Remember My Little Pony Creepypastas? ft. Raymundo 2112

[@ChanceTheCheetah]

I usually read pony horror stories every year for Halloween. It hits harder when the terrible things in the story are happening to characters your care about and in settings you're already familiar with. Where as other horror stories have to buy you into their characters and setting, why you should care about joe schmoe

[@Shunks]

I didn't mention it in the video but I completely agree. I get that w/ rainbow factory especially

[@BerkeLy2003]

Its likely the reason "Come and Learn with Pibby" is getting so much love and attention these days, And for good reason too. Stories like: "Something Sweet to Bite" and "Home is where the Harp is" had inspired me greatly in my own work, and honestly I pray to GOD it doesn't become a trend to make shows like Pibby, I still.want shows like Pibby to still keep its punch.

[@sagaevan9641]

i think i love the idea of mlp creepypasta honestly. of course it's a bit upsetting to hear about bad things happening to characters you love but it can not be disturbing in this context as long as you aren't taking it seriously. i listened to a dramatic reading of the rainbow factory a few days ago and it was quite frankly the funniest shit. the juxtaposition of candy colored horses going "fuck! shit!!! damn hell!! bitch!!!!!!" and then being turned or turning others into big bloody piles of meat and goo is objectively very silly. on a similar note the mlp x phoenix wright crossover fan videos, i think they're interesting and it's compelling to see the plot unravel, but when you take a step back you can't help but laugh at the absurdity. scootaloo was arrested for murder. it's great. i love this stuff as an adult but i can't fail to mention that all this was genuinely disturbing to me when i was a child, the show's original target audience. of course the internet is not generally a safe space for children but when there's something made for kids, crudely perverting it is maybe not cool. i don't think i'll ever be over it.

[@fern9096]

i think i actually like thought of one then told my friends and like creeped them out

[@wxzzandploosh3648]

@@BerkeLy2003 I hope Pibby gets made into an actual series and it’s not just an April Fool’s/Halloween thing

[@genzhours9466]

I've always found it weird how Pinkamena is canonically just Pinkie's first name, and a representation of her when she's feeling sad, but the fandom just decided that she was an evil alter ego

[@null-x8y]

I mean, what did you expect out of the internet? Its a show for kids (well not really but ya get what im trying to say), of course theres gonna be SOMEONE that creates a creepypasta that later on becomes famous, it happens to every fandom with someone adding something creepy to the show, game or whatever, if theres nothing creepy about a certain fandom, it just ends up boring, so uhh... Welcome to the internet

[@Marilynn_1275]

@Ik Oh! I didn't know that. Thanks for telling me!

[@silverkip2992]

@@null-x8y it *is* a show for kids though

[@lainaballls]

@@silverkip2992 that’s what they’re saying, yeah it’s a kids show, but this is the internet and there will always be someone who doesn’t care if it’s a kids show or not. They’ll make something creepy and fucked up about it. People don’t care 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@Gooberpatrol66]

The implication is that her original self is mentally fucked up but she represses it under a forced cheery exterior

[@nivi1904]

'"are these stories really just as scary as they were back then? or were we just nine years old?" the fandom: Y E S.

[@kittyrosefaerie7464]

Me, sobbing from fear on my drive to work as I listen to this video: yes😭

[@marialovesshires2385]

I was just 11 years old 😭 good times

[@StarDustwolf77]

I was 7-

[@hello-hx3pd]

@@StarDustwolf77 lol same

[@hhmairah]

Dude I would tell you my age, but the you'd know I'm still basically a kid

[@Mooms]

Cupcakes was actually written before “Party Of One” aired, so Pinkie was her normal self in the story, not Pinkamena

[@tiffany-chan1235]

Wait hold up?! It did....Damn

[@tudoraragornofgreyscot8482]

It shocked me too, it was too perfect.

[@magpiesoddities]

Woah I wonder if the writers took... inspiration

[@failyore2]

Honestly, I love the fact that you're right. It's such an obscure and overlooked fact haha

[@Mooms]

@@failyore2 I think that since Pinkamena is supposed to be Pinkie’s “insane” side in fan works people conflated it with the Cupcakes fic

[@babeysheep]

I'm surprised that I haven't seen anyone mention Butterflies, I think that's a really good one. Love stories where the villain just genuinely thinks they're doing the right thing, and I think that fic does it pretty well. Apple Sleep Experiment is pretty good too.

[@shywithsprinkles_5619]

Who’s it written by? I’d love to check it out

[@babeysheep]

@@shywithsprinkles_5619 Butterflies is by adcoon and An Apple Sleep Experiment is by Magpiepony, both on fimfiction. :)

[@nehka_6438]

You can also find them narrated by “The Lost Narrator” :)

[@sethx1327]

Honestly like the only mlp creepypasta that actually upset me

[@sky-sx5gt]

Butterflies reminds me of cupcakes because of what happens in it.

[@CharaViolet]

"Pinkamena" isn't a name made by the fandom. Pinkie's name is canonically "Pinkamena Diane Pie", with Pinkie just being her nickname.

[@egk2.010]

Finally someone said it

[@Idk-yj3dr]

I always get annoyed when people call cupcakes pinkamena.

[@hydrashii]

THANK YOU I see so many MLP creepypasta videos saying that's how "the fandom dubbed her" when it's just her actual name

[@healingalternatives3254]

True but it has become the more popularized for “evil pinkie pie” probably because she’s more serious and not going by a silly nickname anymore (I’m probably wrong about the reason but that is the popular term for evil pinkie pie in the fandom)

[@corvidmorgue]

me discovering mlp creepypasta at the age of 8 fucked up my brain development i think. 10/10 would do again

[@skylarthompson299]

You should probably go to a therapist or talk to someone if you think that’s the case. Or I’m overreacting.

[@corvidmorgue]

@@skylarthompson299 well im kinda joking but im pretty desensitised to violence in horror movies.

