Shershah's Hot Takes On Islamic Wars And History!

[@_titanslayer_]

Books I have quoted in this podcast: (33) Books: 1. Griffel, The formation of post classical philosophy in Islam 2. Adamson, The Heirs of Avicenna 3. Zaman, Islam in Pakistan 4. Tareen, Perilous intimacies 5. Attas, Islam and secularism 6. Hallaq , The impossible state 7. Saliba, Islamic sciences and the making of European Renaissance 8. Braumoeller, Only the dead 9. Holland, Dominion the making of the western mind 10. FRANKOPAN, Silk Roads: a new history of the world 11. Collier, Great mughals and their India 12. Balabanlalisar, Imperial identities in Mughal empire 13. Harari, Sapiens 14. Pinker, Enlightenment Now 15. Graeber, The dawn of everything a new history of humanity 16. Robinson, The ulama of Farangi Mahal 17. Bousquet, The scientific way of warfare 18. Heinrich, The weirdest people in the world how the West became psychologically peculiar and economically prosperous 19. Foucault, Discipline and punish 20. Ingram, Revival from below Deoband and global Islam 21. Robert Hoyland, were the early Arab conquests the same as Eileen co 22. Ed. Zohar Zion, Sephardic And Mizrahi jewry 23. M Cohen, Under the cross and Crescent 24. Marshalls, John Lock toleration in early enlightenment culture 25. Graeber, There never was a waste or democracy emerges from the spaces in between 26. Lusordo, Liberalism counter history 27. Massad, Islam in liberalism 28. Hallaq, Origins and evolution of Islamic law 29. El Shamsy, The colonisation of Islamic law 30. Davies, Europe history 31. Schmitt, Political theology 32. Tallet,War and Society in Early Modern Europe 33. War and Peace in Islam

[@aliahmed79]

No muzamil zadi was hurt in this comment

[@rsahmed1527]

Great effort

[@huzaifah03]

@@aliahmed79 "SHAH"

[@rsahmed1527]

Is there any of them available in urdu😌

[@rsahmed1527]

Is there any of them available in urdu😌

[@ZHB_Javaid]

"If you want to avoid a Western style secularization, marry your cousins. All of them." -Aman

[@shifa6874]

😂

[@MohdAnas-wd7bl]

Hahaha Pajeet go Shit somewhere else​@@Rahulprajapati79-k2g

[@MohdAnas-wd7bl]

go shit somewhere else Lindu​@@Rahulprajapati79-k2g

[@hasin7j]

Got to know about shershah through eon live, and im a fan now. Always wanted to read books related to philosophy, but i didn't know where to start. He was the guy who suggested me. ❤️

[@muhammadanas_here]

Please write down them =]

[@_titanslayer_]

1:57:10 I’ve quoted 32 books in this podcast. I’ll share the list soon. :) Thank you for having me. Had a wonderful time. 🙏

[@maaz9699]

Bro playing chess, while they play checkers.

[@MalikAbdullah-je9cp]

Syed Muzammil Shah would be proud.

[@cosmos0909]

Mashallah Brother 🤓

[@shifa6874]

That would be great

[@H.A-Phoenix1]

@@_titanslayer_ thanks Shershah, looking forward to seeing the list!

[@mariambatool2852]

Shershah gave a serious answer to every humorous question😂

[@Hurizai]

Sherhsha should also read a book on sarcasm 😂

[@syedumar7066]

One of the best podcasts youve had

[@ZHB_Javaid]

"Hindutva ziddi nahi hai pagal hai" - Aman 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@H.A-Phoenix1]

It’s Pleasant to see Shershah here otherwise I stopped following EON. Wael Hallaq and Naqib Attas are two most important authors to learn from, in post modern era as their philosophy helps orient oneself as a Muslim.

[@atikaikram-p7v]

Impressed Shershah knows Sayed Naqeb Alatass. People follow Shershah's channel and journey this guy will go far. Proud of you man.

