Subaru, and The True Timeline of Re:Zero: THE "WHO'S REM?" CUT

[@bloswi]

Subaru with "Rem" (Whoever she is) erased is literally a THOUSAND times more impressive

[@urtoryu_dy_althraidn]

Is what I'd assume at least. Not like I remember what the alternative looks like, I just take Subaru's word for it since he says this Rem girl was great and all.

[@bloswi]

@@urtoryu_dy_althraidn I just read the alternative and it's like a spinoff or something

[@Hlebuw3k]

Re:Zero "Take your meds" edition

[@electrichunnel6281]

I have a few thoughts about Subaru knowing Pucks name 1) Puck is the great spirit of fire so its possible that Emilia and Puck could have assumed that Subaru is some sort of well studied scholar, which would be disproven cuz Subaru is still learning to read in the mansion 2) they might have thought that its he knew of Pucks existence because of hes apptitude for spirits, which would be even more convincing when they realise he can just magicaly find beatrices door, though they would probably doubt that to an extent since Puck did need to teach him about how magic works

[@bikalpsatyal6699]

Pucks publicly known name is “the beast of the end” a scholar or books written by someone like that wouldn’t know him by puck so your first option doesn’t work to get his name (plus just studying wouldn’t let him sense the spirits presence in the room)

[@xxsupersayen34xxnoe33]

​@@bikalpsatyal6699don't quote me on this but I think in prophecy of the throne some guy interested in spirits meet puck for the first time and call him puck

[@brybot3288]

In this “true timeline” Subaru had already learned to read in a timeline he died in he gave a whole speech to Rem about how he learned w them but no one remembers before Ram kills him.

[@electrichunnel6281]

@@brybot3288 i dont think he learned to read in the 12 days or so he had in the mantion before the true timeline considering all the stuff he did other than just practice reading he probably finished learning in the month between the mansion arc and the white whale arc

[@electrichunnel6281]

@@bikalpsatyal6699 ah ok then, thanks mate

[@sanek_1648]

Schizbaru really has some impressive achievements under his belt, huh

[@Hlebuw3k]

9:41 That would be really funny but more realistically she just tosses him outside the library and the maid Rem has to drag him to the bed

[@kazutrash]

@@Hlebuw3k truuuuue LOL. I imagine a lot of the time he’ll just be sitting there for hours until someone stumbles upon him

[@ManpreetSingh-hj8st]

Whos rem?

[@Hlebuw3k]

@@ManpreetSingh-hj8st i for real made a typo i meant ram

[@sigiligus]

@@Hlebuw3k So just edit it

[@Hlebuw3k]

@@sigiligus it will lose the heart if I edit the comment now :(

[@AlexRight]

Man, when watching you don’t really clock just how absurd the Arc 2-3 stuff is without Rem lmao, Rem was somewhat carrying his ass in the eyes of others 😭

[@AwesomeBH241]

This is such a good video idea holy shit

[@MylovelyLove-qq9fm]

Damn now it makes sense why people of priestella were going crazy for him the stories must have been crazy subaru from his view died multiple times hating himself thinking he is worthless and powerless to using help of others to defeat strong enemies cause he can't do so himself and that's what he thinks about his personality but for others he must be a fucking legendary madman it's weird seeing the parallels

[@Tobestuckornottobe]

That Rem girl really came out of nowhere. I cant believe the author would add such bad writing.

[@psf_dioufmaulana3040]

And how the author retcon all the previous events to include her

[@Tobestuckornottobe]

@@psf_dioufmaulana3040 fr! It's so weird!! Arc 3 had stakes because Subaru had to defeat the demon dogs, save the children, and then himself all alone, still very weak!!! Adding Rem ruins that!!!

[@tmlarkynado7604]

​@@Tobestuckornottobe ...Arc 2...

[@Tobestuckornottobe]

@@tmlarkynado7604 yes. I kind of got the number wrong.

[@Puppypitsu]

I hope you cover the LN and WN of everyone eaten by Gluttony till arc 6 and onwards if possible. Would love to see that perspective.

