Sigma 28-70mm F2.8 DG DN vs Tamron 28-75mm F2.8 DI III RXD

[@ihavenoidea7432]

Didn't expect you to do this comparison...great that you did!

[@martin9410]

According to the testing I've read about, the new Tamron G2 (second version of the Tamron 28-75) is better than the Sigma 28-70. However, if you look at the Sigma 24-70, it's close, however the 24-70 is more expensive and known to collect a lot of dust. I have the G2 and it is awesome on a full frame camera! I use it on the Sony A7riii. Plus, the new Tamron does have a button on the lens that can be programed to whatever you like. I've programmed mine to switch between AF and manual.

[@carlosguerrerogonzalez6097]

I am looking into the tamaron G2 too did you get it ?

[@martin9410]

@@carlosguerrerogonzalez6097 yes, I have it. Like it better than the first version.

[@BlueHawk80]

dust issues has long been resolved (serial 55641775 and later)

[@irwinnathanael4629]

Great videos. How does it compare with the new tamron 28 75 g2 ?

[@aboynamedjamil]

I think I'd probably go with the Tamron. The weather sealing and the extra 5mm on the long end sells it for me. Great video Arthur.

[@-_--le3zk]

I guess 7.5 percent crop on sigma will not make photos soft,but yeah weather sealing helps

[@ramspencer5492]

Sigma is sharper, better bokeh, better AF performance... More compact form factor. That tiny bit extra reach is really pretty minimal in real world..... Sigma is the obvious choice, IMO. The Tamron is also a fantastic choice though. The only significant advantage is the better weather sealing.....I never let my gearv really get wet, either way, personally...... I'm sure liked most lenses the sigma can handle the occasional ultra light sprinkle...... When it rains...... Your camera element would get wet anyway..... So.

[@k.o.t.o.n.]

@@ramspencer5492 taMRON IS SHARPER ON THE LONG ENF SIGMA IS ON THE SHORT, BUT THE SIGMA HAS BAD VIGNETING AT THE WIDE END IN THE CORNERS

[@ramspencer5492]

@@k.o.t.o.n. mmmh.... Not bad enough to not clean up easily..... Both seem like really good lenses to me

[@k.o.t.o.n.]

@@ramspencer5492 YES BUT TAMI IS HEVYER AND LONGER, CANT DECIDE, I WANT TO BUY IT IN ADDITION TO SAMYANG 18MM F2.8 FOR A7C FOR EVERYDY CARRY SHOOTING :d I LOVE TO6 CAPTURE WIDE FOR PORTRAAITS AND, REALLLY LOVE WILDLIFE TOO, FOR THT I MAYBE BUY RX100VII FOR PEAK DEISIGN TECH POUCH BUT DON'T KNOW RELLY, WHAAT WEIGHT LENS AND QULITY COMBO WOULD BE THE BEST FOR IF I LIKE TO SHOOT BOTH LNDSCPE AND WIDLIFE EVERYDAY. :D

[@JeremyCWW]

if possible , would like to know how it works on apcs body , I might wanna to invest 1 , and even I upgrade my camera to full frame , I'm still able to make use of it

[@aditya_gupta]

Damn..that tamron is already 3 years old? Time flies

[@Cary_mac]

I’d be curious for you to compare the new G2 with the sigma. I think the Tamron would be on top.

[@martin9410]

According to several tests, the G2 is the better lens between the two.

[@Vern_Levine]

I’m interested in purchasing the Sigma. I’m sort of sour on the quality of Tamron lenses as I had bought the Tamron 17-28 last year and I didn’t like how loose the zoom was. It would shift on me while I was shooting. And I wasn’t impressed by the build quality either. I ended up returning it. Sigma on the other hand impressed me when I had an APS-C system. I had the 16 and 30mm and those were excellent lenses.

[@KyurekiHana]

I actually took the new Sigma to a wedding this weekend. I was acting as the backup photographer, and was mostly asked because they knew I had a camera and weddings are limited to 30 people still. It pushed through like an absolute champ when paired with my Sony A7RIV. So glad I invested in it.

[@YoungBlaze]

I just bought it

[@mohsin_sait]

Man, your production quality just gets better and better.