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

As a huge admirer of Professor Halak, I believe you ought to have him on your English podcast. His book, The Impossible State, is excellent; you ought to bring him. I've read it. You ought to have him on your show; he has some really intriguing ideas.

[@syedzaid5771]

I think 'Restating Orientalism' is more insightful.

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

@@syedzaid5771 I agree 💯 Shah g but I thought because this book was mentioned in the video I should reference it.

[@H.A-Phoenix1]

“Reforming Modernity” is also not to be missed.

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

​@@H.A-Phoenix1 dude, do you have a link or something because I couldn't get that book ???

[@H.A-Phoenix1]

@@mmekalmashhadi5467 sorry, I hv a hard copy of it.

[@H.A-Phoenix1]

From 1 hr 30 min onwards Sherhshah is patiently waiting for Aman to come back from food land to “History Philosophy & Politics” But Aman is like we can do that all through food history 😁. Finally Aman gave it an Islamic touch also ..

[@munnaza23]

What a pleasure to have a young chap like shershah. Such a well read person and an insightful talk he has given especially about the europeans.

[@maryamcheema2626]

Wooow. Wasn't expecting titanslayer to be here. But what a pleasent surprise. ❤️

[@lightning_gamerz6359]

A series of talks can be started over his recommendation of books By Eon boys do consider

[@shifa6874]

Thank you for introducing such gem💎 کتابیں پڑھنے کے لیے زبردست کیٹلاگ مل گیا😁

[@ayeshanazirb]

I don't know why people dislike it when Amaan interrupts the guests. I like the way he always tries to prove his point. Obviously, this is a podcast, and the conversation has to be two-way. I really enjoyed Amaan's analysis and arguments more than SherShah's.

[@notzul7138]

My man! Wizard books! The Booklord 📚 bro eats a book with cover in his breakfast casually

[@maaz9699]

Really liked this one. I want you both to host a separate series discussing these topics related to Muslim empires and other empires at large. Basically discussing their civil structures and interactions between those societies. It will be phenomenally successful. If you guys can title them with some history buzzwords like names of famous figures over here. This kind of discussion clearly has a market, case in point dekho suno jano and furqan qureshi. But I would advise it to be more like a documentary-style podcast, with better visuals. And more importantly, the displaying of books, cause it has a more deeper effect on a layperson in regards to the authenticity. Historical amnesia of wars immediately before the colonization, and even during colonization is pretty crazy. Like people legit say the West won because our side had swords and they had guns. It trivializes their 100-year effort to take over India. And by extention trivilizes us. Do it!

[@lightning_gamerz6359]

Surely they should If any from eon team going through this written please do make sure to start a series over this request

[@thepigeoninsider]

Agreed

[@maheen99khan]

LOOOVEDDDD YOUR PODCAST!!! PLEASE BRING MORE!

[@doit7779]

Great MashAllah.. keep it up and aware the people regarding the islamic history and the truth.

[@UstadMulan]

OMG! Shershah is here❤

[@GamingWorld-c9u]

who is Shershah

[@danishMalik_]

Aman bhai tried to divert the conversation many times but shershah was just keen to get back to where he was. I just loved this continuous tug of war between them both.❤

[@m.hassan8145]

No way u finally did it ❤the titans slayer is in the area 🎉

[@omarrana09]

1:16:39 editer: no we won't 🤣😂

[@NoorAfzaaa]

Ahhh! Finally. 🎉

[@qadir21200]

Eon you never disappointed us,always invited the people we want and also discuss the topic that the need.....Thank you🥺✨

[@husnainumar2451]

Finally my hero,Get him on live aswell

[@kook.vengeance]

Man I’ve been waiting on him to show up on eon. Shershah is good guy

[@maxCarnag3]

Salam. Good talk. The two of you have a good dynamic. Shershah can keep on track despite all the "distractions" 😊. JazakAllah kher. Fee Amaan Allah.

