Stardew Valley - All Luau Responses (Best Ingredients to Worst)

Every possible outcome for Pelican Town's summer festival, the Luau, where players are instructed to provide a high quality ingredient for the potluck soup for the Valley governor to sample. There are six possible outcomes - 'missing something' (no ingredient), best, good, neutral, bad, and worst.
Best outcome ingredients (from the Stardew Valley Wiki) [villager friendship bonus]:
Silver star: Crimsonfish, Ice Pip, Lava Eel, Legend, Starfruit
Gold star: Angler, Artichoke, Catfish, Cauliflower, Chanterelle, Cheese, Crimsonfish, Fairy Rose, Glacierfish, Goat Cheese, Ice Pip, Lava Eel, Legend, Melon, Mutant Carp, Purple Mushroom, Red Cabbage, Starfruit, Sturgeon, Super Cucumber, Truffle, Yam
Worst outcome ingredients [villager friendship loss]:
Any quality: Holly, Pufferfish, Red Mushroom, Sap, Scorpion Carp, Sea Cucumber
Bad outcome ingredients:
Any quality: Anchovy, Blackberry, Carp, Crocus, Daffodil, Green Algae, Herring, Joja Cola, Salmonberry, Seaweed, Spring Onion • Sunfish, Sweet Pea, White Algae
Good ingredients:
Normal quality: Amaranth, Angler, Apple, Artichoke, Beer, Beet, Cactus Fruit, Catfish, Cauliflower, Chanterelle, Cheese, Coffee, Cranberries, Crimsonfish, Crystal Fruit, Dorado, Energy Tonic, Fairy Rose, Glacierfish, Goat Cheese, Goat Milk, Ice Pip, Juice, Kale, Large Goat Milk, Large Milk, Largemouth Bass, Lava Eel, Legend, Lingcod, Maple Syrup, Melon, Milk, Morel, Muscle Remedy, Mutant Carp, Oil, Orange, Pale Ale, Peach, Pike, Pomegranate, Poppy, Purple Mushroom, Red Cabbage, Rice, Snow Yam, Starfruit, Strawberry, Sturgeon, Super Cucumber, Tiger Trout, Truffle, Truffle Oil, Tuna, Vinegar, Walleye, Wine, Yam
More info at: stardewvalleywiki.com/Luau
Thanks for watching!
If you've got some time to kill, have a sample of my Stardew Valley commentated playthrough... no pufferfish poison here ;) • Stardew Valley Playthr...

[@Soulkey_sbr]

Mayor: This soup is disgusting. Does anyone want some? *Everyone comes*

[@SasukeUchiha723]

That's what I was thinking

[@jonathonmulvihill7811]

ikr

[@keelansteele8138]

Soulkey sbr this comment is so funny XD

[@movedtoshuwolfie]

Soulkey sbr lol ikr? Weird!

[@diamondrocks2266]

Soulkey sbr XD

[@bittercharmer4870]

You forgot putting in the mayor's lucky purple shorts

[@Warpzel65]

I think it's before you can do this.

[@loony_toony_yuni]

Adam Wesołowski no it’s not.... you get the quest, and you can get them at any point after you have a two heart friendship with Marnie, and also you can do it in the second year or third! :D I hope that helps?

[@Korockinglife]

@@loony_toony_yuni talking about the version of the game

[@loony_toony_yuni]

C Spa ohhh ok nvm then... :D

[@hayfaamanda2226]

@@loony_toony_yuni hey, so... i already finished mayor lewis' quest about his lucky purple shorts. can i get it back? like, from his wardrobe? i want to use it for something fun :(

[@itsLalm]

funny how it all depends on you.

[@billcipher147]

Yeah, like, what have they been doing all these years before you arrived? Haha

[@Enjibenji]

That's because it's a... Video game where things don't have to make sense

[@vanillamist3606]

LALM thelegendary irk. Pam was adding alcohol into it, Linus was probably pissing in it or something and you put in a nice leek and you get the blame for the bad soup lol

[@tomatosoup7704]

Nein Gag lol!