[@kazutrash]

@@Puppypitsu I’ll probably do what I did for this video. Do one just covering the season, then another in depth one with all the gluttony victims gone 👌🏽

[@wymarsane7305]

Ah yes. The "Who's Julius?" cut.

[@ZEROxyx]

I love this video. Thanks for recapping right as season 3 released!

[@kazutrash]

@@ZEROxyx happy to help :)

[@KingLAO2964]

Man, this timeline is only going to get crzier and crazier

[@Shorkii.]

11:30 I believe your interpretation is correct as Ram states how Subaru was responsible for half and Roswaal did the rest. She never mentions herself so I assume she never went to help. Edit: Epsiode 17 season 1 14:00

[@kazutrash]

Oh wait she said that? When was that? I’m glad I made the right choice then hahaha

[@Shorkii.]

she says it at 14:00 episode 17 of first season sorry for my mistake in og. But yes she literally does say that she and Roswaal helped clean up the rest so I assume he did everything solo up until the point Roswaal kills the big ulgarm with Al goa

[@mike-._]

I heard that the author only added Rem in because people complained about Roswaal healing 1 horn when demons are supposed to have 2

[@brandonwithnell612]

i think ram sort of half remembers going into the forest with subaru but the more she tries to think about it the less she remembers as her brain cant explain it without rem, so its sort of like a fuzzy memory that she cant tell is real or not

[@astk5214]

my boy is a bipolar genius!!

[@turtleretward1860]

Next season will be fun for you to make, its not like there will be a certain sin arch bishop related to gluttony or anything

[@joaquincorrea6589]

Right now there is a sin Archbishop of gluttony in Priestella

[@turtleretward1860]

@@joaquincorrea6589 Oh boy wow, I sure hope they don't eat any names 😉😉

[@joaquincorrea6589]

@@turtleretward1860 idk, Otto has not been named recently. Im scared.

[@Axodus]

@@joaquincorrea6589 oh god pls no, don't take Otto away, he had such a hard upbringing and his ability is OP.

[@jaye4773]

Julius we hardly knew ye. Well, now you don't either.

[@Subaru_Natsukii]

this video was PEAK bro

[@penzorphallos3199]

I feel like ReZero is just the AWARE twitch emote over and over

[@whatever0000]

Another great video good job!

[@bettergang2004]

Am i dreaming? I saw this video upload ages ago, and now it only out now? Something smell fishy here!

[@kazutrash]

It’s a remaster of those old videos!

[@rotteegher39]

The mood swings are so hilarious. This is a best part of Subaru. Just a minute you are talking to him peacefully and seconds later you see his horrified face as if he had died and then instane PTSD + hysteria rolling on the ground.

[@JJBitter]

As far as I can tell Ram can't smell the witches scent, only onis who had encountered certain archbishop are able to detect it. Amazing video!

[@bibbobella]

I wonder how many knows of the witch cult's gospel.... If it is common knowledge that the gospel is capable of predicting the future to a certain extend (I have no clue whether it is well known or not) it might also help people understand why Subaru is so knowledgeable. They know he has the witches' scent and they know he has a HUGE grudge against the witch cult and terrifying amount of knowledge about them. So if they are aware of the gospel then I would imagine a lot of people just assume Subaru had somehow been able read part of the gospel while getting away from the cult if he didn't outright have a copy of it that he used in secret. I doubt the soldiers would even question why he would keep it hidden. It would be a powerful, and kind of terrifying, item that would make him A LOT of enemies, so keeping that card close to his chest would make a lot of sense. I could even see some of the soldiers actually respecting Subaru even further with him trusting them enough to tell them about this item, even if he didn't outright state he had it. Like, not only does Subaru know exactly where the cult is located and their plans, he also knows about the leader's power that is capable of taking over people's bodies. If I were a soldier I would make the assumption that Subaru isn't just a former capture of the cult, but that he had actually been one of the fingers before, somehow, getting away from the cult. He has so much insider knowledge that I would assume he was actually one of the leading figures, but the fact he clearly hated the cult and had just helped kill one of the strongest beasts that was venerated by the cult I wouldn't suspect him to be a double agent. I would assume he had somehow managed to not only fight his way out, but also avoid losing himself to having been possessed since it sounded like he knew he could easily become a target for possession by the main leader's power, and how in the world would he have known that if it hadn't happened to him before? Overall, I think it explains the trust a lot of the soldiers show Subaru. Yes, he is suspicious, but he is actually so suspicious that there is no real way he would be a spy, because it just wouldn't make any sense for him to give all of that information and even help kill the white whale for seemingly no reason. The cult wins NOTHING by having him give all of that information, so what would it gain from him being a spy? Nothing. They only lose from it. So he almost certainly isn't a spy.

