Shamika Ravi: Growth In Smallest, Least Developed Parts Of The Country Revealed By Satellite Data

[@rakhirakhi1626]

Very women in India should look up to her ‘ what a conviction Hats off mam

[@KVR8527]

Madam is superb. I understood from her presentation actually what is happening in India

[@ramaraocheepi7847]

This debate is insightful and relevant , appreciated. This apart,as commoner, with no bias to any party past and present, phenomenal allround develooments happened in the last 10 yrs , no denial. I also feel for all this incredible growth, surely the GOI , spearheaded by Honourable pm responsible.

[@Arihant997]

Shamika is quite insightful..

[@sreenavenugopalan936]

See Rahul thinks he is all that! Omg! He needs to really be taught journalism. Its simply sad!

[@manishashimla]

Shamika ji, amazing to seethe way you express your brilliance. Thank you for your work.

[@adiiyer]

Hahaa...Rahul you have the luxury of me being here so let me explain my research. Slap across his face for half baked reporting.

[@bepositive5079]

Excellent.

[@sanjeevkumarc3686]

Change happened mainly because of cheap communication availability after 2g allocation. Once internet availability on mobile was cheap things changed fast.

[@naysayer7540]

2G and speed ?

[@shssolutions6011]

Arvind ji has verbal diarrhoea ... This is not an English Class .... Please share your presentation on Economic Data / SWOT etc

[@lightofdurgalakshmi]

Can anyone summarize?

[@mayurkulkarni2829]

The Challenge of Interpreting Economic Growth: Shamika Ravi's Perspective [00:02] Government's portrayal of economic growth questioned - Private investment numbers may reveal true economic health - Approaches of macroeconomists and microeconomists differ in analyzing the economy [00:53] Understanding the efficiency of FDI in the Indian economy - Examining the percentage of GDP attributed to FDI and its trends over time. - Delving deeper into the nuances to analyze the impact on the economy's growth potential. [01:40] Challenges in private investments due to policy shocks - Policy shocks like retrospective tax and annulled allocations hindered private confidence - Recent growth in private investments is a long-term recovery from past disastrous policies [02:42] Satellite data reveals growth in smallest, least developed parts of the country. - Visualizations show annualized growth rate of builtup surfaces across parliamentary constituencies from 2010 to 2015. - Darker colors suggest higher growth of builtup surface areas. [03:36 European commission satellite data reveals growth in small and underdeveloped areas. - The data covers parliamentary constituencies and subdistricts, showing built-up areas as a proxy for economic activity. - The data indicates an 18% increase in economic activity over a 5-year period. [04:29 Growth in least developed parts revealed by satellite data - Satellite data reveals a 30% growth difference in early epoch - Efficiency in international money usage and government spending leads to higher multiplier effect [05:19]) Economic activity accelerating on the ground - Discussion on the impact of government actions on growth - Highlighting the growth rate from 2015 to 2020 at 3-3.5% [06:18]Achievements and failures in the last 10-15 years are cumulative and bipartisan. - The jam Trinity is an example of a bipartisan achievement, with seeds sown in the previous government. - Focus should be on the government's needs, path, and deficiencies, rather than engaging in political bickering.

[@domini1331]

Is it economic activities or construction activities? Generally, politicians prefer construction activities as they can expect commission and donation to their parties from contractors. Also, public money can be spent easily.

[@lightofdurgalakshmi]

@@domini1331 infrastructure investment precedes economic investment. I think thats what she is implying by increase in build-up area in certain constituencies.

[@domini1331]

​@@lightofdurgalakshmi Unfortunately, often it stops with infrastructure creation. Further activities may not be lucrative for politicians. Also, at present, the government is not interested in starting establishments in the public sector. Private sector is not finding much profitable options either.

[@rajumarella5362]

Satellite data for economic activity !! Interesting.!!!!. I don’t know how they are more accurate than the actual numbers !!.

[@srinisbir8781]

The difference is like getting marks in exam and actually knowing the subject. Gdp can be cooked up, misleading in many number of ways. Satellite data tells us the real activity going on on the ground. China has a similar problem. Its GDP data doesn't corroborate the satellite data. China has cooked up its GDP data to no bounds.

[@Arihant997]

But economic policies work way beyond one elected governments period ..

[@Arihant997]

Shamika maams saree 🥻 ♥️ and blouse match perfectly maybe like her analysis!!

[@MrDeVillie]

Shamika Ravi's submissions were more insightful; Arvind Subramanian's concerns were very high-level, detached, almost academic. His point GDP numbers being off to the point of being ununderstandable needs to be fixed though.

[@greenpeace1474]

God bless raganathanji

[@rajuchinchodi2609]

What is satellite data?

[@hyz4702]

Please stop this advertisement 😅

[@prasadseerasaley6126]

European data never gives rosy picture n progress of our country.

[@kamalsh6123]

I have listened to Shamika a few times lately. She is a woman with conviction and too damn brilliant. Good that Modi has selected a hands on specialist and not some one like bombastic Raghuram Rajan.

