Defending Israel with David Harris: Einat Wilf

[@AnitaSherman-m1m]

Thank you Einat for a very informative lecture. Shalom to you and Israel.

[@MarkHastings-jc3bw]

Thanks for having Dr Wilf. She is amazing, knowledgeable, articulate, succinct, and persuasive.

[@rickipacaci1338]

She's brilliant and love hearing her speak!!! She's a fantastic historian and has nailed the problem completely in my opinion ‼️🇮🇱

[@Ariverwhosestreamsmakeglad]

Thank you for this. Her analysis is well stated.

[@Namko78]

Jew haters used to tell me they wanted the 1947 borders or the Oslo accords borders. Now they are brazen and bold enough to state they want all the land. Her point has been proven on the streets of the west

[@gg_rider]

When you have more time for adding context, it's important to recognize Jewish refugee contributions to Arab families in the region in the decades before Israel. Eradication of the deadly scourge of malaria in the region and thereby creating new habitable land that did not previously exist, more land for both Arabs and Jews. Also, unless I'm mistaken, Arab Muslim support for multiculturalism from notable Arab clan leaders like Nashashibi .. who were terrorized and assassinated by hostile Arabs like Al-Husseini. But also violent Arab hostility to the Jewish presence in the area when they were a small weak defenseless population and not in any sense a threat to Arabs, other than Arab racism and the Islamic requirement to dominate or destroy infidels, especially Jews.

[@David-yp4fl]

LOVE FROM MISSISSIPPI USA 🇺🇲

[@1DaTJo]

Einat Wilf is one of the very few speakers without a speech impediment, and as such, she is a real joy to listen to. Every our beloved Douglas Murray has got a woeful stutter. Dr Wilf is exemplary! ❤❤❤

[@direncakmak8894]

Best wishes from Turkey❤

[@David-yp4fl]

🌿 LOVE FROM MISSISSIPPI USA 🇺🇲

[@saraleigh5336]

Wilf is insightful, even when what is being said is unwelcome and sobering.

[@krzysztofskladanowski2490]

Women will deliver our western civilisation. From Poland with love!

[@lennarthallberg9918]

Nobody has a solution for a two state solution, so what is it? It certainly is not a solution, it`s a problem.

[@marciateperman8811]

Einat ❤❤❤

[@davesax11]

Essential to watch. Corollaries: If the Palestinian Arabs have never NEVER accepted the right of Jews to a State, why is it wrong for Israelis to assert claims in Judea & Samaria? Have Arab Palestinians forfeited their right to a State? What would make a Palestinian State a peaceful neighbor?

[@EddyBasch]

Arafat walked away from the 2 state solution because it did not include his concept of 'The Right of Return' which would have meant a 'One State Solution' for the Arabs since Jews would become a minority in Israel proper. Einat is either extremely naive or blindly invested in her 'Secularism' which continues to hold her prisoner to her wildly contradictory views. The Arabs insistence that there is no place for a Jewish State anywhere in the Middle East (world) is fundamentally grounded in Islam (see Mordichi Kedar's analysis of the situation for clarity). This tough pill, it seems, is still stuck in the throat of Einat who can't bring herself to accept it fully, and finds no solace in her 'Secular Humanism' whereas, observant Jews have known about this since the beginning, and this understanding is not a source of moral confusion. The Arabs must be expelled from ALL of Israel (Judea & Samaria included) pure and simple. The 22 Arab states have their obligations too! That is the logical conclusion/solution.

[@SionTJobbins]

@@EddyBasch moral clarity won't be much use if Israel tries to expel some 4 million Palestinian Arabs. The Arabs will unite and the West won't support you. If you think, "fine the gentiles have never support it" then just take a minute to consider the fate of the Kurds who have no proper outside support or the Armenians (who Israel discracefully betrayed by selling drones to the Turkish genocidal Azeris) who also never got west (or any other) support to defend the Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh or in the 1915 Genocide. States, big and small, need allies.

