My Opinion on College Football 25 Has Changed...

[@SOFTDRINKTV]

Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code SOFTDRINK for $20 off your first purchase. What time is it? Gametime. Terms apply.

[@rollinjay8214]

College Bowl Review coming? Great sequel to Legend Bowl

[@w4tt322]

The game is fun. Gears of war the entire series is a buggy mess but gets great reviews because everything else is good. I would give it a 7/10.

[@smokieinthepot489]

I'm having a better time playing NCAA 2004 dynasty than the time I played the new one, game blows 3/10 have better expectations.

[@MegaBearsFan]

CFB25 doesn't need to add a soundtrack, it just needs to rotate through the school fight songs, which are all already in the game. That would alleviate a lot of the repetitiveness of the menu music situation. You've got 130+ school fight songs in the game! Use them!!!

[@InspireRise300]

Facts, please don't add a soundtrack. If you want a soundtrack, turn on your Spotify.

[@kelvinr2507]

Yeah, exactly what they used to do in the old PS2 days.

[@Mget41]

I honestly just realized this last week I was like wait a minute where are the fight song

[@themultitapper]

This

[@brianbadonde9251]

Yeah but why would you be playing Alabama's fight song while you're playing as Auburn for example? That doesn't make sense. They can add music just make it all instrumental or choose indie songs or something. It doesn't have to be a top 100 Playlist of radio songs

[@ervinghenderson4780]

The truth is Madden has been so bad that we gave CF25 a pass just for being a competent game. EA put cheese on a shit burger and wanted us to be excited about the cheese.

[@JD-fl4dz]

Best comment

[@LenGott8345]

You get it, playa. EA literally beat folks down for YEARS with a shitty pro football game, that they KNEW all they had to do was put together a decent college game and pray folks were so desperate to have a new college game... They wouldn't care that this thing is as shallow as a kiddie pool for $70 plus after tax. People remain the biggest reason these companies won't raise their game any. Cause they keep seeing shit fly off the shelves as is, so why bother? Shitburgers all around!!! (With CHEESE.)

[@Violator225]

They didn’t even put cheese on a sht burger they just changed the packaging and gave us the same shitty burger 😂

[@ts1265]

To be fair 90% of comments were ALREADY PRE ORDERED after a 30 sec trailer. EA always gonna EA

[@wittybanter96]

@@Violator225 Skip Bayless take

[@ST0NE_206]

0:14 someone calling you a sellout for enjoying a game for once is insane ☠️

[@Powerhouse1]

That's the internet nowadays. You're either classified as a hater or a fanboy.

[@glow_jedi]

i highly agree cause im just like him #bringbacknfl2k

[@knephsabir3245]

Lmao! Yeah it is.

[@modernsaints7881]

Lmao ur shallow as fuck

[@edwardjones1482]

@@Powerhouse1 or a shill don’t forget that , you can’t enjoy things that everyone else’s hates or else you get ganged up on , you will get ganged up on if you hate something that everybody else likes or you will just get call fanboy shill or get asked if your getting paid by that company if you like it

[@pumpofwallstreet]

The blocking logic in this game is horrendous.

[@NCYungin]

FACTS

[@Whoyouwishyouwere]

Told you guys not to buy it 😅

[@hehehehaworgrrr1513]

@@Whoyouwishyouwerewell luckily nobody has to listen to you because while so many flaws are in the game, i still have fun with it

[@Whoyouwishyouwere]

@@hehehehaworgrrr1513 you just did lol

[@Whoyouwishyouwere]

@@hehehehaworgrrr1513 stay mad about your sped purchase and gettin schooled by people who actually understand football like me.

[@Kings0424]

A 6.5 is still not bad. Man I have been playing College Football 25 non-stop since it released and I mostly have been playing Dynasty Mode

[@thesuperpimpplaya1]

Same like the amount of hours I have is criminal lol 😂

[@mortystraphouse5077]

if they made it for PC i would have done the same

[@Sora-se2vr]

Facts I’m up to 250 hours and I exclusively play offline dynasty

[@Only_One_Veezy]

@@thesuperpimpplaya1Bro I’m at 200+ and I’m ashamed 😭🤣

[@Kings0424]

@Chris-rt5qu To be honest, I never really played RTG

[@TheAlmightyScorpio]

They need to fix Road to Glory. Playing as an QB is the worst. I had a season where the opponent defense only gave up FIVE PENALTIES THE WHOLE SEASON! Can’t turn up the penalties, so no roughing the passer, late hits, pass interference. The blocking is horrible. The defense makes UNBELIEVABLE PLAYS. Doesn’t matter who you play, you would think ever defense is Alabama. You can beat a DB, MLB, or whoever, and somehow, someway when you throw it to an open receiver, the opponent will get a boost of speed outta nowhere and intercept your pass. And fix the simulation when you’re not playing. No way the CPU should score in 5 seconds after giving them the ball and you don’t see any plays

[@huntercheney98]

But you can…. turn up the penalties..

[@Shuriken1196]

The only way to have fun on high difficulties at qb is to adjust the sliders. Nothing too crazy though. I turned up my ol pass blocking and still got sacked 5 times a game. It’s broken

[@swapsplat]

I can't get my O-Line to pass block to save me life... my QB is getting killed.

[@guaranagaucho3071]

Missing PAT and short FGs too. It’s insane.

[@colins1619]

Facts lol and why can’t we play as a safety of defensive end or rolb. Like literally insane to me

[@oreokingedward9875]

Not being able to edit players is what killed game for me 0 roster customization is crazy even in dynasty when you sim a few years down the line and all the real life players are gone you cant edit players at all number or attributes

[@PhillyDove]

Same

[@JammerAma]

I get it but honestly not being able to edit attributes has made the game incredibly immersive for me. It's harder like the ps2 era NCAA games. But not being able to edit basic information like numbers and names and stuff is super lame. No custom recruits is stupid too

[@MrJones-el9yd]

@@JammerAmayou can edit names it’s just numbers and attributes plus no custom recruits, heard the numbers might be editable next update

[@codycordeiro9772]

Player attribute ratings I don’t mind so much, but the names and at minimum not being able to change the numbers is so annoying. I don’t want my star DE wearing 14 or QB wearing 22. It’s just dumb to me. It would be great if they could do an update to fix this. It would instantly make the game better.

