Ultimate Smart Light Switch Comparison

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks for watching! I think I walked out to my electrical panel probably 100 times installing and uninstalling all of these switches… and it’s been 115° outside 🥵 But it was interesting to compare these and here’s the link to the article smarthomesolver.com/reviews/ultimate-smart-light-switch-comparison/

[@rogersmj]

Nice work. Having installed dozens of smart switches I can only imagine how long it took to make this comparison. I agree with your criticism of the GE z-wave switch in that it’s not intuitive. I used to have some of these, and the non-configurable fade on/off combined with no separate dimmer control caused no end of frustration with guests and even my wife - people would tap it, but because the fade causes a perceived delay they would sometimes hold it a little too long, which would activate the dimming mode. really irritated people. That’s why I switched to the Leviton z-wave dimmers, which have a separate dimmer control alongside the main paddle. Have you ever tried the Leviton switches?

[@apevny]

So I am new to the inovelli red dimmer. I bought a few for it’s smart home capability. My setup currently is for down press I used a bond bridge to turn off the fan, one press up low, 2 presses for medium, 3 for high. I’m wondering if there would be a way with a piston to make it function similar to a normal fan switch. For example it’s off, a press up makes it go to low, then another one press up to be medium and so on, then one press down to lower the speed, and another press to lower further till it’s off. It would ease the family’s learning curve I think. If not I’ll just stick with the multi presses for scenes.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

@Matt Rogers thanks! Yeah I'm looking forward to not installing a smart light switch for a little while. I haven't tried the Leviton switches but I've seen a few other people comment about it and I'll make sure to include it in the next one. The little rocker being more intuitive for dimming is a good point. Thanks!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

@Andrew Pevny I haven't tried to set something like that up in webCoRE yet but I might give that a try this weekend. I think it would be possible using a variable that cycles through the different speeds. I'll look into that for sure. Thanks!

[@apevny]

Smart Home Solver Sounds good, can’t wait to hear what you might come up with. We are in Sacramento, CA but our temp Sunday may reach your type of high: 111 degrees 🥵

[@whitney5092]

The frustration of trying to get the wires back in the box and lining up those faceplates is worth sooo many likes in itself

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks you so much for recognizing how long that part of the process is! That probably took the most time for this review.

[@DIY_Dad_83]

You are out there doing the grunt work for the people! Thank you for this and everything else that you do!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Haha thanks, I appreciate that! I love making these videos.

[@ModernDayTech]

Great job Reed. Well done. I know how much went into this and I'm impressed. Keep up the amazing work!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Eric! I appreciate that.

[@GenerlAce]

Reed is my go-to when researching smart home stuff. Professional, clear, and very un-biased.

[@KeithAchorn]

Thank you for covering such a wide selection of switches. I replaced a few just last week and appreciate what a hassle it can be to install them safely. I spent weeks before searching for a video just like this, but finding none with this breadth. I was a little surprised not to see the 'C by GE' or Leviton switches included, as they are sold in most major US retailers and are two of the few mass-market hubless options. I ended up going with the 'C by GE' ones myself. So far, so good, but I am still trying to get used to the style.

[@ghaithalhalaby4013]

This is a great video, thanks!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

I really appreciate the super thanks! Glad you enjoyed the video! Thank you so much Ghaith!

[@dennisharris144]

Amazing as usual. I never feel you are selling me something like some other channels. Just clear concise info. What more could you ask for?

[@ryandickerson2329]

I love all your endings! I don't know how you come up with such clever endings for every video!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Ryan!

[@105mmshooter9]

If not mentioned before, wanted to let you know you can program the center (dome) button on the pico remote for the brightness level. I have in wall switch and pico remotes by the lamps in the bedrooms. It fixed turning the switch on only to find someone had turned the lamp off. With the switch / pico arrangement you can turn the light on from either side of the room regardless of where it was turned off. If you tap the center button on the pico it turns on at the programmed brightness.

[@r3jk8]

this is the best review of smart switches on the entire KZbin!

[@garapueto96]

Here it is! Been waiting for this one. Awesome stuff as always! 👍✌️

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Mike!

