Shannon Sharpe ranks Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, Tua Tagovailoa & 2020 QB NFL Draft Class | Nightcap

Shannon Sharpe and Chad "Ochocinco" Johnson react to former Minnesota Vikings GM Rick Spielman's ranking of the quarterbacks from the 2020 NFL Draft class. Unc and Ocho rank Cincinnati Bengals QB Joe Burrow, Philadelphia Eagles QB Jalen Hurts, Miami Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa, Green Bay Packers QB Jordan Love, and Los Angeles Chargers QB Justin Herbert in terms of which quarterback they'd want under center for the next 5 years.
Follow Nightcap on all platforms:
Twitter: / nightcapshow_
Instagram: / nightcapshow_
TikTok: / nightcapshow_
Facebook: www.facebook.c...
ABOUT NIGHTCAP:
No more waiting until morning. Nightcap is the new nighttime sports talk destination with legends Shannon Sharpe, Chad “Ochocinco” Johnson, and Gilbert Arenas. Hang out with Unc, Ocho, and Gil as they give their unfiltered takes on the latest headlines from the NFL, NBA, and college football, and give their instant reactions to the biggest games moments after they end.
#Nightcap #ShannonSharpe #Ochocinco #GilbertArenas

[@tjayd1225]

Burrow is the head of the class still. But as a whole this is probably the best qb class I’ve ever seen. Burrow, Herbert, Tua, Love, Hurts is a DEEP class

[@FastLane12345]

Burrow can’t even stay healthy and Herbert a choke artist

[@Ryan-wx1bi]

​@@FastLane12345We will see now that Herbert has a real coach

[@navyglass1242]

I think burrow can ball, Herbert is dope, Tua is not all that, hurts, sorry but he is trash, love ( I'm a packer fan) let's see what he has next year. I'm undecided but I'd take love over Tua and hurts though, love has way more control of the offense and understanding then tua and hurts. I hate hurts, I wish he read defenses better. I'd say burrow, Herbert, love, tua, no hurts

[@047Kenny]

@@FastLane12345you say that like it’s burrows fault he got a bad OLine. Him and Brady the only ones to beat Patty in the off szn and he’s done it twice.

[@inspectah_ant]

You must be young if this is the best class you have ever seen

[@maxb9435]

Jordan Love before Burrow is CRAZY. Talk about prisoner of the moment hahahah jesus. that's nuts.

[@AilmanF2P]

Burrow has been injured for two seasons including his rookie season. He got injured twice last season with two different injuries. If you listened they said "if he can stay healthy" thats a big off and the main reason he is in second place.

[@SmileyBoi21]

@@AilmanF2P it's crazy that in his first healthy season, he reached the Super Bowl and in his second he made it to the AFC title game. It's clear that despite the injuries Joe’s height is greater than the other QBs.

[@onlyysinn]

@@SmileyBoi21You could make that exact same argument for purdy

[@PapaUnc]

@@SmileyBoi21maybe, but he looked terrible this year with the injuries

[@TV1111TV]

Not that crazy, Love has all the arm talent AND can scramble. Burrow can’t run

[@g.o.a.tsports2880]

Love played well for 8 weeks & suddenly better than everyone listed lmao

[@emilianoorozco6498]

yup

[@kodyjacobs3251]

Hate tua and if you take him over tua you’re crazy

[@TopGKev]

YUP gonna own the bears for another decade

[@thetruthis5981]

@@kodyjacobs3251I’d take Love over Tua any day of the week. Tua is the worst out of this list

[@IFWTC]

@@kodyjacobs3251put me in an insane asylum then

[@ur_really_salty]

I like how Hurts has a bad year because of play calling and coaching and now all of a sudden Philly paid him to much no Hurts will prove himself again this coming season

[@derekmoore5271]

Yeah all you c an do is wait and hope they eat their words but hurts has done a whole of hell lot more than anybody in that class outside of maybe burrow.

[@deehill6719]

Hurts only had 1 good year lets stop it

[@jamargraham6707]

​@@deehill6719😂😂😂😂 you didn't have to do Hurts like that. Being real though Herbert should be last until further notice

[@oggoth8923]

@@deehill6719 im so tired of hearing he had one good year keep that same energy for the next 5 and i hope to see you comment again

[@Twisty757]

​@@deehill6719Love played well for a few weeks, not even a full year of playing good, Tua an Justin haven't done what Hurts has, so if you wanna trash Hurts the others I mentioned get no pass either!

[@Mattmusic11111111]

Love wins one playoff game and they want to put him above two dudes that have been to the Super Bowl 😂😂

[@thatisz9370]

Exactly. It's beyond wild

[@sontho6995]

Joe has injury issues and Hurts is more of an unknown variable than love, as he has a really great roster yet lost to the bucs.

[@aliali-ce3yf]

NFL is a what have you done lately league. Lately Burrow is injured, plays for a bad organization. Hurts - who knows if 2 years ago was mostly because of a great OC. Love took out a talented Cowboys team and should've beat the 49ers, and if they did, pretty sure he would've been to the Super Bowl

[@Mattmusic11111111]

@@sontho6995 they have done way more than love and there is no reason to think they can’t keep doing more

[@sontho6995]

@@Mattmusic11111111 I'm hesitant to say that because joe is in a heavier QB conference. And Jalen's play from last season to this season nosedived way too much.

