Shias view of the Companions - Sayed Ammar Nakshawani

Who are Companions?
What is the view of Companions among Shias?
Were all companions loyal?...even after the passing of the Holy Prophet (saww)?

[@mizanali8359]

i respect our sunni brothers as well for taking effort to watch this lecture

[@shafiqueshah5652]

I urge all Muslims to read their history and the truth will be quite clear. Read it for yourself and find the true path which is with ahlul bayt.

[@QinshiHuanfan]

I love how our sunni brother ignore what they sayyid says here and simply attack shia islam. DEFEND YOUR PATH FIRST BROTHERS! ALLAH KNOWS IT NEEDS DEFENSE NOW THAT WE SHIA ARE GETTING STRONGER

[@wordofwisdom1108]

Dr. Ammar Nakhswani MashAllah, really great words explained in the light of Quran and Hadees about the True Companions and Hypocrites Companion....Few illiterate so called Muslims think that every person who lived in the time of Prophet (saww) become the True Companion , when there were both True and Hypocrite Sahaba.....and Shia accept only TRUE COMPANIONS OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD (SAWW), not the Hypocrite Fake Companions.. Alhamdolilha

[@Trueislam726]

I was a Sunni but now I am a true Muslim , A Shia Muslim. The views of Shia are True and we need next level of intelligence and knowledge to understand that Great views of Shia Islam. On the other hand , Sunni views are very stupid, foolish that's why I became Shia ❤

[@farsiaman1432]

ALI is no1 amir ul momineen true amir i am not shia but i study islamic histry ALI was true and real man.

[@commercialandresidentialpl7337]

He was the truest and realest man among them. Selam from ex Hanafi Bosnian brother. :)

[@rukezz2057]

May Allah be pleased on All sahaba ❤️

[@hasnainabbas51]

An intellectual approach! Clarifying various issues in light of Quran & hadees. Jazak'Allah Khair!

[@IRAQImaster2010]

Masha Allah, great lecture

[@shakilatube]

can u give me a reference on the hadith that u mentions please

[@aliyousef6277]

Great and tell your friends about this speech

[@pancatab4806]

Where can i find the source about Abdullah ibn ubayy pledge allegiance under the tree?

[@imranhunk111]

Beautiful Speech

[@pancatab4806]

Where can I find hadith narrators biography?

[@mbousry]

nice

[@sabikasaqlain3400]

Very unique lecture 👍really impressed ❤️❤️

[@jameswohley3332]

*Sahih Bukhari Book 1, Hadith 25* Fatimah got angry and kept away from Abu Bakr and she continued to do so until she died. Fatimah lived for six months after the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). *Sahih Bukhari Vol. 1, Book 46, Hadith 3869* Prophet (ﷺ) said: "Indeed Fatimah is but a part of me, I am harmed by what harms her and I am uncomfortable by what makes her uncomfortable."

[@shaikul4887]

First hadith doesnt exist (about Fatimah's aversion towards Abu Bakr). (I cant find the hadith) 2nd hadith does exist. So show me the firsf hadith?

[@jameswohley3332]

@@shaikul4887 i literally just stated the reference ?

[@swishcheez6021]

@@shaikul4887 first hadith is sahih according to both Muslim and bukhari

[@jkane5808]

Look people , i dont belong to either sect , im a complete outsider , but you cant argue with this guy , he seems to be using facts of the sunni books , and if sunnis disagree then they should say something, so i have gone to videos where they want to defend , but im sorry guys you are always illogical and not ever talking about what doc ammar is specifically talking about . I am sure in a proper debate with impartial adjudicators this doc ammar will wipe the floor with you guys , and most profoundly its with your own books and the info contained. Wow

[@Jab_Air]

Same, after a crap ton of research, I’ve concluded that Sunni Islam is like a badly put together jigsaw puzzle, pieces don’t fit.

