SILVER MOUNTAIN WATER VS CLUB DE Nuit SILLAGE VS MUSKY GREEN TEA! (Which Is Better!?)

[@terencedennis3972]

Just bought my Sillage today. I think I'm becoming addicted to buying fragrances. It's a real habit

[@nofnway9918]

Never smelled Creed SMW. But the guy that use to work for Creed said Sillage was better because it's what SMW used to be. So I purchased Sillage and it's a beast. Funny everyone says it's missing the metallic feel. 1st thing my wife said when she smelled it was "it smells like wet nickles"! I ain't paying Creed prices when Armaf keeps producing better versions of their products for a fraction of the cost.

[@zeusandathena4094]

Thinking they was George from fragrance apprentice

[@nofnway9918]

@@zeusandathena4094 Exactly. Once he made that video I knew I'd never purchase a Creed. I'm collecting fragrances that I enjoy wearing not fancy bottles.

[@zeusandathena4094]

@@nofnway9918 it's just the cost. And if you live in Ontario Canada, like me, it's insane for shipping. But George was blantly honest, and the fragrance community acknowledges this

[@milesdavis9588]

He is to me such a good reviewer. The honesty and he actually "reviews". We dont have to say the name real ones know.

[@nofnway9918]

@@milesdavis9588 Oh you mean spinning, clapping and speaking broken English isn't good reviewing? Or how about swaggering your way through a generic "top 10" list? Who'd a thunk it? 🤣

[@LouiePHSC]

I picked up Sillage and it performs very well. Not sure I'll buy Silver Mountain Water again.

[@loganmosling3314]

I love the fragrance by elmers glue behind you! Very unique dna, and it dries really fast which is nice.

[@rogerwilliams330]

🤌🏿🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@diegomahoudeau934]

Lmao

[@SalemPhiladelphia]

Hahaha i was like what?? Since when?

[@cyclebreaker5947]

Armaf Sillage actually outperforms the newer batch of Silver Moutain Water.. Compliments from every angle💪🏾

[@TheLegacy125]

Sillage every time I wear it I get multiple compliments per day from strangers It's truly One of the best fragrances

[@GardenState2012]

I have just ordered a Armaf Sillage bottle after watching your review. Thank you.

[@johnw218]

If creed kept doing what they always did making some of the best , quality fragrances , they'd be fine. Once a craft business like this lets the accountants and marketing guys run the show they're in trouble. Customers pay a premium for quality but if the quality goes the prestige goes.

[@MansaMusa-v5q]

It’s called taking the Mercedes marketing model…..our name has such prestige that even if we release low quality stuff people still gonna buy

[@natnielsmith8189]

Amaff is a beast smell so so good ,wear it to work and my supervisor was so amaze by the scent the next day it was still on my cloths

[@nykia31]

Armaf now does Creed, better than Creed.

[@ft3989]

They stopped being Creed to become just Greed, that's why smh

[@alsmith5404]

Thanks for the tutorial fam!! I have the AMAF juice, I'm pleased with it. My pockets can't see that Cred juice. Keep em coming

[@SamuelBarrPhotography]

Sillage is nice! From what I've been told it's closest to the OG Silver Mountain Water. I have several Dossier clones and they have all been very good. You can't go wrong with either alternative.

[@MichealC]

I love Creed but my pocket don’t love that price. Great video.

[@profound369]

Creed biggest share is owned by blackrock the same company that owns all of social media and the facial recognition cameras in china

[@EmeryPete]

I have the sillage it's very potent just how I like it. 👍🏿

[@kabelo_m]

for real? what is its longevity (in hours on skin and clothes) and projection + sillage?

[@bagley232]

great comparison, if you are on a budget get the Armaf, but if you're a collector I think you need to have SMW

[@StricklyEverything]

Just smelled the original SMW and mannnn does it smell amazing! 😍 Definitely got the Club De Nuit Sillage clone

[@holcombgl]

They don't smell the same to me. SMW is very smooth and refine. Sillage is really harsh and has a metallic and a rose smell to it. I hear people always say it smells better in the air. I gave it to my son to try and it was the same for me not good in the air and he hated it also. I would just go decant.

