Sodor Productions Needs To Change - This Fandom Is Awful

[@HenryFan1911]

SodorProductions, if you're watching this, feel free to make a video telling me what a loser I am lol.

[@ScottMalkinsonisW]

I’m so thankful that you and fairlyoddenginecreations are in this fandom.

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

@@ScottMalkinsonisW I'm not it was justified at first but I think they're going too far now

[@bacanpancakesproductions6038]

Good on you for calling that jerk out!

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

@@bacanpancakesproductions6038he's not a misogynist

[@YouSoJames]

he doesnt waste his time watching crap, so im doing it 🫡

[@IMEEntertainment]

To be honest, I actually believe this guy is trolling the TTTE fandom, because he KNOWS how easy it is to troll and get reactions out of because of how toxic it is. He could be spurting out all of his anti-LGBT/Anti-left wing stuff for cheap shock value, because that's the "best" kind of comedy these days. But if he's actually admitting his own opinions, then this guy really has something. I dislike the fandom as much as most people do, but people like him give the bright side a bad name, too.

[@HenryFan1911]

I really hope he is just trolling everyone.

[@IMEEntertainment]

@@HenryFan1911 It could be the case, because he didn’t start making more of those kind of videos until after the fandom discovered those initial run of videos he did. It’s sad how overwhelmingly toxic, profane and distasteful the fandom can be. You’d think that some people should follow on the themes, morals, lessons etc. from the show itself but they don’t. I used to do voice roles for someone who was part of the fandom years ago when they were a teenager and whenever he would do live streams it was nothing but immaturish Family Guy style sex jokes coming from him and his friends which I can guess the user regrets about these days.

[@therenamonstan]

I swear to God, his arrogance knows no bounds. It makes me ashamed to be a Thomas fan.

[@HenryFan1911]

@@therenamonstan It’s tragic

[@captainbaxter723]

If it makes you ashamed, try watching something actually good pumped out of here, like a rewrite of a shoty episode or something.

[@Dieselworks123]

I'm 28 and a father of 2, Thomas has been with me since the start and the fact I can share that with my kids is amazing. They will watch any era of Thomas (yes even AEG) it just depends on their mood that day. Now I may not like AEG like I do the classic series, but I can see some positives about. For example they actually gave Nia a character in AEG, and to be fair the merch is pretty on point. What I'm trying to say is what is attacking people going to do? We are all part of the same fandom yet we all seem to struggle to get along. We are allowed to have options, that's what makes the fandom interesting, it's just that small group of fans, that take it to far and somewhat seem to enjoy the drama they cause.

[@joshuaW5621]

Too bad people still choose to hate on Nia for replacing Edward 6 years later.

[@CaptainUnikitty]

I stopped supporting sodor production after seeing what fairly odd engine had to say. Fairly definitely didn’t deserve that and he was only sharing an opinion. Also sodor production began talking about like almost like political stuff that didn’t make all that sense to me. Even kind of saying something about LGBTQ that sounded a bit negative. I myself don’t really like all engines go but I don’t go out hurting others, I respect the creators and the people who like it (for me it’s just hard to watch and kind of uncomfortable) I just hope sodor production doesn’t take all of this way too far, but I feel like he’ll get angry about everything

[@southerncoastproductions7587]

fairly odd engines is a jerk etiher way. nothing he says is valuable. and he should be locked away in a cage.

[@joshuav875]

Ironically, I got AEG commercials before his video plays.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I’ve gotten ads like that when I’m watching videos too! They can be pretty annoying sometimes.

[@OfficialEdwardTheWiseEngine]

7:05 Speaking of death threats, when Nia's VA was revealed to be Yvone Grundy, everybody in the fandom was giving her death threats, and calling her the FUCKING N-WORD AS WELL AS OTHER RACIAL SLURS. What a terrible fandom i'm in.

[@HenryFan1911]

Jesus Christ, how little dignity do we have as a community to send threats like that?

[@jackjackbt]

That’s awful? Was there even a reason? Was it just because people don’t like Nia?

[@OfficialEdwardTheWiseEngine]

@@jackjackbt it appears that are sexist and racist

[@captainbaxter723]

Let's pray that they were just DeviantArt Fill-in Memers and not actual adults

[@Dayronthesonicfan]

Both this and the sonic fandom are crazy

[@captainbaxter723]

To the actual good people in this fandom, NWR1991, Enterprising Engines, ThomasWoodenRailway, TonsOfTrackmasters, James Is Here, TTTE Guy, Shiny Red Engine, ComicFan13, Here's Domix, and many more, which is a surprising amount. As a person who has caused multiple instances of drama, especially on Discord which I'm trying to redeem myself there, I apologize in ADVANCE for what this fandom has become. From a wholesome fandom like what it was in 2007-2020 to this. I AM SORRY.

[@UsefulEngine11]

This video randomly popped into my feed so I might as well say something. Like everyone else when I first saw his channel he made innocent Wooden Railway videos he basically changed the game in terms of sets by making custom ones based on episodes. I feel like his downfall was when he asked someone to start a podcast with him and wanting a second chance at that I took him up on his offer and we made 2 to 3 episodes roughly. And one of them happened to be on magic railroad which sent him down this entire rabbit hole. Now I'll admit I did try to defend him once because I didn't think he was that down of a bad guy. But after seeing him fueling the fire with all these hatred videos and not having done anything barely TWR related in months. I feel like my only option is to distance myself from him as it's this disappointing how far he's fallen in terms doing KZbin mainly on Thomas. PS sorry for making this paragraphs/ a rant but I had to get this off my chest.