[@Aijan100]

People are waking up too late to the reality of the direct connection of the perpetuated Israeli Palestinian conflict and the doctrine of Islam with its metaphysical vision of Jews as the arch enemies of Allah.

[@waitaminute2015]

​@@EddyBasch Are you saying she can't accept the fact that there's a religious aspect to the denial of a state of Israel? People would accuse her of hate and phobia and disregard her argument. They would say there's more moderate Muslims blah blah blah. Why does it even matter why they believe Jews shouldn't have a state? It only matters that they don't. I'm just trying to understand your critique. I'm not an educated person, so if I'm off base, please correct me.

[@EddyBasch]

Palestinian nationalism based on religious ideology can never accept a Jewish State and the entire false Palestinian identity is predicated on this premise. See Jordan Peterson's interview with 'Son of Hamas for clarity on this issue and others like Mordechi Kedar for a deeper understanding of the Islamic Jihadist world view. Based on the fact that this cultural/religious perspective is foundational to the Palestinian (false) identity and that 'Palestine' as a state, country or self governing entity never existed, in addition to the fact that the entire Palestine identity narrative is a false one, it is not wrong for Israelis to claim Judea and Samaria as part and parcel of the ancestral Jewish homeland. Once this false narrative of a Palestinian identity is finally dismantled it could be possible to have so called Palestinian Arabs living in Israel proper as a demilitarized cultural entity.

[@lennarthallberg9918]

Two-state problem is a much more fitting term for the whole two state model.

[@peretzo]

She really IS amazing.

[@oswaldohenriquez7419]

Excellent analysis 👏 👍 ❤❤❤

[@raichel2therescue]

I saw a video where it showed a secondary grenade explosion on the first group. You see the initial gray smoke then two separate fire blasts with black smoke.

[@waitaminute2015]

God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things i can, and the wisdom to know the difference. Palestinians have an addiction to this problem. They cannot change what is. Its time to accept it.

[@marinahayon6701]

כיף הקשיב לאישה חכמה וגם ללמוד ממנה .

[@David-yp4fl]

🌿 ♥️ LOVE FROM MISSISSIPPI USA 🇺🇲

[@colinress]

Explained so well.

[@MichaelElias-q2z]

Ms. Wilf, let's take your realization to the full extent. If Israel ceased to exist, Eygpt, Syria and Jordan would never, ever allow an independent Palestinian state to survive. Egypt would reoccupy Gaza, Syria would take back the Golan heights and much of the adjacent territory, and Jordan would become Transjordan and, for sure, would grab back Jerusalem, the west bank and the rest of Israel from the "river to the sea".

[@ericsuper1627]

Thank you both for discussion for futher recognition of some fundamental issues and highlights on arabic settlers in the land of Israel

[@leebataldar30]

Einat Wolf brings such an accurate and clear picture of the truth.

[@Kurtlane]

Einat is great at points where she has grown up and away from her leftist euphoria. But she has a lot more growing up to do. With regard to Islam, to Arab rulers and people, and to the future of Palestinian identity. And, frankly, to human nature. Still too much hope, too much optimism. Also, no mention at all of those Jews who did listen to the other side and were not swept away into the peace euphoria. And were demonized as conservatives, "settlers" (even if they lived in Tel Aviv), "religious fanatics" (even if they were not religious), "war mongers," etc. etc. They turned out to be right, and nobody gives them any credit.

[@bethcares17anonymous38]

Einat please improve your microphone.

[@msieradzki]

Marvelous

[@Aijan100]

At last Israel seems to start understanding the true Palestinian motives in this conflict.

