Star Destroyer Size Comparison (Star Wars Legends + Canon)

[@EckhartsLadder]

Hey, two corrections: 1. I forgot to update the size label for the Supremacy, it's 60km wide. 2. there's a sizing issue with the vengeance. It's about 3x too wide. Length is right though. I only noticed after render, sorry! Check the description for the artists work!

[@Mooste]

EckhartsLadder wasn’t the supremacy 60km wide? Instead of 19km?

[@EckhartsLadder]

@@Mooste yes that was an omission on my part

[@Mooste]

EckhartsLadder no biggy, mistakes happen.

[@blackshogun272]

@@EckhartsLadder I actually wish the Vengeance-class was that width ! Then it could be classified as a fricking carrier with that much space 😎

[@Predator42ID]

Replicators vs the Star wars universe please

[@Eri.fnn1803]

imagine working at the executor super star destroyer and you forgot that your office is on the other end 15km away

[@Leonhardt_Nukryst]

Oof

[@scoutguard3015]

Underrated comment

[@davesama2396]

Maybe they have some kind of mini transport inside executor and have some kind of highway inside it for easier way but, i get your joke.

[@johndamilkman]

Or if you forgot that the super star destroyer you are on is about to get destroyed because of a single A-wing.

[@florcheditsfx]

If that happening that officer gonna killed by Vader. Executor is Darth Vader personal flagship soo Vader almost always in his flagship. Than that mean If Officer get lost its mean he will got Vader force choke for making Vader angry

[@quantumyoutubeguy2]

The Supremacy was wide so it could fit Kylo ren.

[@conanu4857]

underrated comment

[@user-qv4wm5zl4m]

XD

[@theactualiosif]

putin

[@marekadrspach5845]

U meant Ben Swolo?

[@NinjaSushi2]

Because he had a big head?

[@justafaniv1097]

Ok, after watching this video and seeing the Supremacy's size, it's clear that Snoke was compensating for something of his that was very small... I'm of course talking about his character development.

[@craignewsome2058]

Right. It was so small you needed a magnifying glass to see it😂😂

[@user-mw2vn7pv8n]

Snoke was such a waste. Just like his flagship. It appears for a few minutes and then gets destroyed by Admiral gender studies and we are told nothing about it.

[@chromicm6686]

How did they even have the resources to build that mess of a capital ship anyway?

[@frightrider3525]

@@user-mw2vn7pv8n you deserve an award for admiral Gender Studies

[@martinjrgensen8234]

Callum Gledhill Piss poor world building.

[@willross7486]

Builders: How big should we make it? Snoke: Yes

[@BocchiSensei]

Palpatine: Have you seen my plans for my ships *Imperium USD has entered the chat*

[@sernoddicusthegallant6986]

Legends: "We have such incredably huge super star destroyers" Disney: "Theres always a bigger fish"

[@skeletronprime2827]

Ser, HUMER

[@wiskypapa8380]

Smokes ship looks like a stick of ram

[@LeBrooler]

@@sernoddicusthegallant6986 Legends Yuuzhlan vong mothership thing : *YES*

[@CuppaTeaExe]

Theres ALWAYS a bigger fish

[@XelinaTsukiomi]

and there is even bigger one but don't know from where... its the Imperium Ultra star destroyer. It has never been build but it's about 300km, has a deathstar on it, tie squadrons are replaced by swarms of star destroyers.

[@samthepianoman]

Xelina Tsukiomi it’s a fanon stAr destroyer

[@leaf741]

*SLAPS DESK U Z A N G V O N G W O R L D S H I P

[@leaf741]

Xelina Tsukiomi that sounds sooo impractical as well, considering it would be more girth than a planet, it would have its own gravitational pull as well, but it’s Star Wars, so no science allowed.

[@Goldenboy-pe2ci]

Until a significantly smaller ship piloted by a character nobody likes defeats the biggest fish for some reason.

[@ArtyMac]

“Join the Empire! Our ships are big triangles!”

[@jaellanthehat3693]

Illumanti comfirmed?

[@biascardriver5441]

Those are pringles slices

[@mrnohax5436]

*FLY DORITOS* with no sauce

[@BallMuncher555]

And that’s why I love them so much.

[@misgle]

"Join the First Order! We have a massive boomerang ship!"

[@snowgod8446]

When the smallest ship is 800m long

[@justsomeguywithasurprisede4059]

Now that's *_huge_* (THAT'S WHAT SHE SAID-)

[@commanderbacara4306]

@Avreus what's the carriers Name?

[@thatoneguy7451]

@Avreus and the seawise giant, the longest ship ever built, is only 450 meters long lmfao

[@santiy2081]

That length is similar to the tallest skyscraper ever built, as it has a height of also 800m

[@TSERJI]

Not that huge when u think about it imo. We have regular ocean going ships (and heck, even private yachts) that are slowly creeping up toward that size, plus we have skyscrapers that are already taller than that today. Building ships like those should be easily achievable with today’s engineering.

[@Armor15gaming]

As a navy veteran once said “The Star Destroyer would have been a very good space ship when it came to naval combat if it weren’t for the giant ‘HIT ME!’ Command center sticking out the top.”