[@bacanpancakesproductions6038]

Instead of “James learns a lesson” it should be renamed to “sodor productions learns a lesson”

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I hope Sodor Productions redeems himself soon. I unsubscribed from him because I couldn’t handle the drama. 🎭

[@captainbaxter723]

He ain't going through a redemption arc. In fact, I think you need to go through an arc. Find better stuff to waste your time on. As much drama and toxicity there is in the fandom, there's also a bunch of cool stuff like the Trainz videos (no, not those motherfrickers filmed on android) There's also the rewrites by Steam Powered Cyborg and who not.

[@punchyfilms]

Finally, thank you for speaking out on this! More people need to hear about this, I'm glad I'm not the only one saddened by this. I brought it up to a friend once, and we both agreed he was just being childish and just contradicting himself. I was there from the start of his channel, and watching him fall off like this makes me sad because he was inspiring to me.

[@muni_Thomas_boi]

What happened to the days where the Thomas fandom would recreate a episode in the same style of the show that they love people in the fandom who are essentially strangers to each other meeting up and recreating the best recreation of a Thomas episode there is

[@HenryFan1911]

The days that need to come back.

[@joshuaW5621]

Ironically tugs why he said on one video.

[@captainbaxter723]

They're still out there, just hidden under the rubble of stuff like THIS

[@CTGLite_Studios]

I would describe him in 9 words “Disgraceful” said Gordon “Disgusting” putted James “Despicable” finished Henry

[@TheDee87]

That's not enough

[@buzzytrombone4353]

I had a go at a few of his friends who were defending his actions in the comment section of FairlyOddEngine’s first video on him by making outrageous assumptions about their parents’ love lives and their genetic makeup and stuff to get them off of their high horses, and what really pissed me off the most about them is how they attempted to shut down the people who have been bullied by him by pointing out their sexualities and justifying his actions based on that and other aspects of their personalities.

[@dylanlyles9453]

IKR! SodorProductions has gone too far! He thinks stuff involving Dinosaur bones and pirate treasure isn't realistic for Thomas even though he simps over a Warship diesel with a semi-sentient claw on its roof! And he enjoys Magic Railroad but said awful stuff about Britt Allcroft making it! He's such a hypocrite! He even hid my comments about me pointing out that P.T. Boomer is NOT a useless villain, but does he listen? NO! And he still won't!

[@joshuaW5621]

Well P.T. Boomer did make the engines unnecessary so it was probably for the best that he was cut. And as for TATMR not being realistic, neither is Henry’s Forest and yet that’s one of the most beloved episodes of the show, and I’m sure Awdry would hate season 5, which many fans say is the best season. Also what exactly did he say about Britt Allcroft?

[@dylanlyles9453]

@@joshuaW5621 I told you many f*cking times! He said "Fuck Britt Allcroft!" He gives Lily more motivation to go with Junior! His goal to destroy Lady has nothing to do with magic! And the dialogue made no sense without him! An old man wanting to destroy a steam engine half made out of fucking GOLD is more realistic than a Warship diesel with a claw that breaks the loading gauge! I'm so pissed at people not appreciating Boomer! If anything, he should have been included as the FIRST HUMAN VILLAIN in the Thomas universe! If you don't appreciate him as the real villain, then you're just like Boomer!

[@dylanlyles9453]

@@joshuaW5621 I told you many f*cking times! He said "Fuck Britt Allcroft!" He gives Lily more motivation to go with Junior! His goal to destroy Lady has nothing to do with magic! And the dialogue made no sense without him! An old man wanting to destroy a steam engine half made out of fucking GOLD is more realistic than a Warship diesel with a claw that breaks the loading gauge! I'm so pissed at people not appreciating Boomer! If anything, he should have been included as the FIRST HUMAN VILLAIN in the Thomas universe! If you don't appreciate him as the real villain, then you're just like Boomer!

[@Imaranga176]

Totally agree more, I thought social media was a place to share ur opinions, not judge other people’s opinion

[@anthonyfisher-7090]

It shows how little thought out his points are. Lets take "Emily and replace her with Edward" Edward's Adventure Edward learns to ask nicely whilst collecting timber to repair Farmer McColl's barn roof after a big storm damages it. Thomas, Edward and the snow plough Thomas ignores Edward's advice to put on his snowplough and as a result, ends up getting into trouble in the snow. Edward's new route Edward is scared of a monster in Black Loch but finds out that the monster turns out to be a family of seals. Halloween Edward accidentally scares himself as well as Thomas, 'Arry and Bert at the smelter's yard on Halloween night. Edward knows best Edward pretends to be a king after delivering visitors to the Ruined Castle as an intention to help Percy, but this leads to causing confusion and delay It goes on Edward and the special coaches. Edward's rubbish. Jumping into the Brenner era. Edward saves the world, Best Engine ever, Edward in the middle. None of it works with Edward.

[@chazzywaz]

The titles just feel so.. wrong.

[@joshuaW5621]

He was only talking about season 7 when he said that. Plus the Unlucky Tug said it too.

[@trevortyrrell175]

Sodor Productions should have stuck with Wooden Railway videos, it doesn't help that he was doing all this solely to piss off people and comes off as bigioted.

