'Similarities Between Hitler's Third Reich and Modi's India Growing Everyday': Avay Shukla

[@ranjanpattayat9916]

I have not heard or seen anybody analysing with razor sharp precision. Not a single word is wasted, not single word is out of place, or anything but absolute truth. If you really love your country, there is no way you could disagree with Mr. Shukla. An eye-opener for all the people of the country. But the sycophants still persist , trying everything to hoist an individual even at the cost of our nation.

[@rameshkulkarni2245]

There many puppies and PIDDies in Cogress nobody will hear these P& Ps

[@ranjanpattayat9916]

@Stallion Spirit you may be right. Many things happen which is detrimental in the journey of our life. A nation also suffers in many ways.

[@naanallamuthu5038]

@Stallion Spirit Hitler also thought he ruled the whole world but his dead body even not identified at the end. Modi kind of low life ends up life like that. Thats what history taught us someone with fascism plus autocratic mindset.

[@ranjanpattayat9916]

@@rameshkulkarni2245 ... You are entitled to your opinion. So do I.

[@diva7892]

@Stallion Spirit ..... "Ayegaa toh" genre, are you??!! Shame modi bhakt!!!

[@PN22863]

" fools multiply when wise men remain silent " Nelson Mandela ...quite intellectual, qualitative & a precise analysis@ Ajay Shukla 👍👏

[@raziashraf6209]

Mr Shukla hit the nail on the head when he mentioned the unforgiving truth that the Indian society remain silent before social injustice. Some he says may be afraid of Modi but what about those who go along with him and agree with his atrocious behaviour and his unjust cruel policies. This means most of the Indian society thinks alike and either sheepishly or willingly follow the route to destruction and tragic divisiveness of India. What shall we call them 'The willing executioners'?

[@parmarja]

In a nation of fools the above adage does not apply.

[@haqiqat79]

@@raziashraf6209 I don't fear modi I like him 🙏🙏🙏

[@raziashraf6209]

But those who look away when fools multiply are actually complicit.

[@snowmoon7385]

Hmm

[@humility786]

Brilliant interview. Mr Shukla deserves much respect for the courage of his conviction.

[@janbour8152]

I suspect Hindu Nationalism was developed by the CIA. It follows the same pattern that has been rolled out all over the world since the fifties to undermine and destroy social democracies and socialist countries. It was developed by CIA director Allen Dulles. And it continued regardless the president. In the US CIA, Pentagon, congress, White House often operate independently, and are controlled by different power groups. Dulles developed the strategy to breed fanatical religious nationalism to counteract socialism as a popular movement, taking an example of National Socialism (Nazism) in Germany which also was a radical religious movement, "Positive Christianity", created to unite Catholics and Protestants against Communism. They used a dynamic cross, the hooked cross (NOT swastika) as a symbol. They converted Jesus from a suffering figure into the action figure that beat the Jews out of the temple.The religious aspect was denied after the war, and the "hooked cross" was named a "Swastika" suggesting evil eastern occult influences. But the Nazis were Christians and Hitler was a devout Catholic and his SS was for Christians only, all soldiers wore a normal cross in their belt. They never used foreign words, like swastika. Basically the US took over the role of Nazi-Germany in destroying socialist and communist countries. Often by the inside out, by creating religious fanatics. The recipe has been used over and over again by the CIA in creating fanatical religious groups to destroy socialism. In Israel the socialist founders were defeated by sponsoring radical Islamic group of Hamas with millions to their leader to replace the non-religious adversary PLO. This allowed radical right in Israel to grab power with the religious fanatics in a controlling position. In the US they created a new kind of fanatical Zionist Christianity, Evangelism that took over the Republican party through the TeaParty movement. In the Middle East they created al these fanatical Islamic groups to overthrow socialist countries (Iraq, Syria, Libya). And in India they created these Hindu Nationalists, who are no real Hindu's at all, except for the people fooled into it,, and only promote war and totally isolate India. And they are used in their war against China. Basically these movements destroy the religions they pretend to defend inside out. And it is not Republicans or Democrats, the powersgroups work together to create this world empire, in which they impose their systems on all countries in the world. And the sad thing is, India is now a victim too. They use "human rights" as a pretext to bring down independent nations. These Hindu Nationalists are long time in the making, I discussed with these people on a Hindu forum years before Modi came to power. I was surprised by their fierce hate against Muslims and total adoration for the US. Many of them lived in the US or had ties with the US. I suspect that they also use high ranking Hinduś that are secret converts to Christianity, as that is how Catholicism operates. I see this as coalition between Jews, protestant and Catholic elite that was created after WW2. You can observe that from the growing marriages between Christians and Jews. Biden is a fanatical Catholic, his son is married to a Jew. His Vice President Pamela Harris is married to a Jew. Same with the daughters of Clinton and Trump. The Epstein affair also shows how the elites have become mixed. Biden is continuing the foreign policies of Trump. Basically they have been destroying the US institutions inside out in their bi-partisan war using each other as an excuse. This is now happening in India, but is also happening in Europe by the EU. In Europe powers from nations have constantly transferred tot EU which is body governed by the elite. 80% of Europeans dislike EU, which was undemocratically pushed on them. The media in Europe are no longer free either. It is all politically correct and in de hands of a handful corporations.. Look at the Middle East, what they haven been doing. They are not taken over the systems, they are destroying the nation states to create this global world order. In Europe and US they are destroying national identity and resistance by forcing endless migration on them (many criminals), and at the same create repulsion between groups. .It is Kali Yuga the age in which Demons come to power. They want world power. It is in the tenants of all Abrahamic religions that they will rule the world. The difference now is that their elites started to intermarry and work together towards that goal. Calling their take over Hindu "nationalism" is a dirty trick. Because they want to break nations, they make nationalist leaders look like evil. All Nationalist leaders are painted as evil in the international press and they do everything to make them fail. Trump did everything to disgrace the presidency. What Trump did was really theatrical play to allow Biden to stamp down on nationalists. But people in US are so fed up with both Republicans and Democrats that many still support Trump. That is how desperate they feel about the corrupt system. Basically the Duch empire was the first cooperation between radical fundamentalist Jews and protestants. They created the first multinational trade corporations and slave trade. This was brought to Britain when a Dutch king became King of England. He laid the foundation for British East Indian Company and thus the British empire. The English nobility intermarried with the Jewish nobility and they ruthlessly exploited people all over the world killing 80 million. Churchill for instance was a Jew, his mother was Jewish, So were Roosevelt and Eisenhower. These Jews and Christians were all huge racists. But their racism is not about skin color, but elite versus common people. It is about bloodlines. They exploited the people in Europe as harsh as in the colonies. They see common people as cattle. Like Churchil said: He casually diverted the supplies of medical aid and food that was being dispatched to the starving victims to the already well supplied soldiers of Europe. When entreated upon, he said, “Famine or no famine, Indians will breed like rabbits.” The Delhi Government sent a telegram to him painting a picture of the horrible devastation and the number of people who had died. His only response was, “Then why hasn’t Gandhi died yet?" yourstory.com/2014/08/bengal-famine-genocide/amp When they controlled Arabia, the English replaced the Monarchy by Jewish tribes/house of Saud and Waab and created a fanatical Islam Wahhabism that is destroying countries from the inside by religious extremists or attack them (Yemen, Syria, Libya). They are armed by secret services of the US, Britain, Israel, etc to attack countries, but were also used as terrorists to deprive people of civil rights and create a surveillance state. In the same way Corana is abused to create new laws to restrict people. They control international media and internet social media to a large extend. They create lots of anger in society that destabilizes governments. It is not that the religions are bad, but these fundamentalists are destroying religion inside out. They use angry activists. These ruthless people are basically demons, modern term would be psychopaths and sociopaths. Their common trait is anger. They create anger and fear use anger and fear. Their activists are angry and violent. Look at Modi how he keeps feeding anger and creating new enemies and uses them to create more anger. They scare people so they get their support.