[@sreenavenugopalan936]

How is this guy still reporting... his reporting on Anant Ambani.. was absolutely horrible!

[@vandanadeshpande7171]

Shamika is just superb in front of Arvind. Arvind is look like Rahul Gandhi’s agent

[@agsitaraman3270]

He is not Rahul s agent

[@Noname-oq9mk]

What is the rebuttal of him against that data, he's so defensive

[@prasadseerasaley6126]

Even our own pseudo secularists appreciate the progress of the country.

[@parthibank2736]

The fruits of the seeds sown before 10 years.

[@hereismycomment-l7r]

No doubt about that. All programmes right from rebranded digital India to underwater metro to dwarkaexpress way to every single bit is a Congress gift to the ungrateful people!

[@Junu-l6v]

@@hereismycomment-l7r…outch really !!!!! Yeaah sure . I thought this is not a comedy show.

[@anilkaralamangala1431]

After sowing, need to nurture it, water it, apply manure, protect it from weeds and pests, which the UPA never did, they allowed pests and parasites to develop while the seeds suffered growing up. NDA took care and saw that the seeds grew into tree and started bearing fruits😂😂

[@hereismycomment-l7r]

@@anilkaralamangala1431 Wish all that you said was true. I would have been the happiest. Fact is they got the tree that just needed inaugurations. Nurturing, weed protection etc were in auto-pilot mode. Do you know what auto-pilot means?

[@Junu-l6v]

@@anilkaralamangala1431 …you’re right . One can take the horse near the water but can’t force him to drink . ..that is happening with UPA supporters. They haven’t learn to acknowledge the goodness this government doing…who cares …..if their attitude stays same they will be the losers . We have 350 start-up Companies in 2014 in 2024 we have 90000 start-up companies,most importantly around 111 unicorn start-up have more than $1 billion dollars. ( WION PUBLICATION ON 30th January2024 ) . Bravo to millennials.

[@prasadseerasaley6126]

Good analysis of the govt programs n progress made by the government.

[@amiindra]

Why all starda are commenting.. shamelessly.. even though their masters lost it all but their servants are still loyal

[@sreenavenugopalan936]

Subu guy is just laughing.. and ridiculing and then saying gibberish. When they say bipartisan and we shouldn't compare.. not interesting.. political bickering.. Any fool knows whats up! 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@extreme596]

"Luxury of me being here",??? Is she a narcissist ??

[@robertfox1975]

Most women at that level are

[@WesleyMatthew]

So was Adam Smith, Macro or Micro😅 , 21st century economists

[@abhijitsen8514]

Wasn't she engaged in plagiarism?

[@Nifty1976]

No using verifiable secondary data does not amount to plagarism

[@parthibank2736]

This just a mockery, with builtup area. The population has increased, she is not providing data with respect to population.

[@amiindra]

Let’s Congress publish the data till 2014

[@parthibank2736]

It's already available with the present Govt they need to present

[@AlphaIshu]

The nfhs survey pretty much covers them though not in depth as census.

[@naytonfernandes2991]

Everytime she says "I THINK"...... She is smart.....with time we cannot catch hold of her on what she has said.......

[@sharathahuja8261]

Lutyen's Subramanian.

[@diwakarsharma5542]

Jhooth jhooth jhooth!!!

[@shirazahmed6260]

The stark reality is one third of India's population sleeps without sufficient food to eat. All this jargon being used by so called Economists here is just semantic jugglery.

[@kamalsh6123]

You are, probably, talking about Pakistan.

[@FardeenKhan-ex6mv]

Rahul animals juice

[@keralander743]

Growing economy with a Crashing stock market 😂 Every public companies selling off , National Debt is raising, taking electoral bond as bribery. It is best time for corporate companies not for common man.

[@sulabhrocks]

Better than stagnant economy.. And for record it is better to get the data for last 1 year.. U will get the picture..

[@anitapadhi325]

from which university did you get a degree on Macro-economics ?😂😂 only a fool compares mkt to fundamentals , mkt self adjusts itself boom and bust is a natural cycle just a data US mkts crashed in 30s but 40s were one of the best times for US exactly so was in case of 20s. Structural prob take 30/40 years to show symptoms eg- BoP crisis of 90s was result of mismanagement in 60s.

[@keralander743]

@@anitapadhi325 I know you are a brainless hot potato , In our area your type people known as andh bhakt 🤣 And you guys are selling off our so called fundamentals and should be answered later in the streets when our national debt arise to beyond control ......your godhi media don't show this to you.....

[@keralander743]

@@anitapadhi325 You are an absolute idiot thinking of market will self adjust .......then why SEBI need to interfere and say there is a bubble in the mid and small caps ?????..........

[@keralander743]

@@sulabhrocks No It's a blown up economy built by loan money it will collapse soon mark my word India is not near to even china they have far better infrastructure compared to India their vehicles sold internationally........ they are far better in safety and features compared to indian cars ..........that don't even qualify to compete .