Imagine the Commander game where Aminatou trades lands as well. Everyone would have the wrong lands to cast their spells unless they just happened to have sources of the right color. I think there’s a reason they went with “non-land”.
@matthewbeard784110 ай бұрын
I've played with Aminatou enough in Commander (love her synergy in my Yennett "All Odd Cards" EDH deck) that a common thing I find myself doing with her is floating mana with a land and then minusing with her to flicker the land since that ability can hit any other permanent you own. It's niche, but sometimes it can be useful to go up one mana for the turn like that (usually the turn after I first played her).
@snoopy332310 ай бұрын
Its been awhile since I've played on MTGO, but I think you can right-click: Undo to redo your Ponder. Not 100% sure though.
@gabrote4210 ай бұрын
This league felt like you had too many enablers and tended to be stuck waiting on the Miracle while playing less than 3 of them
@permabanter777010 ай бұрын
You nearly made me fall asleep at work! I chuck your soothing voice on at bed time to send me to sleepytime and have apparently pavlov'd myself into passing out when listening during the day too!
@janhornbllhansen490310 ай бұрын
A little surprised -1 on Aminatou targeting Yorion/Sam/Solitude/Bowmasters didn't come up (in the first 3 games).
@johnfanjoy346910 ай бұрын
Would be kinda hilarious to use the planeswalker to Donate a One Ring with a bunch of burden counters to an opponent at low life total. :P
@Jesin0010 ай бұрын
48:46 I am now imagining a paper tournament where your death&taxes opponent pays 3 mana to put *your* Yorion in their hand and you just let them do it.
@BoshNRoll10 ай бұрын
Shared deck rules. Like DanDan.
@Vuurgeest10 ай бұрын
@@BoshNRoll Someone brought Dândân to a seales RCQ or whatever they are called these days that I was judging to play in the downtime, it was surprisingly fun.
@ericdaniello565910 ай бұрын
4 Aminatou and 4 brainstorm … I was hoping for more than 3 miracles 🧐
@benschmidt67910 ай бұрын
I assume triumph of st katherine would go in this deck in paper, but what would you cut for it if so?
@Nightmare-bn4sr10 ай бұрын
Look, I love a value-engine planeswalker as much as the next guy, but Aminatou was "look at the top card of your deck" 90% of the time, the rest being a card to pitch to force and solitude. I think a different planeswalker would be better in that slot, even someone as Ashiok game-ender (unfortunately doesn’t pitch to solitude tho) would probably be better.
@dawnwakergames64310 ай бұрын
Would be cool to see a combo version with felidar guardian or spark double since they provide infinite ETB and LTB triggers together. would just need some sort of altar of the brood to mill them out. probably too janky. but jank =good click bait content right?
@ElGrilledCheezus10 ай бұрын
I saw a great name for an aminatou edg deck on mtggoldfish called "i can do anything brago can do at a less efficient rate" lol
@Weregoatee10 ай бұрын
What's stopping people from using Aminatou as a 3 color pitch to elementals that can also blink them?
@luna631510 ай бұрын
wasteland, dead card when u dont have wasteland for the most part without the miracle support (edit--- if u watch the cloudpost match u can really see the struggles of aminatou and how underpowered she is. hard to cast, isnt card advantage, ult is pretty meh except in extremely niche situations)
@G.Aaron.Fisher10 ай бұрын
Mostly the desire to win games of Magic combined with a decent sense of the power level of the format.
@Dracomandriuthus10 ай бұрын
The long and short is, if I wanted an esper card to cast esper elementals, I would get the card Esper Charm, since draw 2 is just much better than what Aminatou provides in a vacuum.
@Dracomandriuthus10 ай бұрын
Nimble Larcenist also is a better card on rate, in my opinion.
@ecpracticesquad467410 ай бұрын
It’s so ironic that while trying to nerf the companion mechanic WOTC actually gave companions more utility as pitch cards.
@Ulubai10 ай бұрын
3 mana to draw a card is a lot less powerful than 5 mana 5/5 or 3 mana replay your black lotus
@721823410 ай бұрын
Sorry but i dont get it. They started in hand previously. Now you need to pay to get them to hand. I think even vs extremely heavy discard deck option 1 is better
@Randomperson-pk3ce10 ай бұрын
@@7218234I think you may misunderstand, the original companion mechanic had you casting your companion directly from the sideboard. Due to this, your companions could not be thoughtsiezed away. I agree that the sentiment of the original commenter that the changed mechanic is stronger is incorrect.
