Simple vs Complex Pale Ale

Caleb Whitenack from @psychdocbrewery and I teamed up to brew two pale ales. One as a SMaSH beer ands the other with as complicated recipe as we could come up with. Were the extra grains worth it?
RECIPE KITS: www.atlanticbr...
CLAWHAMMER BREWING SYSTEM: www.clawhammers...
FLEX+: spikebrewing.c...
CF5 CONICAL: spikebrewing.c...
MERCH: shop.spreadshi...
SIMPLE RECIPE (3 GALLONS)
6 lbs 4.0 oz Maris Otter
0.50 oz Cascade [5.50 %] - Boil 60.0 min
0.50 oz Cascade [5.50 %] - Boil 20.0 min
2.00 oz Cascade [5.50 %] - Steep/Whirlpool 30.0 min
1.0 pkg American Ale (Wyeast Labs #1056)
COMPLEX RECIPE (5 GALLONS)
7 lbs 8.0 oz 2-row American Pale Malt
6.0 oz Biscuit Malt
6.0 oz Caramel/Crystal Malt - 20L
6.0 oz Caramel/Crystal Malt - 80L
6.0 oz Carared
6.0 oz Munich Malt - 20L
6.0 oz Special Roast
3.0 oz Acid Malt
3.0 oz Carapils
0.50 oz Centennial [10.00 %] - Boil 60.0 min
0.50 oz Cascade [5.50 %] - Boil 20.0 min
1.00 oz Chinook [13.00 %] - Steep/Whirlpool 30.0 min
0.50 oz Cascade [5.50 %] - Steep/Whirlpool 30.0 min
0.50 oz Centennial [10.00 %] - Steep/Whirlpool 30.0 min
1.0 pkg American Ale (Wyeast Labs #1056)
MY BREWING GEAR
Glycol chiller: blichmannengineering.com/glycol-chiller.html
Kegs: kegco.com/?rfs...
pH meter: geni.us/L39hEX
Hydrometer: geni.us/i1tEX
Fermenter: geni.us/C8uB
Grain mill: geni.us/KcIDv3
Wireless hydrometer: geni.us/ZG7Tuiz
PBW for cleaning: geni.us/YDBhB
Starsan for sanitizing: geni.us/4xMFDE
MY GLASSWARE
Tulip: geni.us/oWlxk
Stemmed: geni.us/tvfH
Pilsner: geni.us/AHtVzeN
Flight paddle: geni.us/UFNoykh
MY VIDEO GEAR
Main camera: geni.us/vi98vr
Second camera: geni.us/Rw61
Main lens: geni.us/BobhSAf
Second lens: geni.us/DeBQ4O
Microphone: geni.us/luBVt
Lights: geni.us/8aMbDC
MUSIC
Where I get all my music (2 months free): bit.ly/3kuaLbW
Created by: Martin Keen
Business inquiries: [e-mail]

[@TyinAlaska]

I would love to see this as a series.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Awesome!

[@NikitaVorontsov]

The tulip glass looks exceptional. Almost like a Teku! Big fan of simple beers and agree with you there on the choices of when to drink which!

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Haha, everything looks better in that glass.

[@Kaesekuchen002]

I like this comparison style video a lot. Also Caleb seems to be a really nice guy. Would like to see more content with him.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Thanks! He’ll be back.

[@Frank-the-Tank-13]

I’m thinking different grains same hops and hop schedule would show the difference.

[@bobhinley5410]

I’m surprised both of you were surprised by the beers differences. The complex recipe has crystal 20L, 80L, Munich 20L and special roast. Darker malts. Smash beers are always less complex. But do provide the brewer benefits in isolating flavors. I’m sure it was fun brewing them.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Yes sure was fun to brew these.

[@larryrhoe2835]

You are too polite.

[@OscarOSullivan]

@@TheHomebrewChallenge The simple one is my preferred

[@sharpie6953]

Great vid. I've been making my "Castennook" APA for a few years now, using cascade, centennial & chinook. It's a combination that works really well.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Great name!

[@normlang1994]

No one would look at these two beers and think they had anything in common. Another great "experiment" Martin!

[@jakedethierful]

I mean they really don't have anything in common different brew system, different mash bill, different hops, likely a different fermenter and conditions, and we only got yeast details from the complex beer.

[@Jango1989]

Great video! Definitely one to point newer brewers to.

[@larryrhoe2835]

No no no.

[@matthewnorth5523]

"Even though I'm on the road, I've still got the whisk." I love your querks Martin.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

😆

[@jabroni982]

Both of those beers look fantastic. I'm having a hard time finding Maris Otter and settled for a 55lb bag of golden promise aswell as a 55lb bag of 2 row. I've been waking up and just coming up with recepies while my water is coming to mash temp and loving it. Did a golden promise, Amarillo SMASH beer recently and it reminds me of this video.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Haha, when I started to get grain storage at home, that was my dream. To just wake up and randomly come up with a recipe to brew there and then.

[@Kveiksmithdaryl]

Love this experiment! I always end up finding my simplest beers my favourite ones, all my best brews have been SMaSHs!

[@iliffavenuebrewhouse6496]

I wish you would have tried to make similar beers; one simple and one complex. Great vid!

