Should Alex Murdaugh Get a New Trial?

[@lightfountain]

Judge Newman was shown to be an honorable and humble judge..full of wisdom and empathy.. Judge Toal is also a no nonsense, top notch judge..

[@jmsim363]

LOVE that judge! Need her in Delphi!!

[@FreedomMatters22]

Ditto!!

[@anitagendler3812]

This Judge is absolutely amazing! 😂😂

[@sar7873]

I watched the trial, and the proof on his son's phone before he was shot was a nail in the coffin. As well as all of the other proof from gps from Alec's truck, and cell pings.

[@WestLondon97]

The phone call changed everything 👍

[@chriscypret5365]

Paul phone didn't show nothing but phone died Bec battery at 8:47 doesn't mean that when they got killed prosecutor making s up all they prove was Alex lier ,steals

[@conniepresley7601]

I love this judge!! She’s right to the point

[@AParallelReality]

She does not mess around.

[@sallypearson1232]

I loved the way you covered this hearing. I was very impressed with how the judge handled it. I think Hill lied a lot.

[@bonnie7684]

The juror isn’t too bright 🤷‍♀️

[@hippieatheart2667]

Judge Gull needs lessons from this judge!!

[@wannabetrucker7475]

what we KNOW so far......the juror is a liar, alex is a liar.

[@Yo77Yo11]

And Becky the clerk of courts is a liar.

[@rachellerockwell3702]

To say I was OBSESSED with this case was a vast understatement. I watched the entire trial. ALL DAY LONG. EVERY SINGLE DAY. I felt like a juror! Which I got a summons for on Monday. Who knows what kind of case I will get!

[@msr305]

SUPER coverage. Very important information. Thank you Gisela!!!

[@sharonedwards-kk1pd]

Thank you, Gisela K.

[@sharonedwards-kk1pd]

I don’t think that the Court Clerk should have went out to the crime scene with the jurors. She didn’t need to be there.

[@G-Lander388]

BH’s behavior should be subjected to scrutiny via ethics committees and criminal investigations not by the trial judge…

[@loreanschaffer2604]

You did very well. A that Clerk Becky was totally out of line. And I don't think she knows how to tell the truth. You did a superb job of giving us this info Gizella.Thank you so much.

[@helene1779]

Thank you Gisela for your hard work!💕🐻

[@G-Lander388]

She (BH) is being investigated by ethics committee as she should…

[@jaimec3159]

Thank you for this defluff video!!! It was a fantastic way to understand what went on without having 8 hours I wish I had to spare!!! 💙🐻

[@Im-Perfectly-Imperfect]

Judge Toal was saying that Mcculloch could go home mostly because he was just recently out of the hospital recovering from a heart attack.

[@nepherteri75]

Loved this breakdown! Thank you! ❤😊

[@connietaylor2533]

That was crazy!

[@Im-Perfectly-Imperfect]

Judge Jean Toal as much as made it clear that we’ll be hearing more about BHill in the future. I think BH should be worried.

[@jenmdawg]

She has two criminal investigations AND ethical committee reviews on her docket. Oh and her son is now also facing charges. Not to mention what’s coming re: the plagiarism. All this woman had to do was follow her oath. That’s it!

[@Takemetothebeach-ob8mc]

Amazing job, Gisela!

[@rebeccawest9476]

Great job G! Thank you😅

[@pennylott6962]

This judge is a whole GOAL for 80!!!! She’s a PISTOL!💖

[@marycahill546]

1. Your editing is masterful. Thank you! 2. Clerk of the court is an elected position, and that is why she is still working. I think only the Attorney General can suspend her -- but that may be premature as an ethics committee is currently investigating her conduct. Her career is over, but it may take some time to get her out due to the fact she was elected to this position. There is no reason for a clerk of court to EVER speak with a juror. The bailiff takes care of the jurors, not the clerk. Maybe in small towns where everyone knows each other things are more informal to the point of this nonsense? I think the international attention to this case overwhelmed everyone in Colleton county.

[@kristinalothman295]

This judge is amazing!!

[@donaldpeck8519]

I watched this trial, so much work went into it, I am glad this judge came to this decision !

[@MizHolmes66]

So much corruption behind the bench!

[@MissaPality]

Behind the bench? The justices have been very good and fair. That is probably the ONLY place corruption didn't occur

[@CharlieP456]

Hi G from UK. Thanks for all u do xx❤

[@WestLondon97]

🙌 Uk member here also 🤗

[@melissafilson3755]

She put him in his place more than once!

[@siobhonc]

I've never seen Poot look so embarrassed and uncomfortable

[@anitagendler3812]

Thank you G! Amazing job! 😮❤

[@maggiedecoy]

This is exactly what I needed (i've been so busy!!!!). Thank you.... You are just lovely and well spoken and my mom and i both enjoy your content big much 🐻🙂

[@pamelahogan5039]

I listened to the entire trial on Monday. You definitely highlighted some of my favorite parts. Listening for the second time, today. Btw, I also like Harpootlion & Creighton Waters, both.

