Shmuley Boteach - Hamas is a Greater Obstacle to Peace Than Israel

[@uncensoredtold]

Well I’m Muslim Ethiopian we have Jewish Christian and Muslims lived together no issues everyone respected each other’s religion and faith. I believe politicians are putting more fuel into the fire to divide us as human beings. I pray to God to have peace on this earth 🌍 💔

[@kfir_krak]

"no issues" haha The Jews of Ethiopia tells a different story here in Israel. Don't lie.

[@bora-cat.project2381]

Politicians, you mean the Imams?

[@mahmoodtahoon1335]

Jews had, arguably, the most peace in their lives when they lived amongst Arabs (Christians & Muslims) Tell the (sex Rabbi) Holy Shmuley to stop lying first, then you can claim that others are lying.

[@mahmoodtahoon1335]

​@@kfir_krakof course they have to. Just as Israel states it's a state of peace and democracy... Hahaha... And we should listen now to the sex rabbi... What a joke 😂

[@uncensoredtold]

@@kfir_krak you’re z*onist not a Jew

[@retroforever]

Rabbi Boteach is 100% right.

[@almiller3721]

yes, he is

[@MrUfojunkiedavid]

retroforever Boteach is an intellectual moron

[@i.c.e.7555]

Idiot

[@deficrypto1234]

No he wasnt. He lied that the Zionists accepted the Peel commission. The Zionists rejected it and the Arabs agreed. He also doesn't understand international law. The occupied has the right to use force to resist and end an occupation. If the occupier doesnt like the force, they need to end the occupation.

[@partydave1067]

@@deficrypto1234 History may suggest otherwise.... Jews would have accepted all form of lands just so they could have their own homelands, I mean there are more qoutes of Ziobists willing to accept any version of the land while there are more Arabs fighting or rejecting the Jewish state prior to 1948.... Nowadays Israel is completely justified to not give or swap lands, because they tried it before, and were attacked and forced to wars countless times because of it...

[@TheThecommenter]

These are the fools that are allowed to speak at Oxford?

[@zaraelizabeth9253]

This guy gave me a headache 🤕 he was shouting.

[@judelion8655]

Morality is so out of fashion! it's all relative for these Oxford geniuses!

[@garywood97]

There's teaching and then there's Boteaching.

[@lordlesuo1838]

@asase fgtre How about you google 9/11? Gosh such ignorance it's insane.

[@lordlesuo1838]

@Tired Sam you are saying Israel did the 9/11? That's not being ignorant that's being flatout dumb.

[@lordlesuo1838]

@Tired Sam didn't know the entire intel of USA is stupid enough to not realize it was actually Israel (their greatest ally) and saudi arabia. And hunted down Bin Laden an innocent arab for no reason for 10 years. Geeez you probably believe in angels and fairies as well.

[@lordlesuo1838]

@Tired Sam Bin Laden was the leader of a terrorist organization named Al Qaida, and is the one that is responsible for numerous terror attacks around the world where thousands of people died. One of them is the 9/11. I don't know based on what you are claiming it's Israel but that's just flatout ridiculous.

[@lordlesuo1838]

@Tired Sam Politicians that have double citizenships in Israel are Jewish. And I doubt that there are many. Every Jew has the right to get a double citizenship in Israel wherever they. Israel doesn't only give USA intel. They also give us weapon parts or even entire guns made in Israel. They are also geniuses in agriculture and cyber and assist us a lot in these subjects. But on the moneyside we give a lot more money to countries like Egypt and Saudi Arabia and probably more countries I dont even know of. The rest of the "facts" you mentioned are conspiracy theory so I'm not even going to address them.

[@JoeLackey]

I'd give a kidney to have his public speaking skills.

[@i.c.e.7555]

Joe Lackey oh shut up

[@thevigilantone5902]

I got a headache after listening to him

[@REAL6]

Then you're a fucking fool.

[@boliussa6051]

@@thevigilantone5902 listen to Dennis Prager on the same topic then!

[@ilq00477able]

I don't agree with everything he says, but the general point is absolutely accurate. Hamas rejects self determination for the Jewish people. Israel doesn't reject a bilateral two state solution agreement. Therefore, Hamas is a greater obstacle.

[@deficrypto1234]

Not true. Hamas has recognised Israel within the 1967 borders. Jews have achieved self determination in 1948. Israel has never recognized the democratically elected government of Gaza.

[@deficrypto1234]

Israel does reject a two state solution. Every year in the UN general assembly they vote against it. Every single year.