[@mrpotential11]

You my friend just saved me $70. Thank you

[@OnionReturns]

I would’ve mentioned pass blocking as a major gripe. And before anyone brings up “IDing the Mike” or “sliding my pass protection” that is not what I’m referring to. The amount of times I’ve had offensive lineman act like literal traffic cones NOT EVEN INTERACTING with pass rushers makes me want to stop playing. For reference, I play on Heisman, and no, sliders have not made a difference.

[@braidenfriday2389]

idk if ea understands what lineman do , i played in right tackle college (jv backup dawg) n i find myself enraged at wtf i see on my screen

[@Ballet4Hooligans]

@@braidenfriday2389 🤣

[@JMAC____]

The honeymoon period is over and people’s opinions has changed not surprised

[@NemoRackkz]

The game is still good... I bet you don't play the game

[@xananadu]

Yes I think so too. I still really enjoy playing it, but my opinion has definitely changed from the hype I had getting it 3 days early (I never do that)

[@CheffSteph]

Every game has issues. There are some flaws that can't be overlooked especially with the game modes but all in all, I feel like I got my money's worth, its a fun game.

[@youreverydayhellknight4257]

@@xananadu I still enjoy this game

[@JDLogan409]

Honey moon phase is gone but I still enjoy playing Sunday with the guys other than that I’m on other games 😂

[@theohadz7118]

After the first 2 weeks cracks started to show for me. Way better than madden but sadly I don't believe we'll ever get another sports game with the love and care the 2000's had.

[@zyeirsilas7044]

So trueeee man

[@gunner_mike]

I've played 400 hours and i love it lol dynasty could be better for sure.

[@theohadz7118]

@gunner_mike don't get it twisted. I enjoy it still but it could be a lot better. It doesn't have much charm. Need different commentary, I'll score a td to win with no time left and they sound like they are bored. You know what I mean?

[@gunner_mike]

@@theohadz7118 Chris Fowler is awful. No energy. Reece Davis is goated.

[@gunner_mike]

@@theohadz7118 they need a news feed, coach interactions (interviews) and more pageantry. Some rival games dont eve n fee llike it

[@xman777b]

hopefully the deluge of hateful comments, following your original review, didn't influence your revised outlook. Long time viewers like myself, know you didn't "sell-out". Take care.

[@SOFTDRINKTV]

I give reasons for why I changed my score in this video, and none of those reasons are because of that.

[@LngLivMamba17]

Softdrink influences the people he’s not influenced by the people lol

[@LngLivMamba17]

I stopped buyin madden in 2021 and haven’t bought one since because Softdrinktv verbalized what I had been feelin for a few years prior and 2k is turning into the same thing because when there is no competitior there is no need for improvement 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@Robo311Star]

I def got disrespectful over you Pov. I'm sorry. I came back and heard you out. I realized why you gave them a pass on NCAA25. I just hate EA Sports for their trash games. I still think NCAA25 sux, but I was wrong for being disrespectful. Once again, I'm SORRY.

[@SuperMacik1]

@@Robo311Star Respect

[@SoggyMann]

I really dont want a CBF 26. If CFB wants to stay a good franchise, they should stay away from maddens' mistakes. Having a new game every year is one of those mistakes. It's not necessary for CBF.

[@louiedoestuf]

Such a W comment

[@wittybanter96]

I think a 6.5 is totally fair. I'm still really enjoying it

[@buggyyuji851]

Same

[@NickJR528]

​@gamewhiz23 Yeah, but there's a difference between a high school grading score than a video game rating score. While 5/10 in school is an F. A 5/10 for a game's score is considered average with 4 being below average and 6 is above average but some people don't seem to understand that

[@JohnDaDong93]

@gamewhiz23good thing this isn’t an academic scale.

[@RVered]

@@JohnDaDong93 Either a 55 or a 60 is a passing grade in higher education

[@Hingusbingus4]

​@@NickJR528if you're a retard lol I hope you like Clint oldenburgs dick

[@ericfallabel9201]

I love CFB25, but two things are driving me crazy: -wear and tear on my running backs is ridiculous. They become ineffective by halftime, yet the game rarely auto-subs-in the backup (and usually only for a single play when it does) -individual offensive linemen are often completely insane, failing to block anyone at all in the run game, and sometimes running far down the field past a bunch of defenders. I can't tell whether this is a bug or if they're just suffering from mental errors due to low AWR

[@thekang79]

Personally, I wish the coaches were as customizable as they were in NCAA 14. I hope that this game was mostly foundational and the future games innovate and improve.

[@actualnotanewbie]

The game treats coaches poorly too. They're not even in ANY presentation cut scenes, like they are in Madden. Seeing to coach pacing on the sidelines during stressful moments in NCAA 14 was always a nice touch.

[@Scheboygan8767]

When has ea and madden gone forward in the last 10 years genuinely, genuinely am asking. I hate when people use this excuse for them, they’ve had 10 years and an exact template to follow for success. They went backwards on features from the 2014 game !!!! Lousy excuse, road to glory in 2014 had a skip play button so if you were a qb you could sim all the running plays and not watch your qb hand it off to a cpu rb you don’t control. It’s simple shit like that, they just do not care. The blocking, no customization, cheese plays, horrible ranking system in dynasty, same exact cut scene after every single win with the guys lining up. This game sucks and ea usually goes backwards not forwards from what we’ve seen in the last 10 years from them

[@jjaakk7214]

Not being able to go to a player page from the awards screens drives me insane. And remember when you could look up the team schedule/leaders/history page from the Rankings or Standings menu?

[@gass_5604]

for the first game in 11 years it’s a good start I just hope they build upon it

[@MCG55SS]

i would love for that BUT seeing how its EA i completely doubt they will. I mean look at Madden, as long as they are the sole company making the game they will put as little effort and money into the game as possible and just sell reskins for years. Without any real competition they will just let the game sell because you can;'t get it anywhere else.

