Should mobile phones be banned in schools?

An age old debate between teachers, parents and students is, whether or not students should be allowed to bring their mobile phones to school. Some parents may say they prefer their children to have a mobile phone with them at all times while teachers say that phones are a major distraction. Whose point of view holds more truth and how can mobile phones be used effectively in schools? We debate in this episode of Heads Up.
Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/vi...

[@leavemealoneforawhile9494]

Today, schools are running in mobile phones 😂😂

[@amanarnob]

Yes

[@historiareiss7646]

Sasha's opinion has been destroyed😂😂

[@deveshkek]

Fax bro Ye toh Sare fax bro

[@priyankadogra2204]

@@historiareiss7646 aot reference?

[@eXnub69]

😂🤣😂

[@ramakantchhangani8627]

A student must be mature and think by himself/herself what is good to me and what not .

[@santiayer7868]

Debate was really interesting as both of them had strong viewpoints.

[@justgirl4110]

Santi Ayer yes I know there Such a smart

[@kingleepanizal7475]

Yas

[@qaimuddinqaimuddin6189]

Oh ! Yes

[@qaimuddinqaimuddin6189]

It is not good in the class

[@girls3061]

💯%need to removed

[@Sheenchi]

Everything have good and bad side, it depends upon how we use it. So it is in our own hands to make phone boon or ban

[@ravichawhan2021]

Exactly 100% your correct

[@qaimuddinqaimuddin6189]

Ok you are right but in school it should not better

[@bhamaresarthak5736]

But small children have not much experience about their responsibility

[@priyankadogra2204]

@@bhamaresarthak5736 it should only be allowed from 7th to 12th class in schools

[@aniruddhamahalder1508]

@@priyankadogra2204 i say from 6th class it should be allowed

[@chandandash9379]

Not to speak about phone. When i was in school even .I was not given cycle as well.

[@sachinbarot4511]

@Raihaan Rashid I also don't had any bicycle🚴 I also went 🏃to school 🏫 with walking 🚶👣 just like you

[@vivektirkey5975]

What ! Incredibly debate I really liked both of your, s ideas are magnificent.

[@coolmasterishaanplayz]

How about "can schools be banned"

[@parikshit28]

Best idea 🤣🤣

[@mousumimallick3043]

YAS

[@balajisarathi4571]

School student emergency use for basic mobile Not Android. after complete school stage then college life using Android mobiles and all things.. this is my point of you

[@kartikey1796]

You are right...only for safety students must carry basic mobile phone with them...Internet must be provided them when they are 18+...coz they must watch unhealthy technology.....but I am of 17 right now but I am at my home

[@rajprakashsharma6052]

This is such a nice debate I know it in future it will help me alot thanks

[@jalobayy5306]

In my opinion it depends on how it’s being used. There’s a time and place for everything. I think the teacher should take the phone away during work, during recess I think you should be allowed to use it. Of course during testing it should not be allowed.

[@shiblirahmani4882]

so what is difference betn schools and collages or the also students is comparing her phone to her company school is instituion where all students is same values so, WE say that there is some diffrence betn values of economy or there is no restriction u will be used phone in her home there is no time of place is everything whatever u used phone in her coolage

[@wryuz]

@@shiblirahmani4882 please go learn some grammar please and don't tempt me to r/ihadastroke you

[@fluffybub]

7:36 This is really a rude line '' Even a beggar now has a cell phone''....😡

[@akshay-jr1qz]

But it's a fact

[@fluffybub]

@@akshay-jr1qz yes it is a fact but she could have said it in a different but polite way....

[@akshay-jr1qz]

@Shaurya Tiwari they are beggars they don't have any money but they have a cell phone beggars don't have a cell phone when did that happen

[@shaggythedilophosaurus9702]

Imagine your Bluetooth connecting to the teachers electronic whiteboard

[@ishtiakhaquejoy2701]

Both of them were really outstanding. Giving their best on the show.

[@tanishatanisha5722]

Ya I know

[@bablisharma5149]

if a student stay in school from morning 07:00 to evening 5:30 and were not allowed to play games as it should be and school worker or a teacher harass a student and they were not allowed to use office phone. then it is required to have a personal phone.

