She Disappeared Day Before 9/11 Attacks Near World Trade Center: What Happened to Sneha Anne Philip?

[@sassyflo94]

I think the biggest question is... Where did she sleep that night? Regardless of the chaos of 9/11, if she stayed with a random person she met, they would remember her. It's really odd that NO ONE has said that she was with them that night.

[@kendrafuller1768]

Unless she stayed with a random person who killed her but there seems to be no trace of her or her body 🤔

[@terriblevampire6422]

Good point I didn’t think about that

[@WiccaLightsMyPath]

She was spotted shopping and leaving Century 21 with another woman that none of the family members or friends knew.

[@unropednope4644]

​@901BusyMama this information is highly questionable. Only one person, the store clerk, said he saw her with the woman and when the s3curity footage was played back, she was by herself.

[@vanessavanderiet8435]

I think the person she spent the night with may have passed on 9/11

[@mirrojas]

It’s pretty shocking how many people went missing on that day & were completely forgotten, still to this day.

[@LoudLilDucky]

Even if got in the news as soon as 9/11 happened nothing else mattered in the news

[@Raraking4796]

Literally one of the worst times to go missing I’m sure. The whole thing is devastating.

[@Zelda_Kitty]

Forgotten by whom?

[@tjm8128]

@@Zelda_KittyRight? Most of the people were eventually found. I think people here that 40 per cent number and it confuses them.

[@mirrojas]

@@tjm8128 I wasn’t talking about people that went missing in the event of 9/11 but rather outside of the event. Even local news weren’t reporting on their local disappearances.

[@amandad2840]

What makes sense to me is that she had a fling with someone that night, stayed at their place as she often did, then the next morning went to the cafe, had her bags with her, then went down with the towers. Would explain the missing bags & would solidify the plans she laid out to her mom the day before.

[@starparodier91]

This is what I’m thinking. And the person she was with could’ve also died that day as well, which is why no one has ever come forward.

[@42Ccastro]

This makes sense to me

[@amandad2840]

Yes, that also! I didn't even consider the other person being with her but yes, that also answers that question as well. @@starparodier91

[@dd4850]

Then why did she go back to her own apartment

[@amandad2840]

They don't know if that was her or not. They said the camera had a glare on it from the sun but the mannerisms resembled hers and the outfit was similar to hers. Other than that, it was not a confirmed sighting. And who knows, maybe she went there before she went to the cafe. @@dd4850

[@Lindsey_Lockwood]

It's a very big no no for a married woman of her cultural background to be bisexual. She was clearly very stressed about this and it drove her to such alcoholism that it ruined her career. Her family would undoubtedly not be very happy with her coming out adding to the pressure. I think that's the reason she doesn't want to resurface. She took the events of 9/11 as a sign that it was now or never to disappear.

[@shadowdemon7770]

Ohh she cares about not being seen as a lesbian, but somehow didn't care about being seen as promiscuous? Sleeping in someone else's bed regularly, instead of at home with her husband. Doesn't seem to me that she took her marriage seriously. I think on the husband did it. It's pretty clear.

[@mhot180]

@@shadowdemon7770 I just want to point out that yes, in some cultures, infidelity is absolutely more acceptable than anything outside of heterosexual relationships.

[@vivienmuller5001]

it's pretty clear lmao..love the confidence

[@skatergirl8019]

I also wondered if she also chose to disappear.

[@WiccaLightsMyPath]

She was spotted with another woman shopping in Century 21 and then leaving together. Both her family and friends didn't know the other woman.

[@briannaoppong-antwi9702]

Nothing that the family or husband says can be trusted. It is so clear that they are trying to save face and value that way more than the truth.

[@Warriee19]

100% agree

[@lonerebeI]

The husband was the one pushing the police to solve it

[@kristendunagan5628]

Yep! The family photo with them beside her picture gave me creepy vibes. 🥴

[@aliceinreality7581]

@@kristendunagan5628 omg same!!

[@ashleymilden5946]

Agree that the family was more worried about making her look good than telling the truth

[@cbk6073]

This case has perplexed me ever since I first heard about it. I strongly suspect that her family, specifically her brother, was involved in her disappearance. They want everyone to believe that she died in an honorable way helping people in the attacks, but it does not seem plausible to me, especially with all the other circumstances of her life.

[@2bbbcc]

Definitely. The family gives off they’re just protecting their imagine.

[@princessnini4273]

why her brother??

[@raulespinoza9987]

Maybe her whole family. Some religions won't accept bisexuality or being gay and maybe the family knew about it. It happens all the time in other countries. They consider it a dishonor to the family name. Their only solution to keep the families name clean is to get eliminate that problem period. It's usually the brothers and sisters who help the parents get rid of the problem. @@princessnini4273

[@kalasmith9472]

@@princessnini4273bc he supposedly caught his wife and his sister having sex

[@sarahalkhafaji8902]

Because he supposedly found her having sex with his girlfriend a week earlier and that when they had a fight. ​@@princessnini4273

[@lauranjo]

I don’t think Ron did it because it’d be so easy for him to say oh she must have died in the attacks but he was fighting for the police to investigate and putting up posters, why would he do that if he did something to her??

[@rylieb1334]

Unless he did it to save face, to play the part of the worried husband desperate for answers so that no one would suspect him. Maybe he knew realistically that her case would be overlooked in favor of the attacks and used that to his advantage. But of course that’s just speculation.

[@lauranjo]

@@rylieb1334 but I don’t think anyone would have suspected him anyway, it would be so easy to blame it in the attacks and the police would have closed the case, but to go through a whole court case where he knew it’d be investigated, risky if he did it!