[@punchyfilms]

I know.. :(

[@mikawaterman3770]

Situations like this is why I tend not to share my views because I cba to deal with any backlash I get for my opinion. As a fandom we should be accepting of others opinions I mean this fandom is slowly turning out like the mha one, even non anime fans are probably aware of how toxic that fandom is

[@TankEngineMedia]

That’s what worries me, I’m hoping we don’t go to that

[@supermariof0521]

I never heard of this user, but he kinda reminds me of how I was a decade ago. Now I never outright attacked anyone, but I did get uppity when I felt people were having takes I thought was unfair, and its honestly heartbreaking that while I've MASSIVELY improved, made ammends with those I would sometimes quarrel with and have learned to better communicate with others and have more civil discussions and debates, others younger than I am, haven't learned. So its like I'm looking into a mirror of my past self and not being able to smack the entitlement outta that younger self.

[@HenryFan1911]

Nobody’s perfect mate, it’s fine to make mistakes as long as you change.

[@supermariof0521]

@@HenryFan1911 Yeah. Its just that for me, when I think back to how I was, I am filled with both anxiety and depression, even if I've made ammends with others.

[@NemesisHero123]

It's fans like sodorproductions a bad name in the fandom. When I watched his video about how he'd fix Thomas, I agreed with "most" of what he had to say, but only to an extent. And after watching most of his videos, I then got a taste of what he's actually like, and it makes me sad... As someone who has experienced so much within the fandom for the last 20 years, I don't think I've ever met anyone as angry, cocky and self-centered in my life. The minority comment was a real shock to me, which goes to show where this kid stands. He gets angry when someone says something that disagrees with him, and pretty much attacks them. There was a reason why I left the fandom for a short period, only to comeback. And now I'm reconsidering... such a shame this is what the fandom is today. :(

[@HenryFan1911]

@@NemesisHero123 Agree with all of what you just said, people like him with this “my word is gospel” mentality make me want to leave the fandom.

[@southerncoastproductions7587]

leave and dont come back we don't need or want u

[@krystalmills1622]

Sodor productions needs to stop bash other people's options, any way is there a way to make thomas Fandom stop being toxic

[@HenryFan1911]

All we can do is to just ignore petty community drama, spread the word, and show the behavior we want to see in this community.

[@WWE_trainsandmore]

I also agree 100% that TATMR is the best Thomas movie but depending on what other people say, ill understand there pov on it

[@mikeyhasfuntoo9164]

The thing that annoys me about him is that he said things that aren’t even true and are just lies, he said that the reason we all love Sodor’s legend of the lost treasure is because some big KZbinrs like it. Bro, are you forgetting the epic final chase, the epic score, the epic callbacks. And then he says we all act like the movies are absolutely flawless, and he admits the faults TATMR, but then, he just deletes all the negative comments. Yeah, sure your admitting the faults.

[@HenryFan1911]

@mikeyhasfuntoo9164 He’s a massive hypocrite. It’s honestly sad

[@toby.fan9198]

4:35 if he’s making a claim like that, then he clearly hasn’t seen Season 8 Emily.

[@HenryFan1911]

@toby.fan9198 I presume he was only referring to Emily’s Season 7 appearances

[@ItsCarlos563]

Apperently, he said that he makes clickbait/ragebait videos for the sake of money. I 100% agree that the TTTE fandom needs to be more respectful to other people's opinions, which can be said for other fandoms such as Disney, Pixar, DreamWorks, etc.

[@HenryFan1911]

That explains a lot. We are making him money by not calling him out on his BS.

[@TobyOliverHenryFan]

Yeah, I agree. The lad is quite too smug for his own good. But he has some points. Mostly that Thomas must be free of anything political. ANYTHING. I think that is one of the reasons why this fandom has fallen off recently. Also, TATMR isn't good. Get that magic rubbish out of there! Diesel 10 was the only good thing out of it! And Splodge.

[@HenryFan1911]

It’s fine if he likes TATMR, as long as he doesn’t expect everyone to.

[@FlyingMontyExpress]

I'm surprised big Thomas KZbinrs like unlucky tug haven't joined in on the hating on him

[@HenryFan1911]

I guess maybe because Tug doesn't care about community drama anymore.

[@FlashCameraStudio-d7d]

Believe me Henry i'm asking myself the same question this community has so much to share so much passion and creativity i will hold hope i can return to the community is a place of unity, passion, creativity accepting a safe space for those of same interests. good god what's happened to this fandom?!. Let the glory days of the fandom return.

[@HenryFan1911]

@@FlashCameraStudio-d7d Couldn’t have said it better.

[@jules_dose_things]

i know thisisint just you but,people need to stop saying fandom is trash or bad when its only 5 or so guys out of the 1000s of fans that are a problem

[@MikeNicholsonThomas]

At this point, he's just digging his own grave as far as I'm concerned.

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

Look. When he released his first video about fixing Thomas, I just felt like saying that the problem with Thomas Nowadays was the Marketing. Because if I’m honest, the Marketing and Merch being poor in the Brenner Era is what led us to AEG. But then he just kept going on and on about the fans. I wanted to be polite and ask him to stop in a polite manner, but he probably deleted the comments by now. Do I enjoy AEG? Not fully, I do find things that I like but it’s mostly just meh or bad. But there will be someone who likes it, and we should respect that because it makes us Human. It makes us who we are. To those threatening others. What the heck? Why are you doing that? To Sodor Productions, please move on. People will disagree, that’s the way of life. And to everyone, please be a respectful person who accepts other people’s opinions, even if it’s something you disagree with. And this sentiment applies to fan content too (as long as it’s not disgraceful disgusting despicable behavior). Yes some people don’t like certain types of fan content, but others do and that’s ok.