[@skuzzyj]

every time you put a new thing up that shows up in my feed, it's exactly what I've been talking about with my girlfriend for like the last couple weeks. I don't know how you do it but you make me want to spend money.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Haha that's awesome. Hopefully your girlfriend doesn't hate me too much.

[@claycottingham6505]

I was an early adopter and developer for Insteon back in 2005/06. Early devices had heat issues and periodic failure. Jump forward 12 years, and their newer devices are rock solid. I built a custom home in 2018 and have over 80 Insteon devices with a Universal-Devices ISY-994 automation controller. This allows complex programming and configuration of my system. You definitely need to dip you toes into the system.

[@jerrycarpenter9570]

It's too bad insteon went out of business. I was planning on using them on my remodel because that's what I've been using for several years. My home automation guy wants to use Zooz with Home Assistant. What do you think ?

[@Aloha_XERO]

DAMN !!!.... Where was THIS video 6 months ago🤦‍♂️ ..... This is "HANDS👍DOWN" the BEST👏 KZbin comparison video that gives great in-depth useful information, I didn't even know there was so many option beside what they never have in stock at Lowes or Home Depot ..I'm so tired of the crappy computer generated top 10 videos on {insert search item here} (You Just picked up a subscriber for life bro😎)

[@arielbaena5254]

I know these videos are time consuming and I appreciate your efforts. Thank you.

[@jasonbaker2341]

The GE on/off dimming ramp can be changed. It can even be set differently based on whether it was turned on by z-wave or by a physical press. You can even set it to 0 for instant on/off. Guess it depends if your hub allows your to change that configuration parameter. I'm using Home Assistant.

[@Ryder0910]

The smart home manual is back 😂

[@stephensiemonsma]

Great comparisons! I started out with Kasa switches, and have moved on to Inovelli and Zooz Z-Wave dimmers. Kasa definitely feels like the highest quality hardware, but I'm a sucker for Z-Wave and both Inovelli and Zooz have put a good amount of work into their firmware and device handlers to makes these devices customizable and feature-packed. You didn't mention it, but it may be worth discussing little touches that may differentiate some of these Z-Wave switches/dimmers. For instance, Zooz has been moving to tab-less switches that are much less hassle to install in multi-gang boxes, and they claim the ZEN27 has greater compatibility with dimmable lights (less lightly to flicker/buzz). I'm not sure if your audience would be interested in leading edge vs trailing edge dimmer differences, but it can make a big difference as far as compatibility with "dumb" light bulbs. I think this may have been the cause of your issue with the Inovelli dimmer. Your lights probably prefer trailing edge dimmers instead.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks! Yes I still have more to learn about some of the more advanced things you mentioned about leading edge vs trailing edge. That makes sense about my issue with the Inovelli dimmer. There were some other things too with 3 way switches and how Zooz handles them. It gets pretty overwhelming but I'll definitely check out the ZEN27 and some of those more finite details. I appreciate the comment!

[@stevewalker9888]

Considering you produced this video in sept 2020 . You guys in the USA are leaps and bounds way ahead of us in the uk. I haven’t seen anything lately that remotely looks or does any of the things they do. Other than my Alexa and all the LIFX that’s voice activated and controlled. Thanks for sharing.

[@BrandonDanz]

Been searching for well over an hour for a resource like this -- GREAT review. Thank you!

[@rjw8316]

Nice comparison. However, next time could you include the Insteon devices? Thanks.

[@BallsworthBallsbury]

Been watching your videos for years now, finally subscribed! Thanks for all the great content, my friend! Wishing you continued success

[@TheMikeBaldwin]

Would love to see you review 3-way smart switches! Nice review as always!! Thank you!

