Sirius Is A Hufflepuff | Harry Potter Theory

Go to stamps.com and use promo code ‘SUPERCARLIN’ to claim your special offer today!
Today J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss the Marauders: James, Lupin, Peter and Sirius, and how each member represents one of the 4 Hogwarts Houses: Gryffindor, Ravenclaw, Slytherin and Hufflepuff
#SuperCarlinBrothers #HarryPotter
Edited by :: Riley Murtagh
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: [e-mail]
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Where my HUFFLEPUFFS AT?!?!

[@enzosansabrino]

Gryffindor here, love your guy's vids

[@Mr._80HD]

Here

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Fear the mighty badger! Hufflepuff and proud!

[@fynndog6893]

I’m a slytherin in a family of hufflepuffs

[@GRC_grayson]

I’m a slytherin for sure respect those hufflepuffs RIP Cedric Diggory

[@Eleanore.Rigbyy]

Imagine how insulted Voldemort would be if he knew Harry’s bogart WASNT HIM 😂😂

[@thatonehufflepuff3643]

Yes

[@It_is_Okay_to_be_Sad]

OMG....This is so underrated comment...LOL

[@BlueSparxLPs]

To be fair, it probably was after he got over his fear of Dementors. He fully expected the Boggart to be Voldemort at first, and that most likely would have happened if the Dementors had not been there.

[@jibizz]

@@BlueSparxLPs you are being reasonable, Not luckily but still Remus protected Harry because he thought his bogart would be Voldemort.

[@DraakjeYoblama]

To be fair at that point Harry had defeated Voldemort once by getting attacked and doing nothing, and another time by stabbing a book with the nearest sharp object. If that's your opponent, there's not much to be afraid of

[@tcshack701]

Dogs are known for their loyalty, and rats are known to abandon sinking ships.

[@windhelmguard5295]

dogs are also very good at finding things.

[@theaspreysisters3587]

TRUE

[@arachnesakura9375]

I mean... Ideally wouldn't any living creature abandon a sinking ship?

[@tcshack701]

@@arachnesakura9375 i meant to say are the first to abandon

[@dharashah2467]

also for being swallowed by snakes!!

[@praharmitra]

"Stands up to Voldemort every June!". Really shows how much Voldy respects Harry's education.

[@AuthorZaraHoffman]

💯

[@olivertunnah3987]

A worthy opponent is a well educated opponent.

[@BlazeStormCloud]

I mean he did have Harry properly duel during the Goblet of Fire. It took some Cruciatus Curses, but it counts :P

[@Thebunnyfudge]

Every June Harry just gets really on edge and anxious 😂 rons like “you alright mate, seem a bit tense” “ITS JUNE RON YOU KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS”

[@JuanMataCFC]

"i really wanna kill this Harry Potter dude, but i won't ever try until the end of the school year, coz education is way more important u know!" - Voldemort, 1991

[@alyssondyer2of3]

The Marauders would have been way more interesting, character wise if they were actually from each of the houses. I bet a friend group of non house mates would be rare at Hogwarts.

[@seventyseven5140]

its rare because its hard to make friends from other houses given that you arent around each other that much

[@deniseclair6100]

Yeah, Dumbledore’s Army is likely the only one that ever happened

[@alexlazzerly3677]

Friends mostly being from the same house is honestly more realistic. They’re the ones you spend most time with.

[@mienfu9824]

@@deniseclair6100 And not even DA members from different houses were friends, they were only practicing spells together

[@ArielVHarloff]

@@mienfu9824 Luna is kinda the only non Gryffindor who really becomes friends with any of the main characters (diggory might have had a chance but he didn't last long enough unfortunately)

[@aumathewarriormouse2549]

I'm a proud Hufflepuff and I always wonder why no one ever mentions our other crucially important virtue, Justice. "Hufflepuff, where they are *Just* and loyal."

[@SomeonesBestFriend11_SBF]

Don't forget, 'particularity good finders.'

[@ninjabluefyre3815]

FRIENDSHIP friendship?

[@pinkajou656]

@@ninjabluefyre3815 FRIENDSHIP!!! WOOO!!!!

[@dubiousgm]

Yes, hufflepuffs are the best

[@phoenix_lament27]

Heck yeah! Also Sirius clearly cares about justice when he is intent on committing the crime he was imprisoned for.

[@jhardman1876]

its kinda funny how Slughorn (a Slytherin) and Peter (a Gryffindor) both used their friendships and relationships with other people to get power, but the Gryffindor (from the "good house") ends up siding with Voldemort and the Slytherin (from the "evil house") ends up siding with Harry. That's a weird parallel I had never thought of before

[@mystic_mimi21]

Omg yes. But I feel slughorn was for clout or popularity and to be able to say he knows great people. For Peter it was because he wanted protection from them either protection from being social outcast or bullied or literal death

[@advaitpanse4675]

It's a good observation.

[@psjrfan4767]

Listen pal, not all Slytherins are evil, and not all Gryffindors are good either, take a look at Peter Pettigrew. Some Slytherins just need love or want love, hence Draco Malfoy. All he wanted was love from his father and to prove himself worthy of the Malfoy name. So be careful what you say, people get offended.

