So this is what the Acheron "RED TEXT" does in Honkai Star Rail

Who let Shaoji and HSR team cooks
Subscribe for more Content!~
Support me on Trakteer: trakteer.id/xafrel
Support me on ko-fi: ko-fi.com/xafrel
Follow my Socials: / xafrelyt
Genshin Memes Playlist :
• Video
Genshin.exe Playlist:
• Tartaglia "childe".exe...

[@TartagliaThe_11th_McDsEmployee]

Man this is such a wholesome story where all characters live happily away from fear and tragedy

[@jeffeyL]

Tru

[@blankenstein001]

Gotta thank Shaoji for that honestly

[@nemesisundead83]

Until now...

[@JustAGuyWithAHentaiPfp391]

*I want you to show me, your fantasy~ (your fantasy~)*

[@SomeRealYT]

@@JustAGuyWithAHentaiPfp391 *No past and no future, That's what i need~ (That's what i need~)*

[@MonoNonsensicalProduction]

I think the red text (for now) is used for conditioning the player about branching narrative. Basically it's this dev team saying "If you see red text, be prepare to make a consequential choice" without telling the player directly. So down the line when quest and narrative gets bigger the players will be ready to make the choice without making a mistake.

[@Mortyferus]

But you get the red text after choosing an option not before

[@MonoNonsensicalProduction]

@@Mortyferus Thats my only concern. Since these choices don't have weight they can do that. We'll have to wait and see 2.1 and 2.2 On what red text truly implies. On a side note if the red text is lore related and not game design. I'd say its related to Sparkles "changing the script" / rearranging memory. Of course, assuming what Black Swan said about Memory is true. Edit: fixed my genshin brain rot

[@IzuShiTei]

@@Mortyferus cmiiw but when in the hallway we do get the red text first and then the choice, but then in the room we get the choice first and then the red text. i think the one in the room is not really us making a choice, it's just that they're showing which dialogue get affected by our previous choices

[@rscode8975]

Imo, I don't think changes in color text meant branching narrative as we always have branching choices(especially on some side quest)in the game already. It could be an Alter ego of her talking or that's just the way how the developers present when the one you talk to suddenly changes their tone(or depict murderous intent?) like they become another person or something

[@nuhurrahman2861]

​@@MonoNonsensicalProductionEdit, its not "4.1 and 4.2", its supposed to be "2.1 and 2.2", we're in HSR bro, not Genshin 🗿

[@Dissapointed_Aether]

I notice that when she talks with white text, her voice is normal and calm. but when she talks with red texts, her voice is deep and is more serious.

[@skyreaper1994]

Maybe she has 2 personality kinda like Raiden Shogun but technically it's a separate entity (Raiden puppet/Ei) just my speculation

[@Herrscher_Of_Tuna]

​@@skyreaper1994 Yeah, also reminds me of Raiden Mei and the Herrscher of Thunder persona

[@McDonaldSeele.]

Hmmm like the stygian nymph battlesuit

[@Herrscher_Of_Tuna]

@@McDonaldSeele. true

[@imgroot6831]

⁠@@McDonaldSeele.and SN’s weapon is called path to acheron, sn’s gameplay is also full of flowers which is like acheron

[@Raymart6543]

What Adventurine said about her was true. She's an emanator of Finality and *she can go back in time* to decide for another choice again, but forgets most of the event that transpired to her after she does it. Meaning, those red lines that you see there is clearly a test for her to know if you're following the same path as her as well as probing you out if you're indeed related to her before she regresses.

[@colonelphenix7770]

Actually, what you are saying makes sense because just before the astral express warp jump toward penacony, the moment the MC got influenced by the Remembrance zone we could see some memories and when this first meeting with Acheron end, Pom-Pom come to see you and one of the dialogue option is : « I saw memories of the future » (iirc). So all of that to say that, maybe the memories that flashed through the MC after the warp jump were those of Acheron (From the future), moreover she said that their spirit/dream are somewhat linked in this zone.

[@dontshitontravelermains5498]

The leak said she is emanator of Nihility so idk

[@IveBeenWithBruma]

No Aeon has been confirmed yet most chosen were guesses in game. Considering she had Sam on the back foot should tell you how powerful her Aeon is though.

[@yume372]

WTF, linking her forgetfulness to her being an emanator of Finality is actually genius. I don't know if this red text was Archeron exclusive, and Hoyo really used it with that intent, but I like your idea.

