Snapped Her Arm Like a Twig

[@mlmichael2791]

No matter whose story you believe, the defendant's arm got broke.

[@rickybobbydastar6534]

Factz and ain’t nobody going to work wit a broken arm

[@bellasamantha237]

@@rickybobbydastar6534 yeah you can indeed work with a broken arm, not in construction but you can do some jobs. 🤦‍♂️

[@rickybobbydastar6534]

@@bellasamantha237 yeah but If u go in the next day u must gonna be higher than the moon. lol

[@julianiwhite]

@@rickybobbydastar6534 you can deaf go to work the next day & not high on meds

[@rickybobbydastar6534]

@@julianiwhite I can’t lol maybe u can

[@Rayallwayz]

You can tell the mother and son practiced that lie. The way they were physically demonstrating it lol

[@tastemypie1]

💯

[@elsadecora7429]

Yup bc ain’t a way a nurse would complain about someone screaming about their arm being broken. The way she’s saying they were positioned, the heigh of the mom & the gf, wouldn’t prompt her arm to break bc there wouldn’t be a way for her arm to break at the elbow, but her wrist & hand would have been.

[@alysiataylor4048]

this mom is an inabler...you can tell the son plays on his mother "heart strings" alot. dude is a grown ass boy

[@Truckeractivityy]

🤣🤣🤣

[@gelly8983]

Swear I was like they could have done better lol

[@nicolebondman4631]

I can hear Judge Judy telling his mother to sit down! and make the son answer everything lol.

[@kimf442]

Lol 😂

[@jermeciaGoddess]

😂

[@chelseywalker7123]

And shut up! Lol

[@nicolebondman4631]

@@chelseywalker7123 lol or her famous "SHUT YOUR TRAP"! LOL

[@Lovely_1One]

And she would’ve been right in doing so! I CANT STAND a mamas raggamuffin!! SMH

[@snake991231]

He did it! And the momma is an in-abler! These weak men are sickening!

[@kimberlytyler3345]

Totally agree.

[@buttliq0ur869]

Enabler

[@rickybobbydastar6534]

@Qamaria I agree . However the girl has some issues herself bcuz it’s no way she should’ve went back in the house with they guy, if he broke her arm the way she described

[@PocaHonestofficial]

@@buttliq0ur869 lol

[@xtubeit8265]

@@buttliq0ur869 Exactly why I’m here…🤭. Enabler

[@joycec6222]

The fact that the son was so quick to use profanity in front of his mother speaks to the level of respect he has for women! How can you expect him to respect you as a girlfriend when he doesn’t respect his own mom? Pay attention to the red flags early on.

[@PrettyYellaTV]

Exactly

[@saetae9208]

Speak on it!

[@imrichbtch1995]

How old are you😂

[@cappag3]

This is dumb because she could of been acting like a b, grown people are allowed to curse how is that disrespecting his mom?

[@joycec6222]

@@cappag3 No, what’s dumb is “could of”… regardless of the situation there are certain things you don’t do in front of a parent out of respect and boundaries. He could’ve expressed himself and conveyed whatever point he was trying to make without using profanity.

[@CookingwithCj319]

I totally understand how that young woman feels. There are so many mothers that defend their son even when the mother knows her son is guilty of a crime. It happens all the time.

[@jofloletschat7788]

loved that- definitely happens

[@cliftonjones6067]

Do y'all see many lie about abuse to? Or it's because women wouldn't lie about abuse

[@tom11zz884]

The young lady needs to stop getting up in men's faces trying to physically fight them.

[@TheTyrisa]

@@tom11zz884 not a fact in this case

[@Shellygrrl2573]

@@cliftonjones6067 exactly! When she stood there crying not shedding one single tear and then was calm in 2 seconds....

[@kpre9874]

I find it very unsettling when a Momma has to speak for a grown Man. Yuckkkk I LOVE THIS VERDICT

[@YoungHaveNot]

Terrible verdict. No one should have won

[@NYBK82]

@@YoungHaveNot💯

[@ayefo7800]

Yuck indeed😬😬😬😬😬

[@ravenlabarrie5515]

He needs to stop babying her son. He needs to take responsibility.

[@tom11zz884]

Umm..The the young women needs to learn responsibility and accountability. Getting kicked out of your mother's house and then trying to move in with some man you hardly knew is silly.

[@rmills807]

My Mother babied me to.

[@sereneamani1713]

@@tom11zz884 It's called being emotionally unstable and traumatized. Learning responsibility and accountability has to be combined with healing.

[@mwebb7292]

You could see on his face, though he held his composure, he's violent and disrespectful. You could tell they told him to be quiet in court and let her do the talking. Lost this case too and racked up more bills.😒The nerve to sue the defendant. Smh why?! Y'all should have stayed at home.