[@ilq00477able]

@@deficrypto1234 The main national palestinian narative is called "the naqba". In translation it means the great disaster. That narative revolves around the notion that everything from the river to the sea is either stollen or occupied palestinian land. Israel never rejected a two state solution. It rejected the notion that Israel itself within its own pre 1967 borders, is either stolen or occupied palestinian land, be it in the context of refugees... or any other context...

[@deficrypto1234]

@@ilq00477able Naqba isn't a narrative. Its a historical fact.

[@deficrypto1234]

@@ilq00477able Try and not focus on narratives. Naqba refers to the expulsion of the indigenous Palestinian population by a European settler group. This is a historical fact. I don't dabble into narratives. Only interested in historical facts.

[@hschoo77]

Boteach is 100 % right GOD bless him

[@kitemanmusic]

Not right about Islam. It is an evil ideology, bent on the destruction of all Jews.

[@yesmate0158]

@@kitemanmusic nope lol where does it say that

[@Zoharargov]

The obsession you Europeans have with the MidEast is astonishing. Having said that, this guy is a true pro.

[@sharpie443]

Zoharargov well the Middle East keeps sending us its trash so it kinda hard not to.

[@Zoharargov]

@@sharpie443 haha I just saw this comment after 3 years. lmao you're right

[@BallyBoy95]

@@Zoharargov 7 years.* Unless you were sleeping in the 4 years in between, which explains why your opinion is so clapped. Americans are obsessed with the MidEast for oil, and Europeans have hitched along. Why else? C'mon, use some common sense.

[@SayGen]

Great speaker, regardless of whether you not you like his arguments.

[@topspeedprintingsolution387]

Within 75 years,,Hamas created 35 years ago.. 40 years no hamas,,so why no peace?

[@מתןשינמן]

There is peace with Egypt and Jordan who were the enemy before

[@topspeedprintingsolution387]

@@מתןשינמן How refugee can make country by force and destruction?...

[@jonathanweiss3245]

Everything he said about the acts Hamas perpetrates is objectively true, and well documented. How you could infantalize a group of bad actors, deprive them of moral agency because they are under an "occupation" and relieve them of all accountability for their actions is beyond the ken of rational thought.

[@deficrypto1234]

U have a right under international law to resist ur occupiers.

[@AntMan3298]

@@deficrypto1234 ah. Does that include wishing a global genocide against a particular religion? Man people literally come up with any and every excuse

[@deficrypto1234]

@@AntMan3298 Who is wishing a global genocide on a specific religion???? Kindly provide evidence of such statement in 2021.

[@idanbotbol]

@@deficrypto1234 nypost.com/2021/05/12/hamas-official-tells-people-to-cut-off-the-heads-of-jews-report/ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas#Hamas_Charter If you prefer watching a Palestinian (Son of Hamas leader Mosab Hassan Yousef) speaking about the conflict instead of reading down bellow, please check this youtube video as well: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mWOxkpyOYs2pjLM 1. Attacking civilians, women, children and elderly is against international law and is not a valid method to resist any type of occupation. (Don't believe me? Do your research, start with suicide bombers and Qassam rockets) 2. Gaza is not under any occupation, they share a border with Egypt and still they choose violence. 3. Hamas have said multiple times they don't recognize the state of Israel and want to kill or transfer all Israeli and take over all of said territory, not agreeing for even less than that as we've shown by past deals given by Israel to return to 1967 territories, with this knowledge and view of reality that Israel is a stronger nation that is not going away and that they are not willing to "meet them halfway" in order to live together, how can you accept their position without accepting their objectives, such as killing and terrorizing Israelis till they take over? 4. Even if all of that doesn't convince you and somehow you believe that they wanna live in Israel alongside the Israeli population, which I wish for as well, ask yourself why they haven't tried talking for peace? offering deals instead of responding to offers? those who truly want peace are always welcomed to sit and talk, especially with a democratic state such as Israel, and if you don't believe me, you don't have to, the international community is not going to let Israel get away with denying peace talks I can assure you that. Now after all these points I made and questions I presented, if you still side with Hamas and their methods, I believe I have no window to trust that you want peace and that is the key to solving this conflict... take the extremist Hamas group out of the equation (by international pressure preferably) and force both sides to talk on technicalities that will allow both Israelis and Palestinians to live together in peace in the same territory, no sane person cares on the name, flag, or whatever reason you wanna mention as a reasonable obstacle to peace.... like Native Americans accepted living under United States, same as Australia and Aboriginals, the Israelis and the Palestinians are not going away, agree to live TOGETHER in peace or accept the fact that you're supporting violence, terror and war. Thank you for reading.

[@ניסיםמזרחיאדריבן]

@@deficrypto1234 there's difference between resistance to terrorism. Secondly, Israelis aren't occupiers. Thirldy, they just wants to occupy the land of Israel

[@AzureVillas]

8yrs ago and now the reality is HERE for everyone to see!