[@StationFilms12345]

You're kind of forgetting to mention how this guy says that the fandom's standards had come to a low just because everyone likes 2022 TWR I actually commented on his video (specifically the one where he rents about why it's hard to be a Thomas KZbinr in his eyes) saying that I don't disagree (necessarily) and I could see people laughing at this in the future I still believe that he was wrong for saying those things Although he didn't really listen I don't think he even read that comment Also although I didn't see that video he did call these fans delusional I'm not sure what fans he's talking about but it could be you guys Yeah I also think he's too smug but I rather not pay attention to him

[@joshuaW5621]

Yeah and NTM how people are giving AEG a free pass just because it’s bringing back Duck, Donald and Douglas.

[@gojifan7976]

I really feel upset for being a fan of Thomas. This guy is just annoying. He expects too much from products

[@HenryFan1911]

Just ignore him man, don't feel bad for being a fan of Thomas

[@gojifan7976]

@@HenryFan1911 I'll try. Thanks for the advice

[@theoneandonlyJT16]

I still don't think it's that deep. Can we all just get along

[@CaptainUnikitty]

What I’m getting is he said a few offensive things and began talking about politics

[@rileywebster2008]

6:17 thats offensive to the 2 year old

[@AbbeyYard]

How is the 2 year old gonna be offended? They're not even old enough to _be_ offended!

[@Gregory_ferrandis]

@AbbeyYard R/wooosh

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

He removed the community posts all together 😂😂😂

[@HenryFan1911]

That is tragic.

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

@@HenryFan1911 that’s a understatement He is just pathetic is what he is . I mean I blocked the hate videos and him from my channel so he can’t come to my comments if he feels the need to insult me again for a false claim !

[@joshuaW5621]

He does it every week apparently.

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

@@joshuaW5621 really ! Dayumn

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

Don't worry about showing your face btw. You look and are pretty cool.^^ Also if I end up in a SodorProductions video I can only say: Thx. for the free publicity dummie.🤣

[@HenryFan1911]

I appreciate it, I still like showing my face with my shades on, it reminds me of Adam Sandler in 50 First Dates lol. I would love to be in a SodorProductions video too, the publicity gain. Thanks for watching, I hope you stick around for future videos.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

@@HenryFan1911 LOL! Also you got it right. Not liking the stuff is one thing, but going on a ligit rampage about crap and intentionally violating the worth of other people is a line you can't cross without consequences. Had he done it less offensive and say coherently and factually explained why for excample he has a problem with LGBTQ+, people may still hate it but hear him out or at the very least ignore him, but this here is just borderline extremism.

[@allenginesgofan101iambeing4]

I was unfortunately in one of his videos as someone "backing up" him... he completely twisted and trimmed my comment... it was very unfortunate, but it was on me, because the first half of my comment kinda looked like I was agreeing with him completely... Fairly (the guy he was attacking) is a great guy, I've spoken to him a ton of times, he's active in a server I'm active on every day, and I was disgusted by what he said about him. When I said I was on his side, it was only for the "allegations" about him being abilist and sexist for hating Emily and Marion.... turned out his hate for them was a bit deeper than what it seemed to be from the few i watched... Oh yeah, and the final part about being an AEG fan, I'm almost an adult, and I'll admit, people have sent me death threats over the show previously

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

Honestly … I am happy you chose the true side And on the second to last comment he cut out the top part of it where I said “not to offend or anything your a great person” . He cut that out where I specifically said I didn’t hold anything against him for it I just wanted him to trufully find a way out of it And now … he went and took that for people to laugh and insult me . Then the final comment name call me and then shame me … I will use the so called victim card here but I am a minor . Specifically 14 . And he is bullying me pubically online . Cyber bullying a child for having a friendly opinion … WOW I thought he couldn’t get any lower but HERE WE ARE what’s your thoughts allengines ?

[@joshuaW5621]

Oh dear, I’m so sorry you’ve been attacked for liking AEG.

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

@@joshuaW5621 we were all attached Joshua . For simply stating an opinion and or fact .

[@steamiesandiesels1232]

dang dude.. even he’s harassing you?

[@allenginesgofan101iambeing4]

Wasn't Sodor productions that attacked me for being a fan of the show, but at the end of the video, AEG hate is Brought up, and I've tragically gotten a ton of it myself, even down to suicide threats as I previously mentioned, but I'm happy myself, enjoying the show. It used to hurt me a lot when I was 14, but that was a couple years ago, and I'm old enough to realise that even when some fans are toxic, I can still have fun with the thing I love

[@westinbridges7321]