[@advaitpanse4675]

@@psjrfan4767 I think we found a draco stan in the wild ladies and gentlemen

[@jhardman1876]

@@psjrfan4767 I don't think all gryffindors are good and all slytherins are evil (most of my friends are slytherins tbh). the "good house" and "evil house" is just the general perception of the house, hence the air quotes. and clearly Slughorn is a good character and Peter is an evil character, hence the point of the post

[@purplenerd5293]

I prefer to separate them by what they see magic as: Gryffindor, magic is a weapon (something dangerous), Hufflepuff-a gift to others, Ravenclaw-something to understand the world better through, and Slytherin-magic is status

[@grlegrl]

That’s an awesome explanation! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 I am going to use that when I talk to Muggles.

[@wompusslompus5424]

I really love this interpretation 😊

[@ryanward5770]

I don't know if you planned this but these are literally what all of the founders items are. A sword that becomes more powerful, a cup that likely is capable of food related magic to feed others, a diadem which grants the user more intelligence to better understand the world and a locket which is already a status symbol and can only be opened by parseltounges.

[@Alex-cw3rz]

I'm glad someone has finally realised how cunning and intelligent Wormtail was. He's always seen as a snivelling bafoon, a comic relief side kick. But his actions really show otherwise.

[@ihopeicanchangethisnamelat7108]

Your name says one thing, but your profile picture says another...

[@JaharNarishma]

Wormtail gets compared to the other Marauders. His careful and unsure deneanor really paints a picture of incompetence whe put beside the others. Take away the others and you have someone that managed to become an animagus at almost record young age (very difficult process) and someone that managed to map out Hogwarts (iirc, he was the one who did most of the mapping by actually going everywhere. Basically nobody else has managed to find all the crannies of the school.

[@ellie2041]

still hate him morally , but Ill admit he aint dumb

[@yellowalexeo66]

Me before watching this "There's going to be a lot of Sirius seriously jokes"

[@appsnake7225]

Sirius is a Hufflepuff seriously? Seriously.

[@avataryangchenbl9706]

Sirius ? A hufflepuff ? With Sirius seriously jokes ? Are you serious ? Come one seriously ?

[@AJ-kx9mb]

shirley you can't be sirius?!

[@davincent98]

@@AJ-kx9mb I am Sirius. And don't call me Shirley.

[@AJ-kx9mb]

@@davincent98 🤣🤣🤣

[@naolmstead]

Did you just imply the mascot for Hufflepuff should be a dog? And I approve the creation of the word lupinly.

[@Imightbealittlegrey]

Yes let's make lupinly wider used in the potterhead community

[@zara2820]

But badgers represent earth and earth Hufflepuff. But I get ur point. Slytherin- Water Gryffindor- Fire Ravenclaw- Wind Hufflepuff- Earth

[@AinsleySunny]

or Remusly rather because Sirius is Sirius's first name

[@advaitpanse4675]

"Bravery is not the absence of fear but the willingness to stand up to it"

[@giovannayamaniha7114]

That is such a beautiful phrase, I might as well tattoo it

[@cutpie9]

I always figured Sirius needed an extreme amount of bravery to reject his family's sorting. Because of the bravery required in being his own person he was put into Gryffindor

[@giovannayamaniha7114]

I agree! Especially when he first met James, he could very easilly responded being defensive or even aggressive about his heritage. It shows how much Gryffindor he already was.

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Do you agree? Are the Marauders meant to represent the 4 houses?

[@Arcond]

👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿

[@tonymaska5386]

Hmm, good question, but my brain is too mushy at the moment to answer this question with any competence right now.

[@kspar7]

I feel like before the 1st and 2nd wizarding wars.. a lot of people got placed into gdoor to combat the future evils coming.

[@judek1166]

Kind of, I mean Sirius for Hufflepuff, James Gryffindor, Remus Ravenclaw, but idk I hate that Pettigrew tends to represent Slytherin, like he may represent ambition at some points but to me it’s more just being a coward. (I’m a Slytherin personally so ig I’m biased)

[@bellkanen1998]

Lupin is a lot like Hermione. Even though he’s intelligent he values bravery more.

[@TheNukedNacho]

Am I the only one who was immediately sold and could see how he’d fit in with Huff? I mean?? “Nice one, James!”

[@frankzhang866]

"I'd rather die than sell out lily and james"

[@vignotum132]

it's not cannon but I get what you mean

[@CeCeBookworm07]

That line breaks me every time.

[@MetalCompressor_]

Not to mention his extreme kindness to Harry as well as the hard work he puts in to become an Animagus.

[@kristinagutierrez]

Remus didn’t know about the Sirius/Peter secret keeper switch because Sirius thought that Remus was the spy. As much as I like to pretend the prank didn’t happen, it was a serious betrayal of Sirius to endanger Remus in such a way. He’s passionate and reckless-the fatal flaws of a Gryffindor. I’d argue that James is more Hufflepuff than Sirius. James, who took Peter under his wing, Sirius under his roof, and Remus under his protection. James, whose blind loyalty to his friends, is what killed him and his family in the end. J brings up James trying to fight Voldemort wandless, as proof of his bravery. I say it’s proof of his loyalty and his trust that his friends would never betray him, that he would be unarmed when his family is in so much danger. “No, I think you’re like James,” said Lupin, “who would have regarded it as the height of dishonor to mistrust his friends.”

