Shekhar Argues with Dr Zakir, “If a Man can Beat his Wife Lightly, why can a Woman not Beat her ..."

[@ptec2694]

Woman are the flower and diamond in our life giving to us to be protected and respected.

[@mohammednaqhid8706]

Only good women, not Feminists

[@MMA_BEASTHUB]

Some of then are throns and rocks

[@mohammednaqhid8706]

@@MMA_BEASTHUB 😂

[@ContentCaptures]

Some are man eaters

[@faisalhossain7748]

@@mohammednaqhid8706 Feminist are really bad

[@joetreetree811]

Almighty Allah says - Surah Ali 'Imran [3:195] - Al-Qur'an al-Kareem “ Their Lord responded to them: “I never fail to reward any worker among you for any work you do, be you male or female - you are equal to one another.”

[@lizardof_odds3424]

﷽

[@umekulsum3172]

subhanallah ! Correct details please , i want to search this in Qur'an

[@ahmedzahid6445]

But Hitting wife is not a bad deed according to Allah ! So how does this aayath justify that ??

[@shahidachoudhury6925]

@@ahmedzahid6445 Yea beat with "Datun" (toothbrush)and can not hit on the face or left a mark on her body ? Is this called beat ?

[@ahmedzahid6445]

@@shahidachoudhury6925 don't let Zakir fool u sister ! it's not about tooth brush sister ! Tooth brush is a small thing what u have in market today ! In ancient times they used ' miswak' . Miswak' is taken from the roots of a tree !! in ancient times U can buy it in long sizes! U can buy it up to 3 metres long ! For commercial purpose today u get it in small size sister ! So prophet was talking about beating her with long Miswak' sister ! And in what hadees u get that it shouldn't leave marks on her ?? Pls check "sahih bukhari 5825" hadees ! In it clearly says it's allowed to beat her hard that her skin turns green !! And also in Quran it gives permission to "strike her". pls Google the meaning of "strike"!

[@amina2334]

Please watch Nouman Ali Khan’s video on this topic it has been explained in more detail and the situation whr this ayah has been sent down for is very extreme situation not for everyday life. The video’s name is abuse of women by Nouman Ali Khan. Its a little longer but clear every bit of the doubt and questions. InshaAllah all the doubts will be clear. Jazakum Allah bekhair.

[@gamingwithgangsters8579]

yes i think its in *its messed up*

[@el_killorcure]

"this ayah has been sent down for is very extreme situation not for everyday life" Where in the Quran (a clear book by its own admission) does it say it's for extreme situations only? If we need some scholar to "interpret" and "theorise" about what the Quran meant (since it doesn't say that), that does not square with the Quran's own statement of being clear and complete and detailed.

[@READ-cj3us]

Silvakie prophet interpret it and showed what is extreme situation . Scholars just remind the laymen who r not aware. Quran is complete . Beating isn't allowed but a situation where teenager wants to do drugs and u have tried ur best to nicely explain it kid and he is still adamant. And say ur wife not u but ur wife or the elder brother or sister of the teenager slightly slaps the teen to prevent him from doing drugs I don't see a problem . Bcuz sometimes we all need stern reminders . Now it doesn't mean it has to be like alright let's just keep bearing him for everything and anything

[@el_killorcure]

@@READ-cj3us You're a liar then: "Men are the maintainers of women because Allah has made some of them to excel others and because they spend out of their property; the good women are therefore obedient, guarding the unseen as Allah has guarded; and (as to) those on whose part you fear desertion, admonish them, and leave them alone in the sleeping-places and beat them; then if they obey you, do not seek a way against them; surely Allah is High, Great." (4:34) - Ibn Kathir commentary confirms the "beat them" section without "lightly" added by some translators. - Your example about a teenager is BS, the Quran says nothing of teenagers in that verse, it clearly (for a change) addresses the wives.

[@chandiokinggameing3328]

Pbhu

[@toobad9295]

the word that says “beat her lightly” in arabic also means “go away” why is everyone using the first meaning rather than the second one when the second one makes so much more sense?

[@fallacyyy]

May I ask where was this mentioned? It’s false

[@toobad9295]

@@fallacyyy I've read it online on several sites, I promise if I knew the names of the sites I would tell you but I can't remember it was a while I go that I read it

[@toobad9295]

so apparently the second translation isn't go away but "to prevent" which some scholars have interpreted as "leave her be", sorry for the mistake

[@aformula4198]

@@toobad9295 May I get a link please

[@toobad9295]

@@aformula4198 you can find different translations coming from different scholars if you search up that specific verse on wikipedia and then there's this link as well which specifically talks about that verse and the different translations of specific words: www.cie.ugent.be/bogaert/bogaert4.htm and I've read on other sites as well but can't remember those since it's been a while because I'm someone who when I hear something I do a lot of research and go through A LOT of sites which then makes me forget every site since I did so much research :)

[@jopathkorowa8538]

The 112 year old Somali man question guy at the back.

[@farhiyoali9723]

Truth Speaker 😂😂😂 yes we’ll never forge🥴🤣🤣

[@Zappp007]

😂😂😂

[@keshab644]

Yes

[@AmenhotepIII1388-]

Truth Speaker 😂😂😂😂

[@apubanerjee2037]

😂😁😀😃😄😅😆😍😎😋😊😉😗😘

[@aaliaabuzar42]

We need so many people like Dr. Zakir Naik, His ability to answer all questions at Moment is Subhanallah, so amazing!!

[@multipurpose6984]

Capitalize the first letter of Allah in subhanAllah by editing ur comment and just take care of that always

[@richardbranche8873]

Yes his ability to lie and avoid serious questions is very powerful 👌

[@AmanJohns0n]

U r absolutely right ✅️ 👌 👏 🙌 👍

[@niq7264]

@@multipurpose6984 He never did answer the question. He started avoiding the question about what do women do when the man is wrong by bringing up father and daughter relationships.

[@sully111]

@@niq7264 watch the video actually

[@rationalbeliever4789]

Hater or Lover!No one can deny his absolute miracle of memory..May Allah bless him♥️

[@yasmeenshaikhoney1699]

Rational believer absolutely.

[@satishmandapati1]

Bro..you read something and by heart it for an year..you can also do this.

[@unknownv8462]

Pedophile and women killer

[@bouchrat8048]

Masha allah

[@spl7031]

@Edward Lim Muslim Muslim Muslim

[@voland6109]

I am so glad my dad taught me to be a gentleman.

[@j4ckj4cky85]

well not mine, however I self taught myself to not harm a women no matter what :)

[@yahyam4752]

I am happy i am muslim ..i learn all of this from islam 🥳🥳🥳🥳

[@godislovesurely6158]

Rightous man will never beat his wife lightly or strongly . Only wicked person with full of mud in his brain will encourage such thing.

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

So if your wife tries to jump from top your response might be "honey don't jump".

[@godislovesurely6158]

Bible clearly says as to how to handle wife in a decent manner and I follow it for the last 22 years.As such, there is no problem in my family life.

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

@@godislovesurely6158 bible does not say about handling a wife who wants to jump from top.

[@faeezparkar9731]

@@godislovesurely6158 😂 well now a days in Muslim families it doesn't happen . Everyone is afraid of their own wives , that she may leave him .

[@godislovesurely6158]

@@muhammadmafaz8530 jesus says man should love his wife as if it is your own body ,as such ,they are no longer two , they are one(question of polygomy does not arise in christianity) .It shuold be uncondtional love. man should not divorce his wife except on adultary. If a man marries a divorced woman,he commits adultary

[@ahadone9745]

My father was an illiterate man and as he was a Muslim in belief, I have never seen him abusing my mother phyiscally or verbally in daily life. He always treated her nice and that was a practical example for me of being a Muslim.

[@fatititititi]

may Allah bless him and your family

[@yourpick529]

Lol kyu jhut bolte ho😂

[@GeorgePhilip-e5z]

Quran says to beat...since he is not beaten his wife even though god said he is a great man..