[@starrjohnson1327]

That's why his mom paid for the physical therapy. Mom is probably afraid of him too

[@nnedwards3260]

@@starrjohnson1327 That would be quite unfortunate. Sad!

[@natashanjf7177]

His mom is definitely an enabler. Ya son is an abuser madam... Bye

[@travisscott9359]

@@starrjohnson1327 Mom is an enabler. She was too old when she had him...

[@ramiyna]

Mom tells him nothing is his fault & he believes it. He must be an awful person to be around. The gaslighting is so loud.

[@shesuniqueinherownwaybenja7647]

Honestly, I believe he broke her arm. The way she broke down describing the situation. Let alone listen to how he’s calling her out her name. What the mother need to do is allow him to be held accountable for his actions.

[@C.O.M.2011]

/$

[@lionhearted3091]

Just cause you call a female out her name don’t mean you would break her arm😂😂💀

[@lionhearted3091]

Not saying he didn’t do it because I believe he did soon as I heard his momma talking💀

[@Orlandoloc83]

Let me get this straight someone runs to his mom for help and the woman is calm also she’s telling him to calm down u believe at that moment he decide to break her arms u do realize if he wanted to really hurt her he wouldn’t have waited to get home to do so

[@shesuniqueinherownwaybenja7647]

@@lionhearted3091 I’m not saying that just because he called her out of her name means he broke her arm, but why paint a picture like he’s the calm cool collective dude when he clearly has anger issues you telling your mother get this BITCH out the car come on where’s the respect for your mother I’ve been pist off on many occasions in front of MY MOTHER and out of RESPECT for your MOTHER usually a purse would say let me Piper down and pump my brakes because my mother is here

[@amorbutterfly]

His mom needs to let him be a grown man and take accountability for his actions... damn shame...

[@kimf442]

🤦‍♀️ right lol

[@on24s40]

Facts

[@Crystal-Love]

The brother too! Everybody had two paragraphs to say except him.

[@on24s40]

@@Crystal-Love cause he lie and beat women so they sticking up for him so he doesn't go to jail cause he scared of men

[@chuck9380]

She isn’t innocent either it’s a reason her mom kicked her out

[@scottrogue946]

So much to unpack here. Grown man coming to court with his “momma” The plaintiffs are weird af 😫😳

[@Sunshine134chick]

Yup 😩😂😂😂

[@kimf442]

@@Sunshine134chick 😩😂😂😂😂

[@soblessed_21]

Rotflmao🤣

[@rhondaharris93]

All 3 of them

[@deidrepatman9425]

Yes I agree ...af ...I'm so glad she got out of there with them psychos

[@deegee6904]

It is extremely odd to move in with someone and their family after dating for 2-3 weeks. Then staying months after getting your arm broken. Just odd.

[@misterbee66]

Exactly, it is odd.

[@lifeof.jariya3307]

she did say she got kicked out and had nowhere to go..she was desperate and working two jobs, baby girl was tired and taking what she could get

[@tianachet713]

It takes up to 7 times to leave an abusive situation

[@tatianadaniel3569]

@@tianachet713 But it wasn't an abusive relationship. They was together for less than a month. She was belligerent and in his attempt to prevent the defendant from hurting his mom, her arm got stuck in between their two bodies.

[@nicolerobinson835]

She could of went to the shelter

[@nikkistarr1702]

What's wrong with society is mother's like these who raise their kids with a sense of entitlement, raising them to believe they don't do anything wrong, defending their ADULT child's actions, even though they absolutely know their child is wrong, that's what is wrong with society! Period!!!

[@srabsolutely]

Mom led him in holding his hand, spoke the majority of the time, and still claimed she was responsible although the son was convicted of it. Yikes. 😬

[@onemotimeonemotime5578]

I literally went back to the beginning because I did not catch the hand holding but yeah .. she sure was holding this overgrown man child's hand! What in thee entire fu--... *Mouth agape hands on hips* 😱😱😱

[@natashanjf7177]

Facts...no morals

[@waldolydecker8118]

Brother at the end with the standard line..."The only reason he was convicted..." Anytime you hear that line on this show, you can fill in the blank yourself....The only reason they were convicted - was because he (she) did it. That's the only reason.

[@esh5168]

Not true ask hundreds of thousand wrongfully convicted people

[@waldolydecker8118]

@@esh5168 - not on this show are there "hundreds of thousand wrongfully convicted people." If there are, please name just 5 of those hundreds of thousand so I can go back and look up those cases. Been watching since JM went on the air...everyone I've seen who was convicted ( including this case) were convicted because testimony and evidence strongly indicated they did it. Only an idiot gets convicted in criminal court, then comes to civil court and tries to pretend that somehow the criminal conviction wasn't valid so the second Judge should disregard it. That's what's happening here.