[@danielmerkley4543]

When starting my smart home, I felt like the industry was pushing smart bulbs (ie phillips hue). I didn't like the idea of spending $20 on a light bulb that would have to be replaced when it goes out three years later. Yes, I know that LEDs are supposed to last longer, but I've experienced less than advertised performance from my LED bulbs. Switches seemed like the best fit for me. Appreciate the review. However, I think you left out a major category of the market! The Sonoff Mini and Shelly products are excellent at a fraction of the cost of even the cheapest switches you listed. You can buy a 20 pack of Sonoff mini's on amazon for about $6-$7 a piece. You install behind your normal light switches and you are good to go. No, it doesn't have all the functionality and settings as these options (ie no dimming, multi press functions, etc) but it is an excellent option. And most importantly, wives and other family members don't have to have a learning curve to use it. It's the same light switch they are used to.

[@paulwood1163]

You might want to touch on something I had issues with. You did talk about switches being wide and hard to work in a two switch box. However, some of these switches get their "features" in by going deep. Deeper than some of the boxes you have had for so many years. I got halfway through a switch install in a wooden placement (my kitchen island) and ended up getting a crafty electrician to finish the install. Ugh! Its hard to fit the wiring in when the switch takes up all the space. Oh, and I cannot finish my comment without saying "Lutron? Booo!". I hate extra hubs. Its like the hidden initial cost that ends up making you wonder if you should just buy their product because ... in for a penny, in for a pound. Keep them coming.

[@hiltoncancel2270]

You missed the Leviton Smart Switches. They too are outstanding and very easy to use.

[@DigitalBenny]

I live in a rental house, so I can change bulbs, but not fixtures. I switched all of my bulbs that I could change to Hue. But that left some fixtures with "dumb" bulbs (for example, my kitchen has a square light with SMD LED diodes in it) so for all of those, I installed Kasa switches. They work awesome. I use Google Home and they have zero issues for me. I also have a bunch of Kasa outlets, for fans and my heat.

[@MarkS6789]

I have the GE and the Kasa Dimmer light switch. The GE has never failed and never had any connection issues however the dimming isn't the best, you have to use the app in order to get the right dim. The Kasa brand as a whole ive had issues with them just disconnecting all of a sudden. But im starting to believe it might be my network getting crowded. When Kasa works however, it works great and the app is really good too! Great job Reed!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Mark!

[@YT-yq6rx]

I’d love a video comparing noon orro & brilliant switches

[@hjkaye]

I have a category for you: Smart switches with RF433 support. I have a few of these installed now, that have support for the RF433 remote controls. This is very handy because there are a ton of inexpensive wall or table mount RF433 remotes available for almost nothing, 1-2-3-4 gang, in lots of colors and styles. I have a couple of variations of the battery operated switches: 1) A Sonoff RF/WiFi switch that I've installed into the base of a table fan, with a little bit of hot glue and drilling, the control switch and the status light are accessible from the base. It's Alexa/Google compatible, uses the eWeLink app. So, Alexa "turn on/off fan works", and I have a tabletop button on the other side of the room to toggle on/off with a tap, very handy. 2) Another variety is a WiFi wall switch replacement available in 1-2-3-4 gang models, in a variety of colors and styles. One implementation: I have a 3 gang version installed, all have relays for switching actual line voltage, but I have only one wired up (neutral is required). The other two gangs I have configured via Tuya automation to toggle on/off smart light groups in the adjacent living room. Just about any scenario is possible with the automation, even changing channels on the TV if you have a smart IR box. Also setup is Tuya automation that sets the wall switch gangs on/off when Alexa, the app, or other automation turns the smart lights on/off, so the indicator lights correspond with the on/off state. So, if I say Alexa turn on Smart Bulb 1, the automation turns on the corresponding indicator on the wall switch. The RF433 support allowed me to add a wall mount battery operated RF433 toggle switch at the other room entrance, so just a tap toggles the corresponding wall switch gang, and controls both the virtual automation gangs, and the physical wired gang. Also included is the support for up to six different remote buttons for each gang. So, the switch installed at the entrance I can use a car remote style RF433 remote to turn the lights on/off from outside the front door it seems to work about 100 feet away. The only downside is it's a toggle, so if on, it will switch off and vice versa.