[@14akamaru]

I'm just surprised that there wasn't a comparison between Sirius' surname and the Hufflepuff colors. Both have Black

[@noorykorky5056]

That is SO TRUE!!!

[@phoenix_lament27]

I think Hermione actually represents Slytherin really well. She’s cunning, uses any means to achieve her ends (Snape + fire, Murrietta Edgecomb, terrifying Neville into joining SPEW, etc.), and she’s ambitious.

[@pawdaypay9000]

Brave like a gryffindor.

[@mayaborg5586]

I agree. One of Ravenclaw's most important traits is open-mindedness, and Hermione never really shows that. In fact, when Luna comes into the story, you see a lot of sharp contrasts between the two, a lot of which I think can relate to their houses (and Hermione's possible representation in Slytherin).

[@keithg460]

Except how she helps her friends a lot with homework and fighting dark wizards. Slytherins aren't known for being so helpful. And of course, she's muggleborn. Otherwise, good point.

[@Imightbealittlegrey]

Actually Hermione is a perfect mix of all houses. She is very hardworking and works for justice, she is ambitous and cunning and will do anything to achieve her goals, very brave, smart, and can be witty. Now that I think about it she is probably the least griffindor! Sure she is brave, and values bravery, but that's really not all that much compared to how much she has in common with the other houses.

[@Imightbealittlegrey]

@@keithg460 I think what you mean is "this is a really good point but Slytherin's bad reputation means that a good character couldn't possibly be in there. I'm going to also add to the fact that a lot of people get sorted into slytherin and question what evil about them because they have only ever known slytherin to be a evil house." Of course Slytherin's aren't *known* for being helpful, and that's (mainly) people like you who believe slytherin is the evil house's fault! I'm sorry that I get too worked up about stuff like this

[@AnnaEmilka]

Actually, Sirius' proposal to change the Secret Keeper proves even more loyality to James, as Sirius was able to take himself down from the pedestal of being the Keeper and suggested a way that (in his belief) protected James even more, placing his firend's safety above his own ego.

[@talathien8771]

Can we discuss the fact that James died at age 21 but looks like he's at LEAST 35?

[@Kelarys]

Never not been annoyed with that casting choice, #notmyJames

[@zlayne357]

Awful casting choice.

[@PS-DLMA]

Dont get started on casting age......Slughorn is meant to be older and have taught Hagrid and Voldy doesnt really look it.

[@talathien8771]

@@PS-DLMA yeah but Voldy has reasons, you know? Also Slughorn was meant to be a great deal fatter.

[@PS-DLMA]

@@talathien8771 i can forgive not being fat enough.......but Hagrid looks similar age to Sirius and Lupin and yet is significantly.older

[@jae5004]

Sirius is not only a dog but also mistaken, by Harry, to be the Grim a dog that strikes just as much fear if not more in wizards as werewolves. This shows even more loyalty to Lupin because even though he can’t choose his Animagus form it still would be a way for Sirius to metaphorically make Lupin feel more comfortable about his own wolffish-ness.

[@kaiyaeatscrumpets]

He actually was rude to lupin and exposed him as a werewolf when he was a child

[@jae5004]

@@kaiyaeatscrumpets Trying to murder Snape and outing Lupin are not the same.

[@ActiveAdvocate1]

"I would have died! I would have died rather than betray my friends!" --Sirius Black Speaking as a (very proud) Hufflepuff myself...come on. Are we not bellowing "HUFFLEPUFF" to the heavens here?

[@killerlight2265]

I wonder how many times Harry showed his slytherin personality

[@elainegoates9792]

Let's put it this way. He could have fled the country, and lived somewhere as a muggle for the rest of his life. He could have not tried at the tri wizard tornament. he was very determined to be an auror, and succeeded in accomplishing that goal. Slitheren means abishon not evil, and he is rather ambishus when you look at what he does and sets his mind to.

[@sahasralol69]

@@elainegoates9792 FR

[@Imightbealittlegrey]

@@elainegoates9792 slytherin* Ambition* Ambitous* I had to I'm sorry 😅

[@jvanegas9]

But, how much of his slytherin personality was cause by the piece of voldemort's soul in him?

[@elainegoates9792]

@@jvanegas9 given his personality didn't seem to change much after he got rid of Mr no nose, I don't think he was effected much

[@glycell5008]

Also as a dog and his heightened sense of smell, he is a particularly good finder.

[@ThaliaVitalis]

My head just filled in Neville's "I'M AWESOMEEE!" 😆😂😂😂😂

[@Miss_Myth]

SAME!

[@Storm-bv7pc]

lol me 2

[@robynhayward]

I may have cried when you started talking about Sirius' loyalty to the Potters 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️ oh my Hufflepuff heart!

[@xxcriminalwolfiexx5492]

dont worry i did to 😅 also fellow hufflepuff here!

[@oscarvanninen2891]

Eww hufflepuffs

[@paradygmshift7826]

No kidding, the fact that he blames himself for their death as much as Wormtail proves the kind of man he was.

[@pinkajou656]

@@oscarvanninen2891 HOW DARE YOU MEANIE 😡

[@wiz3010]

Hufflepuff fans were desperate for this, happy for them.

[@coolnerdlll6053]

As a Hufflepuff, I would gladly welcome Sirius into our house. Where my badgers at?