[@mo5746]

Sure sounds like a complete outsider 🙄

[@aliyousef6277]

Imam Ali a.s. Did not want to divide the islamic Nation and put it thru wars.He was as the mother of the baby, he would do any thing to keep islam away from any possible danger.

[@sw33t65]

Mashallah!

[@urduwale]

Long Live Ya Sayed. Wat a speech. Awesome

[@aliyousef6277]

actually,go by this last paragraph it is very easy to find the whole video with more details and explanations from Quran and Narrations.,Go to you tube and type in arabic language "Ethna Asharah Sahabi Hom Min almonafikeen" that 's it

[@mithaqalmanfi8697]

The curse and the cursed they say to them "may allah be pleased with them" unfortunately our brothers of ahlull sunnah are state of confusion

[@aliyousef6277]

i am right ,look for sefatt or description,it is part 4,Door Sefatt al Monafikeen waahkamahum,if you do n't find it ,type on you tube in arabic 12 sahabi monafik by Kamal Al Haidari and he would show you the book ,the part,the door and the narration number

[@almoses2785]

Imagine in the battle of Hunayn 12,000 Muslims, the moment the situation became difficult, 11,992 companions ran away and some were put on the same/higher level of admiration than the 8 who remained! Absolute nonsense! Go and read Chapter 9 Verse 25

[@aliyousef6277]

i am right,look for sefatt or description,it is part 4,door Sefatt al monafikeen waahkamahum,if you don't find it,type on you tube in arabic 12 Sahabi monafik sayed Kamal Al Haidari,and he would show you the book,the part,the Door, the narration number.i think he can get to you from more than one authentic book from your sources,,,,,also; some of his videoes already been translated to english and he is one of the best so far

[@zamaurdhussain4206]

( what Amir AL- mu'minin said generally to his companions warning them about the dangers of the Day of judgement. ) - May Allah have mercy on you! Provide yourselves for mercy for the journey because the call for departure has been announced . Regard your stay in the world as very short , and return ( to ALLAH) with the best provision that is with you,, because surely, to climb, and places of stay full of fear and dangers.you have to reach there and stay in them. And know that the eyes of death are approaching towards you. It is as though you are ( already) in its talons and it has struck itself against you. Difficult affairs and distressing dangers have crushed you into it. You should therefore cut away all the attachments of this world and assist yourselves With the provision of ALLAH'S fear.

[@BD-hm3fb]

I have a question to Shia What is your view of Abu bakr and umar during the prophets life? Do you class them as Muslims then?

[@titangamer1790]

Yes, off course, but simply being a companion during the lifetime of the prophet doesn't mean one cannot go astray after the Prophet's death.

[@mansourmirza177]

Yes of course; we do not slander them for the sake of offending anybody or for causing division - on the contrary if the Prophet’s(SAWS) holy family had no friction with them - we would love them as our Sunni brothers/sisters love them… however, if we find that they held jealousy, animosity, started Fitnah against, deprived from their rightful inheritance and oppressed them - we prefer to speak the truth about their actions as related even in the ‘sahih’ Hadith books which have been heavily censored in their favour - than to glorify them and idolise them. It was our Prophet’s Sunnah to love his Ahl-ul Bayt, to hold fast onto them and Al Quran to prevent us from going astray after him.. so we cannot elevate those who had conflict with this household. You must ask yourself - this practice of calling them ‘Rashidun’, ‘Sahih’ etc.. is this not actually innovation?.. unfortunately over a thousand years of hiding who the Ahlul-Bayt were and propaganda elevating the histories of other individuals have made it difficult for Sunni brethren to accept any questioning of the Sahaba and their intentions.. thankfully the age of internet means we can have these convos instead of just closing minds and calling everybody kaffir as our forefathers would have done May Allah(swt) guide us to the truth 🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@sonchay007]

you are refuted sir... the same bukhari you quoted. i used the same source. thank you sir.

[@farsiaman1432]

true sayed

[@techunitedbiz4311]

Where is the dalil for the names present at Hudaybiyah? How can he say that the husband of Umm Habiba was there?? The first hijrah was with Ja'far to Abyssinia. If he LEFT Islam, what was he doing back at Hudaybiyah?? What are you talking about??