[@daevon46]

LALM thelegendary yeah it is

[@niknackcreations7586]

Lewis: hey um.. can you find and return my shorts? (Discreetly) Me: -drops shorts into soup

[@unfaithful...]

And we killed the governor.

[@blackmoon4306]

No it’s a secret cutscene

[@-kate110]

Lmaoo I seen videos of it

[@SephTheHuntress]

Marnie: Good soup

[@jrm48220]

They really try hard to guilt-trip you about not putting anything in.

[@At0mHeart]

Yea the first time i tried it i was sweating that the mayor would call me out for not contributing

[@Orchidlettux]

@@At0mHeart Had the same thought too 😂👏

[@atomheart7907]

@@At0mHeart give me back my name you imposter

[@somebody8203]

I thought that I needed to bring c o o k e d f o o d the first time I was in the luau thing

[@the-blind-crow9646]

I gave my friend a lot of jokes about it because he forgot ingrediants

[@ivanm3045]

Adding that unprocessed pufferfish probably straight up killed the governor

[@fnaf_fan3965]

oh crap

[@endergamerm]

i am leaving imediatelly for nepal where i intend to live as a goat

[@100ksubz6]

Damn. *I need some of that soup.*

[@adwans1491]

@@100ksubz6 dickhead

[@pogwater5366]

@@adwans1491 I don't think you understand their response Try reading it again

[@SpeedyWeedyYT]

Me: *puts void mayo in the soup* Governor: *vomits* Lewis: good going guys! Thanks for ruining the festival. Me: yeah nice job guys!

[@shadowmaster1099]

600 likes and no comments?

[@bubblebutt_OO]

641 likes and no comments?

[@LegoBatman2fr]

647 likes and no comments?

[@spotty7769]

657 likes and no comments?

[@TheAlphaStories870]

662 likes and no comments?

[@EChere]

Who knew one man/woman can change the entire soup taste.

[@elisabethotto6082]

The main player is a god ☀️

[@Dragon__Fox]

@@Rosezellious yes i wanna too i put a Great tomato that is not good enough WELL THEN HAVE FOOD POISONING or just D I E

[@dollzo]

Makes you think who bland the town is

[@parry3439]

I mean putting bleach on the soup would make it go bad, so it's really true that one person could do it

[@varian2666]

just put person instead of man/woman

[@marlowmorbid8531]

the governor's dead

[@unconscious7219]

Good, the town deserves better.

[@numerousgeo3015]

Marlow Morbid ha

[@talkativeyapb2745]

Hide the body, forge a will

[@sour_lemon27]

governor is at least 8 times of dead

[@owlgal1111]

Yeah...You need years of training to prepare pufferfish and even then it can still kill whoever eats it...

[@rikithelegendaryheropon8135]

Has anyone else played Harvest Moon DS? Apparently if you put a lvl 100 mushroom into the soup in that game it causes the credits to roll because everyone dies

[@yeaboi3892]

Riki The Legendary Heropon Well that escalated quickly

[@Moonknife]

Riki The Legendary Heropon Thats an intersting speedrun

[@Rilir]

Jonrlax J. Theres an even quicker speedrun where you let your dog keep on attacking the mayor

[@thegrumple5862]

wtf is that game *I love it* xD

[@zhengwenyu1587]

Oh man, the DS version was the very first Harvest Moon I played, I already missed it

[@lukeburdon2930]

If you add nothing and they think something is missing must have been really boring before you come to town

[@anthonybenci9035]

Maybe it senses youre there now

[@unnecessarydelivery5549]

Why do i need to lose friendship points? nobody knows who did it unless.....MARNIE!!! She told the mayor didn't she??

[@Raptor_Ren]

The Hay-Mogul tells the mayor everything in the wee hours of the night.

