They figured Makoto desintegrating and losing his skin was way too traumatizing
@you-5-iver8043 ай бұрын
They shoulda figured its pissed alot of us off bcuz that was iconic.
@Ale-Y3 ай бұрын
I kinda liked how creepy the original was, but i like how more emotional this one is
@recordkeepertype06623 ай бұрын
Original: Pain of Nightmare Fuel Remake: Pain of Emotional Hurt
@oranim123 ай бұрын
@@recordkeepertype0662 What it loses in nightmare fuel, it gains in the tear-jerker territory. Can't wait for TV Tropes to write that one out. XD
@Emperorwolf9993 ай бұрын
i mean it was gross AF and also confusing to see Minato turn into organs and letters then butterflies
@TheCrazyTonyMendez3 ай бұрын
4:10 Did anyone notice a shadow of Metis formed in Aigis's dream ending?
@rattango98193 ай бұрын
aww man. they changed it. that was the best part about the answer.
@cruddyzebrathegamer9793 ай бұрын
What specifically did they change
@alexroobtensaier3 ай бұрын
@@cruddyzebrathegamer979 i assume the finishing blow cutscene? that's the biggest change here i think if you look up the original cutscene in FES, his *skin* literally disintegrates. then his muscles. then his bones. then his organs. there's like letters peeling themselves off his body floating everywhere as he just. a dissappears... super gory, pretty traumatic. i mean i'm not too into gore anyway, but yknow. the impact, or something. P3R's was cool and kinda uh, added salt to the wound the same way as FES, but yeah.
@farizr.batarai82713 ай бұрын
@@cruddyzebrathegamer979i mean in the ending cutscene you litteraly see him disintegrate atom by atom iirc the order is Letters peel of from his skin then the muscles and organs then the bones and then he disintegrates into butterflies
@hiitsalex67803 ай бұрын
Would you lose? Makoto: "Nah, I'd win."
@LazerShark77773 ай бұрын
Stand Proud Aigis You are Alive
@Tubular_dude_20y_ago3 ай бұрын
"You were Magnificent Makoto. I shall have Memories of You™ for as long as you seal"
@yamatonoryuujin48713 ай бұрын
Could've used the original one as an intro showing how creepy and eery it is that their regrets created a shadow of Makoto. While keeping the new one as the cutscene when you beat him which shows a more somber and heartfelt send off.
@evice3 ай бұрын
9:01 That was sneaky. Lol *I'd like to add that there's a like and subscribe text stealthily showing up at time in the video imo. This is still a good video tho.
@craftergamer90583 ай бұрын
Damn shadow Makoto got a huge nerf in reload.
@Shadoxas3 ай бұрын
Would’ve been funny if shadow Minato used Castor during their fight. Would’ve loved to see Ken’s and Akihiko’s reaction.
@Emperorwolf9993 ай бұрын
8:12 OH THATS SO COOL. also, interesting, ???'s reverse personas are pale now instead of black
@raphaelledesma93933 ай бұрын
Personally, IDK what angle the developers were going for in the original showing Makoto disintegrating very graphically system by system. Was it meant to show the rawness of the separation? But admittedly bewilderment rather than an emotional reaction was what it caused in me although I liked the ending of the scene where the memory of him flashed as if to remind everyone of whom they lost. Wish that was included in the remake but the remake at least more straightforwardly shows that the point of the scene was to show longing and sadness.
@JetLagRecords3 ай бұрын
DismArchus, cool content keep it up bro
@milesstorzillo76503 ай бұрын
Honestly, I much prefer this version. The original had no reason to be as horrific as it was beyond shock factor. It was just scary for the sake of being scary. It helps that here they're focusing much more on the characters' reactions to it. I also like how he just closes his eyes before completely fading as if he's saying "This is how it should be".
@bct23083 ай бұрын
My thoughts exactly. This version made me shed a tear. The old one was just creepy as shit for no real reason.
@settledmarker97643 ай бұрын
Bro I need to find out that song we’re makoto is disappearing
@iiy97093 ай бұрын
the butterflies :'((((((
@Essu_3 ай бұрын
Are you fucking with me? Come on ATLUS lmao.