[@skylarthompson299]

@@corvidmorgue Alright then….I’m sorry you had to see that when you were eight lol, to be honest I discovered a few fan fictions or concepts when I was young, like Pinkamena or Cupcakes (not sure if I actually read Cupcakes until I was 11 or younger) and Story Of The Blanks, that was before I could get past the scary ponies, now I can or have once years later or a few years later or a year or months later? And Luna Game, I saw gameplays and actually downloaded the games after, and due to seeing the gameplays I was probably desensitised to anything scary or I didn’t care at the kind and didn’t straight up SCREAM and probably watched the scary stuff happen in the game while playing or played some music or a video to block out the scariness, I’m not sure. If I did that without the TV on or if I ever did that in the dark younger me probably would’ve had or had nerves of steel.

[@StarDustwolf77]

I saw smile HD, .MOV, sweet apple massacare when i was 10

[@GarfieldsTeapot]

SAME -

[@sunbirth4795]

Worth noting, since im good with this stuff! -The creator of Luna Game back real recently, and even made new versions of the old game after revealing themselves! -the author of Why I Stopped Watching My Little Pony still writes in that universe today, and theyve gotten steadily better as theyve gone. I even wrote one that they deemed canon, and helped edit their most recent one, which is going up on fimfiction this halloween! -the author of Rainbow Factory... yeah, you know the drill by now, they came out as gay, got a boyfriend who helped them write a few sequels, its all compiled in a published book you can buy, youve heard it before -Theres a hidden mode in Story of the Blanks where you can build your own level. Thats it, just thought it was cool.

[@freshcupofangst]

What's Why I Stopped Writing My Little Pony?

[@sunbirth4795]

@@freshcupofangst god damn it

[@freshcupofangst]

@@sunbirth4795 Oh damn I was really out here thinking that was like a spinoff or smth my brain didn't realize that was a typo 😭💀

[@nothinpurrsonal]

Yo where’s the link to the printed version of Rainbow Factory?

[@treintaydos4830]

@Pindé Yeah! Izzzyzzz made a video about it not long ago

[@Figgy_Jub]

Cupcakes didn't scare me, but it did upset me after, since it pretty much made the fandom consistently associate Pinkie's whole character as a psychopathic murderer instead of the Pink ball of fun with a hint of crazy. Eventually it died out for the most part, but it's still a tough thing to swallow.

[@ArteAn4rchy]

Ya agreed , cuz when I rewatched MLP everytime I saw pinkie pie im like "guys shes secretly a psychopath"

[@NoNo-vv4vo]

context for sweet apple massacre: it's a grossout fic of Big Mac abusing applebloom and other school age ponies in That Kind of way, it gets pretty damn violent and that's why the video author is giving it a hard pass. Just putting it out there so nobody goes 'owo wats thi-' and looks it up on their own. Allegedly someone wrote it to... get back at someone for camping them in an xbox game? I don't know anymore, the spite would explain it being as shallow surface-level shock as it is.

[@brandoncole5533]

Are you serious about that last part 🤣🤣

[@VintageToilet]

Thanks for this. Because I hated how she mentions it in the video but didn’t really explain the issue of why it’s distasteful. It peaks my curiosity as a viewer as to how horrible it supposedly is. But now that I know it’s truly disgusting I’m gonna make sure to steer clear of it.

[@Hey_How_Does_This_Work]

I remember hearing an audio version of it. I may have been 13 I think. I think I remember someone having someone else's tongue fed to them. Don't listen to it. 6/9/23

[@NoNo-vv4vo]

@@VintageToilet in fairness its always 50/50 whether adding Some of the details still causes folk to search it on curiosity doomscroll but yeah, glad the description helped. (For anyone still curious: the horses in question die from what's happening to them, its not worth reading it, its a beige prose one-shot trollfic anyway. Like when you put aside the edgy edge or you're disaffected by edge in writing its just... boring?)

[@NoNo-vv4vo]

@@Hey_How_Does_This_Work yeah there's a lot of pony fic readings on youtube, there's some good horror readouts (I liked One for the mystery suspense/build-up with Twilight Sparkle roaming an empty Equestria, warning for sad more than anything) but I'm guessing someone took it upon themselves to make audio of apple massacre :| which is pointless as its not a gripping story, its one mans' (alleged) trollfic because he got beat up in call of duty. There's no redeeming value, they're just doing the other kind of nsfw and not age-gating it at that point.

[@bush_kit]

If you want a good grimdark, I’d strongly recommend “The Friendship Test”. It’s in short about Starlight testing the Mane 6’s friendship in deadly ways. The voice acting is incredible and the story will make you shift uncomfortably. 10/10 would have nightmares again.

[@lautarogomez9711]

I remember it..gosh starlight glimmer went too far

[@CitraStitches]

It's good but it's literally a rehash of Would You Rather which is a fucking phenomenal movie

[@IAMSUNLOL]

I love that one.

[@shangothunder1055]

I'd recommend "Something Sweet To Bite" featuring the candymare. It's possibly the most long running underrated professionally written ultra grimdark Fanfiction series of MLP FIM on the Web. You all have to check it out there are multiple stories!

[@brokenpayphone]

WAIT I THINK I READ THIS ONE ONCE BUT I DON'T KNOW, GIVE ME THE PLOT?

[@lottepouwels4926]

I remember being really into all these darker mlp stories. So when my younger sister one day came home with one of those mlp magazines full of puzzles and such, I was surprised to find a page dedicated to "making rainbow cupcakes with pinkiepie." The people that made those magazines were either really in touch with the bronies, or not at all.

[@najpotenicewolf934]

I would presume 'not at all' option. As pinkie baking rainbow cupcakes would be something pretty normal for someone who didn't know about the 'Cupcakes'. Probably oblivious children advertisement.