[@BocchiSensei]

And thats where the nebula comes in

[@bobjoebo8933]

Might as well paint bulls eyes on the shield generators too

[@kamikazesenpai21]

It’s need for transmit

[@oldv1288]

Look, no offense but I feel like the imperial star destroyer basically represents modern aircraft carriers. Know what I mean? (Oh and of course… let’s not get too technical about this either this is humor)

[@muhammadksatriaakbarariend8684]

@@oldv1288 yet it wasn't a carrier ironic

[@samiamrg7]

I can’t help but imagine the Eclipse hitting the Supremacy with it’s super laser and cutting it in half.

[@Erolsaurus]

Supremacy isn't made to be an attack ship like Eclipse. It's supposed to be a ship that builds more ships.

[@bobjoebo8933]

@@Erolsaurus Wait. If those ships build more ships... that is where they got enough ships to build a third death star

[@paratrooper508]

the supremacy isn't a fleet ship nor a "destroyer" but a standalone mobile base in its own category. And I agree apart from the venators the eclipse is the only one I would actually bother building because that superlaser makes it a solid flagship for a sector fleet. Beyond that I would scrap most of these in favor of victory or harrower sized cruisers guarding venator or imperial sized fleet carriers which as real life has taught us, carry most of the actual firepower (as well as a far more flexible response to things like starfighter based attacks, which the rebels are actually using, not arrays of capitol ships)

[@gerere966]

The supremacy was like a flying country with a laser cannon :v

[@jacksonscott3667]

Based off of some rough calculations, I estimate the Supremacy as half the size of Rhode Island.

[@robinroy7123]

The wingspan is gotta be between 95 and 100 km. That's the size of my damn district.

[@jacksonscott3667]

Robin Roy the wingspan is actually specifically stated as 60 km, whereas the length of the ship is roughly that of an Executor class (18-19 km)

[@riverlucier7496]

@@robinroy7123 the wingspan is 60 km.

[@isaackim7675]

Kiez When Supreme Leader needs his coffee, it’s on the western part of the Destroyer

[@hmmm9658]

the first order shouldn't have ships that big, they dwarf vaders ship at the height of the empires power but somehow this faction thats been living in the shadows has the resources to build an entire planet into a death star 3 and have these ridiculously big ships

[@CheeseRunner]

Nice meme well they had 30 years to do so. They didn’t have to worry about being found out, they didn’t have to worry about fighting on any fronts, they could focus all their manpower on building their fleet. It took the Empire 4 years to nearly complete the second Death Star and they had a lot to worry about aside from construction. Imagine these people rebuilding their Empire in complete privacy for 30 years. The New Republic was demilitarizing the galaxy so trust me, all these weapon manufacturers who became very popular because of the Empire would gladly sell their finest tech to the First Order.

[@msgtgalarza9946]

And you're right about that too I mean if they can have all of that they could have kept the clone troopers I understand they were really that we were Bayou Chip War used but that doesn't mean they could have stopped using us clones to battle for them if they can have all of that money to build on big amount of ships and death stars

[@chrissonofpear3657]

The Supremacy is almost ludicrously wide, but it does have to serve as a mobile repair dock as well.

[@evolvedturtleproductions7600]

They had 30 years to prepare, which is more time than the Empire had even existed.

[@motherlyfather9871]

That's the sequel trilogy's mistake. They think that bigger is better.

[@martinjrgensen8234]

The Executor is so darn good looking.

[@MEXUS.]

You're damn right it does

[@BoterBug]

Agreed. Though I didn't see the bridge on that model?

[@Tar-Numendil]

The only ugly ones were the Mandator IV and the Supremacy.

[@Skoombit]

Dillon Locke true but i really do like the look of the Resurgent class Very sleek

[@Tar-Numendil]

@@Skoombit So do I. It's a gorgeous ship. I did say the only ugly ones were the Mandator IV and the Supremacy. I love all of the others.

[@CamaroZL-rx3zl]

The empire are VERY good at making flying Doritos

[@briiun]

Yes they are lol 😂

[@sulerwog703]

Brain cells

[@CoreRealm]

And the first order made a flying Pizza

[@sulerwog703]

Are they allies until now?

[@1zi22]

This comment makes me hungry. LOL

[@dmitrov_dmitriy]

Once, Snoke was asked "what is it like to fly on the best ship of the galaxy?" He replied: “I don’t know, I’ve never been on the resistance cruiser garbage truck”

[@demi-femme4821]

I feel like one of the most underrated aspects of the Venator is that its design makes it FEEL big. Other Star Destroyers are larger, but the design of the Venator really makes it feel like a massive ship in a way that designs for other large ships (like the ISD, Praetor, and Nebula) don't. You get a similar feel from the massive ships like the Bellator or Executor.

[@battledroid224]

Guide to SDs. 1. Make it bigger than the last one 2. Exposed, oversized bridge 3. Don't bother spending money on point defense when you have giant oversized cannons 4. Doesn't have to be effective in battle, just scare them off 5. Don't let them escape, keep them in sight as they waste fuel trying to out-sub-light you since you have hyper-tracking 6. Have contradictions everywhere, you can afford 3 more main batteries behind your other one, just don't shoot at yourself when targetting enemy in front

[@reddatyoshi3773]

UNLESS its the supremacy stupid

[@randycheow4268]

Instructions unclear: dick stuck in hyperdrive

[@sgt.kanxkix9945]

BattleDroid224 the supremacy has millions of weapons not just the cannons

[@battledroid224]

​@@reddatyoshi3773 ​ @Visarion Striker Guide to CrewMs. 1. Too big of a ship? Threaten farmers into joining. 2. Training program too costly? Get the Ensigns to deal with cadets. 3. Lost an admiral? Promote whoever's next in line. 4. Battle commander is an idiot so the others won't do their work? Kill a few lieutenants so the gunners and all would do whatever order says so to keep their lives. 5. Lost some lieutenants? Reference (3.). 6. Vacancy in last position? Reference (2.). 7. Cadets are stupid? Reference (4.). 8. Empty ship? Reference (1.)