As I said on SodorProductions' video where he explained what was wrong with a lot of Thomas fans these days: "Seeing this beef between you and Fairly Odd Engine Creations makes me absolutely disgusted and revolted. Want to know why I choose not to be in the Thomas Fandom very much? YOU TWO are the reason why (among many other toxic TTTE Fandom members)! I believe that, as a Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends Fandom, this community is great, but both of you have made it the most unlikeable and dare I say borderline profane place on earth. Yes, everyone is free to express their opinions, but I believe that the #1 Golden Rule in this fandom is this: “If we disagree with each other, we do not turn it into a war zone.” And so far, BOTH OF YOU HAVEN’T EVEN FOLLOWED THE RULE AND ITS MAKING ME REALLY ANGRY! I’m trying to sound derogatory to anyone, but my tone in this comment feels completely justified! Seriously, what happened to the TTTE Community man.. I can’t not say ANYTHING anymore. You guys in this community are all talented individuals and I see it within you, but you’re just arguing like literal 2-year-olds over opinions that can easily have a conflict resolution, simple. How are YOU (yes, both you SodorProductions and Fairly Odd Engine Creations) even benefiting your fans and other members when you’re making a full-blown war out of a simple hot-take/opinion?!!?! This is just making an already sometimes toxic community EVEN WORSE and no one seems to follow even basic golden rules I see in this fandom. Seriously! If everyone decided to resolve their turmoils with each other within an instant, this community would be a safer, better, and happier place. DO BETTER THOMAS FANDOM. That’s all I’m asking." You managed to hit the nail on the coffin. I thank you for having this video pop up in my recommended feed. Also (if you do find this comment @fairlyoddenginecreations), you have gained my respect. I originally hated you (as seen in my above comment, because I saw both you and SodorProductions as toxic jerks), but after seeing you videos defending yourself, I now respect you. I know that you're not perfect, but the way you handled this conflict between you and someone who I fear may become @Thomas1Edward2Henry3's interpretation of 98462 is brilliant.

[@jacobjcb8883]

And Thomas isn't the only blue character who has a warzone fandom either, (Looks at a certain blue hedgehog)

[@SatyaArgapratama-xi7cc]

​@@jacobjcb8883aslo an Australian blue dog

[@westinbridges7321]

Also, if anyone's wondering as to why I compared this arrogant jerk to T1E2H3's interpretation of 98462, he's already started to display his arrogant and rude personality by justifying why Tragic Failroad is good and the only film with high steaks and bullying those who disagree with him. He also is a political jerk by trying to get politics into Thomas. I'm placing my bets that (if he continues down this rage-bait and click-bait rabbit hole of a KZbin channel he's made) he will eventually become more horrid (maybe even doxxing other TTTE KZbinrs) and eventually insane, murderous, and evil (perhaps to the point where authorities have to get involve and arrest him for breaching others and maybe even attempting attacks on KZbinrs who we unanimously agree with, like The Unlucky Tug, Thomas Theorist, and probably others whom I could mention but I'm not because I don't want to waste time with anyone.

[@TheChadEngine]

agreed, this is the downfall of Sodor Productions

[@ScarfNJam]

Not to mention he has the most generic ass username ever 😭🖐️ Like no offence to this guy but I tried not to include words like productions, studios, Sodor or Thomas.

[@HenryFan1911]

His username being generic is the least of the problems tbh.

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

Good to see your on the proper side here scarf And hello. . Plesures finding you here dawg !

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

I mean my name is just generic … but it is nothing Thomas related . Just straight up my name , the thing I love & that I am a fan of said thing That’s it . Not bashing you’re name scarf . It’s just cool yours is (I am percy bias😂 and love the meme of “I want a scarf” I think his name is just crappy . In general Means nothing and is all around boring and forgettable and has no funny joke to it like ours . Mine means what it is truthfully And yours is a meme made into name . And easy to say . Hence the nickname of scarf … 😊 Meanwhile … his comes up with 3 other people for being so god damm boring in design What’s your opinion scarf my buddy?

[@Carboi0528]

I see so many trackmaster channels that have the same channel name. “*insert character name* productions” with that character on their pfp, their name written on the bottom with a glowing ring around the character that’s also the same colour as them

[@Category4MajorHurricane2015]

i dont see anything wrong with generic names

[@josephmarrison4606]

I laugh at people like him. He thinks he is the best user in the fandom, yet he is the opposite of it. People like him are the reason why I refuse to be in any fandom, let alone the Thomas one.

[@worthybutter2004]

I remember a comment on one of his videos that said "We need more Thomas KZbinrs like you" or something like that. When reading that, i thought "What?! No we don't!"

[@joshuaW5621]

Well I kinda do think he has a point, not in the way you might be thinking though. I mean we need more people who are smart and don’t blindly defend AEG for bringing back Duck, Donald and Douglas and express their ideas about how they would handle the show.

[@HenryFan1911]

@@worthybutter2004 the fandom would go to hell if we had more like him.

[@gamerfan8445]

​@@joshuaW5621here the thing, we already do.

[@andreiemanueltudose2445]

Hm good point but to be honest i have to say this every time it's more like 50/50 here this fandon can be even worse than what he does and yeah he might have said things way to far and i can understand some might not like that but there is one problem with this you can just ignore his content at all or you say your opinion and if he doesn't like what you said just don't waste your time with this crap or simple block him it's really not that hard and that's it

[@Eerierstrap6271]

i have doubts that he’s not a true thomas fan and is just some random troll online that decided to mess with the ttte community because theres NO WAY that someone would ever say a character is bad because they have ADHD or make fun of other disabilities. And make a twitter post about someone not agreeing with him and calling them out. And to top it all off to claim some stuff is bad or good without ANY explanation or evidence to prove his point. Its clear bait im sorry.