[@AntonioBibini]

Than maybe it makes sense why she said sorry when Firefly got stabbed. She could have gone back in time and save her but she didn't

[@Tetsulot]

If you choose male MC, she will remembered you crpss blade, but if it female MC then she will remrmbered you two stand side by side

[@Zeenyu]

So Stelle and Callus are like Genshin impact twins, they both exist?

[@Tetsulot]

@@Zeenyu who knows

[@Khann_2102]

​@@ZeenyuPerhaps, anything is possible

[@azriel.a.r8052]

There was a comment i read saying if its female MC she remembers kiana and if its male MC she remembers kevin. Don't know if its true tho

[@FD-wl7xq]

@@azriel.a.r8052yeah was gonna say,Stelle is probably like kiana and caelus is like kevin.Tho it makes sense since stelle sometimes has that chapter 1 kiana kinda energy and caelus is based of kevin from ggz

[@nguyenquoctoan6354]

My theory is the entire Penacony, even the "reality" area, is time looped in a Dreamscape. In the bugged Dreamscape we encountered on the Express, we could see some fastforward events and we met illusions of characters we haven't actual meet yet and they were talking about what you didn't know. Trailblazer and Acheron are 2 invidiuals that somehow could aware of the time loop slightly. The answers you gave Acheron in the intro would determine how much your character had looped. If you pick that you didn't remember her, it means that the number of loops was still low. Acheron was assigned a different room with a different number to ours, and her stepping in was entirely for helping us. If you choosed that you remember her somewhere, it means that the number of loops is high and what had happened started to leave an imprint on your memory, as well as Acheron's. Since these loops are not 100% same with each others, there will be loops that Acheron had been actually assigned this room and she ended up kicking Aventurine out because she thought this was also her room in this loop.

[@houdinioreo9057]

Damn, this theory sounds correct.

[@saddog6527]

Cool theory, but IIRC I choose that I remember her (or at least the closest one to that) and got the one where she's just helping us.

[@nguyenquoctoan6354]

@@saddog6527 Yep, I found out that the red text is actually random regardless of what you have picked in the "first" Dreamscape. The theory still works though, just not relies on your choice anymore.

[@esmondgoh3112]

My theory is that, the moment anyone is 'invited' into Penacony, those people are trapped in the dream world and Watchmaker is behind it. Why? 1. In the 'Its always Night in Penacony' show, near the end, the bar scene.. it had 3 guys talking. 1 from the Bloodhound and 1 from the Iris, the last guy, being all sus - made the 2 argue, and said something about the Watchmaker. 2. We have been told that the Watchmaker is an enemy. Sunday also seems pretty sus, I would think he either has a deal with the Watchmaker or the real him is being confined by the Watchmaker. 3. Whenever we 'wake up' from the dream world in the story, we don't really wake up. Basically it's the same as you dream of yourself waking up, but you only woke up in your dream, not actually waking up from your sleep. This could be similar to the day-loop quest in Sumeru, where Layla figured out it was a loop. I think, the character that would realise we're all still in the dream would be one of the playable characters instead of us (the TB)

[@nguyenquoctoan6354]

@@esmondgoh3112 Probably Acheron had already realized that this is a time loop even if her memory was also wiped, and she were trying to help us as much as possible during "reset time" at the start of Penacony. She was the first one who taught us to wall walk while later while traveling with her and Black Swan, Black Swan was the one who taught them how to wall walk. At the same time, I think Sam and Firefly are also other people who was already picked up the time loop thing. While in the Reverie Dreamscape, Black Swan had used her Rememberance ability as a Memokeeper to scan the area but Sam was not detected, so I think he had immunity to Rememberance, which could also be the reason that he was picked by Elio for this mission. Firefly's memoria left behind also mentioned that "If I could try again..." that caught the attention of Acheron about "try again" part.

[@crystalplayzgames3424]

There is a clock that you can fix in the dream reverie, where in MC's thoughts there are red texts. And from what the text says it is usually anger or rage. When you fix the clock you receive a creepy film thing and you can either choose to keep it, give it to the family or leave it there. I personally chose to keep it and now its in my inventory.

[@WAVE00799]

Yea I also got it yesterday

[@mikoichiban8934]

You can give it to the man sitting near the bird.

[@guntalamv]

And if you give it to the man beside the pack of origami bird in reverie dream u can get 5 jades achievement

[@Akarumey2023]

Also did the same.