[@PinkIcedTea]

@@Raptor_Ren PFFFFFFT-

[@MaestroAlvis]

I think everyone lost friendship with everyone else too.

[@endergamerm]

this is why i put 700 torches and campfires in her house , so her house can burn down with that snitch

[@unfaithful...]

@@endergamerm Damn that's so many

[@stardust5138]

I've put in a Red Mushroom in the soup for 76 years, and the Gov'na still looks forwards and eats the mush that's called a soup, and he's still alive.

[@tasertag7513]

That's no governer. That's a bloody legend.

[@letsdothis1543]

@@tasertag7513 The governor is a fish :0

[@tydshiin5783]

Put an iridium grade red mushroom instead Maybe he'll mark the town off the map

[@insomniacperson678]

Well he needed harvey to heal him with surgery

[@cynthiabrogan9215]

You’ve made him immune to poison

[@Vinesaucefan101]

i think pam added some alcohol to the soup.

[@polarknight5376]

@Lazy Reaps hey, certain types of alcoholic beverages can really boost the flavor of foods.

[@PurpleTurtleFan]

Yeah, I think u may watch DF

[@Nobody-qk4xu]

If you add beer to the soup, you'll get a good response, easy peasy

[@MaestroAlvis]

Bottle & all

[@lordyasha5944]

@@martinakascakova1492 time to add some poppy honey

[@natasjakammerman2557]

i think it is funny that if you don't put anything in it is bland... does that mean after my grandfather died for the last XX years it has been bland? and how come he is still so excited for it after all those years

[@lychee-bear1155]

ikr

[@shoooooooooooooooooooooooooobi]

Natasja Kammerman Well simple. Since he died, it no longer required his voice, so I'm guessing it was based on everyone else.

[@otakureiss]

Super late here but I would say it makes sense since the towns people put different ingredients in each year just the year you show up is a bad year.

[@alwest4472]

@@otakureiss what about every year after that,

[@TheFireAngel13]

al west well now you’ve set them up with expectations so they expect better soup

[@Velraz]

Lewis be like : "Whoever put that foul ingredient in the soup made the Governor pass out! I'm ashamed. Well... does anyone want some ?"

[@Manas-co8wl]

I put in a gold star melon in my very first play through. I thought it was a typical response, I didn't know it was one of the best ingredients, hell I didn't even know there WAS an ingredient hierarchy. I did the same thing for the couple of years and... yeah it took me some time to figure out this was a challenge.

[@markmozer3340]

Manas is gold star choliflower works too? i left one just for this event but i dont know of its the best

[@Rabbit-o-witz]

What do you get from this festival anyway?! seems useless to me...

[@corycannotfindthehouse7843]

Mukagas you get a higher friendship boost and a better evaluation from your grandpa

[@jinxedly823]

grdanpa does not evaluate Luau results. He evaluates the friendship with villagers.

[@ernestochang1744]

has anyone ever had a soup with cauliflower or broccoli? of course cauliflower is a great ingredient, its delicious both in game and in real life, just dont add a cave carrot '_' i thought it was a normal cleaned carrot, also pumpkin works really well, hmmm now im hungry

[@juliab7934]

My first year I didn’t know you were just supposed to bring one ingredient, I brought a salad...

[@sparkleshua5512]

I brought bread 😭

[@stxrdoom618]

@@sparkleshua5512 I also brought bread and it didn't work

[@unfaithful...]

I brought a salad too. I can't put a cooked food into the soup. So I just re-join the game and bring nothing.

[@cailin1535]

i brought algae 😭😭

[@GnosisDharma]

@@cailin1535 healthy soup, but maybe not so tasty.

[@brettbarnett3465]

Why does everyone blame the player if it's bad or good? How do they know it wasn't one of them who could have put in a red mushroom.

[@KittyEX]

ikr, i am married to Sam, and he teased about putting a joja cola in the soup that year.