[@sta._rina]

Maybe it was both. The magazine peeps probably knew what they were doing with the cupcakes but the higher ups were obviously none the wiser and approved it because "pinkie pie haha silly cupcakes"

[@trixabellian]

god i remember a creepypasta that was literally just about the guy taking some online mlp test and saying how much he wants to see twilight sparkle in knee high socks and then he dies or something. weird.

[@sirsnausages2164]

me

[@lautarogomez9711]

Wait what!?

[@daphnerogers4277]

Oh I remember that one. From memory there was a part where the game basically broadcasted all the photos he had of Twilight in knee high socks on public television at one point?

[@NoNo-vv4vo]

this sounds like a trip lol

[@ethank6452]

If this is real I'd love to know the title so I can read it.

[@Curttehmurt]

The part of Cupcakes isn't the story itself but the fact that it was posted before Party of One aired. The collective shock when Pinkie loses her grip on reality and Rainbow Dash of all ponies is sent to retrieve her for the Surprise party. I remember audibly gasping and laughing like "No Dashie don't go in there! Shes gonna turn you into Cupcakes!" That was one hell of ride

[@boopers6741]

Does anyone else remember Twilight's Dollhouse or is it just something only I was traumatized by? It was a story where Twilight got super paranoid that her friends would leave her and she would have no one left, so she lured a bunch of them to her house one by one to drug them and turn them to dolls and it got really dark. Like I think she got upset at Bonbon at one point and pulled out all of her teeth.

[@jayisabluebird]

I'm fairly certain I read this one, if it's the one I'm thinking of. I can't see hotplates the same way again. Yeugh.

[@boopers6741]

@@jayisabluebird Oh boy I almost forgot about that. And the CMC getting played with like normal dolls and getting torn apart and put back together? Nightmare fuel.

[@AmicaSecret]

Who cant forget about The Elements of Insanity?

[@lautarogomez9711]

Ohhhhh, yes!!. The invertedshadow was very famous by that!!

[@dr.doctor4878]

Oh yeah?! That was amazing! I WANT TO NEXT CHAPTER. I want to know what happened

[@AmicaSecret]

OMG 101 LIKES

[@Diamond_sleeps]

Omg- that's the first thing that came to mind

[@AmicaSecret]

@@Diamond_sleeps to me too XD

[@Flemmli1]

Cupcakes never sat right with me, because I just kept thinking "Those cupcakes would taste so bad." Flesh and blood just don't mix well with sugar and icing if you ask me. Rainbow Factory at least makes some sense, as one could probably find a way to extract color particles from anything and use it to make a rainbow, especially when a rainbow isn't naturally created by light being broken up into all the colors one can percieve.

[@The_Hush_Dragon]

Someone actually tested that by using common meat that would taste like human flesh and baking them into cupcakes.

[@kittenmitten2948]

@@The_Hush_Dragon what did they taste like

[@The_Hush_Dragon]

@@kittenmitten2948 I believe they mentioned it tasted like pig meat.

[@xxscribbledragonxx9744]

i always just assumed it was cuz the ponies are magical, maybe their flesh and blood would taste sweet or smthn. Same with rainbow factory, The Pegasus Device was powered magically iirc so there was probably some fucked up magic stuff going on there

[@not_anymore]

@@xxscribbledragonxx9744 yoo are you actually the real Scribble Dragon? omg dude no way. i'm a fan

[@gelleries]

I read Sweet Apple Massacre when I was 12, years later I can still say it's the most awful fanfiction I've read. Even if you're a fan of gore or noncon (why) it's just layers upon layers of utter trash. Also especially stay away from it if you're young, I remember I read it because some KZbinr I watched said it was "tHe dArKesT mLp fAnFiC" and I wanted to prove how "mature" I was to myself. Warnings are there for a reason.

[@xmelancholic4418]

It's just horrible, it's not even scary anymore it's just, it made me sick reading it when I was like 10. Awful.

[@inactive904]

I read it for the same reason at also a VERY young age, wanted to feel mature and edgy. Utterly gross and disturbing, i just- i know a lot of artists don't condone things depicted in their art, but i can't help but wonder what goes on on the mind of Sweet Apple Massacre's writer.

[@gelleries]

@@inactive904 Yes, I am a writer and I often write about gorey things, but I could never take it to such extreme, not even if I tried. I wonder how they feel about that piece of writing being out to the public forever.

[@inactive904]

@@gelleries Same, my friend. My art usually touches on gore and other things not safe for weak minds, but i don't know, that fanfic was just horrible.

[@najpotenicewolf934]

Yeah, I have read it as 13 years old and it was a really bad experience. In my case, I wasn't trying to prove anything but was just curious. I've read gore fics before. But the noncon is so gross and unnecessary.

[@EnchantedSewerCheeto]

Crazy to think about how I literally grew up with this stuff

[@imamegadisappointment]

Same and i actually enjoyed it. God I was edgy back then

[@jay.5768]

@@imamegadisappointment same 😭

[@mace-18]

Same

[@Sweetie_Belle123]

Same, I was too young to understand any of it tho-

[@SophieBerry]

Same-

[@Raymundo_2112]

That was an awesome video! Thanks for having me on! I loved working on it!

[@alterworldstudios3934]

I hope you do more collabs in the future!

[@pegamationproductions6062]

Shunks has banned me on his Discord server and blocked me on Twitter for no reason at all, do not listen to him.

[@Bleakaboo]

Heyyy Raymundo

[@alterworldstudios3934]

@@pegamationproductions6062 aha... probably for good reason with that attitude 7_7

[@Icheasea_T]

Oh yeah! That’s a good one! I should def revisit it!

[@nevershoutemma3637]

The cough genuinely upset me when I read it for the first time. There's just a genuine sadness and dread attached to having to sacrifice a friend for the greater good, only to have it be in vain in the end. One of my favourites to be sure.