[@UnderdogbutunderGod]

Love the Judge! Wholeheartedly agree with her decision!

[@siobhonc]

This hearing is delightful. Thanks G for bringing us the best bits. Loved hearing Poot say "Yes, your Honour" like a sulky kid 😂

[@smileypawsinthepark2759]

Thanks G mods and grizzlies ❤️

[@croyabc123]

Caught the replay. I love Justice Toal’s spunk!

[@rachellerockwell3702]

I love that the judge is a women. I AM LIVINGGGGG FOR IT.

[@Mom22u6]

This and a few other trials you are covering are off the chain 😮

[@JaneHarford]

Awesome coverage

[@judycummings4059]

Well, somebody lied.

[@Herself519]

Why didn't Rhonda report the alleged "ride with the juror" to judge Newman? It appears to be egregious enough to warrant an inquiry now, but not at the time of the trial..? Something stinks!

[@elleng2023]

Thank you Gisela for the great de-fluffing. Yes, totally laughed out loud a few times.

[@sloride3222]

That was soooo good great job editing this!

[@christinedesjardins4605]

I love this Judge! ♥ And thank you Gisela for sharing this with us, you always do a fine job, keep up the good work! Number one True Crime KZbin Channel ever because of your professional work and for being so respectful and fun at the same time! Thank you again from Canada, I'm a long time subscriber because I love it, hopefully I will become a member soon! :) ♥

[@EuphoricLabyrinth]

Fantastic: thank you for trimming the excess fat. I attempted to watch these Live, but it was quite time consuming.

[@filo8582]

Love watching your videos.. The Adelson case is another interesting one.

[@JoJo-vv9rs]

Court clerk is a liar.... glad the judge called her out

[@mamabear5488]

Something weird happened there!! MOSELLE ??

[@jryan6013]

That Judge rocks ...

[@PattiGarner331]

I laughed when the judge told Poot to take his seat.🤣🤣🤣

[@TheAngie2920]

Very relieved! Loved the judge’s explanation. Juror Z was not credible. Jurors are allowed to convince and be convinced by the other jury members.

[@2Truth4Liberty]

QUESTION: Do you think the denial of the motion for retrial will be reversed on appeal? I give it 90% chance of reversal.

[@pamelahogan5039]

I am almost certain he will eventually get a new trial.

[@FreedomMatters22]

Can this judge PUUULEEEZE take over for Judge Gull?! And maybe every other courtroom in the USA? Then, maybe we could see justice! ❤❤❤❤❤

[@jojocont]

The jury wasn't very intelligent if they let her decide the verdict instead of the evidence. Ppl like that shouldn't have been on the jury anyway.

[@bettywhite6672]

G you are the best ! Thank you for doing this for us. I always like your videos and am subscribed bc you are amazing !

[@Judykroes]

Hey G. I have followed this case all the way since the beginning. I wish there was more done regarding Becky Hill.

[@AnnaMorris411]

The circus has returned for an encore! Put up the big top and bring in the clowns!🎪

[@Mycatbrownie]

I love this judge

[@Im-Perfectly-Imperfect]

Juror Z should NEVER be allowed to serve as a juror on ANY other trial because she’s too easily influenced and manipulated by others. Her testimony was ambiguous.

[@lightfountain]

I've prayed from start to finish of the murdaugh trial.. I believe and trust murdaugh is exactly where he belongs.. Whatever Becky did or didn't do is a separate issue..has nothing to do with his being found guilty of the killing of his wife n son.. It is a horror to me how much attention and effort is afforded criminals under the guise of justice..he got what he earned... justice served

[@19thnervousbreakdown80]

You're right about him probably. But if you think justice is served if it was rigged by the clerk then you have major problems and need to pray about something other than a trial.

[@auntiedigs6154]

I need to manifest this judges no nonsense attitude :)

[@AParallelReality]

Judge Toal is awesome. He cuts through the nonsense and he gets to the true issues

[@G-Lander388]

I agree with the judge’s verdict because there was not clear & convincing evidence that the verdict was affected by BH’s misconduct. If she allowed there to be a new trial nearly a year after the verdict on ambivalent information then the entire justice system could be destabilized by jurors being subject to harassment and intimidation to “change” their mind months after a verdict was rendered.

[@bettywhite6672]

Wow… what a shitshow.

[@deesmysterymagic1313]

Hell G and grizzles an hour behind just got on.1.25 here i come lol

[@angelsbreathatt]

Bravo..

[@joykahumbu4274]

I’m ready 😃🍿

[@deepstatethrombosis]

28:40 "have you communicated with jurors?" She answers, "I have NOT communicated with jurors about ANYTHING related to this trial... At all" then she makes a telltale expression. Her body language as she says, "at all" 28:47 looks, IMO, like duping delight and it's not congruent with her baseline body language when she's answering questions honestly. Additionally, at 28:49 she does a huge blink/eye block while she's looking down as if to avoid eye contact while she wrestles these lies out of her mouth. She uses that qualifier-"at all" which is indicative of someone being dishonest. It'd be like saying, "I swear to god!" or "I promise!" What a shit show.