[@MichaelJordansBurnerAccount]

It’s ea they wont

[@mortystraphouse5077]

EA?

[@TheJalinmyles]

My feelings exactly no matter how naive it sounds

[@terrencetrent2330]

The next one will be no different

[@Ra_in_]

This game has SO much potential, the lack of physics, abundance of glitches and visual bugs definitely make this review justified. Like you said still great fun, I hope we get some updates soon.

[@Jackeroffer09]

One thing that’s small but I liked a lot about the older college football games was the trophy room that would have all conference championship trophies and rivalry games that have trophies with them

[@jraybay]

Yeah you don't really notice how much those little things add up until their gone. This game feels a lot more empty compared to the old as a result

[@Jackeroffer09]

@@jraybay 100 percent also wish they add the feature to have ESPN classics but it could be ncaa classics or something else

[@RMax-lz4ry]

EA could add that with an update, we’ll have to see.

[@Jackeroffer09]

@@RMax-lz4ry man I hope so

[@zyeirsilas7044]

Facts

[@identify952]

Depth is my biggest complaint in dynasty. I love recruiting but I want to have the responsibility upgrade stadium and athletic facilities and manage player’s personalities and off field issues

[@RegularFlyGuy]

This, so much. We've rebuilt Tulane and after 3 championships it feels weird to have this small of a stadium. We should be able to meet certain requirements to select and ''build'' a newer, bigger stadium.

[@gucciflockajuice]

@@RegularFlyGuy it's a shame it comes to this but you could technically upgrade your school using team builder but idk if that works on an established dynasty.

[@carltonbanks5470]

Athletic facilities do "improve" after you start winning nattys to help with recruiting. But no bigger stadium even though they made one up for Hawaii.

[@Syncronym]

I’m pretty happy they’ve updated a few stadiums since release. IMO it’s fun but 11, 13, 14 plus any of the PS2 generation releases are much deeper. Your revised score seems very fair.

[@VX1_l]

You are on point

[@DuecePiece]

I'm going to politefully disagree. I played an entire 60 year Dynasty in 11 against a good buddy of mine, and honestly to me this feels much more realistic gameplay wise. I have to think about the plays I run in 24 and be methodical, whereas in 11 I could cheese plays all the way down the field no matter what defensive coverage because it felt so arcade-like. The new game feels phoned in some, especially with things like the commentary, but overall I don't think it's bad like most Madden players make it out to be. Now if 2K could make a CFB game they could really bring the heat and make EA sweat! 🔥🤘

[@BandoLonnie]

Am I the only person who felt like the early release played better than the global release? It seemed to be so much smoother (I’ve played thru 5 seasons of dynasty)

[@SOFTDRINKTV]

I agree. They tweaked gameplay a bit. It's still fun but things like onside kicks were nerfed hard, and player movement was even more fluid before

[@UnbeatableJacob]

Thought you were a little high the first time, and probably a touch low this time lol. I think you hit the nail on the head with “this is as good as gameplay can be with the frostbite engine” and I’d weight gameplay more important compared to modes, presentation and menus.

[@mr.ohiostate2544]

I really agree with this. Gameplay is high

[@alesolren]

I’d give it a 7 at minimum.

[@Thetallguy_zz]

5.5 it’s an empty shell of a game that’s enjoyable because we’ve been starved

[@frosty8183]

I see you followed in Ty’s footsteps

[@RomeGoLARGE]

Right it deserves a 7.

[@RunN1st9]

This is the only game that has brought my 16-year old son over to enjoy a sports videogame. He is primarily a 1st person shooter gamer but now he plays College Football non-stop! I would still highly recommend it to people!

[@Hookem221]

This is the biggest and ONLY win NCAA 25 has going for it. These types of stories. Otherwise, NCAA 14 is still better

[@youmadbrojr4552]

I am 20 I played with my dad a lot in this game for the 2 and half weeks he was alive to

[@joshdaboss2365]

@@youmadbrojr4552rip to your dad 🙏🏾

[@AlexNFLoffical]

@@youmadbrojr4552sorry

[@BordeauxYT]

I think it’s a real shame the game didn’t launch in its current state, but I’d rate it an 8 I think nostalgia is really blocking how people view CFB 25, because almost everything about it is a step up from NCAA 14. Dynasty and RTG were pretty shallow in that game Most of the critiques were also in 14, like limited RTG playcalling, conference schedules locked, no way to view past season history, etc I would love to see a lot of what you mentioned in future titles, but I think it’s safe to say EA knocked this one out the water vs Madden 25, and deserves at least a 7.5

[@SOFTDRINKTV]

I respect your opinion man at the end of the day it’s a fun video game

[@BordeauxYT]

@@SOFTDRINKTVsame dude always great to hear others perspectives on it

[@atlien1988]

"Almost everything about it is a step up from NCAA 14." Lol that comment right there invalidates your entire post. It's not a terrible game, but the presentation alone isn't better due to the lack of optimization. The commentary team sounds dull & often boring. We can't even properly track career stats or accolades in Dynasty mode.

[@kvunharris]

​@@atlien1988So we gonna forget CFB25 sim logic is 10X better then NCAA 14 or The ai logic is so much better in CFB25 too and many other things.

[@blackisraelite9309]

@@kvunharrishow is it better it’s dogshit, I can’t even have a dynasty mode without every player on my team being white when half of the cfb league is black. Game was rushed and now there paying for it

[@chucknorris3545]

10:38 you can indeed turn the drums off. Just turn music volume to 0. you’ll still have the music in the games but not theses annoying drums that cause my ears to burn

[@michaelcali8304]

I give it a 7.5. It's fun and I don't mind the lack of features as much since I know the NIL contracts limit some freedom. I messed with some sliders and the gameplay is great. I exclusively play single-player and the new dynasty and RtG have given me a bunch to do so far. The commentary, lack of polish, and the drum music are the worst things for me. Great honest review as always SDTV!