[@sonchay007]

The Prophet (sas) informed Uthman (and us) of two things regarding his future: That he would enter Paradise That he would be tested with a major calamity. Sahih Al-Bukhari - Volume 8, Book 73, Number 235:

[@ghalibahmed6676]

Sufi Shamim who narrates this Hadith?

[@aliyousef6277]

in Sahih Muslim Book investigation of Sheikh Muslim bin Mahmoud part 4 Door monafikeen waahkamahum narration number 2779 you read the prophet of islam Mohamed s.w.said : " there are 12 hypocrites among my Sahabah" so not all sahabah are good believers.

[@BornInBosnia]

Which Sunni books? Can you provide your evidence if you are truthful?

[@aliyousef6277]

imam Ali a.s.did not want to divide the islamic nation and put it thru wars. He was as the mother of the baby,he would do any thing to keep islam away from any possible danger especially, there was many rebels such as Musailma al Kathab and his supporters and his warriors

[@shakilahmed-sn4bm]

ÀllahuAkber

[@aliyousef6277]

Our imams peace be upon them are "Mutahareen tathira "Quran Ahlu bait Tathir ayat chapteror Sura 33 verse 33 revealed in (Mohamed,fatima,Ali,AHassan,Hussein) so,You can not compare Omar to them cause Omar is not Motahar tathira means purified the best purification like Ahlu al Beit.Prophet Mohamed s.w. says: " i am from Ali& Ali from me" ;also; he says : " i am from Hussein & Hussein from me ".Prophet Mohamed s.w saying he is from Ali and Hussein peace be upon them. He never said i'm from Omar

[@BornInBosnia]

You said, and I quote: "Alaih Alsalam is mentioned in Bukhri &muslim Books after imams Hassan And Hussein it is mentioned alaihim alsalam". I think you are referring to the term aleyhimu salaam, and also you are referring to Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, not Bukhri as you write. There is nowhere in any authentic Sunni book from AsSalaaf Us Saalih that anyone other that the anbiyyah is reffered to with aleyhimu salaam. Once again, show your evidence if you are truthfull.

[@aliyousef6277]

in Sahih Muslim book,investigation of Sheikh Muslim bin mahmoud part 4 door Monafikeen waahkamahum narration number 2779 you read the prophet of islam Mohamed s.w.said : " There are 12 hypocrites among my Sahabah "so not all Sahabah are good believers .Some of them belong to the lowest bottom of Hell.

[@hatemsworld6769]

So god was wrong when he said he is pleased with them brother please teach our shi3a brothers and Sunni to unite why this issue that separate we all will pay for what we preach much love to my shi3a brothers

[@swishcheez6021]

The verse you are referring to is Surah tawba verse 100 which is 9:100 if you continue reading and go to 9:101 "Some of the nomads around you ˹believers˺ are hypocrites, as are some of the people of Medina. They have mastered hypocrisy. They are not known to you ˹O Prophet˺; they are known to Us. We will punish them twice ˹in this world then they will be brought back ˹to their Lord˺ for a tremendous punishment." This verse clearly states that there were hypocrites among the sahaba

[@levifan1477]

*_I am Maliki_*

[@ihs51]

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion; may Allah have mercy on you ! Don't just grope in the dark ; there are tons of rubbish about Shia - use your brain which Allah have given (to all) and seek His guidance instead of adding more rubbish about Shia. Have a nice day !