@Esper_Compleat10 ай бұрын
@@7218234 They never started in your hand, you were allowed to cast them from your sideboard You couldn't pitch them to forces, you can in this iteration
@supersanttu795110 ай бұрын
@@7218234The were never in your hand though??? OG companion rule let you cast them from your sideboard directly
@gersoncoelho10 ай бұрын
In game 5, couldn’t you just flip the One Ring with Yorion and not take damage ? Thank you for the video!
@Interesting_Failure10 ай бұрын
"Oh no, a delighted halfling! That's bad news" seems kinda mean.
@moneyforshort10 ай бұрын
Samwise being flickered gets you max ring quickly. I think the option only came up once this league but was never mentioned
@officerungrateful509510 ай бұрын
I LOVE BOSH AND ROLL!!!!!
@drillerkiller99 ай бұрын
Chances of the solitude poker in the opening hand are 0.00221% or 1 in 45249. So you should be good for your next 45248 Yorion games (other pokers can occur tho) :)
@MaeseEidos9 ай бұрын
"Why would it stop at lands? Designers are cowards these days!" xD I remember not buying that precon exactly for that reason.
@elismith737410 ай бұрын
I just realized that the deal is for 341 Euros because that's three for one
@zotmaster10 ай бұрын
I am a simple man. I see Cloudposts, I click Like.
@luna631510 ай бұрын
abt the one ring thing at the very end of g1 m1, isnt keeping the new one better? still draws you three cards by the end of next turn cycle, and while it falls behind by one after that i feel like ur just drawing so many cards that you done care
@dallasjohnson645110 ай бұрын
1:36:45 If you cast bowmaster to eat that bauble instead of Solitude, you have a 2/2 to exile for life off of solitude and you end up at 1 on the last turn. And if they kill bowmaster instead of solitude with Unholy Heat, then your solitude eats a lightning bolt (probably) and you don't die to the bolt and you have that 1 extra turn to get Teferi into play
@edde242910 ай бұрын
Is there a reason you're attacking with plague engineer at 19:40. The line you mentioned for if they didn't trade sounds better for you anyways since you'd get to keep the engineer too.
@Interloper_3238810 ай бұрын
@BoshNRoll I have a legacy deck that seems to hold up well against my buddies murktide legacy deck. The sweet tech in mine is "Elspeths talent". Work has been keeping me busy but want to see about submitting it for a play on your channel possibly. Sorry to have to shout out on youtube but want to put the bug in your ear if you havent seen it ;p
@BoshNRoll10 ай бұрын
That’s a crazy one. If you want to set up having me play it, my email is in any video description :)
@joelcright281910 ай бұрын
Bosh: *plays against a 60 card deck* Also Bosh: "Why didn't they put Yorion in their hand?"
@BoshNRoll10 ай бұрын
It would be better if they did. I don't understand.
@RichardPhillips2710 ай бұрын
I love Aminatou! The best she ever performed for me was with Astrolabe so you always had a flicker card advantage engine. Supposed to not see a green base with Abundant Growth
@nate100410 ай бұрын
14:52 If my math is right, the probability of 4 out of 7 cards being the same with a 1/20 chance of drawing each card is 0.021875%. That’s ((1/20)^4)*(7!/(4!*3!))
@music00soba10 ай бұрын
BOSH PACK!!! I GOT MAGICCON TICKETS FOR CHRISTMAS SO GUESS WHOS ROLLING THAT BOSH PACK AND SMOKING IT UP!!!