[@carltonwomble4790]

@@waldolydecker8118 🙏🏿(Dap!)

[@roxeaguebryan7629]

@@waldolydecker8118 lies. Judge Mathis has his off days too. More in recent times as he has gotten older but I do agree with last part. I knew he lost from I heard he was sentenced.

[@waldolydecker8118]

@@roxeaguebryan7629 - what is wrong with you? Did you get low marks in reading comprehension in school? The topic discussed was convictions in criminal court then coming to civil court. Your dizzy yapping about JM "having off days and getting older" have nothing to do with the topic discussed..unless you know any JM cases where the criminal conviction was inaccurate. If you do, then put your money where your mouth is and name the case so it can be reviewed. Otherwise, you appear confused and clueless.

[@anotherprincessstory2348]

hate when judge is in a bad mood. he doesn’t listen as all .

[@Pinkgirlyyyy]

I swear 🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

[@jasoncore5796]

Its not about bad mood..this man and judge judy r the same...in there head they have already made a desiccion to who is wrong...that why now i only watch judge milian..she got my respect tbe day she td a man...she hates him, he is scum and hates the fact that cuz of the law she has 2 make him win...(in all fairness that man really was a f up human)

[@lareinanueva]

I've been watching him for 17 years and I concur. I love him but just like the typical Leo male he gets on my nerves sometimes! 😭

[@ambitiouswomen83]

@@lareinanueva he is an Aries not a Leo 😂 he said it so many times on here

[@naomithomas3276]

At all. Annoying af sometimes! 😒 lol

[@tazt21]

Everybody crazy in this situation, the mama, the disrespectful "calm" son and the "DRAMATIC " gf who lived there even after this

[@Sunshine-r6s3w]

Maybe you don’t understand abuse survivors? I’ve been abused badly and still stayed. It’s very possible and it’s sad that people talk about what they don’t know about.

[@aprilpinketon2567]

@@Sunshine-r6s3w this is so true. I never judge any victim of any type of abuse. All abuse isn't visible either.

[@scottrogue946]

@@Sunshine-r6s3w I mentioned this in another comment too! When you’ve been emotionally beat down with no self esteem it’s very easy to go back because you feel you have nothing else.

[@tazt21]

@@Sunshine-r6s3w not sure if u heard her but she said they dated for 2-3 weeks, more than likely this was his first time hitting her which is why the mom got in between them and said he was wrong so u can't come to court fake crying and and then left out the part of u going back to stay at the house

[@felicitaagosto716]

That part!

[@marskeins]

Why did he need his mama speaking for him?? Smh that said a lot right there.

[@infiniteblayze]

Exactly

[@howdyyall4352]

Shame on the mother, she's just pitiful.

[@MsLady-gb3gy]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@nicolettemorr6588]

Let these men stand up and be men. Actions have consequences. He has to pay the consequence not mom. Mom needs to let him grow up and be a man..

[@isaidwtfisaid304]

Ikr everybody talking for him but him. Like his mouth wired shut or something it wasn't when he was in her face calling her B*itches and snapping arms. But that speaks volumes, he must be the baby and they always coddled him.

[@tom11zz884]

Umm...She moved in with them. She got kicked out of her mother's house. She seems like the one who needs to exercise some accountability here.

[@tmmdeli]

I knew right away that mom was lying for her son. To go as far as coming on television and lying for him is just awful. This woman should be ashamed of herself. Parents, do not lie for your children. In many instances, liars raise liars. I'm so glad the young lady got justice.

[@iatdtv4996]

Can't be having that hairline and still standing behind mommy.

[@leisbookoflife1749]

His hairline's like a shark's fin🎶

[@teresaevans4840]

🤣

[@niashanatashajack9727]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@anthonylucero6650]

Your YU-GI-OH videos suck ya mook😒

[@JessicaSmith-yd2nm]

😂😂😂

[@jeremyc5882]

I believe the defendant but I also believe there is some truth in what the moms other son stated he was very articulate. If you break my arm ain’t no way I’m staying back in that house laying in the bed with the person that injured me

[@scottrogue946]

I’m playing devils advocate here but sometimes people in abusive relationships go back to their abusers. Seems odd but it happens

[@jays.5978]

@@scottrogue946 not someone you just met.

[@Mrs.Adrian]

@@jays.5978 that May be the case if that’s the only person she has. She was already kicked out by her mom where else was she suppose to go? The mind of an abused and abandoned young lady

[@GreekYogurtGranola]

@@jays.5978 if her mother kicked her out and she had no where else to go, then definitely. That’s why it’s important to be financially stable on your own and not dependent on ppl.

