STUPID Black Butler theories

[@_knshoujo]

god i remember the "rciel poisoned ociel" theory 😭 the fact that people actually believed this was insane to me

[@happilyevernever4289]

People used to think 2CT was stupid too. Let's not rule it out just yet.

[@yashashwiwardhansingh]

I need help who is rciel????? One eye??? Or two eye????

[@dollygiki13]

I've never believed in the theory that Sebastian is secretly Ciel's father, due to Sebastian and Vincent looking alike apparently. Also, the belief that a grown up version of Ciel would look like Vincent isn't very convincing to me either.

[@WeebaLu]

I always believed Sebastian looked like Vincent solely because of Yana's same-face syndrome issue during her early artwork. 🤣

[@dollygiki13]

@@WeebaLu Absolutely.

[@SebastianEatsCoats]

This wasn't exactly a popular theory in the fandom but this was a theory I had when I was 12. So near the end of book of circus, Beast, Dagger, Peter, Wendy and Jumbo break into the phantomhive mansion to try and kill Ciel and basically everyone whos in there. Long story short they all end up getting killed by the servants, however there was 1 particular death that was basically the base for my theory. So when Dagger died he was killed by Bardroy, him and Beast were in the kitchen and Bardroy tried to shoot Beast but Dagger shielded her with his body and basically sacrificed himself to save her, only for Beast to be blown up a few minutes later. I also took the information on how grim reapers are made (basically when a human kills themself) and dumb 12 year old me was just like "wait a minute, Dagger knew he would probably die by sacrificing himself to save Beast, therefore he had an intent to die which could be ruled as killing yourself". I then came to the conclusion that DAGGER BECAME A GRIM REAPER AND WAS GOING TO RETURN IN THE FUTURE 😭 I even wrote a fan fiction about it (which I unfortunately never finished) and in the fan fiction I also made a headcanon similar to the Claude being Sebastian and William's child theory, I made it so Dagger and Ronald were brothers but didn't know it until the end. Why did I do that? Because they just happened to have the same hair colour, not knowing that Dagger literally dyed his hair when joining the circus because in flashbacks it showed him as a child with brown hair, so that was basically all for nothing. I also put in my fan fiction that the Undertaker had brought Beast and Joker back to life (despite my fan fiction being set before Undertaker figured out how to actual people back from the dead and not just how to make bizarre dolls) I guess it was because when I was 12 I loved book of circus and was really sad to see the circus members die so I just made up an excuse to bring some of them back to life.

[@teomeows]

Just wanna point out that Ronald most likely has bleached his hair and dyed his hair blonde too, considering his hair is two-toned and darker in the back. So just like Dagger, he isn't naturally a blondie either.

[@inthemoondust]

The poison theory had me WHEEZING. 😭 and the "Yana probably forgot she gave him asthma" sounds so real considering how slow Black Butler has been for well...years? (which IS sad). Also hello fellow Furina haver! ❤️

[@WeebaLu]

Yeah, I get that Twisted Wonderland probably gives her a fuck ton of that good Disney money but ya know, it'd be nice if she focused on Black Butler again! Also yes! I adore Furina, she's one of my all time favorite Genshin characters! 🥰

[@inthemoondust]

@@WeebaLu Same here for Furina!!! And I agree, because the chapters have been super short, the plot barely moved and it sometimes makes me think, will we see the end of Black Butler when we all grow old? 😭

[@happilyevernever4289]

Well yeah..coz isn't it suspicious how our Ciel never contracted asthma during his time at the cult? Even our Ciel recognizes mentions this while making a contract with Sebastian. So it's not a theory completely out of left field. Coz it has some good basis for it unlike Sebastian being Vincent lmao.

[@the_earltrancy666]

Okay, the William and Sebastian theory had my brain hurting. And the poison theory is very fucking stupid. Great vid❤❤

[@inthemoondust]

I forgot to mention, I can't remember if that dumpster of a person, Ciel Star had a theory of Our Ciel being called Astre or something. Belongs to the dumb section considering who made it up.

[@WeebaLu]

I remember someone I mentioned in a video before who took every theory he said as if Yana herself said them. I do think Astre has some merit to it, it's not a totally bad theory and I do like the name personally, but apparently Severus seems to be the more likely name. Not...my favorite because I just think of Snape, but it does make a lot of sense!

[@alexander_yoko]

I swear, these theories only show how delusional some people in the fandom can be. But the worse theory/ headcanon that I heard is that William is a transphobe. As a trans guy who loves William, this really upsets me. There's not even a trace of evidence for that. He never misgenders Grell in the original Japanese manga, never mocked her identity or saying anything about it in the first place. And Grell is very happy around him as well. Thanks for this video, I guess I'll watch more of your stuff!

[@mysticalkeyblade759]

I love this video and I’m wondering if Tanaka’s real reason for staying with r! Ciel was to keep an eye on him and he can tell our Ciel what’s gonna happen

[@WeebaLu]

Unfortunately, that's not likely to happen when Tanaka doesn't know where Our!Ciel fled to or that he's crashing with Lau. He admits himself it's solely out of duty to be the butler of the estate until he dies, regardless of which twin is in power. Not a bad theory though!

[@theworstchannelyouhaveever9573]

Now we need stupid Jojo theories.

[@harrissyed1603]

i heard a theory once that Sebastion is not just a normal demon but high level one seeking to use Ciel soul to bring about the apocoplyse but like it doesnt really make sense consider Sebastion is never shown to have a serious agenda expect eating Ciel and also why wouldn't he just enslave another set of demons like Claude

[@BrandonLee-v8z]

I had my own theory that Sébastien was ociels father cause they looked familiar and when ask to take down the painting he looked shocked

[@aova687]

My theory is that Sebastian and Hermes are related.

[@Rhaivanna996]

This is not a theory, just a question to every BB fan. Cause I’ve seen BB soooo many times by now: How did RCiel summoned a demon? lol. It’s never quite explained exactly HOW Sebastian was summoned. Did RCiel did a mini ritual while he was captive? I haven’t read the whole manga but are there any theories/answers on this? By the way… what are your thoughts on a new season 2024 of Black Butler ?

[@WeebaLu]

Sebastian was summoned via the ritual the cult who purchased the twins. RCiel was sacrificed and his blood+soul was used as payment to bring Sebastian over to the other side. Sebastian explains it like payment for crossing a bridge? Something like that! RCiel had nothing personally to do with the summoning, but his death broke OCiel which probably interested Sebastian enough to cross over.

[@Lisa-mu6kf]

first😭