[@TerrelSam]

Crush brought up a similar point in the first loop he tried to recruit her. She said with all his info either he's a spy or former victim that's hellbent on revenge

[@martianunlimited]

#12:35 Any reason why Ram would make an ice sculpture that is half Roswaal and half Subaru in the "who's Rem?" version? (also why would there be a pool full of mayonaise?)

[@cole7463]

Ram tried to make a full Roswaal statue and completely failed (because she is Ram). As a reward for Barusu, Roswaal tried to give him a buttload of mayo. Ram accidentally dropped a few buckets of it into the bath.

[@SuperExplosivegames]

Yes! I think i dropped a comment about this on the last video!

[@jberry6093]

Guys who’s this rem person

[@mr.cassette6469]

less gooo new vid

[@Narezano-ws6st]

can someone please explain to me who's rem in the light novel, why's she mentioned a lot?

[@alex_zetsu]

Ram and Rom are pronounced differently. Ever used a CD-ROM? You know the things that existed before USB keys? A computer nerd would know. A person with less knowledge might wonder why Chrome is using so much "RAM"

[@kazutrash]

@@alex_zetsu yea I know they’re pronounced differently lol, I was talking about the old man who runs the loot house and the pink haired maid; Rom and Ram EDIT: HEY WAIT DID YOU EDIT THIS? I swear it said Rem and Ram before, but anyway in this video I’m using the dub names. I forgot to include that when I re-recorded the intro lol, so in the dub they’re the same

[@bloswi]

I read it as Ram too because... that's how it's pronounced But despite that I actually see why it just makes more sense to say "Ram" instead of "Ram"

[@bobthebuilder3609]

Bro sounds like he just RBDed ​@@kazutrash

[@balkan.improvement1696]

The video is cool and all , but how did you mess up the hair in the thumbnail? (Its RED)

[@Jsilentwolf]

🐐

[@BoredLNs]

can you do a video (or several) were you just edit "the true timline" and cut out all of the rebirths so we (I) can watch it with just what others see

[@BoredLNs]

without any extra talking

[@BoredLNs]

can you also tag me in that video so I can watch it

[@xxsupersayen34xxnoe33]

will you make another cut when appa sale guy's name get eaten in arc 11?

[@killbill196]

this video was nice

[@Jormungandr633]

It wasn’t a rental hall. That’s the mansion they moved into after the last one burned down. It’s owned by a relative of Roswell

[@crobisbobis]

Ep 1-3 and episodes 23-70+ nothing changes so honestly who cares, might as well include her

[@Cloudedits0]

28:17 they don't know yet that they are 3 trials

[@ALL4ONE5288]

whos rem ,nobody remember her including ram nee sama.

[@rigogarrido4289]

Love it 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@A_itsar]

Isn't rem the only one who can smell the witches scent and Ram can't?

[@xxsupersayen34xxnoe33]

yes

[@Subaru_Natsukii]

going from knowing about Pucks existence and powers, asking Emelia for her name then when wakes up says i'm back here again should seem hella sus to everyone at the mansion IMO lol

[@TerrelSam]

Apparently some characters have an educated guess that he has time related abilities but they don't know the trigger is death.. iirc from the comment I saw Beako and Roswall have the best guess and Otto is suspicious

[@brandonwithnell612]

to be fair with the mansion one it was canonically his second time waking up in that bed being knocked out by betty earlier so they probably just brushed it off as that

[@ElephantThePotato]

Why do you pronounce Ram as Rom?