[@Jesus_Sav3d_M3]

Heyo

[@justalurkerignoreme]

Fellow badger here!💛🖤💛🖤

[@Kaiserin]

*laughs in Slytherin* 💚

[@edthesped186]

Badger gang💛🖤💛🖤

[@EiferBrennan]

Yo!

[@stephanwatson7902]

The Marauders time in Hogwarts is so interesting. We need a book or series of movies about them growing up and being young adults fighting Voldemort!!!

[@k.barbossa]

All The Young Dudes by MsKingbean89 is the answer :) thank me later :D

[@Ruka-oz5ib]

@@k.barbossa YES

[@Ruka-oz5ib]

There is a ton of fics! Like there are 100s and 100s of them but I do love All The Young Dueds

[@RetroGirl1967]

I am not the first person to suggest this. I take absolutely no credit for this idea. I am still posting it here. 7 season maurders TV series. Each season is a year at Hogwarts. There is a movie/mini-series that covers 1977-1981.

[@namanlakhani8923]

I think hermione has a lot of traits of a hufflepuff too because she shows extreme loyalty towards Harry and is the only one who stayed by his side no matter what happened.

[@danielpriest1142]

And particularly towards the end of the series, we see a very compassionate side to Hermione.

[@thetimetraveller2671]

Also, her fight for justice for the house elves is a bit of a Hufflepuff thing to do

[@august1837]

And also hardworking. Book 3 anyone

[@Imightbealittlegrey]

I think that she has hufflepuff, but not due to loyalty. She is very hardworking, heck she took all the classes, while helping hagrid save buckbeak, which also somewhat proved her loyalty! And she has a sense of justice, (SPEW), and that's not it but I don't feel like making this comment 'times Hermione fought for justice' All of this also leads back to determination, which is a slytherin trait. And her smartness and Thurst for knowledge makes some believe she would be suited for ravenclaw, but what about creativity? Thinking outside the box? The only part of Hermione that could be mistaken for those is actually cunning. Hermione is very cunning, and doesn't really let much get in the way of what she wants, which goes back to Ambition. So yeah, I think Hermione is more hufflepuff slytherin.

[@Storm-bv7pc]

No. We Ravenclaws own rights to our badass bookworm.

[@Jan_Koopman]

A dog is not only the symbol of loyalty, but also the closest relative to the wolf, so Sirius' animagus form is closely related to Remus' affliction. Maybe to be better able to help him?

[@lauraeden6224]

And “Sirius” in astronomy is the Dog Star

[@dedenne1341]

Before watching “I’m not so sure about that one guys” After watching: “ok yes 100%” 😂

[@riluna3695]

Every time.

[@TheKabuto90]

Same exact thought process.

[@zora1138]

Me every time I watch one of their videos.

[@Tru1Tani]

This just made cry about Sirius' death again. I always believed the world didn't deserve Hufflepuffs. As a Ravenclaw myself I always say they're good for the sake of goodness. And Sirius was definitely that

[@yoannam5467]

The only time Sirius 'loyalty failed was when he suggested that Peter be the secret keeper when James wanted him to be :'( He would have died before betraying his friends, so he was perfect for the job! I love Serius, but I've always thought this was a plot convenient, and not true to the character ..

[@carlairving]

Not to mention this also meant betraying Lupin. And common sense, but that is another story.

[@TardisCoreST]

It seems kind of logical for me. They needed not someone who will die before releasing the secret, but someone who wouldn't be attacked at all for it. Sirius and Remus probably both were known by the Death Eaters as James' best friends and most loyal protectors, so of course Voldemort would target them first to find Potters. Peter was an obvious choice because who would think that they trust a secret like that to him? He would've probably been dismissed as a source. Little did they know, he was already loyal to Voldemort, but that's another thing entirely. From Marauders' point of view he was the perfect secret keeper because he probably wouldn't been attacked at all.

[@AnnaEmilka]

It's not a fail, it's actually proving his loyality, as he was willing to step down for the sake of James' safety.

[@jrsherlock5888]

I've always wonder why they used one of the group, as I would have thought really they had a few better choices given Voldemort's distain for lower creatures I'm surprised Dumbledore didn't think that a house elf at Hogwarts be made the secret keeper and sworn to silence. If he knew from Peter that someone had been made secret keeper I don't think he's going for the house elf. The other option I've always wondered about was could a ghost or magical object could be made a secret keeper? As if they could either nearly headless nick or the sorting hat would have been other good options that Voldemort wouldn't think of.

[@veronikaczr1105]

Why wasn't James his own secret keeper? We know it's possible. Other than that, I really like the idea of house elf being a secret keeper as in the comment above

[@nurdle8673]

I think Pettigrew and Neville draw a really good parallel. Both valued bravery because they were scared, but the difference is in how they responded. Neville stepped up and confronted his feat, whereas Pettigrew didn’t.

[@poisonbarb75]

Always thought of myself as a Ravenclaw. However, every single of the 4 times I've made the Pottermore quest, I've been sorted into Hufflepuff. Seeing as Sirius is my favorite character, this theory is fully supported by me.

[@jmace2424]

I love that James thrusts an invisible sword while talking about Gryffindor and then Harry pulls the actual sword from the Hat.

[@mienfu9824]

James = Harry (Gryffindor) Sirius = Ron (Hufflepuff) Lupin = Hermione (Ravenclaw) So the only difference is that the trio didn't have a Wormtail in their group.