[@thegrumple5862]

*the bastard*

[@elliott8778]

@@KittyEX same

[@determineddaaf3]

Cuz Marnie watches you when you put something in. And tells everyone that YOU put in that nasty red shroom.

[@Daniel-bf9je]

Maybe they dont like anybody

[@Nekoszowa]

* adds pufferfish * "Lol, what a disaster."

[@eggylove3338]

Marnie: Put something in the soup! Me: So wine? Marnie: Well maybe a vegetable or an e- Me: *W I N E*

[@Urog_ii]

i put in some gold star fruit every year since i have to much👶

[@FirestormAnimates]

The Villager going drunk lol 😂 Maybe Pam and Shane will love it

[@joaolima7131]

@@FirestormAnimates actually puting wine or beer enhances the flavor of the soup

[@FirestormAnimates]

@@joaolima7131 Oo! But definitely not going to put my Ancient Fruit Wine there

[@shrimpy_nazeem]

Glass and all

[@Edriely]

My first year I didn't realize I had to bring something so I was just walking over with my tools. Picked up one of the purple flowers on the way just because and then couldn't leave and come back after I was told to put something in. Thought I'd get in trouble or something if I didn't, or the game wouldn't let me continue so I just tossed in the flower figuring, hey, what's it gonna matter anyway. At least it's something. It was something alright. Something disgusting. Though at least I didn't poison anyone so, there's that.

[@lordpengwinviii4825]

Edriely I did the exact same, only I thought that it being silver star it would be better

[@wesleycagle2354]

Similar experience but I just thinking you had to bring a meal and everyone’s meals would be judged. Being my first go around all I had was a field snack 😂😂😭

[@alexisatkins1621]

@@wesleycagle2354 bro literally same i just saw the word potluck and assumed i had to bring a dish, so the day before i bought a pizza from the saloon. i got there and realized my pizza was useless and the only thing i had on me to throw in the pot was a sweet pea :(

[@isabelasemino2929]

Same

[@Hazyla]

Edriely yeah I put in a sweet pea or something XD

[@just-mees]

0:19 I love how emily just randomly dances on her own

[@jamiecasimir5040]

what a queen

[@goldqnp3tals302]

An icon

[@jamiecasimir5040]

@Cool and Smooth Tooth see her heart events then we'll be seeing who's crazy-

[@Moinaaa.]

@Cool and Smooth Tooth I talked to her at the dance of moonlight jellies and she said something eery

[@redmountain8748]

And I love how it says ‘Emily is unresponsive’

[@RedsnowHD]

I had to laugh so hard when i missclicked a red mushroom in the soup ;D

[@estherlauterbach2189]

I did it on purpose in my first year. i thought that since it was gold star it was good.

[@jonathonmulvihill7811]

ikr

[@jonasvage1550]

I also did that on purpose my first year. I chose it because it was the only thing in my inventory I didnt need.

[@ernestochang1744]

i just put cauliflower from my spring harvest, has anyone ever had cauliflower soup? hmmm its the best, throw in some potato with cheese bites and its freaking delicious

[@AlenBear]

...In my case, a gold Super Cucumber I found it in the garbage...

[@pasawatviboonsunti9066]

This person just added a Legend in the soup for everyone to eat. *What a legend.*

[@sweetwheatsy]

I like the fact that Lewis is drinking his soup out of a wine glass, since it's the same sprite as when he's in the saloon drinking

[@FylixAerou]

To the people shocked by him adding The Legend, I would do this too. There's a lot of things that can make money and this doesn't have any special kind of cutscene or dialogue even from Willy. As far as I know this is the only satisfying use for it other than selling it.