[@fitnessa1]

You are so cuteeeee marry me!!!! 😍😍

[@jflartner117]

Lol

[@agentjtravel_walkthru4205]

Hey!!!!!!! What a minute!!! LOL 😂

[@DimplePoji]

His lovely wife would definitely like that comment 🤣

[@yusuf_quraishi]

😂😂

[@YoungBlaze]

Return to thy STREETS

[@slglasius]

I own a Sony APS-C but I do enjoy lens reviews for full-frame, just to dream or compare

[@jdannug517]

Would you please do a comparison between the 2470 sigma the 2870 sigma the new Tamron 28-70 G2 and maybe throw in the the 24 to 105 Sony F4??? Is the f 2.8 going to be better and more beneficial or the additional range of the 24 to 105 compared to those others?

[@artmaltman]

How about comparing the G2 version of the Tamron to the Sigma 28-70mm?

[@martin9410]

The new G2 is considered better.

[@DiscoverThailand]

How does the autofocus perform for videos? Is the sigma there better as well?

[@carlosguerrerogonzalez6097]

Hey great video, I wonder what are your thoughts when comparing it with the new version of the Tamron the G2 ?

[@apwip]

The Sigma 24-70 had an internal dust issue, can you let us know if the same issue occurs with this 28-70 dg dn lens.

[@JamesClark1991]

Sigma fixed that issue before the launch of this new lens.

[@amijani5912]

Still have this issue😒

[@miang62]

@@amijani5912 you referring to the Sigma 28-70 or 24-70 ?

[@markfdm6125]

if the background blur is smooth, I'll like it more. Could it be similar or close to the 24-70 dg dn art?

[@frankdelsandro3332]

Will you be reviewing the new Tamron 28-75 2.8 G2?

[@GadgetNeil]

Another excellent video! But could you also use youtube chapters? I find them helpful, for example, I might want to skip sample photos and go right the conclusion or summary. I currently have the a6000 and have been considering the Tamron 17-70, given the kit lens limitations. But I am also imagining eventually upgrading my body to the a6600, and when I think of the cost of that body with the Tamron 17-70, I realize I could sell my current gear and get the a7c with the Sigma 28-70. It's hard to resist the siren song of full frame ! I like a small, lightweight kit, but the a7c with Sigma 28-70 would actually weigh less than the a6600 with the Tamron 17-70. I saw your video comparing the a6600 and a7c, and I agree with your conclusion that upgrading lenses is more important than the camera body. But if I am going to buy a mid-range f2.8 zoom, and the APS-C version is around the same cost and weight of a FF lens, then I wonder if I should make the leap now to FF. These decisions give me headaches ! If I am honest with myself, I know that working on composition, and editing skills, and shooting more often, would help much more than buying new gear ;) But when I see what the a7c can do, compared to my a6000, it is very tempting.

[@Тори-ъ1д]

It would be interesting to know which FF lenses work well on aps-c body. This Sigma 28-70 and Tamron 17-28 especially. Thanks a lot!

[@richdandasan4843]

Thanks for a very compact review. I was planning to purchase tamron because I’m satisfied with the images from my tamron 70-180 mm. Now, I am tempted to get the sigma instead of the tamron considering it’s size and performance similarities.

[@martin9410]

Since it was 4 months ago, it may be too late, but buy the second version of the Tamron, the G2. It is better than the Sigma.

[@electrichimp]

This lens looks like an awesome minimal travel lens. Another great lens for the a7c is the 35mm f1.8, would be awesome to see your review about it :) I'm also very intrigued about that new Samyang 24mm f1.8!

[@mnlt2000]

The sigma it’s a bit soft at 70mm. I got mine last week and did some photo test and you need to shoot at f4/f5.6 for get best results when shoot at 70mm. Good video BTW

[@Life_Of_Gal]

Amazing video Arthur! For someone who is in the market for a 28-70mm zoom. Which would you recommend? The Sigma 28-70 or the NEW Tamron G2 28-75??? 🙏🏼

[@olegvorkunov5400]

Actually, I am planning to sell Tamron one and get this Sigma "C" because of its size and weight to be able to balance it on my M3 gimbal. I can balance Tamron on M3, but it is too stressful for tilt motor, but I guess with Sigma it will be much easier.