[@dagoattman]

Yeah, also Ginny kinda parallels with Lily

[@christicrochets9011]

That's why they succeeded where the Mauraders failed

[@taylor_green_9]

Nope! Harry = Peter (Slytherin), and they succeeded because Harry had Slytherin-like leadership qualities

[@giovannayamaniha7114]

@@taylor_green_9 I think is unfair to parallel Harry with Peter, because even having a lot of the traits compatible with slytherin, I guess he is more of a hero known by his courage than by his leadership. Not having anything to do with the similarities between the trios, I guess Dumbledore could very well be in Slytherin, after all, was his huge ambition that made his biggest mistakes.

[@taylor_green_9]

@@giovannayamaniha7114 I don't mean Harry is bad like Peter, only that they're both the Slytherin representatives of their respective friend groups

[@ghostbearr1]

SuperCarlinBrothers: Cuts off Finger Me: Cuts off Hand.

[@solidsnaker1992]

They were meaning when he was framing Sirius, he cut off his finger so he could fake his death

[@thescarletteve]

SCB: Sirius is a Hufflepuff ME: absolutely not... but you’re telling me so it has to be true

[@sophiadavid2405]

love this theory but the part where you mention him proving his loyalty to peter by making him secret keeper just made me sad bc it made me think of how this gesture shows the opposite for remus - sirius doesn’t choose remus bc he thinks he’s the spy bc he was a werewolf so it was him betraying his loyalty to remus:(

[@_monomoon]

Right, it’s so heartbreaking how much they trusted Wormtail? 😔 Though I don’t think Sirius thought Remus to be the spy bc he was a werewolf; Sirius loved Remus, as he did Wormtail and obviously James. I don’t think he would’ve judged him based on that... They effing turned into Animagi for him! Remus also admits that he thought Sirius might’ve been a spy _before_ J&L die. I think it’s bc these two are way more interesting targets for Voldemort to try to infiltrate/Imperuse. Both are much more intelligent and talented than Wormtail, and Remus even could be used as a dangerous weapon (like Voldy is using Fenrir Greyback). I think that’s why nobody suspected Wormtail... bc he really has nothing to offer. Except for his connection to the Order. 🙄

[@sophiadavid2405]

@@_monomoon ok i like this thought i’ve just become so used to the pain of having to read about remus and sirius not trusting each other post hogwarts in all these fanfics but i like your thinking so much more

[@k.barbossa]

I think that it was such a hard time (the war...), for 20-year-olds especially. So much anxiety and fear.. people do get paranoid in times of terror. Sirus already had loads of emotional baggage and trauma on him (abusive household, escaping home, losing his brother which he thought was the 'bad guy'...), that getting paranoid when your best (boy)friend is on some secret missions, doing merlin knows what. I don't find him not trusting him that strange, he was such a messed up kid.. His mind was playing with him, I like to believe.

[@kennachristian8501]

I just love how Voldemort always waits until the end of the year to kill Harry even though he hates him he does care about Harry’s education

[@everythingpotter2016]

I'm a ravenclaw but I actually always kinda got Hufflepuff vives from sirius although on the outside he gives off gryffindor inside I feel Hufflepuff also I would really appreciate if you read this comment it would mean so much to me

[@emeraldqueen1994]

People born in the year of the DOG are known for loyalty too

[@rodan9773]

Using The Locket for Ron is a bit unfair given it was The Lockets Influence and Ron had been wearing it to long.

[@kriegwhatever]

errr actually no

[@rodan9773]

@@kriegwhatever ?.

[@sersastark]

He was sour and a bit nasty before the locket.

[@rodan9773]

@@sersastark Ya but the Locket part its self was unfair given its influence.

[@yusufgazi7]

He was jealous in Goblet of Fire

[@jonnysmpr]

Even though the book always talks about Harry as a slytherin, I’ve always thought that Ron was the slytherin and Harry was the hufflepuff. In the first book, Ron saw himself as head boy, quidditch captain and winning accolades in the mirror of erised, so we know what his deepest desires are, whereas Harry sees his family. Ron gets incredibly jealous when Harry achieves anything, hardly the poster child for Hufflepuff. It appears that their nurturing up until 11 would lead them to be Hufflepuff (Harry - because of a lack of family), Sytherin (Ron - always overlooked and never having nice things) , Ravenclaw (Hermione - her parents being intelligent, dentists valuing her education), but perhaps the hat knows best as each character then spends 7 years effectively ‘unlearning’ these personalities forced on them through their upbringing and becoming closer to their ‘true’ ‘best’ self. That feels like a very Rowlingesque message to me. Arguably, the entire book series is about kids learning (or failing) to grow beyond their ‘lot’ in life into stable ‘good’ adults, their upbringing prior to hogwarts is the thing to which every important character is rebelling against. Sirius would have done well in Hufflepuff, however it doesn’t fit the theme of redemption through rebellion embellished by the other characters. James on the other hand seems to fit Hufflepuff perfectly, however let’s not forget just like Harry we know for a fact he chose Gryffindor.

[@kaitlynbrown1295]

Super Carlin brothers posts so I drop everything my favourite channel ever

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Aw thanks!