[@spire_6451]

yeah.... but there is so many other things to put like the ancient fruit which is pretty common at the point when you can get the legend which require a lot of iridium bars so ancient fruit is my go for thing to put in luau

[@kimothy..]

gold goat chees

[@derpycats8072]

Iridium purple mushroom. Easy

[@Matthew27567]

@@derpycats8072 No you have to get red ones

[@sophiathefurbst]

If you put [163] or the legend id code (I forgot it) in your name a legend spawns in your inventory whenever anyone says your name (depending on what console you’re on)

[@lidianefernandes6602]

Watching this video in 2021, playing the 1.5 update. Here's my recent story with this festival. Sit down folks, here comes the story: The day of the festival I forgot about it and didn't bring any ingredients. A few minutes before the festival starts, I was fishing at the beach and got an iridium super cucumber. It was basicaly the only "good quality" thing I had in my bag. My thougth? "It's an iridium quality super cucumber. What could go wrong?". Turns out it was a really bad ingredient and I got the "worst ingredient" cut scene. I was sooo confused! "IT'S AN IRIDIUM QUALITY INGREDIENT, YOU FUCKING UNGREATEFUL BASTARDS!!!", but then I realized I wouldn't eat a cucumber either. The end.

[@dcmonnie]

What?? I swear I threw in super cucumbers for years and it elicited the best response

[@lunaetic.8819]

@@dcmonnie i’m thinking they meant to say sea cucumber instead, those always receive poor responses. super cucumbers are perfect

[@robloxplays4322]

How did you fish at the beach on the luau day?

[@aubiiu6937]

i’d eat a sea cucumber

[@TailsThewolfcat]

My first ever Luau, I decided to be cheeky and put in a piece of Sap. It was really funny to me.

[@owlgal1111]

I put in gold star chili jelly. I got neutral...

[@mx-mongoose9261]

I put a gold grape

[@vanillamist3606]

Kira hime I think it put a chilli pepper in my first one

[@FatherShaun]

Kira hime I put an ancient fruit

[@lararys7765]

I missed my first luau. On my second luau I put in a gold quality melon and everyone seemed to like it.

[@SneakTheOcto]

In the next update, the player can put in the mayors luck purple “Shorts” in the soup.

[@Coughdropeater]

Me, who cancelled that quest: *NOOOOOOOO*

[@SneakTheOcto]

I actually wouldn’t recommend it. It lowers town friendship a lot. Still funny though.

[@The_Mobile]

No one: Player: *casually stuffs gold quality pufferfish into soup*

[@woooooooooooooooooooooooo]

What about an iridium quality one

[@w1nterdays]

@@woooooooooooooooooooooooo it doesn’t matter. Pufferfish are poisonous. If this happened irl, the governor would be dead

[@thegreenlaser3678]

You added a *Cyanide Pill* to the soup

[@serbiastronk5055]

There is secret outcome you can put mayor’s shirts and governor will pass out but mayor lewis will say who put this in soup...

[@alenzhang4854]

8:39 well, what did you expect from a bunch of people putting random stuff in a big cauldron without talking about it first?

[@SableCatDog]

Good god I feel guilty and I didn't even do it. Poor Mayor!

[@Linktober04]

*Govonor

[@smolbutdedly2822]

Linkmaster 04 **GOVERNOR

[@whotookmypuddingcup4131]

@@smolbutdedly2822 no it's ClEaRlY Gavanar*

[@hirandompeopled4968]

@@whotookmypuddingcup4131 what r u talking about it’s obviously kuvoornuer

[@whotookmypuddingcup4131]

@@hirandompeopled4968 we're both wrong, its gevanyr

[@ellispoo44]

lol the pufferfish one was funny as hell- never saw that one before

[@pyroland4037]

Scott Merrell how to murder silently 101

[@Vinesaucefan101]

sap is another nasty thing to not add to the soup

[@thunderhead9338]

If you want a funny reaction put in the mayors lucky shorts

[@SasukeUchiha723]

I put chilli 🌶 on my first year. and came out a medium response

[@cjpinto7]

Sasuke Uchiha Put a gold star one fresh off my farm and it was mediocre as well.

[@sean8024]

Sasuke Uchiha SAME twins!!