[@jonescurtis1970]

This video is timely, I just ordered from fragrancex “Armaf Sillage” any day now!

[@joshuabrockman_]

Is sillage on discounters now??

[@johngregorio9183]

If you like the SMW you'll love the armaf silage and it lasts hours longer then the creed

[@easternshine8580]

It’s really good!!🔥

[@carlosadame3888]

First time I smelled Creed SMW was some guy at work who sanitized and sterilized. He was around chemicals all day and would wear a haz-mat suit. I could still smell it from 4-6ft apart even with the suit. I asked him the name of the fragrance and I immediately went to the mall to go get mine. I didnt know the price and when they dropped the retail tag on me, my jaw dropped. I sprayed some on a strip and then on my wrist and was disappointed with the opening. All I could smell was the metals. I was begging to think I was being lied to. I went home empty handed. The next day I found the strip in my jacket and there it was. I smelled my wrist and could faintly smell it( I showered)… I went back to the mall and bought it on the spot. This is a fragrance that showed me a lot about fragrances in general. SMW can project and perform extremely and superbly well if you know how to spray it on you. It can even be overwhelming to some people around you but not in a negative way. This is definitely a fragrance where the opening is horrible for the first 45-60 mins because all you can smell is nickels, but once you get passed that.. OMG, you’re going to notice compliments from everyone(married women & my girlfriends best friends). Its become my signature scent. I just hate the retail price tag. If you must have the original from Crees, I suggest you look online in discounters fragrance stores. You’ll be saving at least half of retail.

[@MrCULO-xe5fz]

Musky green tea is a natural scent which 2 me smells great and the Armaf smells 2 synthetic and strong to where it gives me a headache.tried to return my bottle of armaf but they won’t take liquid returns so I’m stuck with a headache bottle but will gift out next year🤷🏽‍♂️.dossier all the way!!

[@emanuelnicolaescu4195]

You are chiken brain bro

[@star_scourge]

Great video bro🙏🏽armaf sounds like the way to go for now

[@altonza]

So glad I have vintage backup bottles for a lot of my Creed frags. Interested in that Musky Green Tea... Great job bro🤙🏾

[@SonyaLCH]

I have it and it is really nice. Not exact, but pretty damn close on my skin. This man's review is spot on.

[@altonza]

@@SonyaLCHthank you!

[@praetorian3571]

For $25, Ajmal Silver Shade is the way to go for a cheaper alternative to SMW.

[@ldgatsmellsgood]

Afnan supremacy in heaven is a great alternative as well. Thanks for the info brother.

[@SukhbirSingh-vf6pg]

Afnan’s Supremacy in Heaven is fantastic in all aspects.

[@ldgatsmellsgood]

@@SukhbirSingh-vf6pg agreed 100%

[@zeusandathena4094]

Agreed. Afnan Supremacy has that nice smokey tail. Damn good

[@lv2465]

Supremacy in Heavens super metallic. Gonna dig out my bottle again.

[@UnclePhilCosby]

My SOTD is my only green tea fragrance, Amarf Derby Club House Blanche 🔥🔥

[@bullboykennels]

for me personally, i get a really really really strong smell of cucumber from sillage, even over an hour later it's still a strong smell to me. Just can't get past that cucumber smell. but CDIM is great.

[@carlos002nz]

A great video, Darian. My recognition

[@Danmandingo]

*Now we're just waiting for you, to do a (Armaf Milestone VS Creed Millesime Imperial.)* 🔥

[@elichisley3031]

Look that buy milestone period it’s dope.

[@TA-ht4jo]

@@elichisley3031 I hear milestone doesn’t perform that well

[@elichisley3031]

@@TA-ht4jo I get about 6 hours. It’s cheap and smells very good.

