Slaughter on the machine is halal.? | Shahid & Bilal Official

[@mehmudhassan8994]

Mashallah Ali Bhai your great schooler ❤

[@zahid..]

عام بینک میں تو ہر چیز پر سود ہوتا ہے جبکہ اسلامی بینکنگ میں بھی تقریبا سب کا سب سود ہوتا ہے۔ اسلامی بینکنگ میں ہر معاملے کو انفرادی طور پر دیکھا جائے گا کہ اس میں سود تو نہیں ۔ اسلامی بینکنگ میں بھی زیادہ تر مورگیج میں سود شامل ہوتا ہے ۔

[@khankhattak5015]

Bhai jaan ye banking system hi haram hai quran kai mutabiq ess mai jesnai account kolai hai aur paisai rakai hai wahi hi gunahgaar hai kunkai wohi es system ko chalatai hai

[@zahid..]

@@khankhattak5015 بالکل صحیح کہا آپ نے ۔ سب کا سب بینکنگ سسٹم ہی حرام ہے ۔ کیونکہ جو اس میں اکاؤنٹ کھولتا اگر وہ اس پیسہ کی سیونگ پر سود نہ بھی لے تو اس کے پیسے پر بینک دوسروں کو سود دیتا ہے ۔ تو اس کا پیسہ سود کے لین دین میں شامل ہو گیا ۔

[@zahid..]

@@khankhattak5015 bilkul sahih kaha aap ne. sab ka sab banking system hi haraam hai. kyunkay jo is mein account kholta agar woh is paisa ki saving par sood nah bhi le to is ke paisay par bank doosron ko sood deta hai. to is ka paisa sood ke lain deen mein shaamil ho gaya .

[@zahid..]

بالکل صحیح کہا آپ نے ۔ سب کا سب بینکنگ سسٹم ہی حرام ہے ۔ کیونکہ جو اس میں اکاؤنٹ کھولتا اگر وہ اس پیسہ کی سیونگ پر سود نہ بھی لے تو اس کے پیسے پر بینک دوسروں کو سود دیتا ہے ۔ تو اس کا پیسہ سود کے لین دین میں شامل ہو گیا ۔ لیکن اسلامی بینکنگ والے یہ دعوٰی کرتے ہیں کہ ان کا نظام سود سے پاک ہے تو پھر ان کے ہر معاملے کو انفرادی طور پر دیکھا جائے گا کہ کس طرح سے سود نہیں ہے ۔ بظاہر میں تو اسلامی بینکنگ بھی سود ہی ہے ۔

[@zahid..]

bilkul sahih kaha aap ne. sab ka sab banking system hi haraam hai. kyunkay jo is mein account kholta agar woh is paisa ki saving par sood nah bhi le to is ke paisay par bank doosron ko sood deta hai. to is ka paisa sood ke lain deen mein shaamil ho gaya. lekin islami banking walay yeh daawa karte hain ke un ka nizaam sood se pak hai to phir un ke har muamlay ko infiradi tor par dekha jaye ga ke kis terhan se sood nahi hai. bzahir mein to islami banking bhi sood hi hai .

[@touhidibrahim2812]

JajakALLAHO khaira Ali bhai

[@VoiceOfRiz]

Mere bhai yeh sawaal app apne local ulma se karien hum tow pehle bhi bolte hain aise bohut se berun e mumalik logon ke masail hain jo Ali bhai ko nahi pata hain ziadater meat to aahi newzealnd se raha hai sistaani saab ka aisa fatwah hai apne bilkul sahee qoute kiya hai

[@gibranmm]

I live in Canada too brother. Don't have a mortgage and don't have any issues with Halal meat here. I don't know what you are talking about. Don't have a savings account and don't have any interest paying accounts. No matter where you are, like Ali bhai says "Doctrine" doesn't change.

[@syedrashedi8220]

You do realize that most meats in canada are haram or machine slaughtered even if they have halal label

[@Banusn]

​@syedrashedi8220 did you go and see all of the meat farms? If you can't prove it then it's a slander, fear Allah!