[@middleagedcouchpotato677]

@@rylieb1334he put himself at risk trying to find her. Went into the heart of the chaos to try and get to her. I don’t think these are the actions of someone putting on a show to get away with murder.

[@editor7354]

@@middleagedcouchpotato677exactly😂 people just want to point fingers at him as the culprit cuz she was the only 1 related to him and lived with him at the time and they jus want a ending to this mysterious case

[@stephanieleaaa]

thank you so much for removing the “on todays episode”.. i LOVE your content but always found myself fast forwarding that part to avoid “spoilers”

[@karimari79]

Agreed!!!

[@amandasmith3005]

100% agree!

[@vintagecapgunsatyourmomshouse]

Yes! I hate that "on today's episode" Even though the algorithm gods say it's necessary I can't stand it

[@UhOhHereWeGo]

My godfather died in the attacks. I remember being brought home an hour or so after school started (1st grade) and my grandma wouldn’t let me turn on the tv. I played around in the backyard for an hour or so until my mom came to my grandma’s house to get me and she turned on the tv and explained to me that my dad was okay but that some buildings fell down in NY and that Uncle David (what we called my dad’s best friend) was there so daddy had to go try and get to the city to find him. My dad was gone for 3 days in the city with his friends going to hospitals hoping for a John Doe. He was in the upper floors of south tower and he was never found, not even a personal item. There are a lot of people who disappeared that day and friends and family were able to get some closure over the years knowing what happened to them through footage and location information archives but I can’t imagine not knowing what happened to someone in all that chaos and having no closure.

[@kendrafuller1768]

RIP

[@Carmen-us1ew]

I'm so sorry about your godfather.

[@SarahBurnette1007]

So sorry for your loss

[@UhOhHereWeGo]

Thank you all. I wish that he could have lived to see what an amazing woman his daughter, my friend Erin grew up to be. She is getting married next year and I know he would be so proud of her.

[@kellymiller1247]

I think she was having issues within herself, questioning who she was. She married out of pressure. Her marriage was not working and they had issues. She was looking to dip out for awhile. Possible she might have even had a "go" bag stashed at someone's house. She was waiting for the right moment and then 9/11 happens which was a huge coincidence in her favor. I think if 9/11 would not have happened, she would have made her way out of that marriage before kids. Just my thoughts. I could be completely wrong and maybe she did die trying to help people but these are just the feelings I get.

[@Lungelo911]

I believe this. You're making so much sense, I found it odd that her mom says she was "upbeat" in their instant messaging conversation, when she was going through so much (unhappy in her marriage and substance abuse issues). Her mom even says "she was looking forward to being a mom" Nah... Cover up

[@stephaniebenavides6287]

I agree!

[@wilhelmina6429]

So in 23 years absolutely no one has spotted her? Plus all her IDs, passport, & money were left behind plus travel was shut down for a few days after 9/11. I just don’t think your theory is plausible

[@christabelle__]

@@Lungelo911 Or she did tell her mom that...because she knew that's what mom wanted to hear, but that was never her real plan.

[@shadowdemon7770]

Here's a couple of issues with your arguments. I know you guys want to believe that she died in the attacks, trying to save people. The biggest red flag for that argument is, where are the people that she helped? The first tower didn't collapse until about an hour and 40 minutes after the initial attack. Don't you think that if she did help somebody, they would remember her? Somebody would remember being saved by this woman? I don't think you're scrutinizing the husband enough, no he probably didn't have it planned out for her to disappear on 9/11, it just happened to be a massive coincidence that he could use to cover up his crime. Their relationship was obviously not typical, and even though he plays it off that he was okay with it, I seriously doubt it. Most men would not be okay with their wives staying out late, sleeping in other beds, not knowing what they're doing the night before or what bed they're sleeping in. My guess is he was tired of it. He got rid of her the day before, and his luck would have it, he had the perfect scenario to paint, as to how she disappeared.

[@jennareyes_]

Came here to say the same.

[@felbicky6333]

16:30 “surveillance cameras in the apartment caught her leaving the house alone” Husband returned late from work at midnight. When could he have done it without the surveillance cameras recording him leaving/ her returning etc ?

[@lauranjo]

If he did it why was he pushing the police and putting up missing posters, he would have grabbed the opportunity to have it blame on the attacks but he was actively saying no she’s been missing since yesterday.

[@shadowdemon7770]

@@lauranjo because he knew he'd get caught in a lie if he said he was missing on 9/11. Also he has to push to look for her right? If he didn't, it would look bad. There are plenty of cases where the husband killed the wife and was out there actively "looking for her" when they damn well knew she was dead. He had to stay face

[@2bbbcc]

THIS.

[@mikeswick6473]

So she was going to lesbian bars spending the night with women and got caught with brothers girlfriend but she’s not lesbian give me a break come on guys

[@kandy1515]

Lesbian here. I agree she was in the closet .. for sure

[@MysticHannah]

Thought the same thing!

[@MiroirNoir]

I was laughing when they said she would spend entire nights “painting and talking” to random girls in their own house. That whole part about the husband saying she would come home with paint on her face… dude, c’mon.

[@BrandyH-eh9up]

Exactly.