[@brewingdad]

Great video lads.

[@Styv93]

Keep it simple! The best and most drinkable beers I have been making were all SMaSH =)

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

There's a lot to be said for a good simple beer

[@stevendavis6561]

Maybe try same recipe but different mash techniques like single infusion vs decoction vs turbid. Not to many videos out there on that. The book American Sour Beer has good info on all of them

[@Dilfed]

Legit made the same SMaSH as my first brew, it is bottle conditioning at the moment and should be ready this weekend. I cracked one open for a gravity ready and tasted it and it's already quite delicious just obviously lacking some carbonation.

[@Buckie93]

My friend and I made a beer like that complex one once, anything that was in the brew tub that was open (leftovers from previous brews) grains hops etc threw it all in. Turned out really good so we called it the kitchen sink because God knows what went in it 😅.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

lol one of a kind.

[@markluxton3402]

Different ingredients, different equipment, different methods; not the "same beer". I don't know how anyone could even consider them to be the same style.

[@ScottBass86]

Cool video, I would be interested to see more side by side comparions but less drastic changes maybe. Like, a traditional hop schedule compared to just hops after the boil, or pressure vs none etc.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

I’m really enjoying these comparisons and yeah those would be good to test.

[@GraveysBrewery]

Both beers looked really good, but just for my own personal taste, I think I'd prefer to brew the simple version more. That said, rather than just have a straight SMaSH beer, I'd be inclined to add a little bit of Carapils to give my beer that little bit extra in body. Great video Martin, I'd love to see you do more of these kinds of videos.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Thanks. I'm such a fan of this SMaSH beer - the keg is draining fast.

[@fabriziodifazio8439]

Combine the simple grain bill with the complex hop schedule, and you'll have a banging pale ale.

[@brotherjohn2002]

Cool video. Cool idea. But I think the "complex" beer grain bill was well outside of the pale ale realm. You could have kept it complex but kept it in the pale ale realm (2 row/vienna mox, biscut malt, oats or rye, and some honey malt). Still a rediculous amount of malt but would have stayed in the realm of pale ale. That said fun video as ever. Thank you sir.

[@Abbynorml1979]

What I want to know is how home brewers can stay so thin? Something ain't right (not talking about my dietary choices).

[@CM-ef8fu]

Important question indeed! Xd

[@CM-ef8fu]

Important question indeed xd

[@jonybakery1]

Hey. I really enjoy your videos. By any chance do you have any content on the equipment you use? Currently I am bottling all of my home brews. I am looking to start using kegs with CO2 but have no clue where to start!

[@stevemorris8545]

Some of my most enjoyable beers (both brew day and drinking day) have been SMASHs. There's something to be said in the beauty of simplicity sometimes.

[@DylanScully1]

It would be good to do this same style but with just different hop and same malt. Or vice versa

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Yes! Would be fun to see the impact, especially in a pale ale or IPA.

[@mrow7598]

I would have kept the same type of hops between the beers. That way they'd be closer to each other.

[@brewtaldeafmedal1262]

he had to say he was a psychiatrist in the first 20 seconds lmaoooooo

[@noodle845]

Nice video. Do you find using a hop spider inhibits the proper infusion from the hop?

[@brennanedwards9582]

Another great vid Martin! Where did you get your whisk from?

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Thanks. Sorry no idea, it’s been years.

[@shawnmacgavin9774]

I was wondering what @psychdocbrewery beer finished at. Martin mentioned his final gravity but you guys skipped over the other beer's FG.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

I think that part ended up on the cutting room floor. 1.017.

[@brewsclues5902]

What is the chugability difference?

[@TheAlchemistsBrewery]

The simpler, the better

[@kg49er]

How would you compare the complex one to an amber ale?

[@Matthewbraaten]

Sooo the complex one is not a pale ale? It looks more like an amber or red.

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

Ambery Pale Ale 😀

[@larryrhoe2835]

Exactly. Rookies.

[@JohnnyReverse]

how many times ya think the psych doc has hit his head on that range?

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

lol he says many.

[@llambibazi3675]

Mi piace molto bravo

[@TheAlchemistsBrewery]

American Pale Ale should be something like base malt, 5% light crystal malt (or US caramel malt) and a C hop. That's it!

[@TheHomebrewChallenge]

There’s a lot to be said for simple.

[@TheAlchemistsBrewery]

@@TheHomebrewChallenge "simple" is only apparently simple.

[@graykilpatrick1319]

I would've reached fir berr # 2

[@ashleythomas1131]

There not the beer in anyway, please explain how they are

[@ashleythomas1131]

Maybe if you used same hops

[@RidesWithAnthony]

The non-verbal ques say everything.

[@Weezulguy]

Simple FTW just cause hipstersSAWK

[@slavanazy]

Chennal бир энд бир...subskride

[@larryrhoe2835]

A smash beer and a beer with way too many grain types. “ It’s astonishingly different. Probably the stupidest comment I have ever heard. “

[@nikolab22]

First

[@ivanbravic5421]

Đes poletio Nikola 🤣

[@nikolab22]

@@ivanbravic5421 hahaha izbacilo mi, a taman na mobu bija