[@dewansaidulazim5437]

@@yourpick529 so only you know the truth🤣 i mean how can someone be so hypocrite. 😐

[@aishas4664]

Ma Shaa Allah Allahuma barik!! He reminds me of me when I looked for truth and found Islam Alhamdulillah... anyone else wonders if he became Muslim???😄

[@aishas4664]

atoz ind usa why?

[@aishas4664]

atoz ind brother I’m not married I’m only 18😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@aishas4664]

atoz ind i call my cat hubby and yeah no problem I wasn’t looking for a husband on KZbin anyways😂😂😂

[@nikkahmutaq1073]

Mohammed I am sure must have forced himself by beating and punishing Ayisha along with Abu Baker to have sex with him

[@AbcDef-yi3it]

Where r u from??

[@nusratakter055]

Whenever I hear Zakir Nayak talk I feel like I failed to be a true Muslim

[@Nitinkandwal]

That means you succeeded to be a true human.

[@nusratakter055]

@@Nitinkandwal thanks

[@Nitinkandwal]

@@nusratakter055 😂😂😂 I don't think you got my point. Here it is. DON'T FOLLOW ANY RELEGION IF YOU WANT TO BE A TRUE HUMAN BEING. Zakir Naik is a psychopath, never believe in him.

[@nusratakter055]

@@Nitinkandwal don't say that, believe in Allah is a must. I do in believe in humanity first before everything but I am not good human that's is a sure because I don't even do what I must do follow my Allah!

[@veryrare3041]

He’s faking if he knows as much as he tries to show about the Quran he 110% faking to control the masses

[@J21364]

Shekar had impressed me with his knowledge.

[@RamanBhagat-up9vj]

@Farhat Shamim you will never accept that others are good tooo...that's problem of many Muslims

[@RamanBhagat-up9vj]

@Loyal Royalty who are you to decide

[@bskr2096]

A Question No Muslim Can Answer (Prove Me Wrong!) watch above title at David Wood youtube channel

[@lawwithmubarak]

Please subscribe to my chennal

[@gymlover1025]

#xenucorp pls subscribe my

[@mubashirm9759]

Whenever I see the title it seems very difficult to answer. But when I see the Video the answer was very simple than I thought😅

[@bskr2096]

A Question No Muslim Can Answer (Prove Me Wrong!) watch above title at David Wood youtube channel

[@abdullahbinfaisal7]

@@bskr2096 Yeah it got answered tho by many people.

[@revisionstudy3103]

@Hakim Zd fr lol, muhammad hijab absolutely killed him in a debate

[@akrepiidfiresupportvehicle2289]

Because of some people take it too toxic. Like they understand "you can beat your wives freely"

[@halynia8646]

@@abdullahbinfaisal7 That is true. 😂

[@vangalanikhilesh6028]

How can he compare the Father-Daughter relationship to a Husband-Wife relationship...He always compares two different things that cannot be compared and makes a conclusion out of it.

[@shahnawazshaikh1157]

He didnt compare....listen again....he explaned two diff scenario

[@vangalanikhilesh6028]

@@shahnawazshaikh1157 but he is using that logic to prove wife can't hit a husband just because daughter can't hit a father. Think about it. Just because man has more strength doesn't give him the right to hit a woman. He says hitting with a brush and hand kerchief....does he even know....it hurts like shit when someone uses them to hit you

[@shahnawazshaikh1157]

Hit with miswak...type of brush....slightly....no mark should appear....i think u forget these words.....and women cant hit husband....she has other ways to protest....no cooking...husband cant do anything....cooking is no wife responsibility....in Islam wife is queen...she is doing favour to husband and family by cooking. Our almighty knows best. He put these rules. For some reason.

[@vangalanikhilesh6028]

@@shahnawazshaikh1157 if woman's way of protesting is supposed to be not cooking food...then why does the man protests by hitting her... slightly according to you or the speaker. He can even protest by not bringing stuff from market instead of causing physical pain. He can also protest in different ways instead of abusing physically. According to u both not leaving a mark on wife's body is okay...doesn't make any sense because u still can hit a person without placing a mark and u can hit her slightly....wowwwww

[@shahnawazshaikh1157]

See these r Almightys laws. And u missed this first u stop tslking. Second dont share bed...third is slightly hitting. Snd suppose ss per u. He didnt bring market stuff. Then no food. Who will suffer wife elder children. Husbsnd has to order fron restaurant. Husband suffer . Wats the use. He did ghis so wife suffer. And if wife stop cooking. Husbsnd suffer by ordering food for whole family.

[@SelimSikh-y8r]

Masha Allah Excellent answers ,may allah protect Dr, zakir and give him long and Healthy life Ameen

[@believerbyheart3501]

A person only hits other person when they think They are stronger or a 'degree above 'than the other person which is why husbands hit wife . And it's not symbolic . It's not even handkerchief but a miswak (which is a big stick) . Hitting anywhere whether it leaves Mark or not is humiliation .

[@nergis18]

Wait miswak isnt a big stick😂 its a small branch you use to brush your teeth, they're like normal toothbrushes but from mother nature

[@asadwholesomememe2749]

Idc what I'm being hit with, the second you hit me I'm done. I didn't grow up with abusive parents only to get humiliated in marriage

[@farzonmarz8686]

@@asadwholesomememe2749 yea divorce after being tapped with a brush is logical

[@skinnylegend9782]

@@farzonmarz8686 tapped? Stike

[@manaan8220]

A really intelligent guy with intellectual questions👍🏻

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@HamdiGlenn]

@@Mayahomok an Nisaa 34 EXPLAIN

[@Mayahomok]

@@HamdiGlenn كلمة ضربة لا علاقة لها بالضرب المعروف في لغتنا العربية أو لهجتنا العامية ما المقصود بكلمة ضرب في القرآن ؟؟؟ What is meant by the word Daraba in the Qur'an??? facebook.com/mohimlaka/photos/a.109082697929725/126041472900514/

[@parveenjk1168]

I never and ever bored to watch Dr Zakir Naik video

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

الإسلام هو الدين الوحيد . وهذا الدين وحده هو الذي يمهد الطريق إلى الجنة

[@karimibrahim2137]

Brother shekar hope ALLAH guide you in right path to heaven.🤲ameen

[@bskr2096]

A Question No Muslim Can Answer (Prove Me Wrong!) watch above title at David Wood youtube channel

[@akashveersingh528]

There is no right path

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation ********* kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@rajaantony3172]

Ultimately, the point is that a wife is the daughter of her husband. Brother makes a good point.

[@tejas.c.s30]

Oh bhai bhai bhai😂😂

[@mansibisht6768]

Wtf ! Muslim logic

[@andreeaboloca4440]

@@mansibisht6768 not Muslim logic ...you all misunderstood what Dr Zakir said and are stupidly mocking us all cause of that ....cheap move..... Simplified,a man can not beat his wife and the only time a man may be forgiven for his short temper which could lead into hitting his wife lightly is if she has cheated ...the verses before the one talking about hitting,are about women cheating .....read then talk......and there is no verse that says a woman can not hit her husband if he is cheating while men and women do react and feel quite different about such situations in the first place anyways....there is nothing that says a woman should suffer but instead Islam clearly states Muslim and women should not accept opression and unfairness ...we are all asked to be fair ....so please,move on ...those without logic were you here..men are qawam to women,so protectors and providers to them ....it is a mere comparation inbetween a father's job and a husband's job which are the same ....the difference is made by the fact that fathers have the fathering feelings while the husbands don't ....to husbands we can argue fairly if they wrong us and leave them,while to fathers we can not say uff even and are not allowed to break blood ties with (obviously unless the wrong was as disgusting as a rape or something like that ) ...

[@mansibisht6768]

@@andreeaboloca4440 really ,I have read that two women equals one man and for divorce women should ask the men then🤨 women should cover herself bcz of other men😐 this is equality..