[@Rajaarslan1400]

Allah pak apko kamyab kry.

[@awaisiqbal316]

Love you bhi❤❤❤

[@muhammadabbasi7195]

Aus par Likha hota hay Zabia Halla ❤

[@mrshamraiz1391]

یہ معاملہ میرے ساتھ بھی پیش آ رہا ہے کہ میری بیوی کے گھر والے فورس کر رہے ہیں مورگیج پر گھر لوں انکا کہنا ہے کہ انکے ماننے والے کسی مولے نے کہا ہے کہ سود ہو یا جو بھی ہو ایک گھر لے سکتے ہیں۔

[@zahid..]

ایک گھر تو بڑی بات ہے آپ سود پر ایک اینٹ بھی نہیں لے سکتے ۔

[@ranaahsan56-7]

Ali bhai ❤

[@rashidmir8974]

Lagta hey comment lekhney walla unpad or jahil hey

[@HarisShah-xf7bx]

Ali bhai apna khayal rakhiya ga

[@IbneHanif6346]

This question should be asked from scholars who lives in those countries

[@afeefakram9824]

No, it doesn’t matter where u live. We need to live and die according to Quran and sunnah. Interest will always be haram.

[@mehboobalamtravelvlog]

Sir mny 2 Questions IMAM sy karny hain Me umeed krta hun k ye Sawal kisi ny nhi kiye hongy

[@mehmoodahmed2524]

Bhai main U.K. main rehta hoon kindly mujhy b time anait farmaen??

[@mudassaraliaheer2812]

Love from Khanewal

[@Enterinfo4u]

There is difference between mortgage and finance. The question not been table properly.

[@MohsinAliS]

islamic bank to bhai or bhe mehnga hai agar conventional interest rate 5 % ho to Islamic bank 8% charge ker raha hoga, kabhi bhe islamic bank conventional rate se neeche ka rate de he nhi sakta jis se sabit hua k back end pe woh conventional ko he follow ker rahay hain sirf sticker islamic ka laga lia hai

[@radd-e-nasibiyat]

Another problem is, Muslims also exploit this situation. If we buy Halal-stamped meat from any Muslim shop, it is affordable and it is clean with no abortive parts. However, I bought meat from a vendor outside of the mosque last Friday, he was selling a bit expensive with all the abortive parts. When I cleaned it, I was left with half of the bought chicken.

[@malikkhan1947]

There are so many shop where you get halal meat … being living in Canada for last 20 years

[@tekashi7044]

Speed of slaughter machine is 120 to 250 chickens per minutes minimum. It is not possible to read takbeer for every chicken. They say takbeer once and run the machine.

[@syedrashedi8220]

Thats why most scholars say machine slaughter is haram

[@afzalwaheed4]

Ali Bhai Mera ik boht aham problem hai main boht preshan Hun how can I contect you

[@ParishaMarketing]

Love EMAM SAHAB ❤

[@hamza83r49]

sheykh bin ba'az ka fatwa ha pls check mirza bhai puray gulf counties ma bee yahi istamal hota ha pls check jzk khaair

[@zahoorahmadlone7493]

Ustaad e mohatram EMAM ❤❤

[@chasifsandhuspain7655]

سب مشین پر ہی جانوروں کو حلال کرتے ہیں،

[@ayazahmed4304]

After hundreds of years we as Muslims stuck with this question

[@54321saqib]

Bhai ye buht bara issue ha west ka

[@zahid..]

جب صدیوں سے دین کی تعلیم ہی نہیں دی جا رہی تو مسئلے تو موجود ہوں گے ہی۔

[@mohammadshadabraza125]

JAZAKALLAH KHAIR ALHAMDOLILAH MASHAALLAH😇🇸🇦🇵🇰🇮🇳🌹💚🤝😇

[@zainhussain9274]

Qirat ki Kon si galti sy nmaz toot jati hy ?

[@zahid..]