[@aliyousef6277]

Alaih Alsalam is mentioned in Bukhri &muslim Books after imams Hassan And Hussein it is mentioned alaihim alsalam.All the prophets except Mohamed s.w. did not have the knowledge that the imams had.Prophet Mohamed was given directly by Allah s.w. all the knowledges and the scinces of all the prophets before him and in his turn he gave all these sciences to imam Ali a.s. till it reached all the holy sinless 12 imams

[@sonchay007]

Narrated Abu Huraira I heard Allah’s Apostle SAW saying, “Anybody who spends a pair of something in Allah’s Cause will be called from all the gates of Paradise, “O Allah’s slave! This is good.’ He who is amongst those who pray will be called from the gate of the prayer (in Paradise) and he who is from the people of Jihad will be called from the gate of Jihad, and he who is from those’ who give in charity (i.e. Zakat) will be called from the gate of charity, and he who is amongst those who observe fast will be called from the gate of fasting, the gate of Raiyan.” Abu Bakr said, “He who is called from all those gates will need nothing,” He added, “Will anyone be called from all those gates, O Allah’s Apostle?” He said, “Yes, and I hope you will be among those, O Abu Bakr.” Sahih Al-Bukhari - Book 57 Hadith 18

[@hasanriadabas3972]

Hopeing and being are two diffrent things my friend. Hopeing is that abo bakr won't cause fatimah to be angry with him, but guess what she died angry with him.

[@Trueislam726]

@sonchay007 Also in Sahih BUKHARI it's mentioned that Hazrat Fatima (as) left this world angry with Caliph Hazrat Abu Bakr and Imam Ali (as) also said that the caliphate was their right but Abu bakr became caliph, so Abu bakr began to cry as he knew it's the truth. 😢May Allah (swt) guides everyone towards the Family of Holy Prophet (pbuh). The Shia views in their books are also mentioned in Sunni books , authentic SUNNI narrations. Surely Truth is such thing that we can find in every book or sect or religion. Even in the bible , Imam Hussain and his martyrdom is mentioned. And also in Holy Quran , it's mentioned that " Only Allah is your wali, and his Messenger and the one who offer prayer and give zakat while bowing ( in Ruku )" In Sunni Sources , it's mentioned that Definitely Imam Ali (as) gave his ring in charity to a poor person , while the Imam (as) was praying and was on Ruku.❤❤ Jazakallah ❤❤

[@Trueislam726]

@sonchay007

[@shiatalias5219]

God curse enemies of sahaba God curse killer of Malik bin Nuwayra ra God curse killer of Abuzar Ghiffari ra God curse killer of Ammar Yasir ra God curse killer of Uways Qarni ra God curse killer of Hujr bin Adi ra

[@hatemsworld6769]

May Allah guid u brother but why not let god judge them why take their sins and talk about them why not bring us together instead of insisting on this I’m a Sunni from Palestine and I love my shi3a brother and sisters pleas let us unite why divide

[@ihs51]

Read the Al Quran and learn and understand before you make a fool of yourself.

[@aliyousef6277]

Read imam Ali a.s. Nahjol-Balagha or Peak of Eloquence book, it is a ,collection of sermons &sayings by Sayyid Shareef ar-Razi.Go to Khotba or Shaqshaqiah speech where imam Ali a.s. says in it that the first 3 khalif raped Khilafa or stole it by Force. When 6 months passed and imam Ali a.s. did not give Baia or Allegiance to Abo Bakr who sent Omar &his soldiers to the house of Ali &Fatima a.s.they did n't let him in ,So,he pushed the Door upon Fatima a.s.he broke her ribs &died &buriedSECRETLY

[@jimcaalefarax2506]

What liar omar didnt kill the kufars second uthman was not great fighter so you are taking away their credits

[@aliyousef6277]

No Amir Al-Momineen Except imam Ali Bin Abi Taleb peace be upon him.Allah praise be to him gave prophet Mohamed s.w. All the sciences and Knowledge of all the prophets who came before him and Mohamed s.w. taught it to Ali a.s..Also,Allah subhanh gave Ali a.s. the title imam ,also the prophet said that Al Hassan and Al Hussein are 2 imams whether they stand up or sit and all the imams including the 12 imams were given all the sciences by one giving it to the next.