[@frankj2879]

And now, three months later, it is hard to tell which side you mean...

[@FlogUncut]

Why not upload the whole debate in one video? :O

[@mrrogers5957]

Nailed it Rabbi god bless you and your people !!!

[@REAL6]

How? He's not even a real jew and they don't have people.

[@meniweizmann644]

@@REAL6 Oh don't cry.

[@TheVeraciety]

@@REAL6 You have racial dysmorphia. You need psychological treatment. It’s okay to be African American. Your people have a proud history, too.

[@jonnyqh]

6:22 Nothing more to say

[@Tangle2Brook]

I love Rabbi Shmuley. He was great here. But IMHO Dennis Prager was even better. Better arguments and confronted Kate.

[@stevenfink3085]

What were the 1947 borders of the State of Palestine? Who was the leader? What form of government did they have? What currency did they use? I was not able to locate this information.

[@stevenfink3085]

Did you answer my Questions?

[@stevenfink3085]

According to Wikipedia (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Jerusalem) in the year 1525 there were 1,194 Jews, 3,704 Muslims & 714 Christians living in Jerusalem. In the year 1846 there were 7,515 Jews, 6,100 Muslims and 3,558 Christians.

[@jessicaatnikov3815]

Steven Fink That's because it was not a 'Palestinian' state. People should learn their history. Stop blaming Jews for all their woes!!

[@stevenfink3085]

Thank You; that was exactly my point!

[@Diaarozza]

Hey, the Brits took over it, you know? Like they usually do, before that it was part of the Ottoman Empire-just some history for you, sir.. And that doss not explain murder, or taking over land just because it does not have a "currency" or a leader, in other words people do not just kill other people and take over their land and make it their own..

[@ebd893]

Holy shit how was this 8 years ago? It fits so well now.

[@christianmeza4941]

i came here after the morgan show debate 😁, this guy has a bright mind..

[@Small_Clips_Apologetics]

​@@christianmeza4941me too

[@Mandems973]

Israel has existed since the 40s and Hamas the 80s. Apartheid and occupation since 67, thats all you need to know about who’s the real obstacle.

[@ebd893]

@@Mandems973 REALLY? that's all I need to know? what about who actually started the war in 1967? What about the fact that the land lost in 1967 was part of a war, one not started by Israel, but, by Egypt, what about the fact that the start of the conflict itself was started by the Arab nations, what about the fact that there had been so many offers for a Palestinian state before the 80s? Also, the only reason that hamas gained so much power was because Israel ended their control of Gaza. So whose the real obstacle for peace? Also let me ask you, please tell me in what way is israel an apartheid state?

[@Mandems973]