[@umerjavednisar]

Was waiting for this for a while

[@MSAHNWN5EMNSSSAKY]

Vikings were finished when they came to fight the Muslims in Spain

[@Mohdaguj]

Oh ja pudhi k 😂 onho ne spain ko tun k lota tha

[@munnaza23]

Also enjoyed Aman's habit of getting carried away vs sherhsah's composure 😂😊

[@shahbazkhan-ek7hp]

No way Bruh said skibbidi toilet🤣

[@maddybbboy]

May Allah give him barakah. Due to him i finished a book called lost Islamic history by firas al khateeb. For many this wouldn't be mind-blowing, but for me who wanted to finish a book for 2 years and couldn't due to notes taking. Shershah suggested not to take notes when you are a beginner book reader.

[@S-sufiman]

45:03 can someone please explain MEHNA?

[@mohammadmustafeez11]

Ye wo period tha Abbasids k dor main jis main mutazilites ki doctrine ko enforce krne k liye scholars pr zulm Kiya Gaya . Ahmad bin hanbal(RH) was one of the victims of this persecution.

[@erikkhan]

Aman is extremely well read and intellectual person who purposely act like a buffon .Its part of his great plan

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

Skibidi sometimes means "dumb" and sometimes means "cool." It can also be used in the meaning "bad, ". It also means silly when you say this gives me skibidi vibes or I am in a skibidi mood.

[@BhaiJaano]

BEST GUEST SPEAKER AFTER SAHIL BHAI 🎉

[@shahzadmalik96]

Excellent podcast. Just a couple of points to add. Islam presents a superior model of society by bonding them on an ideological basis. This is greater than any tribal or nationalistic bond. Another point here is about the apparent separation of executive from the jurisprudential (ulema and Sufis). I think that the correct way to view it is that this was part of the single state. The day the state vanished, the effectiveness of these ulema and Sufis vanished. So it was part and parcel of the same system. As for the scholarship in islam being a loose framework, I would suggest you go to a madrassa even today. There is nothing loose about the hierarchy there. There was an intricate system of succession among ulema at that time and a small glimpse of that exists today.

[@shifa6874]

مدارس بھی ٹھیکیداریوں اور جاگیروں میں تبدیل ہو چکی ہیں پتا نہیں آپکو کہاں وہ glimpse نظر ا گیا۔ باقی کمنٹ سے ایگریڈ ہوں🌝

[@MuhammadAhmed-lc1op]

The "State" did not exist before the French Revolution. Read Wael Hallaq.

[@shahzadmalik96]

@@MuhammadAhmed-lc1op you mean the state in it's modern form (secular, freedoms, legal positivism etc.)? Agreed. I am talking about the state built by the Prophet SAW, then taken forward by khulafa...

[@MuhammadAhmed-lc1op]

@@shahzadmalik96 I'm saying "State" is the incorrect word to use. The word "state" and the word "governance" are not synonyms. The "State" refers to a centralized, hierarchical structure that claims ultimate sovereignty over a defined territory and population, enforcing its laws through bureaucratic institutions and the monopoly of violence. It is genealogically and thus inherently modern and european.

[@shahzadmalik96]

@@MuhammadAhmed-lc1op Got it, agreed. I was talking about the Islamic state. I don't think the word state itself has that fixed connotation that you specified. But anyway, agreed with your point

[@ranawaleedkhan9846]

Him pointing at shershah and throwing him to the indian audience that hates his lineage was peak comedy 😂

[@shaheerahmad8102]

finally a dude, further on the spectrum, compared to Aman. Hats off to Shershah, may Allah keep you safe.

[@worldmatters7384]

Masha Allah He is on Eon ❤

[@Malik007J]

Shershah❤ one of the most promising intellectuals of Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@muskasaleem7715]

Amagaaaad Shershahhhh is backkkkk

[@luqmankhilji1]

Shershah is well known for those who has the thirst for book reading.

[@cherryboy9396]

2 hours of aman skibidi-ing with shersha😂

[@shortie3398]

Way to go SHERSHAH!!!!??