[@joshuaW5621]

He wasn’t trying to make fun of ADHD, he seemed to just be explaining why he doesn’t like Marion, that’s all.

[@HenryFan1911]

@@joshuaW5621 there were better ways to say he dislikes Marion other than saying “she has ADHD”.

[@joshuaW5621]

@@HenryFan1911 tbf you’re not wrong about that.

[@joshuaW5621]

I don’t think Sodor Productions was trying to offend anyone with ADHD in that video, he just said he wasn’t a fan of Marion and thought she acted too much like someone with extreme ADHD. That would be like calling out MikeD57s for not liking Phillip because he acts like a kid with ADHD. From what I’ve heard he has nothing against people with ADHD, people were just taking that quote out of context. Anyways, I can can’t say I disagree with the rest of the stuff you said, but I wouldn’t say Sodor Productions is the bad guy either, cause it’s not like Fairly Odd Engine Creations is any better given he’s had a track record for reacting to others mentioning him according to what I read in the comments of HufflepuffBatboy’s recent post on Sodor Productions and given his response to my comment on his video, I don’t think he’s mature at all.

[@HenryFan1911]

@@joshuaW5621Fairly Odd Engine Creations just innocently said his opinion, and Sodor Productions made a whole video trashing him for no reason. What is this “track record” that you mention he has? I’m genuinely curious. It’s fine if Sodor Productions doesn’t like Marion, but did he really have to say she acts like she has ADHD? I understand how that would piss some people off.

[@joshuaW5621]

@@HenryFan1911 well tbf Fairly Odd Engine Creations’s response did come off as a bit rude.

[@fairlyoddenginecreations]

@@joshuaW5621 sorry for speaking my mind?

[@buzzytrombone4353]

@@joshuaW5621 You considered it to be rude because he was pointing out everything wrong with your friend, which your response was using the emotional part of your brain.

[@joshuaW5621]

@@buzzytrombone4353 he literally said “this has to be one of the worst Thomas takes I have ever seen” and didn’t elaborate on why he wasn’t a fan, which came across as opinion bashing.

[@Bottle30]

He actually changed the video titles in his videos.

[@femboy-gardevoir]

I stumbled across SodorProductions when I saw his video on characters Bachmann needs to make. If I knew that a few weeks later, he’d release an anti-woke video, I would’ve ignored the video.

[@TTTEFan84]

just wanna give a small update but SodorProductions has double downed on his nonsense in a new video

[@HenryFan1911]

@@TTTEFan84 I saw it and honestly I don’t know if I should even make a video about it. It’s genuinely awful. Saying “engines shouldn’t have disabilities” was just disrespectful. He has some good points like how politics shouldn’t be in Thomas, but they’re buried beneath his disrespectful comments

[@gamerfan8445]

​@@HenryFan1911also the fact he is a 100% a hypocrite

[@TTTEFan84]

​@@gamerfan8445 my point exactly

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

@@HenryFan1911make a video henry ! I want to see your reaction !

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

Ya right. Mia ain't that cool, but she and otheres can be rewritten. That's better tham slamming people for being different. You dislike her but accept me for liking her. WAY better than what he does. We should be one team again not fighting each other.

[@HenryFan1911]

Couldn't have been said better mate.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

@@HenryFan1911 Thx. mate.^^ Good that there are still people like NWR1991 who rather do good in the fandom, treats his fans like a family and even does what many never even considered doing. He takes the characters many call bad like Rebecca, takes out the good stuff like her optimism, carisma and nice compliments and uses it to complete rewrite her like in his fan episode 'The ugly Diesel'. You should really watch it when you can cuz he did an awsome job and seems to be a pretty cool dude overall. :)

[@Fan-of-stuff1]

sodor productions is the next bluepuff ball

[@HenryFan1911]

Out of the loop, what did blue puffball do?

[@ABellEngine]

​@@HenryFan1911 He once tried to make a "Thomas fandom rival" and compared the Thomas fandom and his fandom to Democrats and Republicans.

[@Fan-of-stuff1]

@@ABellEngine on god thats what sodor productions be doing rn making a ''right'' and ''left'' side

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

@@ABellEngineAnd he also did a video about a kid that was basically harassing the kid.

[@PerpIsPerp]

​@@HenryFan1911 He tried to make a republican rival to the Thomas community

[@Archiebugg]

I actually threw my phone across my bedroom when I was watching his video about why the other movies after tatmr are terrible like seriously they’re all not terrible (well maybe except MIR DOTD TGR and BWBA)

[@joshuaW5621]

You really can’t accept that he has his own opinion huh?

[@Archiebugg]

@ his opinion is bad ok I can’t respect it ok

[@joshuaW5621]

@@Archiebugg well he can still prefer TATMR all he wants.

[@WWE_trainsandmore]

3:21 fairly odd engines took this clip out of context to make sodor productions look bad. I have adhd and I find marrion annoying. And he isn't misogynistic

[@joshuaW5621]

Exactly. I have ADHD too and I’m not gonna get upset when someone mentions it in a negative manner. Imagine if we went after MikeD57s cause he said he hates how Phillip acts like a kid with terrible case of ADHD.

[@abbeyroadfan94-J.P]

I hope Sodor Productions learns a valuable lesson

[@HenryFan1911]

Me too.

[@TankEngineMedia]

Same man

[@Nic_2751]

It’s ok to say someone’s a lost cause and needs to be disposed of, I won’t judge.