[@fajrprice8453]

Recency bias is crazy 😭

[@MrRock0002]

Heavyyyyyy

[@IronHide3910]

I feel the same, last we heard of Love was when GB got him just to piss off Rodgers, now all of a sudden he’s a top tier QB 😂

[@scottytwo6]

I fw Love but that switch up crazy then a mf

[@TV1111TV]

@@IronHide3910 try watching football instead of relying on what you hear

[@IronHide3910]

@@TV1111TV you think Love is above Hurts as a QB?

[@mattkelley279]

How are we putting Love ahead of Hurts already? Hurts had one of the best SB performance by any player. Love just started his 1st season.

[@GoodFellaPack]

Hurts was ass last season that’s why

[@mattkelley279]

@@GoodFellaPack Love had half of one good season and now he’s the best? Hurts has 1 bad half a season and people act like he’s trash. The entire Eagles team imploded.

[@dumpsterfirefrl]

@@mattkelley279Nah hurts was mid then had 1 elite season under Steichen and when Steichen left he regressed to mid again.

[@rockout2x235]

@@dumpsterfirefrlwhen hurts was mid that was his first year starting before the all pro season love was mid or worse this season so what are you saying

[@Izicon22]

@@dumpsterfirefrlhurts was mid?? Man was mvp runner up till week 11 where the coaching changes destroyed the team.

[@YouReallyDontKnow]

Love over Joe and Jalen is absolutely criminal. These 2 have shown they can be consistently relied on to play great and win games….love doesn’t have that consistency yet, though the has the potential.

[@addster124]

They're going off potential, not resume.

[@tydurk]

💯

[@0831fabian]

@@addster124love doesn’t have more potential than anyone on this list but Tua

[@addster124]

@0831fabian love can make any throw hurts can and is better against the blitz

[@matthewwells2017]

@@0831fabianYou are absolutely insane. The scouts in 2020 LITERALLY said Love has the HIGHEST UPSIDE of any QB in the 2020 draft class

[@BratatoChip]

Burrow and Herbert have highest ceilings imo

[@dice3046]

How is a choke artist that gave up a 27 point lead in the playoffs have the highest ceiling? Herbert defense had 4 turnovers that playoff game he failed to put points on the board the whole second half. Love > Herbert.

[@BratatoChip]

@@dice3046 we shall see my friend

[@theblinkerx]

Herbert has the highest ceiling of any QB not named Josh Allen or Patrick Mahomes. Brandon Staley has done irreversible damage to his reputation

[@BratatoChip]

@@theblinkerx irreversible damage is insane. He still has like a decade of his career left.

[@theblinkerx]

@@BratatoChip agreed but theres already a significant amount of (not smart) fans that think Herbo is a fraud & nothing will change their mind

[@bralendennis]

MY PERSONAL LIST I HAVE: 1. Burrow 2. Herbert 3. Hurts 4. Love 5. Tua

[@Sean-bw2yj]

Herbert chokes have not proven anything

[@MarvG3000]

You can’t have Herbert over a QB is an all pro and almost won the Super Bowl (Hurts). Over Love who’s won a playoff game. And over Tua who makes the playoffs and leads in most qb stats. Herbert’s at the bottom

[@0831fabian]

Herbert hasn’t done anything he’s 4 or 5

[@KlayGoods123]

@@MarvG3000 Dude the Eagles GM would trade Hurts and two 1sts for Herbert today, he’s had the 30th ranked defense for 3 years. Learn ball

[@HockeyDudeJames2]

​@@MarvG3000 Hurts has the best o'line and weapons in the league. Only over Tua because the Eagles tight end is much better. He beat Danny dimes and CMC playing QB. This year he regressed back to what he was before that one fluky run to the SB. Put any of the other guys besides Tua on the eagles. They win in spite of the Seagulls poor defense. Tua can process and read defenses though. Hurts is easily the weak link. Once his running game regresses. He better hope he still has a job. His arm talent is average to mediocre. Push tush hurts😂😂😂

[@finessewrld23]

Who tf put Jordan love over burrow and Herbert even hurts that’s terrible 😂

[@gsleevy]

Jordan love has more playoff wins in first year playing than Herbert’s whole career 🤣

[@finessewrld23]

@@gsleevy okay and that’s really an accomplishment to u like winning a playoff game don’t mean anything if u don’t win the SB plus Herbert beats Jordan in every QB category

[@Free9slatt]

@@gsleevythat does not mean he’s a better qb lol

[@Robuu]

@@finessewrld23 Winning a playoff game with the youngest roster in the NFL is significantly better than Herbert blowing a 20 point lead.

[@Twisty757]

Winning playoff games are a team effort.....

[@BratatoChip]

Love over Herbert is fucking hilarious holy shit

[@PhillyDawg-m4u]

Nope. Herbert hasn't won playoff game. Many talented QBs in history that couldn't win big Gamez. Look up Jeff George. He had very powerful arm and accuracy. Couldn't win big games.