[@flybyky820]

@@scottrogue946 another devils advocate here lol she said she didn't have anywhere to go so yea I do understand why she may have gone back considering they broke her arm and she couldn't work

[@AlwaysAlicia2991]

Grown Man entering court with his Mommy pull out the popcorn guys this is gonna be good 🍿🍿🍿🍿

[@Seeingisntbelieving]

Breaking a limb is painful! I fell and broke my clavicle and screamed to the top of my lungs. The pain was so excruciating I couldn’t make tears.

[@imanibmusic]

Mama, hold your son accountable!!! Especially if he has harmed this poor girl by breaking her arm. The brother asking why did she stay with him? A lot of people don’t leave their abusers the first second or third time. She’s lucky she made it out with just a broken arm

[@MsHoneyla]

Anybody saying she faked it bc she stayed after he broke her arm… Well, where do you expect her to go? 🥴 She went back to the only home she knew & moved out as soon as she could. I really believe the mom is lying about the whole situation, including how long she stayed after bc she pulled a date out of her ass when he asked how long she was there…. Like everything she said just seemed well-calculated / well-written / well-rehearsed.

[@njchic9145]

She could’ve went to that grandmother house she claimed she asked him to take her before this whole ordeal …. But either way once he was found guilty he’s guilty

[@G0dismabestfren]

I agree with you. Sometimes in these moments people just deal with things knowing that it can be harmful all because they feel they have no other option right away.

[@quincycuthbert5408]

his momma...need to stay out it...

[@deegee6904]

She only dated that man 2-3 weeks before moving in. She had other options prior to his mom’s house.

[@move246]

Shelter...he could kill her next

[@kimberlytyler3345]

Then the brother still trying to justify why he got locked up. This case was outrageous

[@nnedwards3260]

The plaintiffs were! I've seen more outrageous than this.

[@MsLady-gb3gy]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ISayToMyself]

Why is she staying in these peoples house after he called her a B, broke her arm, when he doesn’t have his stuff together and his mother is a “liar”? And why would the mother allow her in the house after all that confusion?

[@akuamirci3345]

She said she just kept her dog there

[@Natas_Nico08518]

Cycle of abuse

[@andrejamal5438]

@@Natas_Nico08518 bulljive, it was only a couple of weeks

[@andrejamal5438]

@@akuamirci3345 didn’t pay no rent

[@andrejamal5438]

Brah, abuse is terrible, but this shit sounds accidental at best, and she was pissed at dude and put him in the system bc he called her a B.

[@Imissyoulou]

Grown man coming to court with his mama. Shame.

[@darrylperry9798]

Lmao babies always follow momma.

[@roxiestarr7124]

These mammies kill me upholding these sons

[@Jay-pf2cn]

The “mama” is as integral part of the case.

[@rickeyadams8]

Or maybe you have some people out there that are socially awkward or may have a disorder..in which they have a hard time explaining a situation..that might make them look guilty. Which I'm not making excuses but disorders are real and if a chick is acting aggressive around your mom than alot can happen depending on the human and also I would have never let her stay in the first place but yea

[@dawnhunter3807]

Well it was her home incident happened and she was in the middle of the fight

[@latonyasmith4395]

2 lessons, 1 don't let your son move his girlfriends in and 2 stop moving in with strangers.

[@zulu3274]

😂 Your comment is about as fair as it can get on both sides...

[@aricarii3936]

Enough said👏🏾

[@oodief88]

He must be a mute. Everyone is speaking for him.

[@chuntayejordan5130]

The mother proved the whole entire case. Then if you run it back the son actually demonstrates it. They brought her to recoup the legal fees then lost, rightfully so👏🏽

[@laurenbogans357]

I found it so strange when the plaintiff is suing the defendant and then the defendant wins

[@Nikolewashere]

Play stupid games win stupid prizes. He broke her arm.

[@thatlsk]

Those are my favorite cases.

[@ursulaquickfallbaynes2350]

Plaintiff is clearly a coward..he broke her arm and YES he had to be locked up and they had to throw away the key. He is an ABUSER! Standing there.lookong like an angel...

[@jaydadon777]

is that not how it works? anyone can win with the correct evidence

[@lawjd96]

that's not strange, it's a counterclaim by the defendant. sometimes the plaintiff should let some things go...and live to see another day, financially.

[@fwb1012]

Damn, moving in after 3 weeks of dating🤦🏾‍♀️ That’s always going to be a problem.

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Lmao.

[@nnedwards3260]

💯. Always!