[@Mraz75]

Yeah the print saying made in Japan is very strongly printed in my mind. A branding to buy as it gives a safe sound and prolong quality of use. Go with Sigma😊

[@amitkrupal1234]

8:30 Many review assumes Sigma is designed wider, but you mentioned the correct information. Thank you now waiting for Tamron vs Samyang wide angle for APS-C.

[@tallbozo]

APSC Comparison with these?

[@dannyjang9952]

I was about to order the Tamron 2875 but ordered Sigma 2870 instead after watching this video. Thanks, Arthur!

[@pankajvermacs]

How good it performs on APS-C Bodies? Even since I used SonyFE 90mm Macro on my A6400, I started loving full frame optics on APS-C bodies.

[@berdugosocials9854]

Great comparison review. How does the good old 24-70 f4 fair against it? The only reason why I hold back on third party lens is future support ( new camera bodies)

[@n3cph0en1x]

I don't think it's gonna be an issue for Tamron, Sony owns a quite big share of that company. You can consider it as a Sony B brand.

[@berdugosocials9854]

Good point mate

[@AromaFrank]

How is it in comparison with the Sigma fixed lens?

[@dalefrolander3583]

Now that Tamron came out with the G2 version you'll have to redo this comparison with that lens.

[@nimshardmohamed321]

Just wondering if little particles of dust will creep in due to lack of sealed rubber rings in few years 🤔

[@tylerdurden300179]

I would like to see Sony 6600 with a Sigma 30mm vs. Sony 7c with this lense. How would be the bokeh or the sharpness. Thank you for your helpful Videos

[@mohamadavakian]

I was waiting for testing with APSC sensor result Do this please next time and also compare with sigma 24-70 f2.8

[@JeremyCWW]

yeah , i want to know how it works on APSC body too~

[@jonoy4375]

Mini Focus Distance is a key feature to choose between these two.

[@claudiaabadia9300]

Arthur can I use the sigma on my Sony 6500? Or 6400 (I am looking to upgrade)

[@James.Buchanan]

I nearly bought the Sigma for $520 but found the Tamron for $345 and went that route. Can’t get that Sigma’s compactness out of my head though 😅

[@suzijames5601]

I assume this lens wouldn’t work on a Sony a6100. What do you think would be A substitute for the Sigma to use on the 6100?

[@eugenerukin3816]

can you tell me how the lens behaves when manually focusing? does the focus ring have a linear input like on manual glasses or does it depend on the rotation speed?

[@LuisGGomezPhoto]

I prefer the Tamron. Thanks for the comparison.

[@bimalb3151]

can you pls make a video to know the video quality of Sigma 28-70mm F2.8 DG DN with apsc ?

[@gadgetphilosophy8290]

Some reviewers are saying that the tamron is sharper at the 75mm Tele end. Better for portraits. Is it possible you have a dodgy Copy of the tamron.

[@olegvorkunov5400]

I would rather get an Art Sigma than "C" one for a 200-300 more, because it has wider range from 24mm and up, so I do not have to get another lens for wider shots. But I already own Tamron one, so I am stuck with it.

[@Server16116]

That might be your preference, but the 24-70 is extremely heavy (almost double the weight of the 28-70)! Not everyone wants to carry around a 835g lens all day, especially if you do photography as a hobby!

[@umeshshrestha823]

These lens can be used for a6xxx series,right?

[@EbenPajanconi]

You really just cut yourself off with your goodbye at the end LOL

[@DJ_S-3-R-G]

Is this a full frame lens and can this fit on an APS-C?

[@danmiddle2]

Hi Arthur, great channel and good review. I already own the 1st gen 28-75mm Tamron, I'm thinking of upgrading to the newly released G2. Would you still go with the Sigma over the Tamron 28-75mm G2? Many thanks

[@martin9410]

According to several tests I've read, the new Tamron is better than the Sigma. However, with the other Sigma, the 24-70, they are close, even though the Sigma is known to collect a lot of dust.