[@One_eye_larx]

The disk is a hidden achievement. Give it to the bloodhound next to the main bird in the dream. He explains what it is, and gives you rewards. This completes the achievement.

[@kaudnamoonfox1430]

There was a moment where i tried to refuse a request from her in red text, but eventually you cant refuse and things kinda went her way... I think this is mechanic just like Kafka's spirit whisper where her text was in yellow when she was using it, acheron must have some domination effect as well.

[@arnowisp6244]

Mommy...😳

[@kaudnamoonfox1430]

@@arnowisp6244 ummm 🙄🙄🙄...

[@ossuika__727]

I also clicked on choices that refused her and she just kept saying that she can't hear me until the remaining choices were the same (agreement to Acheron) but the other one is in red text. gave me the heebie-jeebies

[@kaudnamoonfox1430]

@@ossuika__727 yessss exactly the one im talking aboutt

[@otaku-chan4888]

I don't think it's a domination effect. Rather, your option text turned red because you exist in a branching timeline where _you'd never chosen to refuse her._

[@bucky831]

This is quest is giving me Sumeru + Fontaine vibes. You know on basis of "Dreams", "mystery" and two "faced peoples"

[@kevingraham4736]

And people turning into water

[@realice.]

Unless i got minus emotional support since firefly is fireflying somewhere far away and there's no nahida

[@nurventilatoren]

If she really is a Emanator, it could be the Aeon talking through her.

[@christianw935]

Had to scroll too far for this comment

[@justadragonnamemarcus1751]

Or worse.... She's in possession by Aha

[@9990zara]

​@@justadragonnamemarcus1751out of all possible aeons, i dont think aha is the one lol his presence is already there with the masked fools. aha is too joyful to possess someone like acheron

[@awes5893]

This would work but we get a red text option too, if you reply in a certain way when she asks if you want to investigate with her and Black Swan.

[@realice.]

​@@9990zarai've read about Aha joining the express for a year as a companion only to betray and explode a planet alongside half of the train just for shit and giggles. Can't really rule out that theory. Aha is an absolute menace😂 On the other hand, the red text works like some kind of deus ex machina to connect the current acheron to that exact moment of branching timelines. So maybe the current acheron is not yet an emanator but her future self is. And her future self can connect to her existence throughout the timelines. Since Terminus was said to see the world backward and all.

[@Schinak]

Umineko PTSD returns in full force wthe moment I saw the RED TEXT

[@thebiggesthatersinworld]

Lmao, PTSD is real with this

[@2sword]

Gotta find the Goldsm- I mean Watchmaker's inheritance at the big Family meeting.

[@Rainin.7]

​@@2sword Wait a minute, the whole penacony story is an umineko reference afterall 😭😭

[@Schinak]

@@Rainin.7 If they did draw inspiration from Umineko WE ARE SO BONED

[@Kyoshiki_Kiryu]

So we gonna have blue and golden truth soon lol

[@F.I.N.A.L.I.T.Y.]

Love how when Acheron shows up, everything falls apart

[@Robinhs]

When you first meet Acheron she tells you to pay attention to the red, as a way to not get lost in the dreamscape or something. I don't remember exactly what she says but she definitely tells you to look out for red.

[@FrostBite46]

It almost feels like a pick your own adventure thing but not at the same time kinda creepy

[@belldandy_PZ]

I had the second text for my playthrough. Her knowing what was going on and stepped in. It fit and I didn't think anything of it. Today I have been watching others play this part and all got the first text of her lost. I was confused and thought I may have missed something as I didn't remember that. haha This makes so much more since now. This changes how I will watch the red text when the next chapter comes out and see what my firends do as well.

[@kolpolokipo]

I chose the "thank you" and "this is my room" and she said she was teasing. Then I left the game and entered it again so I can choose different option. I chose "Why haven't you left" instead and she was wondering if she came to wrong room. Then I re-entered the game and chose the first mentioned options again and she answered the same. I think there is two or more types of red text answers deteremined by all chosen options before red text but it probabaly won't change anything beside red answers. It can also be devs informing us about different answers.

[@Rainin.7]

Alright, can't wait for the blue Truth in the next update

[@serenitygorloth]

Imagine if Golden truth was there lol

[@zerus3643]

A few lines of text and this level of reasoning is possible for Furudo Erika. What do you think, everyone?