[@jordanp4134]

Road to glory needs an overhaul. We need quicker progression for playing well, coach trust needs to allow you to eventually audible and set protections once maxed. And there should be more customization on player archetypes

[@kingsofthenorth2894]

I really wish you personally upgraded your platers like in Madden. The auto progress just feels less personal. Maybe I'm werid but I personally want to see my player growth from week to week.

[@michaelahurt]

100% I understand not wanting to copy Madden but player upgrades still need to be engaging and rewarding even if it's RNG -- something the old games managed to do. This just sucks. The inability to clearly see when or why players upgrade is super frustrating. Game design 101: if people feel the need to use a spreadsheet while playing the game you have massively f**ked up your UI

[@JayR-jo9]

Not being able to customize players or create a player outside of RTG is not a legal issue. If you can do it in Madden, you can do it in NCAA. If you can create a player in RTG, you can create a player anywhere else in the game. They took out create a player in Madden to force people to play Superstar Mode. Which has more microtransactions. That is the real reason they took out create a player in both games.

[@Sky_Blaze]

This is why gaming is so bad now..just greed and a bad product.

[@jacksonspeed4733]

It actually a legal reason the NBA NFL and other major sports leagues have player unions. Every player in the league is covered. NCAA does not have that so they have to just make blanket offers like they did which was $500 and a copy of the game and You’re in if you say no, they had to make it impossible for you to make that player so arch Manning on the game because he didn’t want to be the person that Edwin when they play his Texas just put him as a starter over Quinn Ewer, you can put in arch Manning no matter how much you try.

[@JayR-jo9]

@@jacksonspeed4733 And yet, I could have still made Arch Manning and any other player in RTG if I wanted to... I could create Charles Barkley in any 2k game. I can create Brett Favre in Madden. The list goes on. If it was a name issue, then filter out names that aren't allowed to be used. Don't take out the feature completely. But I personally think it's to subtle in microtransactions like they did with Madden this year. Next NCAA game will have their own MyPlayer mode with microtransactions.

[@STREAMSONLY-vt6gx]

​@@JayR-jo9 yep true on all accounts

[@burny890]

@@jacksonspeed4733 that's a really good ability to regurgitate MSM gaming journalism you displayed there bud lol.

[@itsokjared9044]

5/10 for me. Experienced a lot of buggy gameplay and several crashes. Lost an entire Dynasty save because of it. Logic is completely busted. If this is the best EA can offer after several years I shudder to think what next year's game brings

[@funkyflights]

Have they patched any of those bugs yet ?

[@itsokjared9044]

@@funkyflights IDK. Haven't really played it since. Losing my Dynasty soured me completely on it.

[@funkyflights]

@@itsokjared9044 … Ah gotcha.. Well hopefully they fix the issue

[@KollinTalksSports]

I completely agree, I want to say it’s a perfect game because it’s been so long since we’ve had a fun football game, but I know that’s crazy. I think the game while being fairly barebones is in a fantastic position due to the replay ability from gameplay and recruiting. While also setting themselves up for many improvements they can make.

[@KollinTalksSports]

On top of this it legitimately feels like the devs care about the game and want to put out a good product.

[@LordWafflestomp]

10:10 there is a way to select offense and defense only before loading into the game though.

[@lumberc]

the presentation is really bad to be honest, it annoys me how there’s only one cutscene when you play a game. The old NCAA games had differences every time i played a game, from showing lee corso and that panel to showing players warming up, and the commentators giving an overview and prediction. The generic fans look awful as well.

[@RomnysGonzalez]

Damn. EA pull off the check after that Madden 25 review? Jokes aside love your videos mate. You're one of the few who always speak of his mind about sport games and how they keep regressing year after year

[@hotboiii_ced215]

You got caught up in the hype package. It is still an EA game and an 8.5 was absolutely crazy at first. It's a painfully mediocre game even after a month

[@NoNot-g7i]

I've been playing for two days and already it's clear it's a lousy and shallow game. I respect the amount of work some devs had to do gathering all the uniforms, fight songs, stadiums, etc. That's an insane volume of work. But clearly leadership is still pushing them to recycle the same shitty gameplay with a nicer looking coat of paint on top

[@deccwith2cs]

O line needs help. Dbs still feel way smarter than wrs that's my 2 complaints

[@thesuperpimpplaya1]

Ah yes the classic the ball is in the air your receiver just continues their route while the defender breaks for and picks off the ball

[@mysteriousj3019]

O line needing help is an understatement. I've got 90 overall tackles with 99 in all pass blocking stats just letting dudes run right by them without touching them.

[@thesuperpimpplaya1]

@@mysteriousj3019 mad facts. You snap the ball and they in the backfield like sup foo!

[@luharianator]

@@thesuperpimpplaya1i thought that was only me because im like go after the ball why is your back turned

[@thesuperpimpplaya1]

@@luharianator nope lol just stupid coding. Just like them jumping up in the air without looking to pick the ball off

[@nathanielroe3279]

This the best gameplay we'll ever get on the frostbite engine. There's a lot I love with the game, but there's also a lot that they can improve and do better. Granted this is the first release of CFB on the new gen consoles, so I'll give them slack, these people seem to actually care about the game unlike the people who make Madden. But my biggest issue with the game is that the end of season awards don't make any sense, I played as VT and my edge rusger won the Hesiman with 25 sacks, but yet he didn't win the best edge rusher or d linemen awards, and he didn't even make any all-american team which is annoying. I also don't like the draft results that they give for players, it seems they just base it entirely on a players OVR and doesn't factor in their stats at all.

[@Bahns007]

They need to really update Dynasty's Custom Conference Rules. You only get like 5 options for the Conference Championship stadium and if you do change anything in a Conference like the SEC or B1G, you'll lose the default stadium you play at. As Kentucky playing in Dyansty, this basically ruined my immersion for Dynasty because the SEC Championship game will no longer be in Atlanta at Mercedes-Benz Stadium

[@mind_of_dro]

also if you customize anything in a conference (for example moving USC and UCLA out of the BIG TEN) all protected rivalries will get flown out the window

[@Megistrus]

They also need to fix the Pac-12 because you either switch all the teams back or you leave it as a 2 team conference. There needs to be an option to remove it and move WSU and OSU to another conference.