[@cozcozmo1565]

Dossier Musky Green Tea I like BETTER than the original SMW, great product 👍

[@armonmunyadzwe5494]

Hi BowTie FragranceGuy please do a comparison of Club De Nuit SILLAGE ARMAF and AL WISAM Day RASASI. Which one is a better dupe for Creed' Silver Mountain Water?

[@mrgreen9628]

Hey brother...love ur content....which of these project the longest

[@rko2004]

Got the Sillage recently, tried it on and my wife said "you smell f***ing delectable" 😈

[@teecee1725]

Great comparison video...greatly appreciated the note break down and value analysis of each....well done and informative!

[@deondeon8760]

Enjoyed the reviews bro.... "THUMBS UP"🥊🔔

[@johngregorio9183]

D""" or Mr Bowtie 😏 I've tested em all I like SMW and the sillage lasts much longer then all imo" and the price is great for a 250$ scent

[@salaamal-fayiz2225]

I just subscribed. Great presentation

[@greggraham9785]

Hello Darian, how are you? Great job on the video and comparison. Have you tried to Banana Republic Metal Rain? I t has a similar vibe to me. Thank you and stay safe

[@darklawdshadow5679]

And now lattafa has joined the chat😂😂😂❤❤❤ Armaf and lattafa, sometimes Afnan is killing it

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great compassion 📹 and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try these fragrances and have a blessed 🌙

[@hughcamp2730]

THE SMW today isn't what it was in 2004. That old school SMW projected with only two pumps all day.

[@RichRobertsonMusic]

Hey. I was wondering if you can add your thoughts of the ALT version of Silver Mountain Water. I own the original, Dossier, and ALT version. I think they all smell similar but would like a second opinion. Thank, Rich.

[@carlosortega8228]

Love the Chanel brother

[@marietta1740]

I don't try any other dupe I will say sillage 100% smell like creed once I used sillage n someone said to me r u wearing creed silver mountain this is the best dupe I have ever tried

[@tonypalacios]

My absolute favorite creed fragrance. Silver mountain water is amazing. I have an older Bottle as well

[@emanuelnicolaescu4195]

Go to slepp. Old man

[@Darkseid_80]

Just thinking about this and this pop up outstanding

[@jayliq]

Anyone smell the Alt version platinum water? I’m not crazy about it but I’ve never smelled the original or the other clones.

[@12345gerrard]

All of them are great!

[@michaelsimpson2609]

Is this a Fall and winter fragrance?

[@ryanfaust7400]

👌👌 great information

[@mikeb173]

How long does Sillage last??

[@kluvdadream6820]

10 hrs

[@tvit182]

How good is the SMW clone by alexandria fragrances (crystal peak). I have it ordered and on the wayyy.

[@sheltonpoteat6241]

Sillage smells like a tightly packed ball of snow with some flowers tucked inside.

[@JLaFragancia]

I'm waiting for them to clone Viking, only Creed I'm interested in. Thanks for the video.

[@GiftedGentleman87]

I'm about to buy this, I hope my wife feels the way about this Frag on me as your wife feels about scent on you. 😊

[@chadczternastek]

Great review. Got me a bottle of both and Armaf is just throwing out their AAA game when it comes to saving the average dude cash. Creed is really, straight up doing slick, cutting corner shit, that only benefits Creed. Like less quality and performance in their fragrances, and dropping the volume and keeping the same price. Like why even do that slime ball shit when it costs $2 max to make a bottle. I'm familiar with cost and production, where it's very common that the design of the bottle costs more than the juice. So Creed is feeling the lump that Armaf is getting them in the throat and passing off the loss of profits to the Creed Army who will artificially think Creed is the best, only, and only because they would feel like the idiots they are if they really know, which they do, that they wasted all those extra $

[@polly2018]

Do you think Sillage is unisex due to the iris? I wear man fragrances, but I do have my limitations..

[@notme3686]

You wear man scent. Butch.