[@jakesummers5469]

In a Star Wars perspective the first order is stupid, but this is Star Wars, where planet destroying battle ships exist.

[@crazedvole]

"The ship is too big. If I walk, the movie will be over."

[@papachi4178]

HAIL SCROOB!

[@KayJayCrazy]

Haha awesome comment 😂👍

[@RichO1701e]

I knew it! I'm surrounded by assholes!

[@TacoSuprize]

Out of order? Fuck! Even in the future nothing works!

[@isaackim7675]

Prepare ship for ludicrous speed!

[@HeckaLives]

*Disney when deciding the size for the new Death Star and Capital ships* "MORE!"

[@jacobgelman]

"So that must be Lord Snoke's star destroyer. Do you think maybe he's compensating for something"- Shrek

[@sheriffhotdog1443]

Other star destroyers: Gets Longer Supremacy: *G I R T H*

[@bobjoebo8933]

It had to be that thicc to fit Kylo Ren

[@scorpixel1866]

You get a space dorito and YOU get a space dorito! EVERYONE GETS SPACE DORITOS

[@EzioDeCreeper]

Make my space dorito bigger than meveryone elses.

[@ArkSucksAtGames]

I am a Dorito

[@me-zc7pu]

and i am baby yoda

[@ArkSucksAtGames]

And I.........Am.............Iron Man

[@jaykilkenny4409]

Are they green space doritos though ?

[@fivelonelyclones]

do a super weapon size comparison

[@EckhartsLadder]

Working on it now

[@jinx8902]

please make a mickey mouse with the death stars and starkiller base

[@commanderknight9314]

That would be so funny.

[@linktheheroofhyrule2498]

@@jinx8902 Yes, please do it

[@mluby7828]

If you throw in "destructive potential" we'll all be able to see how stupid the Sun Crusher was…

[@richieThach]

These ships are actually massive compared to Earth scale. The longest ship on Earth doesn’t even reach 500 meters.

[@The_Warrior526]

A Sovreign class Federation starship is under 700 meters even.

[@l.clevelandmajor9931]

The USS Independence on which my father served was over 3 football fields long, and it was not as long as those that came later. No they are not even 500 meters in length, but you have to understand that an ocean going ship is not going to be practical at the sizes seen in Star Wars. Where would you dock it at any base or at any seaport on Earth? Answer: You wouldn't! Plus it would be an awfully big target to shoot at! All practical considerations dictate how large a ship can be on an ocean or in space. And the First Order Supremacy size is overkill and quite easy to hit with the right weapons.

[@Isildurwasbetrayed]

richie thach no shit sherlock

[@imperialguardsmans9678]

*Holy Terra*

[@vedpatil2353]

Isn’t Supremacy literally the size of a fuckin city

[@LukeKetchum7003]

4:17 The Executor class is my personal favorite.

[@thatonelass3912]

And now I can't help but imagine a pair of Executors sweeping out of Snoke's ship like fighters.

[@bobjoebo8933]

Its a trap!

[@IrishPhoenix7]

The music makes it so relaxing but the ships make it so cool and exciting, I’m so confused on how I should feel....help

[@cumunist2120]

Christopher Murphy sickened

[@lenat76]

This is what we call "Vaporwave" :) It is made to make people feel nostalgic, relax and a bit in the clouds !

[@pcmfplanecrazy9938]

First order officer: so how would you like us to make the ex- Kyle ren: BIG

[@shockarmy100]

Might be wrong.. but Kylo had nothing to do with the executors

[@jacobpeterson4071]

I love how almost every new generation of star destroyer does nothing to actually improve on it's design. Just bigger with more cannons....

[@mir3877]

We are lucky that holdo discovered her maneuver just at the right moment (or more really she decided to escape just at the wrong moment to leave her friends behind as according to more recent data the chances of pulling it off were slim to none and otherwise it was very well known) That also explained the somewhat remorseful expressions of holdo at the time of the maneuver and the hateful faces of her friends when her brilliant plan of escape blew in their faces.

[@noxy4966]

Meanwhile Thrawn is having a heart attack due to the amount of star destroyers he could field with the money and resources used to make starkiller base and the supremancy. In the great words of Gordon Freeman(Freeman's mind edition): "Eat your hearts out taxpayers, this is here you money goes"

[@ufukcangencoglu2279]

Starkiller Base and the Supremacy were good choices for the First Order.

[@paytonkilmer1920]

@@ufukcangencoglu2279 How so? Holdo blew up the Supremacy and two or three other star destroyers. If there'd been no Supremacy, and let's say (conservatively) fifty other Resurgence-class star destroyers, she couldn't have possibly hit enough of them to make a difference.