[@KirkandRA]

Great review. I’m currently upgrading to Kasa Single pole from the standard switches. Just buying a couple at a time so my wife doesn’t blow a gasket 😂

[@aceagui1129]

Thank you very much for taking the time & doing the research, I being doing maintenance for 15 yr went 3yr of full time student in college, you surprise me with your information, and no one has surprise in years me, I know I can do all the electrical but you have done the most important technology end of it, thank you very much

[@JohnNeville617]

I started out with the GE switches/dimmers partly on a whim but I have since replaced all of my switches with them. Some people may be looking for the bells and whistles but I just wanted hub controlled switches that felt normal so they definitely fit the bill. I do have the Zooz double switch for my bathroom light/fan but it feels cheap next to the more solid GE vanity switch. The real reason I went hub controlled was for security. Reliability is one thing but I mostly want to keep a barrier between the internet and my smart devices. There are too many sketch Chinese generic devices out there so knowing that it is z-wave and not wifi is comforting.

[@TechProGabe]

I have some cheap treat life ones, the only compliant is in a bedroom the leds can be quite bright at night. Beyond that they work great.

[@justind.6780]

I'm currently using various TP-LINK and a 4 way brilliant light switch in my home and I absolutely love them. I too had issues with switches not fitting into the older switch covers and ended up buying slightly larger versions at home depot that actually do the trick and you barely notice the difference.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

That's good to know about larger versions. I'll have to look for those next time I'm at home depot.

[@MrTacoMan247]

Thank you for all the work you put into this video.

[@andrepandohie582]

Thanks for the video. I’ve had a lot of problems with the GE Z-Way switches during power outages. getting the Peter Pan click clicking going to replace them with something better.

[@GaryBickford]

I recently bought and installed a couple of Martin Jerry low cost dimmer switches. They use the 'Smart Life' app to get set up. I don't yet have an internet connection through my wifi router, so I haven't done that. But they work well locally.

[@volumeboyman]

"me, ross?" classic!

[@asprywrites]

Excellent work, sir. It's been my pleasure being a longtime subscriber.

[@Techridr]

I've been using the Kasa switches for a long time now and love them. You can set scenes, schedules, you can have one switch control another switch or outlet, tell it to turn on outdoor lighting at sunset or 30 min before, 20 min after etc. and even schedule different brightness levels. For instance, I have two carports with dimmable LED lighjt strings. With the Kasa outdoor dimming outlet, I have my carports light up 30 minutes after sunset to about 80% brightness. At 8pm the schedule goes to 60% brightness, then once again at 10:30 pm it goes to a nice 20% brightness. They stay that way till 15 minutes after sunrise. I also have a set limit on one switch. When I turn on the Whole House Fan, it is set to shut off after 20 minutes automatically. And of course, they all work with Alexa too including dimming levels. Yeah, this video is 4-years old, but I still love my Kasa switches.

[@Longussss]

Hello Mr Reed. Hopefully you can help me with my electrical issues. 1. A motion sensor Lutron, what switch do you suggest on the other side. 2. Six utilitech canless lights on2 3 way switches. I want to use a dimmer. Which do u suggest?

[@jmz6]

I am using Leviton smart switches. They have many different versions available. Currently have the regular wifi smart switch and a dimmer as well their 3 way remote switch. App and features are updated pretty frequently and have a decent amount of features included. they have been decently reliable over 2 years, though have had 2 out of 15 burn out randomly but was replaced by Leviton

[@ckay92390]

I love the video and how you categorized switches into different groups! I was hoping to see a renters/apartment category with smart switches that go over your existing light switches for those of us who have landlords that don't necessarily enjoy having their Tenants mess with the houses electricity. I know these videos take lots of work; even without this additional renters category i still found this video very helpful, thanks!

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks! Yeah that could be good for another video.

[@asinheaven]

Thanks for including comparisons of the click sound between different units. I prefer a totally silent switch.

[@Blue5teel1]

Just got 3 Treatlife dimmers to control the led pot lights in my kitchen den and family room. I like them especially the price. However while dimming them they actually turn on the pot lights controlled by the other Treatlife dimmers. They only work correctly while fully dimmed or at full brightness. They also will dim more when the dimmers are completely off. They are all separate lights but on the same circuit. They are wired correctly, I've tried switching the modes around but still the issue persist. Thinking of going with Lutron because I had the non smart dimmers before and they are excellent. Just bums me out because Lutron is triple the price of Treatlife.