[@mishasingh8144]

@@janbour8152 wow

[@markpaul1958]

I think such interviews serve to encourage us and dispel our own biases - for me it was that someone in GK Delhi is so forthright with his views. He can't have many friends can he?

[@rajeshpaleth8664]

@@janbour8152 That's quite an analysis! It appeals to my critical thinking. I would enjoy reaching out to you to discuss further if you will permit me to do so.

[@janbour8152]

@@rajeshpaleth8664 I am honored I give my honest opinion freely for what is worth. Of course it is only a personal view, one of many. And my attempt to see things in a broader context is bound to be a major generalization. Are there any particular subjects you want to discuss?

[@ruatarengsicolneyrengsi8924]

I thought I was alone in thinking this way. I am really awed by these two's interaction. I really specially applaud the clarity and guts and patriotism of Mr. Shukla.

[@youtheman1367]

😂😂 the audacity of librandus to even compare hitler with this weak govt.

[@neerajk7030]

Agreed, I was also thinking the same

[@avdeshsharma5137]

Mr. Shukla really thinks about the country and the people of India

[@ronydias722]

9

[@jayanchada859]

Bullshit. Crab Mentality Indian Culture

[@rashidratta4921]

Applause , fantastic to understand the situation , and reveals with courage the truth , that where India is going in future . This person is opening the eyes of the people .

[@IITianProudIndian]

I respect your opinion,but wire is really one sided. Also, i agree that Hitler did bad things and deserve to be condemned, but don't forget that during his time German economy boomed, and he made the people to unconditionally love their nation. Not justifying his actions, but it has to be seen from all dimensions to be unbiased!

[@hamza-p4c]

Everybody knows that but this man has balls of steel to talk it out.

[@danishmansoor1604]

What a beautiful straight forward and bold interview. Well done 👏

[@danishmansoor1604]

@Stallion Spirit True. To serve the nasty people nasty dictataors are befitting. We get what we deserve.

[@yogitasharma9120]

👍

[@danishmansoor1604]

@Stallion Spirit I am not here to emgage on foolish matters. Its your domain. Please continue it. May be you will get some company.

[@iqbaliqbal3896]

@Stallion Spirit Are you loyal and faithful to Geeta?

[@moser3712]

They all speak so slooooowly

[@Dendronish]

Bravo! Finally a man who has the courage to suggest actions against divisive channels.

[@cukookhan9622]

Real Indian

[@truthisbitter2840]

@Vijay Manjrekar well said

[@hoejackborseman1059]

@Vijay Manjrekar IT cell bot spotted

[@TheEnglishator]

@Vijay Manjrekar nonsense!

[@ageless1003]

@Vijay Manjrekar answer his genuine questions, instead of diverting attention which BJP supporters are doing since 2014.

[@lookinglass0]

If anyone had even superficially studied Modi since Gujarat, and thought that he would do anything other than create a deeply divided India, they were only deluding themselves.

[@ramaraksha01]

Tell me what he did to divide India - don't give in to jealous hate mongers For a long time we have had govts that only focused on vote banks - didn't care about how the economy was doing - for the first time we do There is so much religious hate - promoted by Muslims and Christians - don't give in to their hate

[@DipDil82]

Impressed

[@ramaraksha01]

Where is your evidence - all we see is RELIGIOUS HATE - this hate against Modi driven by religious hate! Tell me, what is your religion? Are you Hindu? I can bet that you are not! Scum buckets all you do is hate people if they are not your religion! And if you are hated for your religion then THAT IS WRONG! Where are your morals?

[@ramaraksha01]

@@DipDil82 Please don't give in to religious hate - that's what this is - Modi is Hindu and these religions preach hate against anyone not of their religion

[@Ray-ty9hn]

Funny to see the blind followers of This regime arguing without studying the history and without any logic ,with just mare criticism and hate..

[@ManojKumar-gh8sf]

My wife is a history teacher. She told me that what is happening nowadays, there is some similarity between Hitler and Modi because she teaches history to children.

[@aarontennyson2102]

No wonder why Modi keeps winning elections while his opponents whine about EVMs.

[@eyeamraj]

Madan makes no sense at all

[@eyeamraj]

@@aarontennyson2102 something is seriously wrong with the electoral machin ism that modi becomes unpopular yet doesn’t loose elections

[@comfortablynumb128]

@madan pal what he's saying is, you are speaking gibberish, nonsensical language, that is incorrect grammatically and logically.

[@ramaraksha01]

Don't give in to hate - you can say that about anyone - but that is how hate is promoted by the west. Anyone they don't like they start spreading hate & Christians are more than happy to promote hate between Hindus and Muslims

[@sujithkumar2041]

It's good that few good men ready to stand-up, for the country and its people.