[@SasukeUchiha723]

Sean Scanlan Yup we are... mind if i make you my friend?

[@MelleniumEarl]

same.... golden star too... thinking that was a quality pepper

[@owlgal1111]

+Sasuke Uchiha Same.... except I turned mine into jelly first.

[@NocturnalDecay]

The first time, I added nothing. Then I started using gold star grapes, and at year 5, I realized one of the best was Iridium star L. Goat Milk, and used that instead, and I yelled "I ADDED E X T R A CREAMY GOAT MILK, YALL WELCOME"

[@theproz997]

ShipQueen28 physical cringe

[@whotookmypuddingcup4131]

"Goat milk" Yea, sure.

[@beam1796]

You can actually put the Mayor’s pants in the soup 😂 Mayor Lewis and Marnie have the funniest reactions

[@sofiem1225]

I remember getting the best response my first year, so on year 2 I threw algae in, bc I thought that it didn't matter. Needless to say, I panicked and restarted.

[@dalewayward4540]

what happens if you use the mayors shorts or is that not allowed?

[@SpecterReaper]

but you can put it on Stardew Valley Fair and get disqualified! and Marnie will ask about your "Purple Lettuce"

[@SasukeUchiha723]

dude we have same thoughts goin on here

[@TheFlameSlayer]

the governor would be like hmm it has quite a strange taste to it then the mayor goes to take a drink and has the shorts in his cup. that would be quite a interesting scenario. its a shame non food items cant be thrown in for a even more negative impact

[@crashkojote5627]

Wonder what would happen if the governour discovered a diamond in his soup ^^ "Taste is horrible, but the gem is a nice touch"

[@Themicrochili]

If you can actually put it in I Will die of laughter

[@humanperson2775]

Can't put stones in there for stone soup like the tale... I have some complaints about this game :P lol

[@Fossil-de1qk]

Hah, I got that reference! Man, it's been years since I read that..

[@SpecterReaper]

Animal Gamer man, I remember that thing! thanks for the reference!

[@renatacastillo2012]

Animal Gamer I like that tale, but i prefer the vercion with nails

[@ernestochang1744]

watts funny is that we did it at my school once and i must say that was the best soup i ever had, man i wish i could go back to grade 5

[@maverickdarkrath4780]

Isn't the point of the story that with the right motivation everyone can pitch in, like seriously they basically tricked the town's people into solving there food problem by working together

[@mah1na]

First year I put in a sweet pea. I was greedy and figured since it had 'pea' in the name it was edible.

[@mah1na]

I got the bad ingredient result. Next year I got best result with gold star goat cheese.

[@cinnabundreams33]

I did the same, and because I felt so guilty I restarted and put in a pepper getting a neutral response.

[@Urog_ii]

@@mah1na cheese is also the solution (i have no clue if i spelt it right)

[@ObeyBunny]

You can also get the best outcome by putting in a gold star melon, a silver star starfruit, a silver star goat cheese, a gold star purple mushroom, or a gold star truffle.

[@noopa5229]

8:18 for the disgusted result

[@sologoms]

i always put a iridium quality truffle in

[@kevinshekdar8634]

i gotta say, you work hard on your videos. keep it up!

[@Norovo]

Thanks Kevin :)

[@mehchocolate1257]

@@Norovo I once put in a piece of holly

[@Elfealin]

Can we put something différent that the Legend Fish ?

[@sweetwheatsy]

For the first year, I was pretty lucky to have a Gold Cauliflower, but since I didn't know about the grading system, I kinda just went with real metrics and figured a decent/organic cauliflower would have a good taste in a large, mixpot soup. A good amount of thought has been put into what is fitting and less fitting for the soup, and it's pretty realistic.

[@bubblebat5429]

Did the governor fall in to the soup?

[@alobowithadhd6191]

he vomited

[@allisonretherford5822]

Kieran Ennis He....vomited.... into ....the soup???