[@bryane2000]

I have both smart switches and smart dimmers. I did not find the problems he described. I have gosund and use them with multiple cans. Good app and easy programming. No bleed thru either

[@bergermaestro]

I use the Kass switches and it's always a relief when Reed gives something a thumbs up! I use the dimmer and notice a bit of buzzing, but that seems to be because of the lightbulbs and not the switch itself.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Yeah I didn't notice any buzzing with the bulbs I was using. I wish I had more time and resources to try them all out with different kind of lights. Kasa switches are great though!

[@PeterJohnson76]

I have lots of Philips hue touch switches and love them .. most of what you have reviewed requires an electrician to install in Australia and would cost a fortune.

[@dr_920]

I appreciate your inputs about the smart switch. I have a 2007 built-house and the switch is too shallow to have those smart switches due to their deep transformer. It is really difficult to reorganize the wire in the switch boxes unless you upgrade them with deeper boxes. I can't do it myself. It would cost thousands to hire a professional. I guess I have to give up the plan to automate my house.

[@john_thorpe]

One comparison I don't think you made is what happens in the event of a power outage. For example if the switch was in the off position, and the power goes out, what ones remain off when the power is restored?? Also, what ones can be used safely with a ceiling fan (on-off switches that is)??

[@whoisericevans]

You have to review the lutron RA2 switches. Those are some of the high end lutron switches, offer more features and have better designs then the Caseta line.

[@shubinternet]

I’m curious to know if you’ve tested the Lutron 5-wire dimmer in older home construction? I’ve found that I can’t get it to work at all with my home that was built in the mid-80s, because the NERC wiring code changed and back then they were even more casual with how closely they followed what was required by the code at the time. The only Lutron switch I’ve been able to find that does work in my older home wiring is the 2-wire (no neutral required) model. It’s also just a plain switch and not a dimmer, which I really appreciate because almost none of our lights require dimming. Moreover, I don’t WANT dimming on those lights. So, the Lutron 2-wire model is the only one of those types that I will be installing. But I am curious about some of the other types.

[@scobob]

Thanks for the video. Was curious why you didn’t include Insteon? I was hoping to see how they compared to newest options. I have used Insteon for many years and find them super easy to install and configure.

[@jasonperry6046]

Fantastic job. I really enjoyed the overview. I am currently mostly Kasa and lutron switches right now. I hate the interface on both. I have a Wemo dimmer waiting to go in and have plans to buy an inovelli red switch and a GE switch. I am a little surprised you didn't include the Wemo switch, because it seems popular, but I think you included ever other switch I have heard of. Great work. All this to try and find an interface I like. Could I suggest a similar video on in wall plugs.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Jason! Yeah I've heard mixed reviews on WeMo and I've had a few bad experiences with WeMo. But yes they are popular and there has been enough comments wanting me to include it in the next one that I will for sure. That could be interesting about wall plugs.

[@curtisbme]

@@SmartHomeSolver I have had four Wemo dimmers in the house for years now and have never had any issues with them. The Treatlife and Gosund are essentially worse knock-offs of them. Only reason I don't use them everywhere is that they (like most smart dimmers) don't support 3-way. I don't use any other dimmers, like Inovelli, as I don't want to have to hold to adjust dimming. This is especially true if you are controlling lights in double or triple gang and want set them all to the same brightness level (manually) quickly. Wife and I intensely disliked the Casetta as it has to be the worst ergonomically designed wall switch of all time (and nearly completely unusable in the dark as you note) but we both love the Wemo. The only thing I liked about the Casetta was the remote that could be used from the bed so you didn't have to use your voice or phone to control brightness or turn off the main lights. But there are plenty of button options to at least control the on-off.

[@jasonperry6046]

Curtis B, my girls room has a Casetta light switch and it is going to be one of my first moves. There is nothing like running into their room because they are crying and hitting the wrong button, turning the lights on full brightness, and waking both of them up. One day I will find the perfect switch.