[@andreeaboloca4440]

@@mansibisht6768 listen We all know that this is the actual tradition and belief of your very own country so before you come out shouting about equality for women when it comes to Islam,look closer to home and shout out there ....on the other hand,no,that is wrong...what you read is wrong...women are not believed to have half brains and in sunnah there are all kinds of hadiths as well as all kinds of translations which people use for their own benefit or to hurt others without checking it being able to check the authenticity of what they share and spread out there....in some cases there needs to be 2 women and a man if there are no 2 men as witnesses for the simply fact that women may use their feelings above their heads (and the truth) while on other cases it is enough for a woman to swear with Allah as witness ...Aisha our prophet's wife did that ..

[@sabiehijaz]

Masha Allah! Excellent answers. May Allah protect Dr. Zakir and give him long and healthy life Ameen

[@lailauthman5454]

Ameen Ya Rahman

[@nizamulhaq5380]

Ameeen

[@brawdwachick]

🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🙏

[@nikkahmutaq1073]

sabiehijaz can Allah buy zakir a fitting pants, because his granddaughter wants her pants back

[@abidmehsood3340]

The guy’s smile reveals that he is a genius and can’t be satisfied that easy...!!!!

[@luisyopr]

Dr Zakir is amazing and what I love more is that he wants to bring people to paradise helping them answer their questions! May Allah grant him Jannah

[@luisyopr]

Edward Lim you don’t have to be granted Jannah to try to bring people to it.

[@luisyopr]

Edward Lim you probably a silly guy going from video to video to comment stupid things around. I know what I wrote maybe many people know it too you the only one crying over it. Grow up and keep scrolling may Allah give you wisdom and knowledge and may Allah grant you paradise for you and your loved ones. Ameen!

[@MoRiWeeB]

@Edward Lim he didn't say he will bring people to Jannah

[@MoRiWeeB]

@Edward Lim here you are the stupid one

[@MoRiWeeB]

@Edward Lim maybe he did something that Allah didn't like so he cant get to Jannah

[@aaliaabuzar42]

May Allah give him long life, so much knowledge, Allahuakbar!!

[@enginedream8430]

He is good story teller and nothing more than that, whatever you ask him, he will always give an answer in the form of story which is not even related with the question that is being asked. Then again after completing his story he aks you yes or no. You have to say yes in the peer pressure, than he takes you round and round and give you the feeling that you have find your answer. And he has a lot of followers for him to clap. You got your answer in the name of allah.

[@syedsyed551]

You are nothing compare to him.

[@yusuf4844]

You sound stupid.

[@enginedream8430]

@@yusuf4844 everything which is true sounds stupid sometimes

[@enginedream8430]

@@syedsyed551 I am everything compaired to him

[@adammw1646]

Hahahaha

[@trikusumastuti9929]

Genius and modest Dr. Zakir Naik.

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation ********* kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@alamali2383]

Masha allah I'm amazed after watching this lecture May Allah protect him

[@bintumarrah912]

Ameen

[@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45]

Brain Dead christians claim God loved his son so much & despite being the OWNER & CONTROLLER of the WORLD he decided to let his son go through so much pain & then LET HIM GO, Christians 🙄 LET it go.

[@riyabaig2005]

Aameen

[@nojmulhuda4766]

@Bryan Sunyou said "Allah could not protect muhammad from witchcraft and for sure he also could not protect him from the poison that killed him." I agree with you. This is also my point believing Quran is Zionist Plot to create confusion among people about Lord Jesus Christ SON OF GOD. What a fool Muslims are to believe a man who they believe to be the best and the last prophet of their Allah, but their Allah could not save Muhammad from his painful death!!

[@truebeliever5761]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fmiWc3qfpttpkJo All here Muslim and non-Muslim watch 👆 this mind-blowing video about analysis of Quran....than deside Quran man made or from ALLAH ❤️.

[@yousufsaad6738]

Gifted... Dr zakir naik... Soo proud of u... Ma sha Allah ❤

[@shahqurbanbaba1873]

Dr zakir naik is a very wise man. May allah take him to jannah.

[@rebakeja7981]

and us ameen

[@TS-qq7vr]

May he be taken to Ali Jinnah.

[@carljohnson2194]

Edward Lim modi is nothing in front of Allah 😂. What can a human do in front of God? If Allah wills he can destroy modi 😂 😂😂😂😂😂

[@OptimisticCynic45]

Here is a quote translated into english that comes from the Quran. Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand. That can be found on the 34th verse of chapter 4 (sūrat l-nisāa). Yes -beating your wife is permissible.

[@rajeshr5140]

I’m not convinced. This is one question that they will find it very difficult to justify. Shekhar nailed it

[@neutralcommentor3742]

Rajesh R none of Muslim brothers who blindly support Zakir Naik will like your question 😂

[@bocahanom4617]

@@neutralcommentor3742 Well, that too is an underestimate coment of you... For those who studied tafsir and syarah, the question of brother shekhtar is an easy thing to answer. We just need to show him the syarah of the hadits. So he can understand the meaning of the word in the hadits he is questioning, right from the main source that has been written for decades.

[@neutralcommentor3742]

Bocah Anom the problem is I don’t think that Quran is completely correct. The discrimination exists in Quran. And I am not saying that Bible or Gita or any other holy books are perfect as well. These books were written eons ago and times have changed since then. But the holy books haven’t with time.

[@bocahanom4617]

@@neutralcommentor3742 Well....thats depends on your understanding of discrimination brothe. For me quran is the only holy book who up lifting women rights. Indeed there is some verse who seems un fair for the women comparing the men. But if we analyze if further we can find it was for the best, in general.

[@neutralcommentor3742]

Bocah Anom maybe it was the best when it was written. May be not now. I have been born in a family that completely support equality (I.e. no discrimination on the basis of caste, religion, creed, region, sex, etc.) I have grown up to believe that everyone is born equal (in general) but in the end it’s all about what you utilize your time and the decisions you take that decides where you will go. Hence, I have a critical view to all the religious books. Now when it comes to Quran I am curious why you say that it is the most uplifting holy book for women. I have a completely different view about it when it come later to equality. Please note, I am not challenging you or criticizing. I am just trying to understand why you think so and I have a Muslim friends , but I won’t ask them this question coz they would take it personally. Hence, I am asking you coz we don’t know each other.

[@kyeone9626]

It's ok to to have death sentence in America to learn a lesson . But yet they talk about light beating as a last resort in islam. Islam is the best and Allah (swt) is the greatest,

[@abri_xxx]

"light" beating is still beating, isn't it

[@kyeone9626]

@@abri_xxx it's ok to discipline your kids, but when islam teaches disapline you call it a beating when you smack your child you don't cal that a beating.

[@kyeone9626]

@@abri_xxx states to not hit in the face do not hit to leave any mark so how is that a beating like dr zakir sed it's like hitting her with hancheif, but you don't pay attention to the video your jus here to to blast islam in any way possible

[@abri_xxx]

@@kyeone9626 Lol no, I'm not "anti Islam". I'm anti violence. And there are many ways of violence but you are probably too restarted and ignorant to understand that. If Hinduism would teach beating I also would criticize it. Don't jump on that pathetic "You just want mock Islam" - train bc you won't get any empathy 😂 Beating IS beating. Just bc Islam teaches it doesn't mean it's right and it's not beating. Bc it is. It's simple like that. Islam teachings are 1400 years old. Think about it. Beating is wrong and Islam doesn't make it right 😂😂😂 I think you need to get beat to understand that lol

[@kyeone9626]

@@abri_xxx if your anti violence then why don't you go on other sites that beat the fuk out of women who are not Muslims who rape children instead of commenting on islamic videos

[@saumyagupta6291]

Again one more time diplomatic answer... Man is physically strong that's why they can beat lightly but not women... Why they can't beat lightly because they can beat physically in the ans of that lightly beating... That's means acc to him Man don't have patience or understanding nature than women have... It's not always truth in both either Male or female...