[@오뜨-h9x]

Thanks for the good video bro. I'm using a7c and I decided to go with Sigma after watching your video. But I'm worried about waterproof. I heard that Sigma's waterproof is weaker than Tamron's. I'm thinking of taking photos and documentary videos in techno clubs and mountains. Is Sigma's waterproof okay?

[@artmaltman]

Please update this comparison with the Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 G2! (Some of us are agonizing over this decision!)

[@martin9410]

From the tests I've read, the G2 is better than the Sigma. However with the more expensive Sigma 24-70, it's close, even though the Sigma is known to collect a lot of dust.

[@elliotscreations5991]

I’ve been waiting for this video!

[@Lamision316]

Can I use this lens on my Sony 6400?

[@DominicSantini]

Now here's my 3 I'm trying to decide over: Tamron 17-70, Sony G 16-55, and Sigma 28-70

[@Server16116]

Keep in mind that the Sigma 28-70 is designed for Sony Full frame, so on an APSC camera the focal length will be 42-105.

[@ramspencer5492]

Yeah. One of full frame.... The other is for APS-C crop sensor..... Apples and oranges

[@networm64]

I hope Sigma dnt forget about making some good apsc zoom lenses too. They have focuced on FF only recently. A 16-105 f4 or even with variable aperture is so welcome. Also hope they make an apsc version of 100-400mm. It's too heavy on crop bodies.

[@kalengankonge6763]

Hey Arthur. I don't have a full frame camera ( i have the a6000) but if i did, I would definitely go for the Sigma.

[@brianbell2176]

Really on the fence over aps-c/full. Looking for possible lens options on each and of course you have the comparisons I'm looking for. Appreciate your channel.

[@pedrotorres5575]

Hello Arthur I would like to know how does the new Sigma 35mm F1.4 DG DN | Art works in my Sony a6400, thanks, great job...

[@chivatech]

Did you update the software on the tamron lens? It should fix that auto focus

[@cristiabc1310]

The lack of sealing inside the lens is a more bigger disadvantage for nature photographs as go-around lens.

[@Cbyrne-1]

Is the Sigma lens a good option for the Sony A6400??

[@GadgetNeil]

I've wondered about that myself, if I should buy the Sigma for my a6000, so that if I move to full frame (like the a7c) I will already have a good lens for it. But the focal length of the Sigma will be equivalent to 42-105mm, not as useful for everyday shooting. Also, the Sigma doesn't have image stabilization, and the a6000 and a6400 don't have IBIS.

[@stefpix]

Won't the Sigma suck up a lot of dust? The sealing may be something important in the long term.

[@JamesClark1991]

Fixed mid 24-70 production

[@stefpix]

@@JamesClark1991 you mean the latest 24-70s do not suck dust?

[@JamesClark1991]

@@stefpix Correct.

[@richerite]

I’m picking up a used one, how can I check if I’m getting the fixed one?

[@falented2]

Wonder how this would do on Apsc🤔

[@MikaelPersson]

Are you going to do a review on the new Tamron 150-500 on APS-C? Thinking about picking the Tamron over the Sony 200-600 because of the size, if it's close to the Sony performance wise.

[@evenios2831]

thanks for the video i think ill go with the sigma then! seems like an awesome investment as a walk around lens!

[@imAnsar]

wonderful review. just a random question, how do you do your screen capture ? looks very clean

[@pdotc]

I just pulled the trigger on the 24-70. However, in receiving it seems very heat for my A7C. Now I'm second guessing, I did get it for about $50 more than the 28-70. For that price I figured it was worth it to get the better lens with the wider range. What are your thoughts?

[@KoelAnderson]

For me I’ll take the smaller , lighter lens even if that means losing 4mm on the wide end.

[@philipkwon3710]

I personally owned 24-70 art for my a7c and ended up selling it with some loss after the new 28-70 news as it was soooo heavy and big for my taste. A7c is all about small and compact and 24-70 art just goes directly against the camera body and I didnt like it. Now I own 28-70 along with 35mm gm, 20 1.8 G, and sigma 65 f2 and those are perfect combos complementing each other very well.