[@Trip1eGo1d]

There is also Cync by GE smart switches, of which I have several. But I am thinking of upgrading them to the Brilliant switches. I love the idea of having mini control panels, but not the idea of the pricing...

[@BimmerWon]

Do you know of any smart switches that control wall receptacles and won’t fry when I accidentally turn them on with a 1150 W vacuum cleaner plugged in?

[@DanSeaber-Shinn]

Another great video Reed! Huge support from the UK 🇬🇧 I love seeing all the products you guys have....that we can’t get 😂

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks! Hopefully more of this stuff can be available in the UK soon!

[@JamesMason888]

Nice comparison. I'm wondering what your thoughts are on the HomeSeer dimmers (e.g., HS-WD200+ series).

[@deterris1000]

Hello how are you. hey you ever considered doing a review or the C by GE smart switch they released in 2020 I have some in my house there are great to have there are a little buggish but they're working on them

[@kreene1987]

Just a comment on the Inovelli switches, you can set (in settings) the min and max level setpoints that represent 1 and 100% on the switch. Basically you could set 35 as 1% and 75 as 100% and it would dim between 35 and 75 but the UI would show 1 to 100% hopefully that clears that up.

[@MichaelHarrisPhotography]

Great job, very informative. Is there a reason you didn't include Insteon switches in the hub section? I've been using them for years and love them.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

Thanks Michael. I tried to pick some of the most popular smart switches and there were plenty I would have liked to include but time is a big factor. I'm glad to hear you like Insteon switches and I'll remember that for the next light switch comparison.

[@alanmoore2197]

Good review! I would note that while you mentioned some dimmers stand alone operation not being that intuitive to use - that is so much more true for guests (or even family members!) using switches that require multiple presses to control light scenes. Whilst the functionality is impressively squeezed in - I would never do that (because my wife would give me grief about it forever!). I always add scene controllers with dedicated labelled buttons so you don't need a smart home manual for everyday use. I also feel the look of a house is compromised by having many different types of light switches sprinkled around and of course that also compromises usability some for guests too. I don't automate everything so I also appreciate dimmers & switches that don't look jarringly physically different from regular decora switches - because they will all be living together. Keep up the good work (and humor!).

[@michaeleckman3016]

Wemo has some nice switches. Initially, I had issues with my wemos since my house has wifi repeaters/extenders, but it seems that wemo has corrected that issue and now they work flawlessly.

[@Traveling.w-Tiyah]

I'm so glad u did this video. I plan 2 buy can lights and switches during Labor day sale.

[@EternityM]

Excited for this video! Needed to see these compared!

[@dancatalincerba4620]

I would very much appreciate it if you could recommend a dimmer switch that functions like this: single tap on off, but if light is off and I long press upper button it should start at lowest brightness and keep raising light level until I release button. If someone sleeps in the room I want to start at lowest level of brightness, regardless of the last brightness level before switching it off.

[@williamcook669]

Hi, appreciate your review. Was wondering why you didn't include Leviton Decora Smart switches? I'm comparing the Kasa to the Leviton 2-way, non-dimming switch. It will be in the master bedroom, so don't like the "night light" on the Kasa because it appears it can't be turned off. I have a Leviton dimming smart switch and it's "night light" can be turned off with settings in the app. I also like that Leviton operates same as standard switch, tap top for on and bottom for off. I did notice the Leviton is significantly more expensive than Kasa.

[@baronlopez8788]

You have great videos and look forward to watching more in the future. However, I'm curious why you didn't consider any Insteon switches in this review. I've found a lot of success in mixing both z-wave and Insteon.

[@darth.mingdom]

What’s the reason to use a hub for the switches? What can you do with it that is unique?

[@sonnym9954]

So I started my journey slowly. I purchased your recommended Kasa single pole. I was considering a thermostat and smart locks to add to the switches. Will I need a hub for that or can I use my Asus router and SmartThings? I am looking at three ways and double and triple faces.

