Should police be made independent, like judiciary? Explained by Ex IPS officer Rajan Singh

[@StudyIQEducationLtd]

Watch former IPS Officer Rajan Singh’s all videos here kzbin.info/aero/PLpuxPG4TUOR7j9nsScL6yZNoiAbULuAOD

[@abhyudaysinghparmar6055]

Video hindi m ho toh thumbnail m hindi linkh diya karo hindi reach badh jayegi

[@rajeshpradhan3979]

Agar police ko sarkar transform ya suspend nehin karsakta to police apna man marji karenge sarkar ki koi bhi Kam ko barabar nehin karenge, to sarkar ka koi Matlab nehin hoga

[@rajeshpradhan3979]

Ek kaam karsakte hai police ko dekh rekh Karne keliye ek team banaya ja sakta hai jo judiciary se controle hoga, agar police ke birudh koi complain karna ho to log wahan complain karsakte hai,or wo judiciary officer ake enquiry karega or action lega, aise me sarkar kisiko bhi Kahan transfer Kare police ke man me dar rahega, 5 block ko dekhne keliye ek office rahega court ka appoint officer

[@Sagar_Raw_V8]

Sir please make this series a never ending one I am in love with it.🇮🇳🙏

[@User11aus099]

Really got addicted to this series.... Big thanks for giving valuable information sir🙏🙏🙏

[@hdhemraj]

Sir I'm preparing for RAS and I want to become cm of Rajasthan... I was thinking about this question for 2 years... Finally I'm satisfied with your answer... Thank you sir... I think police And education system need revolutionary change... One more thing We have to make our villages smart than smart cities... And finally food, water and air must be pure... Thank you...

[@shubhamagarwal7151]

Really like thought process and reasoning of IPS Rajan Singh. Addicted to his videos.

[@priyathakur4569]

Yaa .. i also agree wd u... police ko kuch hadd tak independent hona chaiye

[@satyajitchattopadhyayyt]

Whole political system, voting, judiciary and police system should be reformed.

[@NikangVideos6377]

The govt in power(MPs,MLAs, ministers) is the only independent (almost) machinery in India. The judiciary is partially independent. The executive (IAS/IPS/all other govt offices) is just a servant of the govt with no independence at all.....

[@Amitabh_vlog]

सर , आपने पिछले वीडियो में बताया था कि पुलिस के मुख्य रूप से 2 काम है । 1st लॉ एंड ऑर्डर , 2nd इन्वेस्टिगेशन । यदि पुलिस को सिर्फ लॉ एंड ऑर्डर के लिए उपयोग किया जाए और इन्वेस्टिगेशन के लिए अलग स्वतंत्र डिपार्टमेंट बनाया जाए , जिसे न्यायपालिका से नियंत्रित किया जाए । इस पर आपके क्या विचार है?

[@neerajkumar4891]

Investigation ke liye CBI, CID, NIA ye sab to hai. Aur kya chahiye?!!!

[@RahulYadav-op9ob]

उत्तम विचार है.

[@rishisingh6677]

@Raman yadav haa bro you are definitely right . Khas kr CBI

[@azad_687]

@@neerajkumar4891 these departments are nothing but the tool of central govt which is used for their political interest due to direct control by central govt.

[@puspendrapatle7900]

@@neerajkumar4891 ji छोटे-मोटे मामलों की जांच एनआईए और सीबीआई थोड़ी ना करती है इसीलिए तो थाना की पुलिस ही चाहिए और मृत्यु जांच का अधिकार तो सिर्फ पुलिस को है इसीलिए लॉ एंड ऑर्डर के लिए अलग से पुलिस होनी चाहिए और इन्वेस्टिगेशन के लिए अलग से

[@kbiswarup82]

Sir I, personally agreed with you,that there should be a regulatory authority to take care of postings and transfer of police. My suggestion is that,if possible, the body should be constructed by CM of the state, rajyapal of the state, Principal Judge of high court, and one MLA of each opposition party of that state.

[@User360iskon]

Great idea sir to make police force less influenced by politicians. Plz give this suggestions formally to whoever concerned.