[@Arcond]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers 👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿

[@georgebroberg7154]

me at the beginning: mm yeah i'll probably be convinced. me after: yup called it

[@sit-insforsithis1568]

Really? You are that easily convinced

[@shinatina2466]

the last time i was this early these socks are amazing was my favorite running gag

[@droowayne]

It's always disappointed me that the golden trio and the marauders were all from Gryffindor. I understand that it's easier to be friends with someone from your house that you share a common room and classes with, but I think that it makes the houses feel unequal.

[@Goodbutevilgenius]

So what? Houses being equal is not really a big point of the story.

[@doodle_bear291]

Last time I was this early, Dudly only had 36 presents (Not my joke but I'm early and desperate xoxo)

[@psjrfan4767]

Before I watched this: Hmm, I didn’t even think about that before, YES HE IS A HUFFLEPUFF After I watched this: Yay my favorite character belongs in the same Hogwarts house as me When SCB say a theory, it is now law.

[@hannahmotley1863]

Hufflepuff should have been a coyote instead of a badger (only those who watch the pop know this)

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Pretty Obvious

[@Arcond]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers 👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿

[@august1837]

Hufflepuff Sirius is something I need but we definitely wouldn’t have gotten. Honestly I would have loved it if the marauders actually mirrored the founders. It would have made them even more interesting and unique to come together from all four houses

[@propandapower7633]

“We have 4 houses:” J’s house, Ben’s house, Tyler’s house, and Parent Carlin’s house.

[@drewpamon]

Pretty sure Ron was the Slytherin. He's very ambitious and his greatest dream is to be the greatest of his family.

[@mystic_mimi21]

I thought that too and Harry is more hufflepuff as he is doesn’t have ambition and hates the attention and being famous arguably. And before he even properly enters the the wizarding world or hogwarts he dislikes Draco as he over hears him in the cloak shop. As a hufflepuff he would also stand up for justice. However I think book Ron is more hufflepuff when it comes to hermione and standing up for her but in the films they don’t really show that and he is more slytherin in my opinion . I think people jump to Harry being a slytherin due to the horocrux, and the sorting hat saying he would be great in slytherin

[@drewpamon]

@@mystic_mimi21 loyalty to hermione isn't loyalty in the hufflepuff sense but the slytherin. Another ambition of his is to make hermione his girlfriend and he's willing to do anything to meet that goal.

[@tuopsy]

@@drewpamon i agrée. i think his loyalty towards hermione was more about his underlying crush on her. which ties into what you said about him being ambitious to have her as his girlfriend.

[@Kelarys]

saying Ron embodies loyalty just feels so wrong to me. He is so prone to abandoning Harry that it's a major plot point of multiple books

[@tuopsy]

@@Kelarys i wouldn’t say he’s disloyal. he just seems like the type of friend who would leave you whenever there’s an argument :/ no hate to him as a character tho. i still think he was a good friend in other ways 🤷‍♀️

[@christineexe]

the hat is a friend matchmaker. doesn’t matter what house you belong in if the hat knows you’re destined for a friend group with a cool name like the marauders or the golden trio

[@pinkajou656]

I wish my school had a sorting hat...

[@gravedigger8482]

Lupin is not making rash decisions ? He almost abandons his unborn child to go on an adventure.

[@accio_firewhiskey8256]

Touché

[@thedragonwarrior5861]

In his defense he thought Teddy would always be ashamed of what he is

[@giovannayamaniha7114]

Another defender of Lupin here, they were present in a time of war, he felt that he could be usefull to the person who could win it. He was also scared and guilty to bring a child being a werewolf, and I love how it took Harry's words to make him realize how important being with family was.

[@gabriellaclayton6407]

“well for one he has claws” NO NO NO STOP

[@xxcriminalwolfiexx5492]

💀

[@pinkajou656]

XD

[@Goddess_Isis]

This is one of my more favorite theories you've presented in a while. I love this!

[@Aisha_Luv]

Um, I think you mean Sirius is Hufflepuff house. And Lupin is Ravenclaw. And James is Gryffindor. And Peter is Slytherin. Think about it.... Edit: I just read the description and that's what this is about. I came across it somewhere on reddit, and it may have evn been on an SCB sub reddit lol.

[@atharvsharma2539]

I don't like the actual title

[@Kaiserin]

Glad Peter isn’t in Slytherin, we don’t want him.

[@silvaousnevermore7437]

No one wants him. I’m a gryffindor and legit no one wants him here.

[@foodofthegods]

Don’t want him in Ravenclaw either. Not that the hat would ever consider it.

[@taylorbevans556]

Video Title: Sirius is a Hufflepuff Actual Video: Only 3min. of why Sirius is a Hufflepuff lol

[@thesilverprincess]

Harry: hey Ron, I really need some moral support, like, my life is on the line Ron: yeah yeah yeah go away famous little liar

[@keithg460]

Awesome, now we know why Ron DOESN'T belong in Hufflepuff. He ain't that loyal.

[@sit-insforsithis1568]

We have a movie only guy here

[@keithg460]

@@sit-insforsithis1568 It's a joke.

[@Goodbutevilgenius]

How are the movies different from the books in this regard?