[@Juxtaposed_IRL]

@@paytonkilmer1920 they should've built the Starkiller base, but used it as a threat, not just wasted a good position by immediately blowing them up for no fucking reason other than ego. The better option would have been to set up negotiations with the New Republic, and used the resources on the planet and from said threat to build more star destroyers. They would still have to build an orbital platform to have the star destroyers dock at, but use the resources from boomerang ship to make three that circle in tandem around the planet. They should then place those massive cannons from that other ship that they used for orbital bombardment for points defense cannons on said orbital ship docks. They could at least have made two more if they were able to make a fucking deathstar 2.0. Also, get better commanders, and then execute the red headed idiot.

[@stevenbean9731]

Ufukcan Gencoglu “Hey Jeff. These guys have been in hiding since their whole regime collapsed, right?” “Yeah.” “Extremely limited resources and manpower?” “Yeah.” “Let’s make them dig a massive chunk out of a small planet and put a shotgun Death Star in it.” “Wh-“ “Trust me, Jeff, it’ll make millions in the Box Office.”

[@unknownalsounknown4238]

@@ufukcangencoglu2279 they could just make 4 xyston star destroyers instead

[@TheAnakinn]

The Supremacy class is just ridiculously huge

[@reedcoffman3210]

Yeah its almost like some company thought kids will love this oh wait

[@commanderknight9314]

Well, it is supposed to be headquarters/sbipyard/warship/and everything in between of course it is going to be big.

[@Tar-Numendil]

Still smaller than the first Death Star though.

[@Tar-Numendil]

@Itnetlolor That is hysterical!

[@dhkatz_]

Reed Coffman You're seriously bitching about this but the Empire somehow managed to essentially build TWO Death Stars in the span of a couple of years. Yet the First Order has 30 years and it's "unrealistic" when the Death Star is the size of a moon.

[@glhf8047]

4:00 the Mandator IV. It was a calm, really boring designing session, for the movie „the last jedi”. Kevin pokes, out of bordem , a slice of pizza with a straw. Then it gets stuck. Rayen looks at him and says: „do that again” Kevin looks at him and than sticks another straw into the slice. Rayan picks it up, turns it and says: „YES!”

[@datkat2001]

Anubis My main problem with the design is that apart from the bridge it’s really flat, almost as if they couldn’t be assed to properly design it

[@lazaglider]

Are you sponsored by commas?

[@aureusknighstar2195]

The painful truth

[@commanderknight9314]

Getting to watch an eckhartsladder video with dinner, so satisfying.

[@Safari_Man]

Commander Knight or with any meal, it is rather relaxing

[@michaelguo369]

Nobody: Me: now that’s a lot of space pizzas

[@user-xj9lp3fs7m]

And it goes pew pew

[@KingBobXVI]

Starting your comment with "Nobody:" doesn't make it automatically funnier...

[@michaelguo369]

@@KingBobXVI thanks for the advice youtube comment knowitall

[@KingBobXVI]

@@michaelguo369 - Hardly a "knowitall", just tired of this lazy dead horse of a meme.

[@JailTheSun]

@@KingBobXVI Shut up you half priced cashew powder.

[@smithwesson1896]

Palpatine: I'll make a big ass flagship to show just how rich and powerful I am! Snoke: Hold my space beer....

[@sks17873]

Well I guess he just exchanged the beer between his own hands then.

[@buttstick7357]

Palpatine’s hands are full with copies of snoke

[@hyperionman420]

The music choice never lets me down. Brilliant.

[@lewissans5845]

This is basically what pizza's look like in the Star War universe.

[@MikeJProto]

dude earth would totally scare off the first order, we have millions of pizzas

[@kritikill7779]

@@MikeJProto fun fact, earth actually does exist in the star wars universe :)

[@avery1647]

@@kritikill7779 what if George Lucas is a harbinger of death and he's trying to warn us about the empire?!

[@GiratinaofFury]

The amount of materials they would have needed to make these. They must have depleted entire planets.

[@jacksonscott3667]

Depleted them of certain resources, probably. Assuming that it takes 1.6 cubic kilometers of material to create an ISD (which is a much larger volume than what an actual ISD consists of), you have to consider that the overall volume of an Earth-sized planet is still roughly a *trillion* cubic kilometers. Assuming that every bit of Earth’s mass could be utilized in the creation of a Star Destroyer, the full mass could be used to complete 625 million ISDs. Given that the Empire’s fleet was typically stated to number around 25,000, it’s safe to assume that planets were not depleted wholesale.

[@andrewscott7728]

@@jacksonscott3667 and there are millions of planets, who would miss one?

[@borknypd1971]

Star Wars fan: Star destroyers. Your next door neighbours kids: *flYiNG gRey PiZZAs*

[@Nate.o]

Lol

[@beld3375]

ツBorkWaffleYT :D I mean, they aren’t wrong

[@unknownalsounknown4238]

@@beld3375 it's treason then

[@squareyoyoer640]

Is that a plot hole I spy in the mandator class dreadnought?

[@ruthlessdraculigula1051]

Lol.

[@tomllttle464]

No it’s just a hole

[@gabeg9810]

The Venator class just looks absolutely awesome. Even though their smaller than a lot of the others, I still love it. Probably because of its ample presence in the Clone Wars.

[@Mourtzouphlos240]

It’s also the best ship. There are hundreds of fighters to do the actual work of killing other ships, it’s inexpensive, tough, easy to maintain, you can make them by the gross, and you don’t need the logistics and institutional structure of of keeping a single ship with the population of Manhattan running.