[@Twinmill69227]

I already made a comment about him actually being grown up enough to actually show the people who disagree with instead people who **bleep** ride him

[@RoundhouseProductions]

He needs to put the fries in the bag😭😭😭

[@Steamboatproductions37]

I’m the superior S productions All jokes aside this guy is the definition of a freakin nerd.

[@jeremiahsisaias8677]

Not all Thomas KZbinrs suck. Some have done wrong things in the past and made up for them while some others can be bad apples when not many mysteriously disappear from the community until the truth is revealed of what their actions are.

[@HenryFan1911]

I know, part of why I said "all of us suck" in the video was my way of saying that all of us have been jerks in some way. We've all played a part. But that's not to say some Thomas KZbinrs haven't made up for their actions.

[@Ripoff_Productions]

agreed man, people in general need to stop being so angry and hateful

[@onetrackmind3558]

Don't say all of us suck. Not all are bad.

[@InactivePannier]

Everyone being assholes this fandom would be an understatement my early years when i was 13, people not accepting different opinions, Twitter. It's one thing to have done something controversial without knowing context being it but stating that you don't like people with ADHD just paints you in a bad image, he's already on thin enough ice as it is

[@joshuaW5621]

That isn’t what he said, again, people are taking his words out of context.

[@onetrackmind3558]

I came here to check out what's going on. All I can say is good luck with this.

[@Bootleg_Metalhog]

Honestly the only thing he does is rant about crap like about the rainbow stuff like all rainbow stuff doesn't mean its gay like gay also means happy

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

Okay I think that he wasn't justified but I think you guys are going too far in the other direction

[@joshuaW5621]

Yes they are, especially the ADHD comment about Marion. That would be like calling out MikeD57s for hating Phillip because he acts like a kid with extreme ADHD.

[@jacobjcb8883]

To be fair, Mike was more considerate when discussing Phillip, even if there are better ways to describe these kinds of characters

[@andrewmcgirt8338]

Never interested in his content.

[@TheOldScrapIron]

I don’t want to take any sides, and I try not to get involved too much in drama like this, but I will say that from the outside perspective it appears both sides are not entirely right or wrong here. Some of his takes are insensitive and are sometimes blatant attacks, but at the same time some of the offended responses to some of the things he says appear to be based in misinterpretation. For example, just because he doesn’t like a character who happens to be female doesn’t mean he’s a misogynist. That just means he doesn’t like a fictional character. And even if I disagree with him, his take on Emily is understandable too. She didn’t feel very unique in season 7. Based on his recent videos, I think SodorProductions was wise in that he just moved on from this whole thing. I doubt he wants to be in hot water with people for reasons he doesn’t agree with, but people are still posting negative things about him.

[@joshuaW5621]

You my friend are one of the few people here who is speaking facts.

[@Britishgrendier]

As a ttte fan you speaking facts

[@HenryFan1911]

Thanks for checking out the channel, hope you enjoyed and stick around for more.

[@ColinIsColin_Okay]

wow he is so nice! (when he is not)

[@TankEngineMedia]

Before the whole drama of him I watched his wooden railway videos which were harmless enough, but when he got to his discussions and made videos calling out those who are jaunt stating their opinion that’s where I lost it with some of his opinions but the way he said it sounded so condescending and like he knows everything which if annoying. After watching his hit era video of squeak rattle and roll (that one was actually pretty decent) I stopped watching his videos after that. Sodor Productions discussion videos make me question what the hell is going on with the Thomas fandom, I know it has its lows but this has to be the lowest you can get by making fun of a character that has ADHD fictional or not. It’s very important that we learn to respect other’s opinions and not being mean about it, but judging by the route Sodor Productions is going I think it might be too late (I do want to have a tiny bit of hope that he somehow try to rectify his mistakes but I’m not to sure).

[@joshuaW5621]

He wasn’t making fun of ADHD, he just said he didn’t like Marion and thought she was acting too much like someone with extreme ADHD. This would be like hating MikeD57s just because he hates Phillip for acting like a kid with ADHD.

[@TankEngineMedia]

@ ohhh, thanks for clearing that up

[@zacharykim436]

He has caused Confusion and Delay!!!

[@iwinosaiyahen7342]

Do you agree with Sodor production's opinion on the new wooden railway system

[@Microsave2]

Bro it's a show about trains with faces calm down bruh

[@joshuaW5621]

Try telling that to whoever freaks out about the show being unrealistic after season 7.

[@captainbaxter723]

I sent a comment on 2 of his videos describing the Snonce Crongldker

[@PRODIGAMES1234]

hello im ur 800th subscriber! your welcome!

[@HenryFan1911]

@PRODIGAMES1234 greatly appreciated man

[@WWE_trainsandmore]

I dont think his videos are childish or obnoxious, I like his content and he has valid opinions. Just because people nowadays cant handle someone sharing an opinion that isnt the same as theres doesn't mean that he should stop sharing an opinion

[@Trainman04-n1y]

He needs to improve himself. I am talking about Soodor Productions.

[@Flakey05]

I agree

[@aaronprewitt344]

I couldn’t agree more.