اگر تلفظ غلط ہو جائے مثلا ق کو ک پڑھ لیں تو مطلب بدل جاتا ہے جس سے نماز کے فاسد ہونے کا امکان ہے ۔

[@SaimaRaza-lm9zv]

In those countries, students finance companies give loans to study at any age with the condition that you give it back with interest if once you get a good job ( a ceiling income is being told )otherwise the company doesn’t/will not ask for return of either interest or principal amount. Some people think it’s sort of Qarz e Hasana. People getting this loan to study at age 50 or 60 think that they won’t be able to get a good job or maybe they would do only part time job due to age factor so they take this loan thinking that it’s fair enough as they won’t be returning it (neither loan nor interest). Ali bhai please speak on this topic as well.

[@maaz87]

In Canada only or any other countries ?

[@zahid..]

If you are signing a contract, where interest condition is mentioned, the interest condition makes the whole money haram whether you return it or not, doesn't matter.

[@SaimaRaza-lm9zv]

Thanks

[@54321saqib]

Yaha her jgha pr asa he ha Australia ma Recorder pr he halal krty

[@HarisShah-xf7bx]

aaj ali bhai aap ne gtv py annna hai

[@mudassaraliaheer2812]

Hamny ak swal puchna hai ustad mohtram se.plz bta Dein iss trah live sawal kerny ka Kia treeka Hai ?

[@FurqanMemon-dz4ce]

Bhai jan apko daily live session me shahid bhai se bat karni hogi woh apko link denge ali bhai se baat karne ka

[@syedrashedi8220]

@@FurqanMemon-dz4ce live seesion ka link kidher hai

[@FurqanMemon-dz4ce]

@@syedrashedi8220 Abhi nh hoga ja shahid bhai live aeen tab wo apni live me link share karte hen us per click karke live join karna

[@aakifdarphotographer9366]

Love you ustaad e motharam

[@naveedanwar3659]

This is live ?

[@Rajaarslan1400]

❤❤

[@AbuubadaAbuubada-tq6yf]

Ya mujhy Smg nhi aaya

[@JuliasCaesar]

بھائی سوال تو کسی پڑھے لکھے سے پوچھنا تھا جو شخص مورگیج کو سننے کے بعد چھ دفعہ مورٹگیج کہ رہا ہو وہ کتنا جاہل ہو گا یہ تو اندازہ ہو گیا ہو گا

[@pushthoonsthechildrenofisaaq]

Assalamoalikum. Bahir ka halal bhe Sirf machine cut nahe hothe balke us se pehle bijli ka jhatka bhe dethe hain jis se wo mar he jatha he. Angraiz kehthey Hain thake usko dard mehsoos na ho.

[@basharataziz5769]

If we use logic that animal is made unconscious by electric current to prevent pain to the animal the it seems like more human.i read that animal does not die with the current.And then it is slaughtered . I don’t know if anyone is there to say Bismillah,Allah hu Akbar. I read that in America it is law to slaughter like this.Just know that it is prepared for Muslims so hopefully Allah, name is mentioned. There is no way we can have slaughter house according to our wishes.

[@beyondgalaxies3960]

چھری ہو یا کوئی مشین ہو، بلکہ چھری بھی تو کاٹنے والی مشین ہی ہے، ہاں تکبیر پڑھنا ضروری ہے۔ آڈیو نہیں چل سکتی۔

[@zahid..]

مشین میں بھی ہر مرتبہ نئے جانور کے لیے نئی تکبیر پڑھنی لازمی ہے ۔

[@salmanmohsin234]

AoA, I am disappointed to see Muhammad Ali Mirza talking to him in a very rude way. From his tone it shows that it is not a normal Q/A session rather than Jazib is challenging him which making himself uncomfortable. It can be seen that enough time was not granted to express concerns fully and put a logic that ‘everything is already explained’. If all topics have already explained on channel then live questioning sessions are purposeless.

[@roshanayzafar8409]

Engineer was so rude to the person. Wo itni respect se baat kar eha hai. Oper se keh raha hai tumnay meri agar itni videos dekhi hui hain tu tmharay pas koi sawal he nahi hona chahye tha. Ajeeb!

