Battle of the Eyeliners ~ Which one is the BEST?

[@monicabierman3450]

Sharalee, you put so, so much work and time in your videos to give us the best- THANK you for all your hard work and time, we all truly appreciate it so very much. You are such a kind and beautiful person( inside and out)! May God bless you and your husband. 🌻

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

You just made my day😍 Thank you so much, sweet lady💗 God bless you too!

[@joeyagirl]

Where is the list of eyeliners

[@1missdc]

@@joeyagirl see that little " v" across from the title? Press it.

[@martastauts3240]

Sharalee,that was a fun test to watched you do. I use primer on my eyes but had no idea it helped with liner. Thank you💕

[@sandraherrera8351]

Thank you, thank you for this video. I have oily hooded eyelids and have a hard time finding the right one.

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

You are welcome! Glad you found this helpful😍

[@melaniewright2283]

I love this video!! I started using the makeup forever liner a couple weeks ago and I’m hooked. I line my upper water line with it and it does not budge all day. So I’m glad I started using one of the winners haha.

[@ysbyttybedbug]

This was such a clever way to test eyeliners without having to wait for them to smudge/come off when you’re wearing them. These brands aren’t necessarily available where I live, but as a start point, I can try the same experiment on the ones that I already own. Another brilliant video, Sharalee. 👏👏👏

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Yay!! Thank you, sweet lady🥰 You will have to let me know which liners pass these tests for you!💗

[@carolvigilante950]

Hi there very interesting on these liners holding up to what they claim to do. I was using the IT no tug liners for a long time but now you have to sharpen them since they changed. I liked the older version better. I'm using the Stila eyeliners - I kinda like them. Learned something new about putting primer under bottom of my lashes I will give that a try. Thanks for all that you do. I am certainly learning a lot from you.👍🥰

[@caroleanderson1106]

What a fun test, Sharalee. Good to know when we go shopping. Thank you.

[@marysmith4939]

Great video! As I watched it, I wondered about putting primer on my lower lid and voila, you answered my query! I have learned so much from you Sharalee!

[@katethawley4356]

At last a video where you can see what works . I cannot find a eyeliner that doesn't smudge or disappear and you have proven that there may be hope. Thank you

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

So happy this was helpful!! Don't forget the power of an eyeshadow primer too😘

[@mimi_to_four7151]

Thank you so much for this! I always have the worse time with my liners smudging, I can’t tell you how many I have bought and tried!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

So glad this was helpful!😍

[@asrr62]

My last one was the stila smudge stick it was ok but my current loreal one is much more creamy and comfy to wear.

[@brendaberry]

I absolutely love that you did this test! I suffer from watery eyes and it is a real struggle for me to keep eyeliner on. Now I have proven eyeliners that work! Great job Sharalee!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Yay!!! So happy this was helpful!😘

[@HelloKittyColour]

i loooove the tests you did!! they show the wear of each eyeliner so well!!! have you tried the l.a colors eyeliner?? if you have how would you compare it??

[@sylviavandegrift1388]

So very interesting and good to know this thank you for taking the time to show us. Bless you!

[@Mimi-tu2ih]

This so helpful. When I wear liner I end up with it under my eyes. Now I know what product to buy

[@rhondapomeroy5695]

My tear ducts have closed up due to allergies. Tears constantly fall, some days are worse than others. I rushed out to buy the IT cosmetics eyeliner. I wore it today and loved it. It wasn’t perfect but better than any I have used. Thank you for your test. ❤ It was a great idea and helped me to not waste money on products that simply do not work for me. I’m going to buy a spare soon! Thanks again!!!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Oh awesome!!! I'm so happy to hear my tests proved true!😍 Thank you for letting me know! If you haven't already tried adding an eyeshadow primer first, maybe that will be the final trick for a full day of wear for you💗

[@justatexasgirl5583]

Great video! Thank you!

[@BethaneyLilly]

❤❤❤❤❤ excellent video! The only one I didn’t own was the IT superhero, which I will be purchasing ASAP

[@1stmoviefan]

It doesn't have great reviews in amazon

[@bevyoung2009]

Beautiful Sharalee, thank you for your updates 😊

[@maryrose7842]

Very interesting comparison. I don’t wear eyeliner except for a little underneath the eye. What is the best way to remove mascara? I’ve tried everything but I lose at least one eyelash every time 😢

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

I do a couple of steps to remove all if my makeup but I use coconut oil to finish removing my mascara/eye makeup. I'll link my last skincare routine video so you can see how I do it😘 kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6mbnGdpltSMqdU

[@maryrose7842]

@@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates thank you

[@judyreece9971]

Great experiment. 👍

[@nancysuda9471]

Great video loved all the info. Thanks Sharalee

[@pacellidoyle2810]

Great job Sharalee so helpful xx

[@vickiporter6251]

Loved, loved this video. You really went all out trying these out. Thanks so much, been waiting for a good eyeliner comparison ! Thanks again

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Yay!! You are most welcome!😘

[@marymonson905]

VERY helpful. I used your links to Ulta to make some purchases. Thank you!