[@HindiTechnicalGuide]

I'm not in agreement with the one on the path to disagreement with the fact leading to having phone.

[@trippy5373]

i'd still bring it even if they were banned

[@tejarajgahir9627]

Irritating" You Know"

[@beautiful.monster.10m9]

Haw many times "u know"

[@paavaniupsc]

😂😂

[@yogeshkanwadiya6738]

No we don't know 😂😂

[@zoya1520]

😂😂😂i also notice it

[@surajm5871]

U know ..why?

[@atulrawat4709]

I love word u know instead of aaa ooo ...etc .

[@thequietkid2715]

NO, ESPECIALLY IN MIDDLE SCHOOL. MIDDLE SCHOOL IS WAY TOO HARD FOR ME. SCHOOLS SHOULD BE BANNED FOREVER

[@raaston9761]

agreed

[@AJ-yx7sw]

😂😂😂

[@justaakss]

😂😂😂

[@yaminivedwan2317]

KZbin has suggested this video to me after 7 years and this is such a great debate... But I was wondering if they would knew about covid then how the tables would have turned. But still I salute the girl who's against the motion. Both of you great job 😇😇

[@shreeyashpandey3530]

" i speak english at 1-2 you know's per second "

[@glassw1ng]

I have a debate at school tomorrow on this subject

[@CreativeAnshi]

Me too

[@dawn7177]

same here

[@tanushkayadav7884]

Same here

[@taiki9002]

Same oof

[@acevivi]

It really depends if we have a phone or not but that can also be wrong.

[@RACHNAMAVI]

Who are watching in school??

[@faiyad1238]

Savage

[@mohitrizwan4543]

Ha ha ha, its me

[@rajeshgope1708]

Yah, I must favour the girl having a favor on mobile should not❌ allowed in ✏📚schools...

[@girls3061]

💯% banned

[@frozenbucket8348]

No evry school allows phone exept stupid india

[@Happpy_Meee]

@@frozenbucket8348 u are stupid frozen bucket. By the way hold ur tongue

[@pinturaj9812]

It's a very nice video on this topic

[@s.nmishra700]

Debate was so amazing both give the best points for debate

[@sophiejan3069]

How much "u know"

[@angww29]

We can do math We can do notes. If you agree, We can also use office lens For taking pictures of forms and Worksheets If you all agree, We students, may find a way, To bring it. But not play with it

[@user-kp3en4zg9y]

hï

[@user-kp3en4zg9y]

hï

[@EVOKEWILSON]

I know why phone's are used in school 😂 because they were KZbin in class l watched meny videos of this

[@EVOKEWILSON]

I seb that rong

[@EVOKEWILSON]

That's all that do is talk to echuter!?👿

[@mubeenuddin8746]

u know

[@ferdiefulgar3179]

When entering classroom and class activity is on going, its better to turn off for a moment our mobile phone during class hours in respect for our proffesor.

[@abhinav2530]

Noooo!

[@spiritualbuddha7295]

It's always difficult to defend the argument which is something not in use currently.. I personally feel " cell phone can be a boon or bane depending on its operation", but, if we judge by the arguments and counter-responses the girl opposing the motion is having an upper hand here.. Mediator needs to be Lil neutral on both fronts..

[@sagargautam8682]

You are very good doing debate

[@vennaphaneendra9931]

So good and I wish NDTV to have one more on this and education system in again please

[@madhumehta2542]

Thank you mem for this video becoz I was finding out about this topic

[@thanos5725]

Ok,ok but now mobile phone is *SCHOOL*

[@artikumari-zn6dw]

Not using technology when it's available is like using a manual fan instead of AC in harsh summers,it's pointless!

[@nilkanthkumarmandal8139]

I need to watch this type of discussion from where I can get

[@dewudinsatthem3029]

So interesting debate, expecting more topics further

[@gaastik]

Keypad phone should be allowed in school not smartphone

[@satyamkpandey233]

Am I the only one here who fall one side when hear one's viewpoint and when hearing 2nd one then think that yeah she is absolutely right .

[@chandnigupta2326]

Yes. Both sister was good understanding with their topic.