[@user-jj7lo3sp2n]

I'll also add to that, it's pretty much the only ship that's truly battle tested. It went toe to toe with equal, slightly less powerful, and more powerful enemy ships. Almost none of the other star destroyers faced off against a similar sized ship.

[@sparklepawz1185]

The first order makes no sense and is so stupid. “Guys we’re the weakened remains of the empire. We have little to no supporters and have to rely on kidnapping kids for troops. What do we do with whatever money we have?” “Convert a planet into a Death Star. Also build like a super big ship. Bigger than anything ever” “But... won’t that make it super obvious to the republic that we exist? Also wouldn’t it be better to use that money for something else like better fighters than the shitty TIE we’re using? Or maybe even build a droid factory and build better battle droids than the CIS did for extra troops that will never defect” “No. I want big ships and a big planet Death Star that drains the sun for power. That way when the sun dies out we lose the planet base because the thing can’t hyper space travel like the original Death Stars” “But... that’s so stupid. We can build like... a million commando droids and magna guards instead. You know the things that were a match for Jedi? Why not build them? Also we don’t even have the manpower to maintain both those things because of how big they are. We’re a small faction remember?” “What? No don’t worry. I’ll make sure that these gigantic things are indestructible. Unless some idiot makes up a universe defying move like.. idk weaponizing hyperspace. I mean if that were possible we’d already be building weapons based on it since the hyper drive was invented. Plus as long as no idiot just lowers the shields on the planet base it’ll be fine. It’s not like a high ranking officer will just... idk... lower the shields because they’re being held at blaster point even though they’re wearing blaster proof armor. Right?”

[@chuckchuck4016]

Ok but you’re a furry so everything you say is invalid

[@koolestkid5999]

Secks Man true

[@marlacarnicom2147]

Wrong

[@marlacarnicom2147]

Despite the fact that we don’t even have enough people to operate them, that is what i want.

[@kingfelix1534]

No one gives a shit just sit back relax and enjoy some sweet looking ships. Plus I'm pretty sure they just have big ships in order to make the resistance look small and helpless, not in order to be realistic.

[@WillFredward7167]

Epic. I still think the Executor is the most aesthetic, but the Eclipse is so intimidating and the Supremacy is so crazy huge

[@Miller54K]

I love how Snokes ship was that much bigger than a super star destroyer but was a fraction of the intimidation.

[@miqo6453]

I freaking love the Supremacy, Harrower, executor, Venator and Resurgent. The mandator IV is also really growing on me!!

[@craignewsome2058]

I don't know why but I really love the Venator Star Destroyer. It's my favorite ship. Then after that it's the Bellator

[@NovoCognition]

Two video ideas: 1. A Star Destroyer Free-for-all 2. Perfect fleet with only Star Destroyers as Capital Ships.

[@nicegarry7421]

Trxp Chimper I think that’s a bit overkill

[@orumonuldor1340]

1 Sovereign SSD, 3 Bellator Dreadnoughts, 3 Interdictor Cruisers, 9 Imperial II Star Destroyers, 20 Victory Star Destroyers and 10 Venator Star Destroyers. As for their fighter compliments: TIE Defenders (Legends version of course) and Missile Boats (Because awesome)

[@NovoCognition]

Orumon Uldor; What about shuttlecrafts?

[@NovoCognition]

RC - 1207; Better prepared then dead.

[@orumonuldor1340]

Preferably multiple very well armed varieties. Star wars legends is replete with them. The majority of my knowledge is comprised from the old TIE fighter game. Delta JV-7 Shuttles and the DX-9 transports for preference. The former because it's a damn good multirole combat shuttle and the latter because you still need a cheap cargo transport. Also, fun.

[@pandathecrusader5658]

I just realized how small the Harrower Dreadnoughts were. In the game and cinematic they seemed bigger but now I realize its smaller than a victory.

[@glendalrymple1842]

it's an inaccurate fact, its much larger than an ISD around the size of an Allegiance-Class, the Cinematic trailer is it's actual size.

[@pandathecrusader5658]

@@glendalrymple1842 no its 800 meters the ISD is 1000 meters.

[@glendalrymple1842]

@@pandathecrusader5658 An Imperial-Class 1-2 Star Destroyer is 1600 Meters - 1800 Meters, Due to SWTOR not being canon anymore no one has made any lore corrections to the Harrowers size. But the one and only reference was a poor approximation and isn't close to the size. But it is closer to the Allegiance-Class if anything.

[@BennyLlama39]

Some of these ships remind me of Spaceballs. Mel Brooks comes running in and says, "The ship is too long. If I walk, the movie will be over." 😀

[@Wastydest]

Bellator Class SSD vs. Resurgent Class SD Nebula Class SD vs. Pellaeon Class SD (or any comparable SD) Resurgent Class SD vs MC85 Cruiser (Raddus) 16th Attempt

[@Galen55]

Sovereign SSD vs Two Bellator SSDs.

[@reedcoffman3210]

MC85 would crush a single resurgent on a 1 v 1 battle

[@squasher0487]

He already did the Raddus vs Resurgent.

[@Wastydest]

@@squasher0487 Really? I can't find such a video. Can you please sent the link?

[@Wastydest]

@@reedcoffman3210 Yeah that might be true, but that does'nt change the fact, that I would like to see Eck comparing them.