[@BratatoChip]

@@PhillyDawg-m4u we’ll see! Still has time! I don’t make final decisions on elite talents with a decade left in their careers 😇

[@mcmic10]

How do you play good half the season and beat out ppl who have years of success? Microwave fanboys

[@BratatoChip]

@@mcmic10 I’m agreeing with you? Lol

[@BabaMcQueen]

What has Herbert done other than throw for 5000 yards and choke in a playoff game

[@natej84]

Love played good for over half a year, but the nfl adjusts after that first year. Theres been plenty of QBs ball out for one year and never reach that height again

[@baltimoremike9161]

Who was the last 1?

[@baltimoremike9161]

Mike Glennon

[@Jp-do9ny]

​@@baltimoremike9161Herbert

[@natej84]

@@baltimoremike9161 Tua had a crazy half season. Mac Jones almost won Roty, if it wasn't for Chase record breaking season. Wentz was a MVP favorite at one time. Hurts last year. I can go on and on and on

[@Bigtheatabighook33]

I agree w this but Love has great arm talent and confidence. He also sat multiple years behind rogers. The other QBs you named didn’t have that.

[@Go_birds6]

1. Burrow 2. Hurts 3. Love 4. Herbert 5. Tua

[@zackhurwitz9441]

Hell no 😂

[@Go_birds6]

Why

[@qouta1456]

That's why the Eagles never going back to the SB.

[@zackhurwitz9441]

@@Go_birds6 because he has one solid season, that was in 2022 on the most stacked roster in the NFL. The only thing that changed in '23 was the OC, and Hurts regressed with the same roster. His numbers as a passer are extremely similar to Daniel Jones.

[@Go_birds6]

@@zackhurwitz9441 The eagles also had one of the worst defenses in the league I don’t see how u can put anyone on this besides burrow above him

[@mikegolden1518]

Ocho face when Joe wasn’t # 1 😂😂😂

[@Itll_Play]

The 2020 qb class was one THE quarterback classes of all time

[@princerob425]

Joe Burrow is the only one to beat Mahomes in a playoff so if he stays healthy, we good

[@bikermike420]

Brady beat him twice

[@princerob425]

@@bikermike420 we are talking about the current guys. I’m not counting brady

[@Chris88McD]

Pat beat himself in that game. He was horrible in the second half.

[@Chiefs555]

Mahomes is 3-3 against the Bengals. He's also 3-1 in Super Bowls. They are not the same. 😂

[@paulgosu2773]

@@Chiefs555he’s 1-3 against Burrow all time, so it is a pretty big deal

[@GoodFellaPack]

About time Jordan Love gets his respect 💯

[@rockout2x235]

He is not him stop it no where near hurts level

[@GoodFellaPack]

@@rockout2x235 hurts a rugby player at hearts lmk when he becomes a 4k yard pass passer

[@Packend]

@@rockout2x235 Completions 352 372 Attempts 538 579 Percentage 65.4 64.2 Yards 3,858 4,159 Yds/Att 7.2 7.2 TD 23 32 INT 15 11 Sacked 36 30 hurts on left, love on right

[@keyboard2758]

@@rockout2x235😂 hurts is a talent merchant

[@Jacobb..]

Jordan love is the future of GB!

[@concil100]

Hurts Burrow Love Herbert Tua

[@kevindukes8185]

😂😂😂 you're funny Hurts ain't better than Burrow

[@Adam-xe5xm]

drop Hurts back below Hebert lol.

[@concil100]

@@kevindukes8185 he is the 2nd best qb in the league and after next year he will be no 1

[@concil100]

@@Adam-xe5xm cant wait for herbert to fail this year with harbugh so yall will realize how overrated he is

[@Adam-xe5xm]

@@concil100 Well ther are 3 qbs on that list who are better than Hurts........

[@steveod2]

Never has a QB got more of the benefit of the doubt then Herbert

[@KlayGoods123]

What are you talking about he the most slandered QB of them all and has had the worst team

[@reallife0728]

JALEN HURTS!!!

[@7211m]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@kidhale020]

I wish people really understood what Jalen has had to go through...Philly is failing him and about to make him Wentz 2.0 if they don't change course. 3 different OCs and QB coaches in 3 years, and 11 of the position coaches being 1st year coaches in the league. That's why they've over corrected so hard this offseason bringing in Moore and Fangio. The talent on that team carried them to 10-1, but once teams saw it was literally no adjustments it was a wrap. And we elevating the same Love that they was talking about was a bust as recent as like week 6 because of his shaky start? Let's see him do it again now that we've got the tape on him. Burrow, Hurts, Love, Herbert, Tua for me

[@davidcrook99]

The eagles are a good team hurts isn’t that good

[@kidhale020]

@@davidcrook99 any QB not named Mahomes would have regressed last year in that system YoY. They're trying to make him a pure pocket passer and he's not that. The RPO game was almost non-existent this season and it was a huge part of their run to the bowl. The management felt it was the coaching, which is why they did a major overhaul. He struggles again this year... I'm leaving the space to change my opinion with new information

[@jeanfourcade]

I'm with you. After the 2022-23 season, Hurts is for me #2 on equal footing with Burrow, above lamar, then Allen, then the crowd.