[@Ayeshathechemist]

Never heard of this man Now i m following you onwards

[@maimunakhan9930]

Finallyyy!! You go sheroooo🫶

[@irumanjum2895]

Great podcast after a long time it was my kind of watch.....aman bhai nai bachae ko bht tang b kia wese..but i guess he knows what he is singing for😂....shersha you are so well read MashAllah. ALLAH bless u always.

[@muhammadfarooq9237]

Please arrange a series of Podcost with Ahmad javed sb

[@Basirat81]

Very deep and intelligent talk.

[@Itsobvs_Kiyara]

Plz invite furqan qureshi in your podcast

[@saliksayyar9793]

Egypt and Ukraine were the two granaries of the ancient world and who ever had those was well set.

[@fayyazahmedramay6287]

شکر ہے پوڈ کاسٹ آگئی۔❤❤❤

[@Moominaaaaaaaaa]

Name of that cooking channel: tasting history with max miller

[@Malik_Zain_Awan]

Din ba din is bat ka ehsas barhta ja rha hai ky log kitny parhy likhy aur samajdar hein aur mein kitna phuddu hun 🫡

[@tariqazeem6540]

Same here bro

[@TareenKhan-re1nw]

Likewise ...

[@tariqazeem6540]

@@Malik_Zain_Awan kitaben parhni parengi

[@Malik_Zain_Awan]

@@tariqazeem6540 ni parhi jati isiliye to podcast sun rha

[@tariqazeem6540]

@@Malik_Zain_Awan btw ma bhi awan hu kahi ye masla hmary DNA ma hi tu nhi

[@darktruths]

No way this is impossible 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 shershah on eon

[@fairykhan9634]

Sher shah.... mashaAllah hats off ❤😊

[@wamiqhamid1388]

Great discussion

[@AroojRajaww]

Wohoooo, my favorite ❤

[@muhammadshahedkhanshawon3785]

The host is very annoying...every time he just interrupts while brother shersha explaining the terms

[@dradilmaher]

Shershah gem from Waziristan ❤

[@huzefahabib1137]

Excelent podcast.. really enjoyed ..tae my words back i said about Sanaullah😂😂

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

Tasting history with Max Miller 1:33:04

[@MSAHNWN5EMNSSSAKY]

The Story Goes that when he came to conquer India and he was fighting Ibrahim Lodi then he promised that Allah if you let me will I will quit alcohol but your one can also be right

[@itznoor7537]

I love to watch him❤

[@Sasuke-bakri]

Our brother "θ shah" You did an amazing job ❤

[@huzaifah03]

Theta Shah???

[@Sasuke-bakri]

@@huzaifah03 haan bhai yahi kaha mai ne 🥲

[@huzaifah03]

@@Sasuke-bakri iska kya matlab hai?

[@Sasuke-bakri]

@@huzaifah03 kion jan'na hai apko?

[@Millathunmain]

@@Sasuke-bakri batao oye

[@Sheenkaaf87]

Masoom shareef bacha amman k hath lag gya..btw interesting sitting... Youth like shershah is need of the hour❤❤❤... from Huge fan of Faloodeh❤❤

[@saliksayyar9793]

In Europe there was divine right of the kings like Shia imamat.

[@abdullahwaseem9134]

When I read title I though Shershah(that subcont ones who defeated mughal king) takes on wars.

[@huzaifah03]

Shershah Suri, Aman k favorite GT Road ka patron

[@salmantahir7559]

Amanullah bhai and shershah 🫡

[@AT25-k3v]

One of my fvrt....❤

[@Abdullah-mh7tj]

hey i cant find the Hazrat Ali hadith where he ate falooda can someone please find it and reply here

[@shifa6874]