[@zayeb1997]

@Stallion Spirit rip india

[@utpalroy1972]

Who was responsible for the rise of The third Riech?The result was gargantuan destruction.The German were united as a nation, are we.

[@easypeasyenglish1331]

He has managed to divide families...no other party did this!

[@gamer-ff6mh]

Ohhh yes. I know right!

[@re-alm9731]

So damn agree...

[@cauliflowerhead2735]

This was seen in the Stalin regime where the youth were so overcome by his propaganda that they betrayed their own family members to the Gulag for being even vaguely critical of him.

[@kesavaannadevara4126]

So true. It's a reality in many families where brothers are arguing with each other. Very sad state.

[@vasugarg863]

At least now we know the closet bigots living around us

[@easypeasyenglish1331]

Indira Gandhi was certainly an egoist but Modi is in a class by himself! She, unlike Modi, did not drag down our nation to the gutters! We never had to hang our heads in shame in the international sphere during IG's time.

[@loneranger1265]

Indira Gandhi was a classy act all the way, she was educated, articulate, dignified, brilliant, iron willed lady, so please I beg you don't compare her to a total novice in every possible way

[@easypeasyenglish1331]

@@loneranger1265 She was...but she too was dictatorial, only with more finesse....that is all I meant to say...and when I said Modi is in a class by himself, I meant it derogatively, as my following comments in the previous post should have conveyed to you.

[@cauliflowerhead2735]

Indira Gandhi was an overt yet careful authoritarian, with greater leaning towards the latter. She did respect the democratic process predominantly, if not consistently. Modi is a covert narcissist and far more relentless as an authoritarian. What he says and what he does rarely matches.

[@rfqshare4384]

"We never had to hang our heads in shame in the international sphere during IG's time." Sure, this kind of trash journalism would not have been spared by her.. Firstly such web news portals were not existent and secondly just read about what she had done to her opponents

[@soundar4270]

@@easypeasyenglish1331 Indira Gandhi split Pakistan, what Modi is doing? He is unable to mention the name China. Instead, Modi was telling " Nobody has entered into India, when Chinese were inside our territory

[@Sudama2000]

Karan Thapar - you are the best !!! The topics you pick and the interviews that you conduct are epitome of journalism !!! Hats OFF.....

[@anandbiga]

Fantastic interview. The part dealing with secularism was touching. It brought tears to my eyes.

[@easypeasyenglish1331]

Yes, silence is no longer an option for us! No longer does silence mean impartiality!

[@TheEnglishator]

Right. Silence means active complicity in the theft and murder going on so unabashedly ...

[@TheEnglishator]

@Stallion Spirit not public...and never silent......sanghi terrorists have been active since murdering Mahatma Gandhi.....only 37% of such bhakts voted for Modi ...the rest have voted against him

[@vikashsharma3018]

@@TheEnglishator Gandhian ideology divide india

[@TheEnglishator]

@@vikashsharma3018 Brahminical-Manuvadi-Hindutvawadi ideology decided India and is still dividing it. Gandhi talked about uniting, not dividing. Aryans-Brahmins have divided India since they invaded this land....in the name of caste gender language and religion. Brahmins quit India!...let it rest in peace!

[@vikashsharma3018]

@@TheEnglishator I am not brahmin.i am jaat.we know leftist anti-national very well

[@hardeepsingh4300]

To reiterate once again, M O D I = Master Of Destructive Ideology !!

[@ranjanpattayat9916]

Messanger ... .... India.

[@mathewkuttydaviddavid993]

M O D I > Master Of Devilish Introducer

[@gangmeiapu5249]

MODI ( murderer of democratic India )

[@sentinentbeign9915]

Khalistani

[@tulsibhatia2823]

Yes. Have lost all the respect I had for Amitabh . He used to be one of the examples we cited in classrooms to talk about being a good citizen and role model. He has lost the respect of many. Shukla is right. He will only speak when his backside is covered

[@Ukjsydney]

Very true.

[@Ajayk9099]

Amitabh is a hypocrite, he licks boots of those in power to maintain his position and so called status. He doesn’t speak the truth and hasn’t got the courage to call spade a spade.

[@TimeTraveller3434]

Well...1984...you had the great actor inciting ppl to violence in a speech near the site where PM lay in state...same streak shown again in a different context for another ruling party...

[@odesau2b]

Joker no1, Selfish, just concerned of his image..

[@ShivPrasad77556]

Its your naivete to respect that fox amitabh

[@Safina757]

Thanks for this interview with Mr.Shukla. We were going through a state of shock thinking that all the intellectuals are gone into hiding. It gives me a glimpse of new hope for India.

[@telepost2250]

@@venkshenoi371 Not even one.

[@kasardevi8]

I agree totally with the views of Mr. Avay Shukla ... as a citizen of Austria, who spent 37 years in India I am deeply saddenend the road India is taking .... there is a shocking similarity between Nazi Germany and the developments in India

[@rajanijani7223]

One of Karan Sir's best insightful interviews. Every word of Shukla Sir has a very deep concern and message to the society and the Indian's as well.

[@vikashsharma3018]

Supporter of Rahul baba

[@samareshbasu1720]

@@vikashsharma3018 hooo.....

[@bannedone3ice138]

@@vikashsharma3018 Whoever shows Modi the mirror isn’t Rahul Gandhi’s fanboy. Look at that state of economy.

[@sanchitluthra1146]

@@bannedone3ice138 well said. But, I Wouldn't entertain such people. They are placed here to just do that n then eventually start hurling abuses n worse start spewing out communal hate. You've made your point though.

[@calvindsouza729]

Karan Thapar and Avay Shukla... Deep respect to both of you!

[@wordgun1903]

Couldn't be explained it better. Good to see some intellectuals are not pseudo.

[@wordgun1903]

@@krishnendusanyal4678 for those whom truth bites.

[@vikashsharma3018]

They are radical naxals

[@wordgun1903]

@@krishnendusanyal4678 the day you call liberals and seculars "so called" your colour and sanghi ideology gets crystal clear. A rational person with conscience would not like to lock his horns with the likes of you. Nick named trash and cowdung.

[@wordgun1903]

@@krishnendusanyal4678 those who classify people based on their critical views on governments failure and rawdyism can't be mentally stable people because they don't understand the basics of free democracy. They are blind and hooligans. If you can't digest anonymity you won't digest disclosure either. For you " us and they" are more important than logic and rationality. Be happy with your andhbhakti after selling out your conscience. And who cares about getting a bull shit response from a gobarbhakt?