[@kiasams8715]

That man-boy looks ominous and is going to kill a woman one day, mark my words.

[@yulnikita]

I definitely got that vibe..

[@K_Cole0128]

He said he asked her to get out of the car calming. Yet the mother and the plaintiff said he was yelling “can you g get the B outta my car?” He’s a liar, the mother is a liar and he is an abuser. The plaintiff stayed bc she had nowhere else to go. She should’ve sued for pain and suffering

[@latonyasmith4395]

How he loved her only knowing each other for 2-3 weeks.

[@perseveranceofkeisha8792]

Great observation. The judge is always so biased, I wud had ruled half & half bc she stayed around afterwards. Then when the relationship failed, now she wants compensation

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

That word gets thrown around too loosely.

[@cartoon171]

@@blackpowerpuff6155 you can definitely know after 2 weeks my fiancé and I met and moved in after 2 weeks and are doing great you have to actually want to be faithful to someone lol it’s not hard I promise

[@cartoon171]

@@perseveranceofkeisha8792 please look up domestic violence statistics smh comments like these are why the black community is looked down upon

[@sarahs.archives]

Men say that to women early as 1 week all the time to manipulate them + help them put their guard down

[@Trishbraidz]

I wanna hear somebody say “get this b#tch out the car” calmly 😂

[@arielprivott844]

As long as everyone keeps making excuses for him he’ll never do better. He was convicted because of his own actions NOT anything that she did.

[@datruestory968]

Sir a conviction is beyond the arrest. That means they listened to evidence and made a decision. Maybe stop making excuses, not saying he is a abuser but that day he definitely handled her too rough!

[@cartoon171]

Once you abuse someone even once you’re an abuser

[@datruestory968]

@@cartoon171 Based on what I heard I could not pinpoint if he was trying to restrain her and he was too rough or if he literally attacked her. That is a difference. Bouncers have broke ppl arms restraining them at clubs. So since I could not determine I stayed neutral. I also notice she never mentioned any other incidence of violence so that is why I worded that way. But regardless, he hurt her, got convicted and needs to own it.

[@jays.5978]

they all learned a valuable lesson.

[@ms.tasiaa]

She said “I can’t believe someone who said they loved me would do something like that to me.” but also said “She took me into her home after a FEW weeks of us dating.” Honey you don’t know somebody within a few weeks.

[@Shellygrrl2573]

THAT part... She didn't love him and he didn't love her and her fake weird crying let me know that she was lying about the incident

[@xoxo1700s]

What's messed up is that alot of men get wrongfully accused (not speaking about this case just in general) the minute they defend themselves by hitting back he automatically goes to jail even if the female hit him first..or some females be like "hit me! hit me!" because they know he'll most definitely go to jail If he did..justice system needs to start holding females accountable just because your smack doesn't hurt as hard as his smack doesn't give you the right to do it in the first place

[@lifewithangelina92]

So her arm wasn’t broken 🤔

[@jew-el1]

My point. She’s manipulative‼️

[@XxiliketwinkiesxX]

The first red flag was when the plaintiff said that the defendant was being dramatic by screaming when her arm was broken???? Who wouldn’t scream if their arm is broken. That was the moment I knew who was full of shxt here.

[@fwb1012]

It’s the Mother demonstrating with the grown behind son just standing there🙄

[@YoungHaveNot]

😂😂

[@azariomaigwa9260]

I Believe the Young lady These are the Type of Mother's Who never very make their Son's accountable. This is a prime example. Glad she Won the Case Good job 👏🏿👍🏿

[@omarscott2373]

The police should have been called to get her out of the car.. That way no physical contact is needed. Do not let strangers move in your house!! If her parent(s) kicked her out, it was for a reason.

[@perseveranceofkeisha8792]

🗣say a reason…

[@datruestory968]

Yeah but being that he was dealing with her she wasn’t actually a stranger and since he obviously gave her the ok to ask to live there his mom agreed. She also said she understands from her own experience. So just bc parent’s put you out does not mean other ppl wont have compassion and leave you in a car or on the streets.

[@omarscott2373]

@@datruestory968 He was dealing with her, not the mother.. The mother let her live there because of her son. She was a stranger to the mother! This young lady has issues beyond this case.. If someone breaks your arm where you are living , you are going to keep living in that same home?.. I’m sure her parents had a good reason or probably gave her an ultimatum.

[@omarscott2373]

@@perseveranceofkeisha8792 Being aggressive, loud and not listening to reason.

[@the4cqueen148]

I thought she said that she was actually going to move to her grandmother's house and the dude drove her to his mother's house instead? Even when she supposedly moved in with them she stayed at her grandmother''s house and would go and check on her dog. The mother said she stayed 2 week's and the plaintiff's other relative said two- three months & the boyfriend ain't talking at all. Something very disturbing about how they cover up his mess for him.