[@brunobonneau9308]

Great video, I am interested by leviton wifi swith

[@bradycooper3912]

Thanks for the great info! My biggest issue when installing smart switches that work with my SmartThings hub is that my old home has very narrow and shallow electrical switch boxes. I have several areas where I have 3 switches in a row and I can't fit three GE switches in the electrical box. Which switches are smallest (in terms of what goes "behind" the wall)?

[@rishi989]

I'm having the same issue -- very tight electrical boxes. Did you find a product that worked for you?

[@CaptAstroBell]

I have used a lot from Eaton smart switches. I think that’d be something to look at. It’s a WiFi switch that has a nondimmable and dimmable switches at affordable prices.

[@formerx]

All that work paid off. Excellent vid!

[@sbernhard83]

Try the Leviton Z Wave switches. They are like the GE, but the dimmer is easier to use and the switch activation feels higher quality.

[@eddiesanchez9095]

Excellent Work Reed!!! Thank you so much for the time you put into this. This will definitely help me a lot.

[@ThomasRushing]

Very curious to see what your thoughts are on the Wiz Dimmer switches. I have not been able to find a decent video out there about them. I have Philips Wiz recessed RGB lighting in my home, throughout the entire things and I absolutely love it, it works great and I am wondering if the switches are any good.

[@scottmorris1210]

Can you replace a standard light switch with a smart switch when there are 2 or more regular switches on the same circuit? I have a switch that operates my family room lights at 2 seperate locations. Thanks in advance

[@scottmorris1210]

Anyone?

[@colormedubious4747]

I don't know about the other brands but I've successfully installed Insteon switches on several 3-way circuits. They include instructions for that.

[@ronm6585]

Thanks Reed. Great comparison.

[@SmartHomeSolver]

I appreciate it Ron!

[@MakeMoneyGuide]

Keep posting interesting contents like this!

[@YungWholey]

What are the best physical switches that work with hue lights or govee lights?

[@andymok7945]

Nice review. One important thing missing is which units can be flashed with custom firmware like tasmota for those that don't want to be locked in to using cloud based app to control vs local based control.

[@billylacharity3443]

Good day. Do any of those smart wifi switches also work with smart bulbs, as in when you use the switch, does it cut the power to the bubs as well?

[@airwarden33]

What about wemo? Should I have not installed them? They seem to be fine but you had some pretty cool ones that I might switch to.

[@driverjb09]

How well does it handle circuits where a light can be turned on from two different switches? For example, my overhead living room lights can be activated from the hallway headed into the living room, or from the kitchen which is on the other side of the living room. Does it get confused or can it keep up with the on/off state of the light?

[@mattengel1866]

Thanks for all of your content. I've been thinking back on this video for the past year or so. Just wondering if you have any updates for new stuff now that this is over 2 years old. I'm recalling specifically something you described as a dimmer memory where the switch goes back to the the last setting it was on when it is turned on again. I have many new applications that I need to do around our new house and want to choose the best options. Thanks! -Fan from Southern Ohio

[@awlthatwoodcrafts8911]

I've had a couple of Meross switches to control some outside lighting for a couple of years now and have had no issues. When I started using Alexa, I was able to integrate the Meross switches easily with a "skill". Since then, I've added some Meross smart plugs and a couple more smart switches and when I set them up in the Meross app, they were automatically added to Alexa's list of devices. The 2 new smart switches were purchased from Amazon for under $25 for the pair. Can't buy a single Leviton in a store for less that $35.

[@jordanray2245]

Hey Reed, any chance that you could do a comparison measuring the idle wattage usage from each of these? I have multiple smart lights controlled by dumb switches, and would like to be a little more energy conscious by replacing them with smart switches.

[@MrRoguetech]

Lutron Caseta has models that DO require a neutral, so be careful when purchasing if you don't have a neutral. GE also offers switches which do not require a neutral, unlike what's said in the video. I have neutrals, so never pay attention, and ended up with both from Caseta and GE. I think it's also worth pointing out that Lutron Pico remotes look the same as the in-wall switches, which is the only option I know of for consistency thoughtout a house between wired switches and remotes. I use a lot of wall mounted remotes to control smart bulbs.