[@CoralSea12]

Hi! First time seeing one of your video's which was great! I am wondering, for someone who wears liner on the water line of the eye, would your top 4 pics still apply? Or would you recommend one of the others?

[@kc326]

Wow, what a great experiment! You not only showed me the best eyeliner, but that i need to quit skipping eye primer.

[@paulawilhite7476]

Especially love this video, ty Sharalee!!

[@s.sanchez3214]

What lip stick are you wearing. Great color

[@juliebradley120]

Great video, I have spent a fortune on eyeliners that don't work, so just stopped using them. But now after watching this, I will start again with your No.1. ... Thanks for all your hard work. You now have a new subscriber ❤

[@donnahalstead531]

I find they stay on my hand great but not on my eyes even with primer and I don’t have oily eyelids at all.. always hunting one that will stay on all day

[@cheryl4291]

Where do u buy the Kiko Milano dual eyeliner??

[@bebright123]

Thank you!! Off to place an IT Cosmetics order!

[@alterspace2012]

Sharalee the Scientist! 🤓 Brilliant - thank you. Very helpful! 🤩

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

😆Thank you, sweet friend 😘💗

[@peggythomas3144]

Wow!! That’s awesome. Thx 😊

[@terrilaycock3789]

Hello this was a great demo of eyeliner products! I have always struggled with raccoon eyes. I am going to try the IT liner. I have never tried it. Thank you so much for this video! 💗

[@wmazoway]

Super helpful!

[@francesharmon1223]

incredible video!! you are the bomb!!!! thank you!! my right eye can compete with the niagara falls. my IT cosmetics eyeliner disappears. will be trying the milano!

[@tracibuckley9314]

Wait, Sharalee, did the Buxom liner smudge the second time? I know that it did NOT smudge after the first 3 mins. But you didn’t mention it after the extra added minutes. Thank you!

[@sinisterkitty8411]

New sub, cause you blinded me with science. One of the best eyeliner videos ever! Thank you!

[@marlahouston5249]

Thank you for this video. What do you recommend or find is the best waterproof eye makeup/eyeliner remover without having to work to get it off?

[@janrodriguez8872]

What a interesting test. Thank you for sharing this information. You are so talented and thank you again. 😊

[@homewithkellyp]

Hi Sharalee! What a great video! Such an interesting concept and so informative. It has truly helped me not only find two new eyeliners to try but also shown the importance of a primer. I wasn't sure how to use it for just eyeliner but your suggestion at the end clarified it. You have done it again my friend!! 😘

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Awww, thank you, sweet friend!🥰♥️ I'm so happy this guided you to some great eyeliners and back to steady use of your eyeshadow primer!😘

[@earenc]

Well…that was AWESOME! I’m buying the IT liner immediately!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

😍😘

[@annejames9221]

I don’t know how you clean your Sigma switch pad, but I just sprayed mine with Dawn Power Wash spray, let it set for a few minutes, then rinse with a hot spray of water. Then I spray again if needed! Works like a charm

[@annroemer4330]

Can you a similar one with foundation???

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Great request! I'll see what I can come up with😘

[@suzanneedwards3356]

Hi lovely, what an interesting video today, thanks xx

[@libbymiller5240]

Oh, Sharalee, this was so WONDERFUL! And just this morning, I was applying my eyeliner thinking to myself, I know I will have to touch this up when I get home. I was getting my hair done, came home and as I thought, it had already smudged and needed a touch-up! So, I will be making a trip down to ULTA today to get IT'S cosmetic eyeliner for sure!! Your timing on this video was PERFECT, my friend!! Sending you love and blessings!

[@catmama54]

I love the Urban Decay 24/7 as my eyes tear incessantly and those pencils stay on and then some

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

They have always held up well for me too!

[@msun3182]

Thank you!

[@galemeyer1049]

Your timing it perfect - I picked up the Pixie Eyeliner and tried it today and I didn't use primer and it smeared right off but it's really interesting that it did a lot better on your hand with primer. I will try it again for sure but I have super oily, heavy hooded eyelids and my go to is the slim eyeliners by Maybelline. They last allllllll day and night and don't budge on me. What a fun experiment! Thanks fro bringing us along toots ~ Hugs, Gale The Happy Stamper :)

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Oh I will have to try the Maybelline ones next! I have super oily eyelids so I never go without primer 😍😘

[@sandraherrera8351]

Hi I am curious about the Maybelline eyeliner pencil you mentioned, is it the master precise skinny gel pencil or the Hyper Easy pencil?

[@galemeyer1049]

@@sandraherrera8351 Hi yes it's the Maybelline Skinny Gel Eye Pencil. Works like NOTHING I have ever used even on the waterline. It comes in a pink colored pencil. I hope that helps, you will be so happy with it I promise. Hugs, Gale :)

[@sandraherrera8351]

@@galemeyer1049 thank you! I can't wait to try it.