[@Terrabreak133]

Me seeing red dialogue after playing lb6 in FGO "You are perfect just the way you are, Acheron. Please do not turn into a gigant black hole worm."

[@Greennaris_Rater]

MAn WHY did u mention that... it's even Oberon and Acheron, they are so f*ckin similar in this sense...

[@izzuddin_]

Obviusly it's bcs Nasu special interview with David Jiang on HSR JP

[@Greennaris_Rater]

@@izzuddin_ whuuuuut

[@duppud]

I remember she said something about feeling countless versions of us making different choices Each one is similar yet distinct

[@controli5123]

Got that one too, it makes sense if I think about my answers they kinda contradict each other, for example, first I said I probably remember her and last I said I didn't, and did the same on the other answers too, I think there is a connection between the red text and time

[@yamatanoorochi3149]

yes me too I remember thinking at the time it was because some of answers were contradicting

[@MuhammadNizarKhalifi]

because theres only one acheron but many MC (us, the player)

[@michaelrunkat6115]

Seeing the red text the first time gave me a sinking feeling I havent felt since the early Hi3 chapters. I had fun the entire time doing the penacony quest but theres always a knot in my stomach telling me somethings definitely going wrong. And sure enough it did. Im honestly excited to see what the team is cooking up in penacony, let the newbloods have a taste in what we eat up in Hi3 lol.

[@zhaq]

I hear Sawashiro Miyuki doubled. I'm satisfied. Thanks for the vid.

[@juan.argueta]

i got the first one when i did the quest, btw if you chose not to trust adventurine and leave with black swan you get an alternative ending at the end of the quest similar to when you chose not to board the expres at the beginning

[@josephoyek6574]

WAIT WHAT???

[@dendifikriyansyah7028]

​@@josephoyek6574 bad end, mc and the crew trapped in dream forever

[@starrkow]

@@dendifikriyansyah7028welt getting nerfed again…

[@dendifikriyansyah7028]

@@starrkow idk, current panacony is like fenghuan down on planetary level, and they just go straight head on defenseless so it's kinda justified

[@Erik-je6fy]

*Aventurine

[@vyx_the_grole]

The only thing the red text makes me think is umineko's red truth lmao. Anyway, i think acheron is probably the key to solve most of the mysteries. And maybe Misha. Why him? Cause like when we go in the true dreamscape and also in other occasions the name Mikhail pops up. And both Mikhail and Misha are variations of the name Micheal, so Misha could be Mikhail or be related to him. As for characters like Black Swan,Sparkle and Aventurine i think they just know something more than us, not necessarily ALL the truth but still more than us, and are acting according to their own agendas (so i wouldn't call them evil or good. Aventurine and black swan probably are acting because of reasons, and sparkle cause well...she's a Masked Fool so she's probably messing around cause it is fun)

[@kudryavka219]

it will still change even if you choose the same choices btw, i dunno what the trigger is tho. got 3 different responses from her except for the one where she's introducing herself.

[@victorb5]

Yeah I don't think it's a "choose your own adventure", I think it's just random which is to show she has some deep schism in her personality.

[@mica_s]

@@victorb5might have something to do with time, she said she'd consider how espontaneus the answers would be

[@rao9574]

For me ... (with my stupid idea from one novel, her sword + her red umbrella in splash art!) It's like her sword talking to us in red. You can see in one shot that it has mostly red design with something look like a symbol maybe eye and Acheron design is mostly purple. Also combine it with Honkai Impact she can be emanator of Finality (or corruption).

[@AnimeFreak1022]

another thing I felt with Acheron, and Penacony is that that I think there is a 'loop' event happening in the dream world. The reason why Acheron asks you if you have met before is because it was not her first time meeting you or us the 'Trailblazer' she met us in Penacony. She teaches us how to use the 3d room, and later she is oblivious about it when another character teaches us how to use it again in Penacony proper further in the story. This is where Acheron herself learned how to do it, and taught us it when we first get there. Another idea I had in line with the Looping is our new friend that we make in Penacony. I think they are who will become March 7th. With the looping I think the rememberance group either make a deal with us, or they down the line makes the deal themself to be 'reborn' and are placed in the ice to heal, and put in the path of the nameless to truly become a trailblazer like they wished.

[@kostuchan4418]

Glad to see I'm not the only one connecting Firefly to March. Though I'm leaning more to a theory that when March became an ice sculpture (most likely due to the illness Firefly told us about), she split into , a body that was found by Express and consciousness that came to Dreamscape.