[@bskr2096]

A Question No Muslim Can Answer (Prove Me Wrong!) watch above title at David Wood youtube channel

[@karlhans4116]

@@bskr2096 david wood 😂😂😂😂

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

قال ابن سماك: "كم من الذين يذكروننا بالله قد نسيوه! فكم من دعاة إلى تقوى الله هم أنفسهم شجعان أمامه! فكم ممن يقرب إلى الله تعالى وهو بعيد عنه! فكم ممن يدعو إلى الله نفسه يهرب منه! فكم من قراء كتاب الله أنفسهم طاروا من آيات الله! ""سنن الصالحين"" 1002.

[@justsomone2694]

A wife cant hit his husband because that would start a physical fight which she cant win. Ok thats mostly true. That would happen if he hits back, but if he is in the wrong, doesnt allah forbid him to hit back? Just askin

[@Nomlezz6th5]

It's forbidden to hit her back. You can only hit your wife as the way said, very lightly and in only some situations.

[@qoutes_and_bibleverses9684]

A father can discipline without applying violence

[@MuhmmedNadeem-cy2tj]

depends on how you define violence.

[@lestasoldier]

culture and context.

[@gazeffstronoff4583]

PROUD TO BE BORN IN SUCH A BEAUTIFUL AND THE ONLY RELIGION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@compassioniseverything4262]

What made you think it is beautiful?

[@eucharistenjoyer]

I didn't fully understand this doctrine of the Quran until I saw the most perfect explanation and refutation of the enemies of the Quran on Sal Recinos channel. Amazing.

[@Shad1991]

Dr Zakir really enjoyed his days of watching Arnold Schwarzenegger.. Always uses him as the strongest man example..lol

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation ********* kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@allinall7977]

My request to you is to make a video on how you gained this much knowledge in a short period of time

[@allinall7977]

I as a student I want to know

[@allinall7977]

please please please please please please make a video on it 🙏🙏🙏

[@litosheikh7088]

his all arguments are from his teacher.. Ahmed deddat

[@QuranwithRain]

But the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) never hit children .... he got his point across with kindness

[@qoutes_and_bibleverses9684]

He is more than hitted when marrying a 6 yr old girl.he corrupted the childhood of that girl.

[@prophetmuhammad1970]

Of course he didn't hit children. He raped them.

[@QuranwithRain]

Rowel Camancho nope and nope. The prophet (peace be upon him) married a woman 15 years older than him. Also he married widowed and divorcees. In the society of that time, they never would’ve been able to get married so they would be left uncared for. The prophet understood and cared for those who were helpless. One wife, was 15 (not 6 as Wikislam states). During that time, 15 was adulthood considering lifespans were shorter and girls matured faster. Because they were 2 consenting adults (and Islam forbids marriage without consent and more obviously rape) there is no problem in this Please have an open mind and stop getting brainwashed by everything people say

[@QuranwithRain]

Rowel Camancho Rowel Camancho nope and nope. The prophet (peace be upon him) married a woman 15 years older than him. Also he married widowed and divorcees. In the society of that time, they never would’ve been able to get married so they would be left uncared for. The prophet understood and cared for those who were helpless. One wife, was 15 (not 6 as Wikislam states). During that time, 15 was adulthood considering lifespans were shorter and girls matured faster. Because they were 2 consenting adults (and Islam forbids marriage without consent and more obviously rape) there is no problem in this Please have an open mind and stop getting brainwashed by everything people say He has NEVER hit women or his children “Do not hit the female slaves of Allah”- Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)

[@prophetmuhammad1970]

@@QuranwithRain He only married Khadijah because she was rich. She was a successful business woman. 15 years old was considered adulthood at the time? So, why did he rape Aisha when she was only six years old? These divorcees he married: You mean like how he married his adopted son's wife after he caused them to get divorced? And, he never hit women? Is that why surah 4:34 commands men to beat their wives? But, this does bring up another good point? How many wives did Muhammad have? How many wives does the quran say a man can have? Muhammad violated his own 4 wife rule.

[@captainsalif4752]

Very Genuine and Educated Person.

[@ismatmina]

Dr. Zakir naik, assalamualaikum, may Allah bless u. I love your answers, and respect for your islamic knowledge.

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@azadalishah2966]

Salam ZN, Pls hv a look at this. And review your answers with deep research. BEATING WIFE? Is it true Really? Beating,slapping n any physical violence against any human is cruel n lack of dignity. Quran should be in sync with Sahi Hadith. There cant be contradiction between Sahi Hadith & Quran. Our Rasool SAW cant contradict with what Quran says. If there is any contradiction, its our lack of understanding or "perhaps" mistake in human narration or mistake in interpretation(Allah SWT knows best). Quran was written in Pure classic Arabic & it was famous for its poetic language. The word "beat" people use in this verse in Quran (4:34) comes from the Arabic word "daraba" which has multiple and many many meanings like beat, tab, "strike" and many other..100s usage (pls see link below) .... Instead of translating it as beat, why not take it as "strike different path/way if other 2 optionsI(talk to them suasively, leave them alone in bed - as mentined in Quran - 4:34) fails"? I will take simplest, safest n purest meaning - "strike a different path" rather than "beating". Let me support my interpretation with Hadith: As per Hadith a Muslim can't even beat an animal on face, see the respect Allah gv to face. There r nearly 10 Hadiths which warn not to beat wife. Beating is disgusting, no matter hw much verbal fight happens. As I simply detest those people who resort physical violence and let me share some strict warning from Allah swt for those who love physical violence. When Rasool SAW didnt beat any human(forget beating wife), why one shud adopt physical violence for any conflict? In so many Hadith Allah SWT strictly prohibits beating wife: 1) In Abu-Dawud, Ibn Ma'jah, Tirmidhi says - "Men who beat their wives are not best amonst u" 2) ... do not beat your wife"(Abu Dawud, Book 1, Number 0142 ) 3) Rasool SAW didnt beat & revenge any1: 'A'isha reported that Allah's Messenger SAW never beat anyone with his hand, neither a woman nor a servant, but only, in the case when he had been fighting in the cause of Allah and he never took revenge for anything unless the things made inviolable by Allah were made violable; he then took revenge for Allah, the Exalted and Glorious.(Sahih Muslim,Book 030, Number 5756) 4) ...Give them food what you have for yourself, and clothe them by which you clothe yourself, and do not beat them, and do not revile them. (Abu Dawud, Book 11, Number 2139) 5) .... Approach your tilth when or how you will, give her (your wife) food when you take food, clothe when you clothe yourself, do not revile her face, and do not beat her. (Abu Dawud, Book 11, Number 2138) 6) ....."How does anyone of you beat his wife as he beats the stallion camel and then he may embrace (sleep with) her?" (Sahih Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 73, Number 68) 7) Prophet suggested woman to reject wife beater's proposal for marriage. Fatima bint Qais (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Mu'awiya, Abu Jahm and Usama b. Zaid had given her the proposal of marriage. Allah's Messenger SAW said: So far as Mu'awiya is concerned, he is a poor man without any property. So far as Abu Jahm is concerned, he is a great beater of women, but Usama b. Zaid... She pointed with her hand (that she did not approve of the idea of marrying) Usama. But Allah's Messenger SAW said: Obedience to Allah and obedience to His Messenger is better for thee. She said: So I married him, and I became an object of envy.(Sahih Muslim, Book 009, Number 3526) PHYSICAL CONFLICT WITH OTHERS: Forget beating wife, Allah SWT even forbid touching face when fighting with others. And imagine how today's Muslims try to attack face first in any physical conflict. Our Prophet peace be upon him did specify that the beating must not include the face. Hitting the face of any human being and even animal is not allowed in Islam. a) ...'The Prophet forbade beating on the face.' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Hunting, Slaughtering, Volume 7, Book 67, Number 449)" b) "...When one of you inflicts a beating, he should avoid striking the face.. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 38, Prescribed Punishments (Kitab Al-Hudud), Number 4478)" c) Even with slaves, if one slaps his slave in the face, then he must set him free: ".... He who beats a slave without cognizable offence of his or slaps him, then expiation for it is that he should set him free. (Translation of Sahih Muslim, The Book of Oaths (Kitab Al-Aiman), Book 015, Number 4079)" The above Sayings of our beloved Prophet peace be upon him preserve the human dignity from being compromised. There is no need to humiliate the person (any person) if you ever have to enter into a physical confrontation with him.. Of course, fighting by choice is also not allowed in Islam. Let me turn the table, "assuming" above verses of Quran is "considered" to b rightly interpreted, there is many clear Hadith which says not to beat wife but treat well as I showed above, which means we have a contradictory/doubtful info ? ISLAM "CLEARLY" SAYS TO AVOID DOUBTFUL MATTERS: "That which is lawful is clear and that which is unlawful is clear and between the two of them are doubtful [or ambiguous] matters about which not many people are knowledgeable. Thus, he who avoids these doubtful matters certainly clears himself in regard to his religion and his honor. But he who falls into the doubtful matters falls into that which is unlawful like the shepherd who pastures around a sanctuary, all but grazing therein. .....”. [al-Bukhari and Muslim] So one can't just say, Wife beating is allowed in Islam for any reason and u cant attack generally any human(even animal) on face. So Muslim brothers stop using/thinking the favorite phrase "slap his/her face". Forget beating wife, prophet Muhammad SAW chose best option & "forgave" and "prayed" for the people of Taif who stoned him and blood was flowing from his body and his shoes were soaked with blood, even when Allah SWT sent Angel Jibril (AS) to kill them by crushing between mountains (Imgine what we will do to our enemy when they stone us). Prophet Muhamnad is the best example of Islam & he took purest option. So, I will take easier, safer, simpler & purer path. Allah swt knows best. May Allah swt forgive me if I committed any mistake. Ameen Read full analysis of beating wife here... at least read summary...: please see 100s of usage of daraba/drab www.quran434.com/wife-beating-islam.html .