[@syedrashedi8220]

O bhai ye konsa admi sawal kar raha hai? There are so many slaughterhouses where even on machine slaughter there is a person reading tasmiyah. The issue is regarding the flow of the blood. Can you please tell me the way to ask question so I can ask him and provide all the details?

[@imrangadit6044]

You are right, please ask if person recite tasmiyah and machine slaughter then? Because issue is halal and zabiha halal.

[@imrangadit6044]

Please ask him halal and zabiha halal issue.

[@syedrashedi8220]

@@imrangadit6044 exactly. I dont know ow how to be in the session. The way he explained machine slaughtering process is not 100% accurate

[@farhanjumani9364]

Wrong answer... The condition is to read takbir so when machine slaughter is automatic so takbeer could be used in recording as well because the intention is to take the name of lord... It is not easy to slaughter 1000 animals in minutes and recite takbir... In that case this is valid.... However, rejection is easy because until the time of all the four imams and other jurists no technology was their so if you are just the postman between that imam and people today so you will say easily it is Haram. If you are intellectual so you will decide and give clear decision.... This response is for the food...

[@parvezkhatana4768]

Mortgage دا تلفظ مورگیج اے۔ T خاموش اے۔

[@hisamuddinansari5521]

Mortgage ka masla to kabka bayan ho chuka hai. Bhai ne theek se tahqeeq nahi ki hai

[@Skibidirizzler45738]

Aslaam o alikum I m live in usa We buy meat machine slaughtered It's mentioned in their box It's machine slaughtered zabiha halal

[@mynature3295]

In canada Mina halal meat is hand slaughtered

[@hamzipamzi]

Machine slaughter per recording ki jaga agr koi banda physically takbeer parhy, tab bhi haram hay? This question was not addressed properly and will solve problems of so many Muslims in America. Yahan k ulma nay sab muslims ko haram per laga dia hay. Is mamlay ko sanjeedgi say detail main discuss kerna chaiya. Especially muslim restaurants main mechanical cut serve kia jata hay aur jab restaurants sa pocha jata hay tou wo naraz hoty hain ya phir bus halal bol dety hain. Aur jo stores zabiha (hand slaughtered) sell kerty hain wo bhi najaiz faida uthaty hain awaam say. Zabiha meat ki price mechanical slaughter say 3 gunah zyada hay. Alhamdulillah hum zabiha handslaughter he khaty hain. From Dallas Fort Worth, Texas

[@syedrashedi8220]

Exactly! This is a huge issue which doesnt get addressed. The guy didnt explain machine slaughtering very well. Yahan ziada tar restaurant machine cut bechtevhain

[@maaz87]

This guy is charlatan youthia

[@zahid..]

مشین کا ذبیحہ حرام ہے, اگر ہر جانور پر الگ سے تکبیر پڑھی جائے تو پھر حلال ہو گا ورنہ نہیں ۔ باہر کے ممالک میں عموما ایک دفعہ تکبیر پڑھ کر مشین سٹارٹ کر دی جاتی ہے اور سب سمجھتے ہیں کہ تمام جانور حلال ہو جاتے ہیں جبکہ ایسا نہیں ۔ ہر مرتبہ تکبیر پڑھنا ضروری ہے اور یہ باہر عمل کرنا ممکن نہیں اور نہ ہی کوئی کرتا ہے ۔ بہتر یہ ہے کہ آپ اپنے ہاتھ سے ذبح کریں ۔

[@radd-e-nasibiyat]

This certification of Halal is not issued by any person or Alim, instead it is a kind of stamp issued by concerned government authorities. We have been facing the same problem in China so far. I have even tried to ask Chinese Muslims involved in this business, but have not gotten a satisfactory answer (in a sense, they do not provide a clear answer, they just say "Don't worry! All slaughtering persons are Muslims", that's it!). Similarly, we have Muslim canteens in every Chinese university. We have been eating there for so long. Ali bhai, Please provide a comprehensive answer in this situation where we are unable to dig deep and verify, whether it has been slaughtered with proper recitation by a person or audio recording.