[@Nevaeh1]

you shouldn't try to live with someone after a few weeks of dating

[@robinaaayyeee]

At all! 💯

[@wildfiregirl1556]

@@robinaaayyeee Facts. Hell no.

[@Proverbspsalms]

Exactly

[@Luvlysis4u]

She's troubled and he did it, I think he thought she was about to strike his Mother.

[@perseveranceofkeisha8792]

Very plausible.

[@perseveranceofkeisha8792]

Your story makes way more sense. Had he jus said that, maybe, jus mayb the judge wud had understood but all in all he broke her arm. He cud had easily restrained her & had someone call the cops.

[@tom11zz884]

She's one of those problematic hood chicks that will bring nothing but drama. Hope he avoids her at all cost.

[@yung1717]

No

[@Sirdewitt]

3:57 Judge Mathis is not impressed, rubbing his hands and know they lying 😒😭😂

[@brandancharles3292]

I believe she started the fight and I believe he broke her arm but i dont think he did it on purpose

[@tom11zz884]

She's one of those problematic hood chicks that will bring nothing but drama. Hope he avoids her at all cost.

[@ariamarshall5161]

Exactly. He didn’t. As the family stated she stayed there for months afterwards. && slept with him & showered w/him like nothing ever happened.

[@longbranch11207]

She’s a very stunning well spoken girl.

[@kimberlyrivers3949]

Sad mom taking up for her grown son I don’t allow that mess my 5 grown children knows no one stay together in my House unless Married smh women beater

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Not even married. More of a reason too have your shit together period!!

[@Wintxxr]

He got convicted over that “cry” wasn’t even a tear in her eye

[@rickeyadams8]

Righttt trust me I've seen women like her and she's dangerous 😳 ☠️

[@cece5464]

Then y did she let her stay in their home? If she lied on them y would they let her stay in the home knowing she has family

[@Proverbspsalms]

🤣😂😂😂😂😂

[@ebonyqueen7954]

@@cece5464 I’ve heard and witnessed too many people moving in people that they barely met. There’s definitely more to the story than they’re saying. Probably a pregnancy scare or just lust gone wrong.

[@Wintxxr]

“Except”

[@salbill4484]

That mother is an enabler. He was convicted of breaking a womans arm... wtf are you guys even talking about. He's guilty wtf.

[@crystalmcwoodson3609]

Mom's is something else PERIOD 🤷🏾‍♀️🎯💪🏾💯

[@Baddestchik911]

Judge Mathis like to gaslight these women especially when it comes to emotionally charged situations.

[@adriennesales6869]

Does he not speak?

[@scottrogue946]

😂 It’s giving “Baby Boy” vibes

[@undertalea2638]

He can't because women can't learn to keep they mouth shut.

[@preciousgem84]

No I don't think he speaks

[@silethaking279]

Right!!🤣🤣🤣

[@wildfiregirl1556]

He knew to keep his ass quiet best decision Lmao.

[@deeransom]

The way they all had no qualms about lying under oath on National TV says a lot about all of them

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

What was the point of his mother coming to court?

[@AlwaysAlicia2991]

To protect her "good" son Chile 🍿

[@darrylperry9798]

Because his ass is a baby.

[@kimberlytyler3345]

To take up for him & not allow him to talk thinking and was doing him a favor and they still lost

[@bernardmcginnis6392]

He broke her arm it was a accident to get their legal defense money back

[@Lovely_1One]

The fact his MAMA stands there starting off with their story is telling me EVERYTHING I need to know!!! Let me finish watching! SMH 🤦🏽‍♀️🥴🙄🙄🙄😑 EDIT: yeah, everything I stated above. They’re gripping at straws at the end and the blabber mouth brother is the one doing all that talking trying to justify her broken arm?! Please!! SMDH 😑 SO glad the defendant won her case! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽❤️

[@cadanceogbbl]

The way this mom is jumping through hoops to win his case, because we all know his mama still paying his bills and taking responsibility for him.

[@shanekameza]

Yup she even was paying his child support for his child that he never told me about until I moved in.

[@peacefreedom4930]

The fact that the mother started off speaking on behalf of her grown son validated the picture the young woman later painted. Mothers think they are helping their children by shielding them. In reality we cripple our children when we absorb the consequences of their actions. Consequences are a teacher.