[@BrandyH-eh9up]

@@MiroirNoirthe guy was in denial or just didn’t care. Or he was actually pissed about it in actuality and knew what was going on and took her out

[@cristinesomerville4522]

My ex boyfriend was very good friends and former roommates with Sneha Philip’s brother John Philip. I think it is very likely that she disappeared the day BEFORE 9/11 but til this day, no one really knows what happened. I know the family definitely misses her dearly. I wish that the NYPD would go back and do a deep dive on Sneha’s case…

[@ArohaStill]

They did and determined she likely died in the towers

[@Ms.Delphine1204]

@@ArohaStillyeah, sure she did 🙄

[@vanessarichardson110]

​@@Ms.Delphine1204I think her husband made her disappear

[@PatriarchyPatrol]

​@@ArohaStillhoe. logic

[@Boi-xc4dk]

@@Ms.Delphine1204if it was in the courts for years I’m sure someone investigated.

[@NoxCattus]

I think her brother lied about what the detective said to not only protect his sister's reputation, BUT also his and maybe even his girlfriend's reputation as well. After all, depending on his social circles, I could see his not wanting it publicly known that his girlfriend cheated on him with his own sister....

[@aliceepalermo5047]

This is the way I’m leaning too!

[@KChelseaVenus]

nah, he lied cause he had something to do with it. It was deflection away from anyone seeing he had something to do with it.

[@mrs.valdez1387]

Agreed. Why would the police make up such a story?

[@JediBunny]

I’m so glad you covered this - this case is so perplexing to me given the variety of outcomes there could be. “Missing on 9/11” is an excellent journalistic podcast which delves deeper into the case than any coverage I’ve yet found. Well worth the listen for anyone whose interest has been piqued by this one.

[@mom.4life]

Where can you find it?

[@JediBunny]

@@mom.4life I listened to it on Spotify, but I believe it’s also on Apple Podcasts, Amazon, Audible, and some other places too.

[@SarinaHowe]

yes second this!

[@peach2210]

Thanks for the info!​@@JediBunny

[@gccntt]

yes I also recommend it ! what I liked the most about this podcast is the 9/11 facts and statistics, which show that it's unlikely (but not impossible) for Sneha to have died "rushing to the towers to help" or "hit by debris". There were actually not that many civilians who died on the ground, and I doubt she would have been allowed inside the burning towers (I don't even think she would try to go in the first place). I think we'll never know what happened to her and it's extremely sad.

[@princessnini4273]

this case is one of the few where i don’t believe any of the theories enough. i really have no idea what could have happened to her

[@clareivinson2553]

What if the person she was with was also a victim of the 9/11 attacks, possibly snehas friend worked in the trade centre and she walked to work with them that morning and followed on home after, then heard the kaos and went straight back to help. Rest in peace to all those victims ❤️

[@bethanwylie757]

This is a great theory, something to link her to the location. She might have not had an online trail of conversations with this person back then to create the link for proof, yet still is very possible she just knew a person working there.

[@haileyranson8255]

This is exactly where my mind went too. I was surprised that this theory was never brought up

[@90sWillowJo]

Highly possible.

[@imham984]

Yes and the bags were at the other person’s home. And she bought women’s clothing things and bed sheet for the other person, not for Ron

[@butterfliesandfate]

It would be great if you could do a show on Ann Dunlap. She was a Pillsbury executive found stabbed to death in the trunk of her car at a Kmart in Minneapolis. Her husband received most of her 1 million + life insurance policies. He married not too long after and moved to Arizona. She was only 31. No justice.

[@Carmen-us1ew]

Wow, I've never heard this story!!!! 😮

[@carolbelyeu8748]

The clips literally gave me the chills! I was at work as a nurse in California early morning and saw it on a patient’s TV. All I wanted to do was get home and hug my daughter.

[@dejuhvu1793]

As a woman, if I don’t want to be hit on, I’m not going to a lesbian bar lol I also don’t go home & sleep at their place after just meeting them. I had to comment this while watching the video lol

[@bunnyellabell]

you're not wrong haha but queer folk tend to respect a "no" more than your commonplace guy in a bar, so it's usually safer if you just wanna hang out and drink :) tho i agree about her possible sapphic attractions

[@belindarocky961]

This is an interesting perspective because I'm the opposite. I'd prefer a lesbian bar. I've found women are more respectful than straight men.

[@kylee7596]

@@belindarocky961yes, but also these are spaces made by queer folks, for queer folks. Unless you are queer or you’ve been invited by a queer friend, please don’t. There’s less than 1000 queer bars in the country vs. 68000 others, and the rise of LGBTQ+ hate makes it all the more scarier 😢

[@xxxxxxxxx3944]

Not really. But at least you won't be physically threatened by a woman. ​@@bunnyellabell

[@mikesanders8621]

If she didn't wanna be hit on she would've gone to gay bars

[@kelsiegerig5353]

Would love to see you do a video on the disappearance of Brian Shaffer. I don't see a lot of poeple cover his case. It's truly bizarre and I would love to hear a lot more theories and details on it. You guys have such an amazing podcast!

[@chrissy8310]

I’ve requested it before on their case request forms but they get thousands so it probably just got lost. The more people who request it the higher chance it has of getting covered!!

[@lonerebeI]

His case has been covered by several youtubers. Baffling case

[@tjs7154]

Yes!! I follow the page on Facebook really crazy story.

[@mackenziemoore7503]

His case has been covered extensively, it's one of the most well known disappearance cases.

[@Raraking4796]

I recognize his name but can’t think of what KZbinrs I follow that have covered his case. I’ll try to remember to look and see if I can make any recommendations just in case you haven’t seen what I’ve been able to find. If I don’t make it back I apologize I would say tag me but I don’t always see all my notifications so I’m apologize in advance because I’m crazy absentminded.