[@alobowithadhd6191]

Allison Retherford Haha. It seems like it. I guess it adds to the collective “flavor.”

[@sircalico]

Did you watched the whole video?

[@Mark_OnEarth]

8:32 is the sound

[@paangwin]

“Puts a battery in the soup and proceeds to watch the entire town die”

[@thebarichild4035]

You forgot Louis’ purple underwear response! 😂 that one is great.

[@neon_tcps741]

Pufferfish 24/7.

[@szeptacz5342]

First time i add Field snack :>

[@giantwisper798]

Szeptacz me too, didn't work too well

[@yourlocalgrubdog3345]

Szeptacz Same xD

[@cinnabundreams33]

I added a sweet pea flower the first time... poor, poor governor...

[@bruh-mt2in]

I added sap, didn't go very well.

[@lucasboxerhead]

same

[@irons880]

Omg, I was about to add puff fish in the soup, i thought it's pretty hard to carch fish and it was gold quality and i thought it would be at least good ingredient, thanks God I found this video

[@jasongibson1225]

Lol pufferfish is lethal to eat if it isn't cooked by an expert chef who is licensed to do it. The mayor died

[@strawbebbiejam]

first time i played, i didnt look up a wiki or anything and all i had in my inventory was a granola bar and the guy threw up 😭

[@cc_cate]

so I just got this rename item mod for stardew. so I rename my sapling "Logan Pual". that mayor say it was so bad.

[@tasertag7513]

Nailed it.

[@Andrea-mc6tv]

When you're just in the mood of poisoning your governer with a pufferfish

[@acashasha]

you can also get the best response with a gold quality truffle.

[@SpecterReaper]

or a Silver Quality Starfruit, which I only have one and I'll put it

[@simonnouchuu]

Acashasha 666 yeah i thought it's gonna give me medium response but it gave me gold

[@aleph6603]

Acashasha 666 also gold/iridium cheese does the trick too. Later on in the game it's really easy to get

[@owlgal1111]

+Meimoutsu Gaming Truffles are an extremely rare and expensive mushroom.

[@etrikia]

There's a whole truffle business and it's mostly in europe...

[@oliviaforsyth815]

Your vids are amazing this did really help me thanks xx

[@gobbledygooker1075]

you can also add the mayors shorts to the soup. it gives the reaction of the bad one with a little twist.

[@Horst_Radish]

Maple syrup in a soup sounds interesting

[@colda.f.238]

marnie sees you putting a raw pufferfish in the soup and does nothing to stop you

[@NoahTheNoah]

You forgot the reaction when you put the mayors lucky purple shorts in the soup

[@volfgang1393]

I got the legendary response from adding a gold star red cabbage

[@lkhrizl]

this game its like fable you can be good or evil

[@angelus_solus]

And then, of course, there's the cheeky bastard who added Lewis' boxer shorts one year as their ingredient.

[@Abbys_Labs]

Proof that once again the farmer is the backbone of Pelican Town along with Robin.

[@xpandorasboxx]

I put a morel in on my first year, it actually did well, they liked it surprisingly

[@TruffleSeeker54]

Raven Wolf I've heard that morels have a delicious nutty flavor

[@XORcircuit]

I was on a group farm with my parents and we forgot it was the luau so all we had for the soup was *SAP, A SPICE BERRY, AND A RED MUSHROOM* (The governor hated it-)

[@JacobTheRandom]

This shows that we all matter because just one person missing can destroy good soup.

[@twentyfirstpil0t]

i started playing stardew valley a week ago and when the luau came, i thought i HAD to put something in the soup, the only food thing i had was sap, and i was like “sap is sweet, it’ll taste good!” and was mortified when the guy threw up

[@HORRIOR1]

I wish you could add a deadly ingredient like the puffer fish or poison mushroom to kill the governor, or possibly the entire village...

[@haz_7055]

Several years were slept away in the making of this video.