[@mistsrider]

Thanks for looking into this!

[@peanutbutter7663]

during the 2.2 mission 'on the eighth day' iirc acheron asks you the exact same questions but your only answer is the ones you picked (need confirm)

[@fashyakupercent20]

Reverie dream, A child's dream, and our first encounter against the big meme monster(i forgot the name) with Firefly in that looping tv room. Penacony is such a breath of fresh air considering this is a mihoyo game

[@user-je2dx6ct9x]

That's cool, I didn't know that! Thank you for sharing with us !

[@shady1212]

I've been wondering about this! I noticed the red text and a voice change and I've been wondering what it was about! Thank you!

[@xemnasxiii3992]

I want to say i almsot did the same thing in the first time meeting her in the dream except i said i don't know her and when she interupted Aventurine and i told it's my room she went straight for the "i know, i pulled this stunt to help you" that's interesting i wonder how much can she say _and i really hope the devs implement a way to replay story scenarios_

[@pranavnair3938]

It was different for me. I chose all the same choices as you, and in the room she says the second dialogue. Then fortunately my network got cut and it restarted from the cutscene and she goes on to say the first dialogue....🤔

[@AntonioBibini]

Than it's random??

[@pranavnair3938]

@@AntonioBibini I'm guessing the red text is to highlight that Acheron is hiding something, and shows the randomness of the dialogue as well. The reaction of Caelus is also how it feels weird listening to her...

[@Shinochaos]

I chose the same answers you did in your first playthrough and got her saying "just relax, this is indeed your room" so idk it could be random

[@dh599]

I thought the red text was stuff she'll forget... or remember. As someone else said it looks like it denotes branching conversations and maybe in 2.3 those branches will chsnge the story, but then it's a little odd that only Acheron has that red text...

[@j0doe1]

Spoilers ahead from the earlier part of 2.1: When Acheron spoke to Sam, she asked him if she was in Elio's script, to which Sam said she wasn't. Interestingly, when Acheron said "I", the I was in red text. Perhaps part of being a self-annihilator is to annihilate yourself to some extent from the destiny of the universe. This could allow her to say things that shouldn't normally be possible to change. Perhaps that's what Sam envies about her. She's completely unrestrained by the "script".

[@dh599]

@@j0doe1 So you predict that anything in red is possibly... "off-script"? Did I interpret you correctly?

[@j0doe1]

@@dh599 Yeah, that's my prediction.

[@gabrielrodriguez9142]

As the Emanator of Nihility she makes everything meaningless. Acheron is very much like IX himself a black hole in which if pulled by it nothing you do means anything. This assures me that the Stellaron Hunters do not follow the Nihility and probably the Finality because the MC has been able to defy the script that Elio gives you (Kafka and Blade quest). Acheron on the other hand forces you into things and when you deny her she changes your answer to a red text. She didn't pull her sword for Firefly because it was meaningless..she is stuck, haunted by the Nihility nothing she does matters she is but a black hole sucking and destroying all including choices and will.

[@JamesFR2007]

The thing i thought on watching this vid is White text represent acheron just talking normaly nothing else in mind but what is happening at the moment Red text she is talking with the past in mind like her old friend, or just thinking mostly about the old friend

[@ilLuctus]

I remember one dialog where we just say no over and over, she says in red text "sorry I didn't hear you could you repeat that" until the second time we are only left with options in her favor and this was infrot of blackswan

[@kaiirynn8987]

coming back to this video after the acheron leaks is wild

[@nishiscarletuwo835]

Shes not the only one who appears with red text. In herta's soace station there's a quest where we discivwr an npc is an Android and has shiet twrm memory; when she maldunctions she had red texts

[@teslapanda1412]

The place with dr ratio?

[@maximeimer]

How come literally not a single comment is talking about acherons line where she says that in a world of black and white there will be a glimpse of red and we'll have to make a choice then?