[@sidekickz2180]

Tua led the league in most passing categories this past year. He was on pace to do that the year before as well (but got hurt)

[@swisscloud4309]

Yeah I really don’t know where all the slander coming from Yes there’s massive areas to improve in but when it comes to anticipatory throws he’s might be the best in the league Only guys better would be burrow and Herbert because of burrow x factor but Herbert big arm

[@coachYte]

That’s exactly what someone who doesn’t know ball will say. Tua is a regular season performer. You can’t win anything meaningful because of him. He’ll get paid and the dolphins will average 10+ wins for the next 3/4 seasons and continue to get bounced in the playoffs

[@ijalloh9]

@@coachYte perhaps, but Josh Allen wasn't part of the 2020 draft.

[@qaxcgyujm]

Yet they're still hesitant if he's worth the cost of a QBs second contract.. think about it.. that's how his organization feels. If they don't respect him why should fans from the outside. At least guys like Love, Herbert, Burrow, Hurts it's known they're their teams future this off-season. His own team not even knowing if he's worth being a franchise QB is one reason why he deserves the least upside of these guys, out of any of these QBs hes the one who probably won't be a starter in the NFL in 5 years and that's not even mentioning his retirement talk he's even brought up in press conferences post head injuries, he's a concussion away from retiring at this point.

[@mac9108]

Tua is fking fraud he literally needs everything perfect around him offensively and even the weather to succeed he ain't built for December January football

[@slojo404]

1:burrow 2:hurts 3:Herbert 4:love 5:tua I feel like love going to go up after next season tho

[@tbrauch2017]

Tua is 2

[@kiko4675]

1a.Herbert 1b.burrow 2.Love 3.Tua 4.Hurts

[@TheJordan97971]

crazy ash

[@fruitstrong5977]

It's all about DUBS. 1. Jalen hurts 34-17 2. Tua Tagovailoa 32-19 3. Joe Burrow 29-22 4. Justin Herbert 30-32 BELOW 500 5. Jordan Love 9-9 At 500. I think Tua will be TOP GUN in the end by taking it from Jalen Hurts like at Alabama. Joe Burrow has missed more games than Tua and Justin Herbert is a young Phillip Rivers whose wasted talented offenses. Jordan Love hasn't put in enough work to be at the top of any list. Put some RESPECT on Tua's name.

[@TheMissiIe]

None of this is fair. Hurts has had 10x a better defence than the other 4, and Hurts is the least QB-esque player. 1. Burrow 2. Love 3. Herbert 4. Hurts 5. Tua

[@fruitstrong5977]

@@TheMissiIe Joe Burrow's backup played better than him last year. No injury excuses. At the end it's all about how many DUBS a QB puts in the DUB Column Tua has always Won games. Even before McDaniel and Tyreek arrived in Miami. And he's not stopping anytime soon.

[@karendorsey4780]

I would go with Burrow, than Jalen Hursts , Tua , Herbert , Love. Love needs to play a full season. Adjustments will be made once the season starts. See what happens .

[@zdr7420]

Hate to break it to you, but Love did play a full season 😂

[@Adam-xe5xm]

What adjustment is going to be made lol. They have had months to watch him and the scheme and he got better as the year went on.

[@karendorsey4780]

@@zdr7420 Oh well, I just payed attention towards the end of season ! That’s on me! Thanks for the correction.

[@duwayneengram9483]

“Sometimes it’s better to keep the peace than to be right!” 😂. He’s right though!

[@Rodricktyrone]

Recency bias is real

[@Packend]

no it's not cause if that's the case CJ would have been listed too.

[@Rodricktyrone]

@@Packend CJ wasn’t drafted in 2020

[@paulinotou]

Herbert had a bad year and now no one is talking about him. If Chargers do him right, at worst he will be like Rivers who isn't known beyond the generation who watched him played yet a competent QB. But i'd agree his ceiling is high. I don't think Herbert is confident, and same with Tua I question if they got that ummph to them

[@KingInTraining]

It’s football it’s always been and always will be a what have you done for me lately league. Besides that Love has only played 1 season so how can you judge him on anything other than the 1 year he’s played?

[@Rodricktyrone]

@@paulinotou we’ll see. I think Herbert wasn’t confident in his coach. Whenever he needed to drop a dime & has some time he did it. But when you’re running for your life, defense is trash and ya hand is broken. You’ll probably look w/o some umph

[@Koyasama]

I get the argument that there's recency bias with Love, and that there's film on him now. Fair enough. Here's the thing: Love has the arm strength to make all the throws. From the very start of the season, even the first half when his accuracy was poor and people were saying he was a bust, he was reading the field well and targeting open receivers. His accuracy was the only thing holding him back--when that part started to kick in...you can talk about "good years," but 18 TDs to 1 INT is INSANE, by any standard. Those things aren't going away--with Love already committed to working on his footwork this offseason, if anything his accuracy will only get even better--and there's only so much film study and gameplanning can do to counter them.