[@ThatOneGuy46696]

Damn it, Canon, why must you change the Venator's length! it went from 1137 to 1155. Reeeee.

[@reedcoffman3210]

Wait so how is 18 meters a big deal?

[@ThatOneGuy46696]

Because my model is still 1137m

[@johnjohnnyj.johnsonjr.1935]

Talking about the real problems!

[@themetalstickman]

REEEEEEEEEE!

[@chrissonofpear3657]

It was made slightly bigger in the Clone Wars Incredible Vehicles guide. That size might come from the CGI animators themselves.

[@Nero_studios]

Didn't realize Resurgents where 2 km long, thanks! Also Secutor is still a sexy arrowhead of a a ship.

[@chrissonofpear3657]

Resurgent's nearly 3 km, actually.

[@bobjoebo8933]

Imperial star destroyers: Powerful, deadly, and sexy arrowheads

[@mandalor223]

I notice one class is missing: the Interdictor-Class Star Destroyers, the ones with gravity well generators used to pull ships out of hyperspace.

[@fabigtimperator1107]

They're useless in the Disney Star Wars universe since everyone can jump into hyperspace from the ground of the planets

[@Outcast115]

@@fabigtimperator1107 fuck off man baby you're adding nothing

[@texasr3d872]

@@Outcast115 what

[@bluerobin2982]

You done being angry now

[@bipedleek241]

Outcast115 dude you’re the one acting like a man baby

[@CorvusRedd]

Even though i've seen some of these a dozen times, I always love looking at the different cruisers in Star Wars, they're so cool looking!

[@jerdasaurusrex557]

Mega-Class Mobile Shipyard/City Fortress

[@alexrator7674]

Two big problems: 1. The bridge is still sticking out above the cruiser (stupid!) 2. The engines are too big, you could fire in there and KABOOM!

[@juanpablomontalvo4715]

Alex Rator Shields are a thing in star wars

[@brs793]

the nebula doesn't have a massive oversized bridge so.......

[@aureusknighstar2195]

@@juanpablomontalvo4715 but only if they are nescessary to the plot

[@dougdeyuuy2577]

Imagine in tlj that all the star destroyers came out of hyperspace just like this after trackin the resistance fleet

[@keepsake327]

Having ships of those sizes beyond the Imperial class is so impractical. I know that there is an entire galaxy and billions or even trillions of personnel in the factions to crew these ships, but it's damn near genocidal to have a fleet battle where several of these capital ships are destroyed. The smaller ones by themselves, let alone the Death Star.

[@bobjoebo8933]

Stick with 2 Km at most for a supper carrier. Have lots of cruisers and battleships. Done deal

[@UncleMikeDrop]

It's funny how the Empire or really any approximation throughout the history of Star Wars never thought to make a smaller, faster, and more versatile star destroyer variant. They just went bigger bigGER BIGGER. It would have been a very compelling role reversal if the new Republic had large unwieldy capital ships and the 1st order had light maneuverable and fast warships.

[@ufukcangencoglu2279]

The Resurgent-Class IS bigger & better

[@michaellathrop3640]

"Commence Primary Ignition" *proceeds to light-speed ram these (supercool) ship designs into irrelevancy *

[@bardenbarden7759]

What about the beautiful star destroyers that we saw in Kotor 1 and 2, the Interdictor and the Centurion? I know they technically started as Republic ships, but they are pretty iconic to the Sith in that era. They are also really elegant looking.

[@Schontaylor]

Barden Barden anything from Star Wars lore was better than the last Jedi filth bleuuuurgh

[@ExcaliburHeavyBattlecruiser]

@@Schontaylor Lol go watch the holiday specials and then comment.

[@stevenbean9731]

Resurgent Class Battlecruiser I will unironically say that watching a Wookiee grandpa have a... fun time with VR women is more entertaining than the more recent Star Wars movies.

[@Outcast115]

@@stevenbean9731 you know that just kind of proves that you're an idiot Man baby like pretty much all neckbeards

[@raendymion3149]

I think you could also add the Assertor.

[@francisgelooo5143]

The common thing is that they all look like pizza Ps im hungry

[@finw-k6805]

The Venator is a much cooler destroyer than the Imperial. Shame they didn’t make it a bit more beefy

[@awildfilingcabinet6239]

Well the Venator was still much larger than anything the CIS had, or at least within the same class. On a whole the clone wars ships were much smaller than imperial era.

[@Erolsaurus]

Lucrehulk

[@garkon8242]

Nice Vid! To me this gives the Supremacy some scale that actually makes sense (as far as something can make sense when SSDs are concerned) because unlike the other SSDs its a command ship, mobile base and sort of shipyard all in one.

[@brbrbrvrbrbrbb1607]

Oh btw, one kilometer is 1000 meeters. That means that the Supremacy is 19 kilometers long

[@bobjoebo8933]

Lets go metric system, easy to follow

[@englishtraduccionlinguisti2718]

The "supremacy" was an excellente design but wasted by the episode 8.

[@CallMeShoe]

If you look at how big the Supremacy Dreadnaught is in comparison to a normal Star Destroyer, it makes Palpatine’s Destroyers in Episode 9 that much more feasible. It also makes the Holdo move more plausible because of how big it is.

[@dzakyeet5444]

Imagine forgot ur phone in that ship

[@lamario295]

Imagine this fleet showing up in orbit of your world

[@bobjoebo8933]

Alderaan: What world?