[@AnNa-hk5yg]

Yup

[@AjaySingh-zv5zo]

Hi

[@AjaySingh-zv5zo]

Good gd

[@Knowledgeadda929]

In favour, arguments are weak Against are strong point

[@itsaditya9832]

You know

[@PAWANKUMAR-tb5pk]

I think if we use any digital gadgets in a correct manner then it would be very helpful But before we will be applying the idea on school childrens then we should think strongly.

[@notatall3607]

Nope.

[@bramesh8030]

No

[@nandubiju5899]

the opposer has "you know" disease

[@siiid.x]

I know that. U know?

[@richamishra5301]

😀😂😂😂😂

[@amankharaliya158]

She was getting on my nerve every time she spoke , "you know".

[@padaisehikalh9773]

😂😂

[@aryanjudah1749]

Because 'she knows'.

[@RakeshKumar-ro3ws]

Nowadays mobile phone is very important for student on study

[@mohitforimprovement]

Next debate : should schools be banned in phones 🤣

[@popcornlovbambi]

I bring my phone to school in case I need to call my parents. And I use it on the bus so I don't have to talk to children.

[@faheemakhtar7700]

Your debate should be with subtitles

[@tanveersingh7613]

😂

[@tanushkayadav7884]

Mam kya ap mujhe kuch main baata skti he that mobile phone should be allowed in school pe mam plsssss

[@bhubaneswarbarik9782]

I am watching during lockdown ..it's interesting debate with strong point ..both have strong point

[@N0tyoursunfl0wer]

I got to k12 and we're not allowed to have cellphones out.If we have them out then we'll get them taken away.

[@srdchannel8028]

Important vocab 1.inculcate:- explain,मन मै बैठाना 2regulated:-नियमित रूप से

[@aspirus_maximus]

Ban phones in class but allowed I school premises and allow them a free period,game period and recess

[@gulshansingh852]

Its all depends upon you that how do use it

[@squattypotty612]

No they shouldn’t what if there was a family emergency or at the school or you needed to go home cause of something this is insane i can’t believe schools are making these rules and treating us like dogs

[@ashokkumarchakraborty3192]

Nice but u no hate you have a damn funny name

[@poojakaparthi]

You Know you know

[@vinitasahu073]

I have my debate Tommaro

[@anirudhsreeram4015]

A shoutout to people in this comments section who have used these words: band (for banned), shd b, clg, y, u, ur, wud, shud, u no, gud, yss, hv. I personally am for regulated phone use in school, but you my friends, are the reasons why I have second thoughts - if this is what your vocabulary has been reduced to by chronic obsessive phone use, then I begin to feel that phones must be banned altogether.

[@jalobayy5306]

Anirudh Sreeram the*

[@donjon2023]

Ever heard of Abbreviation

[@queen4254]

But if we need to find out the meaning of any word immediately and everyone knows that no one keeps the dictionaries with him all the time but we keep phones all the time with us so on that time we can search that word on the spot .

[@huhh6969]

Ever heard of slang?

[@jayzee8367]

"you know"

[@acevivi]

It depends on your personality and what you have researched.

[@subikshark3498]

You government have allow phones to school . See America , Canada but we are not allowing . I am asking why ??? We can regulate like Shubangi is telling. Yes we should allow phone . Shubangi I will vote to you

[@personalitydevelopmentattr6314]

There are both debates good but cell phone is most important for quickly response any solution of question that will be not easy in book

[@aliasger_sabir5151]

why are they not adding researches

[@zamzirulumar3447]

In the end you know?....

[@Vedrajrm]

In the description: “ An age old debate.....” Cellphones became accessible only a few years ago It’s an excellent device with an easy access to the internet. An one stop destination to all the knowledge you want

[@OmegaWolf747]

I think for younger kids, a ban is probably a good idea. I think in high school, use should be allowed at certain times, like during lunch.

[@marutibbagewadimarutibbage1046]

Reason

[@soniabalyan1166]

i strongly agree with opposer.. cellphones should be banned in schools

[@anishmenon3587]

sonia balyan ur such a mom

[@soniabalyan1166]

of course! i’ll be very soon.. 🙂

[@anishmenon3587]

sonia balyan congratulations

[@brijeshmaurya9335]

In my opinion it is right to ban phone

[@surjakantamodak5314]

U know

[@studytime2039]

when u can search everything by ur phone so why r u coming in school leave that and study at ur home ..with the help of ur cell phone..