@@ebd893 (1) Winning wars doesnt make occupation and Apartheid legal. (2) None were real peace offers. They diced up the west bank as an onion. Jersualem, settlers and right if return are inportant points never compromised by Israel in good fairh. Barak retracted offers and walked away in 2000. Only possoble deal was with Olmert and we all know how that ended. (3) Apartheid. The entire premise of the Apartheid state is due to the Zionist regime’s desires to remain the demographic majority and power. Otherwise the idea of it being a Jewish state will be challenged. Therefore, they treat Arabs differently in different parts of the OPT and Israel depending on their location and particular concerns. Fundamentally they are treated differently from Israeli Jews. The rights of Arabs/Palestinians rank in the following hierarchy: Israeli National>West Bank> East Jerusalem> Gaza > Exile/diaspora. You can mover down (or to the right) of the hierarchy, but each step will limit your rights, and you can’t move up the hierarchy (to the left). A Jewish Israeli however, can move between this hierarchy as they please, while having more and full rights at all stages, and always more than any Arab at any one spot. Again, they are treated differently from Israeli Jews. In the West Bank for example, Palestinians are subject to a military occupation administration even when they are not in Israel proper (remember Israel doesnt recognize the two state solution or Palestinian sovereignty). Israeli settlers in the West bank are subject to civil courts where as the Palestinians are subject to Israeli military courts, which give unreasonably high conviction rates, sometimes long periods of confinement without even representation, make arrest of minors and can include torture. Why are Israeli settlers treated differently than to Palestinians in the WB? Israel applies different systems of governance and courts on both groups in the WB extraterritorially and unequally. For example a settler committing a crime goes to an Israeli civil court, whereas a Palestinian goes to a military court, often witheld without trail for ling periods of time, in a hearing that has always been condemned as unfair when compared to international standards of fair trails. Why does Military Order 101 Regarding Prohibition of Incitement and Hostile Propaganda Actions punish and criminalizes Palestinians for attending and organizing an assembly of 10 or more people without a permit for an issue that “may be construed as political”. And then why does it not define what is meant by “political”, effectively banning protests, including peaceful protests, while stipulating up to 10 years’ imprisonment and/or hefty fines for anyone breaching it? Why is a Palestinian’s ability to build homes and move within the west bank restricted and why is the human registry restricted by an Israeli Military administration if they are not Israeli citizens? Why are there tens of thousands of palestinians married to foreign nationals, who cant bring their nationals over because Israels Military administration blocks adding these individuals to the registries, effectively closing them out to immigration to their spouses? Clearly they are subjected to forms of subjugation and domination even when they are not Israeli citizens, and not in Israel proper, because they are Arab and thats the definition of Apartheid. Remember, under the Rome Statute, the crime against humanity of apartheid means inhumane acts committed in the context of an institutionalised regime of systematic oppression and domination by one racial group over any other racial group or groups. And how about the discriminatory zoning laws for Israeli Arabs? Why are refugees not allowed to return to their homes in Israel if all Jews world wide can “the law of return”? Why, according to a 2016 analysis by Mossawa Center of the Israeli Ministry of Educations, do Israeli Arabs get a third of the funding per capita for education and other social welfare programs than their Jewish Israeli counterparts? Why is it so difficult to get building permits for Arab Israelis too? Arab Israelis don’t need to join the army, but miss out on social benefits that come with it, which is fair - but why are the ultra orthodox who also dint join the army granted access to those services? Why are 75% of Gazans registered as non Gazan refugees in the UN Relief? Why are they restricted from using 35% of their agricultural land, 85% of the sea and 100% of the sky by the Israeli occupation? Why is it only that the Eastern Jerusalem Palestinians the ones who are revoked of their ID cards retroactively, if they cannot prove that Jerusalem is their “center of life”? Why does this jot happen to Israeli Jews? There are mannnyyyyy more points that make Israel an Apartheid state, but above are a few. Its so overwhelming and multilayered the best thing you should do to read about it. Have you read any of the reports? If you have I doubt you would be doubting the conclusion. You can go read any of the following: Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, The UN Special Rappetoires, B’Tselem, the ESCWA report, Yesh Din, the International Federation if Human Rights. Pick and choose there are plenty more.

[@joellukewarriorforjesusthe293]

Beautiful I love this guy. Im a Christian and love the Jewish people very much

[@almiller3721]

shmuley hit a homerun with this speech..

[@Adam-st9cd]

where are the question and answers?

[@christianmeza4941]

this guy has a bright man, God has given talent to so many people this is one of them..

[@robZzdaboss]

He sells sex toys, God has nothing to do with that man,

[@talha01110]

Well done man . Amazing logics + some extreme level acting skills , well done once again. You portrayed a clear picture of your thoughts.

[@talha01110]

When you mix truth with false It is called deception. Which is very common in your speeches.

[@liron-hazan]

@@talha01110 Really? What was false?

[@leoniegureghian7156]

ALL. OF. IT. …

[@ebd893]

​@@liron-hazan2 years no answer😂😂

[@mj23926]

@@ebd893 becuase we don’t have to answer nothing it’s clear as day. Keep being brainwashed by this bullshit propaganda

[@cooldudedewends55]

One of the greatest speech I've ever heard.

[@jonsmith9379]

boteach is correct; love watching his vids

[@deficrypto1234]

He lied. The Zionists rejected the 1939 white paper, the Arabs accepted it.

[@partydave1067]

@@deficrypto1234 The Israeli decleration of independance may atate otherwise They have accepted every term to get their own state and invited the arabs living within and outside the borders to live alongside them

[@deficrypto1234]

@@partydave1067 Israel has never Agrééd to thé 67 borders, never Agrééd to an independent Palestenian state with anywhere in historic Palestine, Has never Agrééd to allow refugees return and has never Agrééd to East Jérusalem as à Palestenian Capital. Ur living in a Zionist Meta versé. Every year at the UN général council Israël votes against thé two state solution and peaceful résolution of the Palestenian conflict. Every single year !!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@partydave1067]

@@deficrypto1234 Do you have proof to provide that may support your outragous claims? Or did you made it up/believe in some moronic conspiracy out of anti-semetic mindset? Also most of the things you claim Israel disagreed to do seems more of actions commiting by either Palestinians or Arabs....

[@deficrypto1234]

@@partydave1067 What claims ? Has Israël Agrééd to any of the 'claims' I made ? Yes or No ?

[@richsenyor6641]

chills... great speech

[@Solus3D]

Great? Is just facist propaganda.

[@partydave1067]

@@Solus3D How is it a facist propaganda?