مجھے حضرت علی کا تو نہیں پتا لیکن امام ابو حنیفہ اور انکے شاگرد امام ابو یوسف کا ایک واقعہ یاد ہے کہ جب ابو یوسف بچے تھے تو انکی ذہانت علم کا شوق دیکھتے ہوئے انہوں نے انکی والدہ سے درخواست کی تھی کہ اسکو پڑھنے دیں وہ بہت غریب تھے اور ماں کیساتھ مل کے دھوبی کا کام کرتے تھے والدہ نے اصرار سے تنگ آ کر کہا کہ اگر یہ پڑھے گا تو ہم کھائیں گے کہاں سے؟ اس پر ابوحنیفہ رحمہ الله نے یہ پیشن گوئی کی کہ بے فکر رہو تمہارا بیٹا ایک دن خلیفہ کیساتھ فالودہ کھائے گا۔ وہ دن آیا جب ابو یوسف قاضی القضاء بنے اور ایک دن خلیفہ نے پیام دعوت بھیج اس نے کھانے کے آپکو فالودہ پیش کیا تو انکی آنکھوں میں آنسو آ گئے خلیفہ کے پوچھنے پر بتایا کہ یہ میرے استاد کی پیشن گوئی تھی۔ اب یہ صدیوں پرانا واقعہ ہے ظاہر ہے کہ فالودہ اتنا پرانا ہے اور اسوقت شاہی کھانوں میں شمار ہوتا تھا۔ جہاں تک مجھے یاد پڑتا ہے میں نے واقعہ بالکل درست سنایا ہے ہو سکتا ہے کچھ غلطی ہو گئی ہو لیکن آپ سرچ کر سکتے ہیں یہ آسانی سے مل جائے گا۔

[@jimmy-it7xb]

aman a very brotherly advice apki knowledge beshak bohot achi he aur apne kaafi books parhi he but please guest to aik sentence to complete karne do bhai. woh 3 baatein karta he ap beech me unki explanation shuruh kardete ho. again nothing against you and i appreciate you bringing such awesome guests on the show but please zara unko bhi koi 2 baatein karne den

[@zohaib.meraj_16]

​@studywithanafexactly 💯

[@libos14]

1:16:41 Editor had his chance at revenge and didn't hesitate

[@saadashrafbaig7146]

Yar ye knse books prhte hn...zbrdst...pearls like wisdom

[@urdutricks5414]

Shershah brother ❤

[@Heartsphire.]

40:30 it makes sense 👍

[@tameemasim7716]

loved it

[@MSAHNWN5EMNSSSAKY]

It's not always about food it's about strength from home did not eat these things but he still strong in all the obviously because he is a prophet and let's be honest dates are very better than any food

[@k.komega]

A podcast about Mughal emperors in India-Pakistan and Aurangzeb Alak gir... emperors in Indo-Pak

[@dradilmaher]

The wonderful podcast

[@kartavyasharma5906]

he looks kashmiri

[@MSAHNWN5EMNSSSAKY]

˹Also˺ forbidden to you for marriage are your mothers, your daughters, your sisters, your paternal and maternal aunts, your brother’s daughters, your sister’s daughters, your foster-mothers, your foster-sisters, your mothers-in-law, your stepdaughters under your guardianship if you have consummated marriage with their mothers-but if you have not, then you can marry them-nor the wives of your own sons, nor two sisters together at the same time-except what was done previously. Surely Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful. And these are the woman you cannot marry this is real i***** according to some not cousin marriage cousin marriage is encouraged and the Surat that I gave you right now this is telling which women you cannot marry

[@kidzuna-p4j]

Ustad g Maza agya😂😅

[@mmekalmashhadi5467]

Food, clothes and language represent history and time era, influences and cultures

[@aniket4565]

I listen to this pakistani podcast to not fall into an eco chamber ...loved the discussion around food history Pr yarr sati discuss kra wo thik thaa but kbhi Islam ki blasphemy killings jo apke mulk mai ho rhi hai usko bhi evil bolne ki Himmat rkhoo

[@maaz9699]

He literally did that couple of days back on their other channel, eon clips.