[@pandapuke]

there actually is an 'evil' applejack! an apple sleep experiment has oOoOO spooky applejack, but then again you could argue that it doesn't count since it's based on an existing story lol

[@Duke-Orgulje]

Let me guess, The Russian Sleep Experiment?

[@F5dfgvjh82j68]

I love the applejack sleep expirament

[@yourfavtswiftstan7341]

I remember being super scared of Luna game but it was pretty cool if you think about it there's an in depth video all about it on izzzyzzz channel

[@alexiskuwata]

Hi.

[@yourfavtswiftstan7341]

Alexis Kuwata Omg another Dr fan hi!

[@imperialguard451]

id love to watch it. but because its her, i know it has like 12 ads on it. she puts so fucking many ads in her videos.

[@mothxii5598]

@@imperialguard451 Thats how she gets money, use an ad blocker or skip to the end of the video then press the replay button to remove ads

[@pegamationproductions6062]

@@imperialguard451 Same. Combined with the forced sponsors she does in every video and you get a completely unwatchable video.

[@pinkieglitterheart]

the cupcakes that turned into the muffins series (the pinkie goes to jail and continues with or so ) was my favorite version of it

[@jigzigsaw]

i hope u talking about the one with derpy and babs as apprentices of pinkamena that shit was the bomb

[@vixymix101]

Same, it was so goof

[@tystotallyradicaltoenail]

@@queeniedramanicole9427 That fell through, creator has a video on their channel that mentions it.

[@tystotallyradicaltoenail]

@@queeniedramanicole9427 Were you a fan?

[@tystotallyradicaltoenail]

@@queeniedramanicole9427 Cool, I liked a lot of the concepts in the series like ponies actually tasting like various (mainly) sweet foods resulting in colourful flesh and blood as well, because magic fantasy ponies. Makes the whole no one notices the pony in the cupcakes a lot easier to believe.

[@thelostnarrator]

This is actually a really good time capsule for most of the high profile grimdarks during the 2010s. It's so good in fact, that the next time someone asks about MLP grimdark, I'm going to slide this over to them lol (It's a lot better than my ramblings. LOL) Both you and Raymundo did a phenomenal job with this, and I hope there are more videos like it. I always love seeing what people thought about certain fanfics I've done readings of or helped with the creation of it. I'm definitely subbing. :)

[@somedudevista]

E

[@melissadeleon4512]

Agreed, Losty! Agreed. You have very good videos!

[@themyofmy]

*insert the "BEYONCE?!" meme but it says "LOSTNARRATOR???"*

[@jerryqueer]

AYE

[@TheBlueJay69]

OMGNOFUCKINGWAYTHELOSTNARRATOR

[@Wowzazazaza]

I remember I accidentally came across the Story of the Blanks as a kid. I never understood it was horror because it was My Little Pony, but I do remember it feeling really off. I don’t know I think I should replay it again for some good nostalgia

[@CJCroen1393]

*Blanks

[@aribee8533]

Same exact thing here!! I was really young and played on the Equestria Games website and came across The Story of the Blanks. I didn’t understand the story but it was definitely unsettling but for some reason I always went back to playing it to not be scared of them anymore

[@humansvd3269]

Ruby best pony.

[@xmelancholic4418]

Most of those creepypastas terrified me when I was 10. But now I think it's funny to think of those times. But the one that I can't read again, it's Sweet Apple Massacre. Not the best experience for a 10 year old I guess. Sometimes I think it caused some kind of trauma on me. But hey, this video made me nostalgic, I enjoyed it

[@gelleries]

I'm seeing so much people mentioning this and I'm glad I'm not alone. This really did f us up.

[@xmelancholic4418]

@@gelleries same, I think it really f me up. Glad to see I'm not the only one.

[@jxllobunzzz]

How are they funny?

[@johntheleafeon8107]

@@jxllobunzzz humor.

[@jxllobunzzz]

@@johntheleafeon8107 what does humor mean?

[@winxy5191]

Sweet Apple Massacre was literally one of the worst things to happen to my 11 year old mindset I am SO glad you didn't wanna talk much about that trash of a story

[@nottartaglia]

I liked the video but the "I'm not going to spoil it, go check it out" was slightly annoying as I personally would of just preferred a run-down (and it could of been put in as a "spoilers, skip to (insert time here) to avoid"). good video otherwise, I like the halloween sprites and editing

[@mycelium_moss]

same, sometimes i'm highly disturbed by stuff like that, especially fanfiction, given how much worse text descriptions are for me (for some reason i just really empathize for text specifically) actually that was the reason why i never read the fallout equestria, I'm not so sensitive on gore, but some completely random cruel things might be very offputting for me, like the r..p e stuff from the beginning of fallout equestria or the theme of illness from the cough

[@ApricityGlow]

Yeah, I've only ever dipped my toe into dark MLP stuff, not really seeking them out. I will most likely never go check any of them out because I'm sensitive towards things of that nature. I'm curious to know what the twists are, but not that curious. (I have read The Cough though. That wasn't too bad, as it wasn't about gore for the most part, but it was super sad and shocking.)

[@yoboyteengohan7242]

The creepypastas are bad, but the fan art is on a whole other level - my personal favorite (most disturbing) is the pic of Pinkie (Pinkamena) crawling out of a TV. Shit was creepy af, and I can’t look at the pic w/ a straight face to this day

[@freshcupofangst]

Sounds like a parody of The Ring(?)

[@lautarogomez9711]

@@freshcupofangst that's because it is!!

[@shangothunder1055]

Try "Something Sweet To Bite" featuring the candymare? It's possibly the most underrated professionally written ultra grimdark Fanfiction of MLP FIM in the Fadom. It has like 6 entries and two have narrations on KZbin. Warning it's not for the faint of heart like at all.