[@sandb1867]

Emotive and factual. That's the way to win an audience over even if you don't completely agree with him.

[@Citibank639]

This is why you/ we all need Jesus!! Only in that religion and belief is the highest understanding of holiness!!! Amen

[@odeleya1768]

Jesus was a Jew. He studied Judaism like every other Jew

[@seanchen5993]

Great speech! Passionate and unrelenting!

[@lindatamir2852]

Wow great speaker, very actual now as well

[@kennethhammond6683]

Occupation is the obstacle, there can be no peace while the Israeli occupation continues, occupation is anathema to peace.

[@giulioferretti5310]

Arabs have always been hostile and waged wars long before occupation. Before June 1967 there was no Israeli occupation and see what happened when Jordan was occupying the West Bank. There will be no peace until the Arab world accepts Jewish self determination in their ancestral homeland, which is not negotiable.

[@christophersmith9838]

Amazing how a replay now makes even more sense.

[@imrannazir6931]

It doesn't matter if the Palestinians carry guns or flowers. They aren't getting an inch, no state, no right of return, no rights. It's also ironic that Israeli citizens with dual nationalities and land and property abroad have more right and say over people whose only is Palestine.

[@BigB29357]

Imran Nazir Thats because the Palestinian entity is a hoax created to kill the Jews. Otherewise, why did they not demand their State from Jordan where they are the majority ethnic group (the Falaheen)?

[@imrannazir6931]

I don't get you. Why do they need to go asking for somewhere to live from another country when they had there own homes and land in Palestine and what is now Israel? They are indigenous to that land.

[@jonathanweiss3245]

+Imran Nazir Oh? How many Palestinians lived in Israel in 1880? How many today? Like you would know without Googling it. And wow how racist of you to imply that Jews aren't indigenous to the land despite a slew of studies, some as recent as 2015 which clearly show exactly the opposite. Aw did the racist just assume all Jews were "white" or that they originated in Khazar or some shit? Haha get educated.

[@altGoolam]

​@@jonathanweiss3245 Jews are as Indigenous to Palestine as Tigers are Indigenous to Australia.

[@anhpam9205]

am Yisrael Chai.thanks from an Israeli/Jew -Yasher koach that was phenomenal Rabbi Boteach

[@MrTabla90]

this guy is next level

[@Warner_94]

"You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame: I shot a rocket back." Naom Chomsky

[@iftikharmohammed1742]

Wht boetech says he is smart and represents jews in a honrable way i like this guy

[@ERRATICCHEESE2]

I remember when a 16 year old student asked Boteach why Israel backed and pushed for the formation of Hamas in the first place (to crush the PLO). Boteach suddenly had "no more time to speak" and left the room.

[@ToxicallyMasculinelol]

+ERRATICCHEESE2 as if funding an organization means you have complete responsibility for all their actions decades later. lol. you treat hamas like they're children, and israel as if they're parents. who's the real racist here? hamas doesn't have any autonomy? they're too stupid to make their own decisions? they can just blame all the murders they've committed on the people who funded them back when they weren't murdering their own women and gay men?

[@ERRATICCHEESE2]

Israel loves Hamas. Everything Hamas does gives Israel a pretext not to give back stollen land. Which is why whenever Hamas drifts toward moderism and common sense, like the PLO did, Israel must stoke flames, attack it, or arm/fund even more militant psychos. Remember, the West Bank is peaceful, has no Hamas, and loses land still. The Palestinians are damned if they play ball, damned if they dont.

[@TheGiantKiller8]

+ERRATICCHEESE2 how stupid are you west bank is under complete enslavement with settlements, checkpoints etc complete racist enslavement its why its 'under control' Israel can only exist if it kills or enslaves its neighbors they have zero love for Non jews

[@BabbaYagga]

+ERRATICCHEESE2 Arabs stole Jewish land.

[@ERRATICCHEESE2]

All serious historians, and even Jews like Einstein, disagree with you. Indeed, most historical Palestinians are genetic Jews, and were forced to change their religion due to Ottoman persecution. Israel - which was founded illegally and against the wishes of the UN security council - must obey international law and revert to UN242 borders. It must then publicly acknowledge that it is entirely stolen property, and apologize for not being able to give all the land back.

[@engineerauwalauwal355]

I really respect this man

[@mikem4696]

Great speech from Shmuley!

[@sexoffendertrump]

A Holland Jew chicken to take on a woman. Just like the IDF using weapons the Palestinians don't posses for a fair fight.

[@ftst4756]

Can someone remind him this is not a debate about "Islam a religion of peace" totally offtopic...

[@partydave1067]

He does mention the fact that Hamas launches rockets from public/civilian location and forces everyone (including children) to stay so if Israel attack it, Hamas will use the human shield as a weapon against Israel....