[@aliyousef6277]

in the video you would see the Bokhari Book,Sahih Muslim Book,and ibn taimiah Book ,Go watch it ,Do not be afraid ,it is one of the best .it is a fact you sheiks never talk about it,your sheiks were lying to you when they always said peace be upon them all,they can not say peace upon hypocrites or monafiks but they lied to you till today this moment they still say peace be upon them all. your sheiks are blind and their followers are blind in heart and mind,you must join the ship ofAHLU BAIT a.s

[@aliyousef6277]

sorry,i have forgotten,you do not say peace be upon them rather you say Radia Allahu Anh

[@BornInBosnia]

Question for Shia, and I would appreciate an answer. Why do you use the term Emir ul Mumineen when talking about Ali r.a., when the term itself was first used in respect to leadership of Umar ibn Al'Khattab r.a.? I mean, since you consider Umar r.a. a munafiq why do you use the term that was coined for his position, and by his wife if i'm not mistaken? I would appreciate an answer.

[@Jab_Air]

BornInBosnia nah, ur mistaken my guy, I don’t think anyone has ever called umar that.

[@BornInBosnia]

@@Jab_Air Um yes my guy. Do some research and you will realize that the term emir ul mumineen was did in fact come into use during his khilafah. Ok, my guy!?!

[@BornInBosnia]

So no book or any evidence ha?

[@hatemsworld6769]

Hassan is not all alone like he said Hassan is in heaven this guy is out to divide why. Why why. Love to shi3a who unite not divide u don’t know what u talking about.

[@BornInBosnia]

One more question, sorry shia'a I have many questions for you. Why does your speaker Ammar Nakshawani say @14:40 that Umar ibn Al'Khattab r.a. didn't kill any quraish before Hudaybiyyah when Umar r.a. took part in both battle of Badr and Uhud and has killed many quraish. Both battles took place before Hudabiyyah so I don't understand why he's lying about Umar r.a. specialy the part that he refused Rasul'Allaah saaws? Please explain if you can.

[@jimcaalefarax2506]

THEY ARE DISCREDITED HIM

[@Anonymous-gi4jr]

Umar left the battle of uhad and saved his own life when the quresh attacked muslims. And holy prophet was injured his tooth got injured. He left and saved his own life rather than going to prophet.

[@BornInBosnia]

@@Anonymous-gi4jr Can you provide the source of your claim, evidence. I mean I can say you are son of a mutah marriage but I don't have evidence. You see my point?

[@Anonymous-gi4jr]

@@BornInBosnia It appears that after some time, he and his companions sat down to take rest. From At-Tabari we learn that 'Umar and Talha together ,with some of the Muhiijirin and Ansar, ran away from the field and were sitting on a rock, when someone called out that Muhammad had been killed. Anas ibn Al-Nadr went up to these persons and asked them why they were sitting there. The men on the rock replied that Muhammad (P) had been killed, and expressed their wish that there had been somone who would go to 'Abdallah ibn 'Ubbai, a Munafiq at Medina, and request him to intercede with Abu Sufyan and get an amnesty for them (4) (4) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 20; p. 19. Seeing Imam Ali and the Prophet (P) standing firm on the field of battle, Muslims began to rally round the Prophet (P). Abu Bakr says that the people began to return to the Prophet (P), that he was the first to come back to him, and that after him came Abu 'Ubaida ibn AI.Jarra (5) (5) Al-Hakim: "AI-Mustadrak", Vol. 3, pp. 26, 27.,Tarikh.al-Khamis, Vol. I, p. 485. "Uthman ibn Affan had fled with two others to a great distance, and returned on the third day. The Prophet (P) remarked to 'Uthman that the distance he had fled was great'? (6) (6) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 21,Tarikh Al-Kamil, Vol. 3, p. 60. We learn the following from "Habib-as-Sayyar": One day, Zaid ibn Wahab said to Abdullah ibn Mas'ud, "I have heard that on the day of 'Uhud, no-one except Ali, Abu Dujana and Suhail ibn Hanif remained in the field with the Prophet. Is this information correct?" Abdullah ibn Mas'ud replied that in the first instance when the Muslims took flight, no-one but Ali had remained with the Prophet. Again Zaid asked, "Abu Bakr and 'Umar, where were they?" Abdullah ibn Mas'ud replied that they also had run away. When Zaid asked about 'Uthman, he replied that "Uthman had fled to a great distance, and returned on the third day, whereupon the Prophet remarked to him that he had run to a great distance. (7) (7) Habib-as-Sayyar, Vol. I, Part 3. p. 37.

