.ullah054]

@altaf or kuch ho na ho attention zrur mil jati. Tableeghi jamaat is waqt muslmanon ki sb sy bdi jamat hai so obviously sheikh wants some attention pointing fingers at them

[@MAH-bp9tz]

They changed their life through the tabligh dakwah and reading the book before, now critising them - speak volumes of these people. If not clear and disagree, discuss with their ulama around the world.

[@fmcg60cassim88]

This guy is not even a muhaddithseen nor a mufassireen.

[@Sufismtassawuf99]

He is jahil

[@CarlosMcLaughlin]

He has a masters in hadith, may Allah be merciful to you

[@syedyousuf4409]

Forget what he is and what not. Just concentrate on what he is saying and safe your self from hellfire by not blindly following tableegi jamat

[@m.g.a2672]

Salam alaikum wa rehmat Allah dear brother ❤ Allahumma Barik Ma sha Allah Greetings from Copenhagen Denmark

[@Truth_will_reveal]

This new guy need more subscribers, astafirullah..

[@TalasoBuyole]

Asalam aleikum my brother. Yes,the a hadiths you mentioned may be fabrications but it has nothing to do with the fabrication of the efforts of spreading Islam by the tablikh bro.Am a revert because of their efforts like many more.

[@SHAKHSIYAA]

Sheikh Zakariyya is buried next to Uthman RA and Imam Malik just imagine where you will be buried by talking against him i hope not the gutters of the mexican gangland.

[@moojza]

Subhanallah forget a Shiekh would the Prophet pbuh be happy hearing you speak like this to another Muslim

[@Islamisthelight1234]

You don't even know those people's rewards from Allah only speak on people that Allah has already said we're guaranteed Jannah because you're guaranteed not talking like that you need to stop dividing the ummah by saying such things

[@masaabmushtaq]

@SHAKHSIYAA let's not get personal brothers. We are all Muslims. Let's speak with dalil.

[@funfood6176]

These so called Tableegi ,defending Tableegi Jamat has done more damage to the Jamaat itself

[@FactsWithActs]

@@SHAKHSIYAA Being buried in al Baqī does not make you infalliable you bozo

[@farooqmohammed5035]

Ya "Shiekh" ... You have found proof of (un) authenticity in the book Fadail Amaal itself. Shiekh Zakaria has given the Daleel of Weakness in sanad in his book (You have highlighted with marker all the proofs from his Fazail Amaal itself.) Kind of strange. But that makes, Shiekh Zakaria (RA) more honest in my eyes. Please refer to the book were he answers all the questions regarding errors in all Fadail Kithab. You can Google it. It's in Urdu. I have the pdf if you need. Salaam.

[@teamlegend0.855]

People use this also because it is cheaper in price than Bukhari and Muslim

[@nazeerpasha2075]

But full of garbage.

[@nsikelelomacuphe9665]

There are alot of books that simplify reading and understanding of deeni matters, fazail amaal was written with purpose to encourage people to do goods deeds in the easier manner to understand, Bukhari and Muslim are very complex and ground understanding otherwise you will be misled

[@nazeerpasha2075]

@@nsikelelomacuphe9665 ۔۔۔ The propaganda of the 'aqeedah that the Messenger of Allaah (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) is alive in his grave, listens to us and has the knowledge of the Unseen • The author of Fadhaa.il A'maal, Muhammad Zakaria Kandalvi believed and wanted to propagate that the Messenger of Allaah is: • a) alive in his grave and listens to us; b) has the knowledge of the unseen.

[@ArifKhan-vx1wi]

You are here because of Tablighi, today you will start objecting😢

[@HA554N]

Seems like nowadays you're just going on a tablighi rampage

[@tangokaram2534]

im sure its a old clip

[@IT-nl3ll]

What is sad is tablighi jamaat was the means of his hidayah. The issues he has are sometimes acceptable, but to bring to the awwaam makes no changes to the work. Take it to the mashaikh and why prevent another astray who could have benefited be stopped.

[@ad.808]

Sheikh has very little whitening in his beard in this clip, which means it's old. Common sense if you watched him recently like you're implying. Edit: I just checked the original video, it's a 6 year old clip.