[@lordghetshis939]

Palpatine: Join Us! We have a cool name for you! Anakin: Never Palatine: What about a Epic imperial song specially for you! Anakin: Nope Palpatine: What about a Cool black armour? Anakin: No Palpatine: Cool Voice? Anakin: Nah Palpatine: 2nd Ranked person in the empire? Anakin: Still No Palplatine: Pizza Destroyers? Palatine: You know what I mean :-P Anakin: *hELl yEaH!*

[@randomindividual9131]

Palpatine could have just say: We have oversized flying pizzas and doritos!

[@cominguponinfra-red3038]

Replicators vs a Unified Star Wars universe (338th try now, *_I._** WILL NEEEEVER EEEVER GIVE UP!!!)*

[@hac3359]

#QuitWastingYourTimeIfYouMadeItPastTenHeWontDoIt

[@commanderknight9314]

#nevergiveup

[@greaterhalo0659]

#giveup

[@marsar1775]

Dont listen to the naysayers!

[@Scortch-lo3xy]

keep going man

[@my_MillenniumFalcon]

The iconic Imperial Star Destroyers, impressive though they may be, are really puny little things when put next to the insanely massive Supremacy... 😅👏

[@El_Xrystos]

You can tell me all you want about how awesome the huge ships are. For me the peak in design is the Harrower "Dreadnought" of the old republic era. I love this ship.

[@gregorylumban-gaol3889]

The Eclipses and the Sovereigns would kick the Supremacy’s ass.

[@ZZMonkeysUncleZZ]

Yeah. In a traditional gun battle, the Supremacy probably wins, but as with pretty much every matchup they have, the Eclipse and Sovereign can just auto-resolve with the superlaser.

[@noxy4966]

What were you expecting? Its Empire-built, if it doesnt have superlasers you are doing it wrong.

[@gregorylumban-gaol3889]

Noxy Disney needs to take notes, but there was a time where Legends superweapons were too ridiculous. Remember the Sun Crusher?

[@noxy4966]

Lets agree to never talk about that abomination.

[@RexOrbis]

Lol, so people in the comment section are both saying that the supremacy is too powerful, or not powerful enough, and somehow it's all Disney's fault.

[@kirzuvo7145]

Rip just got the notification minutes late

[@craignewsome2058]

Same

[@CT0197]

A damn week for me 😠

[@rocket8437]

A year late

[@angelbeatzbell4057]

It's been a long time since I've watched one of your vids Eck. But this is the 137th attempt Yuuzhan Vong vs the Reapers * I will never give up hahaha

[@kazuyavanguardtv2937]

Dude, your taste in music is just amazing

[@KwazyIndian]

I hope when we start building starships... they all look like flying Imperial Dorito chips

[@aidanshaw4890]

Would someone mind explaining to me what the Secutor is? It looks to be of Republic design, but when and what was it used for?

[@EckhartsLadder]

Video coming soon!

[@reedcoffman3210]

I am pretty sure the empire used it as a super carrier

[@tennoshenaniganizer9234]

Republic design but mainly imperial used. Its a heavy carrier. It can be used in the battlefront commander mod for Empire at War

[@einfachignorieren6156]

Its a late Republic, early empire Carrier Design for V-Wings, ARC-170 later for Tie-fighter and bomber. I dont think that it saw many Action. Look in wookiepedia.

[@Robotic_Rampage]

I expect a lengthy ramble about its carrying capacity in that video. And for good reason.

[@SC-ce3vp]

Was the death star being blown up like space 9/11 or space pearl harbor?

[@reedcoffman3210]

So are you saying that the rebels are terrorist (oh wait they are) and the rebels are also space Japanese and the empire is America makes sense actually but with the japan thing japan should be the empire and the us the rebels

[@delasee1383]

Neither, the attack on the Death Star wasn't a terrorist attack (more of a desperate, last ditch defense) nor was it the start of a war like Pearl Harbor, as the rebellion had been going on for quite some time. Besides, Pearl Harbor was an attack on a more or less (at the time) equal opponent.

[@hac3359]

Space Pearl Harbour The Supremacy takes the Space 9/11 title

[@matthewwilliam1180]

9/11 is the better comparison. It was done by non-state actors (Al-Qaeda, the Alliance) to unquestionably the greatest military force at the time (America, the Galactic Empire), shattering the latter's sense of invulnerability and refocusing its security policies. Pearl Harbor resulted in a symmetrical war between major powers; the Galactic Civil War wasn't this until its later stages. 9/11 produced the sort of cat-and-mouse, asymmetrical warfare we see in _The Empire Strikes Back._

[@Tyler-2839]

USS Cole

[@pacoramon9468]

A 60km ship that was easily destroyed by a far smaller ship.

[@117swordsmen]

Eckharts keep doing your thing man, videos are relaxing and informative, love the intro, love the outro

[@d3m1g0d4]

Just when you think it can't get any larger.....it does

[@vts0361]

Here’s a list of my favorite Star Wars ships ship: 1.The supremacy 2. Eclipse 3.Venator class star destroyer

[@ExcaliburHeavyBattlecruiser]

My favorite star destroyers 1. Resurgent class battlecruiser 2. Eclipse class dreadnought 3. Pellaeon class star destroyer and Imperius class star destroyer 4. Supremacy class mega star destroyer 5. Nebula star destroyer

[@vts0361]

Pritish Shakya Blogs nice list! ,I like the supremacy so much just because it’s like a battle ship from ww2

[@ExcaliburHeavyBattlecruiser]

@@vts0361 Those super heavy turbolasers were a cool addition that makes sense. It's introduction is epically awesome, that siren combined with the sheer scale of the Supremacy sure made a lot of people drop their jaws.