[@chachdanko]

If u want the SEC championship game in Atlanta change it before the season starts. Not sure I’ve ever seen that issue you’re having

[@jamesdulany2176]

They also need to allow you to turn off the conference championship for all conferences. I shouldn't have to have a conference title game for a 10 team Big 10 with a full round robin conference schedule.

[@LND209]

Am I the only one who hasn’t seen, or is having this issue?

[@gking2709]

Daytime changes not being in is just lazy, it your game starts anytime after 6 it shouldn't still be sunny blue skies at the end of the game lol

[@travisfranz703]

I love how you are the only video game reviewer that remembers All pro football 2K 8 existed, and that it was perfect

[@xman777b]

the game was ugly. So it wasn't perfect

[@berbrick1902]

@@xman777bAnd? The game was made in 2007 so of course the graphics aren’t going to be as good. That’s like saying Mario 64 is a bad game because it’s ugly

[@dcampbell97]

It wasn't close to perfect. The game play is brutal and way over rated. Just like 2k5. I really don't get the love for those games. They were nothing to me when they came out and that is the same today.

[@mr.ohiostate2544]

​@dcampbell97 I notice some say that I think that group of ppl are the ones who like the game doing the work for you

[@xman777b]

@@berbrick1902 you have no idea who you're talking to. It's got NOTHING to do with 7th gen graphics. It's just an ugly game

[@YURU7]

Just because someone likes something doesn’t mean they’re a sell out or a fanboy, and anyone who says otherwise needs to reattach with themselves.

[@Daveybird]

100%!! Many need to!! Too many fans on the Internet act like it's not cool to have fun and enjoy what you have, while acknowledging it's not perfect.

[@jamablasttv5299]

This feels kinda nitpicky tbh. I can still hop in any game mode ( except for ultimate team) and have a few hours worth of fun. So it's still a 9/10 for me.

[@ArtilleryAffictionado1648]

Its extremely nitpicky. Only vieeo of his that feels kinda off. Also, 1 minute add built into the video. I smell b.s

[@lilboaterboy868]

What’s a 5/10 then?

[@jamablasttv5299]

@@lilboaterboy868 A 5/10 is like Madden 16 or 17.

[@johnnyionescu-yr6sk]

I feel like it's missing a lot of stuff I enjoyed from the PS2 and even PS3 era games. I miss the instant classic score and even the college classics. Mascot mode was a fun thing to have to mess around with too. Also the crowds and sounds don't give me that college feel. I don't know it seems to be missing the charm of the old games we all loved I think.

[@ziziworld9652]

this game is horrible, there is no notification when you break a record, the took away the trophies ceremony and trophy room and lots more I was very disappointed

[@alekino26]

I agree the game is not the best NCAA game. The coach AI in RTG is very dumb some times. Also I've had one time where I scored a touchdown and the coach goes for 2, took me (QB) out and we fail and when I checked the highlight it says I was in the game and missed a pass. I should play every snap I am on the field. That being said, I am still having fun. My grade is pretty similar. I would give a 7-7.5

[@TheFrozo619]

Why have a competitive mode if the computer can’t block competively or competently

[@josephlamonica7592]

I’m doing an Army dynasty currently and the most annoying glitch is if you use “rocket toss” out of any formation the game doesn’t register your rush attempt, yards, or TD’s. It’s one of my favorite plays and a staple of Army’s wishbone offense and I literally can’t call it anymore. Such BS

[@BSE1320]

Hell, I am still pissed off at College Football 25 because we dont have a PC port...and likely never will. :/

[@amolb7952]

They know the modders would Go crazy😂

[@taylion3724]

@@amolb7952That and they would get sued a lot if they did let PC players get this game lol😂

[@AndyVanHalen]

Honestly I could not for the life of me understand why people were giving this game such high review scores upon release. I knew this widespread re-evaluation would happen. It’s a fun but seriously flawed game. And if anyone thinks for a second that EA is going to keep adding meaningful features as the years go on… Well, I’ve got the last 15 years of Madden I’d like to show you. This current version of CFB is about as good as it’s going to get.

[@ReinSouls]

It's very easy to understand why. You have to factor in the fact a lot of people who bought CFB 25 have long stopped playing Madden. Heck, the last Madden I got was 18. So when it finally comes to a football game that's new and has actual hype around it. For instance, a game people were waiting nearly a decade for, people are going to get caught up in the hype. There may be glaring issues that cynical people like you or me will see. But we're not the average person. So when people finally get their hands on it and it to an extent does meet expectations. They'll likely be inclined to overblow just how good the game is. This happens all the time in entertainment. It's still a good game and certainly a step above Madden, but ya it's definitely not some masterpiece that people initially were painting it as. Hopefully in future titles more depth will be added, but we all know the odds of that happening are as bout as good as DJ Uiagalelei actually being a good QB.

[@Daveybird]

Yeah, tbh it was probably the mosy hyped annual sports video game release in awhile, because it was sidelined for special circumstances (NIL, pay, etc). The demand always existed.

[@comaxmomax]

I bought CFB25 because of your first review. All the stuff you brought up in this video was a bit disappointing to find... But since i purchaced this game in July i havent been able to put it down lol. The game being fun matters more than dynasty features. However, if CFB26 releases with minor upgrades to this game... Ill be pretty upset.

[@evannix408]

One thing I have noticed while playing RTG as a running back is I always get subbed out going into the red zone. So even if I am the #1 running back in the country I barely score any TDs. Its so annoying

[@LND209]

It depends on the teams offense. Some teams have a different HB when in the red zone, when it’s 3rd down, and when the first down is short in yards. It could be the team you’re playing for. It’s the scheme

[@evannix408]

@@LND209 True, I’ve had this issue with several different RTGs though. I kinda feel like this is a wear and tear situation

[@jerichoanderson6055]

Yea same! One season I had like 1300 yards and only 3 TDs🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣

[@Thrashman-ye4cf]

@@evannix408definitely the wear and tear. I turned it off and haven’t had a problem with it.