[@USER-jo7yz]

BDS people must hear this as well!

[@hot_zas5231]

powerful it's obscure how this is actually up for debate

[@cindyfinlayson4197]

Israel is indeed the greater obstacle to peace.

[@partydave1067]

@@cindyfinlayson4197 Of course they are I mean what kind of a peacemaker tried to make peace with their enemies for all their existence? I mean they gave up on Gaza for Palestinians to rule over and were hopeful for peace with Palestine? And giving them free water and electricity? Only true evil with manipultive intends will do such a thing

[@cindyfinlayson4197]

@@partydave1067 stop lying. Show me documents that show the Palestinians get free anything. Idiot.

[@spht9ng]

@@cindyfinlayson4197 that’s so insane to believe. If Palestinian terrorism stopped for prolonged time, Israel would ceasefire and pull back the occupation/blockade. But that side cannot stop with the ‘shaheed’ behavior so Israel is always on edge

[@Fancymanofthedeep]

He was right up until he started defending the Qur'an. Otherwise good speech

[@kitemanmusic]

Yes, he needs to read the Koran, and learn the truth. Islam demands World domination. No ifs and no buts.

[@hsdjsdshdhsdnsmsd6247]

@@kitemanmusic Islam demands all people to follow it, just like every religion who claims to be the truth. But by free will, not by force. This man knows the quran and the islamic history better than you. Andalusians and Ottomans protected jews from christians who wanted to kill them.

[@deficrypto1234]

No, he lied about the 1939 white paper. the Zionists rejected it. The Arabs accepted it.

[@ChannelMath]

Really sad how it seems (from the comments) that only people who agree with Boteach watched this speech, and only those who agree with the other side watched the opposing speakers. Are we all so easily triggered?

[@spiritualguidance8483]

Well said, Rabbi..

[@OCEAN12389]

There is no occupation, they are on our land called Judea and Sumeria

[@littlefelipeg]

israel belongs to the jews...God will never break his promise...not in 3000 years...ever

[@littlefelipeg]

israel belongs to the jews...God will never break his promise...not in 3000 years...ever

[@TheNaturalust]

+Sima A Been occupying it for 1300 years huh? The West Bank of Palestine is the name my dear and there is statute of limitations for land title in the modern world. Unfortunately for you, the Jews time ran out on the West Bank long ago. Additionally the Israeli Jews are about as related to chosen people God spoke of as the Swiss are to Nigerians. When God gathers his people and RETURNS to the holy land to find it is inhabited by a war-like cult of imposters just how do you think he will react?

[@Ronni3no2]

That's not what the international law says.

[@Ronni3no2]

There's only one, so I don't understand your question.

[@ariesfirst]

GOD BLESS ISRAEL!!!

[@deficrypto1234]

Israel doesnt believe in God. They are a secular state. God has rejected them a long time ago (Deut 30:19,20)

[@sanacher101]

@@deficrypto1234 your argument means that G-d is making mistakes. And that is a sin. that is not a true belief.

[@deficrypto1234]

@@sanacher101 I quoted a scripture to support my opinion. This is GODS opinion in Ps 78:59. Read it please. Israel as a nation has been rejected a long time ago ( Acts 10:34,35) However individual Israelis who follow God's commandments have His approval. Israel as nation approves of homosexuality, sex before marriage, Atheism and human wars ( 1 Cor 6:9,10) None of these are God's standards.

[@mike47734]

I ask Allah to assist the brave men fighting jihad against the cursed disgusting animals in Israel.

[@davidr1620]

It’s silly to me and sad, as Prager noted, that this is even up for debate in a prestigious university.

[@deficrypto1234]

What crime has Hamas committed that the Hagannah, Irgun, Lehi and IDF have not committed? (State of Terror, Thomas Suarez).

[@davidr1620]

@@deficrypto1234 if you were, say, a homosexual, and you were lost in the desert, who would you rather run into, Hamas or IDF?

[@deficrypto1234]

@@davidr1620 Neither cos both have a reputation of committing atrocities. I couldn't be homosexual based on my religious beliefs. But as a Black person and human, I know who I fear the most. ( ReadThomas's Suarez, State of terror). When I see the attacks on Gaza, attacks on UN buildings, hospitals, schools, dropping of White phosphorus, targeted killings, Killing of children, killing of journalists, activities, nurses, sterilisation of Africans, I know who I wouldn't want to meet.

[@davidr1620]

@@deficrypto1234 let me put it this way. Some in The American military have done horrible and unspeakable things. Does this mean to you that the American military are as depraved as Hamas or ISIS? Let me further ask you this: does Israel have a right to exist?