[@RingYourDoorbell]

Whew. I got married 9/1 and was returning to work from my honeymoon on the 11th. I lived in Lawrence, KS, but my brother and sister-in-law lived and worked in NYC. Seeing these clips still take my breath away after all these years.

[@chel9064]

She went shopping but never came home to put the bags away? I wonder if she went missing soon after shopping..

[@CosmicCreatureThing]

I don't believe a word anyone from her family says. They are so obviously trying to save face and create a narrative that reflects what they consider admirable. I really hope this poor woman is alive and well and living her best life somewhere. If she was a victim of 9/11 or if she was a victim on the tenth, her family's constant lying only makes it harder to figure out.

[@2000dns]

I don't believe her husband would have been okay with her behavior and unprofessionalism. & I can't believe she died as a result of 9/11. In my opinion, after hearing the facts, she must have run away or been murdered. How did no one see her after the 10th? But because this case is SO messy, anything could be possible.

[@fieldmouse8910]

Have y'all heard about honour killings? what if her own family had her killed because of her sexual orientation? 🔎🔎

[@tesslott8375]

That crossed my mind as well. Maybe the brother? I personally don’t think the husband did it, but I think it could be a possibility that the brother did since they were fighting

[@jessicaluck5173]

I was just thinking this

[@WiccaLightsMyPath]

A year or two ago the dad who 🔫 🔫 his 2 daughters for having boyfriends and he couldn't "sell" them to other family's to marry his 2 virgin daughters. He thought that they dishonored their family. But their family's priest said that behavior and mindset isn't acceptable these days. Nor would it be tolerated in their faith or legally and that it was most definitely mur**r

[@isabellind1292]

Why are you using the language of men who excuse away the cold blooded murder of women? There's nothing "honorable" about it. Educate yourself instead of using this draconian term to apply to killers, depending on who they kill.

[@fieldmouse8910]

@@tesslott8375 exactly

[@mamabearmeli270]

Josh. Look up Robert Hoagland’s (“Hoagie”) case. He faked his disappearance & lived for years under a different identity. He had a roommate & everything. Nobody found out it was him until after his death when his roommate found paperwork that had his real name on it. This isn’t an old case either. It’s from the 2000s.

[@MysticHannah]

That’s fascinating

[@Sugarcookieloves]

You guys should cover the Sewol ferry disaster in South Korea in 2014. nearly 350 high school students died and it was so preventable based on the response from the Korean Coast Guard.

[@troybolton14]

Seconding this

[@Carmen-us1ew]

This was done on Rotten Mango.

[@KaileyB616]

Oh dude I watched Rotten Mango's video about that and I was RAGING by the end of it!!

[@rumm4881]

I've been obsessed with this case for so long! Thanks for doing it. Minority representation is so important. Such a bizarre case set against a tragic backdrop of circumstances.

[@mariemartins8606]

I am sorry but the husband is blind she was bi or lesbian and couldn’t tell him. She went home with women from the bar. I always believed she either killed herself or her brother did something in the heat of the moment.

[@bunnyellabell]

oh yeah. classic "they're best friends!" moment

[@ItsMeDarlaLee]

I usually agree with your theories but, I’m just not buying what her husband and family are saying. I think Sneha was not straight. Whether or not that was her being bi or lesbian. She was struggling with drugs and alcohol and maybe that was due to her hiding her sexuality. I think she was with a lover that morning saw the attacks and took the opportunity to start her life over.

[@a.walters123]

She bought pantyhose, bedsheets and lingerie the night before… those bags weren’t found at the apartment. That means she bought those items intended for that night. It’s a risky thing, going home with random strangers from a bar. However, it seems she did this frequently, it’s possible that she did run to the building to watch/help and died when it collapsed.

[@hannabeth151]

Josh explaining the couple hours before the attack sent chills down my spine. I still can't believe how much we've changed since then. I was in 2nd grade in Chicago and was so scared cause all I knew was my mom worked in a big building and nyc and Chicago from those angles look exactly the same. She got home so late that day even across the country. A teacher of mine had to walk 60 city blocks to get home cause there were no busses or cabs.

[@WiccaLightsMyPath]

My bother inlaw and sister inlaw were there on business and they had to go to Kinkos to make copies before they could process whatever they had to do there. They had made it 2 blocks away as the first plane hit and they saw the 2nd one hit and they hid in the Kinkos for a few hours until they could go back to his apt. I call her yearly and talk. But he died in 2014 of cirrhosis of the liver.

[@ciru2117]

I've always been fascinated by this story. Glad you're covering it.

[@queenmelly143]

I think maybe she disappeared of her own free will. Maybe she really was into girls, maybe she met someone and fell in love and ran away. She was already having issues w her husband. Who knows? I hope she’s ok, somewhere living her best life.

[@CiinderellaMakeup]

looking at the footage of that horrible day reminds me of the devastation in Gaza right now, 😔. I pray for all the lost innocent souls. what a sad story

[@sol-hb8zg]

100%

[@JenHilbawi]

Absolutely!

[@jamesbowman6925]

Yes, the Israelis are killing as many civilians as they can. I personally think that they're deliberately targeting children in order to try to break the spirit of the Palestinian people. The Israelis are just as bad as the Nazis.

[@bonnylouwho76]

You just popped up on my feed! I saw a video about this case awhile ago, I am really glad that yu are covering it. This is the earliest I have ever been to a true crime video at least for your channel. I am not usually able to be online this early in the day!