[@matildab98]

Been there before, when a man takes advantage of you at your lowest, and his mother covers for him. My introduction to 7 years of domestic violence. #survivor #domesticviolence

[@kabakarazakwaan]

She went back after her arm was broken because "STOCKHOLM SYNDROME" is a symptom of "THE (DOMESTIC) CIRCLE OF VIOLENCE"... All these emotional victim blaming comments not backed by cognitive psychological behavioral knowledge is sickening ‼️ Ppl be simpletons and simps simultaneously ‼️🤣🤣🤣🤣 #AngerManagementClassGraduate #CognitiveBehaviorTherapyGraduate

[@asiam1528]

The mama lying for the son after he broke that young lady arm

[@Levay23]

She should be an actress! That little melt down while explaining her side of the story told me a lot. She appears to be one who doesn’t take accountability for her actions while having a victim mentality. The dude gives me passive-aggressive vibes while being carried by his mother. They all appear to be crazy lol

[@XxiliketwinkiesxX]

Why wouldn’t she break down when a man that she loved put hands on her and broke her arm?? You sound ridiculous.

[@hevolocs]

@@XxiliketwinkiesxX exactly

[@cartoon171]

@@XxiliketwinkiesxX that account is either a black male or an older black woman of course they’re gonna think domestic violence is okay

[@jofloletschat7788]

@@XxiliketwinkiesxX exactly

[@ursulaquickfallbaynes2350]

You would not say this had you been abused and your arm broken! NO man should touch a hair on a woman's head!! No.matter how provocative or dramatic any woman is

[@adrianprince7266]

This is why I tell men to walk away. It's not worth all the drama going through shit with these women. Better to be safe than sorry my grandparents and parents told me. Walk away guys.

[@aprilpinketon2567]

I mean why would anyone need to break anyone's arm?!?!? That's disturbing and he needs help, bc his Mama got him all messed up. I have a feeling this isn't his first victim and won't be his last. She needs some help as well, bc to move in with strangers isn't normal Bn behavior on her part.

[@aprilpinketon2567]

Your case and this case are apples and oranges. They can't be compared. Men can be abused, but most men don't partake in mutual combat. Most men who are not the abuser do leave the relationship, or they put up with it. It's rare to see a case where a man is being abused and stays to fight back, bc they know what they could look like, and they don't take those chances. A small percentage stays to fight back. Most ppl (even women) leave, if they can or feel they can. But in this case, this man broke her arm within weeks of meeting her and that is concerning. There is zero justification for anyone snapping someone's arm in half like a piece of wood.

[@aprilpinketon2567]

@@kietero you never have to defend yourself after the first incident if you leave the relationship. If you choose to stay and fight, then the person who stays in is just as guilty.

[@terriwilliams4803]

The first mistake is allowing her to move in. I would have called 211, or to a women's shelter to assist her, or suggested her to go to a motel, she had 2 jobs. Sometimes you just have to say, NO

[@fhenlizhao5406]

Tell them again.Sometimes ppl are a problem waiting to happen.

[@brotherkhalil]

"My Son ain't never hurt nobody, but he still got shot at Bae Bae's party!!!! 🤣

[@meghanwilliams4295]

Now, hold ON...🤣 Only the REAL OG's know about this!😎

[@hiphoppromoainsleeproducti9068]

Mama Lying For Ha'Baby 😂🤣

[@Subliminalmessage78]

Unpopular opinion: The defendant played the judge. Why would you stay overnight for two weeks plus, with the people with whom your arm was broken in a tussle? Why would you leave your dog there? Wouldn’t you want to break ties with them?

[@angelphilbert1200]

Pun intended 😄

[@Nikolewashere]

Lesser of 2 evils I suppose. If she would rather go back to them than her mother then..something deeper resides there than an arm break. She could also be batty 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@thatlsk]

She clearly didn't have any support if she had to move in with this family after knowing them for a couple of weeks. If she had somewhere else to go, she wouldn't have moved there to begin with.

[@missaislajackson5051]

Exactly!!!! These comments got me.. I agree!!!

[@khrisi9410]

Abuse doesn't make sense. It's plenty of data out there that explains the mind of victims of domestic violence.

[@dawng5890]

This is why you dont pick up strays. Look at someone's family before you choose a mate. You got those out here trying to survive and others that want to thrive with someone. Always look at the immediate and extended family because you are dating or marrying an extension of those people.

[@davidmcfarlane9185]

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@Proverbspsalms]

Pick up strays 😂🤣🤣🤣 true

[@kingjai8609]

I didn’t see no tears in her eyes ever

[@mitzithompson6585]

No tears!!!

[@Proverbspsalms]

🤣😂😂😂😂

[@_MoneyMike_]

Okay but it was confirmed that her arm was broken , what relevance is it that there were no tears???