[@Nicecustomer]

This entire thing was a misunderstanding with so productions words because people in the Thomas community was a panic attention. He pacifically said how Mattel should fix Thomas that Mattel would probably never do this and even showed it in his next video but people were too stubborn to admit that they were wrong and on top of since showed opinions in the video of what they think he should do plus that they thought he’s a bad person for his opinions, which is absolute craziness i’ve talked to this man on stream before. He is a very nice person and you’re giving him hate for no apparent reason. van too stubborn to say you were wrong

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

I don’t know why your praising him in the comments of a video what says negative things on him … Sorry be be like this but we don’t really need your comment here saying things we know are complete fake . Why support a person who insults others and anyone who disagrees with him get hated or bullied by there supposed favourite KZbinr … I think he is a complete ass whole But that’s just MY opinion and you don’t need to agree .

[@buzzytrombone4353]

Stop typing horse shit and go to your social skills class.

[@Chugs1]

Bruv just let the guy be why do yall care sm if you dont like him jesus christ let fam be 😭

[@gamerfan8445]

Simple he can cause damage to the Fandom, look at star wars, or star trek for example.

[@Chugs1]

@ Ok but whats one guy gunna do. You can’t just change the way he is like bro

[@ShunterStudios]

⁠@@Chugs1yes. Even though he’s caused damage we can’t change people. Thats just how some people are. So I agree with you there man.

[@fairlyoddenginecreations]

good video!

[@HenryFan1911]

I'm glad you watched this, thanks for tuning in! I need to watch more of your videos. I'm sorry about SodorProductions being an a**hat

[@HenryFan1911]

@@fairlyoddenginecreations Update: He made a new video that is actually rock bottom.

[@fairlyoddenginecreations]

@@HenryFan1911 yeah i'm not touching that thing again

[@BuddyTheWolfYT]

Yall are proving him right

[@HenryFan1911]

@@BuddyTheWolfYT how? I’m just saying my opinion like he is

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

No we’re proving he is a complete ass of a human

[@buzzytrombone4353]

You using the word “Yall” in a sentence to make it look like that you’re John Wayne’s great grandson who screams “Yeehaw!!” while doing horse riding, isn’t helping your case, nor is it making you look smart.

[@BuddyTheWolfYT]

@@buzzytrombone4353 I'm from the southern usa

[@buzzytrombone4353]

@@BuddyTheWolfYT You still ride horses there regardless.

[@eeveeking3168]

Great points man

[@HenryFan1911]

Thanks for watching, I’m glad you agree.

[@eeveeking3168]

@HenryFan1911 the first video I ever watched of his was the Mattel video which he made some good points on but after that the dude has been a rapid decline in well good points if u catch my drift

[@Tobytramproductions]

"She is to juch adhd"tf does that mean🙏🙏💀💀💀😞😞😞

[@joshuaW5621]

Remember when MikeD57s said Phillip acts like a kid with a terrible case of ADHD? Well I don’t think this is any different.

[@Tobytramproductions]

Phillip is annoying marion is overly excited different

[@Imaranga176]

@Tobytramproductions exactly

[@joshuaW5621]

@Tobytramproductions that could still be annoying to some people.

[@Tobytramproductions]

Ya some people joshua not ttte fans, there's a big difference between annoying and excited

[@TaigaSpringtrap]

Nice video, dude!

[@HenryFan1911]

@@TaigaSpringtrap thanks man, I hope you stick around for the future of the channel

[@ringo-the-bozo]

honestly i dont want to sound rude but SODORPRODUCTIONS SMELLS 🗣 (also the only thing he says in his all engines go video is that everything should be like the 90s again and just whines that thomas isn't what it was before)

[@joshuaW5621]

Totally out of context. Those crybabies were just mad that he suggested doing a proper reboot of Thomas.

[@ringo-the-bozo]

@@joshuaW5621 okay one your here? and two um not really

[@joshuaW5621]

@@ringo-the-bozo I’m just saying he’s allowed have different idea for what the Thomas franchise should be in the future. What’s wrong with wanting to honour Thomas’s legacy and respect it’s source material?

[@ringo-the-bozo]

@@joshuaW5621 yeah but just saying ''everything SHOULD be like the 90s again'' (he litreally said this btw) isnt really giving a idea for what thomas should be in the future, really he's just being a bit of a manchild

[@joshuaW5621]

@@ringo-the-bozo okay I can see how that line may come across as whiny, but other than that he has some good ideas on how the show and merchandise could be handled.

[@inspectorjohnnywolfergad4149]

I agree with you @HenryNWR1911 honestly.....

[@inspectorjohnnywolfergad4149]

@SodorProductions if you're also watching this reply I already said and agreed to him, feel free to criticize me, and call me a loser as well just for agreeing with him, cuz seriously you made me lose all my trust in you and you made me rethink it all regretfully, after all of this honestly.

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKGkf5mgor5mZ7csi=wYeOlJmxILXBEvb1 Living up to this

[@HenryFan1911]

You and SodorProductions when someone has a different opinion than you: m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpjHmp6lgcejnM0&pp=2AECkAIB

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

@HenryFan1911 I'm fine with other people having different opinions I just don't like that you're attacking him as a person

[@HenryFan1911]

@ I’m not attacking him as a person, I’m just saying my honest opinion that he has this very “my word is gospel” attitude that pisses people off.

[@WeAreTheEggmen22]

@HenryFan1911 I understood the push back against him at first but now it's just absolutely insane which is why I made the parody video in the first place I was on your side you know

[@HenryFan1911]

@ I made one video on SodorProductions and left, he’s continuing to make videos about the fandom, I don’t understand how I’m living up to that parody video