[@willdonovanaus]

AWESOME! Thanks Reed. Switches are my No1 topic at the moment and trying to work out where to start and how to narrow down the selection. Cheers from Australia ;)

[@JN-wj5tj]

Would you be able to provide some ideas when the smart switches don't quite fit the switch housing? Issues include things like housing box has a metal tab for screws mid way, blocking the switch from going all the way back. What would you do? What are the options ?

[@h82fail]

Without looking them all up, are these all UL rated? Those plasticy ones had me questioning. I've been mostly looking at Lutron since that is what we use most at work and they have been sold. (VIVE commercial products in highrise offices) For lutron I would go RA2Select or RadioRA2 line personally and bypass the Lutron Casetra, but it depends what your end goals are. The Caseta Line/bridge can't talk to the nicer maestro dimmers, it doesn't allow the scene control keypads, doesn't allow the nice built in looking ceiling occupancy sensors etc. - And the RA2 Select and RadioRA bridges wont talk to the Caseta switches/dimmers (except the pico remotes) so if you went Caseta then wanted some of that other stuff in your Lutron setup you'd have to buy all new stuff. Of course you can get anything to talk to anything if you involve some 3rd party. Just seems like if I can get all or at least most of my lighting on a single system it will setup better and probably respond quicker.

[@jester4761]

Howdy! Im am constantly scrolling through all your videos while getting new ideas for my smart home. Now I'm trying to update my switch situation and I have a question for you: So my kitchen has a 4 way switch for the main lights. Meaning I have 3 switches that can toggle the lights. I can't find any switches that specifically say they can function under that scenario. My current situation is this: I have 2 switches that I try to leave alone and one switch has a third reality switch that covers the toggle to make the lights "smart." The problem is that when someone hits any of the other 2 switches the third reality switch will now have to be told the opposite command to get the desired results until a toggle can be flipped again. It's super annoying, and the spouse hates it. Sooo...my question then is, will multiple of (example) kasa switches be able to function together to prevent my current situation? Or would that be a problem solvers with a home assistant other than just an echo + the switches?

[@itskelvinn]

I got the kasa ones for budget and features. 4 of them for $64. I’m hoping my electrician can use them when he does the recessed lighting. Is neutral wire typically a problem? Kasa requires it

[@hom-sha-bom]

Hello, I have a friend who is paralyzed from the waist down and sometimes does not have the wheel chair close enough to the bed to go turn the lights off. When it's late at night she doesn't want to be a burden to her family and wake someone up to come turn her lights off, so she just deals with it and tries to sleep with the lights on. I know this is a problem we can solve. Which switch do you think is best for a simple use case of just a single light in 1 room that can be controlled by both the switch for anyone who helps her into her room, and controlled by the phone for when she's confined to her bed?

[@SherrifOfNottingham]

Man it's surprisingly hard to find switches that would replace the wall switch and control lights using the wiz app. It's surprising how many people seem to ignore this use case when talking about smart switches.

[@dafne6.365]

I have a question. I simply am looking for a smart switch that I can schedule to turn on my light in the morning so that I can wake up, which has that feature? Thanks for the video!

[@solutionswithryan]

I'd be interested to see you compare the Enbrighten (GE/Jasco) ZigBee Dimmer which is supposed to be near the same as the Enbrighten (GE/Jasco) Z-Wave dimmer you compared. There are significant flickering issues with this dimmer when more than 4 LEDs attached to the circuit when still under the 300W capacity. Jasco refuses to address this issue.

[@paulmardis1512]

test Control4, Crestron and Savant switches. Also GE Z-wave switches have been recalled. One of mine failed causing a ticking sound so I replaced it a couple of weeks back and that is when I found out about the recall from an associate at lowes. They are no longer available in most stores. I am in the process of swapping out about 15 GE switches with Lutron Caseta switches. Good Luck PM

[@forstermatt1]

Wow, looking a GE version now. Sounds like you would not recommend GE

[@paulmardis1512]

correct, I would not recommend those. There are other z-wave switches on the market you can try.