[@zahid..]

اگر آپ یہ confirm نہیں کر سکتے کہ جانور حلال ذبیحہ ہے یا حرام تو ایسے جانور کو نہیں کھانا چاہیے ۔ confirmation کے بغیر گوشت مت کھائیں ۔

[@Scarylarryshorts]

Aik admi kitni takbeer perh sakta hey 8 hours shift main. Factory belt is fast so catching up with the speed will make the reading almost inaccurate. Allah ka naam ley liya gaya on recording, it should be fine.

[@NaeemKhan-bp3in]

Mirza saab bahir to hazaro janwar zabah hotay hay Q k odar company hotay hay meet import or export karnay ka Q k Waha 1,1 Janwar zabah nahi hota hay Kahi sawo k tehad may hotay hay. To kesay har 1 par taqbeer paraye jaye ger. Jis company may Muslim ki tehdad b na barabr k hisab say ho. Jo shops may miltee hay kesay PATA chaly ga k halal hay ya Haram. Q k bahir country's k shops may to Pakistan jesay zabah nahi hota hay. Odar to alag alag countrys or alag alag company say ata hay. To iska kesay PATA chaly ga?

[@muhammadrizwan7179]

This is not the answer. I believe bhai needs to do a proper search on this topic. This will be a great help. Even people read, but the bird is already dead due to the fact that they reduce the oxygen. There are so many ways now being introduced

[@ayazahmed4304]

What are you talking about its not pakistan million of peoples gather in mecca and Medina how can any one can slaughter billions of chickens in such a short time think out side of pakistan farigh qoum also with this comes economics logistics and other factors

[@kamrankhan-qb8wz]

Instalment per kuch lena theak ha ghar q harm ha.

[@zahid..]

سب حرام ہے

[@Faujikafanhooniamindian7360]

haram paise se takbir k sath jaba kiya hua janwar ka gost bhi haram hai

[@Pakistanbiography-English]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 Ali bahi there no Islamic bank in the entire world... Evry single broker in England and Western world is intrest based. Including Ali bahi realitives in England got houses with ribba based mortgage...... So we don't agree with your Islamic banking... In England there's no Islamic bank... And the entire system is based in Riba.. Including it Meezan Bank which علی bahi mention is Islamic bank.. Do some background check, there investments and backing are.. Backed by ribba based...... It's haraam simple... We don't agree with any Islamic banking or we don't class any bank and halal.. 2e are with dr israr ahmed in this stance ali bahi is wrong here.... Simple is that

[@muaazchohan9491]

Pakistan May bh machine sy he ho raha hy ab

[@subhankhannnnnnn]

Gustakhe sahaba tum zara mufti Abdul wahid Qureshi k samne ao kasm kha kar kehta hon tera akhri din hoga ilmi dunya m engr mufti sahab ko call par kehta k apke sath is liye munazra nai karta kyu k meri maa ne kaha agar inke sath munazra kia t apna dodh nai bakhshongi yh t tera hal h r sahaba k khilaf bhonkta h

[@muqthar.shaikh]

Pilopilo

[@Plumber466]

Mirza plumber

[@ZeyaanShah]

Tuu khd plumber hai doosroo ko b smjtae hoo jahil

[@zahoorahmadlone7493]

Tumhari tootiyah leak hogayi hai tumhara ilaj plumber ke elawa koi nahi ker sakta

[@Wasim_Raza]

😂😂😂 Tumhare baba ka nut bolt tight kar diya kaya mirza plumber ne.

[@qammarali32]

Babey ty shaey e koi ni😅

[@thetruthseeker1234]

Mere nabi sa hay koi nehi Tere babe te shai koi nehi

[@waqarjamil3981]

Ye chai ghar main beth ke nhi pee ja sakti?

[@AsifAli-c7z7y]

❤❤❤

[@syedhasnainshahkazmi915]

❤❤❤❤❤