[@BornInBosnia]

@@Anonymous-gi4jr You referenced AtTabari but which book. There is The History of Al Tabari volume 3:children of israel. No mention of your claim Umar running from the battle field. Please provide the name of the book.

[@mancinojackal9546]

don't narrate the hadiths the way u want and lie , and what u have been taught is not what really happened back then ,

[@shabbirlokhandwala8158]

Mancino Jackal This is exactly what the Sunnis do. Lol

[@AfghaNang]

@IH S, i have read the Quran which says Allah is pleased with the muhajirun and ansar, while you shia insult, abuse them. Ur hearts, Books are filled with hatred.

[@zeeshanhaider4428]

This verse has been discussed in the lecture. You need to listen the whole lecture and then make conclusions

[@BornInBosnia]

When you make statements like that, I know that you don't realize it, but you don't do any justice to Ali r.a., because if Abu Bakr and Umar, may Allaah be pleased with them, did that, then what did Ali r.a. do? Nothing? That makes him look like a coward and I know Ali r.a. was not a coward but a lion. Someone can force Ali r.a. to do something he doesn't want to do? Wow, you really don't realize what you are saying.

[@excellentgamer9940]

BornInBosnia fam imam Ali was patient, he didn’t want blood inflicted upon his hands use your mind

[@kumailjanable]

Read khutba Shaqshaqeya in nahj, Imam Ali a.s has said what he bad to deal with. You can never win against ignorant ones

[@swishcheez6021]

If you look at the geopolitical landscape during that time. The Romans were to the east and the Persians were to the west if an all put civil war between imam Ali AS and Abu bakr broke out Islam wouls have perished

[@BornInBosnia]

@@swishcheez6021 Did you know that Ali ibn Abu Talib radiallahu anhu had two sons that he named Abu Bakr and Umar? Did you know this, You've been lied to all your life, Taqiyah is major part of your religion called Shiaism. Ali loved Abu Bakr and Umar so much that he named two of his sons after them. You can tell imaginary stories about "political landscape and how Islam would off perished" to little kids but the truth us far from the rafidi lies. May Allah guide you.

[@swishcheez6021]

@@BornInBosnia first of all quit the lies he didn't have a son named Abu bakr, second of all he named his son Omar after Omar bin Salama al Quraishi not Omar ibn khattab. Now you talk about how they loved each other search up sermon 3 of nahjul balgha. Which is a sermon with over 17 chains of narrators it is mass transmitted and authentic. Your whole belief system is built on conjectures and blind following

[@aliyousef6277]

Amir alMomineen is a title given to the most knowledgable people in the Quran and in islamic laws,All the 12 imams were A speaking or talking Quran they knew the apparent and the hidden meaning of the Quran,till today sunnis they don't know the 100%the hidden meaning of the Quran ,So, Omar not Amir mominee period

[@BornInBosnia]

I'm going to teach you something, so insha'Allaah you don't make this grave mistake again. The term Amir ul Mumineen is nowhere to be found in the Qur'an, ok? The term was used to describe the khilafah of Umar r.a. because it was inappropriate to be called "the khalifa of the khalifah of rasul'Allaah saaws", since Umar r.a. came after Abu Bakr r.a.