[@thakurkartikaypratapsinghb9227]

Jai BJP 🕉️🚩

[@juliusidhayakumarb1300]

viewers should be in millions for this interview. avay shukla is the voice of a common man. heart of a good citizen. and vision of a true indian.. this is karan thapar's one of the best interviews.

[@williamswilliams4948]

The most brave Indian I have had the pleasure to hear. He truly lves INDIA AND THE PEOPLE. HE CARES THAT'S WHAT REALLY MATTERS.

[@indirakuriyan9366]

Salute to two brave, articulate and comprehensively thinking men. Each word fell like a sharp arrow. Indians would do well to listen and digest.

[@ushakaimal1947]

Well said.

[@rajuchacha132]

Hs ha that's funny don't think current generation indian care for this bullshit lopsided analysis ..they can see what's happening in Afghanistan

[@nowonami2524]

Objective is Hindu Rashtra. Ask Aakar Patel. There is no other plan, agenda except to make muslims suffer. Nothing else. It is eventually self-destructive after that objective is achieved. Hindu Fascism ends like Nazism.Or 40 years like from Reagan to Trump

[@vikashsharma3018]

They are redical leftist

[@vikashsharma3018]

@@nowonami2524 hindu rashtra target (1) uniform civil code (2) population control law (3) one nation one election (4) remove birtish penal code

[@Deltasayan]

Exactly! Silence is no longer an option.

[@Deltasayan]

@Stallion Spirit and our children will be paying for the price of our negligence we would do if we vote for them again.

[@Deltasayan]

@Stallion Spirit Sure bro. Time will tell. Btw I said this because I just voted once last time and it went to bjp. I'm just disappointed because I also contributed to the problem

[@Deltasayan]

@Stallion Spirit Sure bro. Just keep your eye open. Hope you see the truth before it's too late. I would say don't listen to anyone. Just do your research properly before making your mind.

[@vikashsharma3018]

@@Deltasayan who give you voted for 2024

[@Deltasayan]

@@vikashsharma3018 If you are asking for for who I will vote for 2024 then, I haven't decided on it yet, but by looks of it not atleast bjp. I will decide on the work of parties till then and then decide whom to vote.

[@urmiibhattacharrya8365]

This should be watched by all citizens who love their country 👍

[@urmiibhattacharrya8365]

@Stallion Spirit 🙄 people are strange. Despite knowing he has failed at every front I wonder how does anyone want him back 🙄

[@vikashsharma3018]

@@urmiibhattacharrya8365 modi better than Pappu (Rahul Gandhi)

[@vikashsharma3018]

India understand leftist destructive ideology

[@Topquark1]

Pegasus should remind you that it's not Modi running this country. Even if the alternate illusory opposition party comes to power nothing is going to change. Both shadow boxing parties are run by international super corporates from outside.

[@Topquark1]

@Stallion Spirit Lutyens media too is financed and controlled by the same destructive international corporates. They finance both sides of the war, parties, left and right ultimately to play the game of chess to achieve their Agenda 21 and 30 NWO one world government through their stooges called Freemasons all over the world.

[@exploreyourself6002]

The worst enemies of the society are those who remain silent in the hours of crisis.....

[@neelumahendra4695]

i agree with the guest totally , he really feels for the country , at least some people are speaking up

[@320Gamer]

That’s your opinion, the people who voted Modi also did it for nation only.

[@asterisk1314]

@@320Gamer the people who voted for Hitler also did for 'nation' 🤡🤡

[@imlaqahmad7325]

Very informative. I fully agree with every word of Mr Shukla. Thanks for honest journalism. People like IAS/ Writer Avay Shukla & Karan Thapar are the backbone of democracy. God Bless.

[@IronFists-32]

@Shivam exactly this type of poison is being pointed out in this interview. Shame on u.

[@Ashaa-kiran]

@Shivam Tu jo bol raha hai woh hum hamesha bolte the aur bolte hain aur bolte rahenge. Per tere jaise bimar mansikta wale ke dabav me nahi bolenge.

[@beulahlad3576]

Rightly said

[@noeladesouza3867]

Messrs Bajaj, both father and son, are the only members of the corporate world who have had the cojones to speak truth to power!

[@varunduttswami452]

They are recognised honest businessman in India.

[@truth7653]

The Bajaj family take no favours they are not worried about CBI/Income Tax raid they seem to be clean.

[@sagaronline265]

just deep respect for bajaj duo,they proved that they are really "Hamara bajaj" yaani bharat ki janta ka.

[@amoonjely5699]

The Bajajs (father and son) have always had the b""ls to speak out their minds without fear or favour, so also Adi Godrej. Kudos these few industrialists moulded in steel. The nation salutes them in these trying times.

[@sagaronline265]

@Stallion Spirit sach bol pagle har jagah taati karneke chaiwala kitna tukta hai tumpar.

[@sanjeevinamdar5750]

But I appreciate your confession and the courage to come out so boldly.

[@mdmasihuzzaman4546]

@Vijay Manjrekar thodha padhai likhai karo troll k jaisa behave nhi karo sirji pakistan ki itni auqat nhi h ki india ko degrade kare comparision to dhang ki country se kia karo

[@debajitsarkar4894]

@Vijay Manjrekar So speaking against the govt = to speaking against India. So according to you, BJP = to India and therefore we can't talk against him. Is that right?

[@ivaerz4977]

If you speak against Government u support Pakistan lol 🤦

[@sanjeevinamdar5750]

@@ivaerz4977 LOL

[@annunegi6462]

@Vijay Manjrekar then whom are you supporting?? Kailasa 😂 there is idiom "fools paradise" but for you it might change to "Rapist and dung eating paradise"

[@SuperLuckysingh007]

“It is a problem for ALL of us” sir you nailed it with this last line!! I totally agree with you word by word🙏

[@buddhoo3137]

थापर एवं शुक्ला सर , आप दोनों की बेचैनी और बेचारगी इस बात का सबूत है कि आप दोनों सच्चे देशभक्त हैं और अपने लोगों से बेहद प्यार करते हैं । अफसोस है कि आज हमारा समाज अपराधियों के चंगुल में है और विवेकवान ठगा सा महसूस कर रहा है ।

[@nazeerbasha8658]

Hats off to Mr.Karan and the upright author for this decisive, meaningful debate,which should serve as an eye opener to every Indians.

