Did SLAVERY Continue After the Civil War? (Slavery and Sharecropping Compared)

[@teddyrapp3043]

Ever since I discovered your channel I have been watching your APUSH videos, and they have made my class so much less stressful and more enjoyable. Your videos are engaging and I really like watching them. Thank you so much for doing what you do! I can’t even express how grateful I am

[@heimlershistory]

Wow, that’s a magnificent comment. That’s exactly what I hope these videos do. So thanks for making a bald man smile…

[@edgardovaldivia3552]

I love your videos Heimler, love how you can make history fun and interesting. I have been using your videos for over a year and you have saved me multiple times from failing.

[@heimlershistory]

That’s awesome… glad we’re in it together!

[@samuelhuber6885]

Three of my grandparents were sharecroppers. In fact, I guess you could even say that my father was a sharecropper, since as a boy he picked cotton with my grandparents when they were still sharecropping. "Working on the halves" is what my grandfather called it. He never complained about it, but he did say things were better after he bought his own farm around 1950.

[@TheHoodVoice2024]

My grandmother and grandfather was sharecroppers on my mom and dad side

[@generalgrievous3731]

Quite interesting. Already finished APUSH with a 5, but it's always good exercise to challenge one's mind, casting modern biases aside and delving deep into a complex historical situation

[@dreambig7965]

Hello, how did you get a 5? Do you remember the LEQ and DBQ topic?

[@generalgrievous3731]

@@dreambig7965 I took the 2021 exam. It's been posted. I remember the DBQ was about economic growth in the 20th century and for the LEQ I choose the one about imperialism. I got a 5 by studying review books and reading through every chapter in the textbook. Also, I took AP Euro and got a 5 on that last year, so I already know the writing skills and the rubrics, which definitely helped.

[@cgkkjggh9290]

The damaging effects of slavery are still felt today in this country

[@Joachim_Meyer]

I love your videos Heimler, but I wanted to ask you about this. You consistently say that slavery was abolished by the 13th amendment, but I find that a bit misleading considering that slavery was very much still allowed "as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted." This led to the over-imprisonment and policing of blacks after Reconstruction failed in companionship with Jim Crow Laws. Please correct me if any of this is wrong, but I thought it was a good point to bring up and I am curious about your position on this.

[@heimlershistory]

You’re absolutely right on that. Slavery as a legal system of labor was abolished by the 13th Amendment, but that punishment clause has been responsible for continued marginalization…

[@Joachim_Meyer]

@@heimlershistory Alright, I just wanted to check and make sure I wasn't spreading any misinformation. Also want to thank you for serving me well during my sophomore and junior years in APUSH and AP Euro and now in AP Gov. Although Gov has been a lot easier than the past two classes, I've remained subscribed to your channel because of the lasting impact you had on me and I will remain subscribed for the quality historical videos even if I don't "need" them anymore.

[@joshpaulson9607]

@@bychen5011 I think he’s talking about shortly after the 13th amendment, not present day

[@radcat8550]

@@bychen5011 I think the high rate of imprisonment is caused by a mix of both excessive incarceration and making bad decisions, but it is important to consider that high crime rates are linked to the underserving of communities. I recommend the novel Long Way Down by Jason Reynold’s; it puts a face on this issue

[@blugaledoh2669]

Involuntary servitude is not the same as slavery. Although both terms have been sometime used synonymously, the main difference is that slavery is fundamentally about ownership of the person.

[@zidaankapoor7026]

Loved the thumbnail :) Congrats on 300k subs! See you at 1 million.

[@heimlershistory]

Ha, thanks! Given my niche, I can’t imagine finding a million people to subscribe. But if it happens, I’ll see you there!

[@korinanabarrete]

This is the first video I've watched of yours but I can tell you are a great teacher and make things interesting!

[@heimlershistory]

Aw thanks!

[@orbit5311]

great video as always Heimler!

[@heimlershistory]

Well, thank you very much 🙏

[@breadlinesareagoodthing4079]

Slavery has existed since men's early existence And continues even to this day. It's heartbreaking.

[@heimlershistory]

Agreed

[@opheliaretardanta8348]

Thank you Hiemler love your helpful videos for all the different AP histories it really makes me have a better understanding ❤

[@opheliaretardanta8348]

*Heimler

[@LolaFansOnly]

thanks for making this video!

[@studentofhistory1848]

this video is awesome thanks for helping me study!

[@gabrielbarragan5093]

Plz make more merch Heilmer. Heilmer APUSH poster?

[@fatimarizvi7732]

Will you be doing micro Econ videos?

[@heimlershistory]

Ha, you wouldn’t want me doing those. Check out Jacob Clifford, though. He knows what he’s talking about.

[@gabrielbarragan5093]

Will you be doing AP European History?

[@heimlershistory]

Yep, but next school year

[@pattystomper1]

History Lesson: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gIDcn42wjd6khpI

[@TheSPORTS504]

This guy is an apologist ..sharecropping was slavery , just couldn’t do it the old way , during that there was peonage and convict leasing …..he talking about how it looked .. my grandmother etc told me how it felt and what it was … the terror , hopelessness and death …

[@karenhorton148]

And it was 1863. It was kept from US until 1865-JUNETEENTH

[@davecooper9733]

Sharecropping and prison labor is taking place of slavery

[@gracex4251]

Taking the test on thursday, I'll update what I get

[@guiitarfreak_]

Well?

[@me3482]

Which was?

[@glmghq6850]

"they would work for further rights and freedom"???? ummmm "work"???????? or did you mean MARCH AND STAND UP FOR THEIR RIGHTS???.....

[@jonny_walters77]

What happened to the macroeconomic videos ;-;

[@jacquesreilly1850]

I got nothing against anything.

[@elsasienna7489]

My teacher met you, Mrs guyer

[@karenhorton148]

1863

[@LolaFansOnly]

for algorithm pt 2

[@atstudios6938]

8th

[@heimlershistory]

Noice

[@YepX]

Your video is wrong from the start, if you read the 13th Amendment closely - slavery wasn't abolished, just reformed.

[@SandfordSmythe]

Involuntarily servitude is not slavery

[@83wasagoodyear]

​@@SandfordSmythesure 👌

[@djrobinson6602]

This sounds like Serfdom

[@LolaFansOnly]

for algorithm

[@r0bkush]

Abe was a black man ✊🏾