[@Adam-xe5xm]

Watching him it was rare you would think wtf is he seeing. It was always a case of he read it right but hes high or behind the receiver. He settled in as the season got going and you could see the jump in the second half. I think he was much more willing to take bigger risks later on as well. Less dink and dunk.

[@gurwindergill9037]

I don’t know what’s worse Love at 1 or Herbert over Hurts. I guess Love at 1 is pretty egregious.

[@FuriousTheGeorge]

If Joe Burrow could stay healthy then he'd be #1. With his health issues he should be #3 or #4.

[@justadude1065]

Despite the health setbacks how many of these guys have gotten as far as Burrow even with 4 full seasons under their belt🤔 I’ll wait.

[@ViNCENT-vm5sl]

Hurts

[@justadude1065]

@@ViNCENT-vm5sl hurts doesnt have back to back conference championship appearances. He got bounced in the 1st round. Hurts is a tush push merchant and when kelce isn’t under center to lead that charge it’ll fall flat on its face.

[@zackhurwitz9441]

​@@justadude1065we always hear people trying to drag QBs for their supporting cast. I personally never hear it for Hurts, and HE HAS THE BEST ONE.

[@justadude1065]

@@zackhurwitz9441 Facts! 1. Tua is 10-8 vs teams at .500 or better, 5-9 against teams that made the playoffs. 2. Herbert has a GREAT supporting cast. People gonna cry and claim hes got nothing to work with? One of the most stacked defenses despite their mediocrity. Solid pieces on offense. Herbert is 30-32 as a starter and his only plyoff game that defense everyone cries about for him converted 5 first half turnovers and held the opposing team to 3 first half points. 3. Jalen Hurts got drafted in the best position among all of them, stacked offensively and defensively with the best oline in football, solid weapons on offense, and a stacked defense. 4. Jordan Love is nothing but recency bias and for what? hyping up a win over the cowboys? Notorious playoff chokers... NFC teams wish they play the cowboys first in the postseason. Burrow is the only QB in the NFL that his his pieces around him used as an excuse to undermine and hate him. He was drafted to the worst position amongst all these guys and despite only have two full seasons under his belt, is more accomplished than all these dudes with four...he brought a team with the longest active playoff drought their first postseason win and his first year as a starter he played the full season he went into arrowhead, beat the chiefs down 18 and won the AFC conference title and went to the SB. People just love to chirp and hate on him.

[@michaelallen8112]

Whene u guys gonna cover HBCU Combine/ Legacy Bowl Shannon & Chad

[@la7era1u54]

Burrow should be first and it's not even close

[@Chiefs555]

First to injured Reserve.

[@jeanfourcade]

Burrow is second to only Aaron Rodgers when it comes to money made per game played, this year. En route for an exceptional career !

[@jacobbiggs2733]

The talent that love showed last 9l8 games and the throws he made none of these other quarterbacks have displayed at the nfl level

[@cameronburnett1897]

Justin Herbert is the answer. He’s the most talented out of the group and is at the very least as productive as anyone on this list. Man has easily been held back the most with the amount of bad coaching, defense, and run game. He’s finally getting competent let alone elite coaching from Harbaugh and he’ll remind people why he’s got top 3 Talent because Herbert is that special

[@77waygodh11]

Exactly 💯

[@brandontran366]

Facts watch the narrative of not winning change so quick now he doesn’t have a division 2 coach and a coach who wanted tyrod to start over him. Herbert has had the worst oline of all the others too.

[@abriaangel9986]

Period!

[@justadude1065]

@@brandontran366how far will you move the goal posts and who will you blame if nothing changes?

[@brandontran366]

@@justadude1065 cus Brandon Staley and Anthony Lynn have the success of Jim Harbaugh for even a single year? Below average GM for 10 years got fired too

[@johnnygva757]

Burrow Tua Hurts Herbert Love

[@diddybob5179]

J Herbo ⚡️💙💛

[@magmax76]

Great QB class. One of the best in recent years.

[@jaredc422]

Ppl were talking about packers needing to move on from jordan love mid season 😑

[@matthewwells2017]

Yeah and they were idiots lmao

[@duncanstevenss9782]

Jordan love over all those guys is crazy. It’s burrow, hurts, love, tua, Herbert

[@tbrauch2017]

Tua is 2!!!

[@marioreyes6896]

There was no film on love, now there is that’s all imma say

[@neenarman]

there was plently of film on love for the 2 playoffs games

[@nick-loading]

He took the youngest team to the playoffs and almost went to the NFC championship game

[@Adam-xe5xm]

loooool. So when they got to week 7 or 8 or 9 did the past weeks of film disappear? Do teams only use film from the previous year or something. He got better as the season went on. Ball park best qb in the NFL after week 9. I think thats when teams got more film on him as well..........

[@micahbinns2740]

And he knows what they are going to throw at him lol

[@muhammadisiuwa3464]

Lol, you people talk like only defenses have access to film. He also has film on his competition as well so shove it. .