[@apolloranger8675]

I just finshed what is available and god I was shocked,So many questions and little answers it has me going for more

[@netneo4038]

The red text has been used in honkai impact on at least 2 occasions, one was when a character was speaking directly to the player, not the character but the player, you. The other instance was when a character was directing their chat towards an omniscient god that could see and know all. Do with that information what you will

[@akashitorayuzaku5706]

It's an Umineko reference

[@vennstudios9885]

She's an Emanator of an aeon of which we dont know With her strange Changing Red text Voice lines she could be the emanator of the strangest and most secretive aeon, The Enigmatic strange, random, secrecy, unknown all falls under the Enigmatic her purpose in Penacony is still an enigmatic mystery

[@nympf]

my idea of the red text is, that she is saying something else. But something want to let the talk go this way so its something only the the second party understand different. I mean, for example, I don't wanted her to go with Black Swan and me but the last declining text was, as well, in red. ... She joined uns ether way

[@Saeralyhn]

Honestly, for me, the red text just immediately had my Umineko senses tingling. Which... is probably not intended, your experiment shows it's not the Red Truth. But it's nice to have a similiar feeling, at least

[@xkayl]

Now I'm scared, it's very strange how the red text changes depending on the account. My theory is that Acheron contains a dual personality but it is trapped in her body and that personality is the one she remembers us the most, for some reason I think that if that is true we will see something similar in her combat mode (more or less like Jingliu) In her dripmarketing, her hair was somewhat white and the background did not match the purple aesthetic of the character, so will she have a second form? (These are theories, please don't judge me and don't give me spoilers either)

[@IveBeenWithBruma]

Or she is being taken over by her aeon briefly. She does lose her memory often.

[@Dfathurr]

Somehow, if we compared to Acheron counterparts in other Hoyoverse games. It actually kinda rhymed Raiden Mei essentially one person only Raiden Ei was two person pretend to be one Now Acheron is one person but with two personality Seems neat to me

[@salazar84]

She does seem to have a second personality. Her banner art has a white shade around the end of her hair and... There's the fact that if you know how to rip models she has two with different textures. But eh most likely we will get a confirmation in a few days when the beta for 2.1 drops.

[@aries21k02]

​@@IveBeenWithBruma(spoilers) this would make sense since she says after (redacted) dies she didn't draw her sword because she had "no choice" Whoever her aeon is he remembers akvili(?) And wanted either that mc saw (redacted) die or that it simply likes to see people die

[@revanninja]

@@Dfathurr Uhm So Raiden Mei DID have another personality it died for her so she can claim the full authority but originally Mei had a Herrescher personality that could take over she even had a bomb implanted near her heart to stop it if she ever lost control. So the 2 personalities fits. What if as an emanator Archeon isnt just a person closest to her Aeon but is also the Aeon's personal avatar. It might even be how Akavali got around. Pom-pom is strongly suspected to be Akavali's heart which empowers the Train and why he cant leave the train and the Body was Akavali which got killed. its WHY no one knows when Pom-pom showed up because once the train was fixed and operating Pom-pom was able to materialize again. So if Pom-pom and Akavali is right its possible an Aeon could have their body and power in one place but their mind or heart in another and that could be what Archeon IS.

[@Oily_Engineer]

i got a different result when i first met acheron i think it went like "its as if i was talking" idk i forgot the rest but it said that i had many 'personality' that gave her an answer per branched sentences

[@blankenstein001]

Same, when I have her different different answers she said to me that as if there were many different personalities in me giving their thoughts and that led to the second dialogue interaction after aventurine left.

[@cortesyes]

While I very much support the theory that it’s her alter ego talking, it seems to work differently from your classic double personality character. Her speech is coherent and fluid, it’s just as if she was talking normally, but the way she speaks and what she says in red text seems somehow different from when it’s in white, even when the two sentences are perfectly connected. A very weird feeling

[@serenitygorloth]

Why does this remind me of red truth from Umineko-

[@n-0697]

this helps me understand what red text means thank you btw I did Acheron dram quest I did choose random answers

[@purplemangablade]

I ask me myself to why is only by Acheron with Red Text. Could be maybe a another Person give a between Warning and Death.