[@fruitninja7681]

Putting the mayor’s purple shorts does get a special outcome.

[@dabomb9218]

What about the cutscene where you throw the mayors shorts into the soup?

[@elanikparrqx8688]

Dabomb921 this video was made in 2016, dummy

[@diamonddude2106]

I had a bunch of maple syrup so i just chucked one in

[@JACK-bt6pk]

I didn't think it was gonna be such a big deal, I just put an average sunfish in the soup.

[@Matthew27567]

When the governor passes out you hear a sloshing noise and then you cant see the governor so I think he passes out into the soup

[@darinae34]

All hail the governer Ramsay !

[@lem2004]

"IT'S BLAND"

[@woussi8385]

what if you out in Lewis's trousers in?

[@simonnouchuu]

Omar Abdi you can only put soup in it

[@chickenlyle0928]

My man skipped many years in Stardew to give us this video. Mad respect

[@datboi265]

The first luau, all I had to add was algae I found in one of the trash cans. Needless to say, the governor disliked it.

[@ilikebeanies3499]

Us: *Throws a whole azz pufferfish in the soup. Marnie: *K E E P S S T I R R I N G* Edit: Wouldn't it be epic if I put straight up trash in the soup XD Can you do that?

[@amxia]

Red Cabbage is good for this event. The governor said it was perfect so yeno. c:

[@spire_6451]

I hate getting them things so I just put neutral :/

[@danny5441]

I remember that one time I made a playthrough with my friends. I put some gold star fish into the soup and my friends threw goddamn red mushrooms into it. We still had a good laugh while seeing how the governor f*cking died

[@TheMindofagenius1]

what's that thing on the porch slightly to left at the end? looks like some kind of sack(?)

[@Soshiplayz]

I put a red mushroom into mine, surprised that no one died or got ill =)

[@sagaesjohansson]

lol ;)

[@Lexi-sd6jq]

mayors shorts?

[@imapersonright]

A. Lex Sander look it up

[@Clefablestarz]

Would a iridium tilapia be a good fish for the luau? Today's the 8th and luau is on next Thursday. I guess I could try for a gold sturgeon but there fishing game is almost impossible to do

[@prophet3091]

I always use gold quality ancient wine and it works like a charm, doesn't take much effort either as long as you're planning ahead

[@waleedahmed4591]

Sap is also the best ingredient

[@spire_6451]

thank you it worked

[@kennethwilliams2157]

The common Sap?

[@bmacmillan]

The first time I used sap that a. Bad idea

[@LadyRey96]

xD same. forgot about it and everything i had in my inventory to put in there was sap....

[@foxloaf8843]

bit late but now you can put the mayor's shorts in the soup, gives unique dialogue from lewis/governor

[@don2thegero]

At first I thought the governor died in the last one...

[@Gryphonzwing]

Can you add the Mayor's Underwear too it? lol

[@CalorDragon]

Gryphonzwing Nah, you can only put food there. Believe me, I tried it

[@richy_tornado]

Just Khayle in 1.3 you can

[@tamamanitohei9334]

Gryphonzwing DangerouslyFunny tried it. The mayor and governor were really pissed, with it had a tangy taste!

[@s0nyn568]

Yup

[@amykluck7523]

I did it on my first ever play through. . . .Bad idea . . . .

[@exequielaloi731]

i put in my very first time a Gold-star grape it worked!

[@intanismail7794]

Exequiel Aloi same

[@exequielaloi731]

c:

[@Therese231999]

I remember putting an Iridium quality ingredient there, but only got "pleasant" as a response. Guess going higher than a gold star doesn't change much.

[@SiennasSketches2021]

I have PTSD from not putting something in the soup and then getting called out in front of the entire village in my friend’s multiplayer game.

[@theskyisfalling3042]

Actually, there’s a different cutscene if you put Mayor Lewis’ lucky purple shorts inside the soup. It’s pretty.... interesting