[@Aatapisis]

Bhai blasphemy ke against inki poori podcast hai , you can watch,

[@Abdullah-mh7tj]

zabrdast great to have exposure specially when someone is trying to understand different beliefs

[@ophamza2987]

MashAllah ajj bra maza aya bus urdu zyada Boyle

[@azharbashir5354]

U've invited a guest to show ur knowledge..

[@Naz20155]

Can anybody recommend from can I get this book "Islam and secularism"

[@syedsubtainalishah7175]

Just Write Islam and Secularism:pdf on google

[@Naz20155]

@@syedsubtainalishah7175 is hard copy available in pak?

[@Moominaaaaaaaaa]

Liberty and suhail academy online

[@BlackWhite-jr7mp]

The podcast was a good one in comparison to many which are just not worth watching - like those which are mere ranting with Sahil Adeem and several others. But the sad reality is that Muslims today don't learn from primary-sources and specialist Muslim authors of their own faith. Wael Hallaq might be a better academician than the other non-Muslim academicians and orientalists, but several of his theories are clear-cut un-Islamic and against the well-accepted facts of Muslim-history - especially his work on fiqh and usul al-fiqh "Origins and evolution of Islamic law". Reading books of different authors broadens one's perspective but only when you are well-grounded in the subject that you are reading on. Both the panelists don't realise that they themselves have become an essential part of the "Western attack" on Islam when they use works of non-Muslims on Islamic sciences claiming that it is a "very good book" ('bohot acchi kitab hain') - when it is filled with errors. Several other claims and ideas of the panelists could be challenged and disproven within an hour, but the major concern here is the total lack of any sensitivity whilst approaching Islamic-sciences and taking 'ilm about Islamic-sciences from non-Muslims who are not even experts in comparison to Muslim-specialists! You don't even need to be an expert on Islamic-sciences merely following people like Farid Responds (Farid al-Bahraini) et cetera you'll find how Harvard, Yale, Cambridge trained so-called "experts" on Islam and its sciences being exposed, they don't know basic Arabic or make basic blunders about Islam and Muslim-history! The guest of the podcast seems to be far-away from researching primary-source materials which the sole indicator of serious scholarship and good understanding of the subject matter. Even a western-trained academic knows the importance of primary-source materials when speaking on a subject, but this is totally lost on our panelists when they talk about serious subjects related to Muslim-history (tarikh), Islamic-sciences ('ulum ad-Din), Siyasah (politics) et cetera. The lack of serious intellectualism is glaring throughout the podcast - unfortunately this is the case with many Pakistanis on social-media barring a few like Qaiser Ahmed Raja et. al.

[@BlackWhite-jr7mp]