[@HA554N]

@ad.808 no one said he recorded it now. But lately a lot have been uploaded against tableeghis.

[@TheBiggg7]

For once, respond to the problems he's pointing out instead of talking about unrelated things.

[@algorithmkk6924]

He is definitely right. But dont stop tabligh. Dont hate this man.. research once. Dont debate.. Thanks

[@IT-nl3ll]

What is sad is tablighi jamaat was the means of his hidayah from jahillyah. The issues he has are sometimes acceptable, but to bringing to the awwaam makes no changes to the work. Take it to the mashaikh who can make the change and why prevent another astray who could have benefited be stopped.

[@FactsWithActs]

And what does that mean? Just because he was guided throught them, they are infalliable?

[@ArkhamDeluxe]

@@FactsWithActs They feel like they have to defend the jamaat no matter what and bring emotional arguments unfortunately. I don't think anyone will respond to your comment.

[@Mohammed-iq8eh]

Thanks for pointing out. Refer to the author of the book as sheikh. You are doing a great work of dawah.. so did the late sheikh as well. And everyone will have their imperfections. But the dawah must go on. Our love towards each other and respect should always be there :) I love you

[@it-a-024-ibrahimfarwahaffa2]

For Salah "Eminent theologians like Ibn Hajr, Abu Laith Samar- qandi (Rahmatullah alaihim), and others, have mentioned this hadith in their books. This hadith, although I haven't found it in the general books of hadith, contains references to various rewards and punishments that are supported by many other narrations" Hazrat shaik RA (Author) has mentioned the above statement that he didn't find hadees but upon trusting Ibn hajr and others he is writing this hadees. Why didn't you mention this in your video?

[@islaminmyheart9348]

Are you Tabligh?

[@قرآتجميلة]

Yes

[@it-a-024-ibrahimfarwahaffa2]

@@islaminmyheart9348 why?

[@islaminmyheart9348]

@@it-a-024-ibrahimfarwahaffa2 I've heard my Lord says that " And do not be like the one who became devided and differed after clear proofs had come to them . And those will have great punishment " Qur'ani 3:105. All Muslim should unite upon Qur'an and Sunnah according to understanding of the companions of the Messenger peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Your statements made me think that you belong to Tabligh sect. If tha is the case then I call you to come back to the Sunnah if i was wrong then I didn't intend except good. And help is sought from Allaah.

[@FactsWithActs]

@@it-a-024-ibrahimfarwahaffa2 He literally did 😭

[@robertpaulson3645]

I see all these people criticising sheikh uthman about criticising the tablighi jumaat. Giving reasons that the tablighi jumaat have done so much good, but I don't see anyone saying that he is wrong, that there are no fabricated hadith in the book. If you call yourself a muslim, then you follow the prophet above all people no matter how influential and great a scholar might be. If the prophet says the one who spread lies about me will be in hellfire: The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever tells lies about me deliberately, let him take his place in Hell.” Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 1291; Muslim, 933. Thus when you know that there are false ahadith in it and you still spread this book to laymen, knowing fully that they wouldn't be able to know the difference of a true and false ahadith, then you have taken your place in hell. O people, stop supporting your brother's in things that you know are wrong, if you truly care about them. The tablighi jumat has done good but they also have their bad. Support them in good and stop them from the bad.

[@UniversalKutub]

As Salamu Alaykum, jazak Allahu khair for the benefit. Is the book muntakhab ahadith an acceptable book to read? Is it free from fabricated ahadith? This is the book that is read at my local masjid. Barak Allahu feek.

[@SBgamerCricket]

It's also same,have lots of fabricated lies and also doesn't have narration chains

[@raizeahamed2754]

​@@SBgamerCricketYou are lying bro. Munthakab ahadees is a compilation of sahih hadith and all the scholars from different aqeedahs also accept that it contains sahih Hadith. That's why it's used widely all over the world.

[@raizeahamed2754]

Munthakab ahadees is a compilation of sahih hadith and all the scholars from different aqeedahs also accept that it contains only sahih Hadith.