[@pdotc]

Haven't gotten the chance to put it to use hopefully soon. Thinking about keeping it and then just complimenting it with some small primes and a good strap. What straps do you guy use on your A7C's?

[@Talk2Mr]

Do both these lenses work with the cameras built-in lens corrections?

[@ArthurR]

Yes, as far as I can tell.

[@sabinshrestha4788]

tamron 17-70 vs Sony 18-105 videos please

[@cxsparx]

No comparison. The 18105 which I used a lot allows nice low dof, but its distortion is visible especially in OOC jpg, resolution at wide end is only acceptable, wide means about 19 to 20mm, it sucks power due to OSS and large lenses. I still like it but wouldn't recommend it except for video over the Tamron 1770. My 1655 outperforms the 18105 so much it almost hurts my eyes looking at shots with the latter unless you are going for low DOF at full tele.

[@richardsteinbach1121]

please do a tamron 11-20 f2. 8 once it come out, thinking about it but i'm not pretty sure. i would be grateful!

[@ArthurR]

Waiting for mine to ship!

[@JS-df5vy]

I appreciate this comparison. It strikes me that with the 'hybrid' intent of Sigma's camera, Sigma would have made the aperture de-clickable on these recent contemporary lenses. The Tamron's 28-75mm focal range too, is more readily imaginable (full-frame, 15-degree increments) 75-30 FOV.

[@manolito451]

Que tal el sigma para la a6700?

[@danieldougan269]

Is it so much more expensive to make the lens a standard 24-70?

[@tomaszmaslona4586]

Arthur, in every review I've seen, they said Tamron at 75mm is sharper than Sigma at 70mm... Your test showed something completely different. How is it really?

[@piotrgorajek1289]

Same! That's the only thing that makes me keep Tamron

[@anonym5510]

Real world photos and charts inside a room are always gonna produce different results. Both videos ive seen people compare in the real world said they look near identical at the long end, maybe the tamron is a tiny bit sharper but the sigma bokeh and sharper in the corners and wider end id take the sigma. Up to you though!

[@dnle3452]

Thank you for all those lens comparison videos. Your info have always been great help. I have a question about the metering that you use on most of your shots. Do you use Spot, Center weight, or multi-matrix metering setting. Thank you.

[@anuvind-tp]

Hai can you do a review on Tamron 11-20mm f/2.8

[@jimou9657]

I like the smaller Sigma, 5mm on Tamron don't give that much reach.

[@kylesharbrough1817]

I want the small sigma, but I need the Tamron's weather sealing :(

[@felipexakal]

Awesome Arthur! Are you planning to compare the new Samyang AF 24-70mm F2.8 FE vs Sigma 28-70mm F2.8 DG DN vs Tamron 28-75mm F2.8 DI III RXD? I decided to buy the Samyang AF 35mm f/1.4 based on your review and I loved it!

[@titan10kk]

Now you need to do comparison review with the new Tamron VXD

[@miscellaneousid6594]

What do u do with your tamron 28-75. Can I get this lens?

[@ArthurR]

I am selling it.

[@sabrinasolfa7631]

I’m doubting to buy one or the other… I maybe go for the sigma so! Thanks a lot!

[@EverydayRiviera]

This is a very interesting review. Thank you.

[@tbeiber09]

Is this sigma the same 24-70 that was known for getting dust in it?

[@cuorebiancorossoo]

Good job Arthur... I Just buy the Tamron 17 70, mannaggia a te!!

[@enniofalcone1303]

Hi, I've been subscribed to your channel for a long time and congratulations on the always very technical reviews. I own a Sony A7R IIIA and would like to get the sigma 28-70mm f / 2.8 dg dn c. Not being an ART series, the lens is able to "resolve" the 42 mpx sensor in terms of sharpness and detail? Thanks.

[@martin9410]

From what I've read the new G2 version of the Tamron is better.

[@MaxusMV]

Nothing was told about macro capabilities of the Sigma lens in comparison with the Tamron which is famously good at it

[@Fingerscrossedkitchen]

I got the 28 - 70 its amazing! love it and use it for everything now

[@YoungBlaze]

Its really light?