[@ilnavertefeuille6738]

Thank you for the demonstration, I didn't know that answers changed ! When we speak with Acheron, she said (in the french subtitles I don't know the others) something like (I don't remember exact words) "In the futur you will see in only black and white, pay attention if you see red, pay attention to your choice" so I hope that some choice had a REAL consequences and not leading at the same point (again). If not, what's the point to say something like this ? For now I wait. I think "only in black and white" referred at the lack of nuance because the MC gonna be angry with all the people who use him, but, if red is really literraly the color red, maybe in a part of a story the MC will see in black and white xD Honestly I feel angry for him with all the people who trick him and decided for him since the beginning ! At his place I will run to the train "Can we go far ? I'm out !" xD

[@RaiRaii17]

I've got so many questions in my head

[@ICNHH]

you can also get red text when you choose whether you want acheron to join you and black swan if u say no, she says she didnr hear u, if u say no again, there is no longer the choice to say no, and there are 2 text options saying to let her join us, but one text option is white and the other is red

[@oussamaalaoui9121]

When she was with misha she wasnt asking questions but here text was red

[@PrototypeMajor]

All is simple: RED TEXT = another personality. We already have red text with man behind gates (Jarilo - VI). That persona - the same, which traveled from HI 3rd, just like Welt. "The memories of old friend" - for Stelle = Kiana and for Caelus = Kevin. When she travelled, her soul merged with other soul: read new Set "Divers of Dead Waters". White text - merged soul (have less experience, don`t have knack), red text - original soul, that become a "Emanator of Finality", just like MC (she can "feel" Misha presence)

[@StrxwberriiMochii]

There's actually a third text where she says she jests and she's also looking for her own room but heard a commotion and came to take a look. She also said that Aventurine looked like he was up to no good

[@ShapeshifterOS]

Acheron does mention being on The Hunt for someone, can't remember the full quote. What stood out to me was the fact the words "The Hunt" was capitalized as if talking about Lan, but didn't make sense in that context. I think this is a clue to the fact she follows the path of The Hunt.

[@Fuzion9000]

theres a dream ticker you can interact with, after solving the puzzle, you arent rewarded, you get red text as in inner monologue, felt like my trailblazer was on a villain arc

[@Crazmuss]

Loved that part where you explained what the "RED TEXT" does in Honkai Star Rail.

[@vitorjjgameplays5786]

They are taking advantage of Penacony to use the idea that "fate is not immutable" to the extreme. In Cocona's side quest, if you choose to let go of her hand, the clothing store gets a new attendant, and at least I don't think you can find Cocona anymore (she's still alive, but she's not on the map). Probably, depending on what we answer to Acheron, she may take on a different position at the end of Penacony, perhaps as an ally or an enemy. In the Luofu, it's possible to skip Kafka's entire quest just by leaving, so in Penacony something like that could happen.

[@ol1ezjka128]

Umineko vibes are Insane ☠️☠️☠️

[@user-nx5ou8ln7e]

I think that’s the timelines thing. She literally says it herself “for a split second it felt like countless versions of you alike yet distinct gave entirely different responses”. And then after she speaks about upcoming tragedies in golden dream she says: “And finally your sight will only see black and white. But believe me in that monochrome world there will always be a glimpse of fleeting red and when you make a choice it will reappear before you once more. What you must do is ponder its significance.”

[@martin144gaming]

When i saw the red texts i felt like its the best if i think before choosing. 1:02 i picked the first , 1:12 i picked that too , 1:20 i picked the first. 1:35 second. 3:22 i got that version. I hope black swan is with me 💍 i only trust her

[@Phantom-_-Crash]

It adds to the mystery behind her character

[@lula9549]

Hoyoverse is probably introducing the concept of the Imaginary Tree in hsr! I’m so excited for the development of the story now that Shaoji (a HI3 writer) is working on the Penacony quests!!

[@Valia2899]

Haven't you do the chadwick quest? Imaginary tree was mentioned there, it was zandar's knowledge. Maybe it is the reason why he can crafted nous

[@lula9549]

@@Valia2899 I worded my comment wrong, the concept has of course already been introduced, but only as a theory in the hsr universe.

[@MorinoTengu]

the first thought when i saw that is maybe the red text is just a loop because she say about her forgeting things and some people think she can back in time but im more toward that the villain or wherever else reseting our memories and that have more setup than just time traveling out of nowhere

[@lk2807]

I love this music

[@sonyaalbated9799]

My first reaction was "tf is this, a kind of threatening word or smth!?!"

[@6ShadowNevermore9]

there were some leaks about a red acheron form so maybe the red text implies the second personality of hers taking over(?)