[@SassyBear_]

Thank you for all the hard work. You are the bestest. Love ❤ and hugs 🫂

[@beckyhehn2064]

I too find it very strange that only one juror’s testimony is different from the rest who is lying or did the defense team interfere with the juror ????

[@jacquerene789]

My opinion is that the Clerk and others feel and behave too comfortable on their job. Moreso than being professional at it. And that she definitely talked to co-workers about the case in close proximity to several jurors. And that even the jurors were very lax in their own protocol and in following the rules. Too cool Gee; that you follow and mention The Behavior Panel!! I'd definitely love to know their assessment of the Fame-Hungry Clerk.

[@sandiunderkoffler1055]

I don't know if I agree or disagree with her ruling. I'm glad he's guilty but I'm not sure how to feel. I hope Becky Hill quits. Did they ever look into if the "Anyone" was paid off???

[@smileypawsinthepark2759]

Hi everybody good afternoon ❤️✋

[@ethelmertz1477]

Well his head bopping stopped. That was so annoying

[@isisnremy]

The outcome guarantees the maximum benefit. No matter how this judge ruled, the decision would be appealed. Here, the judge packaged the decision for the appeals court to address the complex and unsettled law that forms the basis of the dispute. I would be surprised if the defendant doesn't get a new trial in the end. However, we might as well settle and set precedent along the way. It's not like the defendant is going anywhere for the next 20 years or so. If his liberty was really at stake, I may have a different opinion, as it is I look forward to the next 4 or so trials. It actually was very educational, and all parties performed well. I was critical of the judge at first, but her cross of Becky Hill was great. Also, as a retired judge, I don't think she wanted to get mired in the Murdaugh saga and decided to kick it up to a higher court and get some benefits for the judicial system in the process. None of that could have happened, had a retrial been ordered after juror z's testimony...

[@angelacarl9034]

G did a great job highlighting the major points of this hearing. I really liked how G went back n forth between BH, Rhonda and the judge to show how BH lied. The judge is not happy with her lying to her face. I absolutely believe Rhonda. Love Judge Toal. Thank you G. Outstanding job!

[@patsykluting-lucas3804]

Becky is an elected person of the court. They can I think as governor to remove her? But surprised if she gets reelected. Hopefully they remand her to desk work.

[@angieparis5528]

Who is clicking a pen? Is that someone in the courtroom or on your end? I thought your editing and your views were excellent, but unfortunately, that pen was so distracting and made it difficult to hear the responses. I had to move on to a different video. Excellent content though and I look forward to more from you.

[@glasswingbutterfly]

Does anyone know if Buster visits Alex in prison?

[@dmwalker-uj5io]

Agree with judge.

[@seeitwithme1412]

I was so confused, I thought the Judge was a man.

[@pamelahogan5039]

I absolutely love Judge Toal! 😂❤

[@MattieBrown-hf8nl]

I love Grizzly true crime I have been subscriber and joined two months ago today and there’s no community is better than the grizzlies.

[@shaynaletter5589]

This judge got it right.🤙🏼

[@mamabear5488]

He should be sitting up! Thinks he's cool 🤬

[@shirlbibb2343]

Great job on the video! I believed Rhonda..i don't agree with the ruling ,the clerk in my opinion should have been fired..

[@bonnie7684]

All jurors feel pressure from others when it’s 11-1! This woman is dumber then a rock!

[@geeayy444]

Bad ass judge! ♀️

[@TheLucky8Percent]

Ole Alex was staring down the judge when she gave her verdict and that small smile was predatory at best

[@SandraLily2]

I was listening without video and couldn't figure out why the juror kept saying "yes, ma'am" to the judge. Silly me. 😄

[@vickypullam5776]

Loved this. So darn funny and we need it. The Judge is awesome. We will have to wait for the appellate court. Becky is probably on paid leave and may very well not only lose her job but be charged by the Prosecution. She also may have perjured herself. Thank you G!

[@rolfsinkgraven]

She made a big mess getting the book out fast, and messing around with the jurors

[@adrienekausner9701]

52:32 this guy is obsessed with this book. She can put whatever she wants in her own damn book.

[@elleng2023]

Love this Judge 👍

[@TheAngie2920]

These trials will go on until the lawyers stop getting paid. I’m sure he loves getting out of jail for a bit.

[@LauraJReicher]

This is unbelievably horrible!!! 😂

[@PurpleReign1401]

Was this Becky Hill lady in the juror's room? Are there cameras in the deliberation room? If not, there needs to be then any allegations against other jurors or clerks can be looked into much easier. Becky Hill should be fired and charged with perjury in a court of law.

[@lynnettemilligan287]

U got it all right. Filthy Rich entitlement