[@MDKAIFALAM-l9v]

​@@SBgamerCricketcan u show me one fabricated Hadith?

[@SBgamerCricket]

@@MDKAIFALAM-l9v most of the hadith starts like ali a.s narrated as but it doesn't show any narration chain at all which directly links to our prophet,it contains some sahih hadith but also contains maudu hadiths,so why u wanna use some book when u have sahih al bukhari,sahih al muslim read that directly why u want to read any other book

[@muztarshamim2312]

May Allah save us from Nifaq.

[@AhmedKhan-i7b1u]

Sheikh please suggest Some Books For Beginners

[@MuhammadBinAhmadAlTunsi]

the three fundamental principles is a good starting point

[@FactsWithActs]

He did at the end

[@IrtazaAmhad]

If you looking for a beginner hadith book you could start with 40 Hadith of Imam Nawawi or Riyad Ul Saleheen.

[@IrtazaAmhad]

Sheikh also has playlist where he suggests some must have Islamic books for a layman. You can check that out. It’s a 5 video series.

[@mudassirahmad7862]

@@IrtazaAmhad 40 Ahadith of imam ahamd anawawi

[@masoodali3294]

Sheikh well said. Really, these books not only have fabricated and weak hadiths but also have a lot of innovations. The tablighjamaat people are blindly followers. They follow blindly their scholars and they never and ever tried to know how far their scholars teaching matches with the quran and sunnah. They don't even pray the Salat ul Witr according to sunnah. They pray witr same as Magrib prayer. In the authenticated hadith, Rasool Allah strictly forbade the ummah not to pray witr like Mahgrib prayer. They hate raising hands in prayers but they raise their hands in the last rakat of witr salah. WHY??? Going out for dawah for 3 days, 10 days and 40 days is not proven with any authentic hadith. Neither our beloved prophet SAW nor his companions ever did it. They never do tabligh in non muslims area to invite them to Islam and they never talked about fiqh problems as they are weak in knowledge. Many Tabligh and Devband scholars accepted that they talk without evidence.

[@aiyubpatel9165]

What Sheikh Uthmaan says is known in the Tablighi circles. The benefit the work of Tabligh has done in the muslim community far outweighs tye negatives. Does Shiekh Uthman think he is only one who knows about strong and weak habits. These kind of videos do a disservice to the Ummah. Please refrain from such activities. How really are causing unnecessary problems in the muslim community.

[@MoreDawaah]

Nothing outweighs lies on Rasulullah ﷺ. There are many other authentic books on virtuous deeds they can promote. No need of being so staunch on a book that they know has FABRICATED Ahadith. Moreover it'd be a huge mistake giving it to the laymen who don't know the gradings and how it works.

[@ArkhamDeluxe]

@@MoreDawaah The message is clear, may Allah open their eyes to see that Tablighi/tablighi jamaat is not all there is to Islamic dawah and iman revival

[@Ziad_Rahman]

Do not overlook minor wrongs in favor of major rights. What is wrong remains wrong and must be addressed and rectified. Avoid being an apologist.

[@basilfoster3107]

My dear brothers, we are muslims and there's no need to berate or insult each other. If our brother makes a mistake point it out to him with kindness and wisdom. In regard to this book, the solution is simple; It can be edited and the and fabricated ahadiths removed. There's no shortage of sound ahadith that can be used. And of course attributing false sayings to our dear prophet Peace be upon him is indeed a great sin.

[@TablighiJamaat-sh6wc]

It's ironic, the claim that Fadhail Amaal has fabricated Hadith is based on Sheikh Uthman's fabricated evidences! Please read the arabic references properly. I don't think Sheikh Uthman reads arabic well enough.

[@shahzaryarkhan9106]

Show us then. any authentic hadiths.

[@TablighiJamaat-sh6wc]

@@shahzaryarkhan9106 There is already a strong write up on this on our website. We can't post links on you tube

[@zakariagharbaoui1210]

Rarely in Holland did I see them read this book, 99% of the time the read Riyad salihin, Been sitting with brother of tabligh in the Netherlands for over 17 years now.