[@LuckyDuckie115]

Herbert shattered all rookies record in 15 games! (More like 14.5 games since he didn't get to start his first nfl game)

[@IMSmoov1]

Yet burrow was outpacing him until his injury. So rookie record ain’t nothing cuz Herbert ain’t done a damn thing since then either

[@Mike-hw6nm]

Lmao neither has burrow! He gets the most credit ever for reaching a superbowl and LOSING

[@IMSmoov1]

@@Mike-hw6nm so your argument is burrow hasn’t done anything but Herbert has despite not even winning a single playoff game? You’re comparing two players who haven’t won super bowls

[@Mike-hw6nm]

@@IMSmoov1 it’s ok y’all gon see this year with harbaugh

[@IMSmoov1]

@@Mike-hw6nm well yeah I hope he proves something. he and tua need to start becoming contributing members of the playoffs regularly.

[@TumsFestival.]

If Purdy wore Bengals orange, Ocho would put him #1. 😂

[@justadude1065]

Not true at all

[@jasonhayders1550]

It's Burrow, Herbert, Hurts, Love, Tua.

[@Bi5Paul]

Joe, love,Herbert,Jalen,Tua

[@eman22017]

Love is last on this list he needs to prove he can do this consistently

[@BratatoChip]

Love over Herbert is fucking hilarious

[@Chiefs555]

​@@eman22017samething could be said for Joe's injury history. He has to prove he can finish a season.

[@Adam-xe5xm]

@@eman22017 Burrow aside (he has injury issues not winning issues) who here has proven to be a "consistent" winner. Tua and Burrow have no playoff wins and both have had losing seasons. Hurts had one of the biggest melt downs ive ever seen midseason, has to be a coaching issue as well but it cant all be on that. Love did what we expected. Started off slow and then picked it up after week 9 where he played, statistically at least, as the best QB in the NFL. That order he listed is right.

[@kosmicj4310]

Jordan love over Herbert is absolutely insane😂😂😂

[@Bree-r7e]

Joe Burrow

[@Willtellthetruth]

Nah. It's been 30 years since a QB who lost is first Super Bowl start even made it to start another. When Joe couldn't score over the final five possessions of that game and got caught from behind, he put himself on the "lost first SB start list" with a bunch of other ringless QBs such as Jimmy G, Jared Goff, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, Colin Kaepernick, Rex Grossman, Matt Hasselbeck, Donovan McNabb, Jake DelHomme, Rich Gannon, Kerry Collins, Chris Chandler, etc.

[@Bnics_420]

1.) Burrow 2.) Hurts 3.) Love 4.) Tua 5.) Herbert This is based off their success in the league so far to me. I know everybody might switch it around I don’t care.

[@johnwilson8385]

Burrow, Herbert, Hurts, Love, Tua

[@ramonmabry]

Herbert hasn’t done anything

[@Rodricktyrone]

@@ramonmabrynone of em got rings. So you’re not saying anything

[@Adam-xe5xm]

@@Rodricktyrone 2 of them dont even have playoff wins. One of then has only played 1 year. Another has missed 40% of his games and the last one had one solid year on a superteam and then had an all time melt down this year.

[@Rodricktyrone]

@@Adam-xe5xm my point. They all have ups & downs. Pros & cons. But none of them have that one thing that separates from the rest. So for him to single out one player is just media narrative.

[@Adam-xe5xm]

@@Rodricktyrone Herberts track record, imo, is on par with Tua. When you have such a large sample size of very inconsistent play its hard to rate, especially with no playoff wins. Hurts is the same but with higher highs and lower lows re the playoffs. Love hasnt really got the sample size either way but his ceiling is top 5 qb good based on whats we've seen and I would anticipate his supporting cast improving considering their age. Burrow its really just injuries and the Bengals inability to put together an O line that is at least average on a consistent basis. I'd go Burrow (if he can stay healthy), Love Herbert (for upside), Hurts, Tua.

[@aliali-ce3yf]

when it's all over i think it'll be like this : 1. Jordan Love - his team set up to be the best, i think he'll have the most success 2. Justin Herbert - chargers will be in salary cap hell for a while, but harbaugh will get it right 3. Joe Burrow - his health, the bengals can't seem to protect him, and now he's getting paid isn't a good recipe for success 4. Jalen Hurts - idk if 2 seasons ago was his "Matt Ryan MVP" moment because of his OC. and last season was who he really was. he's gotta show more and consistently 5. Tua - too small, injury scare looms large. tbh, if I were the Dolphins, i'd draft Michael Penix. He's a bigger Tua. also with injury concerns but you reset the clock with the rookie contract.

[@justadude1065]

Which QB has an AFC conference title, 5-2 playoff record, SB appearance, only QB to beat mahomes in the playoffs, back to back division titles and back to back AFC conference championships?

[@sontho6995]

​@@justadude1065That QB can't stay healthy.

[@justadude1065]

@@sontho6995 he’s had two fluke injury due his wrist and calf, the ACL/MCL was because his dumbass linemen pushed him into his knee… idgaf bout excuses. Burrow is more accomplished than all these dudes. There is zero debate.