[@1pamperedmomma]

This was great. Would you do some similar testing on tubing mascaras, please?

[@jackiedavis6398]

Wow! What a great video!! Thank you so much for doing this!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

So glad you enjoyed😍

[@maribelmcd5553]

gracias

[@audreyso1201]

super video sharalee, thank you my friend

[@lynnejohnson5477]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@lindahank3503]

Great video !!!

[@sydneylandreneau9566]

I love this information! My eyeliner is always a mess below my eyes. Thank you so much 💓

[@mamatobz2890]

WOW I’m heading to Ulta to try iT 😮❤ love this video! Please do more comparisons videos!!!

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

You got it!!😍

[@gracegraham4421]

So helpful! Thank you!😍

[@goldie51944]

Sharalee…. I found this video of testing eyeliners so interesting even though I have permanent upper and lower liner that I had done years ago. How I was so brave back then I don’t know. Oh my goodness. I must say the permanent cosmetic person who did the procedure was very precise and careful The procedure was done about 6 years ago and it has never faded. Looks just like it did from the beginning. Still am amazed how brave I was oh my. Your testing of the best liners was awesome. 💓🌹💓

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Oh you were very brave indeed! I am so impressed😍 Several years ago, I considered that but couldn't imagine that tiny little needle on my eyes! How wonderful it would be to not have to do that everyday though....so glad yours has lasted so well!💗

[@Aem640]

What liber are you wearing

[@msgloriaplunkett]

Perfect timing, I need a waterline pencil, and now I have 4 great choices.....thank you girl. ❤

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Yay!! You're welcome😇😘

[@TheSWEETLILLYROSE]

Thank you

[@sharronwolfe7711]

Amazing the lengths you go to in giving us the “scoop”! Great info! Looks like I need to switch to It Cosmetics for a great long lasting eyeliner! Thanks a million! And hope you have a wonderfully blessed Thanksgiving! ❤️🙏🏻

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

😍So glad you found this helpful!! Hope you have a wonderful Thanksgiving too!🦃🍁

[@Aem640]

Where are the links

[@lisapierce525]

Intriguing and fun video Sharalee. Great tests for eyeliner. I so appreciate your hard work and time. I’ve heard it said Pacifica is great but since it’s not represented here I guess you don’t think so?? I woke up this morning with a fever, aches & pains, etc. please keep me in your prayers sweet friend. ❤🙏

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Oh sweet friend...big prayers that you are feeling better soon!🙏♥️ I don't know that I've tried the Pacifica liners so I'll have to check them out and see if we've been missing out😘

[@kyradray4938]

The IT Cosmetics no tug eyeliner gets flakey on my eyes after 5 to 6 hour wear.

[@mamacoll]

This was awesome. Would love to see a another of these in more drug store brands. ❤

[@janetcoltin4908]

This was very helpful. I lost all my eyelashes to Alopecia. I started using the Makeup Forever Aqua liner but I will next try the It Hero next.

[@roxannebernard9258]

As a retired research scientist, I loved this video! Eyeliner on my lower lash line is a big disappearing act, but who knew I should put primer there?!? I just bought a new Urban Decay pencil, but for sure I will be buying an IT next time. Question…did you mix all of those lipsticks for your look today? It’s very pretty.

[@cheryl5682]

I'd like the dark brown 🟤

[@cheryl5682]

Can you show the name of the brown 🟤

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

It's the Buxom pencil in the shade "Hold the Line". All of the pencils and colors are listed and linked in the description below the video...click where it says "more"😊

[@deedeegray7489]

Milani Stay Put is THE best and the least expensive !!!!!

[@joannemarie6462]

Can you do a new video with the newest releases in the medium to high price range. Plz

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

Are there any particular brands you are interested in?

[@lucerowaldo723]

Oh!! That's import for me! Thank you... 🇲🇽🌎🇺🇸💕🇲🇽🌎🇺🇸💕🇲🇽

[@pungr]

The skin on the back of your hand isn't like eye lid skin.

[@mlistander]

I heard the IT cosmetics was awful to sharpen. Have you noticed that?

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

I read that on reviews but I've not had any troubles. A good quality sharpener can make a big difference!

[@RhusselleRivera]

this was most of the review on the Sephora site

[@stevenotero2331]

To sharalee do guys really need makeup from Steven

[@joymcdaniel6882]

Your hand is not your eyelid. That’s not an accurate test.

[@denisejohnson9587]

Was thinking the same

[@carriebishop8568]

What a terrible review I've looked up these products that you suggested and the ones that were your top choice had bad reviews lots of them.

[@SharaleesBoxOfChocolates]

If you read those reviews, they are based mostly on how hard they are to sharpen, NOT on the performance. This review was not based on my opinion but on how each one performed under various circumstances. I'd say that's a very detailed, good review.

[@rachelsmith302]

Great video!!!