[@BurnItUpp2009]

This case has always perplexed me. Personally, it doesn't make sense to me that Sneha was involved in helping during the 9/11 attacks. I think something happened to her before that. I do think she was met with foul play.

[@kalpajha3002]

Its very easy for Ron to only say good things about Sneha and their marriage if he was involved in her disappearance so it takes the focus away from himself. I don't know but, if she was going out a lot, not letting him know where she was or whom she was with, it could really be that he was a jealous partner and could have snapped on the fateful day, but its very conflicting and very suspicious.

[@heyyhazy]

I just dont think she passed or went missing as a result of the attacks. There's no proof in combination with the circumstances of her life leading up to her disappearance. The lack of investigation is unfortunate, even years later.

[@kathyparrow1390]

The weirdest thing about it is that the window of their apartment was open. There were HELLACIOUS storms that night. The room would have been soaked.

[@RangerVickyJohnson]

If I’m not mistaken, the window was left open on the 11th, not the 10th, when it was storming out. Remember, it was a very clear morning on 9/11… great weather in NYC… It’s quite possible that Ron left the window open when he left the apartment that morning.

[@arielseescoral2607]

Idk I don’t think she was straight. It would make sense if she went to a GAY bar but she went to a LESBIAN bar. There’s nothing wrong with it, besides the fact she’s married. I feel bad if she was bisexual and felt she couldn’t tell the people who loved her most.

[@alexheldrich4898]

After only hearing the facts of this case from this video I suspect she may have been a victim of opportunity shortly after she was seen shopping. Such a fascinating case!

[@WiccaLightsMyPath]

She was spotted on camera shopping with another woman and I believe that they were spotted leaving together too. Nobody in her family or friends knew the other woman. But they both left with store bags from their purchases at Century 21.

[@graciellacastro2848]

I was also in 2nd grade I live in NY and that day was my birthday I’ll literally never forget that day my teacher’s husband was a first responder in the city so they rolled a tv in for her to see what was going on it’s such a sad vivid memory

[@NoReplyAtAll9]

My gut unfortunately says Brother "may know something".

[@whitneyeve1634]

Omg I am SO glad y’all are covering this case! Ever since I heard it on crime junkies I’ve never been able to get this one out of my head!

[@FTH1723]

wow this case has stuck with me ever since I heard about Sneha a few years ago. as a queer person, a part of me rly rly hopes she found her "happy ending" but I rly do not know what I believe. I want to believe she just used the events of 9/11 to escape and find her queer happy ending, but.. if she disappeared the day before how could've she known it would happen? how could've she known she could run away and disappear? that's the part that makes me lean towards foul play or she took her own life..

[@kylee7596]

Hey just to push back on what Kendall said regarding non queer people in queer bars.. please don’t. We have created these safe spaces for US, the amount of straight vs. queer people in our spaces nowadays is staggering. There’s over 68,000 bars/clubs in the US. About 1% are gay/lesbian bars. Please, for the love of God, don’t come here to “not get hit on”. Unless you’re invited by a queer friend, please don’t use our safe spaces

[@mariacherrington61920]

❤

[@annielane1843]

How inclusive ❤

[@rachapach6192]

I’ve thought about Sneha from time to time ever since I first heard about her case years ago. I’m sooo glad you’re covering it!!!

[@OLALALA1019]

Walter Matthau is a legendary comedian and his named is pronounced MATH-OW. Please look him up, he was an absolute legend in the industry lol. He’s been in many movies “the odd couple” “grumpy old men” “my fair lady” and many many many more

[@briannapost3725]

You're comment is one million percent the best!!! Walter Matthau is one of the greatest of his time, of any time! Grumpy Old Men and Grumpier Old Men are my top comfort movies and guarantees a few good chuckles!

[@OLALALA1019]

@@briannapost3725 I’m obsessed with both of those movies and the odd couple. Anything with Walter Matthau and Jack Lemmon is amazing. Friends til the end they were 🫶🏽

[@beegees21]

I noticed what they did righ away, and I'm not even American.... this generation is weird

[@johnclaybaugh9536]

​@@beegees21names get mispronounced all the time. This generation has nothing to do with it.

[@OLALALA1019]

@@johnclaybaugh9536 It’s not about the mispronunciation it’s about people in this generation not knowing a legendary actor who was in films they probably saw growing up as kids but knowing who the Kardashians are. He was in so much more than I even listed.

[@2000dns]

Adultery isn't "experimenting your sexuality", Josh. It's gross and wrong. Infidelity is Infidelity.

[@medharoy20]

I could be wrong and it is a speculation, in South Asian society we sometimes tell parents what they want to hear and one of the most common thing is being a mom, or having good life and family with husband. It could be possible that she said these things so that her mom wont worry about her. Im sure that her mom learned from her brother about her action towards her brothers gf. And maybe she was all along bi but she had to hide bc of social pressure bc even if people from this part of the world lived in US, they could have the same outlook as before. And she is an intelligent woman. It could also be possible that her family is not telling the truth. If she really changed her identity, i hope She's having a good life. 🙏🤞

[@elainemorgan6205]

To Josh's point, it may not have been the plan but could have been something that happened in the heat of the moment and 9/11 was a lucky break that gave him cover. I don't believe that, but it covers his point. This guy has done all of the things and her family never even suspected him.

[@rachelganthony]

I miss seeing Julia, her personality is so charming and cute.