[@totaltrade9147]

ma get skme help

[@azadalishah2966]

@@totaltrade9147 what do u mean?

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications ************* kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@fohasajid2299]

Well written brother, I was just wondering about you mentioning how a prophet SAW has never beaten a women. What about the Hadith mentioned in the video About hazrar Aisha RA feeling pain after being hit on the chest

[@azadalishah2966]

@Momyla Farooq JazakiAllah but don’t deserve much. I just conveyed message I learnt :)

[@mdrommankhan741]

He is saying "Did u get my answer?" & after that he is again saying " I am not completed my answer yet "

[@familytube6401]

Brother i think uh dint understand his statement . He was telling have uh understood the 1st part of the question. Then he sayss i am not completed my answer. Hope so uh are clear😊

[@fallacyyy]

The question was divided in two, and he answered the first part and just want to reinsure. That’s why he asked if he got the answer

[@mdrommankhan741]

@@familytube6401 bro I am not talking only about this video. There are many video where Jakir Naik acted same. And I am a doctor but I dont support the way Jakir Naik say he is a doctor & he knows better. He always said this thing so arrogantly. I agreed that he is a good man & he has blessing of Allah. But this kind of behaviour will not bring any good for him & this is proven. He is now prohibited from giving lecture & living a life with the permission of other countries president.

[@familytube6401]

@@mdrommankhan741 brother there is allah who knw better then us. He know who is wrong or right. I accept tht zakir naik speak sometime arrogantly but brother his speech says the truth

[@Animeow08]

Edward Lim you are so blinded by hate that you have no objective perception to comprehend someone’s explanation. Pathetic pigs

[@betterourselves]

Thank you

[@MohammedLathiwala]

Why do I feel that he ran away? Cause what the phrase said clearly meant that Aisha has never seen a believer woman this beat up. So believer women were beaten at that time. To an extent that they were bruised badly. What Aisha saw must be much more severe to comment on it. However, her statement was so general that it seems normal until she was surprised by the severe beat up. May be at that time people were still changing and Islam was established but people were not easily changed and patience was needed.

[@realilmikitabiengineermuha4364]

MashaAllah... dr zakir naik has guts to thwarted these kind of Questions with reason logic n science... MashaAllah

[@compassioniseverything4262]

Quran in a sentence : "Do whatever you want but strongly believe in Allah, your place is reserved in Jannah"

[@GamingZone-ql4fi]

How does heaven and hell matter only thing which matters is our perspective people can stay happy in hell and stay sad in heaven

[@mohammednaqhid8706]

Masha Allah superb 👌👌👌👌

[@toma6358]

Zakir does not answer directly. First he thought the Shekar was easy game. When thing went tough the assistant comes and asks Shekar not to take too much time. Just remembering a lot of references does not make one a scholar. This is a lesson to all speakers.

[@sheikhu1039]

I wonder how they're convo turned out

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation ********* kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@Oreoking2410]

A real man should not even get to the point of having to strike his wife.

[@elfranko97]

A Real Woman should not even get with her behaviour to the point where that is necessary for the man. She must obey him and he must respect her. You know common sense, love, respect each other....

[@iamhuman7900]

@@elfranko97 if he does not respect her why would she for him

[@elfranko97]

@@chemnpsych thats wrong. The Woman Must obey to her man. The man obeys only to god. Both have to live a religious life.

[@halimagarba5068]

I believe dey should have respect for each other in order to live a peaceful relationship

[@elfranko97]

@@crystalkandys5169 that’s wrong only the woman obeys to the man. Because that’s what is written and because the man ist the head of the family. You are making assumptions. Of course he can’t say to her everything and if her man says to her she has to do something haram of course she can say no

[@yasmineali9862]

As a muslim, I'm disappointed with this answer. Men are not necessarily always right when arguing, them what makes him automatically granted the opportunity to "warn" and "beat her lightly"? What makes the woman have to bare the pain of someone else? Especially when females are more delicate in nature, and men more dominant/stronger, beating can be painful, no matter how light, and can get worse by time. This is pure physical abuse.

[@Vishal-lu1jc]

Beating is not a solution of problem. It is like to spress the voice of that person. If she is wrong tell her appropriate reasons and take her back to right way. If you cannot tell her reasons.Accept it she is right. Beating required just in exceptional cases like when without beating a person can loose his/her life.😇😇😇 (love Allah)

[@saaem6900]

Yaeh dr Zakir naik said so, first we tell her reason and take her back in right way in very last case when she can't understand truth, then u just slightly beat very slowly.

[@andreeaboloca4440]

The verse about biting comes after the ones about cheating ....so no,a man can not beat up his wife ...but if she cheats then his small sin of reacting may be forgiven ...that's all...

[@mansibisht6768]

Lol it's in no way right...and I have seen him comparing big bang with quranic theory which is again wrong.😅

[@andreeaboloca4440]

@@mansibisht6768 the big bang compared to the way was the earth made (he did not compare it with the Quran) as per the Quran it is actually quite simple to understand why would it be similar ,whether you like that or not ...

[@andreeaboloca4440]

@@mansibisht6768 but please tell me your own belief matches it at all 🤦‍♀️😅

[@ambersherwani262]

Allah is great

[@TrendChaser2050]

You don't have to belittle the questioner so much while answering his questions, dr Zakir Naik.

[@awesomeboy23]

he is belittling the question because it deserves to belittle....and the questioner got full time after session to fulfill all his questions

[@awesomeboy23]

@profaker according to your self hating mind.....other than that he is simply the best 😊

[@awesomeboy23]

Haha and according to your mind billions of people in this world are jokers and this planet is the magical ball 😊

[@toobaaaapi]

How exactly did he belittle the questioner??? He was asking questions and not even letting him complete the answer... You couldn't find anything wrong with his answer so you said, "oh his manner was not right" please come on...

[@jcee1770]

He did not belittle him he was given him knowledge on the situation. May allah swt protects dr zakir naik and grant him the highest jannah such a knowledgeable brother

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

ومن تعلق بهذا العالم سيعاني حقًا من خسارة عظيمة

[@alexandrajames8270]

I haven’t even gotten past the first 5 minutes. Why would you smack your kid? You explain to them that they’re not superman and why they can’t jump, then take them away from the situation

[@muhammadwijaya5635]

I've never heard such nonsensical bullshit, in order to justify beating a woman. The fact is, it is wrong to beat a woman, plain and simple, and the verse that permits it should be unconditionally condemned.