[@Fingerscrossedkitchen]

@@YoungBlaze I would say so yea, didnt bother me much taking it for a spin around on a hike

[@dodgenav6901]

Sold my 24-70 GM for this... Its actually a tad sharper but with noticeable distortion.

[@YoungBlaze]

@@Fingerscrossedkitchen i just bought it!

[@lifeinlenz17]

@@dodgenav6901 was it worth it ? still stuck on them

[@harisankarb4664]

Please review 7 Artisans 75mm f/1.25

[@ulisesgonzalezzuniga7550]

Are you switching to FF, Arthur?

[@ArthurR]

No, I like APSC.

[@dancuaresma0822]

Sir Arthur, I bought mine in Philippines and it says "made in japan". With all your connections/contacts, can you please confirm if this is legit lens? Thank s a lot.

[@rofi3930]

Well if you buy sigma it only produces from japan because its their only factory so yeah its solid

[@dancuaresma0822]

@@rofi3930 yeah i understand Sigma only produces in Japan. Mine is Tamron and is made in japan. So strange.

[@rofi3930]

@@dancuaresma0822 the tamron have a coupla of factory, and one of them is in japan so not so strange

[@dancuaresma0822]

@@rofi3930 so i am lucky i have the one from Japan 😁😁 performance wise it's good. But considering to switch to sigma 28-70 for it's size.

[@urouuroushima5602]

One information in your great video astonished me. You say the Tamron is made in China, either they switched production-location or you took the information from your lens-hood. The Tamron is made in Japan, too. (At least it says so on the lens-body) Just the lens-hood is made in China. Best Regards and thanks for this video

[@ArthurR]

The lens body and the lens hood are both made in china on mine. Designed in Japan, made in China.

[@urouuroushima5602]

This is funny ;) so they either have to sites where they produce em or they shifted the production-site. I did not mention that I bought it directly in Japan. Maybe that is why Regards

[@D-Ogi]

@@ArthurR Mine Tamron body is made in Japan (and designed in Japan). It's hood is from China. I bought it in Poland (EU).

[@lilrr1431]

Hi can you recommend best lense that is sharp for a6000? I bought the sony 35mm 1.8 from your recommendation but not happy with how blurry and zoomed in the lense is?? Help please?

[@rosyaugust7095]

Great comparison. But I will be leaning to Sigma.

[@TaffytheGreyhound]

Cute family, great review and side by sides. Think I will get the Sigma, thanks!

[@SmarTime.]

Im a Sigma fanboy too, cause i love the 16mm and 56mm for Apsc Cameras. After i switched to fullframe i bought the Tamron 28-75 for my Sony A7iii. Im from Germany and in Germany the Tamron is 150 euro (~190dollar) cheaper. So there is no reason for me to choose the Sigma. Maybe for the small A7c Body the Sigma is the Right Lens. Thx for the nice Videos and Comparison. I love your Channel.

[@srgremlin]

Hey Arthur, while I like the way you do the comparison and presentation I noticed a few times that I don't entirely agree on the conclusions. Of course opinions are personal and everyone is entitled to their own but I think in many reviews Sigma comes out "on top" because you carry a tripod around. Can't say for everyone but a humble guess would be not many of us are having either 6500/6600 or tripods with us all the times so no in-body stabilization is a big issue. That's what turned me off from Sigma long ago and I never looked back.

[@martin9410]

Actually the new Tamron, the G2 is shown to be better than the sigma.

[@agentjtravel_walkthru4205]

Anyone selling one??? I’ve been trying to get one for my A6600.. thank you for this awesome video!!

[@bamdevsharma3905]

Get the tamron 17-70 f2.8(24-105 equivalent) instead. It’s wider as well as zooms much farther. And it is stabilized too. I think it’s a better option for apsc shooter than these full frame lenses.

[@agentjtravel_walkthru4205]

@@bamdevsharma3905 thank you for the suggestion!!!

[@makeitsimple90]

can those lens performed well on APSC? Why not you make a review with those lens on APSC. I would love to watch it.

[@charlestonealmacen]

It's a waste of money dude. If you want a zoom Lens, There's a Tamron 1770 for apsc or sony G 1655

[@ArthurR]

This. 100% spot on. 28mm isnt wide enough on APSC.