[@kumailjanable]

Lol how was bakr chosen for khilafat? You all ignorant peeps have no clue of your books and your beliefs, anyone passed by the road narrated some b.s and you took it. 1 - Abu bark highjacked Islam knowing at Ghadir Khumm The holly prophet pbuh announced Ali as his successor, and many other places as well. 2 - How dare you call Umar and Bakr best friend of the prophet a.s while they left his dead body unhurried and ran to high back Islam. According to you , he was elected through election . Now this raises questions: rule of election, how many people needed to be present at time of election to vote? Where was the other sahabs to be elected ? Where was Ali? Imam Ali a.s buried the holly prophet alone without the pagans of jahiliyah who died jahil yes omar and bakr. 3 - so for sake of argument, lets say Bakr was elected and a khakif must be elected through election According to you sunnis, then WAS OMAR ELECTED? or choosen by bakr ? Haha apparently to you Sunnis Abu bakr knew choosing a successor is important but the holly prophet didn't know it was important to choose a leader before his death 😂😂😂 your logic is as fucked up as Omar's answering the questions of man asking if there is no water how do I take wudu lol he replied dont pray. 4 - if leader is to be elected, why was Omar not elected but choose by this Bakr? 5 - lol how was Uthman ELECtED ? 😂 ohh lets not go there lol

[@arshiqsyed7961]

Nightmare for sunni brothers #ammar 🫡

[@BornInBosnia]

I think that you are not qualified for this because the Hadith you quoted, hadith 2779 from Sahih Muslim, has nothing to do with hypocrites but with sacrifice of a cow by the prophet saaws for his wives. Subhanu'Allaah, did you think I was not going to check the hadith? Audhubillaah

[@user-jz9hs7wy4z]

This dude speaks in tongues like a snake

[@titangamer1790]

Akhi, you are just to blind to see what's in front of you.

[@shafiqueshah5652]

Only the jahil curse as they have no answer.

[@BornInBosnia]

First of all, a term aleyhi salaam is reserved fo the anbiyaa of Allaah so I don't know why you put that next to Ali, Allaah has not given him that rank. Second, I believe that Ali r.a. was an imam of the Muslims, so I don't know why you're trying to defend his imamate. However when you say "No Amir Al-Momineen Except imam Ali Bin Abi Taleb peace be upon him" does not answer my question because everyone knows that the term was coined for Umar r.a. so why you use it?

[@imran.abbasi]

He looks like a liar 🤥

[@galloush]

Only an ignorant will have a crappy opinion

[@SuperBubbleking]

Fair enough but most are grave worshipers- i know there so many views in shiaism but most common is grave worship!

[@adamsmith9039]

37:33 - How can I respect someone who angers the daughter of Rasul Allah (Ammar says). When the hadith of he who angers Fatima angers me, refers to an incident where Ali (ra) had an argument with his wife, Fatima (ra) lol. These shia are deluded. A clean shaven man talking dirt about the Father in law and best friend of the prophet lol

[@excellentgamer9940]

Where is your evidence you fabricator

[@joshmatthew2659]

Ur mouth is shut now huh?

[@excellentgamer9940]

Josh Matthew fam be quiet, I’m asking give me evidence where it says that Ali has arguments with Fatima

[@excellentgamer9940]

Buddy no it doesn’t

[@Anonymous-gi4jr]

Lol relations doesnt matter more, character matters. The uncle of prophet is cursed in quran abu lahab too

[@AbuFadl]

Wow this guy lies so much, the hadith says "my followers" and its talking bout ppl who changed the religion, the innovaters. Why would allah surround the most wicked people who will apostize around the nabi (pbuh)? twisting hadith to conform to your meanings. Imam Bukhari and Muslim and all the others are "Murtadeen Nawasibeen" according to shias, so how can you accept any of their hadith, let alone use it for evidence? Ive watched his videos, he lies when stating sources from bukhari and muslim.

[@0oldisbest]

this shaitan doesn't even say sallallaho alaiyhi wassallam!!! lanaah on him

[@QinshiHuanfan]

0oldisbest alaiyhi WA'ALIHI wasalam.

[@afsar9974]

He has spoken a great deal about the virtues of your prophet at different forums. Just by not saying saw will make him a shaitaan