[@fragmericanidiot]

The Musky Green Tea starts off great, but the dry down is TERRIBLE! After a few hours it literally smells like piss. I couldn’t wash it off fast enough.

[@dunndoula7373]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@LOGICAL-JAY]

I still have many 4oz and 2.5oz bottles left of SMW, Aventus, Original vetiver and Royal oud..I use armaf, parfum vintage clones on a daily basis and save my authentic creeds for special occasions. The newer bottles are garbage, reformulated and very weak..after they discontinued the 4oz and 2.5oz bottles( around late 2017 ) I stop collecting creeds..

[@mohammadfarhan7917]

I got both and the winner is... not creed. Armaf is the way to go this time.

[@mohammadfarhan7917]

I would also like to add on sillage smells like the older batches of smw, sillage is just better less inky smell too

[@real.m_jourdain7378]

Other Creed reviewers said Sillage smells a hundred percent like the older batches of silver mountain water 👍🏽

[@jrod1333]

Thank you much.

[@HorseIRL]

Xerjoff Mefisto would have been good here

[@ldgatsmellsgood]

Makin scents has a great alternative

[@Mi3940]

SILLAGE 💕✌️

[@sameold5050]

No need for Creed. Don't feed the Creed greed.

[@sabrinawilliamson7011]

Where are the bow ties lately??? 🤔

[@davidjackson4384]

Bow tie guy I can’t believe you didn’t put al wisam day by rasasi on this list. It is SMW 1A. Please someone talk about this fragrance .

[@lv2465]

I own a bottle and yes, that's very SMW in similarity and it's a beast too. But the bottle design is ugly. Which isn't such a bad thing, because if more SMW lovers found out. The price will be jacked.

[@MansaMusa-v5q]

Buy the Mercedes or buy the Genesis clone? Gotta pay to play

[@MansaMusa-v5q]

I will always support the original….I’m all for these dupes slapping the faces of these overprice brands But I will always respect the original house because they created it these dupes are just copying and adding something slightly different

[@Mmjacksom]

When there’s a clone of a fragrance natural is always better than the cheaper synthetic one

[@GoogleGoogle-sw3je]

Not knocking the clones 🤷🏾‍♂️🏌🏾‍♂️but it ain’t tricking if you got it 😂😂 But I’m only buying creed

[@zeusandathena4094]

Must be nice having currency 💰💰😊😊😊

[@GoogleGoogle-sw3je]

@@zeusandathena4094 I pay for what I like I’m not rich by a long shot

[@honestfragrancereviews1500]

Dossier smell good but last 20 minutes.

[@MRWJP4]

💯

[@armagedon0264]

It smells like a hospital

[@golfbuddy1969]

Silver Mount Water (2019) was my first and favorite Creed. I saved my money to get it. I would never consider a clone. Never. I appreciate the vision, artistry, risk, testing, and investment involved in the original, and do not understand how the fragrance community has embraced clones. They’ve created nothing, risked nothing, invested nothing, and had literally no vision except take money from people who convince themselves that you’re getting something for nothing.

[@thetechlibrarian]

Hey I understand the thinking, but it becomes a problem when the original isn’t the same quality as it use to be and has significantly went down hill.it’s not even getting something for nothing, but if I spend $400+ will I even get the same as my last bottle ?

[@golfbuddy1969]

@@thetechlibrarian mine is only a little over a year old, and it last 7-8 hours easy. I think that for a fresher type of fragrance that’s pretty good. And I get compliments every time wearing it. And if wearing fragrances is for personal confidence (in part), how can wearing a clone improve confidence?

[@thetechlibrarian]

@@golfbuddy1969 I understand both sides. I have a bottle of silver mountain water and it lasts long on me, I tried the amarf and it smells synthetic to me

[@silversurfer4680]

It smells like celery...

[@notme3686]

Doubt you smell better.

[@silversurfer4680]

@@notme3686 back off cry baby.