[@LindaHicksLAH90]

I want to believe for her family's sake that she lost her life saving others. I don't know but I can't shake the feeling that either her husband or someone else took her life and 9/11 was absolutely a convenient hide away story. One day the truth will be found but until then, I respect her family and choose to agree that she did lose her life saving others.

[@LovelyLorely23]

I saw the members only video and was so sad because I couldn’t watch it so this is perfect thank you guys❤️

[@jamieelizondo5603]

This is just speculation, but what if the brother had something to do with her disappearance? They were in a fight because he supposedly walked in on Sneha and his girlfriend having sex. From their cultural background, it's very frowned upon to be homosexual and bisexual. "Honor killings" still happen in some parts of India and other parts of the world for that. The last sighting of her she bought bed sheets, stockings, and lingerie. Then the employee at Century21 shoes says she saw Sneha with another woman, possibly Indian, maybe the brother's girlfriend? Unfortunately there were no cameras there so we'll never know. The brother was also the first person who put out the story of her possibly being a victim of 9/11. Ron hired a private investigator and searched every where for her He was also at work the next day and asked neighbors to go knock on his apartment door to see if Sneha was there when he wasn't able to get into the building. If he had done it I don't see how or when he would've been able to dispose of her body without anyone seeing something and her never being found to this day. There are no reports on what the brother was doing the night of the 10th or before the attacks on the 11th. It's just a lot more plausible that the brother and/or his girlfriend had something to do with her disappearance than her husband being involved.

[@ciaranmurray5724]

It's actually quite straightforward... She stayed out all night and got home a few minutes before the first plane hit.( CCTV of a woman that could be her in her building ) She heard what was going on outside and went to help ( She was a Dr after all ) And unfortunately for her she was killed when the buildings collapsed.

[@jamieelizondo5603]

it's unconfirmed if that had been her in the apartment video footage. The woman in the video didn't have shopping bags, so what happened with the bags she had? If she had stayed out late the night before who did she stay with and where? What did she do after Century21? There were no other transactions on her credit cards to show she went to a bar or any other place that day. With how much publicity this case got at the time why is it that no one has come forward saying she was with them that night? There isn't any proof beyond grainy video footage of woman who may not even be Sneha at the apartment elevator, to show she was even alive on 9/11.Still a possibility she died when the towers collapsed but I wouldn't call it straightforward. @@ciaranmurray5724

[@nicoleevans8225]

"I smoke weed to be closer to God" "Relateable" Hahahahahahahahaha I knew you was my people!

[@LexieJay00]

Hoping for more paranormal or trippy episodes this year 🤘🏾

[@heavenj7]

Yes!

[@bluelagoon9]

I think Josh was on to something when he said she was buying lingerie, someone placed her with another woman in the shoe dept, and she didn’t come home that night.

[@erikaduso4639]

I really think the surveillance video holds some clues. Which direction did she go? Did she leave casually or rush out? What a sad case that happened at such a tragic time. So many people are still unidentified 😢

[@skydellasala7500]

I grew up in FiDi and was 4 years old, in TriBeCa, at my first day of pre-k during the attacks. We had almost no choice but to pass the towers on our way home. I’ll spare you the first memories of my life that are now forever burned into my brain. I’ve never heard this story before, but I think I had family friends that lived in the same building as her that you had mentioned. I’m curious if it’s been coaberated that her boyfriend went back to the apartment on 9/12 because pretty much all of FiDi and downtown manhattan, including the building I lived in that was a few blocks from Battery Park, was evacuated and barred off from civilians. Maybe he had an in since he’s a first responder, but I can’t imagine them letting anyone into any buildings in that area unless someone was in known immediate danger. My family was evacuated for 6 months and we weren’t allowed to get any of our things. It wasn’t until we returned home that FEMA offered any kind of assistance either. Just totally weird to hear about this story though and how the last place she was seen was at that Century 21. That department store was pretty much exclusively where I got clothes, shoes, school supplies, and home goods as a kid. By the way, not to pull your leg, but it’s Battery Park City, not Battery City Park 😂

[@Honeyin2013]

I do think it’s weird that someone was apparently in a down stairs apartment when he got there. I think they would have evacuated if they could open the window

[@peach2210]

​@Honeyin2013 same, but there's 100s of reasons someone wouldn't if their home was "okay". Maybe the first responders were too busy to argue with someone to evacuate?

[@miadee2968]

Never ever have I stumbled upon one of your videos that was uploaded 14 Mins ago. 🎉 Love how you cover the cases, big fan! ❤

[@lanagraham4587]

It appears she was bisexual or perhaps even lesbian which is completely unacceptable in her culture. Perhaps she married as a cover to keep her family off her back. Did she perish in 911 or disappear to live the life that she truly wanted??

[@italia_Irish_Applachia]

I remember this case ! It happened right before my 30th birthday. I also remember unsolved mysteries, I believe, did a segment on it. She definitely met with foul play . This case, Maura Murray, Brianna Maitland, and Brian Schaffer are the top cases that way on my mind. There are a couple other cases that don’t get much coverage that I May recommend in the future. Prays and hope that these cases will be solved ! 🙏🏻💕🙏🏻💝🙏🏻

[@italia_Irish_Applachia]

… it was covered on the Tv series “Disappeared “ not unsolved mysteries. Also the Springfield 3 is another case that weighs heavy on my mind.

[@jenniferburnette7675]

She did Maura Murray

[@italia_Irish_Applachia]

@@jenniferburnette7675 yes, I did see that one ! Kendall always does such a great job with each case 💖

[@murielzambreno]

⁠​⁠@@italia_Irish_Applachiait was also covered on Unsolved Mysteries. Just rewatched the episode yesterday. It’s on KZbin-season 12, ep 3.