[@mahendraomg]

This is one of the best series so far. Study iq-- great thanks

[@riponsingha8841]

Salman Khan hit and run case yaad h na

[@bhuwanbhaskar4979]

ज़रूरत नहीं है पुलिस को स्वतंत्र करने की बस आवश्यकता है, पुलिस को ईमानदारी से अपने काम को करने की। सरकार क्या करेगी? स्थानान्तरण ही तो करेगी न । यदि हर एक पुलिस कर्मचारी अपना कार्य ईमानदारी से करेगा तो सरकार भी थक जाएगी स्थानान्तरण करते - करते।

[@AnshulJain]

Simply 2006 ka Supreme court ka Prakash Singh vs. Union of India wala 7 directives of Police Reform wala Judgemen implement karna hai. 👍🏻

[@farhanreza8435]

Is the system of judiciary independent in a true sense???

[@chandanyadav2703]

Do you have any doubt about you? If yes then how?

[@vanni.]

Yes, if you have any doubt then you don't have any right to stay in this country 😎

[@shashankverma3963]

Surely u must doubt..,😂🤷‍♂️

[@s.s.n9285]

Definately not indpendent

[@s.s.n9285]

@@vanni. who the hell r u to give any bdy right to live or leave the ountry in that way we hindus considerd u guzzar as sabsey jaahil type ganwaar who dnt have hygeine nd uncivilized

[@Riju317]

Sir please make video on Licensing process of Gun in INDIA and the possibility of getting a Licensed Gun for a civilian

[@ayushraina9803]

bhai jack chahiye hota...h..or sifarish... lekin boht sir khpai h... har election me jama krvana pdta h....

[@shubhamverma-uw5xp]

I totally agree with you sir police ko politics se door rakhna chahiye

[@saurabhsharma2630]

Sir Apki baton se kaffiii points clear hojate hai 😎❤️

[@sumanta474]

Sir ,Very well explained .We are all aware of these alarming issues in our policing system but no one is talking about its solution except you .I guess you are going to the right direction in making policing more effective ,corruption free & independent .In this age of information ,I hope every responsible citizen should come forward,raise voice ,contribute and solve this issue for betterment of our country since Governments willingly wont allow police to work out of their control .

[@j.r.ranjan313]

Sir I am a lawyer in high court, I agree with you that a sho has the most difficult work in public server but what I see that the department structure is such that it does not reward his work, an ips officer like can get 6 promotions to be dgp but an inspector is hardly promoted to deputy superintendent before he retires, the reward structure is such

[@puspendrapatle7900]

सर आपकी बात से पूरी तरह सहमत हैं और पुलिस रिफॉर्म के लिए जरूरी है जो आपने बताया लेकिन जैसी सोच आप रखते हैं आपके ही स्तर के अधिकारी ऐसा किन्हीं कारणों से नहीं सोच पाते जबकि वह चाहे तो ऐसे हालात ला सकते हैं क्योंकि देश को आईएएस और आईपीएस भी चलाते हैं ऐसा मेरा मानना है

[@swarupdas8048]

Great explanation. And real experience.

[@lordjhony9974]

Indias perfect यूट्यूब जनरल and current affairs etc;channel

[@sumitgupta-nu7xm]

One nation one police

[@pokegem8733]

Few years back I had the same solution in my mind..

[@sumanpatra3295]

Good perception,yeah it should be

[@gauravraj8043]

Police should be made accountable to Govt. But not through their control.

[@RahulDONga]

sir,.. agar jurisdiction independent he to delhi me rato rat judge ka transfer knyu huva???

[@saminder987]

sir,... rato raat nhi hua, february 12 ko transfer ka order de diya gya tha supreme court dwara

[@pokegem8733]

Judiciary is independent but as sir said, they can be influenced and even appoint judges who will favour the govt. Supreme Court is one big example. Hightcourt judge was about to punish the real convict but Supreme Court transfer him a little early. So judiciary is independent but can be influenced.

[@Amankumar..597]

Yes , police should be in the control of govt. But there also should be an independent body who regulates the transfer of police personal . Why = suppose, if there is a case when a police officer handling a case against any minister who is a part of ruling govt. will directly influences is duty and he can send his transfer to any other place and bring a new officer in charge there who he take in his side by corruptions or make him fear about his future. So I think police transfer regulatory body should be made and independent . Who can be the member of regulatory body as per my perception = A retired and honest IPS officer + a retired H.C judge of that state from where the transfer is done + A retired SC judge + A nominated person by president. Process = majority .

