SportsGamerShow - Madden 21 vs. NFL 2K5

[@SportsGamerShow]

Gran Turismo 7 Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKi2gXuva5h7btU

[@iyemidesolomi426]

They were scared of 2K so they blocked them for 15 years in order to catch up. They still haven’t caught up 😐

[@SportsGamerShow]

This is the saddest part. 15+ years AND into next-gen and Madden is the same old game. Decent, but more of the same.

[@dayquantalbert6812]

@@SportsGamerShow nfl 2k5 might be my favorite football game It's so smooth & the fluidity It's just so on point I can't wait too buy this classic on eBay soon

[@glenwoodedwards9539]

Big Facts bro ✊🏾

[@Keviekev115]

Worst part is they could easily replicate what 2k did but do it better. They either have nerds or old heads at EA that aren’t innovative

[@Keviekev115]

Even Madden 05 is better than madden 21

[@youngchief31]

You forgot 2K’s VIP system; where the game records how you play - tendencies, situations, plays, etc.. are logged so you can either A) play yourself in AI form, B) play a friends VIP as if they are actually playing, or C) play against celebrities VIP’s.

[@kunark3843]

This was my favorite part of 2k playing against Celebrities

[@stephencalhoun3034]

NFL 2K5 had defensive line stunts. Madden still doesn't. It's ridiculous. 2K could make a great NFL game with next gen

[@andrewzebs]

I loved seeing Brady with the updated Buccs outfit in 2k5

[@jorgeadal01]

Madden will always be the same until they change the game engine.

[@osurocks24]

Frostbite is the worst. The Ignite engine was better than that and that engine is terrible as well.

[@TimothyBell90]

They did. They changed from the Ignite Engine to Frostbite. No dramatic fixes to gameplay at all

[@RomeGoLARGE]

The problem is EA doesn’t want to be anything sim players want it to be. Looking at the quality of Madden in every area shows that EA doesn’t care at all. We care more than they do.

[@Raiders-wm5kb]

The problem is the NFL gaming community (you included) I saw you streaming madden with nxtgen720. None of you are stepping up. Ryanmoody has 80k subs and just makes 10secs daily clips of bugs in the game. Sorry to say this But AngryJoe said it best you guys are morons and EA will continue win.

[@RomeGoLARGE]

@@Raiders-wm5kb damn bruh. Do you know the last time I played madden before that? Did you see how I got that Madden? Did you see my online record? I played that nigga In 2 games. That don't mean I support that shit. Never thought you was on shit like that fam. I thought you were better than that.

[@RomeGoLARGE]

And you not sorry to say that either. Moody got the drop on you. Anyone can do what Moody is doing with any game. He make money on people like you. If madden wasn't relevant you would even be here. I bet money you play Madden still too.

[@Raiders-wm5kb]

@@RomeGoLARGE I didn't watch. I wouldn't download the game even it's free. You still supporting them. They count that as profit.

[@RomeGoLARGE]

@@Raiders-wm5kb because I played a online match with nxtgen with 35 viewers? Come on bruh.

[@premulis7837]

Content doesn't mean replay value all of the time. Most Madden players only invest into one game mode and never touch other game modes. Not even once. The best way to measure replay value is to determine which game has a stronger community based on similar timelines. For example, who is left playing Madden 05 and who is left playing ESPN NFL 2K5. And if you base it on a more honest basis such as this, you will find ESPN NFL 2K5 has more replay value.

[@TimothyBell90]

Graphics shouldn't even have been compared. Madden wouldn't even have to do anything and would improve just because the technology difference in the past 15 years.

[@Raiders-wm5kb]

I’m over 30 it’s been 17+yrs since I bought a NFL video game sad.

[@jd52wtf]

NFL Needs to grow a set and stop signing away the "exclusive" rights. Competition here would force EA to do something better. This is a sad spot we are in.

[@SportsGamerShow]

Sucks but madden is a money maker for them. Hoping the upcoming NFL 2K game changes this down the road but I’m skeptical

[@sfktube]

Blame the NFL! They gave EA EXCLUSIVE rights to make NFL games. EA has not really tried to make a good game since.