@gamerbeast36163 ай бұрын
the orginal one is way to gory for todays standards probbaly
@ignit893 ай бұрын
I like the reload ver better imo
@jasoncosmic19963 ай бұрын
The dead man.
@DarkShadow-qj9np3 ай бұрын
Looks like Atlus made that cutscene: ❌️ Traumatising ✅️ Emotional Although the FES version is interesting, I prefer the Reload version as it looks beautiful...
@bct23083 ай бұрын
FINALLY. I swear everyone else is “OH THERES NO GRUESOME SHIT SO IT SUCKS” and then there’s, like, a few people who actually appreciate the cutscene. I feel validated.
@ItaChu787pr3 ай бұрын
Might as well spoil myself.... Thanks 😂😂😂
@shadowgamerz69243 ай бұрын
I likes reload version because its emotional instead doing that creepy one which it was interesting
@leo301433 ай бұрын
I miss door kun
@haridojamaru8293 ай бұрын
You know this part really reminds me of kingdom hearts like how you fight anti sora at the end of kingdom hearts dreams drop distance both sora and makoto dies in the end with a unique situation
@1aundulxaldin3 ай бұрын
They managed to get cutscenes and dialogue down exactly like the original one played on PS2, which is pretty incredible.
@Archon39603 ай бұрын
Yup. And they made them _better._ 8/ Damn Altus...
@craftergamer90583 ай бұрын
You’ve very clearly never played the original the ending cutscene for the fight is completely different.
@Archon39603 ай бұрын
@@craftergamer9058 I feel like having those butterflies made it more symbolic. As if part of it was really Him. :)
@craftergamer90583 ай бұрын
@@Archon3960 and what does that have to do with anything I was simply pointing out the cutscene was nothing like the original so the OP’s claim that they’re exactly the same makes no sense.
@Archon39603 ай бұрын
@@craftergamer9058 You have a fair point. I just wanted to point that out. (Probably should have done it.) :/
@aquatheneptunewolf11153 ай бұрын
They removed the traumatizing scene
@haridojamaru8293 ай бұрын
Technically speaking they did help create the monster , Also are responsible for his death instead of being helpful throughout the whole game they just blame him, sometimes mistreat him inhuman ways , always giving up like this was the best that makoto could ever achieved that’s why the bonds were important in persona 5 imagine if p5 cast were like these joker wouldn’t have been freed from the prison while the makoto sort of helped him these people never actually helped him heck even Yukari who “defends” never did anything to help. It was better that he died actually because these characters were sort of ungrateful towards him and even if they had feelings for him that really helped him to appreciate life and I think that’s why his end hurts me so much.
@haridojamaru8293 ай бұрын
Makoto sort of help them*
@habibicat34923 ай бұрын
Funniest sht is ??? and Metis is a Persona 4 Reference
@cruddyzebrathegamer9793 ай бұрын
She is? What’s she referencing
@habibicat34923 ай бұрын
@@cruddyzebrathegamer979 spoilers She is the shadow of Aigis Basically p4 plot
@ims21233 ай бұрын
@@habibicat3492 Not a P4 reference, the other way; P4 based off Metis’ backstory (The original Episode Aigis is from 2007)
@habibicat34923 ай бұрын
@@ims2123 I know it's a joke
@ssifr33313 ай бұрын
@@ims2123 yeah, P4 is based off the premise of the answer. Erebus being created by human's emotion and so is Izanami.
@Terensworth3 ай бұрын
I always felt the original scene was kind of a big lipped alligator moment. I mean, no other shadow died the way this one did in FES. It was downright Killer7-esque. It does feel weird that there's no shock value to it this time, but it makes more sense... Considering nobody in the original was like "That was gross, yikes." After watching their friend disintegrate.
@haridojamaru8293 ай бұрын
And one more thing ryuji was way better than Junpei like ryuji really did felt like a best friend while this guy never felt like that to me in fact because of how much I disliked him I barely hung out with him not only that but the way he acts makes him the most unstable guy out of the bunch and he barely had any tragic moments unlike everyone else who had went through horrible moments