Jews & 1917 Russian Revolution

Professors Gary Saul Morson (Northwestern U), Gabriella Safran (Stanford U) and Kenneth Moss (Johns Hopkins U) discuss aspects of Jewish culture surrounding the 1917 Russian Revolution. A program of YIVO at the Center for Jewish History in NYC.

[@ur4n1um]

How much does the ADL pay you?

[@Fatelovesirony960]

Jews were lucky to be living in Europe and took that for granted as well.

[@notsocrates9529]

_200 Years Together_ or something.

[@artzcard]

Read “The International Jew” by Henry Ford. He knew the deal back in the early 1900’s.

[@alexmeplease]

It's a fascinating book. It's like a prelude to Kevin McDonald's classic. I'd also recommend the Institute for Historical Review, and fantastic historian called Andrew Joyce who focuses on the topic. There has been a LOT of in-depth work documenting social relations between Jews and other ethnic groups which is never fairly addressed by mainstream academics or media.

[@drbrainstein1644]

What about those who say they are Jews and are not, but are the Synagogue of Satan? I’m trying to point out let’s not collectivize an identity group for mass murder. Instead, let’s focus on our enemies and mass murder them in particular. 😂

[@thebestofallworlds187]

try reading "The Myth Of German Villainy" by Benton L. Bradberry@@alexmeplease

[@gweltas1372]

The same Henry Ford who financed the Nazi Party in the 1930s, having made France a vassal and genocided 36 million Europeans, including 31 million Slavs, in the name of the “Germanness of Europe” ? Lol 😆 !

[@PaulDiNardo-pt5mj]

Wow

[@lindajamshidi]

he's quoting Engles and Trotsky? Shame on him. Jews have no shame.

[@AgendaFiles]

What would you prefer to be quoted, material instead from a sports game? You have clicked on a video that discusses some history of Imperial Russia and Soviet Russia, then are shocked that Engels and Trotsky are mentioned. Mental.

[@eg4848]

...yes why would a historian quote important historical figures. Why the fuck does this comment even have likes you guys are morons wtf

[@d862]

Vermin

[@analogueoverdigital929]

None at all. Trotsky...😅

[@thebestofallworlds187]

35:27 ... it's because he was trying to protect his kingdom from Jews.

[@kagenou3359]

so his country was so weak that a small poor oppressed jews had been such a large threat to him

[@yuothineyesasian]

I can hear the hands rubbing together

[@DontcallmeaCuck]

Lol 😂

[@thebestofallworlds187]

3:23 when the Jewish Bolsheviks, he means.

[@AgendaFiles]

A completely retarded statement, as the February Revolution which established the Provisional Government had nothing to do with the Bolsheviks, who themselves were overthrown by the Bolsheviks in the October Revolution when they walked away and allowed Lenin's rise. Js had little influence in the Bolshevik party, in 1917 they represented 13% of the leadership, by 1922 this was down to 5% and by 1928 down further to 4%. I am wasting my time on someone so removed.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@AgendaFiles After the October Revolution, Jewish Bolsheviks took over Russia's gov't.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@AgendaFiles and he said "When the Bolsheviks overthrow the Provisional gov't." lol

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@AgendaFiles He's not talking about the February Revolution but the end of the Provisional gov't here numb nuts.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

14:34 ... no difference between subjective and objective? what a stupid quote.

[@user-fg8ux8zo6w]

how many jews are there in Vietnam? China?

[@NoahBodze]

This is a classic non sequitur.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@NoahBodze kzbin.info/www/bejne/pXrIiqJ8ZrubfsU

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@NoahBodze how so?

[@TheHeavensFellen]

Historically China had a few small settlements, Kaifan was one area or city where Jews settled inside China.

[@NoahBodze]

@@thebestofallworlds187 do you know what a non sequitur is? What is the name of the video and how is that different from the comment about Vietnam and China?

[@binder946]

what was wring with 1917 revolution. jewish people should be proud of karl marx, tortsky and lenin. we should proudly own them as heros.

[@j.rebekah8605]

'1880...... brought a new jewish culture focused on pan european secular ideals' that's interesting @ 36:15

[@gweltas1372]

1) Of the 36 members of the Bolshevik Party in 1917, only 7 of them were Ashkenazim. Everyone else was Russian, Ukrainian or Georgian. There was also a Belarusian, an Armenian and a Pole. The 80% Ashkenazim of the first Soviet government arrived AFTER the Russian Civil War. And most did not consider themselves Jews but atheists. Knowing that Jews were also persecuted by the Soviet authorities. The USSR was above all radical and forced atheism. Any religious community was doomed to repression or sending to the gulags. Be it Orthodox Christians, Jews, Sunni Muslims, Tibetan Buddhists, etc. 2) Most of these Ashkenazim were killed during the Stalinist purges. The latter also launched a real anti-Semitic campaign at the end of the 1940s, claiming a plot against himself (the famous White Coat Plot).

[@GhostBanned369]

Most were these arabic type of Jews ?

[@tooth8551]

The US and Rothschilds controlled the USSR after WW1. Look at the American manufacturing plants brought in.

[@aburaeese]

24:55 the Simpsons family! 😂

[@Canadian789119]

I'm I listening to a story? Or isn't this supposed to be history lol

[@TheHeavensFellen]

yeah his - story

[@thebestofallworlds187]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pXrIiqJ8ZrubfsU

[@conlawmeateater8792]

​@TheHeavensFellen is it legend?

[@richardnailhistorical3445]

I think you have to be a Jew to understand what these people are saying?

[@AgendaFiles]

Or perhaps have intelligence.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

they are purposefully trying to be hard to understand so they can muddle everything down.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@AgendaFiles Putin is way more concise on this issue when he simply said the first Soviet gov't was 80-85% Jewish: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pXrIiqJ8ZrubfsU.

[@richardnailhistorical3445]

@@AgendaFiles Or perhaps, be a Jew?

[@eg4848]

@@thebestofallworlds187 Why do you keep commenting on this video you're totally obsessed. "hmm this goes against my retarded alt right narrative better sperg out"

[@yuothineyesasian]

Hilarious that they stole the same three letters for the John Birch Society.

[@alexmeplease]

I suppose it's fitting since the John Birchers covered for them. They were like modern republicans, they love talking empty words about the effects of the problem, but avoid the true cause like the plague.

[@villiestephanov984]

Bakunin did not write Exodus 2, nor Marx revolutionized D.24:6 ! But God has revealed Them to us through His Spirit, for the Spirit searches all things -"Yes" - the deep things of God. But we have renounced the hidden things of shame not walking in craftiness nor handling the word of God deceitfully, but by manifestation of the truth commending ourselves to every man's consience in the sight of God. Did not your fathers eat and drink and do justice and Righteousness and then it was well with us?? But no! So Then I say, I will not make mention of them nor speak anymore of their names. Surely, I am Your spoke person for the people before God... Az Surah 58:18 kak da Vi q preveda ? Otgovora E na BG : Surah 57:25-27 !

[@stevej5185]

Oy vey, someone call a doctor.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

the guy in this video muddles everything down.

[@thebestofallworlds187]

@@stevej5185 Jewish Revolution of 1917.

[@BertGraef]

@@stevej5185shut up. Talmud twit