[@johnfoster2584]

I still play 2k5.

[@essbe7158]

I was beyond crushed when EA was given the exclusive NFL license. I knew what it meant for 2K sports, and 2k was so much better. F EA and F the NFL.

[@Akumaa2000]

Don’t forget you also can assign certain defensive players to opposing wide receivers and even double team the #1 receiver in 2K5, still can’t do that in Madden.

[@mattXcatt]

You forgot to add that you get random phone calls from famous superstars that want to play against you

[@THEARTIZZTIK]

I got an Mclassic cable hooked up to my 360 , set the output to 720, the picture quality for this game is mint...

[@SportsGamerShow]

How big of a diff is it?

[@sfnick81]

Lost me when you said "Madden 21's gameplay is solid." Maddens gameplay has and is trash, EA should be embarrassed. Nothing about Madden 21 is good when you factor 2k5 even though dated is a superior game on made old tech.

[@nicholasbrooks7349]

Oh it’s even worse ESPN NFL 2k5 WAS 20 BUCKS at launch and were did you get the roster update files?

[@SportsGamerShow]

nfl2k5rosters . com

[@nicholasbrooks7349]

Thanks!

[@SportsGamerShow]

@@nicholasbrooks7349 I got you, all I ask is that you subscribe!

[@arioca]

UFC Undisputed 3 is much better than EA UFC 4 as well.

[@goodreverend2k1]

2K Has DL Stunts, CB Can play inside or outside the WR. VIP, the crib. etc.

[@vatovic5]

Madden 21 can't even beat Madden 05 let along NFL 2K5

[@nategreatgames78]

I must need to adjust some sliders on 2k5 because when I play Wr's never get that kind of separation from pursuit no matter how fast they are

[@RobsRetroGaming]

NFL 2K5 is the greatest video football game ever, and probably all sports!

[@theacemcfly2420]

First person football might be the greatest game mode. Especially if you've played football irl before

[@asmith8623]

I also used to just put the game in and watch it like it was an actual game. Loved it

[@b_side8669]

Why are we still on this madden vs nfl 2k5 thing ? . Obviously 2k5 was ahead of it’s time & still is the best overall in anyone’s opinion not just my own as well . Just look at all the good stuff 2k5 did very very well presentation check , halftime show check , real to life players check , weather Elements check , commentary hmm maybe one minus but still better then madden . Face it 2k5 was & always will be what madden should be & that’s one awesome NFL kick ass game bar none NFL 2k5 ❤️❤️❤️

[@jameshawkeye8430]

This was an amazing video Rio. I really enjoy your comparison videos as well as your reviews. I hope you will be doin a review for MLB the Show 21 next month because even though I don't have a next gen console yet, I am still goin to get MLB the Show 21 for the Xbox One S.

[@SportsGamerShow]

A review for The Show 21 is coming for sure.

[@jameshawkeye8430]

@@SportsGamerShow Sweet, definitely looking forward to it, love to see the comparison between the two different versions

[@Racinrasslinfan36]

What’s wild is you compared madden 12 to 2k5 back in 2011 Madden 21 isn’t even close to 12

[@SportsGamerShow]

Sad isn't it? I've just about given up on Madden. Got 23 for free, barely played it and didn't even bother with 24.

[@mikekull7183]

I’m amazed, I remember having this game on the first Xbox

[@rywints]

Xbox original is LITERALLY an antique bro! Why is this game way better than madden? Like how? Wtf is wrong with this picture? People make noise so 2k can take over!

[@michaelhopson6342]

Looking forward to your review of Madden 22. What are your feelings on the game so far? Hopefully its a big improvement from last year.

[@SportsGamerShow]

Literally DLing it now. Will post a review soon but not sounding good from what I’ve heard around the block

[@penguinpope2129]

Seeing "The Crib" in the menu ultimately takes it back. Trying to get those personal accolades to deck it out with memorabilia.

[@SportsGamerShow]

Such a cool feature.

[@Retro_Gamer_89]

What version of a Xbox 360 should i get to play this? Does it play ESPN Football (2K4)? And how do you get current rosters on the 360?