[@frontfacingzim576]

Cheerilee's Garden was a grimdark which was actually really well written. You can guess who it was about lol

[@Sweetie_Belle123]

In like 3rd grade I read a fanfic of Babs seed getting bullied and attempting suicide- I hope whoever wrote that is doing ok-

[@jigzigsaw]

applejack grim dark is rare but so well done when ppl *do* write for her . like crapplejack & any applejack doing witchcraft/“earth pony magic” for any purpose was badass

[@fiveythefox3318]

The only creepypasta of mlp that scared me and made me sick was Sweet Apple Massacre. I can't see Big Mac the same also Luna is the first to be an official Creepypasta since it was made in May 14, 2009 (open beta) and Sonic.exe was 24 July, 2013 . That means that was the real OG.

[@gelleries]

Same here, Sweet Apple Massacre is awful

[@deeznutswilliam9433]

Actually sonic.exe was made in 1995

[@Top10Dylan]

How the fuck was Luna game made in 2009 when the show came out in late 2010?

[@fiveythefox3318]

@@deeznutswilliam9433 I go by the release date of the game not when he was brought up.

[@deeznutswilliam9433]

@@fiveythefox3318 Yeah I'm talking about the release date ofc.

[@najpotenicewolf934]

The fic that will always be close to my heart: Silent Ponyville. I know it is basically Silent Hill in the MLP world. But I feel like it still stands strong on its own. Especially to someone who didn't play Silent Hill games. It was my first introduction to the Silent Hill series.

[@Groza_Dallocort]

Gutiuserenade have a reading of that story on his channel

[@pessimisticfish]

I loved that story

[@angellove3607]

There actually is an applejack grim dark that is kinda popular to my knowledge called the Apple sleep experiment. It's really well written, has a narration on KZbin, and even had a song about it's I haven't finished watching the video yet so idk if it was mentioned but there was a point where you said there wasn't a scary version of apple jack. So I just wanted put this here. ;w;

[@gelleries]

RIGHT! I remember this!

[@frenchvanilla7165]

I just listened to a narration of that one not too long ago

[@purplepartytigerd1598]

Yup, by The Lost Narrator Edit: correction, Magpiepony wrote the story, and Lost did a narration.

[@PrederNationteam74]

Sorry but rocket to insanity will be the best grimdark ever made

[@frenchvanilla7165]

@@PrederNationteam74 Rocket to Insanity was so good! It made me a TwiDash shipper lol

[@Infinite-sj9mj]

These creepy pastas got a lot of gore fans joining the fandom. You can still find tons of mlp gore speedpaintings on KZbin in 2021

[@lautarogomez9711]

Wait!?. They still do it to this day!?. I thought they were gone!

[@Infinite-sj9mj]

@@lautarogomez9711 Nope. I still see a lot of them regularly

[@finalfroggitapproaches6418]

That’s so wild to me. What a mashup of cultures. Gorehounds: “I like gruesome depictions of disembowelment.” Bronies: “I like cute, brightly colored cartoon ponies!” Gorehounds: “I’m interested.”

[@wowisntitanamazinglyamazin9550]

@@finalfroggitapproaches6418 "you had my interest but now you have my attention"

[@truckerbrony2571]

Something Sweet to Bite: The legend of the Candy Mare. A classic not officially touched on. And then you got the ones still being written by the likes of Scribbler and Lost Narrator. The tales coming out of the Rainbow Factory are what got me into the fandom side of MLP back in the day. Came in through the back door you could say😈

[@mizzyfrizzy2402]

Oh my gosh the Candy Mare one was the first mlp creepypasta I listened to

[@TJ2T-MAL]

They did a kinda not really prequel/sequel and it gave me life💚💚💚💚💚

[@purplepartytigerd1598]

Lost was actually the first person I subscribed to when I first joined KZbin. Been watching her content for about 5-6 years now, happily anticipating each Halloween and the specials she puts out each year.

[@shrimppee3player563]

Oh my god I remember listening to that story !! It was so good and probably my favorite Mlp creepy pasta, especially the art in the videos :D

[@shangothunder1055]

@@shrimppee3player563 There are multiple sequels you should check them out.

[@wolfumus]

I've recently been going down a rabbit hole of these creepypastas for fun, and too many people online have Sweet Apple Massacre put up on this podium like it's something great. It's poorly written, it has nothing to do with massacre, and it should have never been written. It's absolutely disgusting.

[@animationtrash5389]

The cough by far was my favorite, especially now, it’s about the horror of having to kill someone for the best of everything and dealing with guilt, with COVID and stuff we can relate to it extra hard and it hits home now

[@briarbat]

10:17 If you’re looking for an evil version of Applejack, technically there’s Apple Pills from the Elements of Insanity series!

[@ixchelmartinezchavez4433]

Or An Apple Sleep Experiment

[@linfoxof2013]

Truly surprised no one has mentioned "Cheerliee's garden" yet. This was my absolute favorite mlp grimdark fic back in the day, and i would still re-read it! I loved the way the deaths were set up, and with the added sequel, how mentally fucked up of an ending it reached.

[@Groza_Dallocort]

That story have only been dubbed to like 50% so far

[@smellophone]

Now all I can think of is a Cupcake’s remake where it’s a fun 80’s slasher instead of a snuff. I think Pinkie would be a fun slasher character lol

[@karak962]

you're so wise

[@epoulin4284]

I remember so vividly being a 7 year old obsessed with my little pony being like “Ooo a mlp video” and proceeding to get severely traumatized

[@XPsunnygirl]

Im glad to hear I wasnt the only one who had an irrational fear of jumpscares because of these. Still gets to me sometimes when a game feels too calm

[@nothinpurrsonal]

I have no idea why people looked at MLP and decided to write some creepy stuff with it but yeah we all have the same childhood scarring huh? To be fair though A Puppet To Her Fame is one of my favorite stories

[@wowisntitanamazinglyamazin9550]

Oml I remember listening to the audio version of that in middle school. Great story. Also horror fans like writing horror

[@Groza_Dallocort]

Yeah childhood...