[@alicialewis7317]

Yes they should...

[@user-eu3jz8kb4q]

Anuj Mishra

[@KnowledgeArena786]

Agreed

[@lalungcrazy8770]

I agree with your think but depend on your own . You don't use in the class do you want to use then you can use after class but for good things.

[@ps-lover8380]

Yeah you are right

[@SalmanShaikh-xl2wb]

Debate is so interesting appreciate .

[@sonusuhag7145]

Self phone should be ban... because these are decreasing our memorising power as well because we are indulging in that small *cell* and escaping from which it is very hard... student will remain away from their basic need..like physical education and moral too. As my dear said that they can share class notes and audio then what is the basic need to come school...only one student can come and can send audio or notes to others...by doing this we will remain away from the basic need to go school....teacher and student also distracted by using phones....and the biggest bulky thing i want to pressurise that if we start looking our elders then we come to know that our memorising power is going decreasing....they could memorise a lot of poems,granthas,upnishdas etc orally.But i personally feel that using self phone at school at home mean that in excess we will not be able to express ourself... because we will express the self phones

[@sonusuhag7145]

But the girl without specs also have some good points....in her ttalks

[@NehaSingh-jn1eg]

Totally agree with sasha

[@himansukumar3378]

Debate is most important to increase creativity power.

[@englishfoundation3999]

Phone should be allowed in school...

[@deepakkumar-fb5gg]

Thanks for uploading this types of videos

[@peterthepanda]

Middle ground solution: Ban smartphones for students but allow them to have those basic/feature phones that allow only calling and texting. With that, little to no social media and online distraction while still keeping communication line with parents or guardians open as well as for safety.

[@ps-lover8380]

Exactly bro

[@ThatControlUser]

So you want millions of people to invest in old technology? Damn, that's *progress* right there

[@rickproclip4664]

so what about music, games etc? In substitute periods we are bored as hell so no smartphones?

[@yvann9587]

I have a debate on this I'm con and this was a major boost

[@mishearepic108]

My fucking school banned phones 😭😭

[@Phatnaru0002]

MishearEpic good

[@saikhansurtaltsumiyabazar5403]

MishearEpic yes when my Teacher saw She Takes it And She will make us pya 25$

[@samnaylor9706]

MishearEpic SAMMMMME

[@varrasrinu3256]

MishearEpic

[@varrasrinu3256]

Phatnaru0002 hgfo

[@ASHISH-yo2sh]

smart phones should be allowed in school

[@Anonymous-xu2mz]

3:27 My whole life was a lie me who brought a smartphone in the school which was taken by teacher and called my parents my school comes under that 2% at that time.

[@aryanjudah1749]

What a wise girl, Sasha is! ..... her parents have done a great job. My parenting plan for my 12 year old boy is as follows - smart phone at 16 .... that gives him an active boyhood n the remaining 2 school years to make him 'smart' with the usage of the phone. N hopefully, those lessons will stay with him through college n rest of his life...

[@poojasama1064]

Every coins has two sides..

[@Imaishan]

This is why *I'm love to watch always NDTV* 💙💙💙

[@sahoobabu1160]

Why she is telling... you know you know... Continuously... It's just irritating....

[@minannakc235]

Actually I agree both of u ....... it's just heads upon the user ..how he or she use the self phone.....

[@ishaanchowdhri979]

how many times did the opposer say you know

[@rajesh_banerjeee]

U Know u know u know ...was very irritating 😒

[@mrperfect6065]

in my opinion ,,If we give cellphone without data or internet ,only for note ,recording and calling ,then i dont think so there will be problem

[@orchi8396]

I sort of want to bring phone to school but I'm not that kind of kid who always plays phone in class while studying

So why you want to bring it for? Be on Facebook all day?

[@HomieBox]

He will probably use it for emergencies or notes and things like that. Who still uses Facedookey?

[@ranjeetsidhuninder3405]

Cellphone should not allowed in schools..

[@raycano7706]

It’s common sense. No cell phones should be allowed in schools. We survived without them when I was in school in the 60’s and 70’s. Nuff said!

[@yashpalrana.2451]

Yes

[@khwajahasantehami2480]

You know you know you know..........its irritating 🙄