[@jacktk3129]

Shaoji best, can't wait to see the deja vu happen like Himeko from HI3 and repeat again in HSR 😆

[@VitalTCV]

I believe she is an Aeon. The Aeon of death, Theres a quest or dialogue I remember saying shes not who she says she is and she is apart of that region of power. ( Could easily be wrong ) Theres another thing I believe that the red text is not necessarily a context changer but let alone an opinion on the matter on how YOU see her. I still won't disregard it I believe there is going to be different endings. shes important and I don't know why but we clearly remember her. She was asking questions as if she was going to try again somehow as if "Do you still remember me" and us saying we may remember her is some kind of indication that this may have happened before. Could easily be time looping as your laying there in the dream bath. and or time freezing. There are also NPCS who lost themselves within the scape. We save 2 but I think there are others. There is a lot here that needs to be thought of. We haven't even been with the group for a while, and I believe we aren't going too. This is OUR story. Something is going to happen.

[@captainarkro4376]

I was planning to save my jades till 2.2 but Archeron really grew on me this 2.0 quest. I wasn't expecting this at all from her.

[@SSWchris11]

When she kills you in the dream i was like damn she is motivated

[@rin9005]

I chose the same text's as you did in the first part the only difference is I thanked her in the hotel, yet I got the dialog where she says she was teasing.

[@rikkucrowe]

The moment I saw the red text I was put on gaurd and thought carefully about my anwsers

[@fabianopuma9058]

Now i don't know if it's connected or if there's another sample of this but when aventurine tells she's an emanator subtitles are yellow Just pointing that out

[@Shika_Saki]

What a sweet and wholesome story that left me B R O K E N THX MIHOYO 😢 The more I see of it the more broken I become man.. give us the end of penacony already..

[@rojotm3378]

this is making me wish i put more thought into my answers...

[@bappack894]

Now, the story becomes more interesting than ever before...

[@FeoAntePel]

That Danganronpa reference was immaculate my guy

[@Cyno_General_mahamatra]

'Evil text' - that's the first thing came in my mind after seeing this...

[@iamkevib9718]

Pog, different dialogues for different dialogues.

[@blaznkin]

I too have those same thoughts, and it reminded me of a time in Kafka's companion quest with her game of truth and lie. When she asked what do i think of her, I accidentally chose a negative answer. I was kind of devastated with my choice, and hope i can back track, but it was too late, and now i have constant fear that in one patch in the future, she might bring that up and our dynamic relationship could be ruined because of my dumb choice.

[@DarrenStevensohnOfficial]

It is a nice detail because I recognize her from Honkai Impact as Raiden Mei and it leds to all my answer being vaguely remembering her which then later she will keep acting like we have deeper bond than what it seems on the surface. It help me feeling a bit immersed that Acheron is just another Mei on different universe as she is the most consistent character to appear in most of Hoyoverse games.

[@denysanchez1576]

Red text changes even if you give the same answers, is account linked, if you create a new account and do exactly the same as the first one, you will get anyway a different answer in the red text

[@sniper5126]

3:14 I choose the exact same as you in your first acount exect for the first one, yet I got this response

[@noreencadavedo2742]

I risked spoiling myself with this one lmao cuz i havent played yet, but dont worry, ive already been spoiled about the killings and tragic stuff in twitter so this one doesnt spoil much. Tbh all the spoilers make me not wanna play penacony cuz it kinda changes the vibe of the game for me lol

[@Yungescobar1]

The red text is also in the shinning Easter egg in the hotel in jarilo iv that was part of the trailblazers imagination. Maybe everything is just the trailblazers imagination

[@lacombely6733]

Without simping it can't be seen

[@eminiclam]

I saw onther youtuber get a different answer at the hotel something like "I jest, I know this is your room"

[@Phat_trick910]

It's the Call of Duty "warning text"

[@YuutaKyon]

Now imagine those red text with voices playing together in Caelus brains aaaaaaarghhhh sawashiro saaannnn

[@nowone80000]

I got the second set of dialogue and had no idea you could get another one, I just assumed she had chose us as her new sworn bestie ☺️

[@ryanmalik3378]

I'm not playing the penacony story (because busy irl) but i already meet her in after we sleep in train. She give me the red text. But because I don't think my choice wrong i pick same choice but red text appear again until she give new dialog about my choices.

[@izerob6783]

Stop messing with my brain 💀

[@mahdihasan387]

I think that depends on the first question because I chose that "we probably met before" in the very first red question and all others were the same as yours but she chose the second outcome where she said she was teasing us and knows this is our room

[@DanielDaAbadSukarno]

I can't refuse her to follow me when i go the the dream ! When i go with black swan!

[@TheRamblemanWhoSings]

Pretty cool of the devs to change the dialogue