[@SportsGamerShow]

Any 360. Go to nfl2krosters.com for roster DLs

[@vintage3262]

You really should just use the emulator if you have a good PC. The resurrected mod is amazing

[@Retro_Gamer_89]

@@vintage3262 I have it emulated on my Xbox Series X thru Retroarch

[@vintage3262]

@@Retro_Gamer_89 can you do the resurrected mod on there? I play on PC

[@Xian127]

Where can I find 2k5 game at and should I buy it on ps2 or Xbox for updated rosters and stadiums and can update past champions and stats on franchise mode

[@SportsGamerShow]

eBay is your best bet.

[@vintage3262]

If you want updated textures or whatever then you need a PC

[@Vincentvega124]

Who is here still watching this thinking it applies to madden 22???? I know I am 22 is broken. We deserve much more…MUCH MORE

[@SportsGamerShow]

Posting my Madden 22 review now. Let’s just say this video would apply to this game as well 🙄

[@rcp225]

Besides the great game-play that you competently went over, what made ESPN NFL 2K5 so awesome, was the TV broadcast cameras and replays...absolutely stunning for its time - it felt like you were in a real game. On the other hand, Madden games have always been, are now and always will be about trash gameplay and ridiculous cameras. Think about it. They make up their own camera angles that quite frankly make me want to gag. Stupid close-ups after every play with choppy animation transitions, repeated and repeated at nauseam. And how 'bout that spiffy new intro. they got going. What is it, 5 or 6 players jumping and swaggering like a bunch of idiots...sorry EA, never saw that on a TV broadcast EVER! But that's EA's MO - who cares if it's realistic, the kiddies will love it! Quick question - Does anyone at EA Sports understand what wrap-tackles and gang tackling is? I'm still waiting! Now in all fairness, a couple of the Madden games were fun and I know most people have their favorites. But at no time were any of them a realistic portrayal of NFL football.

[@SportsGamerShow]

THIS. Still blown away at the in-game replays in NFL 2K5, specifically the broadcast breakdowns of big plays and contextual cutscenes (i.e. kicker kicking the gatorade bucket after missing a FG, QB throwing his helmet on the ground after an INT, etc.).

[@johndrake3472]

Can I get this game on a Xbox360?

[@Loyal_homie100]

I heard you need a oem hdd but why don’t you want to play it on original xbox ?

[@johndrake3472]

@@Loyal_homie100 I don't have one.

[@johndrake3472]

@Loyal_homie100 I just got it on an emulator, but it doesn't run well.

[@Loyal_homie100]

@@johndrake3472 i saw videos running on emulators and it plays well

[@Loyal_homie100]

@@johndrake3472 i wish we could play it on new gen xbox consoles same for playstation

[@nyfinestgully]

great video this video deserves 50 million views lol im so sick of current madden its a shame 😩😩

[@josephscott515]

I have a PS2, is it possible that if I get a memory card to you would you be able to save the roster update so I can get them updated on my console?

[@SportsGamerShow]

Hey Joseph, check out this website on how to get updated rosters on PS2: www.nfl2k5rosters.com/2k5playstationrosters.html

[@dmacwbc]

What system are you playing this on? I've been dying to play 2k5 again

[@SportsGamerShow]

Xbox 360. Get a transfer cable and you can DL the rosters on nfl2k5rosters.com

[@dmacwbc]

@@SportsGamerShow much appreciated brodi

[@SportsGamerShow]

@@dmacwbc i got you 👍🏽

[@vintage3262]

Do you have a decent PC?

[@rdaws73]

3:29 You said Madden 21's gameplay is solid?????? You lost me there. The fact that people still make comparison videos proves 2k owns Madden to this day.