[@tariquehussain9882]

Astonishingly candid and intellectually refreshing interviewee.

[@naanallamuthu5038]

@Stallion Spirit Hitler also thought he ruled the whole world but his dead body even not identified at the end. Modi kind of low life ends up life like that. Thats what history taught us someone with fascism plus autocratic mindset.

[@jagannathbuchade2250]

@@naanallamuthu5038 Right very true Hitlers fascist policies precipitated '* World War II*' and led to the geocide known asa Holocaust which resulted in the deaths of some six million jews and another five million noncombatants. Similar examples of deaths of peoples in Gujarat....like Godhara Kand

[@jagannathbuchade2250]

Evil must die

[@tariquehussain9882]

@@jagannathbuchade2250 Totally agree.

[@kumailalimasjide7895]

@Stallion Spirit Evil of 70 years positively contributed to the lush progress of the country , socio economic institutions back then compared to the rusty demonism & demolition of all these institutions caused by this illiterate,autocratic bastard in last 7 years wrapped in a venomous lotus.

[@rumlia]

Catch-22 - Joseph Heller “You know, that might be the answer - to act boastfully about something we ought to be ashamed of. That’s a trick that never seems to fail.”

[@raghuramsanalkumar747]

😀 That book was a masterpiece. 👍

[@kittithelittle3298]

Well said

[@diva7892]

Superb !!!

[@rumlia]

Yossarian survived.............. :-)

[@SudeeptaChakraborty]

Absolutely

[@raziashraf6209]

Martin Luther King Jr once said:' And in the end we will not remember the hatred of our enemies but the silence of our friends'. So true of India today.

[@gnsgamer2382]

those who know Hitler (have seen his documentary, and read books) can totally relate whats going on in the country .

[@69piano23]

Yeah 😂😂

[@mukool7477]

I don't think hindu ppl will ever support gncide and mass murders srsly... Apart from that modi shud really address this issue

[@Sarthakkumarpal]

A clarion call has been made by Mr. Avay Shukla

[@jeyaananthana8577]

In Tamilnadu well running businesses of years suddenly turned into risk, several shuted down, Modi govt to owe entire blame

[@GorditoCrunch343]

@@jeyaananthana8577 Tamil Nadu shouldn’t even be part of that filthy country. Separation is imminent for both the South and North East.

[@jeyaananthana8577]

@Stallion Spirit ok,my point religious fundamentalists never do good things,it not just for muslims or Christian but hindu fundamentals too evidence RSS made demolition of Indian growth treachery

[@jeyaananthana8577]

@Stallion Spirit where gone the job loss data? Modi demonetised the same day Trump became USA President, stupid on every sense

[@jeyaananthana8577]

@Stallion Spirit Demonetasion killed all around economic development in India, your point not relevant

[@NirajPant2]

I agree with the views of Mr Shukla about Amitabh Bacchan!

[@NirajPant2]

Sachin Tendulkar also sits along with Amitabh Bacchan!

[@raviakhl]

Sachin doesnt have any role to play , he is so crook and selfish

[@NirajPant2]

@@raviakhl I concur!

[@NirajPant2]

@Stallion Spirit You nut, at best, you are a spiritless stallion and lack even an iota of sense! You better remain where you have decided to be, at the feet of a Cult! Good Luck to you!

[@surendertoora1997]

This is the first time I heard Mr. Ajay Shukla and blown..... what a clarity, fearlessness, analysisl of thought and presentation.....and Mr. Thapar as usual put all critical questions to Mr. Ajay Shukla...

[@vinodpande7456]

Every bit of this outstanding interview is worth 24karat gold. Each one of the TRUE Indians needs to watch this with attention.

[@rajnj1809]

how to make indian youth to debate and understand this interview ? They are the one who owns this nation , Modi’s marketing is sucking people into long term poison with out even knowing . We are a young nation with old culture , we need institutions evolve & not cause our fabric to break . What is happening in india is well communicated in this interview. Thank You Karan .

[@aayushsamant2784]

you wanna debate. we can have one 😂. But I think I can tell you that opinion makers have different time horizon when they make opinions. In this case they are looking at what future might become in 5 years. But one thing I can tell you that education and globalisation can eradicate all evils in society. So be patient India is in right track. Things will turn good in 50-75 years horizon. Though germans hate jews in 1940s. tell me are young germans hate them in 2023. Same will happen in India. what we have to do right is having economic progress which will take care of everything that is the history of all developed nations..

[@varshasindhu5672]

Curious to know why someone intelligent and with a moral compass that seems to point in the right direction would support someone like Modi after what happened in Gujarat in 2002 under his chief ministership.

[@samarthpandey683]

I thought exactly the same thing, I remember telling a friend prior to 2014 election that I'll never vote for BJP under Modi coz i havent forgotten Godhara massacre, his role and how he didnt even apologise for it. But sadly people forget or chose to out of their biases. And today his govt has failed to recognise (forget apologise) for deaths in second wave due to lack of oxygen.

[@krishnendusanyal4678]

Unfortunately earlier people knew only of Gujrat riots in 2002, but today a few also know Sabarmati Express !

[@sagaronline265]

@Tejpal singh bali so u mean doing madness once should be repeated again and thats not an issue for psycho like u at d cost of nation and people?

[@rajadurairasiah7084]

You lot will be singing the Gujarat song till the cows come home.

[@krishnendusanyal4678]

@@rajadurairasiah7084 No. We will deplore both Godhra and Sabarmati Express in the same breath, unequivocally, without trying to brush either of the two under the carpet.

[@imlaqahmad7325]

We have RSS/ Modi / Amit Shah / Ajit Doval. So No need Enemies (China or Pak) to destroy India. God save India.

[@sagarbisht9818]

Your name suggest everything unfortunately but true

[@simonvarghese8673]

@@sagarbisht9818 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 truth remains

[@sentinentbeign9915]

Why don't you put your head in between Imran Khan ! Gazwa e Hind will never happen in this soil...

[@visantparkash384]

Very valid, clear, focused,, educated, and unbiased discussion. Simply brilliant. It seemed that Avay Shukla was speaking my mind.

[@vjponmudi3899]

Time has come for every Indians socially educated youth to wake up and protect their future.

[@sanjeevinamdar5750]

Mr. Avay Shukla, at your level, you shouldn't have been conned. 2002 and Haren Pandyas had given enough signals.