[@sontho6995]

@@justadude1065 "fluke injury" unless you said the same for tua & hurts when they got injured, miss me with that excuse.

[@aliali-ce3yf]

@@justadude1065 the one QB that tends to get injured, plays for a notoriously cheap owner, and can't seem to get the O line right. Oh and he'll be losing Higgins and maybe other key players.

[@paulbortolazzo2831]

Purdy will be an all pro in 2025 Super Bowl!

[@gami405]

Nah

[@AilmanF2P]

Purdy will never go back to a Super Bowl. You can save this comment for a year from now, even the next 5 years if you feel like it.

[@loganblack4885]

@@AilmanF2P Purdy will win Super Bowl and win league MVP next season before Jordan Burrow Herbert TUA and Hurts

[@Chiefs555]

He will be the starter for one more year because he's cheap, then he's off the team.

[@gami405]

@@loganblack4885 funny guy

[@lososcotti926]

Herbert Joe Love Hurts Tua

[@isaiahh4108]

This is the correct answer imo

[@cs03033]

Love has already in one season done more than Herbert. lmao

[@isaiahh4108]

@@cs03033 no he hasn’t Herbert has every passing record on a bad organization and is going on his 3rd HC

[@AilmanF2P]

@@isaiahh4108 Why does he have so many losing seasons and no playoffs wins? Like OP said he achieved more with a lot less. If you wanna say Love has a better coach thats fine but thats about it. Harder division with a harder schedule.

[@cs03033]

Every passing record is your definition of success? Lmao what a crock @@isaiahh4108

[@Truey96]

Tom Clement’s is also loves QB coach who rodgers has attributed his success to multiple times

[@julianperkins4620]

1. Joe Burrow 2. Jalen Hurts 3. Jordan Love 4. Justin Hebert 5. Tua

[@kevinc-b8u]

No Question 1)Herbert (Watch this year) 2) Burrow (If healthy) 3) Love 4/5)Tua-Hurts

[@jayzwrld_]

Loving all these salty ass comments about Jlove when this year he played better than all 4 of these guys

[@f3rnandoll]

Unbiased opinion as a Chargers fan. My rankings would go like this. 1. Burrow (No debate) 2. Herbert (Coaching has let him down and once he went down with injury, people saw just how bad the Chargers were without him) 3. Love (Need to see more but what we saw is by definition, Elite) 4. Hurts (He did take the Eagles to the Super Bowl but how much of that was Shane? Unable to produce much through the air behind that O-Line is worrisome) 5. Tua (Be honest with yourself, he can’t compete with the other guys in terms of what they bring to the table)

[@thefartist]

1) Herbert 2) Burrow 3) Love 4) Tua 5) Hurts

[@Drako7077]

Casual corner up in here

[@phillybyrd34]

Say what you want, but Jalen Hurts has gone further than any other QB on this list besides Burrow and already has a Conference Championship on his shelf!!! 2024 will be another big-time season for him-so don't be surprised if you see Philadelphia hosting the NFC Championship Game again next January....😤😤👊👊💪🦅🦅

[@freein2339]

Hurts is better than any QB not named Mahomes...Love was awful in the 4th quarter against the 49ers

[@MKR2752]

1. burrow 2. Herbert 3. Love 4. Hurts 5. Tua There is no debate.

[@IMSmoov1]

This is why “they played in the nfl they know better than anyone” is not a one size fits all counter argument

[@zzzkun2526]

I think we just forgot how good Joe was playing before he got injured again

[@christianserrano9034]

Herbert is OVERRATED but fanboys ain’t ready for that convo 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@rellfacts279]

Jordan Love declared a franchise QB after one season is crazy.

[@zackhurwitz9441]

8-9 games at that. No talk about a terrible playoff exit against SF either.

[@TV1111TV]

Makes the playoffs in his first year. Love led the youngest team, the first 7th seed to win a playoff game in NFL history. And beat SuperBowl champs, scoring the most points on the elite KC defence all year. That is a franchise QB. You can’t see that, go watch Pee-wee football maybe you’ll understand that

[@rellfacts279]

@@TV1111TV Way too soon. I say the same thing for C.J. Stroud. Title of franchise QB has to be proven over some years. Look at Carson Wentz, (literally in MVP conversation his second season) Jameis Winston, Marcus Mariota, Colin Kaepernick. Wentz and Kaepernick in particular accomplished a lot more than Love early too. I’m just saying to be patient.

[@TV1111TV]

@@rellfacts279 I agree with being patient, but CJ and J love are already in a different class to all those guys

[@rellfacts279]

@@TV1111TV Are you sure? Wentz again was a MVP candidate his second season. Kaepernick made a run to the SB. At the time I don’t think many believed either were going to be busts. I think it’s just more recency bias. Wentz had 33 TDs to just 7 INTs, higher passer rating, no. 1 seed etc. better season than both Stroud and Love.