[@Elli-gl7gu]

Man these really were just "I'm 14 and this is true horror"

[@nattify743]

Honestly, in my opinion, Rainbow Factory felt more like a Danganronpa execution for a bunch of ponies than "ohhh so scary!!!". It just didn't have that touch that stays with you and haunts you.

[@baydiac]

​@monstrous_maws As soon as V3 came out with the warning that Kodaka himself was finally being allowed to design the executions, we knew they were gonna be messed. up. And they sure were! He didn't mess around :,^)

[@gloomiiii]

@monstrous_maws gundhams execution made me cry for like a week, he was my favorite

[@CJCroen1393]

Story of the Blanks remains my favorite of these. I remember it being something of a trend that fanfics would occasionally reference it in an offhand manner whenever Apple Bloom is involved, like this one Trixie redemption fic where the CMC are heading into the forest and there's a brief moment where Apple Bloom freaks out when Scootaloo suggests going down one of the paths and is all like "Trust me guys, you DON'T wanna go down there..." Trixie goes down it instead, and she _bolts_ the minute she learns what's in it.

[@thisisastrobbery363]

You gotta link this

[@CJCroen1393]

@@thisisastrobbery363 I'm nervous about posting links in KZbin comments, since they get marked as spam, but the fic is called "Getting Back on your Hooves" if you're interested. Note that the Story of the Blanks reference is only one small part of the story.

[@freshcupofangst]

This definitely wasn't a creepypasta, but I remember reading this short EQG comic strip on DeviantArt where Sunset was eating marshmallows, decided to look up what was in them, and learned gelatin was/could be made from horse hooves and was traumatized.

[@xg3m1n1xX]

I remember when I was younger I found a rarity creepypasta where she started killing and skinning her friends to use their fur as fabric, can't remember what it's called but it was pretty good

[@Missmoondweller512]

I think it was called “Rarity’s New Patterns” by EdPlus777?

[@CloudySkiesOfficial]

Yep that's the one. And it's still up on YT

[@umpahumpah2962]

0:32 that Twilight picture is deeply unsettling like how did they make it that terrifying omfg

[@vixymix101]

Kinda wish you mentioned more about muffins in the cupcakes section, cause let me tell you it's super good, there's read alloweds on KZbin made by the creator (before you say anything, yes ik the creator was hacked, but she was able to get back her channel, so all the videos are back up) it even includes some nice art. It fleshes out everything a whole lot more, even including Pinkies sisters, Applebloom, Babs and even Derpy. If you want more of a story to cupcakes, that's your go to series, there's a LOT to it. It even goes into detail on how the massacre started.

[@msicouldntthinkofafunnynam4770]

holy shit a fellow muffins appreciator?!

[@phagocytic1718]

i was obsessed with muffins as a kid and i’ve literally never heard anyone talk abt it

[@msicouldntthinkofafunnynam4770]

@@phagocytic1718 fucking same, i wish there was more (good) fanart of it i always wanted someone to animate it in the style of the show cuz the renders of the characters in muffins always looked show accurate too

[@Lewis_McCartney]

Ahhh yes muffins has been stuck in my head for years! 🎵" Element of magic, isn't it so tragic, she lived a lie and now she'll die and her cakes will taste fantastic!"🎵 has been burned in to my mind for literal years ( might have gotten the Grammer wrong idk I only know the Audio, sorry) It definitely kept things uhhh "creative" at least from what I can remember.

[@msicouldntthinkofafunnynam4770]

@@Lewis_McCartney i just wish it would get finished its been on hiatus since like 2017 i think i would love a faithful animated adaption but i highly doubt anyone would delve that much time and effort into it

[@Darling_2.0]

The only creepypasta that actually made present me genuinely nauseous was 'Cherrylee's garden' Maybe because of the extreme stuff?? I still think most of it it's gore for gore's sake, but i actually felt bad for each character that died, and the ending really shocked me! worth a read!

[@Zodia195]

I can't remember where I heard about that one. I just know I did somewhere on KZbin.

[@DanielVesp]

You have probably not read/listened to Sweet Apple Massacre, because that one is MESSED UP

[@axogothl]

I was hoping someone would mention Cheerilee's Garden! Definitely fond of that one

[@mikanwithagun8419]

We’re can I read it?

[@DanielVesp]

@@mikanwithagun8419 there's some people reading mlp grimdarks on KZbin if you just search up the title on KZbin. If you want to read it though I'm not sure.

[@Schr0jun1]

I think rainbow factory would work more if instead of literally killing every failure from the test, they put them to work in harsh conditions and they work their until they die, it would be more real and depressing than the whole “grinding ponies into rainbows” also removing rainbow dash would make it better too since she was just ploped in there for the sake of it.

[@LastNameWasTaken]

This doesn’t qualify as a creepypasta but I distinctly remember a creepy video that was twilight sending a letter to Princess Celestia talking about gods and becoming one, paired with a news voiceover about bodies being found partially eating at SugerCube corner. The only visual was a dim view of g3 twilight. The OG video has been purged from KZbin and I have not found it since. But it freaked me out as a kid and intrigued me at the same time. I don’t think I’ll ever get the distorted twilight voice and weird flesh tearing sounds out of my head….

[@snazzy9175]

Maybe take this to a lost media community! I'd be interested to listen to it if it ever gets found

[@aubreyskipper9642]

NGL "The Cough" was actually well-written, Kinda wished that it wasn't with ponies though

[@gdunknown4037]

Something Sweet To Bite is still the best after all these years. Nothing even comes close. Knackerman is still one of my fav grimdark writers. I think A Puppet to her Game and Cheerilee's Garden: Scarlet Harvest also deserve a mention. 2 deep, psychological stories.