[@ceilingsintheireyes6288]

@@sit-insforsithis1568 yeah coz book Ron doesn’t turn his back on Harry in book 4 and 7 oh wait

[@keithg460]

@@Goodbutevilgenius I think my main point of Ron not being that loyal is true in both the books and the movies. But as devil's advocate, you could say that movies make it a bigger thing. For one, they make Hermione a saint and Ron useless, so that when he leaves it makes him appear worse than he does in the movies. Secondly, in the books Ron is a much better and kinder friend to Harry than Hermione is. Sure, she gives them all the answers and does the difficult magic for them, but she is very annoying and she doesn't take Harry's side most of the time. Like how in PoA, she tells on Harry when he gets the Firebolt and doesn't apologize when it gets taken. Or in HbP when she acts smug that the Prince led Harry astray with Sectemsempra. Ron more often seems to have Harry's back in the smaller situations and is a better friend to Harry, always agreeing with his point of view and being a good mate. And the movies never show that. That would make both of them seem sort of unloyal. But I definitely think that the Carlinbros missed the boat when they breezed over this fact. Because when the chips are down, Ron is too unloyal to be a Hufflepuff (when he turns his back both times), but he is brave enough to be a Gryffindor (when he puts aside his ego and comes back).

[@davidfitzpatrick4254]

Also how the heck would Lupin perform his Perfect duties if he has to disappear once a month because of the werewolf thing?

[@elainegoates9792]

He does them every night except once a month, because of the werewolf thing. Plus well doing so he keeps an eye on the most dangerous people in his house.

[@christicrochets9011]

Shhhh... don't ask questions...

[@davidfitzpatrick4254]

@@elainegoates9792 fair enough but wouldnt havoc reign when hes not there?

[@davidfitzpatrick4254]

@@christicrochets9011 ill ask all the questions i want lol jk.

[@RetroGirl1967]

My guess is when they make the rotation of who has rounds, the teachers/staff made sure not to assign him patrols on nights with a full moon. On nights with a full moon, Lily could handle house specific perfect tasks alone.

[@SimplySophieLou]

I've always had the thought of gryffindor being "the house where you choose to go to be more". To me, most gryffindors could easily be sorted into one of the other 3 houses. Take the golden trio: Harry Slytherin, Ron Hufflepuff, Hermione Ravenclaw. To me, Gryffindor is a choice.

[@tatianasalazar4066]

I don't really think so...

[@SimplySophieLou]

That's fair :) just my opinion!

[@apogee7765]

"Ron always comes back" Ron is officially the perfect boomerang.

[@stellafanders]

Good joke: ✅ Including Ron: ✅ No Ron bashing: ✅ Good job, one of the best HP jokes I heard in a while.

[@Brink-ex1gv]

I love this theory it fits so well. The fit for the current heroes and marauders fit all of these. I am so excited you guys were thinking along the same lines I was with the comment I had last week lol. Best channel ever keep up the great theories guys

[@bradscott8162]

Hmm. I think it just shows humans are not actually easily categorized. More that our choices define our character.

[@redcactusify]

Totally agree.

[@cinematicallyspeaking731]

Sirius is hands down my favourite character. Although I feel an affiliation to Gryffinfor, I am also a hufflepuff. To think Sirius could also be one is Siriusly awesome!!!! Great video once again, Jay!! 🥰

[@leosong829]

J: We got 4 houses Me: Dang you are rich J: Gryffidor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw and Slitheryn Me: Oh

[@alexricky87]

12:52 and also the dog is the cousin of the wolf so even tho not directly related Sirius saw himself as a brother to Lupin, a warewolf.

[@israelperets7799]

i just power watcht the all first year project so much fun love you guys🥰

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

WOW thanks for sticking with us through all the cringe!

[@Arcond]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers 👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿

[@vedanshi3294]

I relate to Sirius on so many levels and my house is Hufflepuff, so this makes sense

[@iddefusco]

If you keep making them we’ll keep watching them. Love these Harry Potter videos. 🔮💕

[@fudgalicious]

Decided to visit your channel today, pleasantly surprised that you have a new Harry Potter theory video posted tOdAy, thanks! :D

[@claudiacat4249]

I have been in a tottally not Harry Potter mind set today and then at the beginning of the vid when J says "Lets talk houses" I was like, "why? Houses, what do those have to do with Harry Potter.... OHHH"

[@joshuahirst7218]

Same honestly😂

[@lorainelawson7570]

I think Simmons from Agents of Shield would be in gryffindor because when she got the alien virus she was willing to jump out the plane to save everyone else. (If you watched Agents of Shield then you understand.)

[@sirmyself]

Literally just finished the final season.

[@sakeenahniazi7528]

well yes but also she's very ambitious and values that a lot. maybe a hufflepuff/slytherin hybrid?

[@carlsoll]

Love your content guys! Keep it upp

[@ZenDoKaiGuy1]

This is a fantastically wholesome channel. I teared up a bit in this video and it's not the first to evoke an emotional response... Admittedly the firewhiskey may have played a supporting role tonight, but the point still stands.

[@AliAngelpie]

It makes sense due to the intense guilt Sirius feels for letting his best friends be betrayed by Peter Pettigrew after suggesting Lily and James switch Secret Keepers.

[@notsolukky2934]

YESS MY FAV CHARACTER IN MY HOUSE also love the vids

[@marissaelliott6102]

Lol at the beginning he said "OK let's talk about houses" and for a second I thought he meant actual houses you live in and I was very confused lol. Love this observation and how it linesmup so perfectly!