[@jobin2295316]

Beautifully explained 🙏🏿🙏🏿

[@amishakumari2451]

Sir we can do something by taking these measures 1 fix their tenure 2 promotion acording to thier performance and seniority 3 transfer with valid reason 4 officer upper rank of sp should be given autonomy 5 there should be an independent panel consisting of retired judges who will review only work performance and activites of all the civil servants not only ips or ias if anyone found guilty then they should be treated by law

[@shivam8385]

Really informative videos by Rajan Singh sir...... Thanks to study iq for this initiative

[@gulshantirkey5464]

बहुत useful लगा सर👍😃👍

[@Thehumanity95]

Ek time period kar dena chye ki min 3years ek PS mae rehega uske badh transfer hona hoga,,,

[@birendraprasad]

Oh ho... Judiciary kab se nispakchh ho gai sir... Judiciary aur police Rich aur netao k liye hai... Ham garibo ko to yesey hi jina hai aur Marana hai....🤔

[@V7B817]

Brilliant sir. But sir ye kya digitalize nahi hona chahiye taki jiski posting galat jagah huyi hai ya galat hai vo khuch action le sake aur oppose kar sake.

[@Unexist612]

Thanku sjr apke kary ke leye

[@kamalnagar1604]

Very good and thought provoking sir

[@vitthalchavan7578]

Excellent job sir , you are making very useful videos. I must say every should know that kind of info.

[@AbdulRehmanhec_]

Judiciary ko Govt k Control krnay k liay kia Steps krnay chahiye is Pay b video bnao

[@anilyaduvanshia]

Correction/Reforms in police & it’s rules , is a must and it should become an ideal for entire world..! It should show new path in policing...!

[@vijaypratapsingh6716]

I love listening to him

[@raviguravannavar1567]

Sir doing great job continue the series

[@ashishshah4407]

Sir please aise videos continue rakhe. Thank you Jai hind🇮🇳

[@adarshsoni03]

Trial krna chaiy... 5year ya usse kam k liy

[@ganeshsontakke1954]

Thanks for this greatfull thought🙏

[@AshishSrivastav1]

I have no faith in Judiciary or Police.. They are not doing anything to make it up to me... I am an Indian citizen.

[@varindermohanbhandari9006]

Only solution is that no criminal ,gangster ,mafia ,rapist , mentally related and having links with Gangsters should not be allowed to contest any election.

[@kamalkantpatkar]

Sir i m totally agreed with u.....mujhe b lagta hai k kuch had tak police shoulb be independent like judiciary

[@saif7623]

Exactly transfer and posting should not be in the hands of politicians

[@Ranjeetsingh-hu4ud]

Sir ap bahut ache video banate ho

[@detailedanalysis940]

Police regulatory me control judiciary ka ho toh iske kitte side effects honge ya fyada hoga

[@kvijayinstitution6682]

Sir please make a video on police dadageri in market and local area

[@bhupindergoyal3010]

Sir i am your fan after watching your videos. Very nice analysis 👍

[@VeerSingh-nh5rl]

Sir आप foreign मे क्या system है usper बात कीजिय्, जिस काम के लिए आपको सरकार ने foreign भेजा था, उसकी output कहाँ पर दी

[@bhaktirasamritam5130]

Right, bilkul sahi kaha sir

[@stockbuzzr9217]

Sir, I like your content it is very much informative :; aap jaldi upload kijiye. THANKS SIR.

[@prad949]

I think police should be made independent like Judiciary. Not only this, both Judiciary and Police should be given financial autonomy to the extent of running the administration. But still political parties try to influence the lower judiciary through administration and their relations with higher authorities.

[@manashdas163]

Addicted to your videos sir.. Really...

[@ADARSHMISHRA-jj5og]

Awesome explanation sir

[@vibhorkala5144]

Perfectly laid out

[@ankitkushwaha7208]

Thanks for information sir great video

[@kdewangan5999]

Yes, no doubt.

[@manjeet4861]

Achcha suggestion hai sir

[@gordhanjat4501]

Not independent like judiciary but autonomous and accountable to parliament

[@azad_687]

A very comprehensive lecture. Specially I liked it because of same opinion of my on this (police department) which is most effective institute of our societies and day to day life.