[@SportsGamerShow]

To honor the late, great John Madden - Top 5 Madden Video Games of All Time: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYvck35jpKeWi6M

[@realdragonrude]

Even watching the Ai go at it is a fine wine experience in 2K5 i did a super bowl rematch with both Ai controlled teams going at it and it felt like how the rematch would actually go if you want to give it a shot for this year the 2k22 roster update has been released

[@xPOSTALx]

NFL 2k5 had fps on the field

[@OMGIMSAVINCLIP]

How do we get the updated rosters if we are on ps2 Someone please answer

[@SportsGamerShow]

www.nfl2k5rosters.com/2k5playstationrosters.html Here you go! Please subscribe to my channel and like this and my other videos. Thanks!

[@OMGIMSAVINCLIP]

@@SportsGamerShow got you right now and thanks

[@OMGIMSAVINCLIP]

@@SportsGamerShow and when I go to it I can’t find the 2020 rosters unless it’s the all years one

[@SportsGamerShow]

@@OMGIMSAVINCLIP yea, thats on the site moderators. cant help you with that one. they do have 2020 rosters for the xbox, but i know that doesn't help you much.

[@OMGIMSAVINCLIP]

@@SportsGamerShow got you I’ll keep looking or download a year prior thanks for the help still tho wouldn’t have done it with out you

[@santiagolozano3128]

In WWE 2K games there are referees. But imagine if EA Sports did WWE games right now. Cole: Here's the cover. (Ref doesn't show, then you here a voice 1...2...3). Gamers: Satan is the referee! That's what would happen.

[@jayharris2918]

The right stick in NFL 2k5 is God is you master the right stick you'll unlock another part of the game bro I used to hate running in 2k5 until I realized that 90 percent of the run game behind the line and before you interact with the defense is mapped to the left and right stick

[@SportsGamerShow]

You actually have to be patient when running the ball and pick/choose how to use turbo and the stick. Once you learn that, running is so much fun.

[@jayharris2918]

@@SportsGamerShow facts

[@D_Da_Tree]

2k5 is the best football game there will ever be. Not only the gameplay but the features and things you could do. Loved the crib and collecting all the trinkets and custom dream teams... Oh what i wouldnt do for a remaster :(

[@asmith8623]

Im buying this game again twice

[@PeterSellers22]

No contest

[@mikekull7183]

Just the fact that I’m reacting to this is sad for madden lol

[@maslei1581]

Comarable experience? More like better experience than madden 21

[@SportsGamerShow]

Lol

[@osurocks24]

You are way to nice about Madden 21. The animations are scripted and awful and its only based on animations and chance. No skill what so ever needed and your pretty much watching a movie more than playing a game. I watch Ryan Moody's videos on KZbin all time and finds nothing but glitches on top of that. This a polar opposite contest. NFL 2k5- One of the greatest football games of all time! Madden 21- Probably one of the worst video games not just in football but in AAA gaming ever. Madden 05 vs NFL 2k5 however would be more tightly contested.

[@SportsGamerShow]

Did you watch the entire video? “NFL 2K5 offers the best, well rounded game of NFL football over Madden 21 and any other Madden that has preceded it. It’s too bad EA still has the NFL license to create simulation video games because if they didn’t, it would be almost certain that 2K would step in and put Madden to shame…just like they did with NBA Live with the NBA 2K series.” Don’t think I can be any more clear in my criticism of the Madden franchise with that statement above.

[@SportsGamerShow]

Also, I mention the notorious glitches in both my Madden 21 next gen and current gen video reviews. Trust me bro, I’m on the same page as you..it’s why I did this video in the first place.

[@osurocks24]

@@SportsGamerShow Ok. I missed that.

[@rywints]

Why you so easy on madden? The game is fucking TRASH dude it’s unplayable. People need to wake up and make noise about how shitty madden is so 2k can take over

[@SportsGamerShow]

Why am I so easy? Come on watch my other videos. I did this same comparison several years ago where I gave 2K5 the nod, did a scathing video review of M22 and did a recent video listing the top 5 madden games of all time where all the games listed were in the 2000s. The last thing I’ve been is “easy” on the Madden franchise. I just call it like I see it, good or bad.

[@rywints]

Ya I hear ya man and appreciate anyone who speaks out against madden. Which is why I like and comment to try and make noise for the algo and get this info out there. One of these days I really need to start making videos and absolutely ripping madden because in my opinion the game is legitimately unplayable