[@jeremycash2953]

Turn fatigue to 0 and it’ll stop happening

[@ProDucktions0]

It's an improvement from Madden but at the end of the day it's another soulless sports game that has the benefit of being the first of it's kind (debatable) in a decade. The more I play it, the less I like it and the more disappointed I am. 3 years of development for this mid ass game is seriously disappointing.

[@Thetallguy_zz]

It’s impossible to enjoy college football while playing this. You have to enjoy the stick work of the gameplay and bright colors

[@andrewhooper5933]

its defs not souless lmao, they put a lot into presentation.

[@ProDucktions0]

@@andrewhooper5933 Nah, it's pretty soulless. Just reused assets from Madden with some college football traditions. For the time it was in development, it's extremely disappointing.

[@andrewhooper5933]

@@ProDucktions0 nah youre just making a bad faith argument because you hate EA. The game deserves to be reviewed, the negatives should be highlighted, it has many, being souless is not one of them; being souless is the dumbest and most bad faith argument I have heard yet.

[@PBMdanya]

​@@andrewhooper5933explain how it's not soulless?

[@allainangcao28]

We've reached the point where an EA game hitting above a 5 is considered great. How low the sports game genre had fallen.

[@kvunharris]

Not everybody rating system is the same💀

[@luxerhusku2609]

Geez now you're getting hate comments for changing the score. Seems like you can't please these people regardless of being positive, mixed, or negative...

[@BIGMISTAKE333]

ive never understood this take. different people have different opinions. i seriously doubt the same exact people who hated on the high score are the same people now hating for changing it lower.. lets use our deductive reasoning now kids

[@PBMdanya]

​@@BIGMISTAKE333exactly. Idk what this guy is talking about? The reasonings are different and you can't escape that, it's why you should do it right the first time, or you'll end up in a lose lose situation.

[@martyfromnebraska1045]

​@@BIGMISTAKE333 I'm hating for both because everyone said it was just the hype for the new college football game and he said that wasn't the case, and now that the hype cycle has faded (and everyone bought their copies already) it turns out we were right all along. Hard to trust the opinion of a reviewer when their review when most people are deciding whether or not to purchase is glowing, and when most people have already committed money and realized it's not that great they change their tune. It's similar to FudgeMuppet's review of Starfield talking about how amazing it was, and then completely dropping the game for 6 months and going back to Fallout 4 videos.

[@CW-sn3lf]

You’re mistaken. EA has an exclusive deal with the Collegiate Licensing Company (CLC). In other words, no other developer can make a college game that has official teams, uniforms, stadiums, etc. It’s fundamentally no different than the deal that EA has with the NFL. Also,this game lacks the wow factor. It’s underwhelming, especially considering how long the fan base has waited for its return.

[@kvunharris]

But it is. That only goes for college football and not every college sport.

[@Daveybird]

@@kvunharris Fingers crossed NCAA Basketball/College Hoops 2K28 or something...

[@brendangschwind1324]

They definitely need to tune the sim games. I’m playing a mainly sim dynasty with a 94 overall team and lost to an 80 overall Ohio team in the first round of the playoffs.

[@criticaloptimist7961]

Them Ohio teams are no joke. What's 90+ anywhere else is 80+ in Ohio.

[@walaa_gamingyt3327]

I respect the 1st review, and I understand the revision

[@todahouse19]

The drums is the most perplexing choice of all. Who playtested dynasty and thought that was okay and a better idea than a playlist of rotating fight songs ?

[@yourfavoritelawnguy2722]

I'm with you, its a fun game, and im glad it finally came out. But the shine is fading and the mess that was swept under the rug, is coming out

[@thisisthetarter]

I had fun playing the first few days because it was new but I've completely stopped playing. So you aren't alone in this

[@samuelgingras6291]

I totally understand why you gave an 8.5 score originally. Everything is a matter of perspective, I haven't bought an EA sports game since Fifa 21/Madden 21 and the pure joy I had for the first week of EA sports college Football 25 cannot be described. However, the bar has been so low that we forgot what we once had. Great video! Most wouldn't have had the courage to admit they were perhaps too generous.

[@TaeGoCrzy]

Ea gonna be Ea man. They knew all they had to do was do the bare minimum college experience wise and give gameplay technically better than madden 25 and all the same sheeps will buy the game😂

[@Thetallguy_zz]

It hurts hearing SDTV hype up a game for being better than dogass

[@scatt5274]

Miss the option to play a high school season in rtg and try to improve to a 5 star recruit by the seasons end. It was fun to try and win a state championship and have to play well to get recruited by a big school. I know not everyone is going to enjoy that, so just give the option to skip senior year or something what’s the big deal? Also the instant classic feature was fun, don’t know why they couldn’t include something like that so you can go back and be reminded of crazy games you forgot you played. I played a dynasty where I had a mlb win the Heisman but wasn’t named an all American (not even second team???). Had running backs have incredible seasons but not get drafted because their overall wasn’t high enough, when I’ve had “blocking” tight ends who score one TD all year and get drafted in the first round because their overall is like a 96. This simple stuff that seems so easy to get right (even try to include) drives me up the wall. All that being said it’s still a lot of fun to play, just some of the stuff that seems the easiest to get right is still what holds this game (and madden for that matter) back and makes it less immersive/realistic.

[@kylemulkey9659]

The way I look at it is this. In the moment, in the "play now" style game it is fun. Against a buddy for a game or two is really fun. When you dive into Dynasty or other modes that have deep mechanics, that is the problems. Tons of issues where you can't find stats, tons of glitches, the pathetic sim engine, repeated lines over and over, it comes off as really pretty with absolutely no depth.