[@yanderedeku2902]

I agree....

[@lahannasingh8598]

Agreed Candy is such a great villain. As much as I loved the Mean 3 and Discord they ain't got shit on her. Forget Luna Candy is the real queen of Nightmare Night 😎 ( sorry Luna please don't be angry at me you are still my best pony 🥺)

[@FaeFixion]

It’s A Puppet to Her Fame

[@miiqai]

I never see people talking about "My Little Amnesia," i used to be so scared of the video with their voices and images + Speedpaints, only to recently find out it was a fanfic made in 2011-2013

[@CloudySkiesOfficial]

I was actually a little disappointed to find out they hadn't mentioned it. Although I never really knew much about it, it always had seemed terrifying.

[@miiqai]

@@CloudySkiesOfficial it was one of the first things i remembered when i thought abt mlp creepypastas, but at the same time i knew nothing abt it besides that one vid. I found a fanfic abt my little amnesia but it had nothing to do with the video, and its actually really sexual for a mlp creepypasta fic

[@justinecourtneysgavel89]

God, there was this one mlp creepypasta game I remember from when I was younger. You followed the story of a mare who was looking for work in the town of Ponyville, eventually leading to her getting hired at a mental institution run by Fluttershy. Eventually you find out Fluttershy has been mutilating her patients and selling them to the circus. The ending was very heavily inspired by the song "Dark Woods Circus" and it genuinely terrified me as a kid. Can't for the life of me remember the name of it though.

[@p-__]

The game is named Part Time Job.

[@mlpsecrets7931]

The Apple sleep experiment...... It was then that I knew my favorite type of horror because it mentally broke me. It wasn't just Mindless Gore it had a story, a story that disintegrated and broke the structure of my mind. I could not go to bed, I could not stop thinking about it, and yet I could not stop watching it. An at the end, the way Applejack called for Twilight when she wanted to know what happened to Apple Bloom. **sighs** Excellent

[@ccappa2001]

I got no sleep from that too

[@lyndonleedalee1738]

I listened to a reading of The Cough when I was younger. Definitely my favorite.

[@2D.is.anxious]

I was OBSESSED with the elements of insanity cupcakes rainbow factory and lil miss rarity 😂

[@doethundermelon]

I played Story of the Blanks when I was about ten or eleven, completely unaware that it was a horror game and I remember having the shit scared out of me when I examined the fireplace and the enemies started coming after me. Nowadays I think the game is pretty cool considering it is a creepypasta thing but yeesh, the childhood trauma. xD

[@humansvd3269]

Story of the Blanks is the classic best one. I wrote a story of a human with an ak47 fighting the blanks and saving apple bloom. My thumbnail is my pony OC being hugged by a blank pony zombie.

[@yourfavtswiftstan7341]

I remember being so scared of the creepypasta but now I see it as pretty cool work

[@finalfroggitapproaches6418]

This fandom was horrible for my development, honestly. I was an unmedicated, cowardly, Panic Disorder having bullied kid with unchecked anger issues and unbearable psychosis. (AKA: I was in eighth grade) Between the creepypastas boosting my psychosis and anxiety to learning about sex from Banned from Equestria Daily and Princess Molestia dubs, it’s really no wonder I turned out the way that I did. (Mentally ill, distrusting, a maladaptive daydreamer, asexual, fearful of everything, and award-winning fanfiction author.) I was on TikTok the other day, and heard Rainbow Factory for the first time in years, and in the past five years nothing, I mean NOTHING, has triggered my fight of flight response like that did. In one second my hackles were raised and I was a terrified 14yo stumbling across yet another disgusting My Little Pony rabbit hole that was no doubt going to give me terrible fear-induced hallucinations later. Cupcakes, SMILE HD, all of the .exe series (which looking back on, totally slaps), Rainbow Factory, and a metric crapton of tumblr ask blogs have wounded me unlike anything else. MLP was my biggest comfort, HOWEVER, it was also probably the most harmful thing for me at the time. Hooboy, I haven’t even started the video yet, and I’m all kinds of fired up and also kind of scared to bring back any memories I managed to repress.

[@heckarockstick802]

Bro you good?

[@your.gay.cousin]

I have a drastically different diagnosis goin on but MAN I relate, especially about MLP generally being a huge comfort and source of misery at the same time 😭 wishing you well, froggit

[@svetakuklina8398]

Cool. My favorite MLP creepypasta is "A fleeting light in the darkness"

[@Bocqurant]

Oooh that one is really good

[@sunbirth4795]

I just didnt understand that one honestly

[@brandoncole5533]

I listened to a voice over of it and that was good But I couldn’t find the continuation So I was left confused

[@micdingles]

To think I used to read these in the school’s computer lab, things were too easy to find back then lol

[@nightbloomgarden8488]

My heart dropped and I paused for a moment when I saw Big Mac, because I just had a flash back to the amount of disgust and anger a particular one with him involved.

[@FaeFixion]

Sweet Apple Massacre?

[@alexiskuwata]

For some reason I want an animation of My Little Pony theory. Edit: why does the cough sound like what's going on now?

[@alainwolf146]

The one I had the most memories with was The Truth Behind My Little Pony (I vividly remembered listening to CreepsMcPasta's narration on it during class).

[@maiagarcia3777]

I once found a story where pinkie pie and rainbow dash bake ponies into cupcakes and extract they’re color to make the frosting look more colorful

[@tiffany-chan1235]

Shunks? Talking about creepypastas with Raymundo2112? OH HECK YEAH!! Also, my favourite MLP Creepypasta is "The Reason I Stopped Watching My Little Pony" and the series that came from it and "The Experiments Of Twilight Sparkle" I also enjoy Story of the Blanks quite a bit

[@solentsquared6719]

i am so glad u mentioned mlp snes, i remember it so vividly and i’ve never seen anybody else mention it- a narration i watched had an image of twilight with blacked out features and a lesson zero type smile, it kept me up at night for YEARS

[@ICanFightBrendonUrie]

21:07 As a kid I would be terrified of any and all screens in my home, especially when I went to turn them on because I'd expect to be jumpscared or something. Honestly didn't expect to find someone else who had this fear as a kid when they were in the creepypasta/scary internet stuff phase thing too lol-

[@heckarockstick802]

Holy shit me too!