[@mittemari]

Well said sir, people who have been conned haven't done their homework nor had done analysis of what toxic personality the people who are going to occupy power. The entire country will pay this price and unfortunately future generations will pay. A generation of people paid heavy price for Indra and Sanjays misdemeanor's. Unfortunately our kids will.pay for what is happening now.

[@abdullahalfaruquemullick9048]

@@mittemari Sad but true..

[@gamer-ff6mh]

Cmon be practical now, atleast he has shown the courage! Gandhiji made many mistakes. Each one he declared publicly in newspapers so that people will put pressure on him and make sure he won't do it again. Such stuff requires courage.

[@sanjeevinamdar5750]

@@gamer-ff6mh Very True.

[@Ashaa-kiran]

@@gamer-ff6mh kyun Gandhiji ne azadi dila ke galthi ki kya???

[@h79guf]

“read the writing on the wall now as that wall won’t be standing for long”

[@rakeshsachdeva4370]

Brilliantly put across all the failings.Liked the clarity of thought and putting it across by both. But to expect from public and country's Icons to take a stand is expecting too much from pygmies.

[@pritpaldhaliwal6509]

Where there is no vision, the people perish - Proverbs 29:18

[@OldSoul2779]

One of the best politics oriented interviews I have ever heard. Mr Shukla is 1,000% correct.

[@alphasubscription6741]

What a gem Avay Shukla. Never have witnessed an interview so informative and enlightening. Great to hear such powerful self reflection regarding India from an Indian in an age where Godi media is engaged in rogue trolling debates and constantly pushing India back towards stone age. This is exactly the revolution that India needs today.

[@mandeepmann8987]

Well Amitabh Batchan seems on the side of ideology of modi government

[@re-alm9731]

He has Panama account which keeps him on the right side of Modi.

[@ivaerz4977]

Bollywood don't have balls to speak against Modi I now remember the meeting between Bollywood and Modi few years ago in which Modi took that selfie.

[@hardeepsingh4300]

When Panama Papers leak was out, Nawaz Sharif was ousted in Pakistan. Here in India - Sab Changa Si !!

[@neet319]

He is on the side of Power whomsoever it may be

[@shekharharsha1540]

So candid and thus most powerful interaction, not expected these days.

[@rohitmpanchal5803]

Extremely candid and analytical observations from Avay Shukla. It is time we, people of India, realise the dangerous and divisive paths we are being led to. Moral fabric of the nation is in tatters. Do we wish to leave these legacies for our children and grandchildren?

[@ramaraksha01]

Does that mean we must kowtow to minorities? Please them at every turn? Please go into detail what these divisive policies are - cow killing ban? In muslim as well as Israel - pig killing is banned Here in the US Dog and cat killing is banned - chinese and Koreans like to eat them - but as minorities they accept that they live in a different country People like this guy are still slaves of the white man

[@yorisingrango9837]

"Its not a genocide if you win the war" - Sanghtrillonaire grindset.

[@ManojKumar-gh8sf]

मेरी वाइफ हिस्ट्री की टीचर है। उन्होंने मुझे बताया कि आजकल जो कुछ हो रहा है वह हिटलर और मोदी के बीच में कुछ समानता दिख रही है क्योंकि वह हिस्ट्री पढ़ाती है बच्चों को।

[@wannabetroll8509]

Even I feel there is something wierd about Ratan Tata.

[@abdullahalfaruquemullick9048]

in last few years, something happened. I can feel it too.

[@bhudebmukherjee8027]

Ratan Tata is no JRD. He is only exploiting The Halo of JRD and people have not understood it.

[@odesau2b]

He may be cornered by the Gujjus

[@vijaydawri646]

I agree, Modi & Rss are destroying social fabric. It will take long time to repair it. Very unfortunate.

[@jaffarimike9100]

If you know he is RSS why you guys voted for him when you guys know what he did in Gujarat, but the problem is that you guys hate Muslim so much that people voted for him because of hatred, you guys hate Muslim because they were your masters for centuries now you trying to get even, can you treat them in other countries like Saudia, Pakistan, Afghanistan so on, no you will not dare because you guys are coward.

[@damodarpradhan62]

@@jaffarimike9100 bravos

[@anjankumarsarkar6243]

@@jaffarimike9100 I can't agree more

[@gamer-ff6mh]

@@jaffarimike9100 Angrily criticizing any 'you' isn't going to help, especially on this channel. Followers of wire are typically a minority which vote against current government or NOTA. If you fall to hatred, beware, you too will be taken over by reactionaries eventually. I know situation is very hard. We need great mental strength. Look towards our freedom struggle, to Gandhi and Bacha Khan, or to Wahiduddin Khan and Javed Ghamidi. Hope is not lost. I repeat. Hope is not lost. There is no other real way except to live together and cooperate. The world will realize and future will be bright. We must however not philosophize, but act. Act in our own small way, contribute whatever we can. My favorite teacher, was a Muslim. It was only probably few sentences of his which had lifelong impact on me. Trust me, positive words and sentences matter to those who are sensitive, those who can become future allies. There is still humanity. Be optimistic. People will rise against tyrants eventually and the tyrants will fall. But it will need sacrifices.. And time. Sacrifices which we must make. Action which we should now shy away from. Actually it is all about maintaining a level of courage. That was Gandhiji's real message. Death before loss of dignity.

[@kumarmanishone]

Can you define social fabric...is that buying peace by keeping quiet every time and appeasing certain section of society and such people...

[@NirajPant2]

Mr Avay Shukla, hats off to you! I have had the opportunity to read a few pieces on 'The Wire' and was impressed and even influenced by your views! I am quite taken by the comments of Mr Shukla! I even agree with his views about Ratan Tata! Mr Shukla, I will now follow your blogs!

[@debajitsarkar4894]

@Vijay Manjrekar Why do you see anything anti bjp as anti India. Is bjp = to India? So there should be no need for any elections henceforth. We all love India and hence it always should be bjp in power. Is this correct?

[@NirajPant2]

@Vijay Manjrekar This is a paranoid mentality! It seems you prefer to watch Republic and continue watching that if you find NDTV Anti Hindus as you seem to view Avay Shukla!

[@NirajPant2]

@Stallion Spirit Why 2024; he might come in power in 2029 also. But the reality still won't change. The reality of Vladimir Putin remains despite his being at the helm alternately as President or Prime Minister! You remain inebriated with the Cult of Narendra Modi! Good Luck!