[@prashant0833]

We really need it... Sir why don't we start a compaign for this? Sir please start nd write this to government .we will support.🙏

[@rajudas1704]

A TO MERE DIL KA BAT KIYA SIR

[@sujatamahato8537]

Yes so that politicians could not control them, but definitely few exceptions should also be provided.

[@aashishchauhan5948]

I was actually thinking over ir for quite a while. Police do need certain independence from legislators. Right now UPSC recommends transfers and postings of IPS Officers throughout the country but there recommendations are only advisory in nature I firmly believe that there recommendations should be made obligatory on the govt.

[@AjeetSingh-gz2ez]

Sr CBI k bare Mai bhi kuch bataiye ?

[@Ultimate_Learner]

Thank you for very good series

[@ammarsohail8384]

Sir, Jo commission ya police regulatory body hogi uski appointment and removL balanced kar sakte h.... Jaise ek group banaya ja sakta h which will consist of Leader of Opposition, P.m, chief justice etc and shall be appointed and removed by them only.

[@mr.shinchan2003]

How to do .....sabb policemen have to filed case in court

[@pragti1234]

अगर ऐसा होगा इंडिपेंडेंट तो सैनिक शाशन लग जायेगा और आउट ऑफ कंट्रोल हो जाएगी

[@DhirajKumar-rx8hi]

Yes.....govt ka kaam hi km ho jyega

[@TheFlashes007]

@@DhirajKumar-rx8hi to fir police ko gali deneka bhi hak nahi.... Aap achhe neta chuno pahale

[@happybirthday1234]

Nice suggestion 👌

[@gyansagar13233]

सर एक्सीडेंटल व्हीकल के बारे में बताइए कई सालों तक पड़े रहते हैं और खराब होते रहते हैं

[@FLumitT]

Sir great work You are doing

[@shrirangjoshi6831]

जी सर मै भी निजी रूप से मानता हूँ कि पुलिस डिपार्टमेंट को भी स्वतंत्र होना ही चाहिए-- w/o undue political interference and a sringent action must be taken against politicians who deal with the police the wrong way.

[@vipulrauniyar1519]

Isn't the 'Minimum tenure Act' a solution?

[@nitinpandey4283]

No sir, bilkul nahi...It would be disastrous for country

[@Atheist-Libertarian]

Very good idea

[@RITESHKUMAR-wh6qw]

Yes

[@shashiposte1358]

Nice topic sir....

[@roystar2270]

Superb video keep uploaading

[@Rahul_only]

Thank you sir for 🙏

[@dcsharmagyanganga]

If u were a judge then wt u think and do sir ?

[@RahulYadav-op9ob]

पुलिस की ट्रांसफर पोस्टिंग ज्यूडिशरी के अंडर में कर दे तो सरकारी दबाव एकदम से समाप्त हो सकता है.

[@sachinyadav007]

Ask urself with current scenarios is the judiciary is independent now??

[@rishabhshahdeo5245]

On paper it is 😹

[@chandanyadav2703]

Yes, police administration should be independent of political domination. Like recruitment and transfer should be done by independen organization of police.

[@AjaySharma-vj8ty]

सही बात। पुलिसका काम पहले‌ जो रिपोर्ट करता है उसीका सुनता है ।गलत हो या सही।

[@anokhsingh2281]

Thanks

[@bhartiyamudra9394]

Sir, please make a video on " why police dptt can't be made an administrative subdivision under judiciary, why it is kept with home ministry." This will partly erase the matter of arbitary control over posting and security of tenure. Home ministry can ally as a collegium with SC / HC judges in the matters of police administrative matters

[@Shubham_Pawar14]

Don't make police department independent .... But there should not be any pollitical influence on them... Not only police i believe when politics enters in anything.... That thing gets destroyed

[@Shubham_Pawar14]

@@naveensingh6029 polliticans impose tremendous pressure on police department ... Also they treat police as a dog .... Police can't take action unless until they get orders from upside

[@amitagarwal8646]

100% right sir

[@deveshupadhyaya5347]

Right Sir 👌👌

[@kovvadakrishna]

Sir Delhi riots mein faliure of system ke upar ek video dijyee plz.......u r too good sir.....

[@harishchander2521]

God bless you everyone

[@rootpurehappiness6071]

जज भी बिकते हैं, सर जी, बस कीमत सही होना चाहिए।🙄🙄🙏🏼