[@deanandjo4ever]

Sirius is a Gryffindor but I will listen to you because I love y'all, my daughter and I watch y'all all the time for y'alls Harry Potter and Marvel videos. And yall have helped me with my depression by giving my mind something to do. Yall are awesome.

[@RobertVlcek]

"But the fleas. They're murder."... So, it's actually more an interpretation other than a theory (these days the word "theory" is been overused in my opinion and yes "interpretation" isn't as eye catching as "theory" 😉) but yeah, I totally agree.

[@WolfgangDoW]

Hypothesis

[@alexlazzerly3677]

Also Lupin should be in Ravenclaw.

[@foodofthegods]

Maybe his father was. (His mother was a muggle)

[@stellafanders]

Could also be a Hufflepuff. Why? He is patient and kind which you can see in his lessons and he is fair. Dont forget, justice is a Hufflepuff trait. They mentioned in their video about which magical creature the hogwarts houses could be instead of the normal ones that Hufflepuff accepts everyone who doesnt fit in. Remus constantly feels like an outsider and is an outcast in the wizarding community. I already thought about when they mentioned Hufflepuffs house magical symbol could be a werewolf instead of the badger that Godric would find it funny when the first and only werewolf in the school became a Gryffindor

[@aesthetic_vivien7794]

This is the first one of your videos and then i feel in love with your Chanel and i now watch every day

[@bsperoz]

1:00 INCORRECT. Bravery is having no fear, and COURAGE is having frar but doing something anyway.

[@cecilia.tarango9001]

I never thought about it this way, but now you can’t convince me otherwise, SIRIUS ORION BLACK IS A HUFFLEPUFF!!! Also, I before finding out he was a Gryffindor, I immediately thought “ravenclaw” for Lupin.

[@MrTomandersson]

Wasn't the hat just considering putting harry in Slytherin because it felt the part of Voldemorts soul?

[@Kaiserin]

I thought that was only a theory. And Harry definitely does have some Slytherin traits.

[@TheKabuto90]

It is only a theory. The only part that's actually confirmed is that the hat did feel Harry would do well in Slytherin.

[@elizabethatchley4811]

@@Kaiserin But what if harry only acted kinda like a syltherin bc of the part of voldemort in him? Like when they had the necklace on in the 7th book they kinda acted like syltherins. So what if it was only bc of the part of voldamort in him?

[@Kaiserin]

@@elizabethatchley4811 The locket didn’t make them like Slytherins, just made them angrier. It’s possible that the piece of Tom’s soul in Harry gave him some of his Slytherin-like tendencies (like it gave him the ability to speak parseltongue) but none of that is confirmed.

[@MrTomandersson]

Not confirmed but "pretty obvious"

[@ashleydavis3860]

This may be my favourite video ever. Sirius and Ron are my favorite characters and I am a proud HUFFLEPUFF!!!

[@goodestpupper9311]

I do wonder why no one thinks of Harry as a Hufflepuff as well. He is incredibly loyal to others to the point of sacrificing himself for the people he cares about. Even when his first ever true friend Hagrid is revealed to be a half giant, he immediately rushes to his defense. Also he is incredibly hard working and just. As he dedicates his teen years to make the world a better place for others.

[@sophiadavid2405]

i’m a marauders/wolfstar stan till i die and i can’t imagine any reality where sirius isn’t in the dorm w prongs and his moony but i’m listening...

[@aeris3501]

Haha same! (also just noticed there that you said “his moony” which made me way happier than it should haha)

[@sophiadavid2405]

@@aeris3501 yess i was hoping someone would notice:)

[@christicrochets9011]

Raise your hand if you too hate how JK Rowling gave Lupin a compulsively heterosexual wife?

[@sophiadavid2405]

@@christicrochets9011 she really wrote two heavily heavily queer coded characters and then saw queer fans identifying with them and went “yk what? f*ck you guys” and forced them together for no reason😐

[@christicrochets9011]

@@sophiadavid2405 then she threw a dart at a board and really gave us DumBlEdoRe iS gaY gUYs

[@ConnerTravis1998]

Hmm am I the only thinking that the Marauders are not just a representation of having traits of the 4 house but also the founders of Hogwarts themselves? Something about their story (though I believe there’s going to be obvious differences too) that just also might fit quite well how the story of the founders is like 🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@beastwriter3915]

I left a comment in your Wormtail sorting vid abt the Golden Trio + Neville analogy, and just the other day, I had a short discussion with some who argued that Harry is the least ambitious if the Trio. They made some good points too.

[@solidsnaker1992]

imagine if in Voldys army it was normal for them to chop their arm off and have Voldy make a new silver one that will kill them if they mess up

[@ashleycanooo]

hmmm i don't know if i agree with this one by the title BUT let's see if y'all can convince me

[@potterheadfan3741]

Same

[@ashleycanooo]

@@potterheadfan3741 i myself have always seen james as the hufflepuff of the group tbh but that might be just because of fanon rather than canon

[@diyavatsavai5778]

Is it just me, or does it seem weird to call Peter Pettigrew "Peter"?

[@kathzemiau7234]

Ron's Patronus is also a kind of dog, so this loyalty stuff seems legit. Would Ron's animagus form be a dor too? Would have been so sweet if the trio became Animagi. And useful too, perhaps.

[@kigagamer8999]

I felt prepared for this video but than "SILVER FANGS" 🤣🤣🤣