[@NirajPant2]

@Stallion Spirit You, clot, follow Shah and do further damage over what Modi-Shah are doing now and then Shah alone or joined by you! Good Luck, once more!

[@NirajPant2]

@Stallion Spirit Get Lost, you Nut! You go by your belief! Good Luck to you! Don't get into slanging matches with me!

[@neenaobhrai273]

Very true, I was watching documentary of ‘Career of Hitler’ with flags of swastika and BJP, it’s same campaign and it’s scary 😖😖😖

[@stanvkumar]

A very brave book raising just voice against the ominent signs of looming disaster

[@hendrick3938]

The first answer he has given is a matter of paramount importance and it is the time to wake up the learnt citizens of India otherwise we are doomed

[@naqvib]

After a long time, I listened to a logical and in depth analysis of current affairs. Very education and inspiring that there are intelligent and visionary peoples are still there to protect the Indian cultural values. Thanks Karan bring Mr. Shula to us and his vision. Thanks

[@robhurst4101]

baqar send your kids to usa uk Canada Australia on student visa.dont live in fools paradise. No hope for minorities in India

[@imlaqahmad7325]

I just wonder, why Mr Shukla & other Fine Educated People have been silent on Modi's 2002 Gujarat Genocide? & Amit shah's 2013 Genocide of Muslims in Muzaffarnagar / West UP ?? Modi has sold Lands in Gujarat at Rs 1 per yard to Gautam Adani, including Dahej Port / Hazira Port /Mundra Port & many Airports..

[@sarsbindusamanta960]

What about kashmiri hindus1990?

[@joymascarenhas3491]

@@sarsbindusamanta960 stick to topic

[@RakeshGupta-qu9yj]

@@sarsbindusamanta960 if u are worried for them ,what u were doing then... ?

[@loneranger1265]

Imlaq bhai forget it, the water has gone over the head and so has the country, so for anyone to believe that anything good will happen in the years ahead is living in a fools world

[@annunegi6462]

@@sarsbindusamanta960 the question you are asking 30 years later, will rise again in 30 years after about today. The calamity faced by yahudis made them soo strong today, that can repeat.

[@shivhulikere1768]

I happy to see insight by author, I only wish there will be mullions like him who can stand up and talk,

[@independentnationalist1740]

Dear Shiv, Please speak to any govt servant after retirement , no generalization but he can give you thousand of suggestions for improvement . Implementation is the problem .

[@shariqtariq]

That was just beautiful - Karan Thapar is the emperor amongst journalists!

[@saharasathi6264]

Whenever I see any interview of Karan Thapar it reminds me of Modi interview. Dosti bani rahe. Wow that was astonishing. Jaihind

[@sushantchoudhary8585]

Initially we commoner felt everything is going well and fine....where is intolerance...? Why few journalist pointing this out?.... Now we realise what is intolerance....and now we are thinking one mistake we did in 2014 has changed the future of this country 😭

[@lalluram3821]

Vote him out....But you are being dishonest towards an elected process of you call him Hitler.

[@biswarup077]

@@lalluram3821 What is dishonest here? Hitler also came to power through voting.

[@lalluram3821]

@@biswarup077 Remove him if you can...in 2024...dont just cry and bark....if he wins he rules...simple.

[@biswarup077]

@@lalluram3821 Why won't I cry or bark if he is destroying the country with the vote of less than 40 % of Indians? 60% is against him. These 40% idiots need to be awakened.

[@lalluram3821]

@@biswarup077 Sorry we are idiots...You are awakened/Enlightened. ....You defeat our "idiotic" ideology and rule simple......Becareful when you are out to defeat someone...you are already defeated....Go out to win.....You can cannot win over 40% "idiots" by just bashing modi...Can you list out few agendas.. Can you free our temples from government...will your government promise? Can you promise that we dont have to study Babur ,Akbar anymore after your government comes to power... Can you build Krishna Janambhoomi and Kashi temple and free them from the clothes of "Ganga -Jamuni" tehjeeb and finally who is your Leader for PM?....

[@tahsrinivas3535]

brilliantly courageously...shown where we are leading to...and how views can be discussed with the youth ,the future citizens ...for our countries future and stability

[@ravicharles5192]

More dangerous is his ardent bhakts blinded by fierce propaganda that their hatred prevents them from seeing the truth.

[@abhishekranjan420]

Thank you Thankyou Sir Ajay Shukla for speaking as objectively as one can 🙌 True gem you are

[@saleemc]

Karan you are simply Brilliant. The Indian public must be made aware of the dangers facing India due the RSS/BJP extremist policies.

[@un-karnish2967]

I have a genuine doubt and a question for you. You would rather have a Muslim appeasing leader than a leader who might be good for the country overall? Every comment I see in KZbin, a Muslim name mostly speaks ill of Modi. I'm not a religious person and I'm not a supporter of any political party but I have a question. Are majority Muslims taught to hate Modi irrespective of his current policies? Still salty about the bad incidents in Gujarat? Do you even give a chance to his policies compared to Congress party and its policies or you just condemn Modi without even bothering to know the policies that might be good for the country's development? Also please let me know what are the 'Extremist policies of BJP' right now?

[@seanmovie9077]

This is one of the rarest interviews I have really liked … This interview and book should be published in multiple languages where the impact is needed Thank you Karan and Avay for this beautiful interview and knowledge

[@rajadurairasiah7084]

Your world view ....?

[@jyotipaul5786]

Exactly 👏👏

[@sm12560]

finally someone did leadership profile to show that Modi is akin to Hitler. Now similar to russians for third reich, Chinese are going to do their part in north. How can you show similarity of Adityanath to Germany's goebbels?

[@mrgyani]

Adityanath is no goebbels. They do have a goebbels though, hard to say who it is. I don't think it is even Amit Shah.

[@h79guf]

When the tide turns, it won’t be a revert to something old. Most likely just a marginal change with a new face. FUBAR is a real word.

[@rajeevpai325]

@Stallion Spirit Hitler also thought his party will rule for a thousand years. He barely made it past 10.

[@pritpaldhaliwal6509]

See video: Rosa Koire - UN Agenda 21 and The Great Reset: Dropping The Mask [The Greater Reset ] kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYCUmpKGq5uVgLs.