[@BrilexLaAuthority]

Joe, Justin, Jalen, Jordan, Tua

[@SupeDupeTV]

I got a go rewatch Jordan Love games from this season. I know he one a playoff game but geeze

[@throwthe9route92]

It’s amazing that all five quarterbacks from the 2020 draft class made it to the playoffs. 2020 QB Draft Class: Joe, Tua, Justin H., Jordan, Jalen 2021 QB Draft Class: Trevor, Zac, Trey, Justin F., Mac Which QB draft class would you prefer?

[@johnparkhurst3506]

I forgot how good that qb class was

[@worldsgreatest_gaming3498]

Black analysis is so biased when it comes to a black person doing good in sports we’re really choosing Jordan love over Joe Burrow😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@isocalistream4355]

Based on achievements in the playoffs only 1.hurts 2. Burrow 3.Love 4.tua 5. Herbert Most talented for me is Herbert and I have him rank #5 his just in a team managed poorly That guy completed 5 consecutive 4th down vs my team and I respect that

[@BrilexLaAuthority]

The Love for Jordan is insane lol

[@kosmicj4310]

Love plays one season and he’s already 1?!? WTF ARE YALL SMOKING

[@rogerrrabitt]

Damn it was some good qbs out that draft

[@NatureBoii99]

As a GM, Joe Burrow's injury history makes me nervous. Plus, you won't always have two #1 WRs. Hurts, Love, Burrow, Tua, Herbert.

[@nick-loading]

To the people complaining about Love needs to watch the film he took the youngest team in the league to the playoffs and almost went to the NFC championship game in his first year starting

[@youngmal2k682]

ANY list that has Hurts not top 3 is automatically invalid

[@tb7547]

Tua gonna end up More Prolific than them all

[@jeanfourcade]

Panda Bear Tua will become the most prolific backup ever... due to his stats in his fist 4 years 😅🤣

[@suryavedula3713]

Where does this blind faith in Herbert come from? When was the last time he delivered when it mattered? I swear Tua and Herbert are two quarterbacks with similar resumes but somehow one of them is talked of like he can't play and the other one is talked about like he's a generational player...

[@chriscaldwell8570]

Love was a healthy scratch for more games than Burrow missed for injury lol. Hard to have injury concerns when you haven’t played.

[@RayDawnavon]

The kind of hype Jordon love gets from the media is baffling. This is the same dude who threw 2 picks to the same defender in the NFC championship game. Now Ocho picks him over, Justin Herbert and Jalen Hurts?

[@HR-bj4vp]

I’d go: 1. Burrow 2/3 Love or Herbert 4 Hurts 5 Tua

[@anthonyposey7569]

Mahomes, Lamar, hurts, burrow, Allen

[@weezywood4556]

Burrow, Hurts, Love, Herbert, Tua

[@baldridgeroy]

Herbert should be #1. Herbert has had to play against the other team and his own coach since joining the league.

[@kingquince9184]

Which QB had led his team further and better? Who will lead his team to a SB victory sooner? Who’s had more success thus far? Joe B. Hurts Justin Jordan Tua

[@videogames9829]

if a few of them win some chips. Might go down as one of the top 3 draft classes of all time. Herbert is the dark horse. We haven't seen him at his best, and I think Tua would be the weakest qb of those 5. 1.Burrow, 2. Hurts, 3. Love 4. Herbert 5. Tua. In that order, based on what they accomplished these past seasons.

[@MegaLacedup]

Herbert is another Josh Allen, he gets so much damn praise but he hasn’t accomplished anything yet. I have burrow, hurts, love, herbert, tua

[@g.o.a.tsports2880]

Lmao you have Love after one full season.

[@finessewrld23]

What has love done plus Herbert had Brandon Staley if he fails wit jim then you have a case but cmon now

[@markydan1232]

He's not even a Josh Allen. At least Allen has made it to an AFC championship and has won multiple big games in his career.

[@cs03033]

Love has won a playoff game, & didn't participate in an epic collapse of another one @@finessewrld23

[@77waygodh11]

😂😂😂 foh

[@Present4]

That was a good QB draft class!

[@elijahal-shabazz7151]

Love going to the Super Bowl !

[@NZV13]

1 Burrow 2 Love 3 Herbert 4 Hurts 5 Tua

[@ethanswain9119]

That putting anyone over mahomes comment was aimed at ol skippy boy, oh how he should've never let unc leave

[@nathangerrard9792]

obviously Burrow the fact they're even talking about it shows Uncs bias

[@cruzinthruspace]

Can we start taking Herbert off of all of these lists once he does nothing with harbaugh can we agree on that please

[@BratatoChip]

Never gonna happen because he’s about to be even better than he has been

[@choppermontana8212]

Herbert played hurt all season. He's going to absolutely thrive under Harbaugh's coaching.

[@geoschilling]

LMAO Jordan love over burrow💀💀💀

[@TheParlayChannel]

Jordan Love had one DECENT full season. He beat the cowboys now everyone thinks he’s Aaron Rodger’s lmaooo

[@nocompromise6919]

Burrow. Herbert. Tua. Hurts. Love. Don’t debate it. You’re wrong 💀 I’m right.