[@frogberriez]

im 19 and still have moments like this occasionally lol

[@Firebender554]

I just imagine someone at Hasbro seeing Story of the Blanks and the next day bursting into the conference room screaming “GUYS I KNOW WHAT TO DO FOR THE SEASON 5 PREMIERE!”

[@cattifratti2891]

Perfect for the holidays TYSM SHUNKS!

[@Skaabma]

I once listened dubbed version of Rainbow Factory. Acording to the dubber, Wooden toaster's song was inspired by the fanfic not vise-versa. Also Dubber mentions that there is the messy original fanfic and the simplified fanfic whitch he choosed the ladder because it more made sense than the caotic original whitch is literal Rainbow Dash feverdream.

[@Groza_Dallocort]

LostNarrator have reading of that story if you want to listen to it again

[@wavelengthrecords-1]

Well the dubber was wrong, because Glaze has the full story for how he came up with the Rainbow Factory song in the first place and it was uploaded first.

[@Mistressofthelostones]

You forget about friendship is tragic which is about the mane 6 being messed up by a war you should cheek it out.

[@summersweete09]

I’m following a narrator do that story right now! It’s really good

[@FaeFixion]

I found one of the same name where it’s a humorous parody

[@DreamingNightmares]

When I was little (before I even knew about the pinkie pie creepy pastas) she was always my favourite because even in season 1, she was so happy and crazy that I generally believed that she was some sort of phsycopath with dark intentions that will be shown in later seasons but after seeing the creepypasta, only then did I realise that it would never be canon and I was so disappointed that she would never become a villain of pure insanity.

[@amythetoon6535]

being obsessed with this stuff when i was 12 is probably one of the reasons that i love horror today

[@Pinkie_pie_the_pink]

My favourite scary mlp thing is a comic called the surprise trilogy (it’s about pinkie)

[@Bocqurant]

Oh my god I’m so happy you made a video on this! Soooo nostalgic

[@The_lamb_sauce]

10:54 can we just talk about this right here,Someone took the time to draw Thomas the tank engine and Twilight sparkle blushing at the idea of being a couple.

[@AoiUsagiOtoko]

so, fun fact about cupcakes, someone actually wrote an entire concept album/"rock opera" style thing about it, with some extra headcanons of their own. the album is called "something broke: the continuing tale of pinkie pie and ponycide" and it's REALLY interesting as a weird old piece of brony fan media. TWs for violence obviously, and for mentions of child abuse in pinkie's past. there might be other upsetting stuff too, i haven't listened to the whole thing in like...a decade more or less. so enter at your own risk sorry if this was like...a weird comment! i just think of it every time cupcakes gets mentioned, and it seems fairly obscure at this point and figured it'd be a neat little piece of trivia

[@karak962]

oh I'm definitely looking this up

[@genghisdingus]

I remember reading this fanfic called Asylum where Twilight was in an insane Asylum and was certain her memories of the show were real and some unknown villian has taken over equestria. I never actually finished it so I don't know if there's a real ending but it was told pretty ambiguous over whether Twilight was correct about her memories or whether or not she's just insane and imagined it all.

[@berketexx]

The she-ra costume stills are so perfect

[@carolinewheeler77]

Omg…the background art is so cute. Plus the g3 pony art and phantasm footage youre really after my heart here

[@user-ss1yb5fn4j]

I remember being like 8 years old and reading the Creepypastas and then telling them to my classmates to scared them and it worked lmao

[@nhilz]

it's always so interesting hearing the perspectives of people who are slightly younger than me on this stuff. i was 14 at the height of all of this and it really never occurred to me the kids younger than me was also consuming this content. i dont really have anything insightful to say about it, but i still find it interesting

[@emmiesage1173]

Something Sweet To Bite is definitely my favourite

[@scoobydouche9991]

The Halloween Shunks OC is so cute

[@rien6841]

shunks new drip

[@RadiantPercival]

Finding out that Rainbow Dash being the villain of Rainbow Factory and the rainbow sucking machine are supposed to be twists is how I felt when I found out that Dracula being a vampire and Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde being the same person are supposed to be twists.

[@craftezern8392]

I've been super excited about this!

[@craftezern8392]

update: oh my gosh thank u for the art feature omgomg! i love the video so far too!! aaa!!!!

[@casperwashere]

i had to pause for a second when you used goddamn alex yiik as the main character when you were going over mlp snes

[@OrangeSpaceNewt]

The Story of the Blanks made me wanna cry more than piss myself tbh and I wanted to forget it but after being reminded I wanna cry even more now

[@humansvd3269]

Ruby didn't deserve what happened to her.

[@citruslemonade3326]

never did I ever imagine I would get nostalgic over a pony creepepastas but here we are damn being 13 years old is cringy but so fun

[@snowy4909]

My two favorite youtubers collabed! I'm so happy!

[@uniblack591]

The Cough really TRAUMATISED me Holy shit Like I sobbed at my friend's house reading it and it kept haunting me XD I almost spilled my ice tea when I actually heard it mention here

[@ispecs]

This got on my recommendations, and I'm not disappointed.

[@skittay]

years ago i read a mlp creepypasta that was a bad end of the first 2 episodes. when the mane 6 enter the everfree, they all are slowly killed off until twilight, broken and defeated, is the only one left to face nightmare moon. pisses me the hell off that i can never find it again because i loved that story as a child