@Bumbillion10 ай бұрын
I have this comment saved from a while ago, is this you? If so, you're my hero. "KEEP EMAILING ME TAMMY FROM THE HOA I WONT STOP BLASTIN THE BOSH PACK AND SLAMMIN THAT BOSH VOICE INTO EVERYONE IN THE NEIGHBORHOODS EAR DRUMS BECAUSE IM LIVING MY BEST FUCKING LIFE WATCHING BOSH AND SMOKING MASSIVE TREES. I KNOW THAT WITH THE GUIDANCE OF MY LEGAL COUNCIL I WILL ALWAYS BE ABLE TO SMOKE WEED WATCH BOSH AND THERE IS NOTHING YOUR PATHETIC LITTLE EMAILS REMINDING ME TO "BE A COURTEOUS NEIGHBOR" CAN DO TO CHANGE THAT I WILL WATCH BOSH SMOKE WEED UNTIL MAGGOTS PULSE IN MY SKIN HUSK TAMMY YOU HAVE NO AUTHORITY OVER MY HEART MY HEART SAYS BLAST BOSH VOICE AND SMOKE THAT BOSH PACK LETS FUCKING GOOOOOO WATCH BOSH SMOKE WEED WATCH BOSH SMOKE WEED WATCH BOSH SMOKE WEED"
@music00soba10 ай бұрын
@@Bumbillioni believe that was me yes i have been dutifully smoking that bosh pack for some time now you can check most bosh videos for the bosh packers
@troymullin838810 ай бұрын
@8:15 Bring the ruckus, bring the motherf*%$'n ruckus
@nicholasfarrell59817 ай бұрын
30:32 - because of color identity rules at the time, maybe?
@jonathansommer268710 ай бұрын
Love your channel
@BoshNRoll10 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@redpandaplush598010 ай бұрын
The dominaria remastered force of will is so pretty
@LibertyMonk10 ай бұрын
The "Aminatou +" effect doesn't have a clean name, but it's also not an especially bad form of card selection compared to Scry or Surveil etc, people enjoy spinning Sensei's Divining Top. It just is kind of poor at 1 and there's no option to naturally get out of the "lock" so you need a secondary way to shuffle etc. Calling it a "fateshift" feels natural, because that's her epithet (and we call Jace's +2 "fateseal" even though it can scry etc). But yeah, anything else with a similar effect will either cantrip or go deep enough that you don't get locked. The effect is the weakest card selection in a vacuum, but the most powerful if you can shuffle away trash from your hand.
@maxwellsmile10 ай бұрын
I was more thinking brainfart instead of brainstorm.
@EvanAnderson8110 ай бұрын
1:04 I see what you did there
@GGun1t10 ай бұрын
Can you really call it a Miracles deck without Entreat the Angels though? 🧐
@jerryturgin658310 ай бұрын
I mean you kinda can, that card hasn't been worth playing years, especially since you could easily splash red and play the better card in forth eralingas
@BoshNRoll10 ай бұрын
I didn’t play entreat even in the classic miracles era. Monastery Mentor for life!
@GGun1t10 ай бұрын
@@BoshNRoll haha fair enough xD
@Dracomandriuthus10 ай бұрын
I feel like Orcish Bowmasters is justified for banning in legacy. The number of decks that are splashing black for *just* bowmasters is *staggering*. Maybe its a meta thing but its godawfully present in the format, and decks splashing black for just bowmasters isnt healthy imp, especially with the "best answer to bowmasters is a bowmasters"
@michaelsimeone952410 ай бұрын
Sweet revengeance!
@tsimehcMTG10 ай бұрын
Time to get Flicked by BoshNRoll!
@ChrisSaur10 ай бұрын
I am getting so tilted by the reserved list lately. A tournament where you could use poxies for reserved list cards that happend every 2 months closed down. This made me realice that i cant find a legacy deck that is not using at least 3 duals that looks remotely fun. I have a huge modern collection and got the non reserved list legacy cards like brainstorm, force of will and stuff like uro from back in the day but every deck i look at plays a minimum of 1500€ of dual lands. I would love to play temur rhinos again like i did in those tournament but 2 volcs 2 trops and 1 taiga or over 2000€... With all the controversial stuff wizards is doing lately they finaly should get rid of this fucking list... Yes, i could play some linear strategy like burn. But i hate all-in decks/ combo. Another option is Shadow but that deck plays 1-2 Underground Sea the most expensive dual. I feel lost. Can somebody help me? 😢
@nicholasfarrell59817 ай бұрын
Replace half of the dual lands with shock lands (or the new Surveil lands, depending on what you want to build), maybe? I mean, I feel the pain. I literally can't play a brew that I was tinkering with because City of Traitors is stupidly expensive and I was too busy learning multiplication in grade school to bother getting them when they were new.