[@kj1483]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/j4uynXaVpZuniNk Dr. Einat Wilf, the 2021 Georgetown Goldman Visiting Professor, gives annual Goldman lecture hosted by Center for Jewish Civilization at Georgetown. 9 Dec 2021 0:00 Introduction 3:32 Abu Dhabi Accords 10:32 WhatsApp Group 12:33 The UAE 14:13 normalization with Israel 15:42 flipping the narrative 18:49 antizionism vs prozionism the essence of the conflict

[@David-yp4fl]

🌿 THAT IS GREAT INFORMATION ℹ️ THANK YOU FOR SHARING ♥️ LOVE FROM MISSISSIPPI USA 🇺🇲

[@rjh2772]

It all biblical no worries the God of Israel is faithful to defend his chosen people

[@David-yp4fl]

I LOVE WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY ♥️ LOVE FROM MISSISSIPPI 🇺🇲

[@SionTJobbins]

where was your god in the Holocaust, or, did the Jews (secular, haredi, socialist, capitalist, Yiddish, Ladino, children, elderly) "deserve it"?

[@ThunkingTime]

Then meet.

[@TheMomeni]

God bless Israel

[@gagacoco5577]

From the river to the sea ISRAEL WILL ALWAYS BE ❤

[@EddyBasch]

Arafat walked away from the 2 state solution because it did not include the f 'The Right of Return' which would have meant a 'One State Solution' for the Arabs since Jews would become a minority in Israel proper. Einat is either extremely naive or blindly invested in her 'Secularism' which continues to hold her prisoner to her wildly contradictory views. The Arabs insistence that there is no place for a Jewish State anywhere in the Middle East (world) is fundamentally grounded in Islam (see Mordichi Kedar's analysis of the situation for clarity). This tough pill, it seems, is still stuck in the throat of Einat who can't bring herself to accept it fully, and finds no solace in her 'Secular Humanism' whereas, observant Jews have known about this since the beginning, and this understanding is not a source of moral confusion. The Arabs must be expelled from ALL of Israel (Judea & Samaria included) pure and simple. The 22 Arab states have their obligations too! That is the logical conclusion/solution.

[@mozar937]

Qatar and Saudi Arabia name all the major universities as well as the major UK football teams

[@Lonigo77]

Great. A calm, collected analysis. Always best. Thank you, Einat.

[@ThunkingTime]

Calm does not equal correct.

[@Lonigo77]

@@ThunkingTime Calmly expressed.

[@marinahayon9261]

Один вопрос : почему правым это было понятно всегда , а некоторым левым непонятно даже сегодня.

[@gordonmurray2477]

Defending the indefensible. Get a truthful Jewish Historian on, Ilan Pappe. You should all read his book the Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. Also listen to Darryl Cooper’s Martyr Made Podcasts- Fear and Loathing in the New Jerusalem. This provides a complete and truthful account of the Israeli Palestinian conflict.

[@robertgannon-cx2mm]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@carmencastaneda9881]

Ella es muy hábil, pero tiene una mirada de maldad increible

[@augen8819]

You are from eastern europe and morroco and ethiopia and Spain, what are you doing in the middle east???😊

[@shainazion4073]

And you are spreading lies, why?

[@sandyjamison2834]

That's inaccurate. Most Jews in Israel are from North Africa and Middle East decent.

[@augen8819]

@@sandyjamison2834 sephardi are Spanish, ashkinasi are european, Ethiopian are African

[@Foster-rv6ty]

You're from Saudi Arabia, Syria, Lebanon Jordan and as muslim Arabs, what are you doing in Palestine?

[@augen8819]

@@Foster-rv6ty Warsaw gehtoo is ur promised land

[@stefansollberger5658]

very naughty..

[@bosheihab6463]

defending the indefensible...yuck

[@augen8819]

She is from eastern europe, she will go back even after 50 years

[@shainazion4073]

*_"A genome-wide genetic signature of Jewish ancestry perfectly separated individuals with and without full Jewish ancestry in a large random sample of European Americans"_* this study shows that *Ashkenazi Jews can be told (from Europeans) at 100% accuracy by DNA tests.* if you search the bold title with the *National Vanguard,* you will find the study and article showing that Ashkenazi Jews can be told from Europeans at 100% accuracy, even those with just one Jewish parent or grandparent.

[@ThunkingTime]

@@shainazion4073 If you're looking at genome studies, pull up the multiple that have been done demonstrating that the palestinians are more closely tied to historical residents of the regions than ashkenazi jews have ever been.