[@surabenshaban1160]

no where in the quran is a man allowed to beat a woman, the aya in the quran refers to a tap like motion and it is not allowed to be out of anger nor should it leave a mark on the body

[@zesrabtanjeelkhan377]

@@surabenshaban1160 Brother, the problem is people are complaining because they didn't really listen properly. What part was it mentioned beat your wife? They are just too blind by their hate

[@VOLTRON999]

DR ZAKIR NAIK = A LIVING LEGEND just like his master teacher his highness DR SHEIKH AHMED DEEDAT

[@meitanteiconan5971]

@@byteme9718 what happened to defeat was a test of god. He passed it alhumdulillah or I hope so you'll never understand

[@meitanteiconan5971]

@@byteme9718 theres no evidence that god doesnt exist. And also no atheist can prove how we came to existence. God is the only plausible story

[@meitanteiconan5971]

@@byteme9718 science cant prove what's beyond the universe can it? Similarly it cant prove the existence of god neither can it prove it WRONG. Its unambiguous neither right or wrong according to science. Rather prove how we came to existence if god doesnt exist

[@meitanteiconan5971]

@@byteme9718 lol it's not a silly book or false claims. Rather it is an error free book given to the prophet muhammad (saw) who was illiterate he cant write that book. Also science still cannot prove how the big bang happened it just says it happened but It can never prove how it happened. No science can explain how we came into existence. You say there are many other plausible stories. Ok agreed but this one is the most true as the revelation of the book itself is a miracle and it has proved many things right

[@meitanteiconan5971]

@@byteme9718 nah. God is just the god of gaps. The story of the quran is the logical and true one. There are countless signs to prove that it is true. As you said science is the total human learning, humans do not have the capability to understand God completely and the heaven hell and universe etc, but the quran is the word of God god knows everything. Even quran has so many scientific verses. For example the fact that the sun spins on its axis was mentioned in the Quran which was revealed 1400 years before science discovered that the sun spins on it's own axis. Quran said this before science discovered it it clearly proves this is not a book written by humans.

[@akramlabib7040]

Brilliant answer

[@nargisneda9782]

Its obvious that Islam is the only right religion but if we remove the name of Omar abubakr Usman and ayesha...

[@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45]

⚠️The Prophet P.B.U.H said “Verily, the bankrupt of my nation are those who come on the Day of Resurrection with prayers, fasting, and charity, but also with insults, slander, consuming wealth, shedding blood, and beating others. The oppressed will each be given from his good deeds. If his good deeds run out before justice is fulfilled, then their sins will be cast upon him and he will be thrown into the Hellfire.” Sahih Muslim 🔥🔥🔥 😱 🔥🔥🔥

[@jameswohley3332]

@@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45 what about Umar Ibn Al Khattab he has slapped and burnt the house of Fatimah (RA) the daughter of Prophet PBUH in order to get Allegiance from Fatimah's husband Ali Ibn Abi Talib (RA) is he not going to Hell ??

[@nxbeelyt7336]

@@jameswohley3332 there were 2 umar my brother💖👍

[@jameswohley3332]

@@nxbeelyt7336 yeah i know and im talking about Umar Ibn Al Khattab brother

[@nargisneda9782]

@Yousuf Iqbal I don't wanna hurt anyone but better to got more information about our religion if you got time do alittle search. It doesn't change my life if you muslim or even in some other religion.

[@mushtaqueahmad7532]

Dr. You are great. We pray for you.MAY ALLAH GIVE YOU LONG LIFE, PUT YOU IN JANNAH.

[@richardbranche8873]

Imagine your misbehaving wife is going to change her ways when you beat her with a toothbrush, pencil or handkerchief . Why don't you beat your children with the same things? After all the children should not suffer more than an adult. So if the toothbrush, pencil and handkerchief can change the wife then it can more than change the children. These lying teachers are trying hard to defend their lying prophet.

[@supernatural_forces]

@@richardbranche8873 No, its true. Kindness, forgiveness, mercy, patience, etc. are preferred over fighting & avenging as a general rule.

[@jeebund]

HE is clearly stating that men and women are not equal.....

[@anonymousneko7908]

Hey. Being fair does not always mean equal. As he said. *if a women is doing a bad thing* 1. Warn her ->if she dont listen 2. Dont sleep with her. Avoid her >if she dont listen 3. Husban can lightly flick her using either miswak or handkerchief. *If a husband do wrong* 1. Warn him-> if he dont listen 2. Protest by objecting things. (Sleep separately is ok too) Why female cant flick her husband? Because men is stronger physically. If female flick her husband, what if the husband het mad and punch her? Its a tendency for men to do that 💁 well not all. But some men do have ego.

[@faqirahabdullah1364]

@julie andrews its you who does not know anything about the real teachings of the peaceful religion of Islam yet talking about moralities..not even a single obscen word in the holly Quran..get educate and throw away your dark spectacle!

[@ayeshahussain1986]

@@anonymousneko7908 makes sense 😋

[@gundamn17]

@julie andrews lol thats funny because Islam gives more importance to women than men. If you were paying attention to the video, Zakir clearly says your daughters have the power to take you to Paradise and the son do not. Read the Islamic religion first with an unbiased approach and trust me you'll be surprised.

[@CathyKitson]

@@anonymousneko7908 So what are you saying? That it's OK if you hit someone weaker than you because they can't defend themselves and won't hit back? But it's not OK to hit someone stronger? Do you realise how wonky that sounds?

[@rubayetapon2710]

Great explanation

[@zaynab4991]

I can't imagine the damage this scholar has done to so many women by justifying the wrong things by wrong examples.

[@drReetHooda]

True. I checked on Google just to have proof... Google says there are more men than women...In America the percentage of women is higher but globally there are more men in ratio. So that means every woman can be married easily to a man without being PUBLIC PROPERTY which I think the term he has used is extremely deteriorating because so many women these days don't want to be married because of the fear of being cheated on and I think it's terrible to say that a woman will be public's property when she doesn't need to belong to anyone. There were times when women were not secure financially as well as physically but I think any woman is capable to live a life on her own if she wants to.

[@zaynab4991]

@@drReetHooda Can't agree more ! Women were made companions not a property.... that's makes a huge difference. Thank you for sharing this info. Jazakallah !

[@TheNordicBrotherhood]

@@drReetHooda he did mention that in some countries where female infanticide is prevalent the ratio is different. India and China especially. These countries also have the largest populations. Optimally there would be no female infanticides at all, and the the ratio would end up being more women on average.

[@multipurpose6984]

@@zaynab4991 capitalize the first letter of Allah in JazakAllah by editing ur comment and just take care of that always

[@multipurpose6984]

What do you mean to say?

[@Ashhh145]

Now that statement isn’t true... most men fear their wife’s more than they do from their husbands 😂

[@AmitKumar-gj5jg]

Right😂😂😂

[@ayshaamin3552]

Then you’re a good man but not a lot of men fear their wives!

[@SarwarHBK]

he misunderstood the meaning of beleiving woman. by beleiving woman Hazrat Ayesha RA meant same women who came to complain.

[@meghinrocourt7518]

Beleiving woman means : women who have submitted themselves to Allah.

[@peakjvs4967]

@@meghinrocourt7518 It was just a matter of time before one showed up and generalized and took everything out of context.

[@waleed87680]

Dr. Zakir was mistaken in citing the correct reference to the verse in Surah Maryam Chapter 19. It is verse 20 and not verse 47. Please make the correction in the video. May Allah be pleased with us!

[@kwabenagyaukyei3179]

NO ONE IS SUPPOSED TO BEAT HIS OR HER PARTNER, PERIOD ! THIS IS NOT A TOPIC THAT SHOULD BE DISCUSSED IN A CIVILIZED SOCIETY. IF TWO PEOPLE, WHO HAVE OVER A PERIOD OF TIME REACHED A POINT WHERE THEY CANNOT LIVE TOGETHER ANYMORE, THE BEST THING FOR THE TWO IS TO PART WAYS. AS SIMPLE AS THAT. DON'T RAISE THIS BARBARIC TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION. IT IS JUST TOO PRIMITIVE AND THE TOPIC TELLS A LOT ABOUT YOUR BACKGROUND.