[@anav587]

@@rajeevpai325 the country had to be razed to the ground in order for that to happen

[@dsethi05]

An excellent interview . Mr. Shukla has brilliantly analysed the India of the present . Kudos to him .

[@sitaramsharan5074]

Brilliant analysis. The interview deserves to be done in Hindi and all Indian languages

[@shariqulaman9726]

Never had such a Interview to watch. It certainly gave us hope collectively. An Interviewer like Mr. Karan Thapar and as distinguished a persona of a cool Mr. Away Shukla. Times will cherish it and generations to come will gain confidence. Hats off to both of you Gentlemen Geniuses.

[@re-alm9731]

Spot on about Amitabh Bachchan...tallest spineless man of Bollywood.

[@chandrashekaransubramanian2748]

Problem for all of us, for the future generations... Bold, Mr. Shukla 🙏🙏🔥🔥🔥

[@vikashsharma3018]

They are gorge Soros agent to destroy india

[@muditjain8784]

PM Modi learnt politics from Indira Gandhi during the emergency as he was at the receiving end. She is his Guru and he is using her as a role model in ruling the country. No difference between BJP and Congress

[@sandyg11]

Wow wow..what a spine ..what courage

[@flyingafrinak6958]

My best service for my beloved country. I had never voted for bjp

[@suhanism2760]

@Stallion Spirit can u tell the achievements of bjp that are benefitted to the people in all sectors rather than casteism n bringing hatred in the society is the big achievement of bjp

[@suhanism2760]

@Stallion Spirit what about Pegasus spyware where govt is not taking any legal action where bjp is benefitted by harming others life n telling opposition all that is rumor but it's discussed all over the world

[@ageless1003]

@Stallion Spirit hey you forget Feku biggest achievement DeMo. And the GST you've mentioned is not one tax but a slab of 4 different taxes under one name riddled with confusion. Do remember alcohol and petrol are still out of GST ambit. You talk nonsense and it shows in your comment gloriously....regarding 370, tell me has the state GDP increased after abolishing 370 ??...are women more secure after abolishing triple talaq (BJP minister themselves rape hindu woman and later kill her family member as well, Kuldeep Sengar). The less we talk of china situation the better. Feku failed to even name China in his address to nation when our army jawans died in Ladakh. Buying out MLA's if he can't win elections are signs that feku is a sore loser.

[@suhanism2760]

@@ageless1003 rightly roasted.I thnk @Stallion Spirit is the andhbakt of modi n he is only explaining about GDP n 370 rather than that there is nothing more to explain n I thnk he doesn't know that modis govt have been compared with Hitlers govt on international channel (Wire)

[@chhuntul]

How could an erudite person like Mr Shukla forget 2002 and what NM regime had inflicted on Gujarat as social engineering?

[@jyotpurohit9435]

Was it modi who burned devotees in the train 🚂 in Godhra?

[@diva7892]

Karan, one of your best!!!

[@anusha99]

I am amazed by how many intellectuals and historians were fooled or maybe turned blind eye to BJP's hindutva.

[@devarajans668]

Great and full fledged analysis of last seven years wasted under the uneducated the leadership. The damages done by this govt is not repairable as well said by SHRI Ahguja

[@sk8636]

Mein Kampf is bjp’s book of constitution

[@annunegi6462]

Bjp doesn't belive in constitution. They follow only hitlarism. And they will die like him for sure.

[@pritpaldhaliwal6509]

"The definition of fascism is a marriage of corporation and state." Benito Mussolini, Italian Dictator.

[@sagaronline265]

Its best not to react to Idiot Like SS , he cannot see d present destruction by haraamkhor chaiwala ,but mR.SS takes pride in his knowledge about wrongdoings of past leaders of india.this man must have just woken up from graveyard.

[@sagaronline265]

@Stallion Spirit bhai aisi baatein mat karo,janta sab jaanti hai kunse figures kahan se aaye hai,apne pagalpan hone ka saboot mat dho.jab feku ki pitaayi hogi toh paagal log jinhone fekugiri failyi unko bhi maar padegi. waise figures se pmc bank ke 10 lakh se jyaada account holder ke paise unhe waapas nahi mile,naahi majhdooron ko bus train mili lockdown mein ghar jaane ke liye,naahi vaacine mili corona time par.figures pagle sirf figures hote hai,unka kya,insaan ki zindagi practical hoti hai,pagla kahi ka.

[@sagaronline265]

@Stallion Spirit chal pagle.

[@bhaswarchoudhury5468]

Glad to hear such bold and articulate voices are still surviving. I have hope in India.

[@bannedone3ice138]

@Stallion Spirit Modi bhakht crying everywhere while his god is being roasted.

[@ThePrerna22]

I loved the discussion. Specially loved what was said about Bureaucracy - with every year of Service, IAS officers keep loosing one vertebrae. So true. Also, I do not see anyone except the Bajajs in Corporate India having a spine either..

[@flushhh4543]

Things can only settle if India is declared Hindu nation in broader sense, natural home to ethnic Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jain. Public should not forget atrocities of Muslims as well and the way they are obsessed with religious conversions and increasing their numbers.

[@junaidarif9932]

As a Pakistani living in Dubai, I was stunned to see attitude of my Indian friends change since Modi rise. Clearly it was not patriotism but jingoism. It also killed any hope of common south Asian trading/travel peaceful area.

[@riaz.ahmed1483]

Indians are going to do the same mistake which we Pakistani did many times in the past. I really appreciate these two gems who have the courage to say the truth.

[@lordvold9486]

Lol, the benchmark for Bhakt or people who follow Modi strongly is Pakistan, they consider Pakistan as a Model society and are super obsessed with it.

[@lordvold9486]

@Stallion Spirit Just a "Bunch of thoughts" If you know then you know ;)

[@moody1981]

The sick man of Asia, His highness Narendar Modi

[@vishnuthakur9520]

Sick man of Asia is China. Read books not whatsapp.

[@islamkabawaal5292]

@@vishnuthakur9520 perfect

[@vishnuthakur9520]

@Miruis Potov because they also have a nuclear bomb you fool.

[@greyenterprise6682]

I understand democracy as something that gives the weak the same chance as the strong. -

[@viveksrivastava7698]

Very well encapsulated the stand of Amitabh Bachan and Ratan Tata.!!!

[@dkumar7810]

Brilliant and incisive . Watched it for the 10th time . Mr. Shukla has held a mirror to all of us .