[@amandawynkoop9584]

I think this is probably, for lack of better words and I'm not trying to be insensitive, my "favorite" case by you guys thus far. What a mystery. An absolutely heart wrenching mystery. I do 100% believe that was her, though, on the apartment surveillance on 9/11 and she ran to see wtf she just heard and saw and decided to help. Wholeheartedly believe it. Such an incredibly tragic day for so much of the world's population.

[@ItsMeShaniceG]

I’ve followed this case for years and her family is quite exhausting. Allegedly Sneha was having alcohol issues… They completely and utterly deny that. Supposedly she was a lesbian… They completely and utterly deny that. Her employer claims she was on the receiving end of many disciplinary actions… according to the family “nope, never happened“! Their refusal to acknowledge that this woman may have had one single flaw is infuriating. Ron didn’t even know where she slept half of the time but they’re all so confident About what she was “probably “doing on 9/11? Perhaps the case could have been solved if they were willing to be honest. And their relentless effort to make sure she was put in the category as a 9/11 victim pisses me off. I believe she died on the 10th. There is zero record of her being alive on the 11th. And with zero record of her being alive on the 11th, her family is 1000% convinced that she risked her life running into the towers to save people??? The ego is insane.

[@iamsherlocked345]

I think that’s it’s easier to deny than acknowledge she was struggling. Clearly Sneha was struggling and had something happening. We will probably never know what really happened to her.

[@jamieridolfo2951]

Is it possible that she took the opportunity of the chaos and panic going on to disappear ? Maybe she really did have a fight with her brother about her relationship with his girlfriend and he could have threatened to expose her sexuality to her family. As well as her drinking issues and employment issues, she may have decided it was too much

[@laurenpwhitten]

i said this in a separate comment too but there was a postsecret years and years ago that said "everyone who knew me before 9/11 believes im dead" and i always wonder if it was her

[@MysticHannah]

@@laurenpwhittenwhat is a post secret?

[@abbeyball6890]

This reminds me of Michelle Harris... Reported missing the morning of 9/11 from where I live in Tioga County NY. Her husband went through 4 separate trials and is a free man today. 😢 Many first responders and police went to NYC from all over to assist and they've never solved the case or found her remains.

[@SarahBurnette1007]

I'm with Jenelle on this 100% at 52:09. I think there is a decent possibility here that she saw the attacks, somehow wasn't right there, and took the opportunity. Many crimes that are committed are because of opportunity. Same idea.... the opportunity to present itself was there and she took it. Between her substance abuse issues, marital issues, job problems, court problems, and probably facing judgement from her religious friends and family about her sexuality.... she may have decided a fresh clean slate would be the best way out. I'm 70/30 on this... probably terror attack victim. But the possibility she left without a trace using the opportunity of the circumstances is very real too.

[@SeanForPotus]

Broke my ankle running to this video. Missed you guys. 🙏

[@michaeltudor1502]

It would've so easy for her to disappear then. Technology has changed a lot in 20 years, and 9/11 was the main topic/focus of the media for months.

[@aliceinreality7581]

She was definitely queer and struggling with her identity (in my opinion) I think she either ran off or was killed by her family for her identity 😢 wherever she may be, I hope she’s at peace

[@xxxxxxxxx3944]

Some people suspect John, but not the whole family. The family would not have worked so hard to find her if they were involved. Plus they were Christians, not Muslim.

[@djlopez33]

Yaasssss you guys are back!! ❤

[@kandy1515]

Interesting case . I feel I was watching something recently about this again. Im a lesbian and .. . She def seemed in the closet etc maybe her bro did something or her husband.. or she ran off with a woman.. thoughts people?

[@bmac375]

Agreed. These seem way more likely. I think 9/11 was just a coincidence.

[@vict4451]

I think she bailed. Maybe even had planned to leave. The chaos in the immediate aftermath of that day gave the perfect cover to just say "fuck it, I'm out" and she slipped away.

[@marisebelliveau1525]

After all these years I still get shivers see the plane hit the towers. I was 22 and pregnant. I thought the world was ending. I was watching the Live with Regis.

[@kristi_vera_parker]

OHMYGOD OHMYGOD OHMYGOD!!!! 🎉🎉🎉 I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE BACK!!! ❤❤❤ THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR ALL YOU DO!!! 🙏🙏🙏

[@elizabethstraw5173]

I’ve missed you both! Looking forward to this case. I love when you all talk about history.

[@rileymilan]

I was in 8th grade science class and saw it all unfold outside the classroom window with my classmates. Teacher had kids arguing about if the towers would collapse. We were stuck in the basement of the school for hours all trying to get picked up by parents. My dad worked close to the towers at the time and my aunt had to walk across the bridges to get home to our family because the roads and bridges were at a standstill. We lived by JFK and we had very little traffic that year. I remember going from being a little kid to being horrified that the world no longer felt safe. Still remember when the troops deployed in the following years and asking our global history teacher if we’d be going to war. What’s jarring is that the world NEVER felt safe after that day and never will be the same again.

[@aglaurendance]

I was a 6th grader who had just barely turned 11. My school told the 6-8 graders shortly after it happened, but not the K-5 kids. I was too young for my principal’s discussion of it to really sink in. I lived in base housing at the Naval War College at the time, which was closed for precaution the rest of the week. Having our Dads home when we came home from school was what helped us military kids in the base neighborhood really realize that something serious happened (we were all so used to our Dads being deployed or not home from the ship until dinner time if the ship was on base).