[@hsn-20]

You know you're when dr says good question.

[@sufiyanfarooqui3797]

😂 😂

[@sanghalhriamapa]

🤣🤣🤣

[@fayezabhaiyat7198]

😂😂

[@called-matii]

he says that just to calm the audience down, it's a way to make it look like you are on top of a argument or debate

[@muhammadalifarooqui1948]

Dr.zakir Sahab is not ignoring him. He is just telling the rules. He always gives very easy and detailed answers. He is awesome. Mashaaallah. 👍

[@jo-wx2wd]

I love islam and I try to follow it dearly. As a muslim we believe that if we live our life according to sunnah = the way prophet lead his life- full stop. Again I will say; THE WAY HE LEAD HIS LIFE- full stop. How may times he lightly beat his wife. ZERO, ZILCH, NADA, DIDLY SQUAT. This lightly beating is an option and not a compulsion, more over the last of the 2. And the disobedience is not that she has put extra salt in the food but some serious kind of disobedience. The prophet PBUH when he used to give his sermons, people used to sit hunched over with lowered gaze and all ears. It was described as if birds are sitting on them and they don't want to move as they may fly away. And the wives some times would question or argue with prophet PBUH. Arabs used to bury their daughters alive before islam came and subhanAllah , Islam gave them rights of inheritance, right to choose their spouse. Paradise was promised to them if they raise their daughters in a good way. I am afraid Dr Zakir Naik (he is an excellent scholar) could not explain it properly. Prophet Muhammad PBUH said: ' The best among you is the one who is good to his family'. Wallah o alam.

[@ahjeee1992]

Haha from seeing some of the comments, I realized It's very difficult to infuse the thought of "wife-beating" in this modern age due to the whole rave about "equality". Personally, I found that what Dr Zakir Naik said is absolutely logical on how the beating of wife lightly is symbolic, and more importantly, he also mentions how if man and woman just started physically beating each other then the problem cannot be solved (with a hilarious example of Arnold Schwarzenegger). To put in on context of the modern world, if an organization starts saying everyone has equal rights (CEOs, Stakeholders, managers, staffs) in terms of the roles and responsibilities just imagine the disaster waiting to happen in that organization. Similarly, I think, the point is, both men and women have different roles and they need each other to live on. Islam, is that perfect example/guide on how we should live life. One shouldn't just assume, that Muslims young or old, are beating their wives up. Sure, there a number of rotten apples among the Muslims who badly bruise their wives in a haram manner, but hey, similarly, rotten apples exists in other cultures too. I can go on and on about the violence in the west, but I choose not to because I have a couple of western friends who are absolutely perfect in their virtues; it'll be wrong to judge the west based on those rotten apples. Do remember we're one of the largest religion in the world, these rotten apples are bound to exist in such a huge group of peace lovers.

[@demeter7456]

There is no "haram" or "halal" way of beating, abuse is abuse, and that's disgusting.. u probably don't even know what gender equality now days debates ( which is insane), abuse to innocent ppl is an non negotiable incident, if ppl justify it , then society is corrupted

[@TigasFMS]

Sorry man but you're trying to justify something that is not justifiable or rational. You're pretty much saying women are inferior if you admit a man can beat her but the woman can't beat the man. There's ALOT of stuff that Islam defends that I agree, believe me. However, we need to question things and the fact there's an "etiquette" on how to beat a woman is very concerning. I'm not a feminist, nor pro-LGBT or stuff like that but this is one of the things that is indefensible and that muslims will always try and fail to justify .

[@ahjeee1992]

Ah. I wanted to ignore the replies here because any argument made will result in a loop/debate of an unfound basis of "equality". Anyways, to the both of you geniuses who replied me, yes, abuse is bad. Everybody knows that. You don't abuse anyone, man or women. It's a given. However, you're losing the main point here. A system where man and women shares the same spot in terms of leading the family, becomes very difficult to manage. So Islam, teaches us the roles of man and women. They're not equal. Period. The women has rights which man has to honor. The man has rights which women has to honor. It's a clear system to run your family. Now regarding, the abuse, as mentioned, we're not allowed to physically harm women.. The point made was that it's symbolic, and, Dr Zakir Naik already explained why it's symbolic. I don't have to repeat that.

[@adamgillespie3393]

@@ahjeee1992 forgive me if I'm asking to much but, why is this the best way of running a family? Where a man is the main power and the woman is secondary. I know many households that are very happy without these rules of gender inequality.

[@ahjeee1992]

@@adamgillespie3393 hey man. No worries. I think it's a very sensible question. A question which should be posed to a knowledgeable scholar. However, here are my thoughts. Honestly, I know a number of households too whom are very happy with the idea of equality as a basis of their relationship. However, often, at least from personal experience, I hear alot of unnecessary friction in how they should run the family. In an analogy, it's like 2 captains trying to steer away from an ice berg, one says he wants to go left, another says she wants to go right. If one of the captain managed to convince the other, they would barely miss the ice berg. Else, they will hit the ice berg. In a real world example, often I hear about how the man wants a child and he's afraid his wife will get too old to conceive. The wife is afraid that it'll affect her career progression (and she's right to be afraid) and that becomes a reason for her not to conceive or maybe conceive at a later time. You'll see many surveys online where women in this modern age prioritizes career over having a child. Now the problem here is, though it's the man whom wants the child, no matter how much he tries he can't bear a child. Only a women can. So the man unfortunately, won't be able to fulfill the role of a women who can bear a child, and have to wait for the women to be either be convinced by him or be convinced by her career progression. Sure there are many households in which the men and women are both working adults and have children. But they must have worked really hard to make it work. They narrowly "missed the ice berg". As for clearly defined roles, where, the ship has only 1 captain. It's easier to run the family or "steer the ship". Of course however, many rotten scums (let's not call them man cause they're not real man) have abused this.

[@wakeelaryan9694]

With the help of Allah, the blessing of Allah and the knowledge of Holly Qur'an and Sahi Hadith there is no question that may not be answered by Dr Zakir Naik. May Allah grand him Jannah and long life.

[@SilentValley2023]

Then he said: “I am Joseph your brother, whom you sold into Egypt. 5 But now, do not therefore be grieved or angry with yourselves because you sold me here; for God sent me before you to preserve life. 6 For these two years the famine has been in the land, and there are still five years in which there will be neither plowing nor harvesting. 7 And God sent me before you to preserve a posterity for you in the earth, and to save your lives by a great deliverance. 8 So now it was not you who sent me here, but God; and He has made me a father to Pharaoh, and lord of all his house, and a ruler throughout all the land of Egypt. Genesis 45:5-8 Do not be discouraged no matter what you go through, keep the faith like Joseph even in hard times and God will deliver you as long you keep doing the right thing even when its hard and even when the culture says its not "cool". His brothers sold him into slavery, then he was cast into prison for being a just man and not sleeping with his masters wife who turned on him, to being promoted to ruler over the whole house of Egypt. MORAL OF THE STORY: Never give up on God! He will never give up on you! He leaves the 99 to come find you in the wilderness. Keep the Faith Always NO MATTER THE CIRCUMSTANCES. These days Satan is trying to get everybody living in fear so he can try to control us. Don't Buy into it. There's a lot of deception out here. You were bought with a price that JESUS paid for. Give your life to him and he will protect you and shelter you from all darkness and fear. He gives you PEACE that no one or anything else is able to. "These things I have spoken to you, that in Me you may have peace. In the world you will have tribulation; but be of good cheer, I have overcome the world.” John 16:33 "Through the tender mercy of our God, With which the Dayspring from on high has visited us; To give light to those who sit in darkness and the shadow of death, To guide our feet into the way of peace.” Luke 1:78-79 "Peace I leave with you, My peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I give to you. Let not your heart be troubled, neither let it be afraid." John 14:27

[@hazzafullysick9899]

I REALLY RESPECT THIS DR HE IS VERY KNOWLEDGEABLE .