​@@_titanslayer_ , I have not assumed anything at all. You could not pinpoint one thing that I "assumed" about you. I never mentioned anything about you "claiming" to be an academic! I'm not sure if you are confusing other comments with mine. Your claim that I haven't made an 'argument', it is depictive of you not reading comments attentively. I clearly made my argument as simple as possible by stating, 'guest of the podcast seems to be far-away from researching primary-source materials which the sole indicator of serious scholarship and good understanding of the subject matter'. You haven't mentioned any primary-sources whilst discussing/mentioning 'Islamic-sciences' (fiqh, usul al-fiqh, ijmah, tarikh et. al.). If you have, please pin-point the timestamp and I'm ready to apologise for my mistake. I'm always ready to be corrected, there is no shame in learning new things and accepting mistakes (after all I'm just a human I can miss things and not understand things). After becoming baligh, age is just a number (not an excuse) when it comes to 'ilm. I'm happy that you are learning 'ilm from Muslim-specialists I heartily congratulate you on it and make du'a that you learn more beneficial 'ilm. By the way, my comment (it was a simple critical comment) doesn't prove anything about my intellectual acumen but only about the 'intellectualism' of Pakistan because I'm an Indian Muslim who resides in India. You also claimed that I "don't point out the problems in an argument but simply indulge in a blame game" which is simply untrue. I clearly pointed out a lack of mention or discussion, of 'primary-source materials' whilst discussing Islamic-sciences! If that doesn't seem to be a problem to you, I would suggest you stop with most of your online activities and seriously take to studying. Let me also make it clear that I don't "dislike" you, as you claim. Nor did you "say things that" I majorly disagree with or don't like - more importantly the podcast was a marathon without discussing anything in actual depth so there isn't much to disagree with until we know details and specific positions on several issues. Why are you assuming so much about me based on a clear but critical comment which is factful. You also ask me, that if I'm "not a student of knowledge from a madrassa nor have read any secondary sources on the subject". I've read from the primary-sources directly and I'm not a madrasah student, you don't need to be in a madrasah to take 'ilm from an 'alim who will provide you with a sanad and an ijazah on several Islamic--sciences ('ulum) and kutub. The madrasah system is just one of the many ways of getting 'ilm in Muslim-societies - it is newer approach in comparison to the one I am involved in. I personally prefer older Islamic way(s) of learning 'ilm. Similarly, I would like to write an entire paper on the errors of Prof Wael Hallaq. but you didn't mention those mistakes (but mentioned the book which has these) thus I didn't go on refuting you for the mistakes of Prof. Hallaq. You don't need to be an 'alim or even a talib al-'ilm to quote and cite from English translation of classical or modern works of the serious 'ulama. For instance, if you are talking on Ijmah you could have read and referred to the nusus or if not nusus at least the classical works like (translation) of Imam al-Mundhir titled "Consensus of The Islamic Jurists: al-Ijma" (Islamic Literary Foundation, 2014). If you are talking on Usul al-Fiqh you could have read and referred to (the translation of) Imam Shirazi's, "The Refulgence of the Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence: al-Luma‘ fi usul al-fiqh" (IBFIM, 2016). There are tons of modern and classical works translated into English today, if you didn't want to directly approach the nusus, but you failed to even mention these (or other classical works). No serious Muslim gives a damn what Prof. Wael Hallaq has to say on fiqh, usul al-fiqh or ijmah. He is respected as an academic but 'ilm about Din al-Islam is taken from specialists ('ulama) and those who are bona fide scholars ('ulama al-haqq). If you still don't see what you are lacking as a Muslim and how unprofessional and disingenuous it is to disregard primary-sources and classical works written hundreds of years ago if not millennia ago but still think you are trying to learn and disseminate anything serious about the subject matter! Finally, if you want my critique so eagerly try doing a podcast on one-topic (my expertise lies in history and comparative-philosophy and religion) of your choosing in detail and InshaAllah if you are mistaken on major areas I will write a paper in refutation and share it online for everyone to see - please don't assume much about me, al-Hamdulillah I have been writing articles against Hindu-religion(s) since I was 21-22 years old many of these are still available online and still are primary reference point for Muslims in their da'wah to Hindus.

[@AtomsToCosmos]

​@@BlackWhite-jr7mpshare your work brother.

[@dradilmaher]

We want aman to be simple

[@silentlips7103]

1)@Awaz E Haq Uncensored Channel for Hinduism, Ariya Samaj & Atheism 2)@Qaiser Ahmed Raja Channel for Atheism, Agnosticism, Secularism & Liberalism 3)@Sam Stallone Channel for Hinduism & Christianity 4)@Awakening Channel for Hinduism 26.09.2024

[@AmeerHamza-mi9sf]

Try Silver Creed ... Its same mud and rain smell.

[@saliksayyar9793]

Wheel is not Aryan, aryans came later. Wheel and first writing is Sumerian, in Mesopotamia.

[@DriveandGlide]

I am married to my first cousin! 😁

[@NavyanAhmad-g9t]

Finally!!

[@ShahMuhammadx]

1:15 ❤

[@Jeet-2023]

You are right about east shaping the Western mind. But that ancient east wasn't Islamic.

[@Aatapisis]

Neither it was Hindu east

[@Jeet-2023]

@Karachiking45 - please read the recently published book on the subject - "The golden road", by worlds leading expert on ancient south asia, william Dalrymple.