[@Tr7pz]

Always nice to listen to while at work. I’m quitting and starting school next week. Can’t wait for what life has waiting for me. Have to use my bfs account because he has yt red. Thank you guys for keeping me entertained

[@SeaBlue1976]

I am wishing you the very best in your life.I do hope that u will end up doing something u love,take it easy, greetings from Greece 💙

[@kyestrella]

i know i’m some stranger but proud of u!!!

[@dangerousxolady]

I was just on your page wondering when you guys were going to upload a video because I thought it has been a while. Yay! 🎉

[@maddddddisonx3]

Any time they say a case is frustrating I just prepare myself to get pissed off about the case lol

[@euniagar87]

Is Julia coming back? She was great

[@karli226]

Wow I cant believe I never heard about this case before. This is now going to be one that I really can't decide what could of happened. I do kind of believe she was a victim of 911 being that she was a doctor and wanted to help people but then again what was going on in her personal life and never coming home on the 10th did she disappear on purpose. Did she take the opportunity of what happened and left on her own and the timing was just right. I'll be thinking about this one for a while, how sad yet mind blowing to not truly know the truth.

[@GeorgeEvans-km2no]

I never watched a podcast im old😂😂 excited to listen.. justice for this beautiful Lady ❤ FROM JERSEY ❤

[@izabelag6542]

thank you for covering these cases ❤

[@alyssaroxanne9084]

I’m so glad you mentioned the PostSecret! I had been thinking of that secret the ENTIRE video! I check the website every Sunday and that specific secret has always haunted me.

[@montanahelton1272]

I was in 6th grade when 9/11 happened. My dad came into my room and woke me up (I was homeschooled) he said “get up and get your gun, we’re being attacked!” He didn’t know much because we didn’t have a TV. That was an interesting day… so scary for everyone.

[@tiffanyferguson829]

What state are you from? 😂 This has Texas written all over it.

[@montanahelton1272]

Surprisingly I am from Oregon, by my dad would fit right in in Texas! He hates being surrounded by all the hippies in Oregon lol

[@dustmite723]

What a terrifying way to be woken up

[@alinac5512]

What 6th grader has access to a gun? A+ parenting. I hope you get the therapy you need after growing up with such a nutjob. For you and everyone elses sake.

[@simonearchibald2664]

Wow, what a terrifying way to be woken up, & shuddering at the thought you already had a gun at so young! We Aussies 🇦🇺 banned them & I'm glad no mass shootings, especially schools happen here! Call me a conspiracy theorist but I still believe 911 was orcharstrated by your own Gov.. just to tighten laws & another excuse to go to war? I had worked night shift so was meant to be sleeping when hub called me & said turn on the tv, the world will never be the same again.. unfortunately I did, live feeds before they started to edit.. I'll never forget those who chose jumping over burning? So many years later & literally other side of globe still haunts me! Please get rid of the gun

[@skatergirl8019]

More than one employer had an issue with her behavior and job performance, but the family believes Sneha that all these other people are lying 🤔 Goes to lesbian bars, stays the night at women’s houses she met at lesbian bars, would not call home to let her husband know, was caught sleeping with another women, but Sneha is not a lesbian and a detective is lying 🤔 I can’t tell if her family is in denial or if they are straight up lying.

[@victoriakelley664]

Right? And what would be the point of the cops making up all of this? When they can easily write it off as "ah, musta been in 9/11"...

[@susanhorn3952]

I woke up that morning and turned on the TV to get ready for work and just stood there in shock as I watched the plane hit the tower 😢I didn't go to work for a week. I was glued to the television...feeling so hopeless 😢

[@kellireed3941]

I'm thinking...the reason nobody came forward about her sleeping over is because they were with her in the tower the next day and perished as well

[@Brittanym345]

The odds of 2 friends becoming Jane Doe’s due to 9/11 when they had no reason to be at the wtc are slim to none.

[@traceyvincent5843]

What if the person/people that she was with the night before died in 911 too? Did she have a vehicle? I think it would have been extremely hard I imagine to have got out of the city following the attacks. It's very sad that that so many bodies couldn't be recovered and identified.

[@traceyvincent5843]

Just thought, maybe she was coming back to her apartment to grab more stuff to leave that's why she didn't have bags with her. Then she heard the attack and ran out to see what had happened and died from the falling debris.

[@evapreu3011]

Another possibility is that the person she was with that night also died on 9/11 so the only witness is gone, too. Maybe after a night together she just wanted to go home quickly to change or whatever and planned to meet that friend again in WTC afterwards, and when the chaos started she naturally immediately went there to look for her friend.

[@Halezyeah]

Hmmm not sure about this one. I believe she was gay and wanted to be with a woman. Her husband and family obviously knew this. Weird circumstances and timing.

[@RainbowPyramid]

or the personwho she spent the night with might well have been killed in 9/11 which is why that person never came forward

[@Nakiami]

That's exactly what I was thinking. She said she had wanted to go to the windows of the world, and if she stayed the night maybe that person went with her. If that is the case then they both would have died. And there so many more scenarios too.

[@Purrfectlypinkkitty]

I have respect for josh and Kendall on never speculating too much on personal details. I watched a case last night where a lot of speculation regarding the victim was quite disrespectful and disturbing

[@CreekSideLagotto]

I had to just skip thru the footage of the planes I saw that happening on my tv it gave me chills again now watching.

[@tashaemmert2854]

I still miss Julia. Hoping she decides to come back one day ❤