[@yourebeautiful9169]

Allahu Akbar Subhan Allah Mashaallah الله اكبر سبحان الله ما شاء الله❤️🤲❤️

[@comictube1831]

Love the person shekhar very enlightening questions 👍👍

[@nazrul_islam88]

"আপনি কি ভেবেছিলেন যে আমরা আপনাকে কোনও উদ্দেশ্য ছাড়াই সৃষ্টি করেছি?" #কুরআন ২৩: ১১৫। নবী মুহাম্মদ (ﷺ) বলেন... "এই পৃথিবীতে এমনভাবে থাকুন যেন আপনি কোনও অচেনা বা ভ্রমণকারী হন।" #সহীহ_আল_বুখারী ৬৪১৬। #হাদিস #ইসলামেরদৃষ্টি

[@rumibadar8023]

What is the punishment in islam for a husband who beats his wife seriously causing injuries

[@BKeny007]

How did he not finish his answer when he asked the gentleman if that answered his question... I really respect how smart and well spoken that man is. But he really needs to work on his humility

[@sluggishhollow2030]

I m sorry but don't u even know the rules of basic communication?Supposed u asked me a question and the explanation of that question is big.Suppose I would need 10-12 mins to answer that question and there is a high chance that u won't be focused on my explanation the entire time.I am answering u and after 5 mins i say "Are u following u?".That means I want to know if u are listening to me.That doesn’t mean that I am done.That's a basic rule of communication.The man here asked another question about that verse.So the answer was incomplete without that verse.That's how hard it is for us to deal with prejudiced people like u.Always jumping at people without even doing the tinniest bit of thinking

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more explanation *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@Ankitsingh-my1vu]

I just come to hear him,because as i am growing and learning about religion each day i feel blessed that i am not born in a muslim family. Thanks Zakir Naik for that

[@vijaybala7813]

Once here to sadh guru

[@abdussahir]

Mind be opened

[@AmitKumar-gj5jg]

Right bro

[@resalatansari4636]

First time, I m not agree with Zakir sir. Aadmi physical ho sakta h but aurat hogi to galat h and man will left him. Physical takat h aadmi mei isliye wo physical ho sakta h. Zakir sir hurt hua y sunke wo bhi aap k explaination mei.

[@sayedarif7]

Sister pls watch the video again until you get the point he's making this time don't have a feminist perspective just have a neutral state of mind

[@resalatansari4636]

Jaane to mere Bhai Muslim mei Aurat ko sabse bada martaba Diya h ye sirf aur sirf bolne ki baat h😢

[@abdirashidabdi693]

Like your speech sir

[@cutesamiha8718]

I don't understand the example that he gave that 'what if your daughter slaps you?" there's a difference between father and daughter and a husband and wife i still don't get it.

[@Mirackaanmedguy]

What I understand is , this beating from husband to wife is symbolic beat not physically and if womens do same to mans then it could hurt mans proud ( though mans are physically stronger than womans dr zaik compared it with massive bodybuilder and normal man) and mans can physically beat womans because they can actually do it.

[@cutesamiha8718]

@@Mirackaanmedguy Wtf...?

[@n451a]

There is a difference in position/hierarchy within the family between a husband and wife. This is something that is not understood in our modern world. The man/husband is the head/boss of the family. The wife is his subordinate. If she is righteous and obeys and pleases her husband, it will be said to her, "Enter through whichever gate of paradise you wish." Such is not the case for the man. We are on Earth with different roles, each with different tests and trials which ultimately signify obedience to Allah's Command for which we are rewarded.

[@KS-cl8br]

@@n451a Women should marry men who will respect them.

[@parmdeepjagdev8395]

See how Naik avoids the question and begins questioning the man and starts talking in a manner that confuses us and we forget the question. The sad bit is that Islam doesn’t really respect women. Yes it provides protection, but this means being controlled by men. The man is always right. So it’s ok to beat the wife. Violence isn’t just physical. It can be mental. Zakir admits that women are unequal to men.

[@aseriesofvideos]

Islam is proven by Harvard to be the number 1 best book for justice. See the thing is in Islam compared to other religions historically has more rights for women. In the bible a women is to stay quiet and obey her husband, it is even disrespectful for a women to talk in a church, theres even a debate in christianity whether a woman has a soul! I'm a woman, so of course you as a man know so much about me.

[@gauravbhatta8129]

Parmdeep you are absolutely right!!

[@aseriesofvideos]

@@MohammadAsif-tu2os exactly, it's the fact people dont know that the original language of the Quran was arabic! People just try to find anything wrong, and it's embarrassing. Good for you for being factual.

[@MohammadAsif-tu2os]

@@aseriesofvideos Also, most of muslim ppl follow their preachers blindly 🤦‍♂. Trying to correct them is like banging your head in the wall! They don't care even if it sounds disgraceful to Prophet Muhammad ( peace be upon him) and Islam! They are busy trying defending their preachers while putting Islam at stake.

[@ayan_akua7.588]

@Chanchal rai they can never be equal because Allah never created them equal

[@megakida12]

SubhanaAllah I was just thinking about this the other day

[@SHEREAHLEHADEES]

👍👍

[@grimawormtongue8993]

Hello fellow Indıan brothers. I couldn't figure out whom he speaks of at 7:24 because of the thick accent. Whose quotes are the following parts?

[@Rahila2323]

Those quotes are from Ibn Abbas who was one of the early Quran scholars . He was the paternal cousin of Prophet (p.b.u.h.) .

[@grimawormtongue8993]

@@Rahila2323 no, no. I meant the quotes that came after Ibn Abbas. the miswak quote.

[@Rahila2323]

@@grimawormtongue8993 yes brother it's ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with him). He gave an example of miswak

[@Rahila2323]

Firstly Dr.Zakir gives the verse from Surah An Nisa and then the quote from ibn Abbas (May Allah be pleased with him) Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with him, said: ضَرْبًا غَيْرَ مُبَرِّحٍ It is a striking without severity. It was askd, “What is a striking without severity?” Ibn Abbas (May Allah be pleased with him) said: بِالسِّوَاكِ وَنَحْوِهِ It is with a toothstick or something similar. Source: Tafsīr al-Ṭabarī 4:34

[@grimawormtongue8993]

@@Rahila2323 thank you so much brother. It's hard to understand the Indian accent when you're from Turkey, we sound like a mix of Russian and French unfortunately 😅 thank you

[@shohratiqbal4395]

Getting angry on husband is not allowed 🤔 that is not fair though

[@shawon6339]

who said its not allowed?! even maa ayesha sometimes get angry with our pyara prophet

[@weirdosarecool8653]

Dude, you can disagree with your husband. But you cannot hit him. If he abuses you, then you have the right to stand up for yourself. But if you hit him just because of an argument, then you're in the wrong.

[@mrgrenade3709]

Of course it is allowed

[@AR25326]

Its allowed…

[@augilaar7420]

Now thats what u call a question. Well done! may your heart Re concoil to truth :D

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@Rya_05]

13:15 Well explained 👏👏👏 Barakallah feek🤲🤲

[@aishwaryauzayrqaiskhan9078]

U Muslim with Hindu name?

[@sarahjeanty8015]

It's good he's asking questions I would do the same. I'm a converted muslim.

[@Crypto-Vision1]

Love জাকির নায়েক 💖💖💖

[@movieshots790]

I think Dr zakir should not be annoyed with this guy's question or counter questions......

[@hemantd9349]

Also, look how condescending Dr was with the guy who was asking question.

[@neutralcommentor3742]

First he says ask me any number of counter questions. Then he says that don’t ask me any questions. Such a loser Zakir Naik is.

[@mrmu3448]

Who recognised the guy behind the one asking question lol

[@Mayahomok]

There is no beating of the woman in the Quran. watch the video for more applications *********** kzbin.info/www/bejne/laLMgoBqZtt_bs0

[@youssefmkaouar4165]

amazing