[@AndrewAitchison100]

He smashed it! Great speaking but also combining in some real emotion which tends to impact the left more than just facts.

[@dexterlao9783]

Despite this truthful information from 8 years ago , many people still denied the Evil atrocities committed by Sadistic h yen as ha mas !

[@erbderbs]

It's always clear when someone's in the wrong when they provide little evidence to their claims, primarily use an emotional argument and do more campaigning than actual debate

[@SilentWarrior17]

the one who accuses always carries the burden of proof. . .I would be delighted to hear from you which points the speaker presented falsely with your proof. . .

[@erbderbs]

@@SilentWarrior17 case in point, delight away my friend

[@pinkz7911]

@@erbderbs i notice you did not actually name the points which were false.

[@mahmoodtahoon1335]

Well said

[@abbabi1975]

Wow - 8years later. I guess the good Rabbi was right on

[@deadtoselfShema]

Why is "Kate" (Purple Dress) even allowed there? She clearly is not smart enough to be part of a Debate. I hear she takes her video's down, why does she even put them up? Is she there to be the Devil's Advocate? Debate groups sometimes has someone who either a (1) tries to be Devils Advocate, but is usually the best debater who is not the speaker, (and is prepared) we know she is not that. (2) a person who basically asks questions the Speaker may think most of the Audience will want to ask, we know that is not it because they are poor questions r/t the skills of the speakers in this debate. (3) a person to ask questions some of the Audience who will disagree but are too afraid to ask them, this might be why but only shows what the best the other side would come up with, but how can Oxford Faculty or Students ask such stupid questions? So again, why does Oxford even allow her to be there? The best way to shut up Kate - Ask her (1) Are you willing to accept Hamas Version of Islam/Sharia Law - Debate rules? (2) she will probably agree with question 1, for if she does not then (1b - then why are you debating "FOR" them?) but she will agree, then ask Do you have a Legal usually Biological Male relative here? if yes then need to ask him, if it is OK for her to be here, and to speak? or if No, then let her know then by Hamas Version of Sharia/Islam law she is not allowed to be here, and she will need to leave, and remind her that she agreed with those rules, if she fails to leave only shows her level of Integrity, and her word. Where are the videos r/t the other side? Or is "Kate" that sides strongest debater? Hard to believe "Oxford Union" would have a one sided debate. Or was Prager (and other Pro Israel) debaters right it is a stupid question?

[@blackoutninja]

Shame he had to go off defending Islam. Still, a magnificent speaker

[@divinejacobmathew1503]

He is right on everything apart..... From Islam

[@cindyfinlayson4197]

Ignorant twit

[@kimmillard9445]

Purple dress lady is so incredibly full of herself.

[@Prodigalson0078]

I wonder if Shmuley and Catherine went out for drinks afterward?

[@dprite1]

How come this is edited, is this one problem with KZbin, whoever posted this did not post The full debate. Nor is it available else where on KZbin

[@nelsano3]

Amazing speech.

[@mojorhythm]

I gotta give to him; this guy really knows how to polish the fuck out of a turd.

[@indolamabwena]

This guy is nuts!

[@MS-vo1rc]

there she goes again

[@grnhrntskato]

"All life is sacred" according to Islam. No, it's not. This is what the verse really says and what it means. "On that account: We ordained for the Children of Israel that if any one slew a person - unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land - it would be as if he slew the whole people: and if any one saved a life, it would be as if he saved the life of the whole people. Then although there came to them Our messengers with clear signs, yet, even after that, many of them continued to commit excesses in the land.” First, notice the gaping loophole. Killing is allowed in cases of murder or "for spreading mischief in the land." Murder is pretty straightforward, but "spreading mischief?" If anything begged for a careful and precise explanation, a phrase authorizing torture certainly would. But generations of Muslims are left to apply their own interpretation of what "mischief" means - with varying standards. Violating Sharia (Islamic law) or sharing a different religious faith appears to qualify. Verse 7:103 of the Quran even indicates that merely rejecting Muhammad and the Quran counts as "mischief". Secondly, note the broader context of this verse. It turns out that this isn’t a divine command to Muslims after all. It’s a recounting of a rule that was given to the Jewish people (lifted from the Talmud, in fact). It isn’t an admonition against killing. It’s an imagined indictment against the Jews for violating the law given to them. “Any one” doesn’t mean “anyone,” but rather any one of the Jews.

[@Devin_Stromgren]

So who was speaking in the "private video" in this playlist and what was said that they don't want us to hear?

[@isaklein8230]

Israel has not act as the Dalai Lama, either. On the contrary. They considered their right to take revenge against all the people living in Gaza. I was shocked listening their announcement of their intentions.