[@bettergang2004]

At this point we all can say Who is kazutrash??? Looks like "Who is Rem?" is a good way to make video reupload and pretend it never were out ages ago

[@tmlarkynado7604]

Is this an advanced joke? Cause this is insane humour 😭😭😭

[@bettergang2004]

@@tmlarkynado7604 More like a scream of confusion. I couldn;t tell whether i got to see an old video be constantly referred to as a new video by multiple people or am i someone who saw the future? Can i really say tjat i am a prophet that can see the future? i highly doubt that, honestly

[@Ch3BuraShka5]

Ahahahhahah! eah! thats it!

[@10101m]

yes

[@herbalttv]

betty not getting affected by announcement of RBD is because she was made by echidna

[@cole7463]

No, (cut content: during the 1year time skip, Subaru tried to inform Betty multiple times, but ultimately failed.) The more reasonable explanation would be that he was quieter than the anime made him seem.

[@herbalttv]

@@cole7463 thanks for this info. this makes more sense since i never read the LN and just watch the anime.

[@kittentamer2164]

The actual reason, if you don't mind spoilers: When the doors are closed to the library, it's actually a pocket dimension. Satella cannot 'see' Subaru here. Thus, RBD and the consequences of confessing it do not exist. This means the time Subaru tried to die in the library very nearly was a permanent death and Betty actually saved the story. The caveat is *all* the doors in the library need to be closed. If a single door is open, it's still connected to Satella's domain. Subaru can confess RBD in places where Satella cannot 'see' him for whatever reason. Usually due to it being a private/pocket space. In theory, being put in a pocket dimension by Al Shamac would do it. A lot of vulnerabilities do exist now that you know about it. RBD is not foolproof. What makes RBD seemingly unbeatable is that nobody knows that he has it. Right? People finding out about it is worse than dying because he could be permanently killed. Now, I wonder what could possibly protect this secret forever... surely not a failsafe to ensure he can't tell anyone yes?

[@アキラ-です]

Who's Rem again?

[@prakigam]

Where’d this blue haired chick come from?

[@MieuxMerci]

People keep insisting that Emilia and Puck should have brought up Subaru knowing Puck, and shouting to shield Emilia but being aware of the great spirits isn't that weird since knowing that physical forms for great spirits are hard to maintain is common knowledge. It is also possible that Puck doesn't care that Subaru knew of him because he can read his intentions and since they weren't negative he ignores it. Emilia had a million other things on her mind in the moment like the INSIGNIA that literally determines her eligibility for the royal selection and a pretty intense fight with Elsa and saving Subaru and deciding what to do next. Much of the story takes place from Subaru's perspective (we miss a lot of what happens while Subaru is out cold in anime) so another explanation is that Emilia brought it up with Puck later in private or while Subaru was unconscious and Puck tells her not to worry about it or something similar to that. All told there's plenty of good reasons not to bring up Subaru's awareness of Puck outside of the Chibi shorts. Nice video though! Really enjoying The Rezero content.

[@DaGaJbmKojJe]

It was brougght up in a chibi short video

[@MieuxMerci]

@@DaGaJbmKojJe I know. I said ''outside of the chibi shorts." I'm talking about outside the shorts meaning only the main anime series because lots of videos make the Puck observation as though it is some kind of plot hole that should've been addressed, but it really isn't.

[@treeperson1655]

he seems like an ex member tho . He was tweakin while talking to emilia like shes satella. How can someone mistake someone for public enemy number one like he knows satella. He spoke of satella very highly as well.

[@Ravi9A]

😢😢😢

[@darngawn16]

😮

[@ShifterBo1]

Ok ok cool original character, but REALLY, who is Rem???

[@bluejay2749]

If Rem did exist, then that would’ve been peak.

[@marchrushart6594]

I never watched re:zero, so i will just assume this is mostly canon because i am too lazy to watch re:zero

[@TerrelSam]

Tldr the mc resets to a checkpoint with all his memories when he dies and this is pretty much how events would look to everybody else without seeing his loops

[@marchrushart6594]

@@TerrelSam ty