[@resolve06]

You’re good bro. There’s extremists on both sides. I felt good about the game at first too. Then I realized it was an EA football game. I haven’t bought an EA football since Madden 16 but the latest one I played was Madden 18. I used to be a KZbinr like you speaking on this game but it seemed that there were no changes and everyone kept buying it. I was excited for CF25 and bought it. In the end, I do have fun with it but it’s still lackluster and plagued by the same legacy issues. I will never buy another EA football game again unless they start from scratch. I’d still hesitate lol. Keep doing you

[@leaferikson4244]

Somebody needed to pay rent this week

[@BuffaloBeatle]

Every NCAA didn’t have a “soundtrack” just the school band songs.

[@kaylynalexander]

Cool game should’ve been not been $70 . They didn’t put no real love into this game . I think it was a nostalgia feeling been playing a few weeks and i wish i could get my money back i’ll just go back to baseball lol

[@Flint9250]

Honestly, a lot of my love for football video games comes from the schematic side. I enjoy developing a playbook identity, scouting an opponent, creating an actual play-call sheet for different games, scripting my opening drive, calling both sides of the ball efficiently, making adjustments where needed…that’s the side of football that appeals to me. Dynasty is lackluster in many respects. I’m not a huge recruiter, personally, because I prefer just filling out my team needs and adapting my scheme to fit my personnel (like an actual coach). I do wish the “lore” and storylines were more fleshed out, but again, that’s not really why I’m playing… NFL 2K5 is still the most realistic on the field, but the sheer schematic depth of CFB 25 is wonderful. I’m having an absolute blast in that regard! I totally understand where others are coming from, though. We all love college football, but we all appreciate the sport itself and the video games for different reasons.

[@dbzfan4evermj233]

Number 1 thing I hate about CFB 25 is stadium pulse if you play on the road your at such a disadvantage I have had moments were I can’t see my routes as the QB witch aggravates tf out of me and when I audible my QB has question mark over his head when I am the one changing the play is ridiculous I can understand WR or TE doing that hell even RB if I decide to throw to him I can deal with the route moving and shaking that’s fine but not being able to see who to throw to especially in a panic scrambling situation makes me want to uninstall the game and with RTG you can’t audible at all unless you’re in hurry up and coach calls the worst plays I remember I almost lost national championship game because my coach thought it was a good idea to run the ball on 4 and 10 and other thing they always take you off the field if you don’t convert on 3rd down and I don’t like how there is no high school for RTG ncaa 14 was such a better game they had Heisman mode and mascot game mode I never really cared about dynasty in any of the games tbh so I don’t have a opinion on that play now and RTG has always been my favorite modes and kicking meter I don’t really like how fast it is and how that yellow line isn’t in the game to help guide the ball in for the field goal all in all I give the game 6.5/10 or 7/10 if stadium pulse was like momentum from madden then I could care less but stadium pulse is game breaking and makes me not want to play at all

[@IamJUMPWIT]

😢 😢😢

[@ErWoody99]

The sim logic and the overall glitch is what's killing it for me, when I have to calculate overalls and force wins to have a realistic experience, it's not fun for me

[@Thetallguy_zz]

What’s the overall glitch, like I was Texas A&M with a 87 overall offense but my team was straight 78-84’s what were the calculations you did?

[@Thetallguy_zz]

Lmao nvm I’m plugging my ps2 in

[@ErWoody99]

@Thetallguy_zz the calculations for the overalls are all over the place it leans heavily on backups which shouldn't be the case, it should only take starters and a couple choice backups in consideration, but the cpu overalls wont change at all, like for example colorado is a 84 overall, but after the first year travis hunter and sanders leave as well as most of their core and they kinda suck after that but they will stay a 84 and not change, and other teams will get better but not change, texas state for example is a 78 overall on it but in my save years later everyone of the team is 85 overall and up and most are in the 90s but they still only show as a 78 overall

[@Thetallguy_zz]

@@ErWoody99 yeah that makes so much sense I was definitely simming games I shouldn’t because I misunderstood that. Guess I should’ve expected simple things like that to not work properly.

[@kvunharris]

They patch the sim logic like 2 weeks ago. It's working fine for me.

[@davidk713]

I don’t think Dynasty mode is a true dynasty mode. It’s a coach mode. Dynasty mode would include complete control over school activities. We should hire and fire all coaches. Unlock achievements like build or renovate new stadiums or facilities that could help attract players. The ability to tweak jerseys. Consequences for hiring coaches that might have a bad reputation.

[@mr.ohiostate2544]

I gave the game an 8.5 after 2 days. Now hundreds of hours later 7.75. I really like it. Sure, a few bad things like the inability to sub on the fly but I love it

[@Kings0424]

@@mr.ohiostate2544 Same bro I agree love it

[@Laidback718]

Big 8

[@zenmaster16]

The frustrating part is that almost all of the depth issues could be fixed in a single update, but they won’t do it.

[@tlgarceau]

Dynasty should be updated regularly similar to the way GTA Online is maintained. Offline Dynasty Coaches shouldn't cap at 50. For the love of if gawd, permit number changes for anyone that we've recruited or, allow us to assign numbers.

[@gloverhaywood]

I can appreciate you going back to your own review and rethinking it. I wish more people would do this. Cheers!

[@ptorrez211]

You can choose to play offense defense only tho. It’s at the screen where you pick playbook and what not

[@mottdropsie]

Honestly I just got the game and if you do remove all the context surrounding it, yeah its absolutely more fun than the Ps4 Maddens. Animations definitely have more weight and momentum to them and feel more like actual physics, movement isn't too bad, the crowd and stadium environment feels like a proper atmosphere, I haven't noticed any bs glitching so far, but don't take my word for that one. On its own, it at least makes me want to come back to it unlike Madden 19 (the last one I bought). There's potential, and actual improvement from the PS4 Madden era. But we need to keep seeing a leap like this in successive games, and we all know how that will end when there's a monopoly.

[@bman_dc]

This game definitely needs to have a award room even on madden you can see who won the last super bowl.

[@Jayden-zt5qb]

The most annoying small bug to me is if you have too many of one stat in dynasty so it won’t show up in the national leaders category. I had 18 picks in one season with Chris Flowers on Duke, but when you look at the nations pick leaders, he doesn’t show up because he had too many. So the leader in picks is like 9 or 10.