[@vts0361]

Pritish Shakya Blogs Yeah, seeing that scene in theaters was enough for the entire price of the tickets!

[@ExcaliburHeavyBattlecruiser]

@@vts0361 Wondering what new ships we'll see in Rise of Skywalker.

[@journeythroughtherails5294]

They need to make something *WAYYYYY* bigger than the snoke ship

[@WillyWarby]

Hi again , its Snoke you complete numpty

[@ianhines2302]

It exists it’s called the Death Star

[@journeythroughtherails5294]

@@WillyWarby Bruh it was a typo.

[@journeythroughtherails5294]

@@ianhines2302 Death star is gone lmao

[@WillyWarby]

@@journeythroughtherails5294 And I couldn't care less 6 months later thx

[@stephenlutz6936]

Alright everybody, if you had to make a fleet, which three Star Destroyers would you choose from this video. Mine would be the Victory, Nebula, and the Venator. Small, but efficient to take on capital ships and take on fighters.

[@themetalstickman]

Imperial for mainline cruiser, Resurgent for fighter support, and Executor for flagship.

[@MobiusLeader007]

Mine would be the same as yours. The Venator for its unparalleled fighter compliment, Nebula as a multirole carrier with its powerful capital guns, and the Victory for the front line with its missile launchers, turbolasers, ion cannons, and acceptable fighter compliment. These are also all reasonably priced. So losing some wouldn't be a major loss like a dreadnought. I'd also fill them up with New Republic fighters such as X-Wings, B-Wings, K-Wings, A-Wings, E-Wings etc.

[@chrissonofpear3657]

ISD very likely. Venator pretty useful. Resurgent is growing on me...

[@stephenlutz6936]

MobiusLeader007 Exactly. Venator is fighter control, Nebula and Victory on front lines. Also, when one guys down, it’s less expensive and you don’t lose as many people as compared to the Imperial class.

[@MobiusLeader007]

@@stephenlutz6936 These vessels also have a Class 1 hyperdrive, making them great at responding to threats across the galaxy. Admittedly though, the Victory I is rather slow in realspace. So it would be up to the Venator and Nebula to chase fleeing ships.

[@phantomshotgun9223]

The Supremecy is a pretty awesome ship, but the Eclipse is a ship i would love to see make a come back in the lore.

[@lukeshelswell3211]

Ohhhhhhhhhh Resonance always sounds good

[@JohnnyKronaz]

Star Wars really does suffer from "bigger is better" -- they just keep making things bigger and bigger, as if that somehow makes the threat bigger. And it's kinda gotten lame at this point. I look forward to episode IX where they'll have a star-size death star and a planet-sized destroyer. Then episode X where they have a system-sized death star and a star-sized destroyer. Wow, how innovative!

[@karmask9943]

Last 360 Days to Star Vars IX

[@kieranschafer5180]

And then the star sized destroyer gets blown up in the span of 1 hour by the rebels.

[@josiaharaki7310]

In the EU, by the Legacy era, they were making smaller, more efficient ships. The Imperious-class Star Destroyer is only slightly larger than a standard ISD, but it has the shields and weapons tohold it's own against the rest of the Imperial navy.

[@noobikenoobi5580]

Could you do a part two but with super weapons?

[@x9360]

*I was expecting for the assertor class,its massive too*

[@encycl07pedia-]

Beautiful video! Thank you so much for making this. I've been reading and trying to figure out the physical difference between the Victory and Imperial classes. They're pretty close except for size.

[@sirpasta4927]

For each of the ships, you should have included a short clip of the ship in a movie, so people know what's what.

[@ExcaliburHeavyBattlecruiser]

Many of them are from comics and some of them are very blurred.

[@mightystriker3255]

Notification squad like it up

[@timbartschwolfman]

Red Leader Standing by

[@commanderknight9314]

Commander Knight standing by.

[@Sharlie83]

Oddball. You know what to do.

[@thomasjackson6971]

Mighty Striker gay

[@hansmendoza2007]

Viscount Class Star Defender VS 2-3 of the MALEVOLENCE (Subjagator Class Heavy Cruiser) 51st Try

[@Justanotherconsumer]

For comparison’s sake, where on this scale do the Homeworld motherships stack up?

[@viktormatilcak25]

Kushan (height)-2,5 km, Hiigaran (height)-2,5 km, Taidan (width)-2,3 km, Vaygr (length)-2,6 km and Sajuuk length was 4 km so they stack up between Secutor and Praetor Battlecruiser.

[@warbunny13203]

You couldn't pay me enough creds to be that "one" person who gets reassigned from one wing tip to the other on the supremacy😱😱😯😯😯😯🇺🇸🦅🇺🇸

[@Shawouin]

You get a week off for the reassignment.

[@teamtundra2619]

warbunny13203 you’d have to take a day off just to walk there

[@appalachianunderground8474]

The Ships from Star Trek can’t hold a candle. And I really am a Trek fan also