[@MP-wn7ue]

He was lying. He can't sincerely think Islam is a great religion. But he put them checkmate.

[@obiedkhan8080]

what worse hamas has done that Israel has didn't do..???

[@sharpie443]

obied khan suicide bombers, randomly stabbing civilians, putting military instillations in hospitals, shooting unguided rockets into civilian populations, and quite a few war crimes.

[@qwertyuiopzxcvbnm9890]

Like the speeches of Germany's leader in the early fourties

[@regdawgformerusmc]

Freakin Spot on!

[@muhammadasimjavaid4214]

Free palestine 🇵🇸

[@vondas1480]

No such thing only Israel 🇮🇱

[@muhammadasimjavaid4214]

@@vondas1480 in your dreams

[@vondas1480]

@@muhammadasimjavaid4214 nope looking at it right now. I see Israel, the powerful nation that just attacked Iran, i don't see that shit stain flag you sent anywhere. keep crying, pathetic pedo worshipper.

[@dotancohen7688]

I love these videos, they give a very precise point of view of the Israeli-Palestinian debate.

[@debateme8955]

Sheeesh this man was on fire

[@JBYORK14]

Katherine looks like Barney The Dinosaur. With a wig. Her understanding of topic are about the same Barney too.

[@almiller3721]

well said

[@malghamdi5054]

Isn't the guy in the back from Pager university ?

[@starwar2901]

Dennis Prager, founder of Prager university

[@malghamdi5054]

I'm a Muslim and this guy and he's friend say a lot of lies and misleading facts about Islam and Wahaabisim to get emotional kids like you to support the illegal occupation and crimes against Palestine . Put all the bullets u have Ian and I'll probably forgive u because the Quran taught me to be forgiving .Please don't judge an entire faith by what people say and read the Quran or watch Khalid Yasin lectures.

[@malghamdi5054]

I still agree with him against Hamas and ISIS.

[@ianerickson603]

Spare us the taqqiya, too much has been told and no one believes anymore. There is no Palestinian people as there never was such a people prior to 1948. Always Israel and Jewish territory

[@malghamdi5054]

Ian Erickson interesting theory...but history says otherwise.

[@daviddelancey400]

Thankyou Rabbi God bless you

[@jackmargiotta5012]

Clearly this guy follows the anti-historical view of Islam and of Saladin. Saladin on several occasions allowed his prisoners to be tortured to death especially the Templar’s after Hattin; he took in thousands of female prisoners from Jerusalem and let them be raped by his soldiers. And Islam throughout history has waged countless bloody and vicious wars in the name of Islam. 2/3’s of the Christian world we’re conquered by the Arab Caliphate where both Christians and Jews were persecuted. I appreciate him standing up for Israel the way he did but let’s not try to make all about Islam having it’s record tarnished, they’ve done that themselves.

[@blackwood3243]

Islam, Judaism , Catholic, ect.. Can't all be great, either 1 is right and great, or all are wrong and not great.

[@chrisgreaves148]

Even though it’s 8 yrs ago this is a fabulous speech ,the guy is fantastic well worth listening to should be front page on the news today 👍🍺

[@fishingenthusiast0]

likud is greater obstacle to peace than hamas

[@CincyShaves]

excellent speach!

[@bwbailey5187]

Your a blessing 🙏

[@siddhitasethmadan6388]

This might have been the best debate I ever heard, unbiased and dispassionate views won him this argument.

[@Ronni3no2]

It's very telling that they had to invite Prager and Boteach.

[@mirawayne]

Wow I love this man !!! a Genius.

[@junaidbhatti-i7z]

Did you see that Muhammad Hijab was right I am ashamed I listened to this man really

[@DanyBel.]

This Guy is amazing

[@shalomeli1]

Wow this guy is good

[@rosendwv]

Very good presentation.

[@CoreReactionz]

Shmulik very good speaker

[@cestall1]

Greetings from October 7th, 2023.

[@seragsdks]

where is the full debate. where is catherin's response

[@charliealexander4513]

In Romans Paul, a Jew. encourages us to love and honour one another. . . do not repay evil for evil .. . live at peace with one another . . . Do not take revenge my freinds . . . for it is written ;'It is mine to avenge: I will repay,says the Lord;

[@abdulraheem20102]

Mohammad Hijab ❤😂

[@abdelhaykabani8264]

This just what many muslims think that Mehdy Hassan had given a floor dust value for your words on this stage !

[@jameskewley9440]

Can we have the entire debate please. JK

[@treetrain]

Purple dress girl stands up again lol

[@LeeLe412]

she might as well not sit to begin with 🤣

[@khomol]

Dresden?