[@Sludgehammer138]

I like this channel a lot but I also am lol'ing at the idea of a review do over

[@ArtilleryAffictionado1648]

Gotta get that 2 minute ad bro

[@7F0X7]

"It's lazy garbage, but I'm gonna buy it anyway to maintain my social standing." = The problem that got us here.

[@blok--head7472]

Hate to say I told ya... EA never changes. Maybe next year will be different. Then the next year. Then the next.. etc etc

[@Iluvkelly]

we treat EA the way cowboys fans treat their team. “this is our year…. next years our year…. okay NEXT year is our year…”

[@fizzy360wolf]

That point you made about the schedule changes, it's actually really funny because in NCAA Football 99, you could schedule any team to play any team on any week. If you broke the scheduling rules it would warn you, but you could choose to change the schedule to meet the NCAA conference requirements, or you could choose to overrule the NCAA and ppay with that wacky schedule. I made a season with completely randomized schedules. It took a while but it was fun :)

[@avandelayy9089]

The rose-tinted glasses have finally come off. This game was never going to be one of the great sports games long-term with how unbalanced and shallow the game is.

[@teamgarza261]

Don’t need it to be one of the greats just want a fun college football game which is what I received…I’m satisfied

[@DuecePiece]

I think it's definitely a great game, easily one of the best sports games made in the last decade. If you don't like it go back to Madden, no need to shit on a game you're either terrible at or simply don't understand. I agree EA needs to do better across the board, but this is light-years more effort than anything they've done on Madden or Battlefront

[@blackisraelite9309]

Fax, people will settle though and call it a good game because there not really sports gamers and unfortunately these are the mfs that EA will listen to smh thinking they released a fascinating product

[@echodun]

As soon as I received my 100th roughing the kicker penalty even after the patch, straight up on Ebay it went.

[@Oj_0103]

Gave it a 9/10 on first review probably off just sheer excitement and happiness over it being out in the first place would probably give it a 7.5/10 now flawed but I still enjoy playing it and the first big patch definitely improved some of the bugs and cheese from the game.

[@jakkejohnson1111]

Your right on the stats I wish I could see the stats and awards from my players past!! UT will never get played by me I'm an old head that only cares about RTG and Dynasty, as far as the music it doesn't really bother me I do wish they would have put all the schools fight song in there like in NCAA 07! Love the new review.

[@wittybanter96]

Btw man, I'd love to see you do a review on NHL 25 when it comes out. It coming out on next gen exclusively and a promise of a revamp of Franchise mode has me cautiously optimistic.

[@FlyHenryFly]

the trailer looks atrocious for it

[@BigEOT3]

I want to be optimistic for it but considering EA cares for NHL less than UFC or College Football I am nervous

[@wittybanter96]

​@@FlyHenryFlyIt was more vague than anything. It reminds me of the NHL 15 trailer though, so maybe the game will be a massive dissapointment by that logic.

[@Jay123-yk4pl]

@@BigEOT3most people don’t care about nhl so why would ea?

[@wittybanter96]

​@@Jay123-yk4plDefine most?

[@Autistic_Chaos]

Good foundational title, the pieces are there, great gameplay and presentation is solid. However legacy issues are still there and the overall lack of depth holds it back. I hope we see CFB 27 not 26 that way they have more time to polish the code and clean up legacy issues. Great revision to the review man! Really appreciate your videos.

[@miamibrian5335]

#BringBackNFL2K

[@DesertDonkey-c8x]

Idiot

[@JaredGoofball]

This ain’t gonna do anything here. You are just like farming. Post this where people who don’t already watch soft drink are.

[@GOCAPSDMV]

@@JaredGoofballmaybe he is and you just don’t know it… ooh here’s something for you, don’t assume something if you aren’t entirely sure 😊😊. He could also be reminding new viewers???

[@taylion3724]

They probably wouldn’t do better the state of NBA2K is terrible rn.

[@GOCAPSDMV]

@@taylion3724 completion, both companies would want to sell more copies, meaning they would try harder.

[@cfb_press]

10:15 you can choose to play only offense or defense pre game. You go to the bottom in the play game menu and scroll across from “play full game”

[@YOUNGPADAWON]

It’s still a 7/10 for years we’ve complained about unpolished gameplay we finally get really solid gameplay and it’s not enough

[@Thetallguy_zz]

The gameplay is cheesy, it’s fun for old guys playing on varsity and adhd kids

[@YOUNGPADAWON]

@@Thetallguy_zz varsity? I play on Heisman good Sir if your not good at the game just say it

[@Thetallguy_zz]

@@YOUNGPADAWON wtf? That’s not even a response to what I said chud.

[@Thetallguy_zz]

@@YOUNGPADAWON I play on heismsn a too bro you’re not cool for making a bad video game more difficult for yourself.

[@YOUNGPADAWON]

@@Thetallguy_zz really isn’t a bad game tho lmfaooo

[@showtimesportsmedia6906]

Solid return to an old title that we’ve wanted for years and they took time & years to make it that shows effort. Give them time to improve on it for more years as it continues. They can’t do everything in one full swing. Great video bro.

[@DiorShiesty]

I still enjoyed NCAA 14 more than NCAA 25

[@ThatGuyOnTheInternet2023]

Same.

[@wittybanter96]

Nah

[@ItsKryptick]

Still having a great time on this game 2 months later, but 100% agree that it's not fully there. I am hopeful that the CFB dev team actually upgrades the game every year, they already seem to care more than the Madden dev team, but time will tell. I just hope we aren't on CFB 26 and basically playing the same game.

[@jordandennis6794]

The defense of this Madden reskin is insane

[@tgs5725]

TBH you are both right. This game is legit a reskin of Madden 25... Making it good and fun to play. Not great, but an improvement on Madden 24.

[@michaelperez6664]

Please don't even get started about the oline blocking.

[@JordanLittel]

if you can export a rtg player into the nfl, you should be able to export your coach into madden as well. especially since it shows coaches leaving for the nfl every year in the coaching carousel...