[@hotfxytaj]

I hope these dude’s don’t be getting any play after they show up to court with they mamas 🤣🤣 weak asl

[@rickeyadams8]

Or maybe you have some people out there that are socially awkward or may have a disorder..in which they have a hard time explaining a situation..that might make them look guilty. Which I'm not making excuses but disorders are real and if a chick is acting aggressive around your mom than alot can happen depending on the human and also I would have never let her stay in the first place but yea

[@YACKYSNACKY]

This is weird, and I am certainly glad I don't have to judge this case.

[@listen-learn-speak2465]

He seem so disrespectful to cuss in front of his mom, they don’t need to be together and NO ONE’s girlfriend/boyfriend will stay to me!

[@listen-learn-speak2465]

*with me

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Facts. If he want her there he has to provide or her. I wouldn't fix my mouth. My mom would probably slap the shit out of me period.

[@tom11zz884]

The woman was even more disrespectful trying to fight him in front of his mom.

[@misterbee66]

Why continue to stay in their house after he injured you?

[@1demelmf]

Here's a young woman with nowhere to go or no immediate family to live with, that fell head over heels for someone she knew for so little time. All I know is that I can relate to being in uncomfortable situations just to make sure that I could have food to eat and a place to sleep no matter how much I had to fake it and act like everything was all good. I hope she finds peace and begins her SELF journey.

[@LaTonyaLapsley]

Mother and son rehearsed that.

[@OG213LA]

A grown man has his mama speaking for him… WOW!!!!!

[@MsHoneyla]

She definitely told him to let her take the fall & say it was an accident.💀 The sons were dumb to go with it knowing it didn’t sound right….. & even dumber going into court & repeating word for word what she just said.💀💀💀 Very obvious

[@sgbjr2000]

Lol. It's sad when a mom is willing to get on TV and lie for her son. His brother lied too. That family is messed up bad. Momma's boys!

[@vanessakenney3144]

Judge Mathis you need to calm down in alot of these cases.

[@brownskynbeauty4]

Yes he does..his behavior was unnecessary and unacceptable.

[@LethaHumphrey]

That part

[@checkthatbag]

Mom should have left this in the past.

[@mrpitts15]

Bad decisions from all parties involved…

[@BlackMayne]

Too fine to be dealing with momma and her boys.

[@keishamckenzie649]

Mama is quiet at the end lol.

[@904baybeecakes]

A man breaks your arm yet you still move in with him? Crying but not one tear? He hit you but yet the mother is paying the bill and you say nothing about that? Something very off about her story

[@serious7179]

I really feel for this young lady...not sure what JM's problem was... absolutely believe that the mom is defending her violent son.

[@janetholmes733]

Every body was so calm.. How did any of this happen ? My my...

[@tessalester8077]

I got a whole lotta weird vibes from both sides of that case….even if he didn’t mean to break her arm they let it get outta hand to the point that something bad happened. They don’t see it was them both escalating things that got it to that point! They are both in the wrong but she is the one who had to suffer. Plus his mom saying she was being dramatic, let’s break your arm see how chill you are!?

[@ursulaquickfallbaynes2350]

And the mother lying that she broke the arm...good grief!! Mother's a liar and the son's an abuser!!!

[@tessalester8077]

@@ursulaquickfallbaynes2350 yeah it’s sad his mom would try to cover for something awful like that! He will never learn that way!!

[@gt43025]

They let a stranger in & this is the Thanks 😮 they get 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@bernardmcginnis6392]

The family let the liar in their home because they accidentally broke her arm

[@filmtressmu8552]

No, no, no, big brother. Aint your girlfriend, it wasn't your arm and you weren't involved that day. Stay out of it. Mom needs to allow her son(s) to be responsible for their own actions. I do believe her and that silly statement about "I said please, get this b*tch out of my car" in a calm manner sounded so false it was laughable. Good, now she gets a jump on a new start. Good win.

[@antonettestrong1430]

This man brought his whole family…. Look sir the truth don’t need no support

[@kay22100]

Mama’s boy bringing all this drama to his mom’s house! Get yourself together and don’t move women in your mom’s house!! Get your own

[@wildfiregirl1556]

FACTS!!

[@shamikacallis242]

As a Mother of four grown children Two Women/Two Suns,I’ve always told them I don’t entertain lies and bad behavior!! If you’re wrong ,you’re wrong PERIOD!!!

[@lawofashley4241]

the plaintiffsssss plus the witness all were lying. didnt make any since and im glad she was paid

[@dotspkfaqs]

If he don’t take me out I’m going to the police… his brother need to stop the foolishness

[@deejai1173]

They’re just doing too damn much. They lost me with the damn demonstration! I’m confused as to why everyone speaks more than the boyfriend does! Outta here; that whole family weird! 🧐